Happy to see a new CL video. I’ve been watching for almost 10 years. I have some vivid memories of falling asleep to your videos when I was a teenager.
Good to know that you're still uploading on this channel when you announced the other day that you were going to stop making new ITK episodes I was concerned that you were going to stop uploading videos independently on the CL channel so I'm delighted to see that you are still here because I really do look forward to seeing your videos
So two women, and a detective lied about a potential suspect, and an innocent man went to prison, and not one of them suffered punishment? That's some straight up BS!
That deputy that didn't record or take notes broke every interview rule in the book. No recording, no notes, and if he did take notes he shredded them. That is beyond incompetent.
sounds more intentional. He was hired solely to solve this case and had something to prove and nothing to show for his time. So he shoehorned what he thought was a likely suspect as the perpertrator knowing full well there wasn't enough to convict. So he destroyed the recordings of the interview. Thats what it sounds like to me atleast.
It is time to hold prosecutors more accountable for their mistakes. If a prosecuting attorney withholds evidence that could exonerate a defendant and they are convicted but later found innocent then the prosecuting attorney should be very severely punished for their mistakes!! ALL HAIL TO THE GEORGIA INNOCENCE PROJECT!!
I remember hearing about the Swain murders on Unsolved Mysteries. Even though it took almost 40 years, I’m glad that not only will the case be closed, the person who committed the crime will face justice for it.
Agreed - humans are by far the scariest monster out there. Much like wild animals, at least monsters such as zombies, werewolves, or even vampires typically dispatch humans out of either instinct or to eat, lol. Humans use all kinds of abstract or selfish reasons.
Awesome timing CL ❤ getting ready for bed, cat snuggled up next to me and its cold as the dickens outside, tonight in Texas 😮. Yall stay warm and safe 🙏 thanks Rob
Thanks first upload the year CL we love here ❤️ watching from the Bahamas 🇧🇸 peacefully at 11:12 pm 5/1/25 ...hey everyone here be safe , have a great year upcoming will u..😊
@@CallingOutGhouls One day I'll look at the comments section and it won't be awash with nonsensical stupid comments like yours. Today is not that day. 😮
@@CallingOutGhoulsOne day I'll look at the comments section and it won't be awash with nonsensical, bland comments like yours. Today is not that day. 😮
In the Billy case WTF was wrong with the cops? How can someone be accused of the same thing repeatedly and they just keep letting him walk. They are as guilty as him
When I first heard your description of Dennis Perry, I thought, "That's really irresponsible of you to even mention this guy." Then, during the trial segment, I thought, "OK, I get why he mentioned this guy, but the prosecutor was really irresponsible for bringing this guy to trial with this crappy evidence." And then my jaw dropped when you said he was convicted.
Hearing how many times billy got off sex crimes was infuriating. If his offending had been taken seriously Carol, Sandy, Elaine, Renee, Teresa and the unknown woman would likely still be alive
I can watch/listen to brutal true crime stories for hours at a time without great disturbance. However, show a picture of a clay Jane Doe “likeness” and I’m totally creeped out , hoping that it doesn’t get shown again! Without fail, it’s always shown again! 🤦🏻
Thx for profiling these cases. I really feel for Mr. Perry; I knew in my heart there was no way he could have killed those two people. Very sorry he spent 20 years of his life in prison for a crime he did not commit, but glad he has been exonerated.
Carol, bless her heart. 😔 She sure did save that friend by offering to take her place. Wow. 😢 I’m sure she is in heaven for her sacrifice and bravery. The Bible says that we will be rewarded when a person “lays down their life for another.”
I remember watching the Swans murder on Unsolved Mysteries. I am also surprised that they just dismissed the racist guy who lost his glasses and rigged a new pair out of 3.
He means"(In To The Killing)" is taking the BREAK which is (ITK) but (CL) Criminally Listed is sticking around.,.... As far as i could understand 😢😮😂😅❤
I really miss the style of ITK because it's so much more detailed and you share movies, songs, etc. That were popular the year the crimes were comitted. I know it takes more time to research that info but it's great details that mean a lot. I'll always love this channel no matter what
Those extra details could have been the reason the channels itk videos had the lowest views of all the videos posted. I'm guessing the majority of people who watch the channel don't care about prince songs or ghost busters movies that were popular in the 80s.
Plea deals are fundamentally unjust. Giving the man a few minutes to avoid death, or decline the right to plead your innocence, is absolutely despicable.
I think you got some details confused. William, who was the father, slept with his own stepmother and produced Wendy. Because Wendy and Billy shared the same father, but not the same mother, they were half siblings.
Other channels had already covered the first two cases, but I really appreciate the work you put into it. Happy New Year ✨️ Btw it was just me that knew it was Erik Sparre all along? It was insane how little did the police investigate him. And I didn't even knew that the killer had been arrested, only that Dennis Perry was released...
