@@jackmurphy3940 I’m not a Yank, but okay. It just baffles me that you think that the government that supported chaining up human beings because of the colour of their skin should have won. There were good men in the army of the Confederacy, I’m sure. But the Union winning the war was the best outcome for this nation.
@@karlmags4022 postmen are fucking awesome though, unsung heroes if you ask me, once a guy still came to deliver my mail when there was fucking torrential rain, gale force winds and lightning
The first time I ever heard this song, I’ve wanted to play it at one of those dumb Confederate statue protests. No memorials for traitors! Bravo, man. You have a great voice!
@@AlfredFJones1776 He has a great voice though. I'm not a communist, but I do support taking down monuments dedicated to people who took arms against the United States to defend the institution of slavery.
I know you get a lot of recommendations on music but I wanted to get these out of my system lest I forget: Three of my favourite leftist songs "Il Canto della Vendetta" and "Prendiamoci la cittá" and "L'ora del fucile" I also would love a purely piano version of Roter Wedding, since I wanted to do a video of it with a retexted version I made but could never find an instrumental one online. And while I'm at it anyway is there a chance you could do some more IRA songs someday? Sorry if that's a lot to take in, as I said, I wanted to put out some ideas I had before I forget about it.
Honestly, im much more on the south's side but i enjoy all of the songs and stories of the Americans civil war. It's an interesting piece of the history in my opinion.
Bobpob Cf A. No one asked nor said anything about that and B. No it’s not, thankfully socialists, communists, and (some) anarchists only want to redistribute the means of production (which we define as things like factory’s and workplaces) and give them to the people. I think you may be confusing our term of “private property” to mean the same thing as normal private property. We define private property as things one owns that is used to make money or products (the means of production) and we define items normally considered private property (like homes or chairs) as personal property. We still think you are entitled to your personal property, but that private property should be collectively owned.
@@artsyrache the problem with that is that they gained the means of production with there labor or money. Just because you, the worker use the means of production doesn't give you the right to own it.
@Aditya Chavarkar A. Most people believe taxes should be fair, if I pay 20 percent taxes they should be paying the same and they will end up paying more because they make more. I agree that the rich don't pay their fair share because they use loop holes in the tax system. But we don't need socialism for that. We just need reforms on tax laws. B. If the rich are stealing from us, agian we don't need socialism, we laws, regulations and law enforcement to prevent stealing from us.
"And we'll hurl the rebel crew from this land we love the best" is my favorite line it kinda sums up what I think about these roits and murders in my opinion
@@lexingtonbrython1897 Lincoln was not in frequent communication with Marx. There are more than 20,000 letters from Lincoln in the Library of Congress and they don't contain a single reference to Marx. Marx did write a letter on behalf of the International Workingmen's Association which received a brief and formal reply from the U.S. ambassador. Lincoln was a proponent of the free market. Das Kapital wasn't published until 1867 and even the Communist Manifesto wasn't translated into English until 1888. We do know that Lincoln was a fan of John Stewart Mill.
@@Derna1804 The point stands. He still saw socialists as friends and allies. And we support the Union cause while traitors storm the White House and attempt to blow up DC. And no, you Republicans were the ones burning in the South. Ever hear of the Southern Strategy?
@@lexingtonbrython1897 I've never been a member of the Republican Party, it has outlived its purpose, mainly because Lincoln didn't live long enough and was too embroiled in pragmatic solutions for the war effort to stem the tide of corruption that would take over the party after his death. And yes, the Republicans of the time did burn the South to the ground. My grandfather's grandfather was in the Union Army and burned the South to the ground. The point doesn't stand because there is no evidence that Lincoln was even aware of Marx or his writings, while the overwhelming evidence is that Lincoln was a Christian, a Classical Liberal and a free marketer. The Marxists were never allies of the abolitionist Republicans, they ended up murdering Union veterans like William McKinley. Marx never participated in electoral politics (he didn't really believe in it) but he was a kind of politician and did start a political movement so influential it caused more than 100 million murders. And as a politician, he took up causes to rally support for Marxism. But Marxism is not about freedom. Freedom to alienate one's own labor is an anathema to Marxism. Rather, it's an attempt to create a political and economic system which could apply the medieval ethics of economy to the industrial era. It's a very European ideology which is totally out of place in America. A generation before Marx, millions of European peasants had fought bravely in defense of their serfdom against the spread of the French Revolution. They preferred the security of a guaranteed income from an allotment of land to the peril of freedom. And historically, American Marxists have usually been either the children of the wealthy bourgeoisie or recent arrivals from Europe. Today's Marxists are totally out of touch with the working class. They are a product of an ossifying class structure, and support every policy which is driving the working class back into serfdom. Marx could not have predicted that the result of his doctrine would be that the bourgeoisie would rise against the workers. But, things are hanging on a much narrower thread than middle class people imagine. In the beginning of 2016, a prominent moving company in New York was hiring foremen for $10/hour. The only person who can afford such a low wage in New York, is a migrant worker who is living in an illegal tenement and sending the money abroad. Society is close to the brink of collapse. There will not be another civil war, that's just logistically impossible. One potential side doesn't even have its own water supply. But it's entirely possible that within our lifetimes, there will be a social revolution, and every person with a liberal arts degree might end up being killed as a class enemy and social parasite. That's not an endorsement, it's just a concern.
