The grass is actually pretty spot on, in real life the grass in UK has a lower texture quality than Australian grass, I don't think UK even have 4k grass at all yet, great attention to detail.
i dont know if you ever played the old forzas but Turn10 bragged about recording the exact sound of every car in the game (i think it was for Forza Motorsport 3 or 4). FH4 sounds like theres nothing to them and every car sounds the same. so effin disappointing being a car guy :(
FH4 was honestly not great. I dont understand why so many people like it so much, FH1 and 2 were the best in my opinion. FH3 was great too but not my favorite. And FH4 I was really disappointed in. I hated the random seasons, the houses I thought u could customize, the forzathon live was boring especially trying to get points to unlock a car, the map was the worst in the franchise in my opinion. Idk I think for FH4 being the first or second forza horizon game people played it was really good but Ive been around since the OG and I think a lot of people that played way back in FH1 would agree that FH4 is just not great and I would agree the car sounds are not impressive anymore. The game is average Im not gonna say I hate it because I do like it in some ways but just felt like a bootleg version of FH3 to me.
@@thesuperiorgolem5357 FH5 will be a great improvement, and I agree with you, I FRICKING HATE the unrealistic way a sheering wheel works in fh4, it honestly is so all over the place and just quite odd and weird to control.
@@daixhii4481 So we back↩ in the mine got our pickaxe ⛏ swingin' from side to side⬅️, side➡️, side to side ⬅️➡️ This task a grueling 😩 one, hope🤞 to find 👀 some diamonds 💎 tonight 🌑🌌Night🌑🌌, night🌑🌌, diamonds 💎tonight Heads up⬆️, you hear 👂 a sound 🎼, turn around and look up 👀⬆️ Total shock😦 fills your body Oh, no, it's you again I can never forget 💭 those eyes👀, eyes, 👀eyes, 👀eyes, 👀eyes, 👀eyes👀 'Cause baby 👶 tonight🌑🌌, the creepers💥 tryin' to steal 💰all your stuff 💵again 'Cause baby 👶tonight,🌑🌌 you grab your pick⛏, shovel and bolt🏃♂️ again And run, 🏃♂️run 🏃♂️until it's done, done Until the sun ☀️ comes up⬆️ in the morn' 🌅 'Cause baby 👶tonight🌑🌌, the creepers💥 tryin' to steal💰 all your stuff 💵again Just when you think 🤔💭 you're safe ✅Overhear some hissing from right ➡️behind, right➡️, right ➡️behind That's a nice 👌life you have, shame it's gotta end 🛑 at this time ⏳Time⏳, time⏳, time⏳, time⏳, time⏳, time⏳Blows up⬆️, and then your health ❤️ bar drops⬇️And you could use a 1-up⬆️, get inside don't be tardy ⏱ So now you're stuck 🚫❌ in there, half a heart ❤️ is left but don't die Die ☠️, die☠️, die☠️, die☠️, die ‘Cause baby 👶 tonight🌑🌌, the creepers💥 tryin' to steal 💰all your stuff 💵 again 'Cause baby 👶tonight,🌑🌌 you grab your pick⛏, shovel and bolt🏃♂️ again And run, 🏃♂️run 🏃♂️until it's done, done Until the sun ☀️ comes up⬆️ in the morn' 🌅 'Cause baby 👶tonight🌑🌌, the creepers💥 tryin' to steal💰 all your stuff💵 again Creepers, you're mine, haha 😂 Dig up ⬆️ diamonds 💎, craft 🔨⚒ those diamonds 💎💎, make some armor ⚔️👕 Get it baby👶, go ✅🚦and forge ⚒🔨 that like you so, MLG pro😎 The swords ⚔️🗡made of diamonds 💎, so come at me bro😎 Huh, training ⚔️in your room under the torch light 💡🕯Hone that form to get you ready for the big fight 😡👊🤜 Every single day ☀️ in the whole night 🌌🌑Creeper's💥 out prowlin'😛, alright Look👀 at me, look 👀at you Take my revenge👊🗡 that's what I'm gonna do I'm a warrior 🗡⚔️baby👶, what else is new And my blade's⚔️🗡 gonna tear through you, bring it 'Cause baby 👶tonight🌑🌌, the creeper's💥 tryin' to steal💰 all your stuff 💵 again (Gather your stuff💵, yeah, let's take back the world 🌎🌍) Yeah, baby👶, tonight grab your sword🗡 armor⚔️👕 and go✅(It's on) Take your revenge 👊🗡 (Whoo) Oh, so fight👊⚔️, fight👊⚔️, like it's the last, last night 🌑🌌of your life❤️, life❤️ Show them your bite (Whoo) 'Cause baby 👶 tonight🌑🌌, the creepers💥 tryin' to steal💰 all your stuff💵 again 'Cause baby 👶tonight🌑🌌, you grab your pick⛏, shovel and bolt🏃♂️ again And run🏃♂️, run🏃♂️ until it's done✅, done✅ Until the sun ☀️ comes up in the morn' ☀️🌅'Cause baby👶 tonight 🌑 (Come on, swing your sword⚔️ up⬆️ high) The creepers tryin' to steal 💰all your stuff 💵again (Jab your sword🗡 down⬇️ low)
Forgot environmental features, which look DRASTICALLY better in FH3. Environmental features in FH4, including plastic 2D graphics and flickering, constantly self-rendering trees honestly look like they're taken out straight from a 2005 game smh.
