Piper and Phoebe's Mom Tells Them about Paige

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 12 вер 2024
  • Piper and Phoebe learn they have another sister -- Paige. #charmed | Where to watch: para.mt/Charmed

КОМЕНТАРІ • 127

  • @sweetcupcake408
    @sweetcupcake408 20 днів тому +246

    Cole is not wrong though, the apples didn’t fall too far from the tree. Piper and her mother fell in love with their Whitelighters. Also, Phoebe and Grams fell in love with demons from the show.

    • @Maatjuhhh
      @Maatjuhhh 20 днів тому +16

      When Cole made that comment, I really laughed out for loud. Also, only Prue and Paige would date mortals. At the earliest, I really believed that Piper out of the three, would be the one to marry a mortal.

    • @seanbraley2772
      @seanbraley2772 18 днів тому +1

      Slight difference Cole is a half demon not a full it was his human half she feel in love with sense his demon half was basically Farrell

    • @h_4victory293
      @h_4victory293 16 днів тому +5

      Honestly, I loved Cole in this scene. IMO, he was both hilarious and accurate.

    • @blacsiren7903
      @blacsiren7903 16 днів тому +1

      Facts 😂😂😂😂

    • @jessegalvan7892
      @jessegalvan7892 13 днів тому +1

      So true! And prue dying young like Patty did 😭

  • @tyresmith9833
    @tyresmith9833 20 днів тому +175

    Season 4 was one of the last great seasons of Charmed. The fallout from Prue’s death, Paige’s introduction, Piper and Phoebe struggling to get over Prue and accepting Paige. All of it was amazing.

    • @JET1970
      @JET1970 20 днів тому

      It was Oupper struggling to accept Paige after Prues death

    • @COSMICCFREQUENCY144
      @COSMICCFREQUENCY144 20 днів тому +14

      The second half is my favorite season. Phoebe becoming the queen of all evil. The seer tricking them all into getting her way. Dealing with Prue death and real life progression of grief, Paige finding her way and her back story. Cole dealing with losing his powers and the emptiness that came along with that, again the reintroduction of the seer and her importance to season 4 tends to get unnoticed, her getting Phoebe impregnated with her and the sources energy. Just amazing TV

    • @aaliyahlovato
      @aaliyahlovato 20 днів тому +9

      5-8 are good seasons too, they have great moments in them. Some of the best episodes in the series come from those respective seasons.

    • @juanluna2241
      @juanluna2241 20 днів тому +6

      The last excellent and dark season

    • @stephaniwelch5118
      @stephaniwelch5118 20 днів тому +3

      What made Season 4 great to me was they made it a very real and natural progression in terms of how grief and acceptance of a new family member works. They paid proper respect to Prue and her memory and also didn't just make it so Paige's introduction and inclusion were rushed and smooth. All 3 of them struggled with the reconstitution of the Charmed Ones and their new roles in that with the dynamics and as sisters. Piper took a while to forge a relationship with Paige but once they did, you saw the strength of their bond where when Cole turned evil they were the ones with the closer relationship.

  • @ifericonlyknew
    @ifericonlyknew 20 днів тому +107

    The previous lore from S2, made the reveal of Paige as a sister so believable - 💡they got lucky with that. I also loved Piper’s sass when summoning Grams. Cole’s comments etc. Love this scene!

    • @noecases5940
      @noecases5940 20 днів тому +2

      Cuándo dicen eso?

    • @jujub4553
      @jujub4553 20 днів тому +16

      @@noecases5940the previous storyline in the camping episode where they revealed how Patty died. They revealed she had an affair with her white lighter Sam. So charmed show got lucky when one sister died, they just made it like Sam and Patty had a secret baby the whole time which turned out to be Paige

    • @COSMICCFREQUENCY144
      @COSMICCFREQUENCY144 20 днів тому +11

      Right haha. I think about that often, I took a screenwriting class in college and my professor said this is why writers should always introduce loop/plotholes that can possibly be used later on in the series if the series even makes It that far. This plot twist would’ve felt so random if It weren’t for the s2 reveal about Sam and Patty

    • @ifericonlyknew
      @ifericonlyknew 20 днів тому +2

      @@COSMICCFREQUENCY144 Right! it would’ve came so left field, and felt like a stretch. it they tried to introduce all that lore this season. The way it played out was great made it very plausible. that Patty & Sam could’ve had a child thanks to that S2 plot line.

