Activists occupy Columbia University building | DW News
Вставка
- Опубліковано 20 тра 2024
- Columbia University officials threatened academic expulsion of students who seized and occupied a classroom building, intensifying a nearly two-week standoff between administrators and pro-Palestinian activists on the Manhattan campus.
Chapters:
00:00 Introduction
01:48 Ethan Bearman, Adjunct Professor at Loyola Law School
08:24 Benjamin Alvarez Gruber, DW Correspondent
Subscribe: ua-cam.com/users/deutsche...
For more news go to: www.dw.com/en/
Follow DW on social media:
►Facebook: / deutschewellenews
►Twitter: / dwnews
►Instagram: / dwnews
►Twitch: / dwnews_hangout
Für Videos in deutscher Sprache besuchen Sie: / dwdeutsch
#Columbia #USA #protests
Such a biased interview
Na
is it?
"To Learn who Rules over you, Simply find out who you aren't allowed to Criticise "
@@TheNilla2020
"Those who can make you believe absurdities, can make you commit Atrocities "~Voltaire.
Those reporters are conscience-less
Illegal occupation is BAD, right?
Isreal is an example of occupation,
Europeans and Americans are supporters of occupation.
@@SMM-ij7bnIsrael is a legitimate nation recognized by the UN since 1948, little muslonazi.
touche
@@badabinbadaboom7338 so is the West Bank, with recognized borders just like Isreal
So why you don't protest Istanbul being Turkish? 600 years of occupation.
So the guy says at 3:35 that "there has been some speculation and I don't know if there is anything founded in it ..." then, he continues with the rumours which he just said he did not know that they were true. What a bunch of bs ... let's talk about rumours because this is the news nowadays: unfounded rumours.
Agreed he’s lying on several points. He knows what he is doing.
@@Alopen-xb1rb 🎌🏴☠🏳
Terrible interview
Keep commenting so the videos gets pushed out more on the algorithm
Good interview, thanks for pushing it forward with your comment.
Why does DW always bring an pro-Israeli Interviewer, why not pro-Palestinian or even a neutral? Biased!!
Students have the right to protest and should make their voices heard, but covering their faces and forcibly occupying the building is crossing the line. The school was waiting for them to cross the line.....
Covering faces is because national force used to threaten.
Totally!
Same was done in 1968 ,anti segregation , anti Vietnam protest ,the politician are offcource didn't like those either.
Agree
Check 2019 HK riot supported by US.
I would like to see the DNA of Ethan Bearman, to see if he really belongs to the people who were removed from Palestine in Roman times. He looks quite Germanic to me.
If your from the US and Iran is cheering you on… you might want to ask yourself some questions kids
Lol what does the US needs to do with Iran, except that the Israelis dont like them...
So true!!!
Been a lot of soul searching these past few weeks. A lot of historical review. Students were vilified in 68, 85, 03... things never change.
@@mellowInventor Oh yes, becuse the people of Vietnam are so much better off now.
@@mellowInventor this isn’t really just Americas war and is a religious one over the holy land.
Remember, occupation is bad
😂. I guess the students believe it only applies to OTHERS, NOT them 😂!.
Well remember so is islam
Occupation by Meccan and Medinan successors of Muhammud (Peace Be Upon Him) . . . Umar ibn al-Khattab . . . Khalid ibn al-Walid . . . Abu Ubaidah ibn al-Jarrah . . .
Never before had the police been able to dismantle a tent so quickly.
They can also help dismantle tents on the streets.
The tents on the street are not antisemitism.
The tents on the streets are from destitute homeless people.
Have a heart. One day you might find yourself in their shoes.
This is very far from being a peaceful protest.
The German reaction to this war is yet another example of their tolerance for atrocities. It's shameful.
no tolerance for nazijihad
@@joexavier4070 ask hamas
I just need help understanding why disrupting someone else’s education is going to stop this war? With all these supporters why don’t they just go out and fight like the ppl did for the war in Ukraine?
Protests are about disruption ^_^
@@nestharus that’s it… how will this change the war?
@@n.g.l. It's not supposed to. It's supposed to stop US investment.
US hands Israel billions every year to buy US weapons. they are now using them to bomb women and children in Gaza and it is pissing off a lot of people in the US. The students are a bit extreme but they are way more in touch with most American under 40 than the interviewee.