Don't every forget horizon three has had a bunch of patches and optimaztions done to it to make it look better on PC. I'd imagine a year from now it'll be no contest when 4 gets a similar amount of love.
I feel like we’ve reached a point where our current hardware does not allow game devs to drastically make a big upgrade to graphics and realisms. Or the devs are just lazy which wouldn’t surprise me.
You really couldn’t be more wrong in your first assumption, just look as some of the better RTX gameplay trailers. Graphics are a long way from being unimprovable.
Yeah but the big thing that were improved between those 2 games is gameplay and I rather have better gameplay than graphics especially when the graphics are already great, fh 4 run smoother on PC than fh3 with a map that can have 4 different states and have better off-road mechanics but sure they didn't made better water so they are just a bunch of wankers
I think every time you notice something worse in 4 than 3, like the grass textures, it was a conscious decision that was made by the developers to improve the game. Not only in its look but in how it plays. As you said, the game trying to render high-definition individual grass blades as you rip over them at 200 miles an hour is a horrible use of resources. The grass is just a blur for your eyes anyway. The road however, is something you will look at closely a million times as you start up or after crashing etc AND it doesnt move or sway so go ahead, HD the hell out of it! Minimal resources used for a big gain. All of those decisions are bang for buck decisions. The bottom line for me having played neither game before and just now ordering 4 is that the side by side isn't even close. To me Forza Horizon 4 is much more realistic and natural-looking. High definition cartoon is still just a high-definition cartoon.
Blah blah blah If Forza wanted to cut tiny corners to make other things better they should've have wasted months and months of developing on dances and clothes.
@@josiahamen8673 that's why you stick to the Motorsport series. That's way more focused on realism. Horizon is more of a NFS spin off than a Forza one.
I own and play both, for me H4 really looks better graphically especially over time (much more realistic) . Cars especially AMG’s do sound better in H3!, for me personally driving and racing is slightly more fun in H3. Overall i like H3 better but visually H4 got it easily beat.
Thanks for the comparison. As ever a really high quality. I wish the topics vegetation and lighting were a bit more detailed even if its hard because of the different regions.
A few other special effects I noticed in FH4 vs FH3 is more subtle animations on the car parts. Antennae, mud flaps, wing mirrors, rear wings, and wipers all flutter a little bit in the wind when driving. The driver character also moves a little more naturally in FH4. The driver reacts to impacts from landings or collisions and their upper body even moves a tad at low speeds when driving over uneven terrain. Also during skill songs, the driver now dances a bit in the seat.
4:59 the water surface effect is called Screen-space reflection, a video setting for which was added in Horizon 4 (on PC). And it does look much better now.
He didn’t know about it but yes it was the leaves. Although, the leaves shouldn’t have been like that as it was very much like a stuttering effect. In FH3, the leaf movements were much smoother giving it a much more realistic look
3:13, I think the textures on the right are intentionally softer because it's supposed to be wet grass, it makes sense for the dry grass to be more visually distinct and sharper due to the sun
Horizon 4 just came out, horizon 3 has been out and turn 10 has had time to update the game fixing minor issues, while unfortunately they’re going to need time to update 4
I believe the shadows were dumbed down for a reason, given how there is a lot more foliage in FH4 than FH3, not to mention the fact that they had to make 4 versions of each type of foliage to represent the seasons properly. If they make the shadows generic, they can focus more on texture and model quality of the foliage for the best possible appearance, instead of making 2 or 3 high quality shadow maps to go along with it. Game would be massive if that was the case (although it is a rather large download already)
The shadows weren't "dumbed down". Almost all shadows in the game are actually dynamic, meaning they don't use lightmaps. It's more demanding at higher resolutions, but it's a lot more flexible. There are no static shadows being cast by any hero models (like cars) and architecture, meaning everything's rendered at runtime and global shadow resolution depends on whatever you set it. Smaller foliage usually doesn't have shadows to begin with (with the exception of trees and large bushes). Smaller foliage like tufts of grass and small bushes rely more on Ambient Occlusion in dynamic environments, and most foliage LODs don't use baked shadows at all, which is why trees can appear bleak in the distance. The amount of vertices from models like trees that have to be rendered are a non issue since foliage relies heavily on LODs, meaning it really doesn't matter unless you go to extremes (which depend on the kind of game or real time environment you're working on). Game design isn't really a case of "Oh, shadows need to be better, so we'll thin out the tree geometry", it doesn't work that way. If it did, things would've been much simpler! Oops, wall of text.
I say it depends on the lighting. When Horizon 3 is in day time, it looks much more realistic than Horizon 4. I also think that in Horizon 4, when lighting is dim, it looks a bit less realistic than Horizon 3.
I think 4 is using a newer versions of ambient occlusion for shadows and shading in indirect lighting areas. Thats why some areas "pop" more and seem less dim in 3.
It typicaly takes a long time for me to sub to a new channel but i must say you always have quality content with each and every vid. Happy to become a new subscriber!
Horizon 4 looks more so how you're eyes would perceive it, whereas Horizon 3 looks like its being seen through a camera lens with some filtering added to it.
some small notes: -the more muted Colors and less intense light bloom are becuase of tonemapping, which i think improved a lot in fh4. the Highlights no longer blow out, but of Course this means losing contrast. it gives this more filmic, realistic lighting so i like it a lot -the Vegetation and trees actually did improve a lot. lighting of leaves is much more natural and the lower lod Levels look and blend better, which makes them look better at a distance -Damage now has the paint beeing scratch off, so thats a small improvement
Yeah I figured as much. Surprised they don't really allow for any deep customization though. I like how Project Cars lets you set a blizzard in Florida if you want. At least for private or blueprint matches.
