i like this version of the song, less creepy, yet sadder than the usual versions. Also, Abigail's voice is very soothing, perfect for campfire singing sessions
@@panoskamp4324 Check the wiki, his full name is John Marston Jr. Everyone calls him Jack so as to not mix him up with his dad, also Jack also used to be a nickname for people named John.
@@ninjaviking1999 you mean his ‘father’John. In jacks early years Arthur was more of a father to him and it is possible John isn’t his biological father. But, he did become a good ‘father’ to jack.
*LOUIS WILL REMEMBER THAT* CLEMENTINE WILL REMEMBER THAT *LEE WILL REMEMBER THAT* *KENNY WILL REMEMBER THAT* *VIOLET WILL REMEMBER THAT* *JAVIER WILL REMEMBER THAT* *AJ WILL REMEMBER THAT*
@@Pedro_Le_Chef Nobody knows how she died, they don't ever mention it. But this is one of the songs that wasn't written for RDR2, it's old af so don't read into it too much.
For the record this is a song they added way after the game came out. I just reloaded an old save and this immediately popped up when I came back to the ranch. You can really tell how much Rockstar loved this game by how much they continue to add all these seemingly unnecessary add ons for all the fans like me who love them.
Sorry to burst your bubble, but no... The events are random and there's a TON of stuff you probably missed already... This is the first song i heard abigail sing on my playthrough and it was around long before the game got an update like you mentioned... Still, it doesn't change the fact that Rockstar put their heart and soul into this AMAZING game
@@Pedro_Le_Chef yes they could, you major dork. One of the kids complaining John and Abigail no longer looks like GTA 3 characters on the PSP, are you?
Louis: oh my darling oh my darling Oh my daaaaarrrrrling clementine You are lost and gone forever Dreadful sorry clementine Light she was and like a fairy And he sshhhhoooooeeeessss were number 9 Lifting boxes without topses Sandals were for clementine
Louis: oh my darling oh my darling Oh my daaaaarrrrrling clementine You are lost and gone forever Dreadful sorry clementine Light she was and like a fairy And he sshhhhoooooeeeessss were number 9 Lifting boxes without topses Sandals were for clementine
Gotta love this comment section mixing red dead redemption characters with the walking dead characters xD. Both RDR2 and The walking Dead are my favorite games ❤
Oh m'darlin' oh m'darlin' Oh m'daaaaaaaaaarlin' what's her naaaaaaaaaame She is lost and gone ferever Ain't it juuuuuuuuuust a cryin' shaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaame
So after recovering from the ending of RDR2, this Jack and Abigail start doing this song and remind me of the ending for The Walking Dead. I know this song excised before TWD but I fist heard it in TWD. Why do games like to just bash our emotions like that?
I know the name of the girl of song changes depending on what location your at. I'm from the Pacific Islands and instead of Clementine her name is Valentine.
I kind of feel bad because I remember when I found this I started being an asshole to everyone for no reason. I got belligerently drunk and I even remember John starting to sing the song to himself.
JACK ABSOLUTELY KILLING IT ON THE HARMONICA GO ON SON
He really is
*louis is jealous.*
😂😂😂
Yess someone that's from the walking dead game
Pixel_Gacha Xoxo he be hitting on clementine
Im dead bro😂😂
Oh my god yes
I wish there was a hug button in this game. I just wanna hug people so bad.
This is such a sweet moment, I wish John would acknowledge it.
@PC WireLESs i have never heard of that.
It makes me wish they had a happy ending but.
@@FingerGamers3 a thing isn’t beautiful because it lasts
I wish I could buy things for Abigail and jack 😂
'Can I hold you button' like the "vet" lol
*Louis pulls out piano* 🎹
AJ will remember that.
Louie Smithen loud is bad
Louis?
Walking?
I miss the walking dead
THIS IS THE SONG JOHN SINGS WHEN HES 😵DRUNK
So what?
@@juustohoyla666 oi john
@@juustohoyla666 it is me Arthur I'm undercover
@@juustohoyla666 don't tell dutch I'm still alive
@@brainkiller7503 yes? Okey dokey.... Thanks for sacing mr bother
This is so adorable! Abigail has a nice soothing singing voice. 😊
I like your picture
Abigail has the voice of an angel, she could easily lullaby you to sleep with that soothing voice of hers
ASMR
Yeah
...I should be spending more time back at the ranch, shouldn't I.. I didn't even know this is in the game.
Duckkis maybe you should meet clem in her dimension
G a y z o n e
Mr. Brooks, sounds like something you live in.
[BHB] Codename-V-DAWG no I’m stuck in the G a y s o n e help mr
@@mr.brooks8913 take my hand brooo
I like the coyotes in the background
Jack rocking that harmonica and I bet Clem would be proud
And Louis
The walking dead is fire
im just here looking for comments like these
it's so good to see them
@@gsomslayer twdg and rdr will always be my favs :]
@@hammywoods can't comment for rdr, but telltale's twd, abso-freaking-lutely
(?) Clementine won’t forget that
could you send me you display picture plsssss
@@ragadalk353 ❤?