@@nestharus are these colleges Wall Street now? Are these colleges all the investment firms combined? Do these colleges control the federal reserve? Or the treasury? Are these colleges the billionaires who supply these weapons? You’re going to make lots of enemies acting this way.
Why are protesters are treated so violently by US.....😮💨
"After all, they were not pro-Palestinian students but another extension of the Hamas terrorist group, their behavior was exposed."
Same on those ppl in this interview
@@georgekung2003utube
It is very likely that this is the case.
Endowments, tuition fees, research grants, alumni donations and other revenue streams contribute towards financial stability and support their educational aims. As of the 2021/22 academic year, Ivy League institutions generated $40.61 billion in total revenue.
The federal government provides enormous subsidies to the wealthiest universities by paying “overhead” on research grants. Ivy League universities received $1.8 billion for government-funded research grants despite having $192 billion in endowment funds.
-With the MONEY the universities make why is any student in America paying tuition? These universities make enough money a year to pay for your education, your kids education, and your grandchildren’s education. However, they instead give it to countries like Israel who turn around and give it to the U.S. government to buy weapons.
@@DeannThomas-le2ut
Well then, show me the document where I can read everything you say to what it was allocated, and also show me the document where this money is invested in weapons for Israel, do you have it or only Do you want to justify a demonstration in favor of Palestinian terrorism?
@@DeannThomas-le2ut
By the way, in the words of your own President Biden, I argue that it would restore economic and financial resources to UNRWA, the same one that lends its facilities to hamas, and the same one in which Its officials participated in the massacre of October 7.
The country is invaded.
Yes, 70% wealth belong to people of a small middle east country.
Sad for Emerican
Yeah, palestine is heavily so.
Palestine is invaded
@@krisztian3909 Also Istanbul is occupied and I don't see you protesting against that.
@@bogdar2019
I don’t think that there is a genocide in Istanbul.
How is it different from hk university protest huh
Remember what did they say when there was a riot in hong kong China several years ago? Such bi-standarded politicians.
@foxerhu. My post sharing your sentiments was swiftly censored by UT. Freedom of speech my foot.
Lil pink you earn 50 social credit score yah
The riot in Hong Kong was way more violent. They did it for an entire year until COVID and the security law started. And what started the protest was just an expedition law, there were no war crimes and mass graves involved. What the US Congress is trying to do is that they are also pushing a bill to shut the students up on the pretext of an overused term called "anti-Semitism". The term is weaponized to the point that it's becoming anti-democratic.
what else you know about a person's opinion, just it? no wonder you lose.@@dustintacohands1107
Yes, you can protest. As long as you protest in favor of what the ruling parties want to do.
If they want their voices to be heard than they should go where the conflict is..
Or is it more about causing chaos everywhere..?
Right 😅
These kids have no idea where there is...lol
@@cmdkaboom
14,000 +Palestinian children killed.
@@cmdkaboom
You're not the sharpest tool in the shed are ya?
Enemy at the gate. Be ready.
Thank you, DW, for your unwavering support for Israel’s conduct.
If you think one side is worse then the other, why don't you look at gender based oppression first that is used now as a "Cultural" tool to dismiss woman having to wear head scarfs. And google the true definition of Genocide also. Plus you do remember that it wasn't just Hummus soldiers who took hostages, regular men from Palestine joined in, and took innocent woman from a rave as hostages.
Enough is enough in Palestine...
Yeah, Palestinians should just go away.
You cannot call urself OPPRESSED when u constantly refuse peace. The Palestinians refused the peace proposals offered in 2000 and 2008, which included a Palestinian state in the entire West Bank and Gaza. Instead, they chose to attack Israel time after time so what is Israel supposed to do?
And even if you think all those proposals were unfair - then where is the Palestinians' proposal? I've never seen it.
That’s factually just a n intentional lie, Israel never offered to recognise a Palestinian state under international legal borders, they didn’t offer more than a Swiss cheese, sometimes more sometimes less. Just stop lying and spreading misinformation intentionally.
There is a fundamental difference between "Palestinians" and Hamas. They are not the same. This is the fundamental error that the Israeli government is making.
There werent any proposals, ever. Israelis dont want to give up an inch of those territories.
