WHEN AN INDIAN HISTORIAN LASHED OUT AT THE WEST - Reaction! | Brut India
Вставка
- Опубліковано 27 вер 2024
- Reaction Gear: amzn.to/2QgTwk2 (affiliate link)
____________________
Intro music by DAVIS
UA-cam - bit.ly/30OK7RR
Spotify - spoti.fi/2I3vRvE
iTunes: apple.co/2KnvgYN
SoundCloud: / unofficialdavis
Facebook: / unofficialdavis
Twitter: / unofficialdavis
Instagram: / unofficialdavis
___
Jamazing Patrons of February: Krishna Venkataraman, Avijit Singh, Madhan, Bhavya Singh, Sameer, Akash Dhanasekar, Riju Mahna and Shean Roldhan!
Be a patron for Jaby and support more videos like this!
/ jabykoay
___________________________________________________
Original Link:
• When An Indian Histori...
___________________________________________________
SOCIAL MEDIA:
~ACHARA KIRK~
Twitter & Instagram: @AcharaKirk
/ achara
~JABY KOAY~
UA-cam, Twitter, Instagram: @jabykoay
~VEERENDRA CHOWDARY~
Veerendra Chowdary created the opening animation.
Twitter: @NameisVeeru
~MOOSA RAZA~
Moosa Raza created additional background animation.
Instagram: @syedraza7
Twitter: @MoosaRaza27
___________________________________________________
Jaby WEST:
/ getjaby
Jaby ASIA:
/ jabytv
JABY KOAY'S SHORT FILMS PLAYLIST:
• JABY'S SHORT FILMS & F...
Click here to subscribe and know when the next video drops:
www.youtube.com...
Thanks for watching!!!
__________________________________________________
Credit of my favorite movie reviews song:
Highlight Reel Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0 License
creativecommons...
Intro song: Hudson Stanton (looks more like Nick Jonas than me)
UA-cam: / hudson12311
Insta: / hudsonstantonmusic
Jaby is acting like 8 year old kid defending his country 😅😂while Achara as always on point 🙌❤️ in getting the essence of the historian's speech.
Yeah. When Achara asked, "what's your point?" after Jaby was defending the US for outsourcing and why they do it etc. was funny.
Jaby isn't that much smarter
There is mutual benefit. China always has an option to not take that business from the US. Jaby has a point. It's not just US's fault
@@praveenbalineni6651 Yeah and some other poor country gonna take it simply because they need the money, and the blame will now just gonna shift to that country. The issue is inherently the same.
Jaby why you ignoring this comment bich🤣 i know you read it
Achara is on point like hell 💯
She grasps the essence so well, she is such an intelligent woman!
I really wonder sometimes, What is doing with Jaby ?
She is intelligent women no doubt about it. Perfect girl to get married 😉
That's portrayal of good EQ alongwith rational intelligence.
Jaby seems to have totally missed the point. His speech was not about the US or the outsourcing of goods to China etc. The context here is, In recent Glasgow, world climate summit India and China refused to sign to flush out CO2 emissions(coal usage) before a certain time limit in future to become carbon neutral because we are going through an industrial revolution(which is going to be the engine of the economy) which the west has gone through already in the 1900s and they(western countries) have refused to provide the necessary technology to reduce carbon emission during the industrial revolution for India and China. This is also similar to the Non-Proliferation Treaty of nuclear weapons (NPT) where the bunch of developed Western countries that already possess nuclear weapons wanted other countries to sign off the NPT that they won't indulge in making nuclear weapons which India refused to sign too as they deemed it condescending and hypocritical.
Exactly. Jaby seems to totally miss the point.
His monologue on why usa is in the right for outsourcing good. Cant stand it. Such ignorance right after watching a video as enlightening as that one.
Not new when it comes to nested problems discussions, jaby is always wandering in somewhere far from the point in discussion 😂
Well he’s American & American’s ain’t known for being smart or good thinkers
U can clearly see the Brits Mentality everytime their football team loses🤷♂️😂
Lmao underrated comment, deserves more likes
Yep, worse than Pakistanis losing in cricket.
bruh they literally cyber bullied a 14 year old. unbelievable twats.
True that
😂😂
America's imports are not responsible for China's pollution.. BUT America's CONSUPMTION is definitely responsible for a lot of pollution !!