Runs well on mine as well, most of the time it runs smooth as butter though I still suffer from the problems every now and then that I listed. 4790k, 16gb ram, GTX 1080. Edit: The game has been updated a few times since this post & I no longer suffer from any of the problems I stated, it is truly a smooth experience now.
Nice, professional video. Wouldn't have guessed that you have 'only' 30k subs. :) I'm more for FH4 btw, especially as its runs better/smoother I've heard and still looks great, even better, more realistic.
They also toned down the bloom starting with Forza 7. Anyway I wouldn't say Horizon 3 holds up well, given how poorly it runs especially compared to Horizon 4. Good graphics don't mean shit if the game isn't playable. Also, Horizon 4 might have lower res grass textures but it has a lot more grass foliage, not to mention the mud tessellation and whatnot.
More broken maybe. The crashes nearly tripled, the graphics settings don't save anymore for a lot of people and it nuked saves several times. What's most alarming is that the last two occurred when Forzathon was update, not from an actual content update that requires download. That's actually what's keeping me from buying Horizon 4. They have some major issues if they can fuck up your game this badly just by hitting the wrong switch.
your PC must not be very good, I can play it at 4k ultra settings and never dip below 60 fps. It seems to be optimized well for the visuals you receive with it. I suggest either turning down your settings or upgrading your PC.
Did it ever cross your mind that maybe you have a PC that's so good optimization ceases to be relevant? Just because you can brute force the game to run well doesn't mean it's well optimized. These fuckin' guys man.
In my case, after all the optimization patches, the FPS on FH 3 more than doubled, from an average of ~45 on the lowest settings or completely maxed out with 8xmsaa to 100-115 depending on the region (closer to 100 in the city). FH4 however already runs at around 68-70 (maxed out with just 4xmsaa tho) which I don't mind, because even if it's not apparent in this video, the shadows got a massive upgrade due to actually having projected shadows now, especially during the night (FH3 had no shadows during night time, just a veil of darkness).
in my opinion. 3 had way better engine sounds compared to 4. 4 was so much recycled nonsense. yeah they killed it graphically but the actual realism of cars was so shot
Any visual improvements will be because of engine improvements rather than asset improvements as they will have just reused the same assets for all cars that were present in both games.
Did you use the golf courses for the grass comparison? If so then of course they would be different because the course it made to have a smooth texture.
They nailed it on the sound in FH4, have heard the C7 in real life, sounds identical to it. Also the Arial Atom sounds correctly as well, have heard one of those as well
For me it boils down to the beauty of the location. And Australia wins because I love that landscape, reminds me of Oahu Hawaii island of Test Drive Unlimited 1 & 2, the inspiration for Forza horizon.
Somethings messed up with auctions. I keep losing when it says I'm highest bidder. It never gives me a chance to bid again. So lame. People just snipe bids from me
One thing i noticed is that the tail light on FH3 appear much more yellow than on FH4. Even two years ago when the game launched i noticed the lights were almost unrealistic yellow.
Being a console gamer by preference Forza horizon 4 looks amazing and was one of my first real dips into the dynamic lighting with headlights and vegetation or poles and posts, I tend to use photo mode a lot in my honest opinion it's one of the biggest and best changes to the game the effects add to the photos. My preference is 4 mainly for the setting the photo mode and really nice dynamic lighting but I have shown people pictures from 3 that where mistaken as real pictures, so both games are gorgeous.
I did notice horizon 3s crash sounds have a lot more depth to them. like 4s is mostly a loud thud, but 3s have some tinkling glass and bodywork cracking
For the corvette comparison, the fh3 corvette had FE (Forza Edition) tires and a different style of rims than the fh4 version. This made the tires have writing on them and look more shiny. The dirt/mud effects are also stronger in fh4 due to the fact that it is based in Britain where the weather is more humid. Just wanted to point this out.
FH4 runs way better on my GTX 1080 than FH3. FH4 never drops below 80FPS on ultra for me while FH3 and FM7 would drop below 30 for a couple brief seconds atleast once a race which is way more important than graphics IMO.
Question for someone who has played both: I have not played either game, but i was wondering if it would be worth it to get the $60 fh4 or get the $30 fh3? Thx in advance
@Qaotik yeah but the graphics are already good, the physics are already good so you cant really improve on that alot. but the optimization? from 50 fps with stuttering and crashes to 100fps with 0 stutters? thats more important to me than making the game look nicer when its already looking great
@@N4orEditor The impact on tuning has improved quite a bit over horizon 3. Now in 4 it feels like it does what it's supposed to rather than trying to break the game with completely bonkers settings which doesn't even make sense in horizon 3. I still don't get why the cars has to understeer so much by default.
With the shadowing is probably to optimise the game to be smoother ... Which in any racing game I would expect... Sound compare tho I wouldn't expect them to improve the same car sound . It's all about saving money ... New cars would benefit though :) good job mate
things are different because of the tweaked shader model in FH4, along with more ambient occlusion and other graphical updates to look more natural/real
Corrections:
-Forza Horizon lettering is not a default customization.
-Playground Games not playhouse.
*corrections provided by Trevor Townsend
Microsoft wants to buy PlayHouse Games Studios too xD
I want to work at PlayHouse games lol
Nick930 ur still a stud
Nick930 a
Car roster comparison video? I can’t find one
The grass is actually pretty spot on, in real life the grass in UK has a lower texture quality than Australian grass, I don't think UK even have 4k grass at all yet, great attention to detail.