    • @ingaispence9347
      @ingaispence9347 20 днів тому

      I guess they have another baby sister and baby brother from the vampire... Patience and Patrick..😂

  • @tessax
    @tessax 20 днів тому +50

    This season was really juicy, the family secret, Prue’s death, Paige’s intro and killing the source.

  • @aaliyahlovato
    @aaliyahlovato 20 днів тому +46

    This show made a great move, by adding My girl Paige Matthews to the mix. I love how they tied in Patty and Sam’s relationship from Season 2 - it's amazing how well it all fits together! 😮‍💨☺️

    • @PittsburghSportsFan43
      @PittsburghSportsFan43 17 днів тому +2

      I think they wrote that in when things were heating up between Shannen and Alyssa behind the scenes. They figured one would have to be replaced eventually, and they would need another sister to continue the show.

  • @alexandroskarvounis
    @alexandroskarvounis 12 днів тому +7

    The moment the sisters discover Paige is such a powerful turning point in Charmed. It’s not just about adding a new sister but redefining the entire family dynamic after losing Prue

  • @bwtawny
    @bwtawny 17 днів тому +15

    I really liked Cole. Wished it could have worked out f or them. The actor playing was so hot.

  • @RobertLydonReviews
    @RobertLydonReviews 17 днів тому +15

    Why is Piper’s reading of the spell hilarious? It’s totally in character but it got me to chuckle

  • @petewong2372
    @petewong2372 14 днів тому +14

    Piper can’t accept it because no one can replace Prue

  • @xengar
    @xengar 20 днів тому +67

    Holly is giving such a great performance here. Piper's trying to process but is still in mourning, looking like she might leave the room at any moment.

    • @BrianLloyd1991
      @BrianLloyd1991 20 днів тому

      Well tbf she wanted to leave the show after shannon was forced to but holly was blackmailed to stay

    • @desupair
      @desupair 20 днів тому +3

      Being blackmailed to stay and being forced to work with the person who got your bestfriend fired could draw out such raw performance

    • @COSMICCFREQUENCY144
      @COSMICCFREQUENCY144 20 днів тому +3

      @brianlloyd1991 she wasn’t blackmailed. She was in a CONTRACT with the production company. Is this something else you all have made up? Has Holly ever said that? Blackmail is a very strong accusation

    • @BrianLloyd1991
      @BrianLloyd1991 20 днів тому +1

      @@COSMICCFREQUENCY144 im sure she said that in the podcast with shannen where they fully explained it

    • @Digimonisbetterthanpokemon
      @Digimonisbetterthanpokemon 18 днів тому +3

      ​@@COSMICCFREQUENCY144 she said it on the House of Halliwell podcast. If she left the studio was going to sue her for their losses no matter where she went. So yes she was under contract and yes she was blackmailed into staying.

  • @GHSanteFan
    @GHSanteFan 20 днів тому +31

    Finola Hughes is stunning.

  • @Gor85
    @Gor85 20 днів тому +18

    This is so touching scene. Grams and Patty revelation of Paige,Phoebe and Piper reaction,Cole's comments. Great scene! 😀I can imagine how difficult it was for Grams,Patty and Sam. They had no choice. Piper was just 6,and Phoebe was a toddler so they didn't notice. So sweet scene

  • @googoomoomooxD
    @googoomoomooxD 20 днів тому +38

    The way Piper incites the spell always has me.

