Red Dead Redemption 2 Is Boring...

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 11 вер 2024
  • Red Dead Redemption 2 has recently been called out as a boring and lackluster experience. While many claim RDR 2 to be one of the greatest storytelling games of all time, Twitter actually finds it to be one of the lamest and most boring games of all time when compared to RDR 1. Arthur Morgan is a cliche instead of being one of the greatest fictional characters of all time... Sometimes I think we don't need internet...
    Red Dead Redemption 2
    Rockstar Games
    RDR 2 boring
    Arthur Morgan
    RDR2 Story
    RDR 2 story
    RDR 2 vs RDR 1
    Rockstar
    RDR2 analysis
    RDR 2 twitter
    So enjoy! And please subscribe if you like it!
    -------------------------------
    Follow me on:
    DISCORD: / discord
    Twitter: / silvartop

КОМЕНТАРІ • 302

  • @ObviousMalcolm_PLUS
    @ObviousMalcolm_PLUS  2 місяці тому +17

    My boy Arthur shouldn't have gotten those COWBOY AIDS
    PS: Sorry for mic quality. Something happened during recording

  • @JG9Youtube
    @JG9Youtube 2 місяці тому +57

    I think more people were bored playing this game than they'd like to admit.

    • @bullymaguire3385
      @bullymaguire3385 Місяць тому +8

      Well yeah it’s boring most of the time

    • @shakpreme8568
      @shakpreme8568 Місяць тому +6

      The story was fun but after that it’s definitely boring

    • @toke182
      @toke182 Місяць тому +3

      yes

    • @OJ90-
      @OJ90- 19 днів тому +5

      🎯💯 facts. It's practically an interactive movie where u do tasks to get to the next portion of the story. The gameplay is very boring.

    • @Sin-pt2eq
      @Sin-pt2eq 15 днів тому +1

      100% it’s a 10/10 story an absolutely beautiful piece of media, but as a game you physically play and interact with its mind numbingly boring the majority of the time.

  • @Alilnoided99
    @Alilnoided99 Місяць тому +11

    I genuinely think that the people that like this game too much hate video games. They think that the story is the most important thing rather than the heart of video game which is the gameplay. The first rdr is better than the second

    • @K3rhos
      @K3rhos Місяць тому +5

      100% agree, I'm generally not a fan of this narrative/realistic/movie like video games, they're just NOT video games, if you want a game like that, just go and watch a movie !
      And I would say, it's not even about narrative games being bad, I really like some narrative games, but that just doesn't fit the RDR franchise to me, especially when you played the first RDR and you try the second one, it feels like a completely different franchise, a completely different type of game !
      RDR 2 is too much narrative/story driven imo. The gameplay on the other hand, is not that great !

    • @Alilnoided99
      @Alilnoided99 Місяць тому +5

      @K3rhos there's place for narrative games but it shouldn't be the main standard for video games, which is a great point you made. 👍

    • @JG9Youtube
      @JG9Youtube Місяць тому +3

      ​@@Alilnoided99 Yep, and the irony is the classics did it better in terms of more imaginative stories and dynamic storytelling (through gameplay, true dynamic choices, actually interactive worlds etc). Then somewhere along the line the modern gaming industry threw all that away and downgraded the medium to be mere scripted movies pretending to be games. RDR2 not only lacks progression/levelling-up, creative level design, challenge, fun creative traversal, etc - the game's story and premise does everything it can to kill your desire for any of these things in the first place.

    • @JG9Youtube
      @JG9Youtube Місяць тому

      @@Alilnoided99 You wanna hear some other common statements from these people?:
      "Games like RDR2 prove that games can be art"
      "RDR2 has ruined other games for me, after playing it I can't play anything else"
      ^^ These people never liked videogames

    • @Alilnoided99
      @Alilnoided99 Місяць тому +1

      @JG9UA-cam oh I forgot to say that. The whole one game ruined other games for me. How can one game ruin other games? Make it make sense. If anything it did ruined the gameplay aspect of that game rdr2.

  • @gvulture1277
    @gvulture1277 Місяць тому +12

    I have attempted to playthrough RDR2 4 times since it released on PC and each time I restart because it was a long gap from when I last played it that I feel like starting mid game is pointless as I would have 0 connection to what was going on but every time I try it again I am just bored out of my mind, that prologue is garbage, it's not just that the movement speed overall is slow it's the fact that even though this is an open world game they want you to do everything their way, they want you to stop moving forward to stop you and throw more dialogue at you, after the first train robbery you get into a wagon and go to the camp site and all of a sudden the wheel breaks off then you gotta watch these grandpas slowly walk over to the wheel and put it back in just so you can have a random nothing cutscene that takes control away again. This last time remembering that part I just couldn't take it, the game is complete ass.

    • @unuser0
      @unuser0 Місяць тому +3

      You can dislike the game, sometimes a game just isn’t for everyone. But just because it isn’t to your taste doesn’t mean that it’s garbage.
      The game purposefully takes it’s time to ground and immerse you within its story, the slow pace of chapter 1 is partly to get you to feel the struggle of the Van Der Linde gang, and see these characters that you’ll spend the next 40+ hours with at their weakest and most vulnerable.
      Having said that, sometimes people just don’t want that from a game, some people just prefer a faster paced action packed shooter, opposed to a slow paced and immersive narrative based cowboy game. The game takes its time, it wants you to really play pretend as Arthur Morgan, and that is a lot easier to get into, if you are focused on the narrative and interested by it.
      By the way here, I’m not suggesting the game is perfect, it definitely has its flaws in some areas such as mission design, and although in my opinion, most of the gameplay is pretty good, at least for my tastes, I can understand why some may dislike it.
      But despite of all that, I personally think that this is one of the best stories ever told in the video game medium. Obviously I’m not gonna go in depth and explain why exactly that is here, but I’d appreciate it if you could just trust me on that part.
      Overall though, I don’t it’s right to call the game bad, I think the game just isn’t to your taste, as games obviously aren’t made for everyone.
      (PS, sorry for the long reply, I just wanted to get my point across in the best way possible.)