Wow! These cases are real humdingers! Especially the last one. It just goes to show how important it is for law enforcement officers to be thorough and careful when handling evidence and conducting an investigation. There have been too many cases where innocent people were railroaded and convicted for crimes they did not commit. Thanks for another great episode!
My god . Someone says he is Eric's boss by the phone and police buy it. What an idiots They were so lazy they didn't check man in person what is standard procedure.
So wait on the 3rd case, he did it or not? I am so confused at first they said he was guilty sentenced to double life, the conviction gets overturned he's free, several months/years later he goes back to jail?
You've got it confused. The guy originally charged/convicted was acquited. The actual killer was only arrested last year, 4 years after the other man was let go/his DNA was connected to the crime which is very suspicious.
A fire break is for fire fighting vehicles to travel on, hence their width. Forest fires easily 'jump' a fire break through burning embers or just the heat or ferocity of the fire.
If Billy liked women why did he kill them if he didn't like them why not keep away from them ? I mean with a father he had I suppose anything is possible, maybe he blames women for not protecting him.
More than 3 men a day, here in the US, murder the women who they claim to “love”. It’s a power & ego move. Lots of times the woman is pregnant by the offender.
I mean I've been watching the shift so long. A lot of these guys are this piece of shit that don't freak me out but this dude. Billy freak me freaks me out for some reason
Happy to see a new CL video. I’ve been watching for almost 10 years. I have some vivid memories of falling asleep to your videos when I was a teenager.
Right?!! Me too, about 8 years now. Still my favorite
6 years here but still my favorite thing to fall asleep to!@@micheleshively8557
Me too
The channel hasn't been around for that long.
@ just checked and the oldest videos are from 8 years ago. That’s when I was referring to… so…
Please DO NOT STOP the INTO THE KILLING uploads. 🤞🏻🙏🏻🤞🏻🥺
Good to know that you're still uploading on this channel when you announced the other day that you were going to stop making new ITK episodes I was concerned that you were going to stop uploading videos independently on the CL channel so I'm delighted to see that you are still here because I really do look forward to seeing your videos
Same!!! My heart literally dropped.
He did say he was going to continue uploading...
Alleged @@BlueBirdsProductions
He said ITK was on an indefinite hiatus but glad there's new CL content
@@katerryjackson749 I did not see this post. Why did he say that into thd killing is ending? I'm curious what made him drop it!
So two women, and a detective lied about a potential suspect, and an innocent man went to prison, and not one of them suffered punishment? That's some straight up BS!
This happens more often than you think.
for real. They should be punished, that's absurd.
That deputy that didn't record or take notes broke every interview rule in the book. No recording, no notes, and if he did take notes he shredded them. That is beyond incompetent.
I was in awe when he said that... I was like "how much more incompetent can you be"?? 😑
I was in awe when he said that... I was like "how much more incompetent can you be"?? 😳
sounds more intentional. He was hired solely to solve this case and had something to prove and nothing to show for his time. So he shoehorned what he thought was a likely suspect as the perpertrator knowing full well there wasn't enough to convict. So he destroyed the recordings of the interview. Thats what it sounds like to me atleast.
@@danieleriksson5728 it sounds like he was a corrupt cop to me.
It is time to hold prosecutors more accountable for their mistakes. If a prosecuting attorney withholds evidence that could exonerate a defendant and they are convicted but later found innocent then the prosecuting attorney should be very severely punished for their mistakes!! ALL HAIL TO THE GEORGIA INNOCENCE PROJECT!!
I remember hearing about the Swain murders on Unsolved Mysteries. Even though it took almost 40 years, I’m glad that not only will the case be closed, the person who committed the crime will face justice for it.
Monsters are real and walk amongst us.
Agreed - humans are by far the scariest monster out there. Much like wild animals, at least monsters such as zombies, werewolves, or even vampires typically dispatch humans out of either instinct or to eat, lol. Humans use all kinds of abstract or selfish reasons.
Its insane that for decades a man could sexually assault a so many women & just go home after a day in jail. Crazy!
He was raping ERRYBODY! And was barely in prison. WOW!!!!
I mean when you acquit serious criminals what else do you expect to happen Billy should have been kept in prison the first time
Or in jail for 50 years like his monster of a father was
Awesome timing CL ❤ getting ready for bed, cat snuggled up next to me and its cold as the dickens outside, tonight in Texas 😮. Yall stay warm and safe 🙏 thanks Rob
So a child molester was allowed to walk free its just never ending
Thanks first upload the year CL we love here ❤️ watching from the Bahamas 🇧🇸 peacefully at 11:12 pm 5/1/25 ...hey everyone here be safe , have a great year upcoming will u..😊
As soon as I see new Criminally Listed videos in my notifications, I can't tap on them fast enough... Always excellent material!
