Response Video: The Best Books Jared Read in 2024

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 23 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 38

  • @jaredplus
    @jaredplus 12 днів тому +31

    My only criticism of this video, and of your general assessment of my video, is that I was hoping it would be much meaner!

    • @saintdonoghue
      @saintdonoghue  12 днів тому +9

      We've always got Voxer!

    • @DerekKWatson
      @DerekKWatson 10 днів тому +3

      Very cool to see this interaction! I am a fan of both, if that is allowed. Much respect.

  • @TheActiveMind1
    @TheActiveMind1 12 днів тому +20

    Phew! I dodged a bullet here…

  • @joshuacreboreads
    @joshuacreboreads 12 днів тому +13

    4 videos today! We are in for a treat.

  • @Ben-O25
    @Ben-O25 12 днів тому +6

    Finally, an hour+ block of Steve! As a sidenote, the justifications on your Worst Nonfiction list gave me a much needed chuckle.

  • @Contraband_Pigments
    @Contraband_Pigments 12 днів тому +4

    There's an old episode of Frasier where he is mistakenly thought to have died and his obituary is prematurely published. It includes the memorable description of him as "lovably pompous." I am often reminded of this when watching Steve's videos. I say this affectionately. 😊

  • @marcellusrafanellirosatti
    @marcellusrafanellirosatti 12 днів тому +4

    "B.s on bs": this cracked me up.

  • @johngroundmarch7073
    @johngroundmarch7073 11 днів тому

    Being Orthodox myself, I did not expect to learn about Penguin Classics publishing the Philokalia from Steve's channel!

  • @Sandwichism
    @Sandwichism 7 днів тому

    I couldn’t tell if this whole video was sarcasm or if you actually don’t recognize the importance of philosophy

  • @thenewterrorbilly727
    @thenewterrorbilly727 12 днів тому

    I'm not sure if the background sound of the whole video was just rain or someone furiously typing on their keyboard.

  • @thomashefferon9711
    @thomashefferon9711 12 днів тому +5

    I get your disdain for philosophy, though I don’t share it. What I don’t get is your taste for theology which I see as philosophy of the supernatural. There is no supernatural. What gives?

    • @saintdonoghue
      @saintdonoghue  12 днів тому +12

      @@thomashefferon9711 But that’s just it: the best of theology can read like an infinite appendix to The Lord of the Rings, with generations of scholars (some of them quite eloquent) writing their hearts out about these nonexistent but fantastic things. In philosophy, a) it’s always the dullest writers writing b) endlessly boring elaborations of c) decidedly non-fantastic things.

    • @Sandwichism
      @Sandwichism 7 днів тому

      For a man as well read and as erudite as yourself your dismissal of philosophy as a discipline is fascinating more than anything else. You say “philosophy is not physics” ignoring that physics is a science and science is itself founded upon philosophy and epistemology, and you say “philosophy is not mathematics” when in reality mathematics is nothing other than applied logic, in the truest sense. Your failure to recognize that all these academic disciplines you hold in high regard are themselves supported by philosophical axioms is puzzling to me. You also on this channel in the past have made remarks about right and wrong, so what do you think philosophers of morality/ethics are doing? Much ado about nothing? You can’t yourself make normative claims about the world and simultaneously reject the importance of moral philosophy, what else can your normative claims stand on?

    • @thomashefferon9711
      @thomashefferon9711 7 днів тому

      Steve doesn’t need me to defend him, but his refusal to engage philosophy is perfectly reasonable. He simply wants to read about and think about other things. The idea that the other disciplines stand on philosophy is wrong. There are no foundations. Disciplines evolve out of the need for them in building better lives for ourselves.
      Most people don’t see that
      the endless arguments of
      philosophy add much to how they get along. Even people as broadly and deeply read as Steve.

    • @Sandwichism
      @Sandwichism 3 дні тому

      @ wanting to read about other things is fine, someone can do that without ridiculing one of the oldest academic fields in existence.
      And you are wrong about other fields not being contingent on philosophy. Within theory there necessarily must be a philosophical base to whatever it is you are studying whether you recognize it or not. Science itself is founded on empiricism, which is a philosophical concept, there is no circumstance in which science is being conducted that doesn’t pertain to a philosophical foundation. The idea that the rules of math should be consistent across time is philosophical, the idea that there is an objective reality outside your consciousness is philosophical, the idea that anything in reality logically correlates to one another is philosophical. These things are all philosophy whether you admit it or not, and scientific and mathematical theories are necessarily assuming these things. Just because other scholars refuse to engage with philosophy doesn’t mean they aren’t operating on top of philosophical assumptions.