But importing and outsourcing are two totally different things though. One is purchasing manufactured goods from an international company while the other is a company 'choosing' to use an outside source to make or manufacture their goods. So while the US may not responsible for the pollution from importing goods but they're definitely responsible for outsourcing. Also, every country imports something from one another which is the basic point of a trade.
China chose the produce it, so I think China is equally responsible. He is communist historian, so he will defend China for sure, and will only blame west, let’s get it straight he didn’t mention most important part, technology transfer to reduce pollution.
@@Kathakathan11 He's a Marxist, not a communist, there's a difference. And no one is saying that China or other Asian countries are not to blame and it's all the west's fault. He's just pointing out the hypocrisy and elitism of the west's finger pointing towards the east when they're equally to blame. The technology transfer point is totally invalid when it comes to third world countries because they were not part of the industrial revolution, unlike the west so they had to catch up.
@@Kathakathan11 Also, the west has done something similar before with the Non-Proliferation Treaty of nuclear weapons (NPT) where the bunch of developed western countries who already possessed nuclear weapons wanted other countries to sign off the NPT that they won't indulge in the making of nuclear weapons which India along with a couple of others countries were the only ones not to sign the treaty as they deemed it condescending and hypocritical so this is not new.
@@Navin4061 and do you know how this industrial revolution was possible? Where did resources come from? Who is paying the actual price of knowledge economy of USA? It wasn’t done only on their behest.
The problem is not about getting things for cheap. That is ok but shifting blame for pollution and looking down on other non-white nations is the problem. The problem is having a holier than thou attitude when you are the source of problem.
Yep exactly. The point was not about the US or China or outsourcing, it was about the west's attitude towards Asia in general.
Exactly! Jaby gave a looong monologue but missed the main point 😂
That point is more than obvious. It's pretty overtly stated in the video. I'd have nothing to offer if all I said was, "Yeah, agreed."
@@CineDesi Totally agreed. It just felt like you didn't get the gist of what was being said so I tried to clarify to the best of my abilities.
Loving the Money Heist reaction btw, you and Syntell have an amazing vibe.
@@CineDesi okay but what you said was also obvious to us. We know why China is producing hub of the world so it felt like either you didn't get the point or you're defending west.
"You want to tell us that we are responsible for all the problems because you'll never accept that you're the one principally to blame" Jaby proved the point 👍
Every time I see an article on BBC about any achievement of ISRO or any other scientific or any achievement in any field by India, the Brits go....'and we are still sending them aid'? in the comment section. First of all that 'aid' is peanuts. Also there were no reparations for all the atrocities during colonialism and if 'aid' is how we are getting (a miniscule part of it) back then so be it. I completely agree that the West has a condescending mentality towards the third world! The casualties during the colonial rule by Churchill and partition were waaaayyy more than the Holocaust and while the Holocaust was deplorable don't our deaths deserve the same kind of attention as the Holocaust gets in the world? Churchill is celebrated like a hero!!!!! He was as bad as Hitler if not more!!
Those aid are private aid. It is not to the govt of India!
My opinion about Churcill and hitler is that, Hitler was cruel to Jews who looks similarly to white people. While Churcill and other white heroes were cruel to African, Indian, Asian who white people still thinks as lower society like peasants/rodents who are barbaric and doesn't know how to live. Like how today also in some parts of India lower caste is treated. That's why Hilter is bad and Churchill is good because Churcill wasn't cruel to white people and Hitler was.
@@koushikdebnath31 Yes they stopped sending us a couple of years ago. But an average Brit isn't aware of that
@@seanmikk3655 Interesting
@@seanmikk3655 Well the Brits did have the 'Black zone' 'Grey Zone' 'White zone' policy where Israeli origin Jews in India and Parsis were placed in the 'grey zone' since they were lighter skinned than an average Indian and therefore 'deserved' to be treated better. I wouldn't be surprised if your theory was actually true!
To Jaby ,The historian is saying to the "developed world" not to lecture poor nations or the nation's who are producing products for West.He says that West should take responsibility to make the world a better place to live and stop caring only about West, this selfishness will doom the whole world, it's not only about one nation it's about all nations.Everyone must be fed and educated, if this can't be done than what is the point being rich.Its high time lets be more human and help all
Also, the developed nations today became developed off of exploiting the today's developing/underdeveloped states. If colonialism and the west exploiting other nations at their whim (out of selfish interest) didn't happen, the story might've been different. Countries like India would've been way above in the developed nations league, and UK still catching up.
