I love Colm's hanging. One of my favorite cutscenes in video game history. After all the laughing he did thinking he was about to escape the gallows once again, the "I'm fucked" look he has on his face after Arthur blows him a kiss goodbye from the rooftop is absolutely priceless. If they would've waited 5 more seconds to release the floor he probably would've died of a heart attack. He was truly a coward who had no problem dishing out death indiscriminately to innocent people, but couldn't take it when he realized his number was up and nobody was going to save him this time.
My favorite too. I find it disturbing as it is satisfying watching his slow panic as it set's in that there's no escape this time, he's gonna die and no one is going to save him.
It's cathartic in the way that revenge is cathartic. We're so caught up in that feeling of having our revenge we forget that Colm, the worse of two evils, was keeping the Pinkertons busy a bit. (He was also robbing Cornwall) And so it would have been better for the gang to let Colm be, just as Arthur advised, revenge is a fool's game.
The difference is that the law made him do dirty work for them in exchange, but not for him but his family they had an agreement instead they betrayed him acting like they were angels but they were devils instead but way worse
"You murdered three men, and for that you must pay with your OWN life! Oh, hey Arthur. Don't forget to go down to the post office after the hanging and pay your $20 bounty for killing all them fellers this morning Alright now, pull the lever..." - The Sheriff of Valentine, who replaced the Sheriff that you murdered after robbing the Valentine doctor's office.
@@matthewriley7826yeah people like that know they did bad things and they know the past won’t be changed but the conviction they have to redeem themselves by being better for everyone would earn my respect for them
anybody hear the reference to John in the epilogue on number 7 they said "you can't runaway from your outlaw past. Trying to run away and become a rancher and family man" or something like that 🤔
I almost always save the unknown guy that hangs in front of his family (free bolt action is a bonus) and mark johnson. Sometimes I’ll save the armless guy.
Even if you save Mark Johnson, he dies anyway. He flees but the law kills him, and no matter how much you protect him the law still catches up and takes him out.
These aren't realistic strangulation hangings at all. They more resemble long drop hangings where the neck snaps. Traditional hanging victims thrash around violently and take many minutes to die, colloquially referred to as the gallows dance. By many accounts it is really horrific to watch, and the victim often urinates and defecates involuntarily as well. It is a fucking nightmarish execution method compared to the long drop that is a rather recent invention. Keep in mind that the electric chair was originally invented as an alternative to the brutality of hanging.
surprising how the protagonist (Arthur or John) doesn't get hanged even after murdering an entire town while on the other hand some random npc gets hanged for one murder
Most of those people saying things like "Man, I'm hungry after that, I could go for some crawfish" really puts it into perspective how screwed up most of us are.
I got the game 6 months ago or so and am on the epilogue. I didn’t see a hanging until black water. Do you have to go back to the town right after the bounty?
Weird...I have searched every where and couldn't find black widow hanging scene, only just go to Valentine bar (where Arthur beat the fat guy) and the bartender would tell you black widow had been hang
"a a man who thought he could just leave his outlaw past behind and become a rancher and family man. well the law dont work that way" john marston : :|
The bounties you capture in Valentine don't get hanged, just stay in the jail. When the guy gets hanged there it's just a random event (you didn't capture him or see him beforehand it's just a random hanging taking place). If you mean the killer prostitute that also begins as a random event where she approaches you in Valentine at night and asks you for help disposing of the body of a client she just stabbed to death (in self defense she claims). Instead of helping you can capture her and take her to the sheriff. If you wait a few in game days and come back to Valentine you can witness her hang. I guess it's possible to miss it though, if for example the random event triggered but you didn't notice it was going on.
Can u pay to be the executioner in Mark Johnson or any other hanging event ? And if u can, is it possible to just release him as the executioner and keep him alive ?
honestly he deserved it, iirc sadie mentions "one of his boys wanted for murdering a girl" referring to cleet being the one killing the girl, and he was in a desperate situations so he would say whatever got him out + he was protecting micah
@@cornjulio played another 15 minutes, and tried to play as a pacifist in the first mission. I uninstalled the game after Dutch died and had to start all over again.
