Yamaha "Silent Brass" Review and Demo
Вставка
- Опубліковано 5 вер 2024
- Donate: trent.nz/donate...
Become a patron: / trenthamiltonnz
Send me stuff!
POBox 5107
Wellington 6140
New Zealand
Get some Merchandise! shop.spreadshi...
Join me on Facebook: / trenthamiltonnz
Join me on Twitter: / trenthamiltonnz
"not annoy her anymore than more than my presence does" relatable
Wrathful Panda He really should do a comedy act, I'm sure it would be awesome.
Ikr
Well said.
I love that lol
Totally
1:47 "And practice in the same room as my wife while she is watching TV and not annoy her as much as my presence usually does." That killed me
112 likes and no comments, let me fix that since that was also my favourite line in the video 😂👌🏼
That is an older model. The new version fits entirely in the bell and has better air flow. The Personal studio has less noise but only 2 reverb settings.
"Silent brass" was my high school band's nickname. Guess why.
it didn’t exist
it didn’t exist
it didn't exist
it didn't exist
it didn’t exist
I think that is the old version of the silent brass, with the newer one they reduced the back presasure and made the reverbs a lot more realistic. They also made it fit flush with the bell rather than protuding outwards, enabling you to put the trombone in it's case with the mute in which is rather useful for transportation.
Do you like the new version sound? I have the older trumpet one and found the sound really stuffy or unrealistic (like you were playing in the bottom of a well)
Also its cheaper
I am a trumpet/cornet player and recently bought a compact ProTec practice mute. It does produce quite a bit of back pressure which is unpleasant, but I discovered something about it that that resulted in me using it all the time when I practice now. I have found that it not only helps me improve the clarity of my intonation, but it also strengthens my lip and increases my durability because the back pressure exercises your lip more and therefore strengthens the lips. I especially find it useful for getting my lip back in shape in a short period of time after I get over a cold or something, and of course it’s awesome to be able to practice anytime anywhere.
I have the later model and it blows easily. It also has an option for an auxiliary, which I can hook to a recording and play along with (hearing it and the trombone through the headphones). Greatest thing since sliced bread.
"not annoy her any more than my presence generally does”….a man who knows himself
Any affects on tuning? Most mutes throw the horn out of tune; some significantly.
I have this mute. It acts jsut liek anyother mute. Plenty resistant. Plenty of intonation issues. It's purely for listening to yourself
The lowest harmonic on the trumpet/cornet silent brass mute is abominable. Almost a quarter tone sharp. I assume the trombone one might be less so considering the trombone itself is a little more secure in the lower register.
I have this system, the tuning will make you sharp slightly and in the range from low b flat to low f is extremely sharp. These mutes are best for high range work and mid range long tone work
Yeah, there are intonation problems - just like any practice mute. You can use it for everything except intonation practice though.
Don't listen to these people. I have this mute, and the Silent Brass is a ton more useful than my Humes & Berg practice mute. Don't believe me? Here's a link to some testing. trombone.org/articles/library/viewarticles.asp?ArtID=166
While the reverb feature may be impractical for skills improvement, as you mentioned, I could see myself still using it a lot just for the cool factor, trying different songs, etc. IOW, a potentially dangerous thing to put in the hands of a procrastinator like me. : )
It’s like a guitar amp for brass instruments
3:37 *This video has been copyright claimed by UMG under the title: "Happy Birthday to You"*
nul00000000 jokes on you. HBtY is in the public domain! 🤣
en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Happy_Birthday_to_You#History
🖕🏿 Warner
Nice try numpty
another use of it is to plug-in an audio source with a backing track and practice with it. Useful for practicing improvisation.
Actually, I can see a good use for this in being able to record your instrument.
How would you do that?
The mute really messes up your tone and the reverb levels are pretty bad. There are much better ways to record than with this set-up.
@@evanoliveras9717 There is a 'Line Out' port on the unit that could be fed into your computer and captured with any DAW software.