@@georgenorris2657 No, that's the fundemental mistake Hamas is making, and why they use their own child4rn as shields and martyres.
@@gaborrajnai6213 you have it backwards
They are so sure of their convictions, and that truth is on their side, they hide their faces!
those are people hired by aipac
That is BS. It is fear of repression from authorities. Fear of expulsion from the university.
sad thing is these kids just don't know their history. It's good to have active youth against injustice, but this is simply NOT THE CASE.
I thought Ivy league universities are the best of the best...
Endowments, tuition fees, research grants, alumni donations and other revenue streams contribute towards financial stability and support their educational aims. As of the 2021/22 academic year, Ivy League institutions generated $40.61 billion in total revenue.
The federal government provides enormous subsidies to the wealthiest universities by paying “overhead” on research grants. Ivy League universities received $1.8 billion for government-funded research grants despite having $192 billion in endowment funds.
- something for those naysayers to consider. With the MONEY the universities make why is any student in America paying tuition? These universities make enough money a year to pay for your education, your kids education, and your grandchildren’s education. instead they give it to countries like Israel who turn around and give it to the U.S. government to buy weapons.
@@gaborrajnai6213They've been the best of the best at making money for a long time, not for excellence in higher education. Those days are gone, they're expensive diploma mills now.
Some of these numbskulls couldn't even pinpoint Gaza on a map until a few months ago.
@@badabinbadaboom7338sure thing little hasbara 🧌😂
that what they say during vietnam protest as well. it's never the case. lol
Lock them in, see they can tolerate in there.
Shame on you," these children are bombing on civilians " ,
DW is shame
Presstitudes pretending to be a news outlet😁😁🤡🤡🤡🥺🥺🤭🤭@@georgekung2003utube
@@georgekung2003utube Thanks🌹
Please insist on habeas corpus for hostages. In any criminal proceedings victims are first series of witnesses. ICC should first examine victims before any other procedure. I believe all universities have faculty of law who should be advising students and guiding them on nuances of law. Students of Harvard should have consulted their friends in law before rushing to sign petitions or organizing protests. Hostages themselves are material evidence.
U r judged by what u do at home and not what u say abroad.
Worst and most baseless and biased DW segment I've seen in months.
they are rioters, not peaceful protestors
I'm not sure you know what a riot is, i hope you never have to experience one.
@@jordanp5469 i think riot is defined by nature not by scale
If you think these are riots, you haven't seen riots. It is very clearly peaceful protests. Police initiating violence does not change the nature of peaceful protest. Under that criteria, most of Gandhi's peaceful protests and the MLK civil rights marches would be "riots" (no they weren't) because police or national guard initiated violence against them.
This is nothing compare to HK riot supported by US.
@@jojotang8339 were you not in the US in 2020? Those were actual riots. Get a grip on reality please.
Why are they hiding their faces ?
Why so many bots in the comments section here?
A moral army. Respect
of course its wrong to occupy a hall and same for a land not belonging to them!
Yes, palestinians stole that land and now they need to give it back
Endowments, tuition fees, research grants, alumni donations and other revenue streams contribute towards financial stability and support their educational aims. As of the 2021/22 academic year, Ivy League institutions generated $40.61 billion in total revenue.
The federal government provides enormous subsidies to the wealthiest universities by paying “overhead” on research grants. Ivy League universities received $1.8 billion for government-funded research grants despite having $192 billion in endowment funds.
- something for those naysays to consider. With the MONEY the universities make why is any student in America paying tuition? These universities make enough money a year to pay for your education, your kids education, and your grandchildren’s education. However, they instead give it to countries like Israel who turn around and give it to the U.S. government to buy weapons.
Your at college to get an education
"Taking a jab at Washington, India on Thursday (April 25) implied that the US, which arrested scores of university students protesting the Gaza war, should be less critical of “other fellow democracies” and stated that America will be “judged by what [it does] at home and not what [it says] abroad”.
Who cares what they think
@@blazer9547 Because US tried to lecture them when something similar happened in India.
DW news IDF tool
Thanks for promoting up this interview with your comment. Great Interview.
What a ridiculous interview. Extremely biased. I’m unsubscribing from this trash.
