We rate YOUR watch collection!

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 28 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 335

  • @owenjones63
    @owenjones63 Рік тому +44

    This episode was humble, innocent and makes you appreciate the journey of other people's collections, it's not about spending the world it's about taste and personal journey :) Great episode !!
    I love the fact you were giving collections with casio F91W's and Seiko's such high scores :) love you guys!

  • @adamjodell
    @adamjodell Рік тому +28

    This episode was awesome! It's so great to see collection videos made by people who really understand the hobby better than anyone else. Honestly, this has got to be my absolute favorite episode so far! Please keep making more of these - they're amazing!

  • @TheNeybor
    @TheNeybor 7 місяців тому +2

    Literally the highest quality watch talk show on UA-cam. This evokes feelings of OG Top Gear for me. Keep it up guys.

    • @990v6
      @990v6 7 місяців тому

      they broke up

    • @TheNeybor
      @TheNeybor 7 місяців тому

      @@990v6 Seriously? When did they announce this?

  • @1412alucard
    @1412alucard Рік тому +2

    the piece at 17:32 is a humism, i have one too with yellow dial and looks really cool. The're tag line is turning time into art

  • @yojimbo21
    @yojimbo21 Рік тому +85

    Can you imagine if they did George’s? It’d be the longest episode ever.

    • @edwardmcardle
      @edwardmcardle Рік тому +9

      A series dedicated to George’s watches 😂

    • @MrJeremy9835
      @MrJeremy9835 Рік тому +4

      @@edwardmcardle❤❤❤George is such a nice guy and he is so funny for a British

    • @michaelcollins3132
      @michaelcollins3132 Рік тому +1

      There’d be some great watches there buried under the thousands of DLC coated neon accented shitters

  • @joshuatvernon
    @joshuatvernon Рік тому +7

    The jazz trumpeter collection was missing the Oris James Morrison Limited Edition. James Morrison is one of Australia’s most famous jazz trumpeters and the watch has a tuning fork hand. It’s really beautiful actually

  • @mathewgruenholz
    @mathewgruenholz Рік тому +27

    Love this. One of my favorite episodes. Absolutely love seeing other people’s collections and wondering about their story and watch journey. I’ll have to submit my collection next time!

  • @austinreiter2594
    @austinreiter2594 Рік тому +3

    The concept of this episode is so much fun. I love when you guys guess on the collector's personality and the intricacies of their decisions and life experiences through just a photo of the watches.
    It would be super cool to do something like this again and interview everyday folks and talk to them about their collections and why they bought what they bought. UA-cam is filled with interviews of rich celebrities and their watches. I want to see a show on everyday watch collectors!

  • @larrykelley3651
    @larrykelley3651 Рік тому +3

    This was a fun episode and I really hope they do this on a regular basis! I’d Kill to have them look at my collection! Well done Fellas!!!

  • @RegginaldRiglet
    @RegginaldRiglet Рік тому +3

    This is so fun. Love to see more rank our watches episodes. Great work guys

  • @robpelletier2103
    @robpelletier2103 Рік тому +2

    One of my favorite episodes. Hope you do another one soon!

  • @nilssaugen2303
    @nilssaugen2303 Рік тому +2

    Very nice episode - really hope you do more of these. Also as a quartz entusiast I salute the comments about quartz watches!

  • @PJM16
    @PJM16 Рік тому +2

    More of these, please!! Love it.

  • @jasonphilp4444
    @jasonphilp4444 Рік тому +1

    Brilliant, definitely one of my favourite shows. Please do some more of these.

  • @Crispyrendang64
    @Crispyrendang64 Рік тому +4

    The watch at the bottom left hand corner at 19:00 is actually from Humism, a indie watchmaker from my country, Singapore 🇸🇬. Funny seeing it here since I was just researching on local upcoming/microbrands haha

