As of 6/20, the official UA-cam smart tv apps have broken support for user-uploaded 5.1 videos. You are still able to listen to surround sound content by using third-party apps such as SmartTubeNext. I will update this comment once the official apps have been fixed!
And also works through my ccwgtv comes up as the same specifications. It's been working for me for months...maybe UA-cam is taking a while to turn 5.1 on for all compatible videos?
I have a 5.1 surround sound setup. All 5 work on the setup test tones but on this video, the surround speaker sound is coming from the corresponding front instead of rear channels. IE, right surround comes out the right front, same with left surround.
This doesn't work from UA-cam. Stereo sound only. If i use a 5.1 test file natively in Windows 10 with MPC, i also get sound in surround speakers. I also get 5.1 in PC Games, so 5.1 on UA-cam is broken as all test videos there have 2.0 output.
hehehe i just could not figure out my ear buds issue it was like all sound came from the opessite side. Apearantly it did, i crosed cables while fixing it with my buds making side sounds go haywire thanks for the nice test sound
Thanks for the onfo. I am thinking maybe it just sounds backwards. The rest of the test its accurate, all of my games, movies etc are all correct. Im thinking just my poor judgement cant tell? Does sound good either way. Thanks again! @@jehorigby8778
@@akyhne My computer is just another component in my home theater system. My "computer monitor" is a 65" OLED. The audio from the computer is run through a high end surround processor and then an amplifier, then to full-blown home stereo/surround speakers. Of course, gaming on it is the bee's knees....
@@batman.darthmaul I was just curious to what audio setup you have. I can't seem to find a decent set of surround speakers, for PC. My audio card is not that high end, just a Soundblaster Z.
@@akyhne I was lucky enough to buy the Logitech X-530 set when it was new back in the day. They've been great for simple computer speakers! Sorry they aren't made anymore, but there are probably similar options.
Thanks! I wanted to verify if my system works correctly with DD5.1 and it didnt... Then i changed some settings now channels come through separately as they should.
A bummer that left and right channel test different frequencies in this video. For a moment I thought my headphones broke. Got some Beyerdynamics MMX300 B-Ware and almost sent them back but they were fine in other tests.
@@gamagama69It probably just sounds like it works for the center channel. Check if it's not just because left and right are playing the exact same audio. That would give the same effect.
I found this online. I'm quoting it in two separate posts, as UA-cam tends to remove links, but the video ID is YEvROdECGDw: "Try adding one of these: --try-supported-channel-layouts --force-wave-audio --disable-audio-output-resampler to the target path of the shortcut that's on your desktop. will look something like this: "C:\Program Files (x86)\Google\Chrome\Application\chrome.exe" --try-supported-channel-layouts The top one worked for me. Got the info from this video"
I played this video in my 5.1.2 system when front left and front right sound producing sorround back left,right also produce sound and when sourround speaker time to produce sound there is no sound in surround speaker
I can’t seem to get 5.1 surround sound to work on UA-cam. Right surround is right and left surround is left. Actually, my received tells me it’s a Stereo recording.
Please help me, I'm looking for the TWS inears with the deepest bass, it has to be boom and make my head explode. Really fat. And the TWS should be loud too. Which ones are the best?
@@playnicegames So here’s what I’ve figured out. I have a few ways to play surround/Atmos content in my studio and I've confirmed my results. My files are correctly encoded and still stored as 5.1 on UA-cam servers, but the official UA-cam app broke support for 5.1 on user-uploaded content as of Saturday. On Android TVs, you can use “SmartTubeNext” (worth checking out regardless), and it plays back the user-uploaded 5.1 correctly in all of UA-cam's 5.1 compressed audio formats. “My Scientology Movie” works because it’s an official Google upload for the “UA-cam Movies & Shows” platform. Along with that, UA-cam TV's surround sound content still works. I’ll stay updated on this issue and see if there’s a fix. If you want me to, I can reply to this comment chain when I have more information on the future of user-uploaded 5.1 content. Sorry!