Shameful journalism from now a disgraced channel
spot on ❤❤❤❤
Ha ha, your agenda can't work anymore... You call it genocide but in fact population growth is rocketsky
Yeah, that's why you're here 😂
icc, where are you?
NYPD have a Seige Weapon. 😅
DW shows only the Israel side, that is not a good journalism.
Yes!!!
Yes, proper hypocrites
You are right ✅ Al jazeera too?
Dude literally tried alluding to a conspiracy theory and the interviewer didn’t even attempt to push back asking why that was said without evidence on air. That’s libel
What are you talking about?
Great interview thanks for promoting it with your comment.
@@davedays504 he said there were outside influences to the protests possibly financing it and the best the interviewer said to that was ok. He didn’t press him on who he thinks that is or how. He let that comment stand with no push back.
I love your speculations, such professional high level journalism
I like how, how so much "people" are pro what every normal person think is a terrorist state... I truly hope they will get to live in such a place.
And there is such a place, I hope they are so upset with the "american ways" and they get to live their dream there.
Oh, the usual lesser evil argument. Ok, so why do the US needs to send billions into a middle eastern country with a known trackrecord of human right violations? Whats the benefit? Besides OK, you dont like international law, I get it, then why are you crying about rules based international order? Then its might is right and thats all.
Most of these students are ironically quite ignorant on what is really doing on. They just see one group is smaller than the other and automatically think the smaller group is the right. If the shoe was on the other foot, Palestine would have committed a real genocide. Israel is just makung sure that never happens (history don't repeat itself).
True, there are too many pro-American people in the world.
Why did gaza attack first?Why provoked Israel?
Hello there, dude Israel has been occupying gaza for years and applying an apartheid system to the palestinian...This is not about just the last months, it is a problem create by Israel many years ago❤❤❤
@@Tito-Freedom they could have talked peacefully, why did Hamas kill Israeli people ...Now even Israel is doing well
@@rke1995lol talks with biased cheap democracy
Actually Israel attacked first, 1948.
@@Tito-Freedom yeah but it’s not wise to attack a country with a multi-billion dollar military. What did they expect, the Israelites to ignore it? If they really loved their people, why did they start a war at this scale? To invite rockets from the other side?
The world stands with the students!
Bt nobody is saying that freedom is under threat in us
Most of the world does not stand with them, most think they are loud disruptive entitled kids
you brought a wrong guy who has a violent view on this peaceful protest.
Arrests at Columbia University: Police enter hall where students barricaded
Talking bs
When in history were college students ever on the wrong side of history? Never
Terrible person to have on ashamed of you DW.
The video intro photo shows aggressive violent Arabs, not regular students demonstrating against an injustice in the opposite part of the world.
Yall are covering the protests but not what they’re protesting? Why is that?
Lesson - whether its America or Russia or Canada, u r allowed to protest only if u toe the govt line
Not good but quite a big difference. Particularly since in the US the charges are nearly always dropped. Likewise in CA with huge protests against gov policies that for the most part people are free to do as long as they don't disrupt the entire economy which is much more than just the government's interest.
Free Free Palestine 🇵🇸 ♥️
Free free from debt!!😭😭
70% wealth belong to people of a small middle east country.
Sad for Emerican
Who is paying for you bots?
No, People living in USA from Middle East are poor are from war zones and Rich shaik won’t leave there land In middle east
Endowments, tuition fees, research grants, alumni donations and other revenue streams contribute towards financial stability and support their educational aims. As of the 2021/22 academic year, Ivy League institutions generated $40.61 billion in total revenue.
The federal government provides enormous subsidies to the wealthiest universities by paying “overhead” on research grants. Ivy League universities received $1.8 billion for government-funded research grants despite having $192 billion in endowment funds.
- With the MONEY the universities make why is any student in America paying tuition? These universities make enough money a year to pay for your education, your kids education, and your grandchildren’s education. However, they instead give it to countries like Israel who turn around and give it to the U.S. government to buy weapons.
So sorry DM for your loss😂
Many thanks Colombia for standing with the truth. Long live Gaza long live Palestine. One luv❤
Since they will be expelled, they can protest from their parents’ basements. 😂
Let’s see how long it will take before their own parents also expel them
But but but then they will be homeless and can go live in Iran or something. lol
That's pretty f'ed up to wish someone to loose there future career because they protested for the wrong thing, don't you think?