I love when Jaby watches informative videos like these. I have already watched the video but it's interesting to hear his and Achara's Opinion on this topic I wish he starts doing more of this type of content.
IKR
I was going to say this but you've already worded it very eloquently :) Here take my like
@@anubhutidhawan6914 here .... Take my like! 😂😂😂👌
@@spylock8816 :)
He is not viewing this for information or to spread knowledge if that was supposed to be the case he must have point out how west is playing the blame game. He is doing this as India is a big market. if He watch something associated to India, more indians will see that his video, so it's just a money making machine. Have you seen any Indian Making reaction on West No, as Market. So In short, " Ye sab milke hamko pagal bana rhe h ******. *********** " aage toh sab jaante he h.
Hey Jaby, people are aware of the multiple facets of the issue. We are trying to tackle them. The problem is lecturing us from a high pedestal of self righteousness.
Well said.... am so proud to be an Indian
His rant wasn't about outsourcing stuff to other countries......it's about shifting blame to such countries even though u know that u are indirectly responsible fr a significant chunk of those emissions which u're blaming them for
The rant ws about the hypocrisy & the superiority mindset of the west which enables them to think that they are the only ones who care about the future & such "care" gives them the authority to tell others how to do stuff, while being completely disjointed with their day-to-day challenges
creating net emissions would make sense, where the CO2 emissions of imports are added and the CO2 emissions of exports are subtracted.
KLMFAO The west is filled with self hate and doubt. We are literally importing the third world replacing our native populations. Its so cool right now to despise the west. Go ONE DAY without our tech and our inventions. I dare you to try. We will die off and the sun will set on our reign BUT we WILL be mi8ssed when we are gone TRUST ME!
@@miketyson3824 LoL! Another misinformed westerner on the net!! Go get a life.
I guess the person was saying how these emotions grew large but I would say we had much time to work on these emitions because now we need solutions for the rising pollution
*emissions
Powerful about how the Europeans had an effect on India as well, I loved truth being revealed. If India and Africa could unit it would change the commerce game.
Yes, but don't bring Islam.
india would not be anywhere near as developed if we hadnt helped to develop them
the reason africa is a worse off is you rejected us and burned what we built down,now you starve and blame us for that also.
africa will never thrive
@@random_an0n stupidest thing anyone ever said.
@@airbornefox11 YET you have no counter argument. PELASE explain to me why Egypt south Africa and India ALL have had higher GDPs then their neighbors who didn't have western influence? PLEASE EXPLAIN! You think Egypt didn't benefit from us building the Suez canal genius? You think the infrastructure of India which is still primarily from our building would be there without us?
@@miketyson3824 our building? What did you do personally 😂
He just nailed the westerns,proud on you sanatani putra
This is so true children are starving to death in the middle east in Yemen and so many in refugee camps.
In parts of Africa and Asia there's famine and poverty.
The poor starve and die everyday yet we in the west have an obesity problem.
We like to tell them not to consume when we over consume.
and in the distant past so did we,and we was forced to work in mines as children,work houses and die an early death being paid next to nothing
EVERYTHING 3rd worlders have to put up with europeans had to do once too,but we developed past it and due to the sweat blood and tears of our ancestors we live good lives now,3rd worlders seeing us living cushy cannot understand this and are jelous with hatred
their ancestors too one day will be just as cushy if they work hard but they dont want too,they want to come here and steal the sweat of my great grandfathers brow like a thief
What no-one is bringing in is that, the reason is not the cheap production. It is the unnecessary production which is not the need but wants. And the kind of wastage you guys do without thinking of the global consuquence. 🙏🇮🇳
Exactly unnecessary wastage should be stopped.
and they laugh at people who reuse things instead of throwing in the bin raising carbon footprint
Vijay Prashad is one of the most important voices in Geopolitics. Please look into him and his books. One of the greatest minds of our times
Do you realise that even today USA and Europe are creating extraordinary levels of pollution per capita compared to most other countries, even considering that a lot of their products are being manufactured in China, Vietnam and other poorer countries.
no we dont lmao,our carbon footprint is much smaller than china and indias,our rivers are clean and so is our air,dead bodies float down the ganges and the lakes in china set on fire due to chemicals,stop being silly..
@@random_an0n your name says it all.