WHAT 😂😂😂😂
Wtf 😂😂😂😂
is a Brit, I can confirm this. our grass quality is very low res
wtf
You should increase the graphics by wearing glasses
I hope that in forza horizon 5 (if it will come out) they focus on sound and you could hear antilag and turbos like in real life cars.
i dont know if you ever played the old forzas but Turn10 bragged about recording the exact sound of every car in the game (i think it was for Forza Motorsport 3 or 4). FH4 sounds like theres nothing to them and every car sounds the same. so effin disappointing being a car guy :(
Yes, and add diesel engines with black smoke from exhaust. 👍
Viper8828 they didn’t record the zonda cause that car always sounds pretty inaccurate in every forza
Viper8828 that was Motorsport 2
I have the game and they have a video in it or something there they show recording REAL cars.
Alot more smoke when drifting
The only similar thing between both is that I cant run the game on my laptop
I can
@@XxScorpionxX1901 nice, I cannot
I can easily run the games on my laptop
Bus Arne what type of desktop and what at ur specs
I can On my Xbox
The most crucial detail that FH4 failed at was definitely engine notes, as well as FH3 with certain cars, but not most of them like FH4
FH4 was honestly not great. I dont understand why so many people like it so much, FH1 and 2 were the best in my opinion. FH3 was great too but not my favorite. And FH4 I was really disappointed in. I hated the random seasons, the houses I thought u could customize, the forzathon live was boring especially trying to get points to unlock a car, the map was the worst in the franchise in my opinion. Idk I think for FH4 being the first or second forza horizon game people played it was really good but Ive been around since the OG and I think a lot of people that played way back in FH1 would agree that FH4 is just not great and I would agree the car sounds are not impressive anymore. The game is average Im not gonna say I hate it because I do like it in some ways but just felt like a bootleg version of FH3 to me.
@@thesuperiorgolem5357 FH5 will be a great improvement, and I agree with you, I FRICKING HATE the unrealistic way a sheering wheel works in fh4, it honestly is so all over the place and just quite odd and weird to control.
Shut up kid@@thesuperiorgolem5357
7:23 that farmer wanted you live or dead.
Dead or alive dumbass
@@lucaguida4286 Oh boy, that escalated quickly
@@daixhii4481 So we back↩ in the mine got our pickaxe ⛏ swingin' from side to side⬅️, side➡️, side to side ⬅️➡️ This task a grueling 😩 one, hope🤞 to find 👀 some diamonds 💎 tonight 🌑🌌Night🌑🌌, night🌑🌌, diamonds 💎tonight Heads up⬆️, you hear 👂 a sound 🎼, turn around and look up 👀⬆️ Total shock😦 fills your body Oh, no, it's you again I can never forget 💭 those eyes👀, eyes, 👀eyes, 👀eyes, 👀eyes, 👀eyes👀 'Cause baby 👶 tonight🌑🌌, the creepers💥 tryin' to steal 💰all your stuff 💵again 'Cause baby 👶tonight,🌑🌌 you grab your pick⛏, shovel and bolt🏃♂️ again And run, 🏃♂️run 🏃♂️until it's done, done Until the sun ☀️ comes up⬆️ in the morn' 🌅 'Cause baby 👶tonight🌑🌌, the creepers💥 tryin' to steal💰 all your stuff 💵again Just when you think 🤔💭 you're safe ✅Overhear some hissing from right ➡️behind, right➡️, right ➡️behind That's a nice 👌life you have, shame it's gotta end 🛑 at this time ⏳Time⏳, time⏳, time⏳, time⏳, time⏳, time⏳Blows up⬆️, and then your health ❤️ bar drops⬇️And you could use a 1-up⬆️, get inside don't be tardy ⏱ So now you're stuck 🚫❌ in there, half a heart ❤️ is left but don't die Die ☠️, die☠️, die☠️, die☠️, die ‘Cause baby 👶 tonight🌑🌌, the creepers💥 tryin' to steal 💰all your stuff 💵 again 'Cause baby 👶tonight,🌑🌌 you grab your pick⛏, shovel and bolt🏃♂️ again And run, 🏃♂️run 🏃♂️until it's done, done Until the sun ☀️ comes up⬆️ in the morn' 🌅 'Cause baby 👶tonight🌑🌌, the creepers💥 tryin' to steal💰 all your stuff💵 again Creepers, you're mine, haha 😂 Dig up ⬆️ diamonds 💎, craft 🔨⚒ those diamonds 💎💎, make some armor ⚔️👕 Get it baby👶, go ✅🚦and forge ⚒🔨 that like you so, MLG pro😎 The swords ⚔️🗡made of diamonds 💎, so come at me bro😎 Huh, training ⚔️in your room under the torch light 💡🕯Hone that form to get you ready for the big fight 😡👊🤜 Every single day ☀️ in the whole night 🌌🌑Creeper's💥 out prowlin'😛, alright Look👀 at me, look 👀at you Take my revenge👊🗡 that's what I'm gonna do I'm a warrior 🗡⚔️baby👶, what else is new And my blade's⚔️🗡 gonna tear through you, bring it 'Cause baby 👶tonight🌑🌌, the creeper's💥 tryin' to steal💰 all your stuff 💵 again (Gather your stuff💵, yeah, let's take back the world 🌎🌍) Yeah, baby👶, tonight grab your sword🗡 armor⚔️👕 and go✅(It's on) Take your revenge 👊🗡 (Whoo) Oh, so fight👊⚔️, fight👊⚔️, like it's the last, last night 🌑🌌of your life❤️, life❤️ Show them your bite (Whoo) 'Cause baby 👶 tonight🌑🌌, the creepers💥 tryin' to steal💰 all your stuff💵 again 'Cause baby 👶tonight🌑🌌, you grab your pick⛏, shovel and bolt🏃♂️ again And run🏃♂️, run🏃♂️ until it's done✅, done✅ Until the sun ☀️ comes up in the morn' ☀️🌅'Cause baby👶 tonight 🌑 (Come on, swing your sword⚔️ up⬆️ high) The creepers tryin' to steal 💰all your stuff 💵again (Jab your sword🗡 down⬇️ low)
let him be a dick this is internet !!!! @Grad1258
@@lucaguida4286 thats Interesting
7:23 *SAD* *FARMER* *NOISES*
69 likes, noice
100 likes noice
108 likes noice
150 likes noice
151 likes noice
1:46 : That‘s just the Racing tire texture, not the car itself
Mika Sengebusch yeah which is part of the car
JT-Kawaii Matthew but you can also get that in FH4
aSneakyChicken that’s not the point 🙃
Red_ Nutt it’s a direct comparison between the two. It is
Ur very fun at parties aren’t you :/
Horizon 4 looks more natural in colors, lightning while Horizon 3 looks more contrasting, and clean, shadows where a Step back for sure.