Mike Badley way better ways to record whilst muted? Interested to hear them
The system has improved tenfold since this version. Ironically, I got mine last week. I can say the sound quality is much clearer, the reverb makes sense. The pickup can actually fit in your pocket, and just overall it's much more efficient. I haven't taken it out of my bell yet. I'd return that and pay 165$ for the new version. 300$ is too much, especially for the older version
but what about guitar pedals for an electric trombone
Knotty Virus you can, which is the main reason why I want one
Maniacal 4 does "Carry On My Wayward Son" with this effect, it's pretty cool
ua-cam.com/video/DNwnjoKwbW8/v-deo.html
Thank you for the demonstration, Trent. I'm surprised that the trombone version of Silent Brass differs so vastly to the trumpet model, where there is very little noticeable back-pressure. I would say that the amount of back-pressure caused by the trumpet Silent Brass is comparable to the trumpet ssh mute.
My unit, which is an older generation, does not contain the same ridiculous levels of reverb as the one you demonstrated. I too would find that level of effect to be useless.
For a time I used my Silent Brass regularly, but less so these days when I'm less considerate of my family and neighbors.
I thought it would be cool to mix in some feeds from the AUX port and then LINE OUT to a speaker but the reverbs on the unit are terrible and you get an awful trumpet sound back from the mute. So, nix that idea. I also hated all the wires to and from the main unit. (This was a lot of years ago - they've made lots of improvement on wireless mics now)
The high levels of reverb are for practicing for a performance in a large concert hall or something else that requires you to articulate very cleanly.
I was literally just about to buy this thing. Thanks for the review man!
I found the tuba variant of this on Craigslist for $50 a few months ago
4:29 I personally would use it to create songs with a trombone on a computer without having to worry about my neighbors being annoyed
and in a real life example, i'd use it to familiarize myself in a performing location's reverb level. My marching band practiced with ear plugs in before finals because it would simulate how it sounds in a stadium while performing.
Damb, I was kind of hoping for a shoot out with those other practice mutes you mentioned
How come the newer ones don't have nearly as much options and button
Thank you for a great review !
I live in an apartment, but really the main reason I think it would be nice would be to play along with songs, backing tracks, etc. all in headphones.
Cheers,
Steve
I purchased the tuba version this year. I thoroughly enjoy it. My work schedule (if you can really call it that) often means the only time available to practice is late at night. I also like being able to connect my iPhone to the control box so I can play along with my favorite songs. The mute disassembles so it can be stored inside the instrument, inside its case. The only downsides to this mute so far are that it adds about ten pounds of weight to the instrument, and it’s a bit complicated to set up, as it comes with a strap to secure it to the bell. However, that extra weight is actually a benefit, as my tuba now feels significantly lighter when I don’t use it!
I actually think the reverb effects are a great idea. When playing in an echoey auditorium, performance hall or otherwise it’s advisable to adjust your articulation/note length to account for the reverb, and using a reverb setting would allow you to actually hear what you’re doing on that front.
This appears to be an older model. The updated version is much smaller, lighter and blows more freely.
I use one of these with my cornet when I travel for work. It only has slight reverb and works pretty well, but lower notes are hard to keep in tune. Still, it's more fun than a Shh mute and hasn't disturbed anyone ... so far. Mine can also channel backing tracks or other accompaniment and blends in pretty well which is useful.
They haven't manufactured that kind since back in late 2013/early 2014. I got mine in late 2014. The updated one is much better. More free blowing, fewer intonation issues, and the mic system sound is much better. You should let your viewers know there is updated models out there.
Oh, and it also fits flush with the bell. I leave my mute in while the horn is in the case.
The reverb is useful because the higher the reverb (as in the larger the room) the less precise your articulation is. Its much more difficult to have a clean crisp note in a concert hall than a practice room.
