The progression between both versions is like your own villain arc. Starting off well trimmed and in a smart suit as the calm, collected, slightly psychotic villain to now with the longer hair and beard, the less formal (for lack of a better word) suit as the villain who has surpassed psychotic and arrived at full on deranged. I love it.
The original is like 'Oh darling, condescending, mmmhm~' This is just 'I will eviscerate you as I sing out your soul from your picked apart corpse'. I love it.
The original cover of this is still one of my favourites (5 years? FIVE?! Bloody hell) but this..this..this is INTENSE. The original was evil in a 'sipping fine wine while watching things burn' kind of way. This is evil in a 'sipping fine wine straight from the jugular' kind of way..
That cover five years ago was what introduced me to you, so seeing it remastered is the second most exciting thing I’ve been here to experience (only second to Starship Velociraptor!!!) I haven’t finish listening by the time I’m writing this, but you’ve done stunningly as always !! Thank you for this
under the old cover someone imagined this as "a demon trying to sway an angelic counterpart resorting to intimidation, belittling and violence when it fails" now THIS feels like a revisit, the demon completely becoming unhinged after failing the first time.
I love how you turned a song about a crab showing off his own shell into what could be very well be the theme for a rich, corrupted noble about to strike. You never dissappoint man, keep the fire tunes coming!
I was obsessed with the original cover of this when it first came out, I never expected to see a remastered version 5 years later! Not only have you improved a lot, but you definitely look a lot more metal now than you did then. Sick cover!
I can see where he improved from the old one...I didn't like the Moana version found it to....bleh. I like this amazing version it's more twisted and...sickening I love it :D
1:03 - 1:19 and 1:58 - 2:17 are definitely my favourite parts omfg its so good and the "your armour's just not hard enough" sent chills down my spine its so much better than the original song
@@jonathanymusic aww that sucks u did look good in it and I love how u did this idk y u kinda reminded me of rob zombie and the undertaker a bit in this one I love it
I listened to the old version first to compare, and within 15 seconds of this version, I was like "Daaaamn!" You have definitely improved! And the original version was incredible too!
this scratches *every* itch for metal in my brain. the original cover had so much swagger to it and had the kind of vibes of a suave and so cool it's scary villain, but this is like, ten times as menacing and super creepy. hell yea!
I've listened to the first cover of this way too many times and I somehow love this one so much more. Also all the creepy vibes are perfect for spooky season~
I remember watching your first take at this song when it first came out and now I have the pleasure of seeing your second take and how much you’ve improved.
The original is one of my favorite covers you've done. It always felt like a riff on the villain barely keeping his mask of cheerful amicability in place. This one? Tamatoa simply doesn't care anymore. Incredible. It's mesmerizing.
holy molly huge improvement, I am now torn which one I like more... the original was one of my top favorites now I think this one kicks it down from its throne
Lyrics: Well, Tamatoa hasn't always been this glam I was a drab little crab once Now I know I can be happy as a clam Because I'm beautiful, baby Did your granny say listen to your heart Be who you are on the inside I need three words to tear her argument apart Your granny lied I'd rather be Shiny Like a treasure from a sunken pirate wreck Scrub the deck and make it look Shiny I will sparkle like a wealthy woman's neck Just a sec Don't you know Fish are dumb, dumb, dumb They chase anything that glitters (beginners) Oh, and here they come, come, come To the brightest thing that glitters Mmm, fish dinners I just love free food And you look like seafood (seafood) Well, well, well Little Maui's having trouble with his look You little semi-demi-mini-god Ouch What a terrible performance Get the hook (get it?) You don't swing it like you used to, man Yet I have to give you credit for my start And your tattoos on the outside For just like you I made myself a work of art I'll never hide, I can't, I'm too Shiny Watch me dazzle like a diamond in the rough Strut my stuff, my stuff is so Shiny Send your armies but they'll never be enough My shell's too tough Maui man, you could try, try, try But you can't expect a demi-god To beat a decapod (give it up) You will die, die, die Now it's time for me to take apart Your aching heart Far from the ones who abandoned you Chasing the love of these humans Who made you feel wanted You tried to be tough But your armour's just not hard enough Maui Now it's time to kick your Hiney Ever seen someone so Shiny Soak it in 'cause it's the last you'll ever see C'est la vie mon ami I'm so Shiny Now I'll eat you, so prepare your final plea Just for me You'll never be quite as Shiny You wish you were nice and Shiny
I love it! You've really improved with the "villian" thing you've got going on. If you're gonna do another redo, I think This is Halloween would be an excellent candidate. Your original cover was banging but you could absolutely annihilate it with how you are now!
