My M12 Impact turns ALOT of nylon nuts for a year before it died. Milwaukee warranty repaired the tool and sent it back to me. My M18 Impacts haven't died at all. My Dewalt impacts died after 2 years. It's a toss up for longevity for me
My boss uses strictly dewalt so I end up using a lot of dewalt. Can’t say I’ve ever had problems but they eat batteries like crazy. I’ve never been a dewalt guy and I have a lot of red and black all tool brands, so I’ll never be a dewalt guy. But I’ve never broken a Milwaukee either. 🤷♂️
Bought the M12 fuel set with the return battery for a total of $160 after, and the M18 set for $260 and don’t know which to keep. Only DIY and household applications. Thought I could future proof with M18 since I have no drills or batteries from anything but I might just keep the M12
I love the size of m12. If you are not going to get any routers or circ saws... the m18 isn't needed... but I also own 2x M12s and 1x M18 so there's that lol
I am currently testing the gen 4 drill. I will say I have a 2018, non fuel, milwaukee drill that is still running strong. I bought the newer model purely for testing.
I use it to drive in 2-in bolts in concrete and this is the only tool that does it quick enough (although sometimes it literally over drives it and chips concrete)
Ever tried one of their impact wrenches? Not suggesting, just curious, have you tried the M12 Fuel 3/8" stubby? I've heard a ton of mechanics swear by them.
@@mfcbuilds I haven't, I do have all different kinds of M18 impact drivers and this one never gets stuck, I don't even have any overheating issues and we typically drive in 500 bolts each day
@yankybraver9403 The battery is what overheated for me during testing. I've nvr had one overheat while working, only testing. BUT that lag bolt test is essentially running the tool for about 5 minutes straight.
Great video Guy tells it as it is M12 works for most applications But if you're into construction every day than yah it makes sense otherwise the gen 3 m12 8@ great thats my go to for DIY stuff around the house Including fence and deck repairs Again great honest video
Hey man, if you get to see this comment I just want to know what you think about the current Home Depot deal on the dewalt set. Impact driver and drill and two batteries with a charger and a case for $299.99 and a free selection of a tool that can be as much as $219.99 meaning if the return works you can get a Dewalt impact and drill for $80. Kind of ridiculous. Also they have a set of batteries for 199 that if you could return the free gift would make them free.
Not exactly how it works. So I found the promo you're referring to. Here's the breakdown. 20V Drill & Impact is on sale for $299 (orig. $329.99) including a FREE tool, like the $219 Jigsaw. The cost of the "free tool" is discounted from each item. Meaning the 20V Drill & Impact combo cost $172.59 and the Jigsaw cost $126.41 Return the "free tool" and you get the combo kit for the $172.59 + tax. It's a great price. Hope this helps.
Any tool used to it’s limit will die sooner, my tools work really hard but I don’t push the limits with them just because it can do a big bolt doesn’t mean it’s a good idea I have Milwaukee Dewalt and Makita stuff for various reasons and they are all good tools obviously some better than others in some situations and jobs that is the reason I have more than one brand.
They are fast and strong but they are not the most reliable. That has been my experience around them, but some folks run them for ever . M12 fuel line has served me great though.
The M18 fails a bit too often. The previous model is more reliable. TTC had 5 fail while using them for various videos. Milwaukee will warranty them, but they've got a higher failure rate than they should. I'm a Milwaukee tool owner, btw.
I also saw the same video... I even recall there being an issue with the previous generations' collet. Fortunately/unfortunately I have no personal experience with failure....yet.
If you are an electrician or joiner and have to drill hole with augers then this is not for you. 2 month amd it just runs for a second and cuts out. The older impacts are much better amd the surge, just stay away. The surge will fail in a year.
Still running a Gen 1 from 2015 and its used daily on a building site. Its in a dreadful state but still working.
That's awesome. My old M18 impact was given to my father when I bought the M12. That thing is the non-fuel and still running strong.
Well worth it. Might just be because I’m a Milwaukee believer tried and true
😂 agreed
Tool reviews today starting to sound like they are reviewing firearms. Lol. The "military characteristics" are taking over everywhere. But I want one.
I've fired off just a few rounds before.... It was worse when I reviewed the Sawzall. I was not happy about the safety 🤣
are you using your M18 with a Weaver or an Isosceles?
@@pkdude5334 😂 I've always been more of an Isosceles guy. Full transparency, I was not military. LEO for a short bit.
Me like CORDLESS POWER TOOLS and OPE EQUIPMENT and GUNS and KNIVES and BOWS
@THEBEARDEDTOOLGUY 💪
My M12 Impact turns ALOT of nylon nuts for a year before it died. Milwaukee warranty repaired the tool and sent it back to me.
My M18 Impacts haven't died at all.
My Dewalt impacts died after 2 years.
It's a toss up for longevity for me
I burned through a few ryobi, and bosch, and dewalt... haven't killed a milwaukee yet... but there's still time lol
My boss uses strictly dewalt so I end up using a lot of dewalt. Can’t say I’ve ever had problems but they eat batteries like crazy. I’ve never been a dewalt guy and I have a lot of red and black all tool brands, so I’ll never be a dewalt guy. But I’ve never broken a Milwaukee either. 🤷♂️
Just picked up one of these for 296 after taxes including one extra free XC5. Very happy.!