  • @kimmyray018
    @kimmyray018 17 днів тому +8

    Piper and Phoebe look so much like their mother and grandmother ❤

  • @SachielSkandia
    @SachielSkandia 20 днів тому +38

    I was always bothered by Patty and Penny's attitude towards this situation, it was like "yes Prue died but hey guess what, you have a lost sister, so don't cry or get angry over Prue's death"!!!

    • @DAWNNEON
      @DAWNNEON 20 днів тому +3

      Don’t get
      Me started, the emergence of Paige will always be why this show jumped shark and became corny.

    • @aaliyahlovato
      @aaliyahlovato 20 днів тому +7

      @@DAWNNEONWell how else were they suppose to carry on with the PO3? With Paige coming from pre-established lore from S2. It maintained the essential narrative of the power of three. staying true to the core concept of the show. Judging by it continuing on for 4 more seasons, I’d say it worked out well.

    • @DAWNNEON
      @DAWNNEON 20 днів тому +5

      @@aaliyahlovato it actually didn’t workout well because the actual concept of the show was based around the power of 3, not 4 just Incase one dies. A lot of you act like this wasn’t just written by a writer in actuality the girls would have never gotten over prue so quickly and they’d also be able to summon her like grams and their mom. Skip to the last episode where it shows all of the family members and nothing of prue. They all lived happily ever after right? Give me a break. It worked out well for the fans who started watching the show in syndication. I love rose but her acting never put me back in the show they even chose the wrong actress, they coulda also came up with a better storyline to reconstitute the power of 3 without Shannon but still keeping her with another actress. They totally missed the mark.

    • @aaliyahlovato
      @aaliyahlovato 20 днів тому +1

      @@DAWNNEON Like I said it still worked, because in this case one did die. & they needed to be reconstituted. Judging by how much was going on in the background, with the source looming etc. they were lucky to have gotten the amount of time they did to mourn Prue & it was done respectfully. They tried recasting Prue with Tiffani Amber Thiessen & Jennifer Love Hewitt. Which flopped (thankfully) because they turned it down. Also, you can’t sit here and tell me you would’ve continued to watch the show. with a different actress playing Prue, they would’ve criticized her into oblivion & been #NotMyPrue to death. Because in a lot of peoples eyes Shannen is Prue. they went with the better option of bringing in a new sister. Rose was chosen perfectly and was a great addition to the show, people can talk about her acting. but she played Paige just like how she was suppose too. Rose is Paige, nobody could’ve done it better than her. Paige fit into the Halliwell family like a missing puzzle piece. & cemented herself as a huge part of Charmed’s legacy! So they stuck the landing.

    • @DAWNNEON
      @DAWNNEON 20 днів тому +1

      @@aaliyahlovato I most likely would have NOT watched the show if another actress was cast as prue and she was re-instated that’s not what I said.
      Shannon is the only option for me. I’m just saying that would have been a better concept …TO ME. The idea of their being another sister is just LAZY writing. so dead that immediately.

  • @brettteply1207
    @brettteply1207 16 днів тому +10

    Cole had a point. Apples 🍎 don’t fall far from the tree. Now I know where Piper got her Whitelighter attraction from

  • @juanluna2241
    @juanluna2241 20 днів тому +31

    RIP Shannen Doherty 😢😢😢😢😢

  • @Kamo766
    @Kamo766 20 днів тому +24

    Their Baby little sister 🍼 Paige❤

    • @TheBandit025Nova
      @TheBandit025Nova 8 днів тому +2

      Actually if anyone gets call Paige the baby sister title it’s Prue

  • @sifilore9462
    @sifilore9462 20 днів тому +31

    1st here. Forceful way to summon a spirit. Hope we get the clip of Paige tries her telekinetic orbing for the 1st time on a church candle. That scene surpised all of Charmed fans.