I still listen to the original cover of this.. I love how far you’ve gotten, and love the fact you have got heavier with your sound. I still remember when I first listened to you and it was your cover of this is halloween.
I’ve been watching your covers since the original one you released! Your improvement has been amazing! Even your older stuff was fantastic! Keep making these amazing covers and originals!
Your old version of Shiny was one of my all time favourites from this channel and overall my favourite version of the song... But this one... God, this is just another level.
Jon... Holy crap I think you made this scarier. I LOVE IT! I have chills. Please do a cover of Boston's Foreplay/Long Time. Do it with an epic Keytar/Keyboard opening. Do it with your friends or alone. Please.
Oh my gosh... Both covers were amazing but they bring completely different vibes. The first cover was more of a sophisticated, controlled kind of frightening like a lot of the regular Disney villains. THIS cover leaned more into the heavy metal, much more chaotic. Scary in its own way. Leans a lot more into what Tamatoa might have been like if Disney didn't have to keep a PG rating. Goes just as hard :D Sooooo COOL :D
Ooh, I really like this version. Before, you sort of kept with the theme of being flashy and arrogant, but here you actually sound ravenous and evil, like you just can't _wait_ to tear someone to shreds. Amazing work, JY.
Me sighing and whining to myself about how Disney still won't pick him up. Disney made Genie for Robin Williams so imagine the next Disney movie having a character made for Johnathan just to sing a song
Old version sounds like the villian would release their enemy with enough resistance This one ? Sounds, and looks like they'd use someone's fingerbones as toothpicks 10/10
This feels like the reprise to the other one, ths difference between the two is that the first one is at the beginning of the movie introducing the villain while this one shows his true colors.
Johnathan didn't have to go this hard but he did. He did this for us. Well done mate, you crushed it! Didn't even think your version could be improved but you've definitely refined yourself over time!
This really hits home how much he's grown. I remember back when I stumbled on a cover of gauston and was like yeah, this kids fun, I'll watch his videos. Now, here we are, years later, and that kid tromping around in big boots and a plastic sixpack, is a fully grown metal god, and still the first video I click when a new one pops up. Heck of a ride and I can't wait to see how far we'll all go together. Love this community, love these videos, and love this guy.
This is easily one of the best covers you've ever done. Don't get me wrong I love the vast majority of your songs, they helped me get through learning to walk again after surgery.
1:57 pega muuuuuuuuy fuerte, si las anteriores pegaba fuerte, este es que te tiren el jodido Titanic encima La canción esta genial, me hace sentir en peligro, esta guapísima
The first one was good, and then this one is such an amazing demonstration of your growth as a musician and arranger. I love how much spookier it feels - your character voices have improved so much too and that 1000% made a huge difference! Thank you for sharing this with us!
Has it already been 5 years? God, I feel old 🤣 Absolutely freaking awesome cover! 👌 Perfection, as always! What should you do next?? One Jump - Aladdin remake?? Be prepared from the lion king would be freaking awesome! Especially in your metal style. You may have already done them but XD Just dropping two songs that I could think of at the top of my head.
I’ve been listening to the first cover since it got released very often. Probably more often than healthy would be considered lol I absolutely felt in love with how the first cover was done and I was listening to it this morning. And then… THIS happened. What a joy. This is one of my all time favorite covers getting an absolute upgrade in skill, quality and love. Simply marvelous. Thank you for my new favorite Shiny cover ever. And I’ll surely be performing this in one of my drag numbers because this is too fire for me not to do!
I know you probably won't see this but this means the world to me bro I've literally been listening to the OG shiny on repeat at work for the longest time guess I'll be adding this to the music playlist.
I was so confused before clicking on the video lol I love both versions, though I can definitely hear the difference between them. This one really scratches that "metal" itch 🤘🏽
I got so hyped up when i got the notification!! I always do!! I love your songs and covers!! I listen to them everywhere! Its no day without listening to a song or cover from you! I love your voice and I can feel that you like what you're doing. I feel the way you love the music and you put all your effort to make the best covers/songs i ever listened to! Keep it up!!