Okay wow, I'm gonna call it: it's 2023 and Red Dead Redemption 2 looks dated. In fact parts of it might have felt dated at the time, we were just distracted by sunlight shining through ears
"You got a reason to be hanging around here?" "You wanna get a loitering ticket?" To everyone's eternal shame RDR2 is neither deep nor wide. Not game of the year material.
@@m.h3846 Janky mo-cap, graphics aren't that good, animation is a bit clunky. I can imagine a better game 5 years later, but in 2018 I really couldn't. Makes sense, took me about half a decade to start seeing RDR1's "amazing graphics" from 2010 start to date.
@@m.h3846 Same thing happened with Terminator 2 Judgement Day. When I was a teenager that thing was the greatest movie ever and no movie would ever top it. Now I can admit it looks like the 1980's, even though it came out in 91.
Nothing like ending the night whilst watching a large number of hangings.
Bruh I'm doing the same before going to sleep rn 😂
Same
Bro stop
@@Kevin_1337 bruh same
We're The Same
I love Colm's hanging. One of my favorite cutscenes in video game history. After all the laughing he did thinking he was about to escape the gallows once again, the "I'm fucked" look he has on his face after Arthur blows him a kiss goodbye from the rooftop is absolutely priceless. If they would've waited 5 more seconds to release the floor he probably would've died of a heart attack. He was truly a coward who had no problem dishing out death indiscriminately to innocent people, but couldn't take it when he realized his number was up and nobody was going to save him this time.
My favorite too. I find it disturbing as it is satisfying watching his slow panic as it set's in that there's no escape this time, he's gonna die and no one is going to save him.
It's cathartic in the way that revenge is cathartic. We're so caught up in that feeling of having our revenge we forget that Colm, the worse of two evils, was keeping the Pinkertons busy a bit. (He was also robbing Cornwall)
And so it would have been better for the gang to let Colm be, just as Arthur advised, revenge is a fool's game.
Like Dutch wasn't the exact same?
@@SliceIceNDice what has that to do with Colm's hanging being satisfying?
@@SliceIceNDiceDitch was still a better person than Colm, even RDR1 Dutch. Dutch was insane, Colm was evil
Mark Johnson is like John Marston, his story of becoming a rancher, even his name
And his fate
The difference is that the law made him do dirty work for them in exchange, but not for him but his family they had an agreement instead they betrayed him acting like they were angels but they were devils instead but way worse
That's why I'd never do his bounty hunting mission it just doesn't feel right
@@noorulhasan4904 me too, i completed it only once
Foreshadowing
0:50
The wife’s VA must’ve been paid a Helluva lot more than the son’s VA lmao
The armless guy was the most confused and amazed I've been in any encounter in this game.
I didn’t know he was a murderer next time I encounter him i’ll leave him to die
I love how the people come to see the hanging and then are completely disgusted
When the killer lady was hanging hear the crowd it’s really funny what they say “Burn in h you b*tch”
It's the delivery of it that makes me laugh
Yes! The way he said it sounded like a South Park character. Haha
I always love that too 🙂
"You murdered three men, and for that you must pay with your OWN life! Oh, hey Arthur. Don't forget to go down to the post office after the hanging and pay your $20 bounty for killing all them fellers this morning Alright now, pull the lever..." - The Sheriff of Valentine, who replaced the Sheriff that you murdered after robbing the Valentine doctor's office.
he was probably just happy that he got a job
You may have murdered the sheriff during that robbery but I didn't.
I didn't kill any law when I robbed the doctor's office. Tied up a few O'Driscals then ran out the door after grabbing the loot as fast as I could.