Imo they release the games too close to each other. I bet if they would’ve waited another year they could’ve made more drastic changes.
they're on a 2 year release schedule, alternating with Forza Motorsport
gabenlife _ it’s the same gen of consoles. Not much you can change except textures for PC.
Forgot environmental features, which look DRASTICALLY better in FH3. Environmental features in FH4, including plastic 2D graphics and flickering, constantly self-rendering trees honestly look like they're taken out straight from a 2005 game smh.
reflections on pc are glorious
If you play fh4 you can tell the game runs much more smoother, and Cars look a tiny bit better with shadows n some area imo
Couldnt be more incorrect. Even people with sim wheels cannot play fh4. Overall sound is worse and the driving is more arcade rather than sim.
I agree
With king
Frick you John Doe
No Forza game got sim style driving... most players play it with a controller. Horizon 4 is reported to run better though.
2:24 longborghini
Radal
Get out.
L M A O
nice
@@bobbyanderson1184 he says that the Lamborghini is longer than usual because if the angle he took the photos at.
i edited this comment because it didn’t make sense lmao but thanks for 1.8k likes ❤️
(8th January 2021)
@Awais Ali and I live in Australia lol
so?
@Awais Ali I could tell by your name you live in UK
How does that explain anything
@@kwible3682 because the grass is greener in 4 and ya know, grass needs water to grow.
Don't every forget horizon three has had a bunch of patches and optimaztions done to it to make it look better on PC. I'd imagine a year from now it'll be no contest when 4 gets a similar amount of love.
Horizon 4 is already better optimized than Horizon 3 after 2 years.
horizon got downgraded lol, it looked worse every patch...
Forza 4 has already had its 1st update on Xbox. For what? The world may never know! 👾
@@saintkenny9296 trying to patch that money glitch every person was doing.
@@TheHanfi93 Yup. the downgrade made forests look like a few broccoli lying around. and grass had a buzzcut. Didn't reflections take a hit too?
The only conclusion i have after this video is that both games look so fucking amazing that my eyes are always fascinated
4:00... he hits a rabbit running across the road in front of it.
😲
r.i,p rabbit
It's Nearly Impossible to hit animals in FH4. I once hit a goat when I lost control of my Agera RS at 410 Kph and sent it offroad!
Air that’s illegal
3:41 playground* games
I almost died when he called the alloy wheels on that lambo "Wheel covers"
and? hes not a car freak lol
@@Miichi5 you are damn right
1:50
FH3 uses Racing FE tiresFH4 uses stock tires.
That's why they look different.
The rims do look different though as proven by you.
In Horizon 4, if you sit still in your car while it is snowing, it accumulates a good amount of noticeable snow on top.
3:41 xD playhouse games
😂😅😂
I feel like we’ve reached a point where our current hardware does not allow game devs to drastically make a big upgrade to graphics and realisms. Or the devs are just lazy which wouldn’t surprise me.
Fuk ur face
You really couldn’t be more wrong in your first assumption, just look as some of the better RTX gameplay trailers. Graphics are a long way from being unimprovable.
Yeah but the big thing that were improved between those 2 games is gameplay and I rather have better gameplay than graphics especially when the graphics are already great, fh 4 run smoother on PC than fh3 with a map that can have 4 different states and have better off-road mechanics but sure they didn't made better water so they are just a bunch of wankers
They hit xbox console limits, pc hardware allows them but console doesn't...
because of fucking consoles
I think every time you notice something worse in 4 than 3, like the grass textures, it was a conscious decision that was made by the developers to improve the game. Not only in its look but in how it plays. As you said, the game trying to render high-definition individual grass blades as you rip over them at 200 miles an hour is a horrible use of resources. The grass is just a blur for your eyes anyway. The road however, is something you will look at closely a million times as you start up or after crashing etc AND it doesnt move or sway so go ahead, HD the hell out of it! Minimal resources used for a big gain.
All of those decisions are bang for buck decisions.
The bottom line for me having played neither game before and just now ordering 4 is that the side by side isn't even close. To me Forza Horizon 4 is much more realistic and natural-looking. High definition cartoon is still just a high-definition cartoon.