    • @K3rhos
      @K3rhos Місяць тому +1

      I 100% agree with you and I feel exactly the same, I don't know exactly why too, but yeah I attempted multiple times to try this game, I actually was a fan of the first RDR, and idk why but RDR 2 I just can't... Maybe this is just me, or maybe the prologue didn't appealed to me, too much talking, too much cinematics ? Idk exactly why, but the game simply just wasn't fun at all to me.
      I'm really liked most of R* titles but RDR 2 is one of the rarest title with Max Payne 3 that I just can't find the fun out of it and I quickly quit !

    • @OJ90-
      @OJ90- 19 днів тому +2

      The gameplay is complete aah cheeks. Very boring, very easy, the gameplay has no challenge whatsoever. It's like your just doing tasks to get to the next portion of the story with cutscenes. I can't fathom how this game got all the hype it got.

    • @KenKaniff-dw4jw
      @KenKaniff-dw4jw 14 днів тому

      Its just a bad game and no way around it. The gameplay is so bad. Everything is a chore. Rockstar gameplay is always trash

  • @Gambito99100
    @Gambito99100 18 днів тому +4

    Thinking RDR2's gameplay is boring is legit 100% a skill issue, I can easily play this game for 8+ hours straight and not feel the time pass, the only reason I don't replay it more is bc of how sad the story is

    • @utrip6599
      @utrip6599 16 днів тому +1

      it’s boring asf. movement is slow and you gotta ride your horse for 10 min lol. completely boring missions and weak gameplay

    • @KenKaniff-dw4jw
      @KenKaniff-dw4jw 14 днів тому

      Bro its just a bad game. 6 out of 10. Amazing world, scenery and solid story. But everything else is a chore. Like i felt like I was working when i played this game. It was a job and not fun

    • @CRenggi
      @CRenggi 8 днів тому

      ​@@utrip6599 example?

  • @zuz2366
    @zuz2366 2 місяці тому +62

    Same people who hate on RDR2 are the same ones who only play Fortnite and COD for a living

    • @iamwhoiam7887
      @iamwhoiam7887 2 місяці тому

      they watch videos on masculinity to make them more manly

    • @sosigrolls2539
      @sosigrolls2539 2 місяці тому +5

      Not everyone, Cockstar just didn't finish the game and abandoned online

    • @declannathan707
      @declannathan707 2 місяці тому

      @@sosigrolls2539 Online is still good though

    • @NECKBEARD_OF_PIRATE_BAY
      @NECKBEARD_OF_PIRATE_BAY 2 місяці тому +8

      I hate it, its too slow, im gonna go play ai dungeon and cataclysm dark days ahead

    • @Agnei
      @Agnei 2 місяці тому +5

      i cant even say that aint true cuz i legit got a friend just like that

  • @exucia669
    @exucia669 2 місяці тому +18

    it unironically is boring though, the overarching plot is good but it drags you through so many boring missions that just function as exposition dumps and takes far too long to get going

    • @Wertyber
      @Wertyber 2 місяці тому +5

      same can be said for rdr1 tbh

    • @bretmaverick9434
      @bretmaverick9434 2 місяці тому +5

      ​@@Wertybernope

    • @bretmaverick9434
      @bretmaverick9434 2 місяці тому +2

      ​@@WertyberRDR1 was much smoother in terms of story, combat, and control.
      Rdr2 story was great...the game itself is trash.

    • @Wertyber
      @Wertyber 2 місяці тому +5

      @@bretmaverick9434 99% of rdr1's missions are filler, it took like a dozen missions for John to even start attacking the fort, rdr2 is undeniably better in this regard. combat is debatable, control is smoother in rdr1 sure, but rdr2 is still better in a lot of things and that's just a fact dude. never understood this trend of people just saying "old game good, new game bad" like it's so corny tbh

    • @theraiden1018
      @theraiden1018 2 місяці тому +3

      @@Wertyberno it can’t cause rdr1 isn’t as long or tedious. I can tell youvr never played it

  • @oldmatejohnno
    @oldmatejohnno 2 місяці тому +22

    obvious shitpost is an obvious shitpost

    • @ObviousMalcolm_PLUS
      @ObviousMalcolm_PLUS  2 місяці тому +6

      my name fits

    • @godzillazfriction
      @godzillazfriction 2 місяці тому +2

      ​@@ObviousMalcolm_PLUSall of the ppl you've mentioned & the overall General Consensus of RDR2 are too Superficial for a game such as RDR2...
      also, crying doesn't = knowing the games' writing is intricate & deep/complex.

    • @bretmaverick9434
      @bretmaverick9434 2 місяці тому +1

      ​@@godzillazfriction"Intricate"
      Everyone being happy than a highly stereotypical, convenient thunderstorm hits is the lowest form of storytelling.

    • @theraiden1018
      @theraiden1018 2 місяці тому

      @@godzillazfrictionintricate deep and complex. Yea sure. Thanks for letting us know you’re an idiot that just says random words because none of those things describe RDR2

    • @DeadX2
      @DeadX2 2 місяці тому

      rdr2 fans thinking everything is a shitpost cause they have a diferent opinon

  • @unknownbannana8241
    @unknownbannana8241 2 місяці тому +6

    Tbf if their criticism had more details , it could be seen as more valid . Even ppl that love RDR2 do hv some issues with the movement and the gameplay. The most common argument for sub-par movement is the cover mechanic and having to button smash to run . Boring is the fact that missions are VERY scripted . Allowing very little player freedom and creativity.