What a pleasant surprise 😏😏😏 Sure wasn't expecting this one, and i definitly prefer it to the one you did 5 years ago (even if it was a banger as well :P) GG dude, that's a blast !!!
disney really out here rhyming "glitters" with "glitters" 🙃
🦀🦀🦀🦀🦀🦀PRESAVE THE MOANA METAL EP : ffm.to/moanameetsmetal🦀
Would love to see this level of quality for Frozen Heart/opening song from Frozen
🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟 Feeling Shiny now Jonathan Young?
Please cover Silver Scrapes.
Love your musik
Can you do "Blame Canada But It's Cursed"?
The Shiny-er cover ✨️
Absolutely glamorous, a glittering and *shining* beacon in this bland darkness
Shiny-est
@@jonathanymusicdon’t know my eyes didn’t melt out but I’m gonna wait another 5 years
God bless you and Jesus loves you! ❤️🙏✝️💖👑
I mean to be fair this does feel quite a lot darker than the original so...
The original cover was already amazing but dude this is breathtaking
Thank you!!!!
No you're breathtaking!
(meme's aside, defenitly af breathtaking cover)
I fully agree.
God bless you and Jesus loves you! ❤️🙏✝️💖👑
God bless you and Jesus loves you! ❤️🙏✝️💖👑
The progression between both versions is like your own villain arc. Starting off well trimmed and in a smart suit as the calm, collected, slightly psychotic villain to now with the longer hair and beard, the less formal (for lack of a better word) suit as the villain who has surpassed psychotic and arrived at full on deranged. I love it.
Man went from the voodoo doctor from princess frog to Rasputin from Anastasia
His friends from the other side cover is one of my favorites
@@barryward2128 Same here.
Very well said.
And honestly, it's rad af
whoever isn't using headphones is missing out, absolute masterpiece
😃 1:06 demands headphones
@@jonathanymusic facts!
Yeah it sounds absolutely amazing with headphones 🤩🔥🔥
Thanks for letting me know, gotta check it when i have the chance
Thank you.
The original is like 'Oh darling, condescending, mmmhm~' This is just 'I will eviscerate you as I sing out your soul from your picked apart corpse'. I love it.
Love the original cover, but this sounds like a possessed collector of 'shinnies' and I LOVE it.
It's as if egotistical elitist collector of original cover finally waved adieu to his sanity and now just hoards everything
@@AmadeyAzalin "I even have the skeletons of previous attackers. Look! I made them SHIIIINNNYYY!"
@@XigbarTheFreeshooter he sounds like one hell of a friend
This goes unbelievably hard what the fuck
I didn't think anything could go harder than your original cover of this
Thanks!!!
@@jonathanymusic I thought you did a cover of this already? But great work john
couldn't have put it better
@@oisinlynch8427 he acknowledged it in the intro (sorry for bad english)
@@jasongrenbox6997 don't even worry man, your English is spot on
The original cover of this is still one of my favourites (5 years? FIVE?! Bloody hell) but this..this..this is INTENSE.
The original was evil in a 'sipping fine wine while watching things burn' kind of way.
This is evil in a 'sipping fine wine straight from the jugular' kind of way..
Excellant comment, you win!
That cover five years ago was what introduced me to you, so seeing it remastered is the second most exciting thing I’ve been here to experience (only second to Starship Velociraptor!!!)
I haven’t finish listening by the time I’m writing this, but you’ve done stunningly as always !! Thank you for this
Thank you :D
under the old cover someone imagined this as "a demon trying to sway an angelic counterpart resorting to intimidation, belittling and violence when it fails"
now THIS feels like a revisit, the demon completely becoming unhinged after failing the first time.
I love how you turned a song about a crab showing off his own shell into what could be very well be the theme for a rich, corrupted noble about to strike. You never dissappoint man, keep the fire tunes coming!
I was obsessed with the original cover of this when it first came out, I never expected to see a remastered version 5 years later! Not only have you improved a lot, but you definitely look a lot more metal now than you did then. Sick cover!