One day I'll look at the comments section and it won't be awash with cringey, tedious comments like yours. Today is not that day. 🙄
@@CallingOutGhouls One day I'll look at the comments section and it won't be awash with nonsensical stupid comments like yours. Today is not that day. 😮
@toddrichardson8595, same. I really enjoy tis channel too.
@markysumm72, one day we might look at the comments and not see unwarranted, nasty remarks like yours. Today is not that day.
@@CallingOutGhoulsOne day I'll look at the comments section and it won't be awash with nonsensical, bland comments like yours. Today is not that day. 😮
A case with not a shred of physical evidence should not have the death penalty on the table. In my humble opinion.
It’s sad to hear that “Unsolved Mysteries” lost important evidence while covering a case.
In the Billy case WTF was wrong with the cops? How can someone be accused of the same thing repeatedly and they just keep letting him walk. They are as guilty as him
Absolutely!!!😡😡😡
It’s mostly the judges, not necessarily the cops. Cops do their jobs and the pedo judges let them walk with little or no punishment
When I first heard your description of Dennis Perry, I thought, "That's really irresponsible of you to even mention this guy." Then, during the trial segment, I thought, "OK, I get why he mentioned this guy, but the prosecutor was really irresponsible for bringing this guy to trial with this crappy evidence." And then my jaw dropped when you said he was convicted.
I can not believe how brave Carole was. RIP.
Hearing how many times billy got off sex crimes was infuriating. If his offending had been taken seriously Carol, Sandy, Elaine, Renee, Teresa and the unknown woman would likely still be alive
I can watch/listen to brutal true crime stories for hours at a time without great disturbance. However, show a picture of a clay Jane Doe “likeness” and I’m totally creeped out , hoping that it doesn’t get shown again! Without fail, it’s always shown again! 🤦🏻
The paper bag brothers? Amazing.
I can't believe I have watched your account grow from roughly 5k subs to almost a million now!
The evolution has been crazy!!!!
Proud of you Brother!
Thank you, thank you, thank you! Your videos are always a treat! ❤
Carol and Billy; talk about two people on the opposite side of humanity's spectrum
Thx for profiling these cases. I really feel for Mr. Perry; I knew in my heart there was no way he could have killed those two people. Very sorry he spent 20 years of his life in prison for a crime he did not commit, but glad he has been exonerated.
Could they have given Billy any more chances??
Carol, bless her heart. 😔
She sure did save that friend by offering to take her place. Wow. 😢
I’m sure she is in heaven for her sacrifice and bravery. The Bible says that we will be rewarded when a person “lays down their life for another.”
The Bible doesn't say that
So after fracturing the skull of a corrections officer, only two years are served? Scary 😱
Billy's father was as screwed up as he was
Yeah, sleeping with relatives smh
40 charges of sex crime... 😮 6 girls. 50 years in prison.... No wonder Billy behaved the same...
Harold Swain was born on July 4th
Thelma Swain was born on Christmas
I remember watching the Swans murder on Unsolved Mysteries. I am also surprised that they just dismissed the racist guy who lost his glasses and rigged a new pair out of 3.
Thanks for the upload and Happy New Year 2025!
Thanks for the upload CL! ❤
He means"(In To The Killing)" is taking the BREAK which is (ITK) but (CL) Criminally Listed is sticking around.,.... As far as i could understand 😢😮😂😅❤
Moral of the story: Be careful who you associate with. A lot of bad eggs out there. Don't be familiar with strangers.
Thank you!!! I love your videos!!
I always look forward to CL videos!
No, you don't, bot.
No, I'm not a bot, weirdo@@Flamsterette
@nataliep501 Yeah, you are.
@@FlamsteretteWhy do you think certain comments are from Bots? I am curious
@chartroy You can tell.
Rob Thank you for sharing ❤❤❤
I’m so glad you’re still making videos! I eagerly wait everyday for another one of your shows! Excellent!!! 👍🏻👏🏻
I really miss the style of ITK because it's so much more detailed and you share movies, songs, etc. That were popular the year the crimes were comitted. I know it takes more time to research that info but it's great details that mean a lot. I'll always love this channel no matter what
It's a shame that so many of the comments on the ITK posts that mentioned contemporaneous events were complaints that they were 'irrelevant.'
Those extra details could have been the reason the channels itk videos had the lowest views of all the videos posted. I'm guessing the majority of people who watch the channel don't care about prince songs or ghost busters movies that were popular in the 80s.
I really enjoyed that part of ITK, I was born in the 80s so I loved how nostalgic it was. It also helped me place myself in the era.
I enjoyed it too. Shame
If you're a family members of the victim unfortunately you may not live to see the perpetrator finally being convicted if it takes about 45 years
Thank you for all that you do, taking people’s stories to make sure they’re not forgotten
Happy New Year guys!