Mark Johnson, foreshadowing John Marston, even kind of swapping the names around
I tried to leave him be, but they don't give you the option.
@@RomanticAntihero You can however save him before being executed by shooting the rope.
6:52
bro really pulled out the "Rip Bozo" move with that cigar
" a change man dont change the crimes what he commit"
one of my favourite sentence!
I guess, the fact that they are willing to change should still be acknowledged though.
@@matthewriley7826 don't mean shit to the pain you caused to the people around you
@@matthewriley7826yeah people like that know they did bad things and they know the past won’t be changed but the conviction they have to redeem themselves by being better for everyone would earn my respect for them
@2:47 “Jeezzuss, all this excitement and it didn’t cost a penny” 😂
if you look into colm's eyes, you can see tears forming
“Kinda makes me hungry, watching that”
11:28 literally the moment Colm realized he isn’t getting out of this one anymore.
anybody hear the reference to John in the epilogue on number 7 they said "you can't runaway from your outlaw past. Trying to run away and become a rancher and family man" or something like that 🤔
Johnson, John(Mar)s(t)on ? [Just playing around with words]
You can hear the neck snapping this game is an absolute masterpiece.
5:12 "kInD oF mAkEs Me HuNgRy WaTcHiNg ThAt"
1:45
Any reason you still HANGING around
Ahaha thats funny
Rope still holds. That's a good reason I guess.
0:48
Funny story, in my save file, when this execution happened, the guy just fell to the side, didn’t even go through the trapdoor, funny as Hell.
I almost always save the unknown guy that hangs in front of his family (free bolt action is a bonus) and mark johnson. Sometimes I’ll save the armless guy.
1:46 hehehe
Hate to be that person but even if you shoot Johnson down he’s shot to death in Saint Denis
Even if you save Mark Johnson, he dies anyway. He flees but the law kills him, and no matter how much you protect him the law still catches up and takes him out.
@@Alfa-mb5es wasn't that the armless guy that got killed when running away?
2:06
Love the line delivery here
Wow 13 minutes of just pure hangings that's alot of hanging
There’s one in Rhodes for the guy who drowns his wife in the trough, it’s the hardest one to trigger
These aren't realistic strangulation hangings at all. They more resemble long drop hangings where the neck snaps. Traditional hanging victims thrash around violently and take many minutes to die, colloquially referred to as the gallows dance. By many accounts it is really horrific to watch, and the victim often urinates and defecates involuntarily as well. It is a fucking nightmarish execution method compared to the long drop that is a rather recent invention. Keep in mind that the electric chair was originally invented as an alternative to the brutality of hanging.
2:05 bro the burn in hell you B- got me on my side on the floor 😂
😂😂😂😂
surprising how the protagonist (Arthur or John) doesn't get hanged even after murdering an entire town while on the other hand some random npc gets hanged for one murder
Kinda creepy how they just leave the bodies hanging
Most of those people saying things like "Man, I'm hungry after that, I could go for some crawfish" really puts it into perspective how screwed up most of us are.
Damn I missed all of these while playing Arthur
the killer lady was actually the same one from the random encounter at the saloon where you have to dump a body into the pig pen
Oh I thought it sounded like that
I followed the boy home after the unknown man got hung and he just sat in the garden like it was a normal day 💀
LoL
I’ve been looking for this since I played the game, thanks
Np :)
6:52 Arthur going full "RIP Bozo. Rest in piss, you won't be missed" by smoking that cigar
0:40 bro the kid has a goofy ahh voice 💀💀
8:13 the horse doing his business at the back
Wearing the Union officer's hat and smoking a cigar like Grant as you watch Wofford swing was perfect.
It's funny how the last guy still has his gun lol
To bad they won't let you hang bounties in Red Dead online. That would have been a cool feature
I got the game 6 months ago or so and am on the epilogue.
I didn’t see a hanging until black water.
Do you have to go back to the town right after the bounty?