I can see where he improved from the old one...I didn't like the Moana version found it to....bleh. I like this amazing version it's more twisted and...sickening I love it :D
1:03 - 1:19 and 1:58 - 2:17 are definitely my favourite parts omfg its so good and the "your armour's just not hard enough" sent chills down my spine its so much better than the original song
DAMN YAS
There are hydrothermal vent snails that have iron armour.
Tamatoa definitely has some more metal integrated into his shell this time round.
This is undoubtedly really good, but I do miss the suit you had last time. Fantastic work!
I don't think it fits me anymore RIPPPP
@@jonathanymusic should've worn it and then flexed it into sheds on camera for effect! Would been a real... RIP ba dum tsss
@@jonathanymusic aww that sucks u did look good in it and I love how u did this idk y u kinda reminded me of rob zombie and the undertaker a bit in this one I love it
@@jonathanymusic Too buff for it.
@@jonathanymusic Idk. Could go for a "psychotic but classy" look. XD
I listened to the old version first to compare, and within 15 seconds of this version, I was like "Daaaamn!"
You have definitely improved! And the original version was incredible too!
" You TRY TO BE TOUGH, but your armor's JUST NOT HARD ENOUGH" chills, literal chills.
Always a treasure to see Johnathan post. Yes, I used a pun for this song
He definitely outshine his old one
@@Slurp_Durp Yes
0:20
I don't know what it is in the end of that line, but there's so much nostalgia in that delivery for some reason
Favorite part: 1:03
" well we'll well, little Maui's having trouble with his look"
this scratches *every* itch for metal in my brain. the original cover had so much swagger to it and had the kind of vibes of a suave and so cool it's scary villain, but this is like, ten times as menacing and super creepy. hell yea!
This Is a Certified Hood Classic
I've listened to the first cover of this way too many times and I somehow love this one so much more. Also all the creepy vibes are perfect for spooky season~
It's September.
@@TanwenPaladin As they said, exactly: spooky season. (I mean it's spooky season all year round with the right music playing 😉)
I remember watching your first take at this song when it first came out and now I have the pleasure of seeing your second take and how much you’ve improved.
I loveeeed the original. That’s how I found you, this gives me goosebumps
The original is one of my favorite covers you've done. It always felt like a riff on the villain barely keeping his mask of cheerful amicability in place. This one? Tamatoa simply doesn't care anymore. Incredible. It's mesmerizing.
holy molly huge improvement, I am now torn which one I like more... the original was one of my top favorites now I think this one kicks it down from its throne
Lyrics:
Well, Tamatoa hasn't always been this glam
I was a drab little crab once
Now I know I can be happy as a clam
Because I'm beautiful, baby
Did your granny say listen to your heart
Be who you are on the inside
I need three words to tear her argument apart
Your granny lied
I'd rather be
Shiny
Like a treasure from a sunken pirate wreck
Scrub the deck and make it look
Shiny
I will sparkle like a wealthy woman's neck
Just a sec
Don't you know
Fish are dumb, dumb, dumb
They chase anything that glitters (beginners)
Oh, and here they come, come, come
To the brightest thing that glitters
Mmm, fish dinners
I just love free food
And you look like seafood (seafood)
Well, well, well
Little Maui's having trouble with his look
You little semi-demi-mini-god
Ouch What a terrible performance
Get the hook (get it?)
You don't swing it like you used to, man
Yet I have to give you credit for my start
And your tattoos on the outside
For just like you I made myself a work of art
I'll never hide, I can't, I'm too
Shiny
Watch me dazzle like a diamond in the rough
Strut my stuff, my stuff is so
Shiny
Send your armies but they'll never be enough
My shell's too tough
Maui man, you could try, try, try
But you can't expect a demi-god
To beat a decapod (give it up)
You will die, die, die
Now it's time for me to take apart
Your aching heart
Far from the ones who abandoned you
Chasing the love of these humans
Who made you feel wanted
You tried to be tough
But your armour's just not hard enough
Maui
Now it's time to kick your
Hiney
Ever seen someone so
Shiny
Soak it in 'cause it's the last you'll ever see
C'est la vie mon ami
I'm so
Shiny
Now I'll eat you, so prepare your final plea
Just for me
You'll never be quite as
Shiny
You wish you were nice and
Shiny
Nice
1:15 my favorite part!