  • @davidbrandon-cox4204
    @davidbrandon-cox4204 Рік тому +2

    Hey About Effing Time, I have an idea for your next video of rating collections (I enjoy your content immensely btw. Big big Fan!!):
    How about you do an even more “academic” (sorry for pretentiousness..) rating on the viewers collections. That would make us WatchNerds geek out, and you get to really show off your WatchMojo;)
    I’m thinking in terms of formulating a framework for judging a collection. You can be pioneers in doing this on UA-cam!
    These are just some suggestions for criteria:
    1.Personality: lack of dogmatic choices. Not purposely opting to please the narrative of which watches to own. For example, instead of having a Daytona and a speedy, the person has two Daytonas. Just because he really likes Daytonas. Perhaps that would be an indicator of his personality shining through.
    2.Originality: in terms of straps, dials, brands etc, How generic/original is his mix of choices?
    3.Tradition: is he keeping his choices in line with the classics? How well is he doing that?
    4.Balance: is there a balance regarding spread of timepieces?
    5.Judges own taste: here you can leave your own personal preference on the collection.
    Then you’ll do the math and each judge will get an aggregate score for each collection.
    I know that some of these criteria contradict each other in a way. But I think that’s okay. It just enables for more equality regarding the opportunities for different types of collections to gather points.
    Love ya!!

  • @CreateTimeToListen
    @CreateTimeToListen Рік тому +1

    The watch at 17:32 is one from Humism: the Humism Rhizone. The black dot indicates the hours, the hollow dot the minutes. Instead of a seconds hand they use layers of cut-out discs with a design on it that spin around and create a kinetic pattern that keeps changing. It's kinetic art and mesmerizing to look at. Humism is also an independent brand. The watch houses a Seiko NH35A movement.

  • @nbcuni
    @nbcuni Рік тому

    This was awesome. Really hope you turn this into a regular part of your show.

  • @rajmehta6210
    @rajmehta6210 Рік тому +1

    love that you took on my idea gents. Andrew- I'm considering pulling the trigger on the Hublot Stormtrooper after our interaction a while back. saw it in person- a real stunner. keep up the great work guys.

  • @saeednazemzadeh1664
    @saeednazemzadeh1664 Рік тому +1

    One of the best episodes guys, do it again 👍🏻

  • @nocolo123
    @nocolo123 9 місяців тому +2

    I love this rating episode, please keep it going make it to a series!

  • @joeplatz7289
    @joeplatz7289 Рік тому +2

    Fun video. I missed the call for submissions but you guys definitely inspired me to do some state of the collection shots

  • @davidparrishproductions5082
    @davidparrishproductions5082 Рік тому +2

    Really fun format guys! Thank you !!

  • @recaanharb
    @recaanharb Рік тому

    Absolutely amazing episode! Please do another one, fellas!

  • @BlakeATucker
    @BlakeATucker Рік тому +2

    I loved this! Again, lads! Again!

  • @xBboySpazzx
    @xBboySpazzx Рік тому +5

    This is genuine apprectation and a connection between audience and the team. I would love to hear you guys be more opinionated and say what the collection speaks or says about them. These collections are probably nerdy collections given the audience here. I'm sure I'm one of many who wishes to be roasted by the gentleman as well! Hope this continues! Cheers, Ken

  • @fransker13
    @fransker13 Рік тому +2

    LOL literally seeing my bosse's collection in this episode :) Wont name drop though XD
    We have a Watchnerd channel in our Slack, all praising this show btw :) keep it up

  • @michaelmillas1359
    @michaelmillas1359 Рік тому

    This was one of the best most interesting episodes of any watch channel ive seen . 40 mins went so fast.👏👏

  • @AndreasGilbert666
    @AndreasGilbert666 Рік тому +3

    Great segment! If you could have one of the watches from the collections that you´ve seen here, which would you take?

  • @v.s.4948
    @v.s.4948 Рік тому +1

    Great video guys!! Loved the collections, but did else notice the Sub @28:00 looking a bit off? Fake?

  • @wongfeihung9724
    @wongfeihung9724 Рік тому +1

    Thoroughly enjoyed this episode. Please do more! Love the banter. Consider yourself subscribed. WFH

  • @malikknows3510
    @malikknows3510 Рік тому +1

    This was great fun! Thanks! Yes, by all means -- do it again!!

  • @franklucente3517
    @franklucente3517 Рік тому +2

    That GShock full Ti model is one of my absolute favorites from Casio. Lightweight, solid, solar, awesome matte color scheme…top class edition. Mine will undoubtedly outlive me. 😂👍

  • @michaelissac3337
    @michaelissac3337 Рік тому +6

    You guys are great on your own and even better together. Love the show and love the episode. Id love to see this episode annually.