After 2 in game days
1:40 he says hanging around and it’s on a hanging vid and he’s right at the hanging thingy
nice... 😃
2:06
I was looking for this comment 💀
Must’ve been a brother of the victims or some
@@earth8515 you are welcome partner
that killer lady did a magic hand trick
"burn in hell you btj" 🤣 2:05
8:33 😂
Sadie
“Hang Him”
The way she said it was kinda cute
Man said kinda makes me hungry watching that
Colm's number one for me.
3:25 foreshadowing..
I love it when they yell "you dirty son of a bitch"
always save mark johnson. always
“That made me hungry, I can go for some crawfish!”😃
Arthur literally smoming that Lindsey Wofford pack
*smoking I hate my fat thumbs
I took that fella to Saint Denis when i encountered him, half dead and bleeding out. I shouldve left him there.
Ive play through this game twice and only seen 2 of these.
I heard someone at the bar saying that the n9 was innocent
Weird...I have searched every where and couldn't find black widow hanging scene, only just go to Valentine bar (where Arthur beat the fat guy) and the bartender would tell you black widow had been hang
Funny that all the hangings go right, while the electric chair demonstration goes wrong in so many ways.
does anyone know if you can get the bolt action at everyone one of these
First one was brutal
"Kinda makes ke hungt watching that" 💀
Did anyone notice that the killer lady mover here hand before hanging
🤣
lindsay wofford hangs as well as mark johnson. Think the del lobos hang too
One question how i can see the hanging the prisionerss are always in jail.
"a a man who thought he could just leave his outlaw past behind and become a rancher and family man. well the law dont work that way"
john marston : :|
Does anyone know what to do and where to go when there is an execution?
Just watch em?
@@AshwinYis it when your entering a place does it have to be during a certain part of the game ?
2:06 😂😂😂
I know the old west were lawless times but man.
¿no cuelgan a Benedict Allbright?
How do I encounter the hanging in Rhodes and Saint Denis?
Bounty hunting. Do the bounties and bring them alive then check back every day to see if the event triggers.
Thanks🤝
Cleets hands were not tied he could have held onto the rope and pulled himself up
How to get this scene? until i finishing the epilogue, the killer still in the valentine jail and not get hanged yet
The bounties you capture in Valentine don't get hanged, just stay in the jail. When the guy gets hanged there it's just a random event (you didn't capture him or see him beforehand it's just a random hanging taking place). If you mean the killer prostitute that also begins as a random event where she approaches you in Valentine at night and asks you for help disposing of the body of a client she just stabbed to death (in self defense she claims). Instead of helping you can capture her and take her to the sheriff. If you wait a few in game days and come back to Valentine you can witness her hang.
I guess it's possible to miss it though, if for example the random event triggered but you didn't notice it was going on.
You Miserable Sow!
For anyone demanding bigger punishment to prevent crime, even hanging hasn't helped
1:46 punny
Why do all these people about to get hanged remember Authur
Watch it again..
Lol cuz he’s usually the one who turned them in….
Killer lady a baddie
Does shooting the rope give you honor even if they're bad?
Can you shoot the rope on all hanging?
Shooting the ropes will lower your honor..
@@oldironsides4107 yes you can
Can u pay to be the executioner in Mark Johnson or any other hanging event ?
And if u can, is it possible to just release him as the executioner and keep him alive ?
No.. You can't..