So this explains why John randomly sings Clementine when riding in the wilderness, hunting or swiftly walking through the Ranch...
He sings it also when he drunk)
Everyone abrigails voice is so adorable JACK IS KILLING IT ON THE HARMONICA
as a lover of telltale’s TWD and RDR2 i’m very proud to see the Louis comments here.
💝
i feel the exact same way
Same 😂😂😂
Never liked Louis myself. My Clementine rejected him. My Clem doesn't have time for love.
Same
She can't read but goddamit she knows how to sing
Also learns to play the piano.
Or cook
reading and speaking are two very different things
Haha I bet that statement was said a lot back in the day.
@@freethinker3716 i'm sure of that haha
i like this version of the song, less creepy, yet sadder than the usual versions. Also, Abigail's voice is very soothing, perfect for campfire singing sessions
**L o u i s w i l l r e m e m b e r t h a t**
Mah boah ARTUR do you have da MONEH
@@Greyyguy28374 You had a plan
@@professor7683 I still do have a plan you just need some GODAMN FAITH
Damn Abigail has an amazing voice and John Marston JR. slays on that harmonica.
Jack. He's name is Jack
@@panoskamp4324 Check the wiki, his full name is John Marston Jr.
Everyone calls him Jack so as to not mix him up with his dad, also Jack also used to be a nickname for people named John.
@@ninjaviking1999 oh sorry then
@@ninjaviking1999 you mean his ‘father’John. In jacks early years Arthur was more of a father to him and it is possible John isn’t his biological father. But, he did become a good ‘father’ to jack.
@@panoskamp4324 There are even a dialogue in RDR1 where Jack said "My name is John Marston...Jr"
*LOUIS WILL REMEMBER THAT*
CLEMENTINE WILL REMEMBER THAT
*LEE WILL REMEMBER THAT*
*KENNY WILL REMEMBER THAT*
*VIOLET WILL REMEMBER THAT*
*JAVIER WILL REMEMBER THAT*
*AJ WILL REMEMBER THAT*
John sings this song when he gets drunk. Which I thought was sweet since it must be one of Abigail's favorite songs.
almost 4 years and I just discovered this wholesome moment on my millionth playthrough
I love hearing Javier play it on his guitar
Yes, Javier plays it beautifully
Abigail has such a sweet voice.
Louis: Hold chairless
Its chairles
Jacks got lungs of steel
RIP Abigail 🙏
Louis will remember that
Stolen
Stop copy
Funny how Javier used to play this song on his guitar during the "Arthur" times.
I heard Arthur whistling it in chapter 2 and I couldn’t believe my eyes
"I miss Lee.."
That dig at John at the end tho
my little red dead headcanon is that the marston daughter's name is clementine and drowned when she was young since john cant swim :(
There’s so many different versions of th8s song ugh
Even almost every country in this world had their own version of this song just like twinkle and happy birthday
I know lol
I literally did a slow look around when she was singing like, "this is a nice life."
Thank you for uploading this video Fay. I watch this everyday it brings me back too a much happier place than now
@@danielfilho7920 I'm very glad it helps. ❤❤❤
My favorite scene in rd2!
everytime i hear Abigail singing i want to make her know how good she sings, but John always goes like "Hello" and thats all aljfksjd
The epilogue is beautiful
I discovered this today , and i love It! Such a sweet voice and excellent song , RDR2 keeps impressing me :D
I'm going to take a guess and say they would've went for Clementine for their daughters name. 💔 John sings it too, whilst drunk.
John mentions a daughter that died young in the first game.
Well if you see on wiki it says that they had a daughter in the middle of events of rdr2 and rdr1
@@TheJotaroKujo Is that how John's daughter died ? By drowning? Jesus, the Marston water curse spares nobody.
@@Pedro_Le_Chef Why do you write this comment everywhere? 🗿
@@Pedro_Le_Chef Nobody knows how she died, they don't ever mention it. But this is one of the songs that wasn't written for RDR2, it's old af so don't read into it too much.
*Clementine will remember that*
Wow Cali Elizabeth Moore has a great singing voice
i sing this song whenever playing TWD
For the record this is a song they added way after the game came out. I just reloaded an old save and this immediately popped up when I came back to the ranch. You can really tell how much Rockstar loved this game by how much they continue to add all these seemingly unnecessary add ons for all the fans like me who love them.
Sorry to burst your bubble, but no... The events are random and there's a TON of stuff you probably missed already...
This is the first song i heard abigail sing on my playthrough and it was around long before the game got an update like you mentioned...