They are ones lecturing developing countries
This is what I want to say to all those rich one percent and movie stars who lecture us for "environment " and issues .
While they themselves live under air condition , fly private jets , drive cars that consume most fuel , waste food etc .
The speaker is asking the first world countries to reduce consumption before asking the developing countries to do so. The focus is towards future-asking to reduce consumption,materialism
6:50 nope USA has a lot too. The thing in this is that for the engineers to work and function the factory in USA would require more money as compared to those in China or India. So it's cheaper, it's not that there are less engineers in USA for that work
There are less engineers in US that's why the H1B1 Visa program exists!
@@BlackHawkTejas they have HiB1 to get very good, best of best engineer. And they don't have a number of engineers which could be siad is low. As for their population they have a many engineers.
@@user-cv1jb9xv2p Not enough to fullfill the requirements!! Have personally seen it from close quarters. H1B1 also get average engineers from around the world.
@@BlackHawkTejas hmmm the requirement is more in US than other places.
Someone else commented the backstory. I copied the comment and I am pasting it below.
->
"Dr Prashad clarified in an interview after this outburst, as to what the immediate spark was that instigated this rant.
He had met some oil company officials at the COP26 conference, and spoke about the atrocities committed by the western countries, in cahoots with local governments, against a poor village in Mozambique when they protested against oil refineries in Exxon and Total near their village. The oil executives had told him that yes, everyone knows what's happening but noone cares. And that is what triggered this anger, according to him."
EMOTIONAL DAMAGE🔥
9:43 The great Pyramid's of Giza were not built by slaves, that is a common misconception because of biblical accounts. The fact is, it was built by Egyptians workers who were well paid for their labour, it was considered a great honor among Egyptians.
There is actually little to no proof of any Jewish slaves in large numbers being used for anything in Egypt, there were slaves in Egypt for sure but they didn't build the pyramids or anything for that matter.
🙏🏼👍🏼 trying to break propoganda, misconceptions, fake news
Thank you i'm egyptian and i literally just commented that
The slaves part cannot be proven for sure, what achara said is just misinformation from white supremacists. Mostly learnt from western history books or movies
Crt
@@ranamselem171 i want to come to Egypt... To visit historical places
Very interesting civilization
Its not about outsourcing.... Its about the lecturing done by US ON Asian countries about pollution... But in the hind sight they are also responsible for the increase in the pollution there
Welcome to real capitilism jaby.
Total cost=private cost for production+social cost experienced by the country(negative effects).
The historian is talking about the social costs that the western world don't want to rise in their own country. That is the reason why developed contries outsource their manufacturing to developing nations. And because the standard of living in developing countries is still very low as compared to developed ones, majorly because of colonialism, their market is cheap. So in order to rebuild their economy developing nations,cauz of lack of capital, give incentives to attract major cash to flow in again that was sucked out. And now the hypocrisy by West, In doing so the developing nations are forced by West to excercise capitalism and lower the total cost to get deals, but at the same time restrains them by lecturing on social costs and imposing sanctions , chaining their economy in a rigid state.
Long story short: The west dosent want to pay for the social costs incurred in the developing country for their products being manufactured,but also lectures the developing nations to take care of them on their own. And apart from that dosent give aid but debts to get profit on that.
All the world's beauty and cosmetic products made by child labourers
That guy doesn't even know anything
All the points you are talking about to defend the West is exactly the condescension the debate is talking about.
What a clear and eloquent man!
Jaby look it is simple, in past west industrialised itself using all resources but now when it is our turn you guys are lecturing us about nature
It was India that made the policies for the IPCC's 1st meeting in early 90s for global warming. When no country was listening to their scientists. Few of Indians who pushed for IPCC to come into existence who supported it from day one and was the one to form the guidelines but very few countries then signed it on that day. It took west time to sigh it. And now they are saying that India and developing countries like India should stop their work for global warming.
It is India which was has significantly increased its green cover in last 50 years. It is India and China which have huge population but still pushing hard for electric vehicles, yes USA is also doing good for electric vehicles but they are more developed infrastructure.
About the last part, it again depends on what producer's country can produce for $1. The main reason China was producing world's good was because at that time it could produce a lot more for $1 than now because it produced a lot more in those 2 decades. Because of which Chinese people got rich and now they can't produce cheaper than India.