  • @vaggos013
    @vaggos013 14 днів тому +10

    I hate those first episodes of the 4th season. They all try to make the audience forget Prue, except from Piper. Especially Alyssa Milano as Phoebe... I believe she did her best to put Prue (Doherty) in oblivion. Her satisfuction is obvious even through her acting. A normal family would not react like this in a loss. Only Piper remembers Prue for 3 episodes.

  • @manuela1102
    @manuela1102 13 днів тому +2

    Apples dont fall far from the forbidden tree had me dying.

  • @helenivanic1628
    @helenivanic1628 3 дні тому +1

    Cole: here I thought my family were screwed up 😂

  • @jessedellross3245
    @jessedellross3245 20 днів тому +23

    It didn’t make sense why the girls didn’t know their mom was pregnant. I can understand pheobe not knowing as she’s the youngest but piper? She was already a kid and should’ve known

    • @sw9618
      @sw9618 20 днів тому +19

      Piper was around 6? Patty could’ve just said she got fat. I’m sure little Piper didn’t really care or pay attention with Prue and Phoebe driving her crazy.

    • @jujub4553
      @jujub4553 20 днів тому +17

      Patty says it in this clip “you all just thought mommy got a little fat”, and I’m sure Penny and Patty probably did their best to hide her pregnancy since it was so forbidden with extra baggy clothes etc

    • @sweetcupcake408
      @sweetcupcake408 20 днів тому +8

      @@jessedellross3245 also, Patty was trying to hide her pregnancy secret from everyone. Remember, Patty and Sam had a forbidden romance where the Elders could be eavesdropping on their lives too.

    • @COSMICCFREQUENCY144
      @COSMICCFREQUENCY144 20 днів тому +14

      Do you have concrete memories being 6 ? Lol I mean you might remember some things but very rarely do kids remember their mother being pregnant. The human mind is very fickle and like a pandora box, we tend to only remember joyus memories or hold onto very painful ones. Not details of someone else’s journey.

    • @rickyspanish2337
      @rickyspanish2337 20 днів тому

      ​@COSMICCFREQUENCY144 what about prue?? If piper were 6 prue would've been 8, she would've know by that age

  • @shanware2
    @shanware2 15 днів тому +2

    I know they killed pru off but it always irked me how the always summoned grams and their mom n not pru

  • @user-ux6ko7jo2r
    @user-ux6ko7jo2r 10 днів тому +2

    I like when Piper & Phoebe ask grams why the source thinks the charmed 1's can be reconstituted & Patty tells Piper & Phoebe that they never told anyone cuz patty was sacred that if the elders found out that sam had a child with patty the elders would take away the sister's powers forever & you can definitely tell that how painful it was for patty tell her daughters that she had to give up her own daughter & patty told Piper & Phoebe that Paige is their sister & Paige gets her powers & she helps her new sisters cast a spell to kill shax for good & I'm glad Piper Phoebe & Paige avenge Prue's death in charmed season 4

  • @Pinkranger87
    @Pinkranger87 11 днів тому +1

    I always wondered if Prue knew about Paige

  • @troyvo8069
    @troyvo8069 20 днів тому +7

    Remember when Phoebe needed the power of 3 to use this spell during jury duty? lol

    • @tidus1ph
      @tidus1ph 20 днів тому +3

      The fact that Piper just got a power upgrade. Her power alone is enough to cast this level of spell.

    • @troyvo8069
      @troyvo8069 20 днів тому

      @@tidus1ph I believe their power that they pull behind their spells are always the same, the power of 3. Their active powers are the one the grows. Phoebe got her second power in season 3 as well.

    • @varric
      @varric 19 днів тому

      @@tidus1ph Remember when Piper blasted that door to save a kid? The same door that literally no-sell the Power of 3?

    • @EuroMIX2
      @EuroMIX2 17 днів тому

      I think, other than just gradually getting stronger, they're also performing a spell in their home (which is a spiritual nexus) and summoning a family spirit that they'd likely have a stronger connection to.
      Phoebe might need the full power of 3, at that time, because she lacked all those factors.
      The sisters are at their strongest all together in the house.

