The one positive to come out of this terrible, evil video: It confirms what we already knew, that Fluttershy is secretly the toughest and bravest of them all.
Well, that and the animation is good for something fan-made and the rendition of the song is nice. But other than those, yeah, Smile HD is atrocious. And the three positives named are not enough to redeem it in the slightest. So I give it -50 stars, maybe -500. It's that bad.
Congrats Shy Guy for you have unfortunately witnessed the animation that completely ruined the Smile song for literally anyone and everyone who's ever listened to it. I mean nothing against the animator of the video they did good work but i'm sure even they realize that they completely ruined that wholesome song with that animation.
@@UrFavShyGuycongratulations you have gone through the rite of passage of being traumatized by Smile HD that every up-and-coming brony has to go through
Personally, this video has never ruined my enjoyment of pinkie pie or the smile song. Yeah, it's gory and gross, but I guess my head separates the two from the show itself. I was also older when I saw this, and I definitely feel bad for the kids who saw this back then.
Totally agree And it's easy imo to mske the separation becsuse there's no story, anything relative to eve ts from the show It's like goku vs saitama animations for exemple, but made only to be gore
Yeah I was like 8-11 (forgot exactly which age) when I saw it and it scarred me mentally. Especially cause people were sending it to each other *and* kids on the internet to trick them
I saw it when I was younger, but i'm a lucky fuck because i've always loved horror and turning cute things creepy and scary. I like mlp, i like horror and gore, this video was a *GEM* to me!!!
Watching Smile HD and/or Cupcakes HD is a rite of passage of sorts for all fans of this show to go through at one point. If that doesn't scare you away, nothing will.
Well you can't say you weren't warned. You chose to watch despite what people told you about it. There's a whole grimdark side of the fandom if you want to go looking for it. Cupcakes is probably the most infamous, but quality wise it's pretty terrible. Rainbow Factory and its sequel Pegasus Device on the other hand are very well written, but can be even more disturbing to read than Smile HD was to watch. There's some good songs about them though. There's also Fallout Equestria. The story itself isn't grimdark per se, but it certainly has grimdark elements. It is an absolutely fantastic read, though, and it got popular enough to sprout its own subfandom!
I can attest to Fallout Equestria. despite not being the biggest fan of grimdark pony stuff (I even avoided Friendship is witchcraft for the longest time thinking it was grimdark) I actually ended up loving FoE. it helps that it the violence thats there isn't glorified, or exploitative. there is weight and pathos behind it. also, its mostly OCs (original characters). the mane 6 only being seen in the backstory, and even when known characters are seen, they stay in character (with one exception). the story overall has the same moral foundation and values as the show, and works also most like a condensed version of the show, just in a more mature setting. Fun fact, the song for rainbow factory came first, then a fic was written based on it. the trio of songs, "Rainbow Factory", "Awoken", and "Pegasus Device" are all really good and tell an interesting story.
@@lissienicole7355 I was more referring to the fic, but Cupcakes HD (also by Mr. Davey) was quite well made if gory and disturbing. And the song is quite catchy, I believe it was Ready to Die by Andrew W.K.
ok, time to propose some wholsome/cute MLP animations to make up for this one: - your little pets / your little cats (both by Forgalorga) - Pony Girl, (all versions are good but something tells me that you might like Fluttershy version) - My tiny pony
Shy Guy: "Oh, it's not so bad! ;) " Also Shy Guy a second later: [surprised Pikachu face] :D Yeah, welcome to the dark side of the fandom, and don't say we didn't warn you ;J BTW the volume of your voice is finally good :>
Welcome, now u have a wider and deeper knowledge of the fandom and it's parts, congrats. Anyway, it's just a fan animation, so don't take things seriously. Or do, it's up to you. *Smile*
If it makes you feel better, i was dressed up as pinkie pie for halloween when i was like eight, and our neighbor WHO WAS A GROWN ASS MAN came over and show me this "cute video of pinkie pie that youll love" since she was my favorite of all time. Fucking traumatized. Literally shaking while watching this knowing its not as bad as it was back then but STILL. I HAD OVER SIX PLUSHIES OF PINKIE PIE THAT I WOULD SLEEP WITH EVERYNIGHT, I HAD A JACKET OF HER AND SHIRTS AND HAD HER AS A BIRTHDAY CAKE, LIKE I WAS OBSESSED WITH HER SHE COMFORTED ME THROUGH SO MUCH AND BRO WAS LIKE AS YES LITTLE CHILD LEMME SHOW YOU THIS CUTE VIDEO. DUDE THATS FUCKED UP
I'm pretty sure it was smile hd but I think he showed me cupcakes too, and rainbow was my second favorite at the time (still is, Applejack's my fav now like a decade later). It was fucked
Oh... Yes... The darker side of MLP, well at least you did watch it, otherwise people would keep saying that you should watch it. Now... Would you watch more like these types of videos regarding that dark side of MLP? Alright, let's give some more wholesome MLP videos! Like Friendship is Musical by Tridashie!