Today, India & Vietnam are getting companies to manufacture goods, but tomorrow when India will develop and produce less for $1, maybe another country from Africa will come into manufacturing geopolitics?
All in all, if cheap countries started producing at low price, there are loads of other countries ready to grab the opportunity. Reason being only handful of developed countries outsourcing from literally any country who can produce more for $1.
The point he made there was atleast not to blame on the carbon emissions if that's not done unnecessarily and strongly not to blame if that's done to suffice our need... ( our needs include usa being dependent on China for product production ). The point is usa made china to raise it's emissions not unnecessarily but atleast not blame them for that.
I just love Achara from North East India 🇮🇳
Wow, the way he gave his speech, salute Sir.
That's the western ideology
Achara is more connected and factual like most Asians. West doesn't not know Asians
Achara always gets the deepest of the basics! Kudos to both of you
China, India and other asian countries produce cheaper products also because American companies underpay the employees. They’ll have to pay so much more to their own citizens, so they outsource the manufacturing.
Underpaying people doesn’t only limit to labor, it also extends to well educated engineers, doctors and scientists. And then, when immigrants come to the country for jobs, the local citizens blame immigrants for coming there and taking “their” jobs.
Jaby went on a altogether different tangent. Achara is on point.
If you look at it at a net perspective, that one product becomes cheap for you. But Net expense increases for the people in countries which is manufacturing, because even though one product becomes cheaps, the pollution is causing health issues and finally a person ends up paying $5 lower for that product but pays extra $50 for medicines.
Been a jaby fan for a damn long time still love his vids tho❤️
Whattt??
"though" doesnt work if you're already a fan.
Fan?
@@karankapoor608whatever man 😊 i was commenting on Jaby's vid not yours anyway
@@roflgandhi. i dont have a video. So its physically impossible to comment on it something that doesn't exist.
Thank you for sharing this, wouldn't have known about this video if you had not shared it. NIce one!
“Scientists for iphones”let that sink in
Jaby being a baby ! Example of permanent Colonial mindset !
They're hypocrites
I study economics and trust me he is speaking just true words. All countries blame us that we increase pollution and we are poor but you are responsible for this.
0:50 oh this video. It's good.
Lol jaby you are wrong, west goes to china for cheap labor... that is due to due to currency difference and the simple fact that there is more supply (humans) hence less labor cost (even without currency difference). Cost of living is low in India/China when you look at it in dollars. Maybe USA must add a "China Tax" for every import?
Indians are indebted for unveiling the truth.....sufferings of India in the past.
Well, talking about right now, just run a quick google search on CO2 emissions and pay attention to per capita (per 100) column. You will find that yes total pollution from China and India are massive BUT (and it's a huge but), the per capita shows that what 100 people of China emit, 100 people of US or europe emit way more than them. Which means, still people of China and India are using way less resources than people of the west.
That's all I can say.
India is a already proven that, It is one of the greatest countries in the world. After the independence, Even though India's education system is 13% and the economy dropped down, but still there is no damage to the unity. India still formed unity with rich different cultures and different languages.
India is also a breeding ground for hatred amongst the diverse groups that supposedly "coexist" in its own lands. It's absolutely not "one of the greatest countries in the world", I don't know how you've managed to come up with that notion. In a country where minorities are marginalized and even after 75 years of independence, it is unable to abolish a flawed Quota and reservation system that was initially set up for the betterment of the people. India has just as many flaws as any other country. No country can be outright declared to be in a list of "the best countries". The issue at hand is that the west's patronizing towards African and Asian countries for being third world and majorly contributing and causing issues such as global warming and having large carbon footprints is inherently an issue that is sourced from the west. This is not the right place or discussion for patriotism. Looking at this issue and also your own country from a more realistic approach might be good you know, just blindly praising it for the sole reason of being a citizen shows for the lack of introspection and the blatant ignorance of turning a blind eye towards its flaws and shortcomings. I otherwise wish you a good day, cheers mate.
The problem is not having cheaper. Problem is today we don’t know where to draw the line and say we need less. We need to live simple. We’ll want everything and MORE.
Love your reactions keep it up
Achara was a 100% on point. She perfectly grasped the essence of what the video was all about.
I think probably the only reason why USA outsources production to China and India is simply because of how cheap our labour is. It has nothing to do with the level of scientific development or the availability of expert scientists. It's simply cheaper.