    • @theraiden1018
      @theraiden1018 2 місяці тому +2

      Easily the best comment in this comment section cause it reads like someone used their brain to type it out and not just another AI response glazing it like it cures cancer or sumn

    • @vyomraina7238
      @vyomraina7238 Місяць тому +1

      W opinion

  • @jaydenm1076
    @jaydenm1076 2 місяці тому +18

    Bro this Game is amazing Even the Hunting system is Better then most hunting games made this year... The Gunfights the Graphics if you look at Rdr2 and the Realism IT gets you very excited for GTA 6🇳🇦love from Namibia

    • @bullymaguire3385
      @bullymaguire3385 Місяць тому +1

      Realism doesn’t make a game amazing this game has tons of flaws

    • @jaydenm1076
      @jaydenm1076 Місяць тому

      @@bullymaguire3385 name them.

  • @andrewsilva9721
    @andrewsilva9721 2 місяці тому +12

    The first RDR is one of my favorite games of all time, but it took me multiple attempts to get through RDR2 because of how boring it is. The plot doesn't properly start until the end of chapter 4, and up until then it's just pointless meandering. Does anyone actually enjoy the whole "pretending to be deputies" arc or the grays and braithwaites section? Then the game is so on rails that it might as well just be a movie. Sure, there's the honor system, but that has about as much depth as Infamous, which is pretty much none, because all of the choices you can make get reduced to one choice-good or bad-and then you pick those options for the rest of the game.
    I think a lot of the enjoyment hinges on how you feel about the characters. I don't find Arthur interesting or even likeable until the TB starts kicking in, and Dutch is very clearly off his rocker from Chapter 1, so most of the game for me was just waiting for stuff to start happening, and no, inconsequential characters like Sean dying don't really count. John isn't really the same man as he is in RDR yet and the rest of the gang is just bland to me, they feel more like real people than the wacky characters in the first game but in a way that just makes them dull. I'd much rather interact with someone like Seth or Reyes than any of the gang members from RDR2.

    • @MetalDeathHead
      @MetalDeathHead Місяць тому +3

      Agree, RDR1 is amazing but RDR2 is the worst boring game ive EVER played along with GTA5.

    • @angelhd2648
      @angelhd2648 Місяць тому

      ​​@@MetalDeathHead nah

    • @OJ90-
      @OJ90- 19 днів тому

      ​@@MetalDeathHeadU had me until u said GTA5 lol.

  • @Seb7an
    @Seb7an Місяць тому +15

    It's boring af. A walking simulator, an interactive movie with clunky controls. It's not even a game.

    • @nimbites
      @nimbites Місяць тому +2

      Bro has 3 second attention span

    • @OJ90-
      @OJ90- 19 днів тому +3

      Big facts 💯. It's practically an interactive movie where u do tasks to get to the next portion of the story and cutscenes. The majority of what u do is ride a horse. The missions are SO BORING & LACKLUSTER.

  • @fusion913
    @fusion913 2 місяці тому +6

    I like rdr2 but I can understand why some people see it as boring, because it doesn't have basic features that exist in rdr1 such as the nightwatch activities and unlimited bounty hunting activities that add so much more fun and the ability to rob banks in freeroam, and limiting some stuff to online like the navy revolver and the ponchos ect... and some side quests and challenges are so fucking ass such as the exotics side mission and the gambler 9 challenge, it's just tedious and not fun. but that doesn't make the game bad for me although I find it fucking stupid that they didn't add this stuff.

    • @theraiden1018
      @theraiden1018 2 місяці тому +6

      Exactly. And linear ass missions that fail u for trying to do anything independently. Long ass horse rides tapping x for an hr shooting hundreds of guys. Rinse repeat

    • @fusion913
      @fusion913 2 місяці тому +1

      @@theraiden1018 that didn't bother me as much if at all, long horse rides can help you find new stuff in the game, I usually hunt on my way to a destination and find some random encounters and special locations. You can always use the train station and stagecoach but I don't have much problem in long horse rides tbh but the fact that the horse deliberately crashes into a tree on it's own or walk away from you when you try to mount it suck, one time this happened and the horse fell off a cliff and almost died

    • @DeadX2
      @DeadX2 2 місяці тому

      @@theraiden1018 its just realism

  • @bluntforc3studios198
    @bluntforc3studios198 Місяць тому +2

    It is too slow and movement/ controls are janky it’s not 10/10 or even close.

  • @sunnywagle8995
    @sunnywagle8995 Місяць тому +2

    Currently on my second play through and honestly, I now feel that RDR 2 is saved by some amazing writing and incredible graphical details. Else from gameplay prospective, it doesn’t feel like an action adventure game but a tedious life simulator.

    • @bullymaguire3385
      @bullymaguire3385 Місяць тому +1

      The writing is average at best

    • @OJ90-
      @OJ90- 19 днів тому

      He really said "amazing writing" 🤣🤣🤣. The game is such a boring mediocre slop. I'm 30% in it with a lot of hrs in, & the only reason I'm forcing myself to play it is because it took 11hrs to install, I spent way too much time installing it to just to delete it without atleast beating it 😅

    • @KenKaniff-dw4jw
      @KenKaniff-dw4jw 14 днів тому +1

      ​@@OJ90-bro i tried 5 times. I can't do it. I simply get pissed off playing it. Id rather go to work.

    • @OJ90-
      @OJ90- 13 днів тому

      @@KenKaniff-dw4jw Yeah man, its a real chore. I heard so much good things about it, I said I have to give it a try. Man it turned out to be 1 of the worst games ive played, & ive been playing video games since the NES.