This is the first generation Silent Brass, launched back in 1995. I bought mine in 1996-ish. I still use it, and if you take in to account that this is a 24 year old electronic design, I think it is quite good. What would be interesting is if you could test the old vs the new design. I haven't tested the "new" (the second generation was launched in 2014), but it is said to have less back pressure, and I would guess that the electronics in the box has been upgraded quite a bit after 20 years.
Here is a official video from Yamaha back in 2014 with some professionals giving their first impression of the second generation. ua-cam.com/video/Hm-jX-rSKS8/v-deo.html
And here is a review made by someone who has testet both the first generation and the second generation. Time stamp to where he is commenting on the difference between the two: ua-cam.com/video/vYdWKmby1aY/v-deo.html
There's a really prominent upper harmonic with each note played that sounds really odd like a weird aftertaste. Wonder whether that is connected to the back pressure thing. Or if it's just how the internal mic is mounted - perhaps picking up too much mechanical vibration from the bell instead of just the airborne sound from within.
Something interesting here is that the old mute fits your bass trombone: the newer units aren't listed as compatible with bass trombones, and mine doesn't work on my 9" bell bass. Something for folks to keep in mind, and a good reason, perhaps, for owning both models, or at least the mute portion of each.
I wonder if they make these in tuba size...
Good Lord, it would be the size of a crock pot... with a tail section.
Yes they do
They do and its huge
I have the Silent Brass Trumpet mute, and I can play while my wife sleeps in the next room with the door open, and she does not wake up!!
I have tried many mutes over the years, and this is tho ONLY mute I can say this about!
If you have to practice, and don't want to have to go outside and sit in your car to play, this is the mute to do it with!!
One thing you failed to discuss is the AUX IN port to allow you to port in a Music Minus One or some other source of play-along accompaniment. I found it pretty useful for practicing quietly without the need for an amplified accompaniment. I don't use it much, and have the older version like you've shown here. I'd be interested in the 'new' version if I could really justify more of a need for it.
If you are going to get a trombone mute get the Yamaha SB5X, which is better than the SB5 in that it has a hole in the end that allows the air to escape. Same features minus all the extraneous reverb settings. It has volume, reverb one (small room) reverb two (big room/concert hall). I have also used it with effect pedals and amps to get some very cool sounds and have more reverb options. Any pedal you have you can use with an small to big aux adapter. @Maniacal4 uses them in there cover of “Carry on my wayward son” if you want an example. Super helpful for late night and early morning practice sessions. It has a 3 connection ports. A “mute” in connecting the mute to the power/controls, an “aux”, and a “phones” for connecting to headphones or going the other direction and connecting to pedals and amps. The best part is it also fits perfectly into flugelhorn bells
I believe that is the original version and that there is a new version available. The model on mine is "SB5X". Both the mute and the amplifier are much smaller.
trombone amp tho? can you hook it up to an amp?
Yeah you can hook it up to an amplifier. I have the trumpet version of the silent brass. There's three just; one for the mute, one for headphones, and one for auxiliary.
I have the newer version of this for trombone and like it, but it's in a more affordable price range similar to regular practice mutes. Want to add a practice mute for my tuba, however, and can't find anything in stock in the USA under $300. That being regular practice mutes as the tuba Silent Brass mute is $500-600, so something like a Denis Wick mute for $200 less makes more sense. Assuming I can ever track one down that doesn't jump a couple hundred dollars in price.
Personally, I use my Trumpet Silent Brass for slightly different reasons. I use the 3.5mm headphone out jack as a DI to record directly into GarageBand. Also mine came with an adapter for a guitar amplifier, so I plug my mute into my Fender Acoustasonic with some cool effects pedals.
mine Yamaha silent brass 2 mute made my trumpet play out of tune som flats some Sharp
I have the Yamaha Silent Brass for trumpet. It's the best mute by far, in my opinion.
I bought one years ago and was told that I could use for the same one for my tenor. It was an older model then the one you are using, I was very unhappy withit. expected to much
TOP TIP, RIGHT HERE….. (that got your attention) use with a Hercules trombone stand, the one that doesn’t go inside the bell!