I love it! You've really improved with the "villian" thing you've got going on. If you're gonna do another redo, I think This is Halloween would be an excellent candidate. Your original cover was banging but you could absolutely annihilate it with how you are now!
I love the cover from five years ago, but in this one you surpass yourself, incredible!
Never thought I’d see metal Moana covers
I still listen to the original cover of this.. I love how far you’ve gotten, and love the fact you have got heavier with your sound. I still remember when I first listened to you and it was your cover of this is halloween.
The old version of this was the first song I ever heard here. Hearing the remake and how far you've come in such a short time is incredible.
“Because I’m beautiful baby” that’s my favorite line only because of the way Jonathan says it 🤘🏽
I’m loving the updated cover, but more than anything I’m loving that jacket. Style games on point with this one.
I’ve been watching your covers since the original one you released! Your improvement has been amazing! Even your older stuff was fantastic! Keep making these amazing covers and originals!
THE FIRST COVER I’VE HEARD FROM YOU!! ITS ALL COMING FULL CIRCLE
Has the student become the master?
Your old version of Shiny was one of my all time favourites from this channel and overall my favourite version of the song... But this one... God, this is just another level.
Jon... Holy crap I think you made this scarier. I LOVE IT! I have chills.
Please do a cover of Boston's Foreplay/Long Time. Do it with an epic Keytar/Keyboard opening. Do it with your friends or alone. Please.
Thank you!!!
Oh my gosh... Both covers were amazing but they bring completely different vibes. The first cover was more of a sophisticated, controlled kind of frightening like a lot of the regular Disney villains. THIS cover leaned more into the heavy metal, much more chaotic. Scary in its own way. Leans a lot more into what Tamatoa might have been like if Disney didn't have to keep a PG rating. Goes just as hard :D
Sooooo COOL :D
The audio mixing and effects and stuff was absolutely stellar.
This gave me chills and is everything I ever wanted from this song.
I listening to your original cover repeatedly and this is just as awesome!!
Ooh, I really like this version. Before, you sort of kept with the theme of being flashy and arrogant, but here you actually sound ravenous and evil, like you just can't _wait_ to tear someone to shreds. Amazing work, JY.
YOOOO, I DIDN’T EXPECT YOU TO REMAKE THIS COVER!! THIS IS ONE OF THE SONGS THAT INTRODUCED ME TO YOU, YA DID AMAZING DUDE!!
Me sighing and whining to myself about how Disney still won't pick him up. Disney made Genie for Robin Williams so imagine the next Disney movie having a character made for Johnathan just to sing a song
You were in a suit for that old cover and now You're truly shiny 😌 Character development i must say Jonathan
I love the old version, and I love this version😌
Jesus Christ, what a spectacle 🔥
Disney should really ask you to play a villain. You just give those songs so much more depth and character.
Your covers never get old Johnathan❤ love ya man
Wow this is a huge change. Your Growth as a singer made this song all the better.
THIS WAS CRAZY! AND I LOVED THIS!
Old version sounds like the villian would release their enemy with enough resistance
This one ?
Sounds, and looks like they'd use someone's fingerbones as toothpicks
10/10
Somehow, you made your villainous cover even more sinister. Well done!!
I'm french guy, this is my favorite song. The first one was incredible but this version hell yeah! You're so talented!
In 3yrs he'll come back with the shiniest cover
Seriously, though. not only does this man make great covers, he also responds to people's comments at two million subscribers.
This feels like the reprise to the other one, ths difference between the two is that the first one is at the beginning of the movie introducing the villain while this one shows his true colors.
Johnathan didn't have to go this hard but he did. He did this for us.
Well done mate, you crushed it! Didn't even think your version could be improved but you've definitely refined yourself over time!
I'm convinced Jonathan young is a Disney Villan from another universe that became human in this one
The Shiniest insane cover!
I don't know how you made it even better but here we are.
Aaaaaah!! That's my favorite song!!!!
I have never seen Jonathan having so much fun in a video before. Keep that spirit man🔥
You definitely need to do "I Put a Spell on You" from Hocus Pocus (I know that's not the original). Your style with that song would be incredible.