  • @beniwastaken
    @beniwastaken 2 місяці тому +6

    it's a narrative game with immersive gameplay mechanics, what the hell do people expect from it? it's like saying you don't like fist fights in Yakuza or hate looking for clues and questioning people in L.A Noire

    • @bretmaverick9434
      @bretmaverick9434 2 місяці тому +6

      The gameplay mechanics in Yakuza and LA Noire are way better than RDR2

    • @theraiden1018
      @theraiden1018 2 місяці тому +6

      Better gameplay with more responsive controls and better wanted system

    • @K3rhos
      @K3rhos Місяць тому +4

      "What the hell do people expect from it ?" The answer is in the first words you said: "It's a narrative game with immersive gameplay mechanics"
      The problem is here, RDR 1 was NOT a narrative game at all, most of R* titles are not narrative games, RDR 2 is the first R* titles that I played that had so much narrative and cinematics, honestly let's be honest, story is a cool addition in GTA/RDR games, but the gameplay is the primary concerns, especially when you're not a native english speaker like me, and still rely on subtitles bcs I don't always understand what characters are saying during cinematics, so for me having a game with more cinematics and narrative is even more boring to follow and understand !
      GTA never was a narrative franchise, and the same for the first RDR, this is why RDR 2 was a strange choice to me bcs GTA/RDR fans were not waiting for this, I mean I love narrative games, but not for this type of games, and especially open world games, bcs to me narrative is incompatible with open world games, a narrative game should be on rail, and should be really scripted, just like a movie, but in a game like RDR 2 when the main selling point of the open world is the fact you want to mess around, adding too much narrative just make the game longer for nothing, adding more and more boring cinematics and scripted stuff to a game already that huge to explore just kill the mood to me !
      Also the prologue was a weird choice to me, bcs it was wayyy too slow, wayyy too long, the snow, the boring cart we drive to go to our camp close to Valentine... so much stuff that I was like: "When is the game actually start ?"
      The first 30 minutes of the game/movie is really important, this is the moment when you catch your spectator/player, and in RDR 2 the prologue didn't catched me at all !
      The prologue with all the characters etc... is the type of thing I would rather like in a early/mid game thing to learn about, but not for a prologue, a prologue should be simple, don't introduce too much characters in one go, not too much talking/cinematics/non necesarry animation (just like the wheel that detach from the cart when going to valentine, completely useless and just make the player even more bored when he just want to actually play the game lol).
      Well maybe that's just me, but RDR 2 didn't catched my attention, I got so much bored already of the first 30 minutes, that I didn't lasted that much on the game, I made some missions here and here in Valentine and never restarted the game since.

    • @theraiden1018
      @theraiden1018 Місяць тому

      @@K3rhos well said

    • @bullymaguire3385
      @bullymaguire3385 Місяць тому

      Last Of Us is also a narrative game and is much more fun to play than this

  • @Tiiliroskis
    @Tiiliroskis 2 місяці тому +5

    It is a bit boring but i still love it. Im doing my 2nd playtrough

  • @Angel-Otk
    @Angel-Otk 2 місяці тому +4

    I thought this the first time I played it and now it’s my favorite game ever🤣💀

  • @MetalDeathHead
    @MetalDeathHead Місяць тому +7

    You dont understand WHY a game that has TERRIBLE controls, slow and clunky, awful gunplay, uninteresting characters, story and missions sucks? RDR2 is literally the most boring uninspired garbage game EVER made! RDR1 however is awesome.

    • @Ice_Animates
      @Ice_Animates Місяць тому +2

      why are you going on every comment and rage baiting people 💀

  • @laser678
    @laser678 28 днів тому +1

    When it first came out, I got fooled by the marketing and hype for the game and bought it instantly.
    I regretted it almost right away.
    I really wanted to give the game a chance as I never want to waste my money on games as they get more and more expensive, but the game literally bored me to death. As a 30-year-old man that has responsibilities and limited time to play games, I don’t want to play a game that is a real life simulator and that demands me to brush my horse, brush my teeth’s, trim my beard and watch a 2min cutscenes of Arthur butchering a deer. They went way too far with the realism, and I think it is a huge disservice to the game.
    I honestly don’t understand people calling it a “masterpiece” and the “greatest game ever”. I really think that it’s a huge cope on their part but I’m not there to hate, I just want to give my opinion and if people enjoyed the game than so be it. I’m happy for them.

  • @HirstMovies
    @HirstMovies 2 місяці тому +4

    Max payne 3 has the best gunplay imo with rdr2 close second . This is just me as well though , max Payne 3’s gunplay was so addictive and fun rdr2’s was fantastic don’t get me wrong but like gta it just felt like it was ‘there’ probably because max Payne 3 is all about shooting and rdr2 is OBVIOUSLY about more than just shooting

    • @theraiden1018
      @theraiden1018 2 місяці тому +6

      Rdr2 gunplay is clunky af. Deadeye is like required since Arthur always sways the reticule like he’s drunk or something

    • @bullymaguire3385
      @bullymaguire3385 Місяць тому +1

      RDR2 gunplay doesn’t deserve to be high on the list

  • @itfrombit12001
    @itfrombit12001 Місяць тому +3

    Too slow-paced, hell you can't even save the game before finishing the prologue, which forces you to sit there for 2-3 hrs. I know the technical aspect is top-notch! But who cares if the gameplay is crap? Then the lack of vehicles, which makes the GTA games more enjoyable for me. The environment looks boring and is not distinctive at all. So overall this is not a game it is a third-person over the shoulder horse riding and walking simulator.