@@wazup3333does it get recognized by your AV Receiver as 5.1 source? If not every Yamaha will skip this information or down mix it to just front left and right
good evening, I'm facing a problem and I haven't messed with it at all, the logitech speakers, the surround ones are not heard when I do a test on youtube, only the ones in front of the fronts are heard and when I test them in the PC control panel sound, can they hear what's going on done?
UA-cam broke their official client support for 5.1 audio on user-uploaded videos about a week ago. I'm still waiting on a response to see if there is a time frame for it to be added again. You are still able to use third-party UA-cam players to listen to the surround sound such as SmartTubeNext on Android TV devices. Sorry about that!
@@jacobdoesaudio Only on mobile devices and TVs where audio is generally stereo or mono... It's paradoxical, but you could say it's "smart" on Google's part. However, it doesn't make sense that it can't be experienced on a PC, where it's more likely that people have multichannel audio.
What sort of setup are you trying to play it on? It plays on my Denon receiver using an Apple TV and Chromecast with GoogleTV. Nvidia Shields are not supported yet but other Android TV devices might be compatible. 4K TVs with the UA-cam app might be compatible as well according to the documentation Windows does not currently support 5.1 UA-cam playback through audio interfaces or receivers. Here is the official documentation: support.google.com/youtube/answer/11904456?hl=en&ref_topic=9257587
@@jacobdoesaudio windows 10, Sound blaster Ae 7 soundcard . 5.1 Analog , DTS, or Dolby. The weird thing is I can get alot of youtube videos to work .. this one does not.
@@neko77025 Do you mind sending me a video that plays correctly with your sound card? I would love to know how to fix future videos if I did something incorrectly.
@@jacobdoesaudio some videos Work with mine but most of the individual 5.1 tests don’t including this video. I’ll link you a video that did work fine with my sonos beam and surrounds from eARC and most official dolby videos do too
The fact that YT only supports 320 kbps and it still sounds great. CD formats can give 1140 kbps with 16 bits depth and 44.1 MHz bitrate. Wish there were some of these videos on Netflix. They support 640 kbps Dolby Digital and 760 kbps Dolby Atmos. So the sound range would be a serveral magnitudes better.
This video is with Dolby Digital Plus. The lowest bitrate for Plus, is 640 kb/a, so this is a minimum of that, and up to around 1200 kb/s, which is max. for Plus.
Bruh what the fuck are you talking about, this is definitely 5.1 Dolby Digital Content and is playing correctly on my Sonos AMP with all channels except Center which is streamed to both left and right to create a phantom channel. Chromecast Ultra with eARC Sonos Amp
As of 6/20, the official UA-cam smart tv apps have broken support for user-uploaded 5.1 videos. You are still able to listen to surround sound content by using third-party apps such as SmartTubeNext. I will update this comment once the official apps have been fixed!
6hjjn
Works for me on my Android phone with Android 13 QPR beta 1 with spatial Audio, comes up as ec3 5.1
And also works through my ccwgtv comes up as the same specifications. It's been working for me for months...maybe UA-cam is taking a while to turn 5.1 on for all compatible videos?
For me work in my Fire TV 4K Max through Yamaha Receiver.
I can’t get 5.1 on my Xbox series x so this is useless
Man this sounds great on my cricket Android phone!
What’s the brand of your Android Device?
@@NightSide1349 cricket
@@NightSide1349 it's the 5G plus
Finally. I’m like when Is someone going to post this type of video or reupload their old test. You’re a man of culture sir.
Man of culture?
@@harshvardhansingh8883 0:29 0:29 llll 0:29 ll
same. the youtube not supporting 5.1, dts, etc
I never thought Dolby Atmos on a Galaxy phone could sound this good. Pleasant surprise
I have a 5.1 surround sound setup. All 5 work on the setup test tones but on this video, the surround speaker sound is coming from the corresponding front instead of rear channels. IE, right surround comes out the right front, same with left surround.