  • @LothricSun
    @LothricSun Рік тому +2

    appreciate seeing interaction with the fans fellas. wanted to ask if you guys would do a section on the LV tambour watch and that project, some opinions and some thoughts?

  • @mikehenkelman2111
    @mikehenkelman2111 Рік тому +9

    this is my favorite episode so far...it literally allows watch junkies "behave" like passionate watch junkies...and reviewing others watch passions and choices is what watch journeys are all about

  • @khronokraze
    @khronokraze Рік тому +1

    Great show. I'd liveto see what you think of my collection some day. Hope you do more like this episode from time to time. Looking forward to the next episode.

  • @jerelido
    @jerelido Рік тому +2

    I love this eopisode!
    Hope you're gonna do one again!

  • @clementsarastov5339
    @clementsarastov5339 Рік тому +2

    I am doing an antropological study on mechanical and smart watches, can you guys explain to me why would one choose one over the other, the meaning their collection carries etc. Do you associate memories to your watches. It will be of immense help.

  • @davec4224
    @davec4224 Рік тому +2

    Thanks for making it safe for families and work so I can share!fun show!

  • @andrewgee2775
    @andrewgee2775 Рік тому

    Thanks guys, another great episode. Love seeing others collections and the stories behind them. Cheers

  • @tombell5599
    @tombell5599 Рік тому +3

    Citizen is a seriously underrated brand in my opinion

  • @franklucente3517
    @franklucente3517 Рік тому +2

    George’s complete exasperation: “I KNEWWW you’d say that.” 😂😂

  • @jgc3434
    @jgc3434 Рік тому +2

    Vintage Junghans! I thought I was alone on that.

  • @firminshepherd4834
    @firminshepherd4834 Рік тому +1

    Great stuff, especially the BYOI. Very cool.

  • @seikowatchsan
    @seikowatchsan Рік тому +6

    Great and funny episode as always🥗
    Nice to see collections from other AET-watchers!
    Too bad you didn't pick my Seiko collection, maybe next time😋
    Greetings Seikosan from Switzerland

  • @morgan97475
    @morgan97475 Рік тому +2

    Cool episode. Looking forward to more like this.

  • @christophermills7304
    @christophermills7304 Рік тому +1

    Definitely another episode of this! Loved every second would love to send mine in for review 😂🙏

  • @mitchmitchell9588
    @mitchmitchell9588 Рік тому +2

    The third collection, odd watch on bottom left. I think that’s a perpetual motion watch from a small shop in Kyoto Japan. Hard to see clearly, so I could be wrong. But if it is, it’s a cool piece.

  • @lawsonmarr6110
    @lawsonmarr6110 Рік тому +1

    Love this kind of content, a true reflection of watch dudes

  • @SerialWheeler
    @SerialWheeler Рік тому +2

    Really enjoyed this one! This is like the old Top Gear for watches.

    • @yahyahra
      @yahyahra Рік тому

      hahaha you're right, I was wondering why I was feeling some sort of nostalgic deja vu

  • @williama-d6
    @williama-d6 Рік тому +2

    I saw that joke on instagram I laughed this time round but I think its because I was prepared for it. Nice video

  • @aapeaape
    @aapeaape Рік тому +1

    Guys! Adrian, Andrew, & George! Once again a great episode, you were all in very good mood, tongue-in-cheek but professional, opinionated, and fun and witty! And the collections were great too - keep it up! 🙏

  • @arshute
    @arshute Рік тому +2

    Really interesting guys. Hope you do this again.

  • @ooxyxo
    @ooxyxo Рік тому +1

    Was a great episode, you should keep on!

  • @BenMwatches
    @BenMwatches Рік тому +1

    Love this episode
    Such cool very different collections

  • @RATBONES8
    @RATBONES8 Рік тому

    Nice fun episode guys, greetings from Canada! Perhaps make it a small segment on every episode where you rate one or two collections?

  • @seattlegrrlie
    @seattlegrrlie Рік тому +1

    I'm just starting at that blue watch from the opening and I'm going to have to get my first Bamford. My God that's gorgeous

  • @PaulKaiser42
    @PaulKaiser42 Рік тому +1

    Love this….another awesome show👍👍. Really great collections

  • @watchesandburgers
    @watchesandburgers Рік тому +2

    Awesome stuff! Keep it up.

