Garga Chatterjee speech | Your Empire and My People

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 26 сер 2024
  • Introducing Unadhu Perarasum Enadhu Makkalum
    (Your Empire and My People).
    Essays on politics, language rights and federalism.
    Intro speech by Aazhi Senthilnathan
    Special Address by Dr Garga Chatterjee (Author, member of Campaign for Language Equality and Rights), Kolkata.
    This video made exclusive for UA-cam Viewers by Shruti.TV
    +1 us : plus.google.co...
    Follow us : shrutiwebtv
    Twitte us : shrutitv
    Click us : www.shruti.tv
    Mail us : contact@shruti.tv
    an SUKASH Media Birds productions

КОМЕНТАРІ • 81

  • @subratamukherjee4498
    @subratamukherjee4498 8 місяців тому +8

    Time has come for an absolute political unity amongst non-hindi speaking states.

  • @kundrathurdude4460
    @kundrathurdude4460 6 років тому +55

    Garga Sir, pls do visit tamilnadu frequently, make more friends here, bridge bengal and tamil 🙏❤

    • @karma1977
      @karma1977 5 років тому +6

      include maharashtra too

    • @dada5minute130
      @dada5minute130 4 роки тому +5

      Love from Bengal ♥️

    • @sgovin2228
      @sgovin2228 3 роки тому

      Don't trust this guy. He creates hatred by going to every non Hindi speaking state. Bengalis oppose Hindi but they are teaching Bengali for just 84 students in a Adi dravidar school on karur. Plz see this link
      www.google.com/amp/s/m.timesofindia.com/city/chennai/learning-bengali-in-tamil-nadu-government-schools/amp_articleshow/68043753.cms
      Also they have Bengali as second language in Karnataka

    • @thoughtdriven6542
      @thoughtdriven6542 3 роки тому

      @@sgovin2228 you are a loser....you are spreading hatred speech ....we have proof in facebook

    • @bhijeberal9458
      @bhijeberal9458 2 роки тому +3

      Best Wishes from Bengal. 💓✌️🙏

  • @yogeswary30
    @yogeswary30 6 років тому +27

    GARGA , BRO YOU ARE A GREAT THINKER , We Tamils should join hands with the bengalis to distroy the DELHI EMPIRE for the good all diverse nationalities in the so,called ' INDIA'. Thanks a million for your powerful presentation.

    • @gsingh5267
      @gsingh5267 6 років тому +2

      Nalliah Sivananthan we would love to go with you

    • @bidyutbikashtalukdar8675
      @bidyutbikashtalukdar8675 5 років тому

      Pathetic creatures.

    • @sgovin2228
      @sgovin2228 3 роки тому

      It would be better to integrate with North Indians but not with bengalis in the name of language domination. As pet him, if Hindi is dominating why a Bengali song has become national anthem. As usual, please stand alone without any of these regional snakes. We are emotional fools and stay away from these kind of poisonous educated illiterate. If he is so fond of his Bengali language, why did he go to Harvard? Did he goto study Bengali literature there? He studied there and working in a great place like ISI Calcutta add talking about the saving the language.
      He should have studied Bengali literature liked Tamil literature and worked as a Bengali teacher or professor.
      This is called in Tamil, padikradhu Ramayanam, idippadhu hanuman koil.

  • @anidutta129
    @anidutta129 5 років тому +9

    জয় বাংলা ✌✊

  • @AmitDas-wv4ok
    @AmitDas-wv4ok 9 місяців тому +2

    We proud to be Tamil and Bengali ❤‍🩹

  • @managmuni9860
    @managmuni9860 5 років тому +9

    Good Talks Garga Sir ...
    From Karnataka

  • @Cacofonixravi
    @Cacofonixravi 6 років тому +7

    Bro Garga. Good thought provoking speech, thanks for taking the time and reaching us. TN is the foremost state to have their own party ruling and rejecting national parties. Fraternity should be practiced and no better time than now to show. As you rightly mentioned every body should come out to fight and defend our freedom and right to be treated equally, in a country/state where the majority are illiterate and poor struggling to make a living the responsibility comes to the learned and well off to take leadership and propagate, bring awareness what is the right thing to do. We can find few lessons in French and American Revolutions. And remember the story of David and Goliath. There is always a giant killer. Keep the dialogs going and sure we will celebrate the victory with rasagollas at appropriate time. Thank you.