  • @Thc_freeshards
    @Thc_freeshards 2 місяці тому +15

    The people that say rdr2 is boring are the same people that buy the new cod every time one comes out

    • @bretmaverick9434
      @bretmaverick9434 2 місяці тому +14

      It was slow, boring and the controls sucked.

    • @theraiden1018
      @theraiden1018 2 місяці тому +3

      @@bretmaverick9434these fanboys are insufferable man. They wanna call other people kids but they all say the same stupid thing only a dumb kid would say

    • @Thc_freeshards
      @Thc_freeshards 2 місяці тому +4

      @@bretmaverick9434 liking your own comment doesn’t make you right,you’re a little kid who couldn’t beat chapter 1

    • @xMatthii
      @xMatthii 2 місяці тому +3

      ​@@Thc_freeshardsImagine getting mad and resorting to insults because someone doesn't like the boring ass slow game that gives you a hard on.

    • @tarro1114
      @tarro1114 2 місяці тому +1

      @@Thc_freeshards Ah yes, people on the internet reacting well to others having a different opinion than them. I love it.

  • @Alduin3914
    @Alduin3914 2 місяці тому +5

    I really loved rdr 2 But I hated the movement and there is no running in the bloody stupid camp, But i hated the epilogue playing as John it was so boring beaning a farmer I rather play as Sadie and Charles, at the same time.

    • @declannathan707
      @declannathan707 2 місяці тому +2

      @@Alduin3914 Skyrim has worse movements and boring repetitive fetch quests.

    • @Alduin3914
      @Alduin3914 2 місяці тому +3

      @@declannathan707 I know you mean but I still love playing Skyrim were can fly on dragons but I've just really burnt out the rockstar games especially GTA online and rdr online the only games I play now is Skyrim and oblivion and elder scrolls online. Please don't judge me. I just prefer elder scrolls online over GTA online because it's got better characters and quests and bigger maps.

    • @theraiden1018
      @theraiden1018 2 місяці тому +3

      @@declannathan707were talking about rdr2. wtf does Skyrim have to do with it? Weirdo

    • @declannathan707
      @declannathan707 2 місяці тому +2

      @@theraiden1018Stop playing with your wojak dolls

  • @yashuab.2979
    @yashuab.2979 2 місяці тому +4

    Clearly that man doesn't know how to rob a train. See, you'll want to put on a mask, rob a singular carriage of its passengers or of its safe (Only passenger cars have valuable people or safes to rob), then you get off and run in the direction the train is going to get away from the cops, then you jump on another carriage and rob all over again. If you're bad honor, you can even kill the guards before getting on to get a small amount of more time to get away (Rockstar just says so, I don't notice a big difference so far though). It's real therapeutic, scratches the honorable bandit/dishonorable bandit part of the brain this game is trying to itch.

    • @theraiden1018
      @theraiden1018 2 місяці тому +2

      That’s stupid af. It should work as advertised instead of having to do it exactly like that.

    • @yashuab.2979
      @yashuab.2979 2 місяці тому +3

      @@theraiden1018 It does work as advertised. It’s just like the movies, jump on one carriage, steal, jump on horse and then jump on the next carriage.
      If it was glitchy, the loot from the safe and the NPCs would respawn, but they don’t respawn and they stay empty.

    • @theraiden1018
      @theraiden1018 2 місяці тому +2

      @@yashuab.2979 tf are you even talking about? There isn’t just one way to rob carriages or trains. Why are u talking like there is? The issue people have is the wanted system. They’ll immediately know the train is being robbed even in the middle of nowhere and that Arthur is robbing it. Even if you’re wearing a mask. Which isn’t like how it was advertised.

    • @yashuab.2979
      @yashuab.2979 2 місяці тому +4

      @@theraiden1018 Bro, just get out the red zone, with a mask on. That’s how you avoid a bounty.

    • @theraiden1018
      @theraiden1018 2 місяці тому +2

      @@yashuab.2979 You know how the wanted system works don’t you? From the minute you’re in the red zone npcs magically know it’s Arthur even w a mask. Even if u use a different horse and clothes. I really wish they just fixed that part about the wanted system because the bounty hunters are annoying af when trying to do missions or explore. If u make a camp they will b there when u wake up. Other than that it’s not that bad

  • @FlamingElmo
    @FlamingElmo 2 місяці тому +6

    5:45 I'm sorry... I had to rewind 4 times to focus. Please forgive me 🙏😭

    • @ObviousMalcolm_PLUS
      @ObviousMalcolm_PLUS  2 місяці тому +1

      I do not blame you... At all

    • @FlamingElmo
      @FlamingElmo 2 місяці тому

      @ObviousMalcolmEssays Thank you for your forgiveness, my lord. 🙏

  • @BlackSmith6969
    @BlackSmith6969 2 місяці тому +9

    Really big fan of your videos man,
    Plz make a video why Rockstar keep uploading I mean milking GTA V online mode and why they don't tell about GTA 6 except trailer 1 for 7 months,
    They haven't gave us any goddamn screenshot nor artwork 😢

    • @ObviousMalcolm_PLUS
      @ObviousMalcolm_PLUS  2 місяці тому +2

      I guess i kinda cover that here: ua-cam.com/video/dva8CVId1iU/v-deo.html
      But thank you for the love and support!

    • @dudemp4
      @dudemp4 2 місяці тому +1

      wait until dude finds out that gta 5 and rdr2 didnt have a second trailer until over a year later

    • @theraiden1018
      @theraiden1018 2 місяці тому +1

      @@dudemp4yea bro is slow. They always do this

  • @sillywabbit7989
    @sillywabbit7989 2 місяці тому +8

    By far the greatest game ever played. Still playing it on redm today. 🎉🎉

    • @theraiden1018
      @theraiden1018 2 місяці тому +7

      You don’t play much games then

    • @xsts420x4
      @xsts420x4 2 місяці тому +2

      ​@@theraiden1018you don't know when to keep your mouth shut do you?