  • @NedStarrk007
    @NedStarrk007 Рік тому +1

    Totally agree on quartz. I’ve been looking into finally getting an omega and I just honestly like the 90s / early 2000’s quartz the best over anything newer.

  • @matthewmckenney7230
    @matthewmckenney7230 Рік тому +1

    Great episode! Great BYOI call out!

  • @79Hokie
    @79Hokie Рік тому

    Excellent episode as usual. Thanks so much for sharing. "The whole is greater than the sum of its parts" (that includes you Marcus!)

  • @gabelogan8302
    @gabelogan8302 Рік тому +1

    Seriously guys, you should talk about Fortis, and other like brands, it’s not all Omega and Rolex. Also, just to be clear I love the work you’re doing and really appreciate all three of you. Also, George is always right.

  • @albertorbinati5511
    @albertorbinati5511 Рік тому +1

    I loved this episode! Well done, mates!

  • @AfiftheChief
    @AfiftheChief Рік тому

    One of my favorite watch related videos ever. Really cool!

  • @grahamtaaffe4261
    @grahamtaaffe4261 Рік тому +2

    What do you guys think of the company 'glycine'? Thanks in advance..

  • @respectablylate3081
    @respectablylate3081 Рік тому +1

    Loved it and loved the variety! In my over 220 watch collection, sorry Adrian, I have around 2 of everyone's that were perused. I know it's not a competition but as everyone says... buy what you like. My 26 clocks on my office wall draw inspiration from George's room. You don't have enough time on a show to review my collection and I'm trying to reduce it by 100 or so! Lol!

    • @respectablylate3081
      @respectablylate3081 Рік тому

      PS, yes I do have security, safe, shutters, locks, cameras, alarm and a dog!

    • @marcusflack1523
      @marcusflack1523 Рік тому

      YESSS a DOG@@respectablylate3081

  • @vishnu.narayanan
    @vishnu.narayanan Рік тому +2

    20:52 Guys, the average of three 8's is not 7.2 (unless you're doing some weighted rating)
    Good video :)

  • @raysway1897
    @raysway1897 Рік тому +1

    CONTROVERSIAL TAKE - several G-Shocks in a collection, is like several Daytonas or Nautilus. Yes, excellent watch, but for a collection - boring. Great episode as always, Gents!!!

  • @TheOilDoctor
    @TheOilDoctor Рік тому

    Great show. Love what you guys are doing. Question- does a collection “need all bases covered”. Surely a great collection has a focus or a theme that is strong, with depth… a full series of omega constellations, heuer chronographs from the 60s, Rolex dive watches, the dirty dozen etc. All these collections under review are mostly a mishmash of stuff. Some are very much trending toward a theme (heavy on independents, watches worn by musicians etc), which is great, and if they went all in I think they’d transcend “all bases covered” in a good way.

  • @NischalSheodayal
    @NischalSheodayal 11 місяців тому +1

    love the Fact ...you guys kept it very real and Honest... Cheers...

  • @HSalamista
    @HSalamista Рік тому

    Hey Guys! Great show, I really enjoyed you rating watch collections in this way and format! Keep it up and I would love to have this as a permanent component of your programe! Thank you :)

  • @augieonorato2377
    @augieonorato2377 Рік тому

    love the epi. Your guys' views are awesome when it comes to independent and "entry level" brands. Side note, George, where do you get your wall clocks from?

  • @MPD90
    @MPD90 Рік тому +15

    Great episode, would love to see this become a regular segment. Could be better still with a bit more structure - i.e. each collection what's the one you'd drop, what's the one you'd add, what's the ugly duckling, what's the pillar of the collection etc.. just ideas!

  • @neolim
    @neolim Рік тому +1

    love the episode! Not alot of hype pieces. Wondering if they were left off submissions 😅

  • @videogamesare1
    @videogamesare1 Рік тому +1

    Love the “would I talk to them” exercise

  • @davesrc_crawling8349
    @davesrc_crawling8349 Рік тому

    Another great episode. Have you thought of including Marcus in the wrist check at the start of each episode?