It would be good if it had a key change function so brass can play in a key friendly for them but the sound coming out is in a key good for guitars.
Take the line output from the preamp and feed it into a pitch shifter :)
Rob Cuesta that'd work.
Find a better guitar player.
Willem Errens fair enough I guess. I can cope as a guitarist playing in hard keys, but can't be bothered.
I think the revered is for if your playing in stadium sort of envirments often, like in a high school marching band. But I don't see why it would go to far with the revered
Great review as always, Trent.
That looks like the old model, however. The new models (mine is the SBX-7) are much smaller - basically the same 'footprint' as my K&G trumpet stand. There's no 'overhang', so I can put the Strad in its case with the mute in the bell (I don't, but I could :-D).
The new preamp has only one input and there are only two reverb settings. Some people hate the reverb, but I find the lowest setting is fine - just like rehearsing in a typical room rather than an acoustically treated studio. The high setting is great for hiding the odd articulation issue :) Both are a lot more realistic and less intrusive than that old model. It would have been great if Yamaha had given a way to turn reverb off altogether, though.
As regards back pressure, I can't comment about the trombone version, but the updated trumpet version doesn't create much additional resistance - there's some, but not huge amounts, and certainly nowhere near what the old SilentBrass did. What it DOES do is create huge amounts of water - I end up clearing the spit valve every few minutes. So I'm banned from the living room even with the SilentBrass - my wife hates it when I dribble on the hardwood floor lol.
The big gotcha is that it does affect pitch. Not so much on the Bb trumpet and cornet. But on the Eb soprano cornet, the bottom end goes horribly flat and the top goes ridiculously sharp (G above the stave is almost an Ab - I have to use 1+3 to play in tune). I suspect this is related to the backpressure, since that particular pattern of pitch hell is usually down to player airflow issues :-D That would also explain why it gets worse as the instrument gets smaller, and I assume on a horn, trombone, euph, etc. it wouldn't even be noticeable.
A lot of people forget that the SIlentBrass is effectively a piezo pickup, much like you'd get in a guitar. That allows for some very creative uses: I picked up a guitar effects pedal on Ebay for $40 and feed the output of the SBX into it when I'm feeling adventurous :-) It does need some adapters (the SBX is stereo, and the pedals expect/require a mono signal) but they were only a couple of dollars on Amazon :-)
Do you know where I can get one of these? I do live in an apartment complex and there are heavy restrictions on loud noises. A system like this would be very beneficial to me
Thomann and Amazon have those on their websites. They also cost around 180 USD around there
This can also be used for recording
Okay so this is a question that might seem super stupid but cut me some slack I’m a trombonist that rarely touches a trumpet. But I understand the whole concept of trumpet fingerings and all that but why is it that when you play in 6th or 7th position you have to push the slide out manually? I mean like why isn’t the slide adjustable similar to a main tuning slide instead of having to move it out specifically for those notes
I bought this in high school and it was terrible. You should get a best brass practice mute instead. It feels wayy more natural.
I heard that this mute provides significant back pressure while the wires can be quite annoying
Trent, could that same mute be used in my straight belled baritone without getting lost down the bell? OR does YAMAHA make special "Silent Brass mutes for baritone and euphonium players' instruments alone I've had one for my trumpet for many years and I know that won't work in a baritone. Is a tuba mute to large for a baritone? Please reply! Thank you for your time,
Dan
Maybe, yes, yes
Is that not the unite that allows you to play the music through it as you play. In other words play along as you practice
The advantage of brass, easy to mute. Not so with woodwind! To be able to mute my clarinet like this would be great because no bugger wants to hear it
Anyone from America
From South, Central or North America?
Americans tend to be from America.
heimat North
No
Ah, OK. Mexico and Canada.
Should review the newer model. Way more portable and practical.