Sweet
Well worth it. I had my last set last me just about 9 years with daily use. You get what you pay for.
Agreed. My previous version, non-Fuel, was just given to my father as I only upgraded to review the newer version.
Bought the M12 fuel set with the return battery for a total of $160 after, and the M18 set for $260 and don’t know which to keep. Only DIY and household applications. Thought I could future proof with M18 since I have no drills or batteries from anything but I might just keep the M12
I love the size of m12. If you are not going to get any routers or circ saws... the m18 isn't needed... but I also own 2x M12s and 1x M18 so there's that lol
4 a drill and impact driver I get M12 but my only reason why I have M18 is for the platform all the saws
Excellent commercial! On a serious note, thank you, Man. Love the demo and Home Depot hack explanation 😎
You got a new sub
That's awesome! Thank you so much.
Do you show the receipt when you do this hack? Or do you just return without receipt for store credit?
Return with receipt. Also, if you buy online, it has personally been a nightmare. Just buy in store and return in store
In thinking of getting this with the gen 4 combi , are the combi drills durable ?
I am currently testing the gen 4 drill. I will say I have a 2018, non fuel, milwaukee drill that is still running strong. I bought the newer model purely for testing.
I use it to drive in 2-in bolts in concrete and this is the only tool that does it quick enough (although sometimes it literally over drives it and chips concrete)
Ever tried one of their impact wrenches? Not suggesting, just curious, have you tried the M12 Fuel 3/8" stubby? I've heard a ton of mechanics swear by them.
@@mfcbuilds I haven't, I do have all different kinds of M18 impact drivers and this one never gets stuck, I don't even have any overheating issues and we typically drive in 500 bolts each day
@yankybraver9403 The battery is what overheated for me during testing. I've nvr had one overheat while working, only testing. BUT that lag bolt test is essentially running the tool for about 5 minutes straight.
Got it for 250 very happy with this purchase
That's awesome!
Just bought it with a 5ah and a 2ah battery for $200 at Home Depot online. 😎
@@mr-toyotathat’s a great deal.
Good comparison between the two, but if you had to choose between the two for the homeowner, which would be the better option?
If you intend on running circular saws, routers, or sawzalls.... go 18v.
Great video
Guy tells it as it is
M12 works for most applications
But if you're into construction every day than yah it makes sense otherwise the gen 3 m12 8@ great thats my go to for DIY stuff around the house
Including fence and deck repairs
Again great honest video
how did you return that 8.0 free battery without receipt for store credit?
Hey man, if you get to see this comment I just want to know what you think about the current Home Depot deal on the dewalt set. Impact driver and drill and two batteries with a charger and a case for $299.99 and a free selection of a tool that can be as much as $219.99 meaning if the return works you can get a Dewalt impact and drill for $80. Kind of ridiculous. Also they have a set of batteries for 199 that if you could return the free gift would make them free.
Not exactly how it works. So I found the promo you're referring to. Here's the breakdown.
20V Drill & Impact is on sale for $299 (orig. $329.99) including a FREE tool, like the $219 Jigsaw.
The cost of the "free tool" is discounted from each item. Meaning the 20V Drill & Impact combo cost $172.59 and the Jigsaw cost $126.41
Return the "free tool" and you get the combo kit for the $172.59 + tax. It's a great price.
Hope this helps.
Any tool used to it’s limit will die sooner, my tools work really hard but I don’t push the limits with them just because it can do a big bolt doesn’t mean it’s a good idea I have Milwaukee Dewalt and Makita stuff for various reasons and they are all good tools obviously some better than others in some situations and jobs that is the reason I have more than one brand.
Completely agree. Have multiple drivers for the same reason. For these large bolt an impact wrench is the way to go
They are fast and strong but they are not the most reliable. That has been my experience around them, but some folks run them for ever . M12 fuel line has served me great though.
is the gen 3 m18 still worth buying
I vaguely recall them having some chuck issue, not positive on that. I honestly have no personal experience with it. I skipped that generation.
The M18 fails a bit too often. The previous model is more reliable. TTC had 5 fail while using them for various videos. Milwaukee will warranty them, but they've got a higher failure rate than they should.
I'm a Milwaukee tool owner, btw.
I also saw the same video... I even recall there being an issue with the previous generations' collet. Fortunately/unfortunately I have no personal experience with failure....yet.
Mine working and stopping and reason why
Battery, I don't know
The gen-4 keeps stopping on me, sending it off to get it fixed 4 times in less than 6 months. It is junk.
Mine performs excellent and does better than my m12 fuel
As it should
How you getting on with it, is it comfortable to use?
@@sparx2391 I have zero complaints. It is a solid tool.
I bought it
I'm pretty happy with testing. Zero complaints.
Too bad Ryobi with the biggest battery can't beat 60% of its torque specs. 1800 in.lb struggles for 900.
It's a Milwaukee that should tell u all the need to know, 👎
🤣 I think they're all to the point where you can just pick a color you like and be fine
Jesus loves you God bless
Thank you
If you are an electrician or joiner and have to drill hole with augers then this is not for you. 2 month amd it just runs for a second and cuts out. The older impacts are much better amd the surge, just stay away. The surge will fail in a year.
That's rough, but thanks for sharing. Did you utilize warranty, and how was the process?