  • @sabaalam7239
    @sabaalam7239 5 років тому +4

    Garga bhaia ,you are always caring about freedom in BANGLA language , Hindi is not language of bangoli people and nobody should push to Speak Hindi!!! Hindi is not Indian national language. In Indian constitution no national language is written!!! Every one can speak their own language. It should be people own choice what people choose. Bangle is only for Bangoli people. Every-things are taken by none Bengali people in west bangle. Indeed other Indian states people doesn’t want bangoli people to live in west bangle, it is a corporate business hub for whole India!! They think Bangoli people should go to hell ,no caring for people of bangol, nobody cares about Bangoli people .Bangoli people are sleeping with mustard oil on their nose!!! Every opportunities are taken by none bangoli people!!!!!!Weakness is necessary for Bangoli people !!! Weak up brother and sisters of west bangle. You have to free the land and struggle for your own freedom ,success and prosperity. Education is the first choice for you own people.Think before it is too late!!!!! God bless you all

  • @ardhenduchakraborty5843
    @ardhenduchakraborty5843 4 роки тому +7

    Yes ,Tamil, maloala, Karnataka,odia, bengalee must unite against hindism , The Hindi people always against non Hindi people . We can not tolerate Hindi as national language . Start movement.against Hindi .

  • @vinodchelladurai3046
    @vinodchelladurai3046 6 років тому +10

    We must encourage other indian languages to counter the influence of hindi....!!!!

  • @souravdas-ln1uk
    @souravdas-ln1uk 3 роки тому +6

    জয় বাংলা

  • @SwapnDey-bs4nq
    @SwapnDey-bs4nq Місяць тому +1

    Joy.. Tamil.... Joy... Bangla....... Joy... Hind

  • @anupkumar9116
    @anupkumar9116 5 років тому +7

    People of India has not heard of Raja Raja chola and Pala Empires .But have heard of Rana Pratap who was a marginal player

    • @rajvardhansinghsisodiya1095
      @rajvardhansinghsisodiya1095 2 роки тому

      Who told Rana Pratap was a marginal player

    • @Jungle_boy123
      @Jungle_boy123 Рік тому

      @@rajvardhansinghsisodiya1095 😂🤣😆

    • @rationalindian1409
      @rationalindian1409 Рік тому +2

      ​@@rajvardhansinghsisodiya1095 Rana Pratap did resistance movement against Akbar . Every one respects him for his actions ..but get this thing that he mainly resisted against Mughals for rule over mewar , In a similar way Rayashresta pratapaditya Guhathakur resisted against them in West Bengal...Now my question to you ...Have you heard of him ??? I guess not because CBSE/ ICSe is a Delhi board / Hindi belt board .

  • @subratabhowal7590
    @subratabhowal7590 9 місяців тому

    "Turn a tree into a log and it
    will burn for you, but it will
    never bear living flowers
    and fruits." - Gurudev
    Rabindranath Tagor.
    "I want all people to be
    Indians first and Indians
    last and nothing else but
    Indians."
    - B. R. Ambedkar.

  • @datalicious43
    @datalicious43 5 років тому +2

    Well said Gargo. Keep it up. I am with you.

  • @bauwndule
    @bauwndule 6 років тому +9

    Joy Bangla !

  • @VBPuthige
    @VBPuthige 6 років тому +4

    Amazing analyses

  • @biplabdey6367
    @biplabdey6367 6 років тому +6

    Right , go back hindi

  • @aritrasarkar1134
    @aritrasarkar1134 3 роки тому +2

    Joy Bangla 💪

  • @muthu1111111111
    @muthu1111111111 4 роки тому +2

    I like your speech..

  • @arkaraychaudhuri_
    @arkaraychaudhuri_ 8 місяців тому

  • @munmunhussain3195
    @munmunhussain3195 6 років тому +4

    you real hero

  • @sgovin2228
    @sgovin2228 3 роки тому +1

    Tamilnadu people who attended his speech should use your brain. When he told 87 percent bengalis in wb, you guys should ask the percentage of bengalis in other states. Why he didn't mention that there are 67% bengalis in tripura and 28% in Assam in 2011 census? Does he have a selective memory?
    So, please don't waste your time by attending this kind of shitty speech. The way you are against Hindi, follow the same for other languages except South Indian languages.

    • @rohitchakraborty6914
      @rohitchakraborty6914 Рік тому +2

      According to what I know there are about 9 crores Bengalis in whole of India, out of these 9 crores 7.5 crore Bengali reside in west bengal the remaining 1.5 crore reside in other state out of which jharkhand and tripura comprises the maximum Bengalis, while on the other hand there are close to 2 crore Biharis and UP people residing in west bengal.