most famous line "oh this not so bad why you guys make it seem so bad" and that loving smile turns to WTF of horror welcome to the fandom the gates are now locked enjoy your stay.. he first time I saw this (only time other then reactions) I looped and watched the original song for almost 10 hours strait to clear my mind and stop hating pinkie so much. sadly the fandom is fucked up when it wants to be if you ever want nightmares and avoid sleeping ever again check out the stories cupcakes and rainbow factory and then look at "grimdark" art. so yeah next time we warn ya bro I'd take the advice we've seen shit you (literally now cant) unsee
Smile HD is essentially the fandom's sick and twisted sense of humor manifesting as the means to troll new fans by leading them blindly into something completely out of left field.
ForgaLogra and AgrolChannel does pretty good mute animations. Taking place post season 4 and beyond, with the ones from the past few years being post season 9.
I remember being traumatized by Smile HD very early into my journey with this fandom. I found it by accident when I was watching pony videos in my room in the middle of the night. I had no warnings. 😣😵
'Least the remix is awesome. I mean, I like the whole thing but it is mostly just violence for it's own sake, which has a very limited time and place. If you want something similar, CupcakesHD is (in my opinion) the best version of the Cupcakes 'story'. If you want the polar opposite tonally I'd go with practically anything by ForgaLorga, Agrol, or Tridashie.
yeah its definitely an interesting fan animation i think i first watched when i was like 7 probably not the best thing for little me to watch but better than other stuff i could say that for sure i felt so bad for you after you said it wasn't that bad ngl
I'll probably delete this from my memory in a few minutes but I remember being traumatized when I first watched the video. I was a kid. The algorithm did me dirty since I was dipping into creepypastas at the time out of curiosity and obviously I was into MLP along other kid friendly stuff but still. I learned my lesson since then 😂 I can't watch the video anymore. It gives me flashbacks. The audio itself sends chills 😭
I didn't mind the grimdark stuff back then but now it just seems like it's in poor taste now. Like "omg im so edgy cause i animated pastel horses killing each other ITS NOT A PHASE MOM"
If you want more wholesome fan made content then watch Snowdrop. Though that one is kinda sad. Then there’s also Double Rainboom which is also a crossover with Powerpuff Girls.
i rmember watching this like after it came out i was like 8 or 7 i was so shocked... I saw so many bad things as a kid of mlp stuff that was showing so much gore or 18+ stuff...
The original video gives the context for this video. "Pinkie Pie was tired of being the comedic reliefe and has had finally had enough. She decided to show her friends just how much she appriciated it!"
I don't get why people want to suggest these types of old content for new comers, like what is your problem? I mean, sure I don't mind, but do you really want to see new people getting traumatize that badly? Sheesh. Maybe wait for the right time at least, and try recommending something that isn't bloody and gorey. Like for example, "Shy Heart - Ponyphonic", a good fan song for reactors like him to enjoy.
Well, that's the thing about reactions: you react to stuff, and the more you're surprised/amazed/thilled/puzzled/whatever, the better ;) It's all about dem emotions ;) Don't worry though, he didn't run away terrified, so I think he'll be fine. And we've got a lot of good stuff in stock for him to react too ;)
Pinkie is a cute girl. She cares for her friends, this SHD is just stupid. She's not my favourite, but when she slows down, she becomes a cute fluff. :D
I remember when Smile HD came out, if I remember right the guy who wasn't even a fan, he just thought the fanfic Cupcakes was funny. Some rumored it was an DHX Animator, but I'm pretty sure that was a rumor. NGL the animation itself is solid, but the rest is dumb edgelord stuff, like the fanfic was.