  • @crypsid
    @crypsid 12 днів тому +3

    What do you mean Private Government is junk, it was in one of your 100 nonfiction recs videos! Yes I re-watch them periodically..

    • @saintdonoghue
      @saintdonoghue  12 днів тому +2

      It's a very engaging book! But its various theoretical contentions ... hoo boy ...

    • @crypsid
      @crypsid 12 днів тому

      Hah, sounds like I was a bit too hasty to remove it from my TBR!

  • @InkNSap
    @InkNSap 12 днів тому

    Ohh is this your first video on Jared? I have been enjoying his videos recently… 😊 I am glad you have enjoyed some of his content. I didn’t know he had a second channel, thank you for recommending it.

    • @crypsid
      @crypsid 12 днів тому

      They have had a number of Zoom chats on this channel! Well worth checking out, their dynamic is fun.

  • @LouiseReader
    @LouiseReader 12 днів тому +3

    Gaseous Nonsense!

  • @karenpotter3015
    @karenpotter3015 12 днів тому

    Allright! 4 videos today ❤
    A BS in BS 😂

  • @DDB168
    @DDB168 12 днів тому +1

    He seems like a more moderate and likeable dudebro. Therefore is he really a dudebro? 🤭 He has the beard I suppose.

  • @monaedoyle3631
    @monaedoyle3631 12 днів тому +1

    Is Jared going to read any romance books ? I didn’t hear any mention of romance ??

  • @JosePereira_3000
    @JosePereira_3000 3 дні тому

    Your brazen ignorance about philosophy made me question all things I've heard you say on the many topics I've little knowledge on. Kind of sad :/

    • @saintdonoghue
      @saintdonoghue  3 дні тому

      Kind of sad for you, maybe.
      I've read more philosophy than you have, in more languages. I've read more studies of philosophy and histories of philosophies than you have. I've talked about philosophy with more philosophers than you have. It's objectively impossible to claim I'm ignorant of philosophy.
      But you're not talking about ignorance here. You're talking about agreement. And you're saying the fact that I don't agree with you about this subject makes you claim you now question literally everything I've said about literally everything, from Homer to Vatican II. That's not only an idiotic stance but also a deeply, intolerantly religious one.

  • @grreeeeee
    @grreeeeee 12 днів тому +4

    your ideas about philosophy are so weirdly naive. philosophy has a direct handle on our political, material reality. without philosophy, women wouldn't have the right to vote.

    • @saintdonoghue
      @saintdonoghue  12 днів тому +4

      @@grreeeeee What absolute nonsense.

    • @grreeeeee
      @grreeeeee 12 днів тому +5

      @@saintdonoghue what do you think politics is based on? do you think it just developed out of thin air? what is any country's constitution based on? you can disagree with philosophy or think that a lot of handwaving and nonsense is done WITHIN philosophy, but to dismiss the entirely of a branch of thought is hilariously stupid.

    • @saintdonoghue
      @saintdonoghue  12 днів тому +9

      @@grreeeeee I keep re-reading that line "without philosophy, women wouldn't have the right to vote" - so the phrase "hilariously stupid" is definitely on my mind -

  • @ILoveAsuka
    @ILoveAsuka 12 днів тому +1

    Wow if you weren't 100 years old this would be a really condescending video

    • @ThatReadingGuy28
      @ThatReadingGuy28 11 днів тому

      Unless you were aware that him and Jared are friends, so he’s poking fun

  • @grreeeeee
    @grreeeeee 12 днів тому +2

    why do you have so much vitriol for this random dude whom you've never met and is fairly innocuous? sorry I wasted any time or views on your channel, what on earth am I watching

    • @renaisreading
      @renaisreading 12 днів тому +5

      You're obviously new here. Steve and Jared are friends and Jared has been on the channel several times. (By the time you posted, Jared himself had posted his approval). There is no actual ad hominim attacking here - Steve just doesn't like philosophy.

    • @grreeeeee
      @grreeeeee 12 днів тому +3

      @@renaisreading you had me at 'doesn't -like- understand philosophy,' I don't need more reasons to not watch

    • @Contraband_Pigments
      @Contraband_Pigments 12 днів тому +4

      People don't realize that Steve is a satirist like his hero Erasmus. He can lay it on a bit thick sometimes though.