    • @MetalDeathHead
      @MetalDeathHead Місяць тому +2

      @@xsts420x4 rdr2 = the most boring uninspired garbage game EVER made!

    • @bullymaguire3385
      @bullymaguire3385 Місяць тому

      It’s not go play other games dawg this game has tons of flaws take those gush glasses off

    • @bullymaguire3385
      @bullymaguire3385 Місяць тому

      @@xsts420x4You mad your game is being criticized fanboy? Lol sad

  • @dudemp4
    @dudemp4 2 місяці тому +2

    seeing the no emotes in the thumbnail is so godamn funny

  • @tobrathecobra
    @tobrathecobra 2 місяці тому +10

    rdr2 is ass. the horse is slower then shit, the missions are boring asf, the weapons are boring asf. prove me wrong😂😂😂

    • @user-ww4oc5cp2n
      @user-ww4oc5cp2n 2 місяці тому

      Ok virgin go back to gta 5 only time a woman touch you

    • @declannathan707
      @declannathan707 2 місяці тому +6

      Go back to cod then

    • @NECKBEARD_OF_PIRATE_BAY
      @NECKBEARD_OF_PIRATE_BAY 2 місяці тому +2

      You're right and noone will agree

    • @bretmaverick9434
      @bretmaverick9434 2 місяці тому +4

      ​@@declannathan707weakest argument

    • @theraiden1018
      @theraiden1018 2 місяці тому +2

      @@declannathan707literal NPC response. U dimb kids always repeat the same NPC line “go back to cod” how about an actual argument?

  • @Drifting_Turtle
    @Drifting_Turtle 27 днів тому +1

    RDR2 provides a very monotonous and contrived gameplay experience, both in missions and in the open world.

  • @Ramlin1210
    @Ramlin1210 20 днів тому +1

    Man, this comment section is cancer. Don't let anyone try to change your opinion, guys.

  • @rationaloptimist5747
    @rationaloptimist5747 2 місяці тому +4

    I don't know, man. Just because someone got a different opinion on a subject does not mean that this someone is wrong. Neither does it validate to trying to dismiss him by calling him a "cod player". People have different opinions and that is okay.

    • @theraiden1018
      @theraiden1018 2 місяці тому +3

      I can always tell an npc when all the idiots say is “lul go back to cod!”

  • @biscuitbros152
    @biscuitbros152 2 місяці тому +1

    TLDR: the Gameplay is nothing special and the story isn’t perfect but the world of Red Dead 2 is amazing and has a lot of detail to explore.
    I think the gameplay is a little to be desired sometimes, the button layout feels a bit lazy since one button can do about 6 different things and leads to easy miss inputs.
    The story has its moments, Arthur is one of my favourite protagonist in any game.
    It’s visually stunning with a lot of small hidden details and it’s all backed up by amazing ambience and sound that brings out a lot in those details.
    The game also has a great soundtrack as well has a great casting of actors, giving us some of the most memorable moments in the story, both cinematically and in gameplay.

  • @log9700
    @log9700 2 місяці тому +1

    I love the movement in rdr2 more than Gta v where I feel like a turtle when turning

  • @naruto-uzimak9145
    @naruto-uzimak9145 Місяць тому +3

    Boring game horse riding sim

  • @aaronsosa187
    @aaronsosa187 2 години тому

    I’ve beat this game over five times it’s amazing. Yes the game can be slow but the world is immersive .

  • @HushtheMag
    @HushtheMag 14 днів тому

    It's weird because with the Previous Red Dead redemption with John Marston I felt invested in the story and character the whole way though. With RDR 2 I felt the story at the start was interesting, but Arthur terribly dull, then the story started betting boring and dragging on but Arthur suddenly becoming interesting as he was dying, then the story just wouldn't fuckin end!
    Arthur Morgan just felt like a Main character in a Red Dead Redemption Fanfic.

  • @mysterious3311
    @mysterious3311 Місяць тому +1

    i mean one who just picks up RDR2,
    there is nothing captivating about it gameplay wise first 5-10 hours
    it limits you alot* and you need to give it time to get to you
    overall you gotta play the game on its own term

    • @KenKaniff-dw4jw
      @KenKaniff-dw4jw 14 днів тому

      I know but i cant play it anymore. I would rather go to work.

  • @OAndreDrumond
    @OAndreDrumond 2 місяці тому +21

    RDR2 is da goat!
    EDIT: All of you replying, at least tell me your favourite game or top 3 or something like that, so I'll know if I should take your opinion seriously or straight to the trash.

    • @theraiden1018
      @theraiden1018 2 місяці тому +5

      Greatest movie of all time

    • @DeadX2
      @DeadX2 2 місяці тому +4

      overrated

    • @OAndreDrumond
      @OAndreDrumond 2 місяці тому

      @@theraiden1018 tell me your favourite game

    • @OAndreDrumond
      @OAndreDrumond 2 місяці тому

      @@DeadX2 tell me your favourite game

    • @DeadX2
      @DeadX2 2 місяці тому +3

      @@OAndreDrumond rdr1
      l4d2
      dying light
      saints row 2
      lethal company
      dead rising games
      black ops 1 and 2 zombies
      walking dead games
      etc

  • @marcocloutier4387
    @marcocloutier4387 9 днів тому

    recently, a friend of mine recommended this game to me, said it was ''the best game he ever played''
    gave it a try (20.2h exactly)
    this is the first game i ever played, where i had to stop, and take a nap because i fell asleep during a mission...
    the cast : the entire gang is hateable, i wish i could kill micah, sean, uncle and dutch, the girls are annoying, for some reason you let kieran live AND STAY ????
    the missions : not only do they make you waste your time by having to reach em, the missions themselves play more like a interactive movie than a game (did i really waste 20mins of my life teaching a npc kid how to fish ?)
    most of the system are so badly explained, i have to go on reddit to get answers most of the time
    like i reaaally tried to like it but.. damn that's 60$ i'll never see again

  • @tarro1114
    @tarro1114 2 місяці тому +5

    I love Red Dead 1 but the second game was just so boring. Everything just is way too slow. But what really ruined the game for me was the Multiplayer. RD1 had one of the best multiplayer modes ever. Plenty of awesome playable characters to choose and amazing game modes. Multiplayer in RD2 was just so dead.