Still, it doesn't change the fact that Rockstar put their heart and soul into this AMAZING game
I
The song was already in the game. And for all the détail rockstar put in rdr2, they couldnt get their most iconic character to look right.
@@Pedro_Le_Chef somebody sounds grumpy and opinionated
@@Pedro_Le_Chef yes they could, you major dork. One of the kids complaining John and Abigail no longer looks like GTA 3 characters on the PSP, are you?
I loved it when Javier would play this song on his guitar! Finally someone singing it!!
Me too! Whenever he'd play it, I'd just stand and listen ❤
Oddly appropriate how they sing it to John who, like the miner, also can't swim as if to call him out on it.
Can’t beat louis’ rendition
I beats it by a mile
Been playing this on my harmonica since forever but i was today years old when i found out it was ahout a dead girl.
Louis will remember this.
i remember the song differently
There are multiple versions
Or they changed it to fit 1907
Makes sense
Louis: oh my darling oh my darling
Oh my daaaaarrrrrling clementine
You are lost and gone forever
Dreadful sorry clementine
Light she was and like a fairy
And he sshhhhoooooeeeessss were number 9
Lifting boxes without topses
Sandals were for clementine
Louis: oh my darling oh my darling
Oh my daaaaarrrrrling clementine
You are lost and gone forever
Dreadful sorry clementine
Light she was and like a fairy
And he sshhhhoooooeeeessss were number 9
Lifting boxes without topses
Sandals were for clementine
Jack has the lungs of a god
He learned to take care of his lungs after seeing what happened to Arthur
I literally just found this interaction for the first time ❤. This game is just... eternal
This song is very beautiful
And very sad. Just like the game.
The peaceful and beautiful times before that damn Agent Ross and those damn Pinkertons!
Gotta love this comment section mixing red dead redemption characters with the walking dead characters xD. Both RDR2 and The walking Dead are my favorite games ❤
Flawless.
Good one Arthur...
The Walking Dead 😢
🥺♥️
This isn't a walking dead reference
@@voicelessglottalfricative6567 Dude, its is. Look after. Or find it on the search "Oh my darling clementine".
Good lord she’s gorgeous 😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍
Your going to the G a y Z o n e
@@mr.brooks8913 show us your sauce boah
ua-cam.com/video/izk4cQ6H2l8/v-deo.html show us yours
Its 5am i cant sleep and im vibing
One amazing game recognizes another good game
Abigail's western accent (I don't know what other way to describe it) is just perfect.
The Walking Dead reference
you did it Arthur, this is all thanks to you
once I was in Butcher Creek with Arthur, and an npc whistled this tune
Leeennyyyyy!
Ups sorry. Wrong place.
Louis has competition
2:08 Uncle in the background lol
She can also be found in the earlier chapters humming to the camp songs that are sung during the camp parties
When Ms downed is like go boy
Today I learned that both John and Abigail sing this, I’ve only ever known about the Butchers at Strawberry and Valentine who whistle it
*[Louis will remember that]*
lee will remember that
Jack is talented
Nah this is for The Walking Dead game
this Song makes me so God dammed sad. atleast clementine got to live forever in atleast one way
My phone display has been broken on this
Wait, but this music was repaired my display
The walking dead vibes
Louis like that :D
Oh m'darlin' oh m'darlin'
Oh m'daaaaaaaaaarlin' what's her naaaaaaaaaame
She is lost and gone ferever
Ain't it juuuuuuuuuust a cryin' shaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaame
I liked it when Abby sang.
It reminded me if my Mom when she would sing.
JACK WITH THE HARMONICA
Clementwine
So after recovering from the ending of RDR2, this Jack and Abigail start doing this song and remind me of the ending for The Walking Dead. I know this song excised before TWD but I fist heard it in TWD. Why do games like to just bash our emotions like that?
Poor Louis
Those coyotes needs to shut up or it's the butchers table for them
Abigail messes up some of the words
Right it’s a game. They just wanted to switch it up
no she's singing a different version
I know the name of the girl of song changes depending on what location your at. I'm from the Pacific Islands and instead of Clementine her name is Valentine.
Maravilhoso.
Everything is sweet until you remember that John and Abigail had a daughter who died shortly after birth.
Louis 😂
"ugh... Stop. Now..." xD
I kind of feel bad because I remember when I found this I started being an asshole to everyone for no reason. I got belligerently drunk and I even remember John starting to sing the song to himself.
This is the song John sings when he's drunk😂😂
There is a famous malayalam funeral song based on the tune of this song
I just went through this and I got John drunk and went back to Abigail, he started drunkenly singing it back to her lol it was cute
Abigail and Louis collab
I'm here after Outlander. (Also played RDR2)
The walking dead oynadıysan ayrıca anlamlı bir şarkı
Ah yes, rdr2 undead nightmare
Its Walking Dead Reference
I’m surprised, she’s pretty good at singing
Rad profile pic dude 🤙🤙