His point regarding pollution, isn' one in defence of China but rather one which counteracts the age old narrative that China is the only "big" country that pollutes. His aim was to communicate the fact that if USA didn't outsource production as greatly then they would be the worlds biggest polluter instead of China.
Actually, he did a monologue. That entire clip was a part of the monologue.
11:46 Nope Naah. He never said that China's pollution is basically America's pollution and neither did he meant that. He said - You outsource production to China and "Then You Say China Is Carbon Polluter ... Try to produce it in your country then see your carbon emissions rise." He meant that you, me, we all know that you outsourced production to China, then why are you blaming China (developing country(s) ) as if it is those nations who are wrong and you (the west) is right. He was annoyed by the condescending, clearly. He was annoyed by the blaming. As condescending word was mentioned many time since the beginning of the video clearly the meaning of those lines is this one.
The point is not using homegrown products but using fewer products... so wherever that pollution is generated it is less.... basically focusing on consumer-based carbon footprint and not production-based carbon footprint
Wow Jaby... Lot of courage is needed to show this videos in your channel when it is against one's country. I respect your viewpoints. Keepit up Jaby and Achara.
We’re not talking about ALL THE POLLUTION rising from China. He was talking about China creating pollution which should have been created by the USA and other west European countries if they were mass producing daily necessities which are required by the USA and Western Europe.
9:23 naah Not Every, there are a lot of structural, monument that were built out of love, devotion, etc. A lot in Indian subcontinent as I know. I don't know about rest of the world... But, I'm sure, there must be structures which didn't involve barbarianism.
Actually there is a lot of archaeological proof that the pyramids were built by salaried professionals over a very long timescale. They had special towns and burial sites near areas of pyramid constructions, (there are 1000s of pyramids all over Egypt and Sudan btw), the vast majority of construction workers were freemen. The slaves in antiquity were mostly used for working in mines and extremely dangerous occupations.
no there isnt all records say slavery
No one has committed more sins than Abrahmic religions followers on earth
Ans that's coming from a Muslim
Varn vyavastha
And blame the monarchy not the religion you should know that at that time period there was no such thing as democracy they were even fighting among themselves for territory and power just like In Indian subcontinent Ashoka killed thousands of innocent people for example in Kalinga war wasn't Ashoka a hindu
@@Hoe-numan5 ashoka wasn't a hindu as his grandpa was a jain
@@vinaykumar9002 it's a same thing its a dharmic religion
Bravo!
A report came out about 2 months ago that said that the developed countries were doing the least for climate change while the developing ones were doing the most to tackle climate change. Also you've to look at the historical carbon emission of usa, uk, France and all of these developed nation before crying about the emissions of China and India. USA is the topmost contributor in carbon emission. Also in 2011 or near to that year, india and other developing countries requested the developed nations to assemble 1.something trillion dollars, so that this money could be distributed among developing nations and they could turn to using renewable sources of energy generation. But this is yet to be delivered. Also india ranked 10th in the list of countries that are doing most to tackle climate change, and nobody is ranked in 1st three, so india is 7th in that regard. India has already achieved 40% of its energy generation by renewable sources, which it had promised to do in 2030, but it achieved in 2021 itself. So now indian is aiming to achieve 50% by 2030.
All I want to say that despite being the biggest reason for pollution and climate change, the developed nations are still not doing enough to tackle climate change. All they have done is they themselves stopped emitting, well that's not enough, they need to help other developing or underdeveloped nations in shifting towards renewable sources of energy. Especially USA with that big of an economy , can do much more than what it's doing right now, but I guess people love to play the blame game.
lmao WHAT?!?! we are the ones developing the green tech and reduced our emmisions low af be quiet
@@random_an0n So I gave a whole lot of data and wrote a big ass paragraph and all you had to say is "yeah, we're investing green tech hurrah". How do you say those things with a straight face, with millions of homeless people even though you've a 24 trillion dollar economy?
Asking that outsourced entities should pay more wages, is like asking outsourcing entities should pay more for cost for production 🤦♂
You are dealing with today as a businessman, dear sir the extreme weather events like heat waves, cloud bursts, droughts are happening because of historical carbon emissions.
Jabby just ended up talking about those 5 seconds and dropped whole other things in 4+ minutes!
A very healthy reaction. 🙏🏼 Actually, do hell with the apology........ I want that 45 trillion Pound back. India came strongly to the international stage in 75 years. The colonial powers should pay their dues and then we shall see how long these dirt poor, so called first world countries will take to get back to where India is today.