Blah blah blah If Forza wanted to cut tiny corners to make other things better they should've have wasted months and months of developing on dances and clothes.
@@josiahamen8673 that's why you stick to the Motorsport series. That's way more focused on realism. Horizon is more of a NFS spin off than a Forza one.
@@MAILMAN9936 were talking about graphics not gameplay
@@josiahamen8673 ...... Forget I said anything
@Adolf Hitler holy fuck its Adolf hitler
Forza Horizon 3 = Game Graphics.
Forza Horizon 4 = Real Life Like Graphics
Forza Horizon 4 + Ray Tracing = Nuts
Is forza horizon 4 able to use raytracing?
@@gerson4729 No. I meant if It could
crazy cause fh4 is much much much more optimized than fh3
I mean horizon 4 looks identical to real life so I don’t understand how ray tracing would make a difference.
@@silentndles7365 I assure you there's still a little bit of improvement needed on FH4. Ray Tracing would make a difference
I own and play both, for me H4 really looks better graphically especially over time (much more realistic) . Cars especially AMG’s do sound better in H3!, for me personally driving and racing is slightly more fun in H3. Overall i like H3 better but visually H4 got it easily beat.
I feel like it's the lighting and tge fine details like dirt and especially snow that makes forza horizon 4 look better
Thanks for the comparison. As ever a really high quality. I wish the topics vegetation and lighting were a bit more detailed even if its hard because of the different regions.
Thanks for watching! I appreciate the feedback and will make sure my next video will go more in depth with both vegetation and lighting :)
Great video man always keeping the high quality content!! Your channel is underrated, you should and probably deserve way more views than you get.
Only comparison video we all watch full. Thanks to the admin for such a nice job!!
A few other special effects I noticed in FH4 vs FH3 is more subtle animations on the car parts. Antennae, mud flaps, wing mirrors, rear wings, and wipers all flutter a little bit in the wind when driving. The driver character also moves a little more naturally in FH4. The driver reacts to impacts from landings or collisions and their upper body even moves a tad at low speeds when driving over uneven terrain. Also during skill songs, the driver now dances a bit in the seat.
Subbed. I love those direct comparisons, always very interesting!!
I am watching your channel more than I am comfortable admitting! Excellent content bud.
Great video dude! Helped alot
I just watched this video and subscribed to you.This was an amazing video and you have quality content.Keep up the good work.👍
4:59 the water surface effect is called Screen-space reflection, a video setting for which was added in Horizon 4 (on PC). And it does look much better now.
Play House games
ha yup.
hahaha......
No entiendo
sebazk someone should make a rip-off of Horizon and the developer group should be named Playhouse games if it’s not already taken.
4:20 Isn't that just leafs waving in wind?
He didn’t know about it but yes it was the leaves. Although, the leaves shouldn’t have been like that as it was very much like a stuttering effect. In FH3, the leaf movements were much smoother giving it a much more realistic look
Nice
@@saidapotato4413 Yes
Well yeah but it was glitching out
3:13, I think the textures on the right are intentionally softer because it's supposed to be wet grass, it makes sense for the dry grass to be more visually distinct and sharper due to the sun
5:54 it seems to me that damage effects are now more visible
Horizon 4 just came out, horizon 3 has been out and turn 10 has had time to update the game fixing minor issues, while unfortunately they’re going to need time to update 4
Horizon - Colorado
Horizon 2 - Europe
Horizon 3 - Australia
Horizon 4 - United kingdom
Horizon 5 - Canada?
Japan
Russia!
Africa
North Korea
Dutch Van der Linde What about Guarma Dutch?
Nice fair comparison +1
Also with the environment, I think Playground really nailed the countries they're set in
I believe the shadows were dumbed down for a reason, given how there is a lot more foliage in FH4 than FH3, not to mention the fact that they had to make 4 versions of each type of foliage to represent the seasons properly. If they make the shadows generic, they can focus more on texture and model quality of the foliage for the best possible appearance, instead of making 2 or 3 high quality shadow maps to go along with it. Game would be massive if that was the case (although it is a rather large download already)
The shadows weren't "dumbed down". Almost all shadows in the game are actually dynamic, meaning they don't use lightmaps. It's more demanding at higher resolutions, but it's a lot more flexible. There are no static shadows being cast by any hero models (like cars) and architecture, meaning everything's rendered at runtime and global shadow resolution depends on whatever you set it. Smaller foliage usually doesn't have shadows to begin with (with the exception of trees and large bushes). Smaller foliage like tufts of grass and small bushes rely more on Ambient Occlusion in dynamic environments, and most foliage LODs don't use baked shadows at all, which is why trees can appear bleak in the distance.
The amount of vertices from models like trees that have to be rendered are a non issue since foliage relies heavily on LODs, meaning it really doesn't matter unless you go to extremes (which depend on the kind of game or real time environment you're working on). Game design isn't really a case of "Oh, shadows need to be better, so we'll thin out the tree geometry", it doesn't work that way. If it did, things would've been much simpler!
Oops, wall of text.
IGN review of FH4 is 5 min long. I'm wondering why they have 10 mln subs...Thank you! Great video as ever!
haha is it really? Glad you liked it :)
Dont forget about ACG gaming.
Angry Centaur is another of my fav channels! If he says "don't buy" I simply obey...
@@PlanetThrill let's read the words, the words...
@@stanradanov428 Of the developaa
3 looks cartoon and 4 is more realistic.