Happy New Year ❤
I love thus channel !!!!
Plea deals are fundamentally unjust. Giving the man a few minutes to avoid death, or decline the right to plead your innocence, is absolutely despicable.
gonna watch this ,eat and sleep😊
very well presented. thank you
Yeah, a new video 👍
I love this channel!!
It wasn't just his "half sister", it was his whole ass daughter.
I think you got some details confused. William, who was the father, slept with his own stepmother and produced Wendy. Because Wendy and Billy shared the same father, but not the same mother, they were half siblings.
In the last case....I knew it was that guy
Other channels had already covered the first two cases, but I really appreciate the work you put into it. Happy New Year ✨️
Btw it was just me that knew it was Erik Sparre all along? It was insane how little did the police investigate him. And I didn't even knew that the killer had been arrested, only that Dennis Perry was released...
11:22 “his father was an electrician”……Shows a video of a telephone lineman. 🤦♂️😂😂😂
Electrician on steroids haha
Wow! These cases are real humdingers! Especially the last one. It just goes to show how important it is for law enforcement officers to be thorough and careful when handling evidence and conducting an investigation. There have been too many cases where innocent people were railroaded and convicted for crimes they did not commit. Thanks for another great episode!
Thank you CL. I hope you don't stop ITK!🙏🏼💔🕊️
So the first guy is a possible serial killer who got away with it
Billy was a serial killer.
My god . Someone says he is Eric's boss by the phone and police buy it. What an idiots
They were so lazy they didn't check man in person what is standard procedure.
OMG what cretins....
Thanks, Robert.
Judge: How many chances do you want
Billy: A lot
Note from first story, it’s pronounced “Peed-mont”, I was born and raised in Charlotte area and went to CPCC myself
This made my day ❤
Tfs🎉🎉bless you ❤
Wow. An awful lot of lost evidence and incompetence here.
Light a candle 🕯
No more ITK videos?!! NOOOOO! I love those episodes!! 😢😢😢😢😢😢
Last time I came this early my relationship ended 😅
Short or long sleeved? LOL
@@amberservold2187 the long way lol
Why do they let obvious monsters who never change out of jail over and over again !
Im from and currently live in Burlington NC…….. that’s crazy
ITK 4 LIFE 💅🏻
So wait on the 3rd case, he did it or not? I am so confused at first they said he was guilty sentenced to double life, the conviction gets overturned he's free, several months/years later he goes back to jail?
You've got it confused. The guy originally charged/convicted was acquited. The actual killer was only arrested last year, 4 years after the other man was let go/his DNA was connected to the crime which is very suspicious.
Happy new year 2025!!!
Some really weird and sick people in this world.
A fire break is for fire fighting vehicles to travel on, hence their width. Forest fires easily 'jump' a fire break through burning embers or just the heat or ferocity of the fire.
Ive never been this early.
5:40 party and playing?😊
In case two, the drawing looked little like the description.
If Billy liked women why did he kill them if he didn't like them why not keep away from them ? I mean with a father he had I suppose anything is possible, maybe he blames women for not protecting him.
More than 3 men a day, here in the US, murder the women who they claim to “love”. It’s a power & ego move. Lots of times the woman is pregnant by the offender.
Love this channel but too much adds
I mean I've been watching the shift so long. A lot of these guys are this piece of shit that don't freak me out but this dude. Billy freak me freaks me out for some reason
0:25 It's pronounced 'Peed-mont'.
Were those names Jay Beaver...and his daughter Carol Rabbit?
Jane Beaver
Jane Beaver and Carol Rabin
🦫🐇
😅@@NannupTiger
Okay okay okay old school style no bs I can get with that
Yessss
Never go out after midnight
I work the swing shift
@ Be careful! It seems most reports about violent crimes happen in the very early morning hours. It has really stood out to me the last few years. 😔
@@chartroy no doubt . The crazy ones come out at Midnight. I can attest to that seen and encountered my fare share of incidents
@@chartroy thanks for looking out for us who work the 2nd and 3rd shift
How did they know it was a .22 in the second case?
What a sick family!
🎉
x 1.25 🙏
9:44 Ugh..the fingernails
doomdoom deyuuuuiiiuuuhhhh
It's sounds like you're fighting off the urge to sleep while narrating
She wanted a bike to b go a hundred feet
It said she walked 100 feet to get the bike from her uncle's house, then she was planning on going for a bike ride through the woods
45:44 what a clown show
Unfortunately, he doesn't interact with his audience.
🏴🔥👍🏻👊🏻🍓
🎉2025
Dude can't say Piedmont.
AI - that’s why
@@sunshine3914He's not AI
He’s def not AI lol
3rd Case: perhaps you shouldn't say a case has been 'solved' if the trial hasn't happened yet. That was the problem the first time around!