How Pakistan’s Taliban Bet Backfired
Вставка
- Опубліковано 31 жов 2023
- Compare news coverage. Spot media bias. Avoid algorithms. Be well informed. Download the free Ground News app at: ground.news/tldr
Pakistan has long been considered the Taliban's closest state benefactor since the group's inception. The relationship has largely endured through the Taliban's time in and out of power in Afghanistan, but since August 2021, relations seem to have deteriorated sharply. In this video, we take a look at the history between the Taliban and Pakistan, why things are getting worse, and how Pakistan's Taliban strategy backfired.
🎞 TikTok: / tldrnews
💡 Got a Topic Suggestion? - forms.gle/mahEFmsW1yGTNEYXA
Support TLDR on Patreon: / tldrnews
Donate by PayPal: tldrnews.co.uk/funding
Our mission is to explain news and politics in an impartial, efficient, and accessible way, balancing import and interest while fostering independent thought.
TLDR is a completely independent & privately owned media company that's not afraid to tackle the issues we think are most important. The channel is run by a small group of young people, with us hoping to pass on our enthusiasm for politics to other young people. We are primarily fan sourced with most of our funding coming from donations and ad revenue. No shady corporations, no one telling us what to say. We can't wait to grow further and help more people get informed. Help support us by subscribing, engaging and sharing. Thanks!
////////////////////////////
1 - www.cfr.org/backgrounder/tali...
2 - en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Afghani...
3 - en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pashtun...
4 - www.usip.org/publications/202...
4 - www.nytimes.com/2022/04/17/wo...
5 - thediplomat.com/2023/04/pakis...
6 - thediplomat.com/2022/01/talib...
7 - www.reuters.com/world/asia-pa...
8 - www.reuters.com/world/asia-pa...
9 - www.lowyinstitute.org/the-int...
9 - www.dw.com/en/pakistan-orders...
10 - www.ohchr.org/en/press-briefi...
10 - news.un.org/en/story/2023/10/...
11 - www.amnesty.org/en/latest/new...
12 - www.hrw.org/report/2017/02/13...
13 - www.reuters.com/world/asia-pa...
14 - www.usip.org/publications/202...
![ПОЛНАЯ ИСТОРИЯ ЭКЗОРЦИЗМА [Топ Сикрет]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/qBySr6Bt0B8/mqdefault.jpg)
Who would've guessed backing extremists would backfire?
Ask murica
@cyberverse9141 ask India and Pakistan.
@@cyberverse9141murica didn't back any extremists as the video shows, they financed the mujahedims who were a variety of ideas group but common point was being anti-commie and comunism is also an extreme ideology.
@@FatBunny168which extremist did India support u r just lying Pakistan yes and is still supporting .
@@puraLusa Why do people constantly think it's okay when America supports terrorism but pretend to care when others do it?
Pakistan: Supports terrorists
Taliban: Commits terror
Pakistan: Surprised Pikachu face
I never knew that protecting women's honor, stopping opium cultivation and preventing pedophilia-homosexuality were terror acts.
pakistan had supported mujahideens who formed taliban later on
@@gameworld6740so had CIA
More dirty hindu comments
@@Believer1995ofGod Yes, what is the moral of the story?
Do not support violent funadmendalist groups that hate you but are using you to acquire power and are going to betray you as soon as they can.
As Clinton once said "You cannot feed snakes in your backyard expecting it to only bite your neighbour"
Exactly !
Damn, couldn't be put into more prefect words
The Americans know from experience with all their shenanigans
Do you believe that "Unnatural" means "a duration of time", or "the future", "present", OR "past"?
@@seanrowshandel1680 it means none of those things lol
How could be training and giving weapons to terrorists a bad idea?
yeah like what could possibly go wrong? right?
Play stupid games win stupid prizes
Lol Pakistani ISI is like the Americans, producing it's own enemy.
America is very good at doing that as well.
Apparently Israel did that with Hamas so to have someone destabilize Fatah...
As it turns out
Supporting fanatics and giving them guns is a bad idea
Who would have thought…
tell that to usa because they provide guns many thing to Taliban's and mujahideen to fight off soviet union
@@Bryxz2Liar.