When the discussion about Climate Change was going on at the international level, all the countries reached an agreement which he mentions in the video.
According to this agreement, the developed nations agreed to provide financial and technical aid to middle and low income countries to better tackle the issue of climate change. But only an insignificant percentage of the agreed amount has been given. Despite this the leaders of these nations showed a holier than thou attitude in the recent Glasgow gathering. This was that guy's response to this attitude.
Jaby when I listen ur point and compare to achara ….makes me feels like women are smarter than men….jaby is like true American….whatever is going on….not my fault…
On one side, they are asking why India is not focusing on removing poverty instead of focusing on space; on the other side, they are saying, why don't you switch your cheaper source of energy for a much greener (more expensive), for which they are not even willing to finance or technology transfer cheaply and they talk about equal responsibility for the future.
whether it is speech, comments on any subject, movie review, Why Jaby gets them wrongly. why he understand it incorrectly and whoever with him have to correct him. its been many years, almost 2 million subs. but still Jaby is unchanged. How he maintains that. its commendable.
Well said. I wonder the same
You have basic misunderstanding. Yes, it is cheaper in China to manufacture, because the workers there are underpaid, not because China has better scientist or infrastructure.
This man can make 'condescending' the most searched word on Google.😂😂
Okay just think it that way if China didn't export much items in America UK etc, their Carbon emission would be much less and world is only looking for top 3, and now it shifted from China India to US UK that's how it works. And if you want cheap you have to utilize resources that are not good for environment, and check Carbon emission per person and check the chart and see how West is not much back in the race but to lead it
Point he is talking about whole climate change issue developed nations are not keeping their promises of helping developing countries with resources and technology. Point is they are lecturing developing countries to stop using coal and transition to green energy point he is making is people who already have limited resources how they are supposed to directly jump into expensive green energy if developed countries are not going to help
‼️‼️‼️ with all respect to ur explanation.....the Indian guy at the starting said "Principally" ....not talking about why and howaboutary of it 👍🏼‼️
Before British came to India, India contributed 25% of the world's GDP and 50% of trade was happening in India when they left our GDP was just 2-3% of GDP
The whole thing about pollution is if you are benefiting from production in china/india then don't complaint we are polluting.
I like you guys, keep up the India work!:)
Please react to Attack on Titan 🙏🙏
u dont get the point he wasnt asking the america ,uk etc to build their own good in their country ,he was saying that they cant produce goods on their land so they outsource things but still they lecture china and india about how they should reduce their carbon emmision and consumption when they are exactly doing most of it on their orders ......this is the point (hiring a hitman to kill someone then arresting them saying that murder is a crime)...
Love Vijay! He calls it like it is. He’s a national treasure
I am from India. India isn't poor because of the British. That was a valid argument till say 1977.
But you can't blame the British 75 years after independence. India is poor because it adopted socialism.
The West is rich because it is more capitalist. It isn't about exploitation.
Poor Westerners fall for these tales Indians give
Finally a sensible comment. Finally no victim card and just reality.
What the west forgets is that it has already ‘developed’ at the cost of the environment and other countries resources.And what essentially triggered the environmental collapse post the Industrial Revolution.And now they expect fairness in this collaboration,while still consuming more than their fair share.They should ideally be prepared to give more or consume less
If Acharaa opened her own channel, many of us would just shift there for sure! Acharaa you should open up your own channel as well! Pls🙏😍❤️
It is not about china Jaby, the gist of the video is that the west cashed on fossil fuels for last two centuries, and now when developing countries are trying to benefit from these conventional sources, all of a sudden the west is asking us to reduce carbon emissions. The west is far more responsible for historical emissions than east.
West is always like "What we do is principled and correct and never evil or barbaric"
You can buy that mug for $1 in India. You are cooking your food in the neighbor's kitchen and say we have no smoke in our kitchen.
First of all Jaby, you totally missed the point which other have pointed out in the comment section. Second, Asian and African countries are incentivizing because the West looted and took all of the resources for 100s of years. We have to start from the ground up and we are starting in -ve balance. There is only so much ways you can fight with the West where they threaten with their advanced military and nuclear technologies. The West is responsible for 90% of the stuff. We are trying to fix that now piece by piece. Return us the resources looted over the years and we will show you progress and may even trump you in a lot of areas. We have the intelligent people and we have done a lot with limited resources.