It is actually really good and cool
So if you were to plug in speakers instead of earphones, you've got an electric horn..! Or maybe you can plug the mute into a different mixer and get cool different sounds!
Hi Trent, is the horn you are using a King 7B or 8B and have you ever reviewed it? I've been the proud owner of an 8B for 30years+, have been offered a 7B for a reasonable price but would appreciate a review of the 7 before I commit.
7B. They’re beautiful instruments. I personally prefer the 7 over the 8, but I’ve only spent a little bit of time playing an 8
You can also play at midnight with it
Good review.
How can I use the silent brass to record my playing along with a digital backing track simultaneously into audio/video program?
Is there any reason you reviewed the old one when the new one had already been out for like 5 years at the time of upload?
Because that's the only one I had :)
Do they make this for tubas, that would be useful
Trent, could you do another update video on the TR-430?
Can you do a comparison between the e flat bass and b flat bass
I imagine it can record audio too with interface?
Is there anything along the same lines as the EWI for brass? Or is the EWI about it?
I can bet you a 2 dollar bill that he can sell all his instruments and be able to buy a whole 99 cent store
When using the mute, I plug it into a direct box to record music.
I’m gonna get the trumpet version
What’s that circular silver instrument to his left of his head, with the long bell? If someone can tell me I’ll be highly grateful
It's a very old melophone Conn made a while ago!
It works fine on trumpet, but not with pocket trumpet
Can anyone compare the backpressure of silent brass and the shh mute?
Honestly, I have a slightly older model for trumpet and it is shit. After 5 minutes of playing it just stops working. It barely amplifies the sound to begin with and aftrr some playing it doesn't amplify it at all. Basically all I would hear is the sound coming out of the actual thing and not the headphones. It is practical in other ways I must say. For example when you really feel like playing at 12 pm, you could play without bothering anyone. The resistance is a real bugger for keeping notes from getting false and it takes a lot of breath too.
What does the Player 1 / Player 2 knob do? Does it adjust the volume?
Yes. On this model you can connect two different compatible practice mutes, and this adjusts the volume of each of the inputs.
what was the first song he played 2:36
Do Re Me from the sound of music
What instrument are you best at like what do you play
I share a room with my two brothers and one of their girlfriends so I wanna buy this
Hello Trent. You are a wonderful musician. I was wondering I you would like to do a duet on my channel.
Hi Trent!
Im a music looner, have no friends to play with, so I play for UA-cam and Daily Motion sites!
Lets say I play tune Summertime, I a recording with Silent Brass and a CD recording, or I take the tune from You Tube and play together!
At the same time no one get disturb in my house, great!
You also have Silent Brass old studio, why did Yamaha quit making those? New one is not good at all?
Ok, thanks for sharing, talk more of plastic mouth pieces!
Johnny D Bergh on YTube
Hi busy guy what do you say on my comments?
Wats that instrument on your right
Is it worth it?
mine is much smaller than that and just has a switch instead of dials
tmbgfan1 I think this is the one for bass trombones. I’ve got a tenor trombone silent brass and it is much smaller unit like your describing.
1:53 Ba dum Phssssss
I have the trumpet version. I don't like it. I used it for about a week, then put it away. First annoyance: trailing wires that get tangled - have they not heard of Bluetooth? Second: why do I have to buy batteries and put them in? My phone and just about every other equipment I use has built- in rechargeable batteries. Finally, I hate the sound I'm listening to through headphones - so artificial, and unlike the natural acoustic sound. Yamaha ought to know better! They're a high-tech company after all. I don't think this kit is fit for purpose. It's cumbersome and demoralising to use.
What kind of trombone is that
Do they make them for trumpets?
Yep
Yes.
I want one for my Horn📯😭
Ugh those reverbs are so noisy.
Very lol video bro
What were you looking at? Lol
The audio levels on my monitor as I record.
Trent Hamilton great video as always!
Second
Silent brass impossible!
first
What trombone is that
King 7B 2107 Bass Trombone