  • @Mini-nw7nx
    @Mini-nw7nx Місяць тому +1

    blah blah blah, agree agree disagree agree, great video.
    just saying, i feel like you expected this to blowup. issues:
    1. no one defends rockstar games because of rockstar.
    2. still an opinion, just turned comedy. The tweet you are basing this on has a stronger point about RDR2 thank yours.
    3. the comedic comments are structured in common. I.E "it doesnt exist and made you cry," claiming insanity over simple subject, agreeing with flaws followed by "but"
    thus, not truly deep feelings/opinion, just a product.
    a product intended to help channel growth.
    is this what you want?

  • @Rogue_David-1-2
    @Rogue_David-1-2 2 місяці тому +4

    I think that guy that said everything about RDR2 sucks I think he missed took it for cod Vanguard

  • @PriWapo
    @PriWapo 2 місяці тому +2

    if they coulve just added online features like emotes it wouldve been better but ofcourse they never fucking do so

    • @mr.nuggies3087
      @mr.nuggies3087 2 місяці тому +1

      Are you trolling?

    • @theraiden1018
      @theraiden1018 2 місяці тому +1

      They never support single player. Rockstar isn’t like how they used to be

    • @mr.nuggies3087
      @mr.nuggies3087 2 місяці тому

      Bro ain't nobody want emotes in rdr2 bruh

    • @theraiden1018
      @theraiden1018 2 місяці тому +1

      @@mr.nuggies3087 bruh yes some people do bruh bro the guy literally just said that bro bruh. And im not talking about emotes specifically. But the weapons and customization and gun tricks and other features like horses and carriage owning etc. stuff that’s only in online for some reason. They don’t even support online anymore. Why not port over those features and items into SP the part of the game most people prefer ?

    • @mr.nuggies3087
      @mr.nuggies3087 2 місяці тому

      @@theraiden1018 ok ye MB I agree with the gun tricks and stuff like that. it's just that when he said emotes I thought he meant like fortnite emotes and I was like hell nah. My fault bro

  • @3dp2dino
    @3dp2dino 24 дні тому +3

    it is fucking boring.

  • @user-ww4oc5cp2n
    @user-ww4oc5cp2n 2 місяці тому +5

    Same mf shitting on the goated campaign also loves the MW3 campaign

    • @theraiden1018
      @theraiden1018 2 місяці тому +1

      Is that the only thing u NPC idiots can say?
      “REE U DONT LIKE RDR2? UR A COD OR FORTNITE FAN!” literal AI level response. U guys are a bunch of bots

    • @MetalDeathHead
      @MetalDeathHead Місяць тому +1

      face it, rdr2 is super boring crap game

    • @user-ww4oc5cp2n
      @user-ww4oc5cp2n Місяць тому +1

      @@MetalDeathHead yeah you probably only made it to chapter 1

    • @MetalDeathHead
      @MetalDeathHead Місяць тому +1

      @@user-ww4oc5cp2n wrong, i finished the boring ass game

    • @user-ww4oc5cp2n
      @user-ww4oc5cp2n Місяць тому

      @@MetalDeathHead then your dementia ridden self forgot any action

  • @yak-machining
    @yak-machining 4 дні тому

    I only hated the guarma chapter

  • @Agnei
    @Agnei 2 місяці тому +2

    people that aint really into RDR2 im fine with, but than the mfs that hate RDR2 for "being too realistic" or "Being a boring cowboy game" i cant stand, like if you dont wanna play a good game than look away from rockstar games and look at a different game company

    • @MetalDeathHead
      @MetalDeathHead Місяць тому +4

      its the most boring game ever made

    • @Cassernn
      @Cassernn 22 дні тому

      The game is good but the story is boring and the gameplay and gunplay is limited main flaws of the game

  • @trignite
    @trignite 2 місяці тому +12

    Nah, RDR 2 IS Boring, unironically. Everything is so damn slow. Spen 10 seconds killing 10 O'Driscolls, spend 1minute looting each of their bodies. Spend 2 seconds killing an animal spend 30seconds running up and skinning it. Brushing the horse, making camp, looting 500 cupboards and draws to make a buck, then you do the bank mission early and make money mostly irrelevant. Cant run in camp (why), have to hitch your horse (why). The overall story was the worst part of making the game feel boring though, it takes sooo long for it to pick up the pace. I have tried to play RDR2 Four times now, replaying the start three times. The start is the worst part of the game, it does get better after the first town, the city seems cool then the story really slows down. The raid on the farm is cool but the lead-up is boring. So much of it had me falling asleep and wanting to close the game despite the amazing visuals and fun gunplay.