It's always the ones who aren't even fans to make the stupidest and edgiest mlp content. I'll pick happy pastel horses any day over garbage edgelord shit
I haven't watched my little pony in so long I forgot almost all their names all their names I could remember is rainbow dash pinkie pie and apple jack I forgot what the Dino was called and the purple pony to 'starlight and Rex or something' is there names?i forgot💀
I prefer people getting this recomended after season 4 at least. Not this early in the journey. It is a good remix, good animation, and quite questionable content.
In the words of Applejack; I hate to say, I told you so, but I told you so. I literally commented on the video called a friend in deed or need that you shouldn’t watch smile HD or cupcakes HD. Congratulations shy you now officially know why I said that. I knew that it wouldn’t be appropriate for you personally so hopefully this doesn’t ruin my little pony for you
3:00 “it’s not so bad why do you guys make it seem so bad?” 5 seconds after shyguys face: 😧
lmaoooooooooo i took my words back right away
@@UrFavShyGuy 😂 people are evil for making you watch this
how dare those people
@@UrFavShyGuy😂
The one positive to come out of this terrible, evil video:
It confirms what we already knew, that Fluttershy is secretly the toughest and bravest of them all.
factssssss
Yeah,actually,i would say that do be true,and she's the angriest mane six,you see,on some eps,when she loses her mind,no one can stop her
Well, that and the animation is good for something fan-made and the rendition of the song is nice. But other than those, yeah, Smile HD is atrocious. And the three positives named are not enough to redeem it in the slightest. So I give it -50 stars, maybe -500. It's that bad.
@@artbytesia why is it bad
@@UrFavShyGuyfr😂🎉
2:51 - spoken to soon... a few seckonds to soon
🥲
Congrats Shy Guy for you have unfortunately witnessed the animation that completely ruined the Smile song for literally anyone and everyone who's ever listened to it. I mean nothing against the animator of the video they did good work but i'm sure even they realize that they completely ruined that wholesome song with that animation.
😅
@@UrFavShyGuycongratulations you have gone through the rite of passage of being traumatized by Smile HD that every up-and-coming brony has to go through
Personally, it made the song better for me. :)
Didn't ruin it for me
Mister Davie knew good and well what he made is disturbing. That’s was the point. Also Cupcakes.
Personally, this video has never ruined my enjoyment of pinkie pie or the smile song. Yeah, it's gory and gross, but I guess my head separates the two from the show itself. I was also older when I saw this, and I definitely feel bad for the kids who saw this back then.
Totally agree
And it's easy imo to mske the separation becsuse there's no story, anything relative to eve ts from the show
It's like goku vs saitama animations for exemple, but made only to be gore
Yeah I was like 8-11 (forgot exactly which age) when I saw it and it scarred me mentally. Especially cause people were sending it to each other *and* kids on the internet to trick them
@buriedinbooks881 I can see why that would be terrifying. That's horrible. I was much older when I saw it. I'm sorry people did that to you!
@@buriedinbooks881i'm sorry for you
I saw it when I was younger, but i'm a lucky fuck because i've always loved horror and turning cute things creepy and scary. I like mlp, i like horror and gore, this video was a *GEM* to me!!!
Watching Smile HD and/or Cupcakes HD is a rite of passage of sorts for all fans of this show to go through at one point. If that doesn't scare you away, nothing will.
I would rather sign my name in blood.
Everybrony reacts to smile hd someday.It's a tradition.
Well you can't say you weren't warned. You chose to watch despite what people told you about it. There's a whole grimdark side of the fandom if you want to go looking for it. Cupcakes is probably the most infamous, but quality wise it's pretty terrible. Rainbow Factory and its sequel Pegasus Device on the other hand are very well written, but can be even more disturbing to read than Smile HD was to watch. There's some good songs about them though.
There's also Fallout Equestria. The story itself isn't grimdark per se, but it certainly has grimdark elements. It is an absolutely fantastic read, though, and it got popular enough to sprout its own subfandom!