You know I can't help but despise these sneering upper-class Marxists. This guy comes from the most elitist school in India and did his post-secondary schooling at expensive private institutions in the US. He's had a life and career beyond what most middle-class people anywhere could possibly hope for and he dares to deride the "middle-class, bourgeois" Westerners. And the so-called Indian "right", who would not tolerate one word he says as a mouthpiece for CPI(M) or China, is totally fine with boosting this stuff because cheap nationalism trumps any other minimal notion of principle they might have.
Yup. bullseye. People are just like wifi repeaters nowadays. They see some information and if it fits their freq, they start repeating it. Absolutely 0 thought and effort to know who is saying that and why are they saying it. I think we are headed towards a world where public discourse will only be narrative parroting. Context and nuance are near extinct and this is a breeding ground for Evil like Hitler, Churchill and Xi Jing Ping. Dark days ahead.
People aren't like repeaters, people should be like this. In a sense that we should agree/disagree with ideas and not people. Even the most Marxist of people can make a valid point and the this is valid for the people associated with Right wi g movements too. In this 5 mi use speech, this guy talks of colonial abuse which isn't wrong. I can disagree him on 99 points because economically I tilt to the right and though I can be categorized as the same middle class bourgeois he's deriding, I agree with him on this one point.
@@soumyaranjanpattnaik2354 Whenever someone utters the word "Bourgeois" I know its an Elite Liberal funded up CCP pretending to speak on behalf of the "Working Class"
@@zombieda6855 To a certain extent yes, because these aren't laymen terms. But, it's drawn from the French revolution, much like the definition of the Left and Right wings of today. I dont know, but even if this guy is CCP funded, he's making a valid point. As I said, it's not about supporting that person but what he's saying. Tomorrow if he speaks ill of India, the same folks who are appreciating his insight will deride him. And that's how it should be. We need to fight what's being propagated and not the person himself/herself.
@@soumyaranjanpattnaik2354 We don't live in an ideal world. What you are suggesting that we should support ideas and not people is again very utopian. When people start following some body, they don't follow people, they follow the ideas that those people communicate. Later when the same person tells them about things that they are not well aware, they will believe in whatever the person says based on their bias of previous affirmation. Why every horrible dictator in history was a populist leader? Because they initially started with the ideas that were right and resonated with people. It is therefore very important who is uttering the idea, than just the idea itself. Ideas without context is the textbook definition of Propaganda. In this case the context is that the guy has always had the agenda of defending nefarious activities of China. So even if you agree with what he says, by giving his words your voice, you are becoming a part of that agenda whether you like it or not. Hence, don't be a repeater of everything you agree with. Look whom you are agreeing with too.
Achara is just downright smarter than Jaby. She just gets the context better.
I like you guys..Hi from India 🇮🇳 ♥️
Okay, i think the discussion went sideways. Everyone should note the context of his bashing the west. It was from an environmental and climate change perspective. This is the problem associated with these videos. They take out excerpts and compile them without contextualisation. Then, I guess people do not have patience for consuming full videos even if that clears the whole picture. The irony is that this change in perception is also west sanctioned.😜😜😊😅
Jaby needs a few books on Economics
Hell yeah season 2 of the revenge of mortals and the Gods against Lusif
I always skip to the part when Achara starts speaking. It's obvious that I wanna hear stuff that makes sense and not just defending your country without understanding the context discussed in video.
I don't any of this channel's movie/tv show content or any entertainment driven content but I do like watching this kind of videos where there's a lot on useful information and constructive talks and ideas.
Man i saw this coming lmao
I hate these videos 😗 For how many years , these PPL will blames west for our own failures . Dude It's over an century , high time to take responsibility for own failures instead lashing out at some rando
What's over a century?
45 trillion. I think we should remember for 500 years more at least.
Love your videos with Achara, keep them coming! You didn’t talk about a major point the journalist made - US carbon emissions accounts for way more as compared to their population. Per capita carbon emissions of US is 15 + tonnes whereas that of developing countries like India is 1.5! An average american emits 10 times the energy an average Indian does. Excessive use of fuel guzzling cars, air conditioning, wasteful appliances like clothes driers - all account for a very large percentage of emissions. This is the hard part - reducing this luxury. And developed nations need to take responsibility for how much they consume.