  • @RaY-db7sm
    @RaY-db7sm 14 днів тому +3

    0:10 0:11 0:32 0:38 0:39 0:42 0:45 0:47 3:22 3:24 3:26 3:27 3:29 3:30 🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂

  • @brettteply1207
    @brettteply1207 16 днів тому +1

    When Patty said “decided”, she meant “had too”

  • @aa.r2588
    @aa.r2588 18 днів тому +1

    It's amazing Prue didn't get summoned after her death

  • @Digimonisbetterthanpokemon
    @Digimonisbetterthanpokemon 21 годину тому

    2:31
    Patty: "And that's why we had to"
    * looks at her mom *
    "Why we *decided* to give her up for adoption"
    Grams: "*yes*"
    Grams being shady af right there.

  • @MateusChristopher
    @MateusChristopher 16 днів тому +1

    Did patty also bind Paige's powers? I thought the book was necessary to release the binding spell...

  • @CoffeenSpice
    @CoffeenSpice 20 днів тому +3

    They didn't need the candles on? 🤣

    • @aaliyahlovato
      @aaliyahlovato 19 днів тому +1

      @@CoffeenSpice Piper was so heated she said to hell with it. 😂

  • @SeanKraeling
    @SeanKraeling 17 днів тому +2

    Sean kraeling future prayer requests 🙏 ❤

  • @Iamfreetobeme24
    @Iamfreetobeme24 12 днів тому +2

    Imagine if the original Phoebe actress hadnt quit. Prue wouldn't have died and Paige wouldn't have existed. I wonder if the storyline involving their mum and her whitelighter would have been a thing. If it wouldn't have, then could they have explained the elders' decision to allow Leo and Piper to be together? I guess it could still be a 'reward' or a thank you for all of their selfless work to save countless innocents

  • @jenniferromero571
    @jenniferromero571 17 днів тому +1

    Cole tried so hard to be good. He was perfect for her. Just not strong enough.

  • @bekenotsalony2905
    @bekenotsalony2905 20 днів тому +13

    See this always messed with me, because Gram's is like, it was unthinkable before Piper/Leo. But when Paige goes back to the 60/70's and meets Leo as a younger white lighter and Grams in her 20's Leo hits on and tries to sleep with her... so he was being a f*ck boi back then and sleeping with witches... so if it's so unthinkable... how was he ever allowed to stay a white lighter?

    • @trent_king
      @trent_king 20 днів тому +3

      Alternate timeline.
      That 60s episode grams was like 20yrs old but when they went back to the 70s, she was past 50 with an adult daughter and two grandkids 😂

    • @ImpossibleCaseEdits
      @ImpossibleCaseEdits 20 днів тому +1

      We don't talk about that episode. 😆

    • @bekenotsalony2905
      @bekenotsalony2905 20 днів тому +1

      @@trent_king Here's the shocker, Prue was born 3 years after Paige's visit in 1967 (had to go look up the year) Their mom was born in the 1950's, Grams vanquished the Necromancer in the 1950's. -pinches the bridge of his nose- The more you try to hold onto this timeline the more it unravels. The fun of continuity errors.
      (so she met Allen, had Patty, got seduced by the Necromancer, banished him, became a hippie, lost allen, and 3 years later her mother and aunt both die, Prue is her aunt's reincarnation, 3 more years later her mom reincarnates as Piper, and 2 years later her cursed aunt reincarnates as Pheobe...) Busy time frame.
      They really should have had someone who worked as their continuity department...

    • @bekenotsalony2905
      @bekenotsalony2905 20 днів тому

      @@ImpossibleCaseEdits Yeah I get why. I mean... I find F-Boi Leo fun and all but I mean the time lines make no sense for that era. In 1967, Patty was 17, and was sent to spend time with Prue's past life to not be there, and poor Allen's life that 17 years. He meets Penny, they get married, she has Patty, then cheats on him with the Necromancer, then goes BACk to Allen only for him to die when they became Hippies in 1967, and 3 years later Grams has lost her husband, her mom, her aunt, and has her first grand daughter Prue is born. Busy time frame.