Same for mine
Same
Same
Same
same here.. would be nice if the person who posted this video would reply and offer us some kind of an answer.
This works again for some reasons. At long last! I'm so happy. :)
This worked perfectly on my 5.1 system. With a Sound blaster audigy card and some great speakers.
Perfect on my Vizio V-series 5.1 home theater. Every channel checked out.
Pratique pour tester les branchements facilement et rapidement. Merci !
Works perfectly on my Sony HT-SS360 using S-Air 5.1 Surround setup via my Chromecast Gen 3. 👍🏻
This doesn't work from UA-cam. Stereo sound only.
If i use a 5.1 test file natively in Windows 10 with MPC, i also get sound in surround speakers.
I also get 5.1 in PC Games, so 5.1 on UA-cam is broken as all test videos there have 2.0 output.
Use Potplayer. Make sure that the format must have been AVC.
hehehe i just could not figure out my ear buds issue it was like all sound came from the opessite side. Apearantly it did, i crosed cables while fixing it with my buds making side sounds go haywire thanks for the nice test sound
The first test, the LR and RR are backwards. Other than that very cool and helpful. Thank you
It's correct
Thanks for the onfo. I am thinking maybe it just sounds backwards. The rest of the test its accurate, all of my games, movies etc are all correct. Im thinking just my poor judgement cant tell?
Does sound good either way. Thanks again!
@@jehorigby8778
Thats very cool! Thanks you for having this on youtube!
thank you, this sounds great on m y iphone
very good video I downloaded it to my apple mp3 player and listen to it on the bus ride home to my village in central slovakia
Wth this actually works now! There is a 5.1 option in the settings
spot on..displayed dolby digital on my system
0:33 is my favorite from the test
My ears are blessed
Excellent fabulos victory perfect
If you download the video, the surround channels will work as they should. I played the video back with VLC.
You have surround speakers at your computer?
@@akyhne My computer is just another component in my home theater system. My "computer monitor" is a 65" OLED. The audio from the computer is run through a high end surround processor and then an amplifier, then to full-blown home stereo/surround speakers. Of course, gaming on it is the bee's knees....
@@batman.darthmaul I was just curious to what audio setup you have. I can't seem to find a decent set of surround speakers, for PC. My audio card is not that high end, just a Soundblaster Z.
@@akyhne I was lucky enough to buy the Logitech X-530 set when it was new back in the day. They've been great for simple computer speakers! Sorry they aren't made anymore, but there are probably similar options.
Thanks! I wanted to verify if my system works correctly with DD5.1 and it didnt... Then i changed some settings now channels come through separately as they should.
What did you change?
A bummer that left and right channel test different frequencies in this video. For a moment I thought my headphones broke. Got some Beyerdynamics MMX300 B-Ware and almost sent them back but they were fine in other tests.
Wow that was amazing test thanks
It would be nice if Google could update the Browser apps with 5.1 too, something they have clearly not done.
it partially works for me. the center channel works but not the rear
@@gamagama69It probably just sounds like it works for the center channel. Check if it's not just because left and right are playing the exact same audio. That would give the same effect.
I found this online. I'm quoting it in two separate posts, as UA-cam tends to remove links, but the video ID is YEvROdECGDw:
"Try adding one of these:
--try-supported-channel-layouts
--force-wave-audio
--disable-audio-output-resampler
to the target path of the shortcut that's on your desktop.
will look something like this:
"C:\Program Files (x86)\Google\Chrome\Application\chrome.exe" --try-supported-channel-layouts
The top one worked for me.
Got the info from this video"
ua-cam.com/video/YEvROdECGDw/v-deo.html
For Now the Perfect 5.1 Dolby Surround Test. Thanks Jacob From Panamá 🇵🇦 👏🏻 can you make for 7.1 Please? ❓
UA-cam only outputs in 5.1 not 7.1 if I'm not mistaken so that will be up to UA-cam to change it.