    • @marcusflack1523
      @marcusflack1523 Рік тому

      Nah forget that guy. Hes just a button pusher

    • @davesrc_crawling8349
      @davesrc_crawling8349 Рік тому

      @@marcusflack1523 😂 a button pusher with a following and a watch! Get amongst it! 👍

  • @WparuSlowach
    @WparuSlowach Рік тому

    That Furlan Marii, such a watch!
    I just dusted off my instagram account. I haven't used it for years to send you my collection today.
    Great episode! :)

  • @jordanmorgan1009
    @jordanmorgan1009 Рік тому +1

    George mentioned using a safe, what’s the threshold for requiring additional security?

    • @marcusflack1523
      @marcusflack1523 Рік тому

      the threshold is (if they were stolen would you simply buy them all again without blinking? if not then you need a safe. )

  • @stevehanley-bw2qf
    @stevehanley-bw2qf 11 місяців тому

    How can I get hold of one of those Bamford GMT’s I can only find it in steal thanks
    3:50

  • @notenoughtime7274
    @notenoughtime7274 Рік тому +2

    Loved the episode
    Congrats to everyone whose collections were shown. Great to see these, and loved the insights from the panel.

  • @tab3Gator
    @tab3Gator Рік тому +2

    Second best episode. More of this please!

  • @dgiz14
    @dgiz14 Рік тому +1

    Great episode! If you ever decide to do this again is there a way I could submit my collection if I don't have Instagram (or really any social media)?

  • @powerdoga
    @powerdoga Рік тому +1

    Best episode. IMO, the guy with Schofield watch wins, hands down.

  • @stuartbrand5617
    @stuartbrand5617 Рік тому +2

    Great to see the watches that make our friends smile.

  • @Cartridgegenerationgaming
    @Cartridgegenerationgaming Рік тому

    This was epic! This would be an epic monthly type episode.

  • @PadreDePato
    @PadreDePato Рік тому +1

    How do we submit pics??

  • @Timepieceguy
    @Timepieceguy Рік тому +2

    This is such a great episode. I really want to hear what you have to say about mine as much as other people. I have 95% sports watches on bracelets and would be scared to hear what you think. Any chance of more of these ? Another request. I would love to see a full SOTC of George’s watches. That would get special!

  • @BrokenClock2U
    @BrokenClock2U Рік тому +2

    Wow, the odds I’m wearing Bamford X Goodlife denim GMT! ❤

  • @Officially_UnCertified
    @Officially_UnCertified Рік тому +1

    Sad I missed uploading to this. I’ll definitely be contributing to the next ‘rate my collection’

  • @wladimirfichmann9446
    @wladimirfichmann9446 Рік тому +2

    Keep on rocking guys! Best podcast in the Marianna trench and on Mont Blanc! 🏆🧗🏼🗺️🌄

  • @magnusswann2403
    @magnusswann2403 Рік тому +2

    Not that its a competition but Christopher wins for me here, American 1921, Explorer I and a Watermel0n... Awesome!

  • @DeMobBoss
    @DeMobBoss Рік тому

    Seriously entertaining ep. Wish I knew about this I would've loved to have handed my collection up. Do it again please.

  • @christopherengberg-brixen386
    @christopherengberg-brixen386 Рік тому +2

    Great episode! I'm biased since you rated my collection favourably, haha 🎉. I did very much try to match you guys with that selection😅

  • @Uracas2012
    @Uracas2012 Рік тому +2

    Love it, though I score that first collection MUCH higher. :)

  • @spenl3x311
    @spenl3x311 Рік тому

    Adrian, in 2020 when I purchased my rootbear my AD quoted me £4k. I decided the oyster was good enough. Love the show

  • @barryvercueil2346
    @barryvercueil2346 Рік тому +1

    Absolutely loved this episode 😊 cheers.

  • @chrisenchemin7183
    @chrisenchemin7183 Рік тому

    Hello and thanks for this vid. About the watch you don't know about into the third collection, it's a Humism (a micro brand founded in Singapour in 2017). And the 3rd and the 5th collections are surely the better ones, in my opinion.

  • @RSSpec
    @RSSpec 6 місяців тому

    I have the same 114270 and 💯 agree that for THAT Model the 36 is just better proportions! Even compared to the newer 36 (124270) this older reference just has better proportions.