    • @ObviousMalcolm_PLUS
      @ObviousMalcolm_PLUS  2 місяці тому +12

      Don't you think thats a clear case of a game not being for you? Something objectively boring will make the majority (if not all) bored. The tempo is perfect for a narrative masterpiece as emotions are convened even in SIDE MISSIONS and all those elements yiu complained are RP elements that people enjoy doing even today. I love having to maintain the horse and make camp. That's how the game is supposed to be paid. Slowly and deliberate. It isn't an ADHD shooter. You can't judge it as such

    • @coreycasciano3255
      @coreycasciano3255 2 місяці тому

      It’s slow because it’s a wild west simulator 🤣

    • @commanderblack5045
      @commanderblack5045 2 місяці тому +1

      I understand that you don't like the game, but like the other two comments say the game plays in the wild West so it makes sense that weapons are Shooting not fast or that you have to wait a few seconds for looting a person or skining an animal

    • @declannathan707
      @declannathan707 2 місяці тому

      @@trignite Go back to fortnite

    • @bretmaverick9434
      @bretmaverick9434 2 місяці тому +5

      ​@@declannathan707RDR2 is slow. Its controls are bad. It's story is lazy and predictable.
      Fortnite tho

  • @1035pm
    @1035pm 2 місяці тому

    The same people that think RDR2 is boring are the same people that think gta5s driving physics are the best ever created!

    • @K3rhos
      @K3rhos Місяць тому +1

      So I just proved your statement is wrong lol
      I hate GTA 5 driving physics and I consider RDR 2 as boring ! lol

    • @bodhi9945
      @bodhi9945 3 дні тому

      @@K3rhos same , I was invested in niko's story tho .gta 4 was good imo

  • @artpropaganda420
    @artpropaganda420 2 місяці тому +7

    Maybe it has best story ever i never experienced it fully cause i was SO bored. I started rdr2 twice and both times dropped it. The most boring game made for people who like netflix and watching movies more then games. Rdr1 is much more fun

    • @cantinadudes
      @cantinadudes 2 місяці тому +5

      Has to be bait

    • @artpropaganda420
      @artpropaganda420 2 місяці тому +5

      @@cantinadudes nope. Playing ghost of tsusima now, and cant stop doing it. Played like 60 hours and never had a thought to drop it. Because it has fun GAMEPLAY! Not like push dead eye button kill everyone in sight and then go loot them for 10 minutes because it it is soooo immersive

    • @cantinadudes
      @cantinadudes 2 місяці тому +4

      @@artpropaganda420 bruh the game is about soo much more, you must be shitting me

    • @artpropaganda420
      @artpropaganda420 2 місяці тому +3

      @@cantinadudes yeah it is about so much more and it has a great story and characters etc but it is BORING af. Rdr1 was arcady and it is a great GAMEPLAY choise for wild west shooter, and rdr2 is a simulator of wild west life + netflix series inside. Simulators are never fun, it is like playing arma and immersivly sit in bush for 4 hours instead of playing battlefield (not 2042 it is crap) or rising storm if you more on realistic side. Core gameplay in rdr2 is not fun for me personaly, good and fun gunplay was in max payne 3, rdr2 is not even near btw

    • @commanderblack5045
      @commanderblack5045 2 місяці тому +3

      ​@@artpropaganda420i understand you point put the more arcade than realistic times for Rockstar Games are most likely over, GTA IV was in a new era with more realistic physics but i think most people hated the driving (saying it drives like a boat) years later people hated the arcade like driving in GTA V and said that GTA IV driving was better

  • @SonicAdventureEnjoyer
    @SonicAdventureEnjoyer 2 місяці тому +2

    RDR1 is a better game for me personally because its a lot more fun gameplay wise and i prefer John over Arthur and the rdr1 side characters and its OST but i also never understood hate for 2 like that much. When I played it on PC i enjoyed it and had a good time with the open world and more dynamic NPCs in the world.
    I enjoyed the video lol

    • @theraiden1018
      @theraiden1018 2 місяці тому +2

      Same. Better gunplay. Hit reactions from enemies. Better story

    • @DeadX2
      @DeadX2 2 місяці тому +1

      i agree

    • @MetalDeathHead
      @MetalDeathHead Місяць тому

      @@theraiden1018 Exactly! rdr1 is 1000 times better than this boring garbage game

  • @RenjiSuzuki
    @RenjiSuzuki 2 місяці тому

    if the game was bad i wouldnt have 100+ hours on it.. i downloaded it a couple weeks ago.

  • @Sin-pt2eq
    @Sin-pt2eq 15 днів тому

    Beautiful story but a terrible game

  • @gamemaster27
    @gamemaster27 2 місяці тому +3

    Boring Game... Is... Boring... 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

  • @therealeverlade
    @therealeverlade 2 місяці тому +4

    Nuh uh

    • @ObviousMalcolm_PLUS
      @ObviousMalcolm_PLUS  2 місяці тому +3

      I second that "nuh uh"!

    • @therealeverlade
      @therealeverlade 2 місяці тому

      @@ObviousMalcolm_PLUS Skee Yeehawww!!!

    • @DeadX2
      @DeadX2 2 місяці тому

      yeah huh

    • @therealeverlade
      @therealeverlade 2 місяці тому

      @@DeadX2 RDR2 is factually one of the least boring games one could play.

    • @DeadX2
      @DeadX2 2 місяці тому

      @@therealeverlade not really lol game is senseitive af if u run a guy over on accident he gets the cops if u stare at a coo u get the law on you
      If u go 5 meters away from a mission the mission fails no creativity and freedom
      Infinite lawmen spawn so ur making no progress and there’s no accomplishment after killing all the law
      The gunplay and gameplay suck it’s clunky and shaky and way too easy you can spam deadeye and enemies die way too easily to some guns

  • @Godtierlightskin
    @Godtierlightskin Місяць тому +2

    "RDR2 is boring" 🤓🤓🤓🤓