@Digby Dooright comparison to each other
It does not looks like a cartoon, you can say 4 is better than 3 in graphics
@@CarRevvedGaming it looks way better than h3 on Xbox one X tho
Don't know exactly...but it (4) is pretty nice.
I say it depends on the lighting. When Horizon 3 is in day time, it looks much more realistic than Horizon 4. I also think that in Horizon 4, when lighting is dim, it looks a bit less realistic than Horizon 3.
I think 4 is using a newer versions of ambient occlusion for shadows and shading in indirect lighting areas. Thats why some areas "pop" more and seem less dim in 3.
Sir can u make a video of direct comparison between assassin's creed origins and odyssey?.. Thank u.. :)
Sure sir...
It typicaly takes a long time for me to sub to a new channel but i must say you always have quality content with each and every vid. Happy to become a new subscriber!
Welcome aboard!
@Yo Bitch MCM by any chance, is it your time of the month???
You sure?
89 people do, including myself.
@@Nick930 he made himself look like a person who is cautious about who they subscribe to so people like his comment.
Horizon 4 looks more so how you're eyes would perceive it, whereas Horizon 3 looks like its being seen through a camera lens with some filtering added to it.
Dude, your eyes are lenses.
some small notes:
-the more muted Colors and less intense light bloom are becuase of tonemapping, which i think improved a lot in fh4. the Highlights no longer blow out, but of Course this means losing contrast. it gives this more filmic, realistic lighting so i like it a lot
-the Vegetation and trees actually did improve a lot. lighting of leaves is much more natural and the lower lod Levels look and blend better, which makes them look better at a distance
-Damage now has the paint beeing scratch off, so thats a small improvement
I think the reason you can’t get equal blizzard effects is purely contextual and we never get blizzards like you see in fh3 in the uk.
Yeah I figured as much. Surprised they don't really allow for any deep customization though. I like how Project Cars lets you set a blizzard in Florida if you want. At least for private or blueprint matches.
FH4 is better because it's a good port..
Not quite, it still suffers from: crashes, memory leaks, random stutters(rarely though.)
Sad to hear, I've only played the demo but it seemed to run really well on my system
Runs well on mine as well, most of the time it runs smooth as butter though I still suffer from the problems every now and then that I listed. 4790k, 16gb ram, GTX 1080.
Edit: The game has been updated a few times since this post & I no longer suffer from any of the problems I stated, it is truly a smooth experience now.
To me FH4 runs at stable 60 FPS, FH3 instead around 50-60 FPS.
theres no stuttering problems in fh4 unlike fh3 and is very consistent
nice comparition video keep it up
Nice, professional video. Wouldn't have guessed that you have 'only' 30k subs. :)
I'm more for FH4 btw, especially as its runs better/smoother I've heard and still looks great, even better, more realistic.
what happens if u havent gone outside for a year and start judgin the nature in games lmao
ShadowYeeter I do that for some reason
* in quarantine *
This hasn't aged well
@@allhaillordtachanka1957 agreed
:(
In forza horizon 4 even the fences have shadows (xbox one x enhanced)
Main sound difference is that left and right sounds are more noticeable/pronounced. I like it.
Perfect comparison!
When I first went to the beach on Forza Horizon 4 I was in awe because of how realistic it looked (I am from the UK myself)
4:27 shadows from tall trees would never be as crisp as in horizon 3 in real life
I feel like once they update FH4, it’ll be a different. If possible could you make another comparison video in the future? :)
@Nick930 When you do direct comparison could you high rev the car while driving so we can hear the difference?
Thank God you made this video. Because its too confusing to compare whats the difference
You can add forza horizon tyres on upgrades and tuning in forza horizon 4
oshit, they added a gradient on the logo of the game, the most impressive change imo
I think the flickering in the tree shadows is suppose to look like the trees moving in the breeze
They also toned down the bloom starting with Forza 7.
Anyway I wouldn't say Horizon 3 holds up well, given how poorly it runs especially compared to Horizon 4. Good graphics don't mean shit if the game isn't playable.
Also, Horizon 4 might have lower res grass textures but it has a lot more grass foliage, not to mention the mud tessellation and whatnot.
Is the performance still shit in horizon 3? Ive heard that it got a lot better after a few patches. But maybe not?
More broken maybe. The crashes nearly tripled, the graphics settings don't save anymore for a lot of people and it nuked saves several times. What's most alarming is that the last two occurred when Forzathon was update, not from an actual content update that requires download.
That's actually what's keeping me from buying Horizon 4. They have some major issues if they can fuck up your game this badly just by hitting the wrong switch.
your PC must not be very good, I can play it at 4k ultra settings and never dip below 60 fps. It seems to be optimized well for the visuals you receive with it. I suggest either turning down your settings or upgrading your PC.
Did it ever cross your mind that maybe you have a PC that's so good optimization ceases to be relevant? Just because you can brute force the game to run well doesn't mean it's well optimized.
These fuckin' guys man.
In my case, after all the optimization patches, the FPS on FH 3 more than doubled, from an average of ~45 on the lowest settings or completely maxed out with 8xmsaa to 100-115 depending on the region (closer to 100 in the city). FH4 however already runs at around 68-70 (maxed out with just 4xmsaa tho) which I don't mind, because even if it's not apparent in this video, the shadows got a massive upgrade due to actually having projected shadows now, especially during the night (FH3 had no shadows during night time, just a veil of darkness).