Our flag is proudly floating on the the land and on the main, shout shout the battle cry of freedom! Beneath it oft we’ll conquer and we’ll conquer oft again, shout shout the battle cry of freedom! Our Dixie Forever she’s never at a loss down with the eagle and up with the cross! We will rally round the Bonnie flag we’ll rally once again, shout shout the battle cry of freedom! Deo vendice
@@r.coburn3344 oh and also, those men had to fight overwhelming power, do you understand that? Do you understand what those men had to do? And at the end, those farmers with guns even though they pretty much lost, still, whipped yalls butts.
"And though he may be poor he shall never be a slave." Damn
We really fucked up on that one huh
@@laurioho2041 we gotta do it again, boys.
8 Johnny Rebs disliked this video.
9 months later and it is still only 8 dirty secessionist traitors
Make that ten!
@@jackmurphy3940 Don't make me come back down there
@@generalsherman1213 I dare you to “come back down”
@@generalsherman1213 Make them howl again!
This is the only song that has ever made me feel in any way patriotic.
This and Union Dixie
Amen
@@chubbyroll233im not gonna lie, Union Dixie is over played and doesn’t go as hard anymore. Marching through Georgia is underrated
have you ever listened to the Battle Hymn of The Republic?
As a Korean-American, all the Independence Movement stuff counts lol
*PRESERVE THE UNION*
Nah
And that’s why them yanks were fighting.
At first, yes. And then it was to free the slaves.
@@williamt.sherman2172 Dude...
Dude....
Dude...
Yanks are so funny😂😂🤣😂😂
@@jackmurphy3940 I’m not a Yank, but okay. It just baffles me that you think that the government that supported chaining up human beings because of the colour of their skin should have won. There were good men in the army of the Confederacy, I’m sure. But the Union winning the war was the best outcome for this nation.
This has always been my favorite song
Mine too
Confederate version is better.
@@jackmurphy3940 cry about it
@@jackmurphy3940 Confederate version is cacophonic shit.
@@jackmurphy3940 Ok Cringefederate
Fun Fact:
Postmen are the resurrected versions of Union Soldiers
Suddenly I have the funny mental imagery of postmen driving around casually running over confederate sympathisers.
Love the effort put in for these. You should try Mother Anarchy with vocals if you haven't yet
This! Please! We need Mother Anarchy with vocals, that would be amazing.
Yes! Mother Anarchy, please!
The only based boys in blue.
Nah the other boys in blue are based.
Alfred F. Jones Which other boys? Postmen?
Yee
@@karlmags4022 postmen are fucking awesome though, unsung heroes if you ask me, once a guy still came to deliver my mail when there was fucking torrential rain, gale force winds and lightning
@@taloob493 I mean that is their motto, right? "Neither snow nor sleet nor driving rain"
WHAT?! This may be in the top 3 renditions I've heard. Absolutely fantastic.
what’s the number 1 on your list?
The first time I ever heard this song, I’ve wanted to play it at one of those dumb Confederate statue protests. No memorials for traitors!
Bravo, man. You have a great voice!
Yet you’re here supporting a communist.
Alfred F. Jones The man can sing.
@@AlfredFJones1776
He has a great voice though.
I'm not a communist, but I do support taking down monuments dedicated to people who took arms against the United States to defend the institution of slavery.
@@unclebobbyb6537 I agree, statues of Grant and Sherman in place of every traitor
@@unclebobbyb6537 because nobody should defend slavers
Yay for all the civil war-era union renditions lately!
Would love to hear you do '14 Minutes to the Start.' A soviet cosmonaut song.
It's so fucking timeless
Again, those notes hit so hard i get so pumped
1:34 this slaps so hard bro
Great Work! Please do the Einheitsfrontlied.
Such a great voice ❤️
Perfect voice for this stuff.
Beautiful rendition, cheers
Down with the traitors!
And up with the stars.....I'll be willing to go burn stuff like my great great great grandfather did during the war.......
@@gabeking9444 oh he burned down some stuff?
And you want to too?!
So brave...
Like the Union?