@Neil Beveridge I hope they do 7.1! Thanks for the information anyway. :)
Got a new USB C to 3.5mm dongle and came here to see if it supports Spacial Audio on Pixel😁
In Potplayer did work. Now we have to get the PC with 5.1 Speakers!
I like it on my Bose earbuds 😊 love it
Well I don't know how to word this with YT deleting, but there is a loophole to be able to view Surround content on Windows.
MPC-BE
It seems my TV decodes surround channels as a mono stream. Getting no separation on the rears. Or is that bc of UA-cam's surround codec?
Yes, it works on NVIDIA Shield, but it does not work under Windows chrome/edge browser
Works great on my Sonos + chromecast setup
Perfect test.
Thank you this is brilliant
POTPLAYER 64 bit para PC te da la opcion para Dolby Atmos
i watched this with headphones it worked
this video is sterio nice !
5.1 works as it should on my end. Using Sony str-an1000 streaming through UA-cam on a 55in Samsung.
I played this video in my 5.1.2 system when front left and front right sound producing sorround back left,right also produce sound and when sourround speaker time to produce sound there is no sound in surround speaker
Does not work for Samsung S22. Both rear speakers do both left and right equally..
I can’t seem to get 5.1 surround sound to work on UA-cam. Right surround is right and left surround is left. Actually, my received tells me it’s a Stereo recording.
don't work in my system 😢 The device recognizes dolby audio but is muted
bro when I turn on surround 7.1 it doesn't work 💀. It only works without it on :/
Perfect
It's working
there are no sub woofer sound?
Left right front and back same
Please help me, I'm looking for the TWS inears with the deepest bass, it has to be boom and make my head explode. Really fat. And the TWS should be loud too. Which ones are the best?
Waaaaaaa, so good
Is it no music edit movie ?
Doesn’t work with my Surround sound system
Do you mind sending me the equipment you are using? I was reading reports that some of the UA-cam apps broke surround sound today.
@@jacobdoesaudio it’s not my equipment as “My Scientology Movie” is playing in proper with 5.1 playback. I believe your video isn’t encoded properly.
@@playnicegames So here’s what I’ve figured out. I have a few ways to play surround/Atmos content in my studio and I've confirmed my results.
My files are correctly encoded and still stored as 5.1 on UA-cam servers, but the official UA-cam app broke support for 5.1 on user-uploaded content as of Saturday.
On Android TVs, you can use “SmartTubeNext” (worth checking out regardless), and it plays back the user-uploaded 5.1 correctly in all of UA-cam's 5.1 compressed audio formats.
“My Scientology Movie” works because it’s an official Google upload for the “UA-cam Movies & Shows” platform. Along with that, UA-cam TV's surround sound content still works.
I’ll stay updated on this issue and see if there’s a fix. If you want me to, I can reply to this comment chain when I have more information on the future of user-uploaded 5.1 content.
Sorry!
🔥🔥🔥🔥
Mine doesn't play the rear left and right only front right left and center, why?
Because you have to make this test with a receiver 5.1 channels.
@@rafmil13 I do have a 5.1 setup and it's not playing the rears. Is it because UA-cam won't play 5.1 sound?
@@wazup3333 I am using Fire TV 4K Max with a Yamaha Receiver 5.1 the test work perfect.
@@rafmil13 me too and rear don't turn on when it does rear only
@@wazup3333does it get recognized by your AV Receiver as 5.1 source? If not every Yamaha will skip this information or down mix it to just front left and right
still does not work on pc using denon
good evening, I'm facing a problem and I haven't messed with it at all, the logitech speakers, the surround ones are not heard when I do a test on youtube, only the ones in front of the fronts are heard and when I test them in the PC control panel sound, can they hear what's going on done?
Doesn't work properly with my system. 🤔
Apakah suaranya ini real 5.1
right sorround and right channels are the same... same for left
Sooo iPhone has 2.0 but functions as a 3.0
Works!