    • @anyname13579
      @anyname13579 20 днів тому +1

      The time line is all wonky because originally it was meant to be their mom in that episode, not grams. I don't remember why they had to change it. I think it's because Finola Hughes wasn't available to film at the time.

  • @ziweiho7614
    @ziweiho7614 20 днів тому +1

    If there is one thing that never made sense to me here, it would be how Penny and Patty were afraid of how all four sisters would be denied their powers if Paige’s existence was revealed. I mean, Penny is supposed to be the formidable witch who not only survived the death of her husband (and later on, her beloved daughter) and all those failed marriages and engagements, but also created all those fabulous potions and spells in the legendary Book of Shadows. Patty is also a powerful and knowledgeable witch who had contributed her fair share to the Book. And they were afraid of what those so-called Powers That Be would do if Paige’s existence was revealed? 🤔

    • @shayla106
      @shayla106 20 днів тому

      Yes, they are not the charmed ones.

  • @AnitaFirmini
    @AnitaFirmini 20 днів тому +5

    ❤❤❤❤❤❤

  • @ShinyAntics
    @ShinyAntics 20 днів тому +3

    These new magic white orb effects are really bad, unfortunately. Whoever remastered this series needed better feedback.

  • @Digimonisbetterthanpokemon
    @Digimonisbetterthanpokemon 16 днів тому +2

    "You were both toddlers, you thought mommy got a little fat."
    So what did Prue think?

    • @caesilver4947
      @caesilver4947 16 днів тому +2

      I always thought the same..she was like 7 😅

    • @Digimonisbetterthanpokemon
      @Digimonisbetterthanpokemon 21 годину тому

      ​@@caesilver4947 Grams did more of that memory wiping she does. Grams is real shady when she wants to be.

  • @jarlairess
    @jarlairess 18 днів тому +1

    Ok from what I know that he's right he _can_ search the premises but he can't walk in there without informing them. Don't they need to be _served_ with that warrant _before_ they go ahead with the search?

    • @uhejnjd
      @uhejnjd 18 днів тому

      Ehhhh no because think about it, if you just skip town, and suddenly they can't get access to anything of yours without basically permission.

  • @user-hs8ze3md7c
    @user-hs8ze3md7c 18 днів тому +1

    A secret in the family not good🤫😕

  • @yoni5570
    @yoni5570 20 днів тому +7

    Five seasons of what could have been great art completely ruined by Shannon and Alyssa having problems.

  • @LadyRose2023
    @LadyRose2023 18 днів тому +1

    I never liked this part.. I liked Paige coming into the story, but not the reasons she was given up.. so let them not have 'birth right.. ' or find a way to get it,, but not give up a child..

  • @tysonanderson7232
    @tysonanderson7232 20 днів тому +7

    Season 4-8 WAS Da BEST Seasons OF MY Life Tho, & Da Sexy Rose McGowan & SIP 2 Da Beautiful Shannen Doherty!!!

  • @RanselCruz
    @RanselCruz 11 днів тому +1

    I love this series but i not fan of reboot

  • @sofakulit6670
    @sofakulit6670 20 днів тому +2

    The acting was bad

  • @wicca_high_priestess
    @wicca_high_priestess 20 днів тому +2

    Hi there... Ever witnessed real Salem spells? 🧙‍♀🪄❤💕🔓✨

    • @Gor85
      @Gor85 20 днів тому

      No

    • @wicca_high_priestess
      @wicca_high_priestess 20 днів тому

      @@Gor85 I do white magic only🙂 live on tiktok

    • @jacquiepittet1757
      @jacquiepittet1757 17 днів тому

      Salem magic spells were folk magic. In and of them selves harmless. Discovery of their use provoked mass hysteria which was very harmful.