No he means people like you jack
@@Willteach34 Ah, Yes I understand.
Danka.
Basically have this on a loop today.
Love this
wow that"s a good voice!
I love this song too :)
I'm also practicing the piano solo version
Good shit my guy
Thanks for what you do. Please perform the song "The Tramp"
请问这个版本的五线谱可以在什么地方找到呢
I know you get a lot of recommendations on music but I wanted to get these out of my system lest I forget:
Three of my favourite leftist songs "Il Canto della Vendetta" and "Prendiamoci la cittá" and "L'ora del fucile"
I also would love a purely piano version of Roter Wedding, since I wanted to do a video of it with a retexted version I made but could never find an instrumental one online.
And while I'm at it anyway is there a chance you could do some more IRA songs someday?
Sorry if that's a lot to take in, as I said, I wanted to put out some ideas I had before I forget about it.
who's here after the failed coup in DC yesterday. THE UNION FOREVER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
DOWN WITH THE TRAITORS AND UP WITH THE STARS!!!
If the fascists want my country they can fight me for it, and they’ll die just like they did in Germany.
Timbers:shivered
Can you do 14 Minutes to the Start? One of my favourite USSR classics
My friend you are going places
Hell?
@@jackmurphy3940 heaven
@@ashleyyoungs6252 😂
@@jackmurphy3940 Nope, pretty sure Robert E Lee is rotting in hell.
@@jackmurphy3940join the traitors in hell
Jesus Christ, comrade. You must have a lot of time on your hands because of the rona.
Please do "when that day comes." It's a Chinese "communist" march. It's a cool song and your awesome piano skills could make it even better .
DO IT AGAIN UNCLE BILLY
Huzzah boys! On to Richmond! On to Charlottesville!
thank you. singing with you as i'm watching! down with the traitors, up with the (red) star!
Communism is treasonous
aka: CHAZ
No no _no._ We had the conversation with the Soviets, do we really have to have it with you?
@@bobpobcf9723 Pretty sure the only traitors they are referring to are the Confederates.
Put this man in the opera
The actual thin blue line
Oh please
Honestly, im much more on the south's side but i enjoy all of the songs and stories of the Americans civil war. It's an interesting piece of the history in my opinion.
🇺🇲 THE UNION AND CONSTITUTION FOREVER!! 🇺🇲
#UnionGang! GANG! GANG! GANG!
Long live the federal union boys and gals.
Iron brigade to the front.
Is power in the Uniom the socialist version of this song?
Taking my shit and giving it to someone else is not freedom.
Bobpob Cf A. No one asked nor said anything about that and B. No it’s not, thankfully socialists, communists, and (some) anarchists only want to redistribute the means of production (which we define as things like factory’s and workplaces) and give them to the people. I think you may be confusing our term of “private property” to mean the same thing as normal private property. We define private property as things one owns that is used to make money or products (the means of production) and we define items normally considered private property (like homes or chairs) as personal property. We still think you are entitled to your personal property, but that private property should be collectively owned.
@@artsyrache sounds like communism to me
@@artsyrache the problem with that is that they gained the means of production with there labor or money. Just because you, the worker use the means of production doesn't give you the right to own it.
@Aditya Chavarkar A. Most people believe taxes should be fair, if I pay 20 percent taxes they should be paying the same and they will end up paying more because they make more. I agree that the rich don't pay their fair share because they use loop holes in the tax system. But we don't need socialism for that. We just need reforms on tax laws.
B. If the rich are stealing from us, agian we don't need socialism, we laws, regulations and law enforcement to prevent stealing from us.
Curios, that need change some words (or don't change anyfing), and this song can be communist. Truly "battle cry of freedom".
This song is too good to be a communist song
@@RobertElee-ip4uz I find your comment so funny when taken in the context of your username XD
But yes, very true. Better dead than Red.
@@PhoenixT70 Then you cry when we take you up on that offer smh.
@@h3nder Try me. There’s a reason I’m armed.
Billy Bragg re-wrote this song into a Socialist anthem
It’s called “There is Power in a Union”
Never thought I I'd say this to a communist but oh my goodness you have a good voice
You say that like being a communist is an insult or a bad thing
@@cammiehalliday757 Imagine unironically thinking communism works. Sad.
@@PhoenixT70 Imagine unironically thinking capitalism is working. Sad.
@@gaiagribhinneach2632 tell that to Cuba lmao
@@cammiehalliday757 Ewww
Your a communist, gosh.
Communists can go die in a hole.
Mfw MacArthur seizes power: 💀
"And we'll hurl the rebel crew from this land we love the best" is my favorite line it kinda sums up what I think about these roits and murders in my opinion
Solidarity and Socialism, all across the world.