Bernie Sanders gave a good answer that you can rely on, instead of going to people who are biased
He is a CCP asset 🙅♂️
@@MrWhitmen1981He's not. Bernie is the most honest politician the USA has since FDR.
He's wrong on this issue though.
Free free Palestine.
Never
Woh loge jo Gaza ke protest ko dekh kar critised kar rahe hain, unko gaza mein bumbari nahin dikhti jo har din 100 civilians ko mar dete hai.
Where’s Kfir?
Bhai yeh west hai hypocrisy ka pitora
Ah! freedom of Speech
Ah! Human Rights,
Ah! Democracy .
The protest is not about free speech
If you question them they attack you
The only speech they allow is theirs
Shame on the US
What a biased bs interview! Rumors presented as facts
You guys misspelled pro-Hamas.
DO NOT Send your Children to violent universities.
USA should be called UAS i.e. united arab states 😅😅😅😅😅😅
europe and usa facing everything that they used to lecture others about 🙃
There are certainly external influences😂😂. As always, it's Russia.🤣🤣
"Whatever we don't like is Putin's fault!"
From the music festival to Gaza both Israel and Palestine should be free
Isreal must leave the occupied land.
@@SMM-ij7bn The whole land is occupied right?
Russia boggie floated by "experts"
Dude this guy has an agenda
Thanks students❤❤❤❤❤
Strategy of divide and rule? It's an example of bad journalism
What a disappointment DW has become. Dismal interview.
No one is free until Palestine is free,,,if politicians turns to be biased and hypocritical, the young generation will stand up to clean the mess
Aaa ..DOLF is back!
Calling for the National Guard could lead to a situation like the Kent State massacre. What a boneheaded statement from the Speaker.
Free Palestine!!!
Psh
No surprise from dw 😏
"But it is a surprise for the pro-terrorists."
In american (govt) mind 32k life lost is justified and not crossing the rubicon 😢
In the real world we know those figures are rubbish. Statisticians have totally debunked them as impossible.
The real genesis: have you ever wondered why they tend to protest when they should be taking finals?
They like making coffee?
Uncle sam has a german shepherd dog. Its job is to guard demoncrazy farm on the east.
Good to See students are frustrated But not enough to change current government policies. What they need is systematic reform which can not be done with people's revolution, US people need to Rise up and change this two party constitution with heavy cooperate funding also heavy involvement of US military industrial complex. This current government system will fight back against it's people to keep theose powerful politicians in power But no longer represent People's voice.
把反纳粹反战与反犹划等号的人，难道是把纳粹和战争与犹太人划等号吗？😅
This is about tax $ move to other country for kxxxxxxxxxxx11ing
Best way to protest is to create sympathy and not antagonise the public.
Beautiful interview, This man is a great humanitarian.
It will be considered as peaceful protest if not in US . In fact those students even not throwing petrol bombs
"And it's not just Netanyahu. It's the world that he made, and the world that made him, it's Zionism" Naomi Klein
With that facial structure, i could tell a mile away.
🍉 ✊ 🆓 🇵🇸 ✊ 🍉
The US preach human rights,the right to protest, free speech and democracy to the world and yet it's not ok in the US.
What horrible heavily biased on one side journalism though.
If you listen closely you can actually hear John Kirby choking on Netanyahu's rock hard shtickl.
These lying spokesperson are a 🤣🤣🤣. What happened to US bureaucracy 😅😅😅.
Oh, now we have limits to the first amendment?? That had never been said until now, what a coincidence
Limitations to speech protected under the First Amendment have always existed. For instance the First Amendment does not protect the right "Of students to make an obscene speech at a school-sponsored event" as per
Bethel School District #43 v. Fraser, 478 U.S. 675 (1986), nor the right "to incite imminent lawless action" as per Brandenburg v. Ohio, 395 U.S. 444 (1969), both of which have occurred during the protests at Columbia.
The First Amendment therefore does not protect the anti-Semitic speech which has unfortunately found its way into the university campus protests against the situation in Israel/Palestine.
You mean that situation, where Israeli cabinet ministers openly talked about the use of atomic weapons on Gaza?@@wilsonlane9929
It was also said during tge January 6th riots. Not the first time.
anti-zionism is not anti-semitism