@@AshwinY ok thanks
I really appreciate your fast answer always
You can save him though, if you shoot the rope before he dies he escapes on a horse
@@technetium9653 Ok. Thanks
@@mostafaaysser4276 you can shoot every body and hang him yourself
👍🏿🤣✌🙏👎😃😁🥰🤲👏💪😾🎃🍦🍙🍱🍳🚦🛩🚌🚋🚅✈️🏅☕🏖😷😇😍🤑🤝🤡👹😀☺😭🥶🤩🥚💨🌪🌫🌊💧💦☔🌟✨⚡🔥💥☄️☀🌚🌔🌓🌒🌑🌝🌛🌜🌙💫🌾💐🌷🌹🥀🌻🍁🍂🍃🎋🎍🐀🦔🐾🐉🐲🦢🐇🐁🐩🐈🐈🦏🐎🐖🦛🐪🐊🐆🐅🐅🐟🐟🦂🦀🦑🐙🦞🕷🕸🐢🐍🐍🦎🦋🐌🐚🦟🦇🐺🦄🐦🐤🐣🐣🐥🦆🙈🙉🙉🙊🐒🐯🦁🐮🐶🐱🐭🐹🐰🦊🦊🐻😀😀😀😀😀😀👍🏿👍🏿👍🏿👍🏿👍🏿👍🏿👍🏿.
I saved mark johnson
So wait, why wasn’t that Black Widow chick also hanged? Didn’t she have several bodies to her name?
She was not right in the head.
Do you get a bounty if you save them?
Yes lol
And a hail of bullets fired in your direction.
2:06 Twitter comments irl
1:10 knowing me, would have killed her
8:30 the horse is literally taking a dump while Elias is getting hung
@2:03 how she able to wave lmao
Sorry 2:00
1:44 Any Reason you still hanging around? 💀
😅
Lol
How do you encounter the second one?
Colm O'Driscoll?? Story mission
@@AshwinY K
i dont killed cleet in my playtrough. senseless blood.
honestly he deserved it, iirc sadie mentions "one of his boys wanted for murdering a girl" referring to cleet being the one killing the girl, and he was in a desperate situations so he would say whatever got him out + he was protecting micah
@@ParrotPentester oof thats 4 years away for me 😂 i dont remember the story.
@@ParrotPentesterno Micah killed an entire family and Cleet tried to save the little girl but failed
@@ParrotPentesteralso cleet wasn’t protecting Micah he just wanted to change and put Micah’s gang behind him
@@deadlan2424 then why was he the one wanted for killing the girl?
😊😊😊
Can you save them from hanging?
Yes, except Colm
@@SiIhouWell, also Cleet... i mean, you save him from the rope but not from Sadie
What happens if you shoot the lawmen?
Wanted
@@AshwinY I mean would they still be hanged
Is it possible to save them?
Yes..
@@AshwinY oh. I own a copy of RDR2, but I've only played like half an hour of it and then gave up.
@@makimakipapura7543 don't give up you can do it
@@cornjulio played another 15 minutes, and tried to play as a pacifist in the first mission. I uninstalled the game after Dutch died and had to start all over again.
@@makimakipapura7543why would you try to play an outlaw game as a pacifist of course you had a bad experience😂
Why do you antagonize the lawmen?
Can u save the people? Shoot the rope?
Yup.. Some
Yeah,u can
Okay wow, I'm gonna call it: it's 2023 and Red Dead Redemption 2 looks dated. In fact parts of it might have felt dated at the time, we were just distracted by sunlight shining through ears
"You got a reason to be hanging around here?" "You wanna get a loitering ticket?" To everyone's eternal shame RDR2 is neither deep nor wide. Not game of the year material.
@@GlennDaveyWhat about it is dated?
@@GlennDaveyAnd how do those lines make it any less “wide” or “deep?”
@@m.h3846 Janky mo-cap, graphics aren't that good, animation is a bit clunky. I can imagine a better game 5 years later, but in 2018 I really couldn't. Makes sense, took me about half a decade to start seeing RDR1's "amazing graphics" from 2010 start to date.
@@m.h3846 Same thing happened with Terminator 2 Judgement Day. When I was a teenager that thing was the greatest movie ever and no movie would ever top it. Now I can admit it looks like the 1980's, even though it came out in 91.
"any reason you keep *HANGING* around"
Nah man, the police men are ruthless
Sound like death effect in Fortnite
'burn in hell u beech' PERFECT.