Me trying this on my 5 dollar amazon basics ear buds lol
Ça ne fonctionne pas... j'entends les enceintes arrières sur les enceintes avant... Quelqu'un sait comment faire?
It works
No surround or LFE chennels using Chrome on a PC.
Only android TV app
I cannot make it work in PC!!!
0:39 😢 I dont have that speaker😊
Oculus have 5.1 surround sound
for windows?????????
Potplayer!!!
Tried this on my jbl extreme 3 and the deep bass sound almost broken some glass windows.
2D stereo
It doesn't work
UA-cam broke their official client support for 5.1 audio on user-uploaded videos about a week ago. I'm still waiting on a response to see if there is a time frame for it to be added again. You are still able to use third-party UA-cam players to listen to the surround sound such as SmartTubeNext on Android TV devices. Sorry about that!
@@jacobdoesaudio Only on mobile devices and TVs where audio is generally stereo or mono... It's paradoxical, but you could say it's "smart" on Google's part. However, it doesn't make sense that it can't be experienced on a PC, where it's more likely that people have multichannel audio.
ya, hooked up with a Yamaha AVR with optimal input and this does not work at all. gg YT
Thompson Dorothy Lopez Brian Brown Jose
DO NOT TRUST THIS TO TEST YOUR PC. IT DOES NOT REALLY PLAY IN 5.1. CONFIRMED IT WITH OTHER SOFTWARE THAT DOES WORK
doesnt work
Wrong side. Left Right.
Steel series arctic pro wireless headsets are crap - just FYI - you're welcome
Wilson Sarah Young Linda Gonzalez Barbara
0:08
0:32
Sounds not accurate
@0:33
0:26
Dai mayru in nombor Po du parathesi naye
Jackson Deborah Davis John Jackson Sarah
0:32
Statorice at
NO
this is not 5.1
Bad sound test with swapped sound channels. Lol.
BS , does not work with my Dolby 5.1
What sort of setup are you trying to play it on?
It plays on my Denon receiver using an Apple TV and Chromecast with GoogleTV. Nvidia Shields are not supported yet but other Android TV devices might be compatible. 4K TVs with the UA-cam app might be compatible as well according to the documentation
Windows does not currently support 5.1 UA-cam playback through audio interfaces or receivers.
Here is the official documentation:
support.google.com/youtube/answer/11904456?hl=en&ref_topic=9257587
@@jacobdoesaudio windows 10, Sound blaster Ae 7 soundcard . 5.1 Analog , DTS, or Dolby. The weird thing is I can get alot of youtube videos to work .. this one does not.
@@neko77025 Do you mind sending me a video that plays correctly with your sound card? I would love to know how to fix future videos if I did something incorrectly.
@@jacobdoesaudio some videos
Work with mine but most of the individual 5.1 tests don’t including this video. I’ll link you a video that did work fine with my sonos beam and surrounds from eARC and most official dolby videos do too
This one worked perfectly for me ua-cam.com/video/vI9UUjrpNVs/v-deo.html
another stereo test not a 5.1 test
You can't do 5.1 on windows. Google the program MPC-BE.
useless
The fact that YT only supports 320 kbps and it still sounds great. CD formats can give 1140 kbps with 16 bits depth and 44.1 MHz bitrate.
Wish there were some of these videos on Netflix. They support 640 kbps Dolby Digital and 760 kbps Dolby Atmos. So the sound range would be a serveral magnitudes better.
This video is with Dolby Digital Plus. The lowest bitrate for Plus, is 640 kb/a, so this is a minimum of that, and up to around 1200 kb/s, which is max. for Plus.
I LOVE these bullshit videos encoded in stereo and all the idiots going " wow great it really is surround" :D People suck at hearing audio
Bruh what the fuck are you talking about, this is definitely 5.1 Dolby Digital Content and is playing correctly on my Sonos AMP with all
channels except Center which is streamed to both left and right to create a phantom channel.
Chromecast Ultra with eARC Sonos Amp
It doesn't work.