I second THIS
In the meantime look up Anglina Jordan performing it. She's 9 at the time with the voice of a 30yr old
This really hits home how much he's grown. I remember back when I stumbled on a cover of gauston and was like yeah, this kids fun, I'll watch his videos. Now, here we are, years later, and that kid tromping around in big boots and a plastic sixpack, is a fully grown metal god, and still the first video I click when a new one pops up. Heck of a ride and I can't wait to see how far we'll all go together. Love this community, love these videos, and love this guy.
This is amazing such an epic villain cover! 💕 you should do the pirates who don't do anything cover .
Omg Veggietales meeting Metal… Y E S
I know right!? In brand with sea shanty theme also😆@@Hopeful_Gal
@@Hopeful_Gal oh btw Skillet did a great metal version of veggie tails song stand up 💕
This is easily one of the best covers you've ever done. Don't get me wrong I love the vast majority of your songs, they helped me get through learning to walk again after surgery.
1:57 pega muuuuuuuuy fuerte, si las anteriores pegaba fuerte, este es que te tiren el jodido Titanic encima
La canción esta genial, me hace sentir en peligro, esta guapísima
My jaw dropped
It's on the floor dude
This colors really feels like 80s, maybe even late 70s. I can't think about nothing, but retrowave.
It could be fun cover, haha)
The first one was good, and then this one is such an amazing demonstration of your growth as a musician and arranger. I love how much spookier it feels - your character voices have improved so much too and that 1000% made a huge difference! Thank you for sharing this with us!
Has it already been 5 years? God, I feel old 🤣
Absolutely freaking awesome cover! 👌 Perfection, as always!
What should you do next??
One Jump - Aladdin remake??
Be prepared from the lion king would be freaking awesome! Especially in your metal style.
You may have already done them but XD Just dropping two songs that I could think of at the top of my head.
He remade Be Prepared already
@@darknessbobulus I missed it?! Oof. Been too busy to keep up 😅 Thanks though! I'll look it up!
It's been on my doing chores playlist for a long time
For some reason, this was one of your most memorable covers for me. You definitely improved it a great deal, which is saying something. I love it!
Yooo this is an absolute banger
There is not a bad Jonathan Young song. Covers and originals rock!🥰🌻
I’d love to hear “Reluctant Heroes”. With this kind of talent, it would be amazing.
It's crazy ,i see your song shiny , i'm listening for the man
I’ve been listening to the first cover since it got released very often. Probably more often than healthy would be considered lol
I absolutely felt in love with how the first cover was done and I was listening to it this morning.
And then… THIS happened. What a joy. This is one of my all time favorite covers getting an absolute upgrade in skill, quality and love. Simply marvelous.
Thank you for my new favorite Shiny cover ever. And I’ll surely be performing this in one of my drag numbers because this is too fire for me not to do!
BELLS OF NOTREDAME!!!! your version is the best. It would be nice to see the improved version.
This was really really good and well done , I been listening to your music cover since 2017 the first time hearing it was the shiny cover song
Ooh got the chills
I know you probably won't see this but this means the world to me bro I've literally been listening to the OG shiny on repeat at work for the longest time guess I'll be adding this to the music playlist.
This has "Vampire Dad" vibes, and I love it.
I was so confused before clicking on the video lol I love both versions, though I can definitely hear the difference between them. This one really scratches that "metal" itch 🤘🏽
after further evaluation,
jonathan young is HIM
Those high growls/snarls...*chefs kiss*
Beautiful
The acting is absolutely immaculate! 🦀 💯 🦀
I got so hyped up when i got the notification!! I always do!! I love your songs and covers!! I listen to them everywhere! Its no day without listening to a song or cover from you! I love your voice and I can feel that you like what you're doing. I feel the way you love the music and you put all your effort to make the best covers/songs i ever listened to! Keep it up!!
Dude the facial expressions are incredible omg
Это уже не просто кавер, а целый клип, растет мужик)))🔥
This is amazing. And omg the guitar! Turned out so beautiful!
What a pleasant surprise 😏😏😏 Sure wasn't expecting this one, and i definitly prefer it to the one you did 5 years ago (even if it was a banger as well :P) GG dude, that's a blast !!!
This should be Tamatoa's voice on Moana 2 if he Appears there 🗣🗣🔥🔥❗️❗️
This was always my fave of yours
i didnt know i like metal covers until you showed up. I love how theres more emotions and the feeling of villain singing it!