    • @Jungle_boy123
      @Jungle_boy123 Рік тому

      @@rohitchakraborty6914 2 cr 😆

    • @9edevbansal608
      @9edevbansal608 Рік тому

      JUST SHUT UP FELLOW HINDI GUY DISCRIMINATING BETWEEN NON HINDIANS

  • @wasiulhasan6919
    @wasiulhasan6919 6 років тому +1

    Very good

  • @munmunhussain3195
    @munmunhussain3195 6 років тому +2

    nice garga

  • @goodtimes5868
    @goodtimes5868 4 роки тому +3

    You can give as many as speeches you want but india will never be broken

    • @S.Ghosh_221
      @S.Ghosh_221 3 роки тому +5

      If Non Hindi people standing for rights and determination of their Non Hindi identity ,makes India broken, then what does it say about India ?
      Are you saying India is a union for suppressing the identity and rights of Non Hindi people and non hindi people must accept it?

    • @goodtimes5868
      @goodtimes5868 3 роки тому +1

      @@S.Ghosh_221 even if bengali people or any other decide that they want to become a separate nation it won't happen .

    • @S.Ghosh_221
      @S.Ghosh_221 3 роки тому +1

      @@goodtimes5868 We didn't say we want to become a separate nation...But it seems you can't fathom anyone demanding their linguistic and cultural rights within a united India in position opposite of hindi which smells very imperialistic and not respectful of India or Diversity at all .

    • @S.Ghosh_221
      @S.Ghosh_221 3 роки тому +1

      @@goodtimes5868 Isn't it you, who is implying that bengali or any other community should not be demanding any rights and freedom to express their identity in their state until they are a part of India while you expect bengalies and other non hindis to embrace Hindi ,no questions asked.?
      What does that make you?

    • @S.Ghosh_221
      @S.Ghosh_221 3 роки тому +1

      @@goodtimes5868 Aren't you implying that diverse linguistic non hindi communities as anti national for demanding their rights and right to determine their 1000s of years old identity while you expect Hindi from North India to be all pervasive, imposed and represent even non hindi people, no questions asked ?
      What does it make you?

  • @shanthinarayan7019
    @shanthinarayan7019 6 років тому +9

    Garga is breakingindia

    • @sameerwadgaonkar8782
      @sameerwadgaonkar8782 6 років тому +5

      a TMC PIMP

    • @ben-dr3wf
      @ben-dr3wf 6 років тому +1

      great argument

    • @jaividraksjosh
      @jaividraksjosh 6 років тому

      Rightfully so..

    • @i.ronnick9683
      @i.ronnick9683 4 роки тому +3

      The day non-hindi speaking states are on equal footing with hindi-speaking citizens, we will stop dividing India. The day our children are able to give write central government jobs in their mother tounge, we will stop dividing India. They day we will be able to get railway tickets, passport in our mother tounge, we will stop dividing India. The day we are no longer told in our own states to speak hindi, we will stop dividing India.

    • @sgovin2228
      @sgovin2228 3 роки тому

      Ivan pechai Tamil makkal kettaal avargalin nilai periyavargal sonnadu pola arasanai nambi purushanai vitta kadhai agum. Ivan oru bengali Brahmin.

  • @spaul8531
    @spaul8531 6 років тому +4

    garga is a tmc nut and greater Bangladesh propagator

    • @afsanahamed619
      @afsanahamed619 5 років тому +1

      Not greater Bangladesh , bt greater bengali people....

    • @kingdomofsaqulu7623
      @kingdomofsaqulu7623 3 роки тому +1

      @@afsanahamed619 You are NOT a Bengali , you're an Arab from from the desert.

    • @afsanahamed619
      @afsanahamed619 3 роки тому +3

      @@kingdomofsaqulu7623 I am not Arab bcs if you know history correctly majority of Muslims in Bengal are converted from lower caste Hindus and Buddhist community....for their social status

  • @paridhisharma621
    @paridhisharma621 3 роки тому

    Hahahh

  • @karanvarma4843
    @karanvarma4843 4 роки тому

    Commies keep making fools of the poor and literate. Now that people are uniting now they are finding ways of dividing us on the basis of language and race and caste. This is the same kind of people who screwed India for the past 60 years.

  • @ArunGupta-wj1xl
    @ArunGupta-wj1xl 6 років тому +1

    So the Gol Mukh has become the emissary for Pugli Mamata Banerjee in Tamilnadu.