I can attest to Fallout Equestria. despite not being the biggest fan of grimdark pony stuff (I even avoided Friendship is witchcraft for the longest time thinking it was grimdark) I actually ended up loving FoE. it helps that it the violence thats there isn't glorified, or exploitative. there is weight and pathos behind it. also, its mostly OCs (original characters). the mane 6 only being seen in the backstory, and even when known characters are seen, they stay in character (with one exception). the story overall has the same moral foundation and values as the show, and works also most like a condensed version of the show, just in a more mature setting.
Fun fact, the song for rainbow factory came first, then a fic was written based on it. the trio of songs, "Rainbow Factory", "Awoken", and "Pegasus Device" are all really good and tell an interesting story.
Thank you for reminding me Cupcakes existed. As a kid I loved the song used (rock/metal fan) and now i can go find the song XD
@@lissienicole7355 I was more referring to the fic, but Cupcakes HD (also by Mr. Davey) was quite well made if gory and disturbing. And the song is quite catchy, I believe it was Ready to Die by Andrew W.K.
a bit ago Diamonds HD and another one dropped to continue the series. This ones with the crusaders and diamond tiara
ok, time to propose some wholsome/cute MLP animations to make up for this one:
- your little pets / your little cats (both by Forgalorga)
- Pony Girl, (all versions are good but something tells me that you might like Fluttershy version)
- My tiny pony
Second all of those recommendations, but **especially** Pony Girl, both versions
"Snowdrop"!!!
@@bonbonpony but this one is sad...
@@fluttershyisnotadoormat4678bittersweet more like. It definitely makes me cry but good feelings come too yk?
Shy Guy: "this is not so bad why'd you guys make it seem so bad?"
*two seconds later*
Shy Guy: 😨
Shy Guy: "Oh, it's not so bad! ;) "
Also Shy Guy a second later: [surprised Pikachu face]
:D
Yeah, welcome to the dark side of the fandom, and don't say we didn't warn you ;J
BTW the volume of your voice is finally good :>
Lol thanks for welcoming meeee and letsssss goooooo finally my audio is good I’m actually happy for that
Welcome, now u have a wider and deeper knowledge of the fandom and it's parts, congrats.
Anyway, it's just a fan animation, so don't take things seriously. Or do, it's up to you. *Smile*
lol i gotchu
Condolences…
If it makes you feel better, i was dressed up as pinkie pie for halloween when i was like eight, and our neighbor WHO WAS A GROWN ASS MAN came over and show me this "cute video of pinkie pie that youll love" since she was my favorite of all time. Fucking traumatized. Literally shaking while watching this knowing its not as bad as it was back then but STILL. I HAD OVER SIX PLUSHIES OF PINKIE PIE THAT I WOULD SLEEP WITH EVERYNIGHT, I HAD A JACKET OF HER AND SHIRTS AND HAD HER AS A BIRTHDAY CAKE, LIKE I WAS OBSESSED WITH HER SHE COMFORTED ME THROUGH SO MUCH AND BRO WAS LIKE AS YES LITTLE CHILD LEMME SHOW YOU THIS CUTE VIDEO. DUDE THATS FUCKED UP
I'm pretty sure it was smile hd but I think he showed me cupcakes too, and rainbow was my second favorite at the time (still is, Applejack's my fav now like a decade later). It was fucked
thats sooooooooo messed uppppp i feel so bad for you
@@UrFavShyGuy nah it's good now it's kinda funny, I just love telling that story so much it's so funny
I'm a pinkie pie Fan too
Literally mlp fandom’s canon event
Oh... Yes... The darker side of MLP, well at least you did watch it, otherwise people would keep saying that you should watch it.
Now... Would you watch more like these types of videos regarding that dark side of MLP?
Alright, let's give some more wholesome MLP videos! Like Friendship is Musical by Tridashie!
most famous line "oh this not so bad why you guys make it seem so bad" and that loving smile turns to WTF of horror welcome to the fandom the gates are now locked enjoy your stay.. he first time I saw this (only time other then reactions) I looped and watched the original song for almost 10 hours strait to clear my mind and stop hating pinkie so much. sadly the fandom is fucked up when it wants to be if you ever want nightmares and avoid sleeping ever again check out the stories cupcakes and rainbow factory and then look at "grimdark" art. so yeah next time we warn ya bro I'd take the advice we've seen shit you (literally now cant) unsee
Smile HD is essentially the fandom's sick and twisted sense of humor manifesting as the means to troll new fans by leading them blindly into something completely out of left field.