When I played forza 3, I thought all the engines sounded pretty similar
@Cameron XP yes
in my opinion. 3 had way better engine sounds compared to 4. 4 was so much recycled nonsense. yeah they killed it graphically but the actual realism of cars was so shot
Of course horizon 3 and forza 6 have the best cars exhausts
Forza motorsport 4 has the best car sounds
from your experience, which racing game has the most realistic graphics? does the drive club include?
Was this on a one x? and if so was it set to quality or performance? I have mine on quality and it looks incredible
Forza should’ve added a nice idle sound to all cars. And engine sounds when you pass by another car
Both games are great
I cant wait for fh5 vs fh4 comparison... its gonna be huge!
Any visual improvements will be because of engine improvements rather than asset improvements as they will have just reused the same assets for all cars that were present in both games.
We should capture the reactions of a gamer who was in a coma for the last 10 years and sees this video.
better say someone who been in prison
2:20 forza horion 4 looks like it has a matte paint job
Did you use the golf courses for the grass comparison? If so then of course they would be different because the course it made to have a smooth texture.
They nailed it on the sound in FH4, have heard the C7 in real life, sounds identical to it. Also the Arial Atom sounds correctly as well, have heard one of those as well
Your smoking
Horizon 3 looks better but 4 is more realistic
TheGoldenL 4 looks slightly better than 3 you mean but it’s just a tiny difference in terms of graphics
@@russiannoodleman3402 True.
Just listen to the sound of the Koenigsegg One:1 from both games.
Fh3 has a much better sound.
Because 3 doesnt have cloth to distract the developers
@@derpderogation735 nope, FH3 looks better than 4 overall, no point denying it.
What?
For me it boils down to the beauty of the location. And Australia wins because I love that landscape, reminds me of Oahu Hawaii island of Test Drive Unlimited 1 & 2, the inspiration for Forza horizon.
Somethings messed up with auctions. I keep losing when it says I'm highest bidder. It never gives me a chance to bid again. So lame. People just snipe bids from me
1:24 it is due to blooming effect which is causing the light to be blurred
4:30 well that wheel shadow is OK but not great: the wheel seems like it's flying above the ground
Always love your vids man. Do you plan on comparing AC Origins with AC Odyssey?
Yeessir. I'll try and have a video out on Friday :)
*Thanks!!!*
One thing i noticed is that the tail light on FH3 appear much more yellow than on FH4. Even two years ago when the game launched i noticed the lights were almost unrealistic yellow.
There's FH written on the tire because its the FH racing tire compound. You can get the same racing tire without the writing on them.
Being a console gamer by preference Forza horizon 4 looks amazing and was one of my first real dips into the dynamic lighting with headlights and vegetation or poles and posts, I tend to use photo mode a lot in my honest opinion it's one of the biggest and best changes to the game the effects add to the photos. My preference is 4 mainly for the setting the photo mode and really nice dynamic lighting but I have shown people pictures from 3 that where mistaken as real pictures, so both games are gorgeous.
I noticed that the rear lights reflects on the rain drops on the screen on FH4. 8:13 Nice touch.
I still find FH3 better overall. Also, Australia
They do as well on FH3. And yes, Australia
I did notice horizon 3s crash sounds have a lot more depth to them. like 4s is mostly a loud thud, but 3s have some tinkling glass and bodywork cracking
How did you use blueprint to create custom events with no opponents and just one car? I’ve been trying to do that for ages and haven’t found a way to
For the corvette comparison, the fh3 corvette had FE (Forza Edition) tires and a different style of rims than the fh4 version. This made the tires have writing on them and look more shiny. The dirt/mud effects are also stronger in fh4 due to the fact that it is based in Britain where the weather is more humid. Just wanted to point this out.
FH4 runs way better on my GTX 1080 than FH3. FH4 never drops below 80FPS on ultra for me while FH3 and FM7 would drop below 30 for a couple brief seconds atleast once a race which is way more important than graphics IMO.
Okay?
What does IMO mean?
@@jb-kp8go In my opinion
I have a gtx1080 and it has never dipped that's ya cpu or ram not keeping up my dude
or you have to much shit running in the background
I do really care about visual stuff, as long as its nice and doesn’t effect FPS too much. I mostly focus on the actual gaming experience
the light textures appeared blurred probably because you had lens effect enabled. (its in hud options)
4:51 horizon 3 has great dirt accumulation. You just didn’t drive around enough
the c7 (zo6) sounds better in FH3, the hurican sounds better in FH3, and the quad sound better in FH4, in my personal opinion.
Super video man ! Bravo... ! Very pro...
Question for someone who has played both: I have not played either game, but i was wondering if it would be worth it to get the $60 fh4 or get the $30 fh3? Thx in advance
i rather them focusing on optimization rather then improving the graphics
Exactly!
@Qaotik yeah but the graphics are already good, the physics are already good so you cant really improve on that alot. but the optimization? from 50 fps with stuttering and crashes to 100fps with 0 stutters? thats more important to me than making the game look nicer when its already looking great
@@N4orEditor The impact on tuning has improved quite a bit over horizon 3. Now in 4 it feels like it does what it's supposed to rather than trying to break the game with completely bonkers settings which doesn't even make sense in horizon 3. I still don't get why the cars has to understeer so much by default.
Who is here now
With the shadowing is probably to optimise the game to be smoother ... Which in any racing game I would expect... Sound compare tho I wouldn't expect them to improve the same car sound . It's all about saving money ... New cars would benefit though :) good job mate
things are different because of the tweaked shader model in FH4, along with more ambient occlusion and other graphical updates to look more natural/real