I'm not sure if I agree with you there...
Ahem.
BETTER DEAD THAN RED!
Hi, can you do please "SS marschiert im Feindesland" / "Grüne Teufel" ?
Its funny you think a very leftist channel would be willing to sing an SS song
Why not?
The piano would be enough too without singing.
Whole lot of communists seem to enjoy this Republican classic.
Yeah, lots of leftists support the Union's message of anti-slavery. Did you know Lincoln was actually in frequent communication with Marx?
@@lexingtonbrython1897 Lincoln was not in frequent communication with Marx. There are more than 20,000 letters from Lincoln in the Library of Congress and they don't contain a single reference to Marx. Marx did write a letter on behalf of the International Workingmen's Association which received a brief and formal reply from the U.S. ambassador. Lincoln was a proponent of the free market. Das Kapital wasn't published until 1867 and even the Communist Manifesto wasn't translated into English until 1888. We do know that Lincoln was a fan of John Stewart Mill.
@@Derna1804 The point stands. He still saw socialists as friends and allies. And we support the Union cause while traitors storm the White House and attempt to blow up DC. And no, you Republicans were the ones burning in the South. Ever hear of the Southern Strategy?
@@lexingtonbrython1897 I've never been a member of the Republican Party, it has outlived its purpose, mainly because Lincoln didn't live long enough and was too embroiled in pragmatic solutions for the war effort to stem the tide of corruption that would take over the party after his death. And yes, the Republicans of the time did burn the South to the ground. My grandfather's grandfather was in the Union Army and burned the South to the ground.
The point doesn't stand because there is no evidence that Lincoln was even aware of Marx or his writings, while the overwhelming evidence is that Lincoln was a Christian, a Classical Liberal and a free marketer.
The Marxists were never allies of the abolitionist Republicans, they ended up murdering Union veterans like William McKinley.
Marx never participated in electoral politics (he didn't really believe in it) but he was a kind of politician and did start a political movement so influential it caused more than 100 million murders. And as a politician, he took up causes to rally support for Marxism. But Marxism is not about freedom. Freedom to alienate one's own labor is an anathema to Marxism. Rather, it's an attempt to create a political and economic system which could apply the medieval ethics of economy to the industrial era. It's a very European ideology which is totally out of place in America.
A generation before Marx, millions of European peasants had fought bravely in defense of their serfdom against the spread of the French Revolution. They preferred the security of a guaranteed income from an allotment of land to the peril of freedom. And historically, American Marxists have usually been either the children of the wealthy bourgeoisie or recent arrivals from Europe.
Today's Marxists are totally out of touch with the working class. They are a product of an ossifying class structure, and support every policy which is driving the working class back into serfdom. Marx could not have predicted that the result of his doctrine would be that the bourgeoisie would rise against the workers. But, things are hanging on a much narrower thread than middle class people imagine. In the beginning of 2016, a prominent moving company in New York was hiring foremen for $10/hour. The only person who can afford such a low wage in New York, is a migrant worker who is living in an illegal tenement and sending the money abroad. Society is close to the brink of collapse. There will not be another civil war, that's just logistically impossible. One potential side doesn't even have its own water supply. But it's entirely possible that within our lifetimes, there will be a social revolution, and every person with a liberal arts degree might end up being killed as a class enemy and social parasite. That's not an endorsement, it's just a concern.
Imagine being a far left socialist and not knowing you’re the traitor that the song is talking about.
Marx himself supported the North in personal letters to Lincoln
Pretty sure the Marxists supported the union and fought against the actual traitors.
The confederates were socialists?
Pretty sure the song is talking about Confederates...
Yea, I don't speak retard. Piss off, Neo-Confederate
can you do a confederate version of this. your skills are amazing
I don't think a leftist would do it
I think he wouldn't do this as he is a leftist.
You're sounding like a traitor
I don’t think someone like that turd would do that.
pretty sure right-wing people also do not like slavery
Our flag is proudly floating on the the land and on the main, shout shout the battle cry of freedom! Beneath it oft we’ll conquer and we’ll conquer oft again, shout shout the battle cry of freedom!
Our Dixie Forever she’s never at a loss down with the eagle and up with the cross! We will rally round the Bonnie flag we’ll rally once again, shout shout the battle cry of freedom!
Deo vendice
Your Dixie quite literally ONLY lost. Pokémon Go lasted longer.
@@r.coburn3344 And also I don’t care.
@@r.coburn3344 oh and also, those men had to fight overwhelming power, do you understand that? Do you understand what those men had to do?
And at the end, those farmers with guns even though they pretty much lost, still, whipped yalls butts.
Imagine thinking you're fighting for freedom when you fought to keep slaves in chains.
adopt me lasted longer