It's also proof that MisterDavie is completely demented.
ForgaLogra and AgrolChannel does pretty good mute animations.
Taking place post season 4 and beyond, with the ones from the past few years being post season 9.
I remember being traumatized by Smile HD very early into my journey with this fandom. I found it by accident when I was watching pony videos in my room in the middle of the night. I had no warnings. 😣😵
2:51 last words before disaster
That part coming up:
Shy: 'It's not that bad!'
The timing couldn't be any better. Welcome to the black sheep of the MLP fandom.
'Least the remix is awesome. I mean, I like the whole thing but it is mostly just violence for it's own sake, which has a very limited time and place.
If you want something similar, CupcakesHD is (in my opinion) the best version of the Cupcakes 'story'. If you want the polar opposite tonally I'd go with practically anything by ForgaLorga, Agrol, or Tridashie.
The remix is amazing. If I watch this with my eyes closed, it's quite soothing and enjoyable.
Thank you for this reaction. You made me smile the whole way.
3:40 She thought that if she did as the lyrics demanded and smiled, perhaps she would be spared.
*She was wrong.*
If we had to be traumatized by it, so do the people reacting to MLP episodes
Flutter shouldve won 😒
😢😢😢😢😢😢ya😢😢😢😢😢😢
2:50 just wait a few seconds!
Shy guy: Why do you guys make it seem so bad?
Famous last words
You just like me...i love fluttershy ❤ and when she,s dead i cry💔
But i like all ponys too !!!
needs more likes and All of the reactions to the pinkie pie HD song is priceless
yeah its definitely an interesting fan animation i think i first watched when i was like 7 probably not the best thing for little me to watch but better than other stuff i could say that for sure i felt so bad for you after you said it wasn't that bad ngl
The vid:💀
The music:🥰💖💞
I understand you , i had IT too and i propose watching something silghst lying down np.
I shouldn't be laughing, but I am😭
am i weird for seeing this at the age of 9 and literally smile from it? and then seeing it again and smiling again?
that smile movie is really good. i hope you enjoy it more than this😭🙃
should i react to it on my channel😜
@@UrFavShyGuy yessss❤️
Don't blame me blind arrest
Ah rip
I'll probably delete this from my memory in a few minutes but I remember being traumatized when I first watched the video.
I was a kid. The algorithm did me dirty since I was dipping into creepypastas at the time out of curiosity and obviously I was into MLP along other kid friendly stuff but still. I learned my lesson since then 😂
I can't watch the video anymore. It gives me flashbacks. The audio itself sends chills 😭
I found this video when I was a kid and I loved it, I was super into the dark side of the mlp fandom lol
I didn't mind the grimdark stuff back then but now it just seems like it's in poor taste now. Like "omg im so edgy cause i animated pastel horses killing each other ITS NOT A PHASE MOM"
Amen,I got introduced into the fantom via rainbow factory creepypasta.
y’all should’ve seen my face when shy guy said “I hope she doesn’t hurt pinkie”…
MY CHILDHOOD SHOW💅
OMG i was so scared of this video when i was younger 😭😭
This video was the definition of old YT.
The looks on everyone's face right after asking why is this so bad? And then their questions gets answered. LOL
HAHAHAH U WERE WARNED
This is so sad 😢😭
I watch that video Long time ago and it scared me
5:25-7:56, WHY WAS MY MIND SCREAMING FLUTTER SIMP-
Don't watch cupcakes if you don't like horror movies or things like that
i loveeeee horrorrr
@@UrFavShyGuy oh you do like horror than that is great just didn't want you to get scared that is all
We tried to warn you. lol
If you want more wholesome fan made content then watch Snowdrop. Though that one is kinda sad. Then there’s also Double Rainboom which is also a crossover with Powerpuff Girls.
All things considered the remix on the song is actually pretty good
It's foozogz's remix. He does pretty good stuff.
i rmember watching this like after it came out i was like 8 or 7 i was so shocked... I saw so many bad things as a kid of mlp stuff that was showing so much gore or 18+ stuff...
And then there is Rainbow Factory 😊
The original video gives the context for this video. "Pinkie Pie was tired of being the comedic reliefe and has had finally had enough. She decided to show her friends just how much she appriciated it!"
"oh its not that bad!!"
pinky: "oh yeah?!" *fucking k*lls twilight*
You look like Chad from High School Musical.
Don't watch cupcakes...
I hate Smile with a passion.
7:40 #RipFluttershy
faxxx
Theres a version on youtube where fluttershy wins
bro's went too deep into this fandom
Smile, with one l
I don't get why people want to suggest these types of old content for new comers, like what is your problem?
I mean, sure I don't mind, but do you really want to see new people getting traumatize that badly? Sheesh.
Maybe wait for the right time at least, and try recommending something that isn't bloody and gorey. Like for example, "Shy Heart - Ponyphonic", a good fan song for reactors like him to enjoy.
to be fair, there were many who warned him not to do it and he didn't listen...
And whose fault was it that he knew about this?
Exactly.
@@snobtavia563 yeah... anyway, at least he didn't watch it when he was looking for smile song earlier
Well, that's the thing about reactions: you react to stuff, and the more you're surprised/amazed/thilled/puzzled/whatever, the better ;) It's all about dem emotions ;)
Don't worry though, he didn't run away terrified, so I think he'll be fine. And we've got a lot of good stuff in stock for him to react too ;)
@@bonbonpony agrred ill be okay just keep sending stuff in :)
“I don’t see why this is so bad”
-immediately showed jsut a sliver of how bad it’ll be-
9:55 mine is the part where Fluttershy fights Pinkie
agreedddd
I was so worried you were going to find out this video exists-
There's a lot more videos like this-
Bro flabbergasted
Pinkie is a cute girl. She cares for her friends, this SHD is just stupid. She's not my favourite, but when she slows down, she becomes a cute fluff. :D
Stupid and evil!
Well my little pony is like reading G but then this video is MA
its pinkie dont question it
😢😢😢😢
I Going to get holy holy water after this
You can see his world view shatter as soon as pinkie pie hit twilight 💀
Apple Jack was smiling because. She hates rarity.
7:20 whaaaaat
I remember when Smile HD came out, if I remember right the guy who wasn't even a fan, he just thought the fanfic Cupcakes was funny. Some rumored it was an DHX Animator, but I'm pretty sure that was a rumor. NGL the animation itself is solid, but the rest is dumb edgelord stuff, like the fanfic was.
It's always the ones who aren't even fans to make the stupidest and edgiest mlp content. I'll pick happy pastel horses any day over garbage edgelord shit
I haven't watched my little pony in so long I forgot almost all their names all their names I could remember is rainbow dash pinkie pie and apple jack I forgot what the Dino was called and the purple pony to 'starlight and Rex or something' is there names?i forgot💀
Quote: play the witch mare game horror
Oh no no no oh buddy no! Oh noooooooooo XD I’m so sorry
If Pinkie couldn’t break the 4th wall Flutter would’ve cooked her ass.
@@ZPaul_ ON GODDDDDD
6:40 what is face fluttershay and pinkie pie?
Im so sorry to tell you MLP had a dark trial of just gore and creepypastas, this was one that jumpstarted it
Damn
If I was in there I would be gone 😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅
Smille
Scariest part of this video is rhat Chris Chan commented on it
3:40 *WHAT*
Y'know the fun part is that my dad is the one who showed this video to me-
Haaahaha
NO PINKY NO😭
That’s my song by the way
Cupcakes 😬💀👁👄👁
Bro went silent
Shy Guy, have you made a video in request of someone?
I prefer people getting this recomended after season 4 at least. Not this early in the journey.
It is a good remix, good animation, and quite questionable content.
5:35 uhm, watch epic moment before it I guess
In the words of Applejack; I hate to say, I told you so, but I told you so.
I literally commented on the video called a friend in deed or need that you shouldn’t watch smile HD or cupcakes HD.
Congratulations shy you now officially know why I said that. I knew that it wouldn’t be appropriate for you personally so hopefully this doesn’t ruin my little pony for you
This is messed up man😭😭