@@Bryxz2The US funded Mujahideen, not the Taliban.
Notice how Taliban means "students" ? They were students in Pakistan - Not the USA.
@@Bryxz2the taliban did not exist in the 1980s. The Taliban never fought the Soviets. They were formed in the 1990s in Pakistan.
Which muslim has attacked a hospital or place or worship or a refugee camp? There's pics and videos of usa and israel doing it....
If there's one constant in human history, it's that "the enemy of my enemy" is most likely just a future enemy.
This reminds me of world war 2 were the enemy of the west and the Soviet Union was the fascists they beat together then they went back to being enemies.
@@bornstar481operation unthinkable would've solved this
Yes Israel initially helped Hamas to weaken PLO. Now Israel is regretting it
@@Miya-ub5qn they're getting what they want out of it actually
@@Miya-ub5qnIsrael ne muhamoot ke ashiqon ko muhamoot peene ko majboor kar diya hai hamas jaise rkhel ki auladon me agar zara si bhi haya hoti to wo Palestine ke bachho ko bachane ke liye surrender kar dete. To muhamoot ke ashiq Palestine ke bachho ka asli dushman hamas hai
Pakistan helped the Taliban against their ally "USA" and then got backstabbed. I am playing the worlds smallest violin.
Agreed
It shows Pakistan 🇵🇰 never thought ahead and shows us Americans that our friendship and trust was misplaced.
you trust muslims was your firdt mistake LOL@@thewingedhussar4188
US helped taliban against soviet. then they got 911.
No wonder US starts to move toward Indian more and more.
Where's ur proof that Pakistan helped them against the US? Pakistan was simply willing to recognise and trade with them. The US itself supported the seeds of the taliban just to beat the soviets.
Pakistan originally supported Taliban and other radical groups to destabilize and extend their influence in central Asia, in the heyday of their power when Pakistan was a country growing economically. They used Islam more and more as a national glue, to counteract the strong divisive tendences of the several ethnic groups composing the country (one of which had succeeded, giving birth to Bangladesh).
Are you saying the elite of a region used religion as a tool of control? How novel!
They learned nothing from the history of Afghanistan and reasons of US and Russia’s failure.
And why would Pakistan want to detablise Afghanistan? It was already badly destabilised by the soviet and US invasions. The US was the one supporting the talibs during the soviet afghan war to contain the spread of communism.
And we see how well Bangladesh is off now
All of the taliban were trained and educated by Pakistan
As a Bangladeshi we couldn’t have enjoyed a better life if it was still East Pakistan
Sad that Bangladeshis today have more support for Pakistan just bcoz they have oner thing in common -- ISLAM!
@@mg9854go away pajeet
As Pakistani U guys are lucky to independent from the mess which is now pakistan , Bangladesh has brighter future then pakistan Rn
@@hungerquest7862 Hopefully u guys can beat militarism and fundamentalism
@@hammad4178 bro ur name is haram it has Ham in it :O...
World thought that Osama was in caves around Durand line while he was living in Abbottabad in Punjab province. That's says all.
World thought India was being friendly to West and Qatar--recent incidences prove otherwise. That says it all.
@@yourend3177 well we are country of so called non believers or kaffirs so I am not surprised by the order. Qatar houses US military as well as Taliban and Hamas that says lot about Qatar.
@@shashanktrivedi27 Also--Russia is now unhappy with India too. Reason---not paying up for oil on time. Rupee not accepted by Russia, Yuan-- India doesn't want to buy in and that leaves Riyal Or Dinar. Something India doesn;t have much as compared to Dollar--useless to Russia.
@@yourend3177go check indian foreign policy from 1950s we always claimed to be non aligned and neutral we never joined any milatary pact that's why our foreign minister have easier job to explain indian stance
@@nikhilhembrom8952 i know but talks are cheap.
Hence USA always sided with Pakistan and India was always friendly towards Soviet union.
Pro tip for villains: if you're not sure you can put down the bad people you want to help if they betray you AFTER calculating how helping them will make them stronger, DON'T HELP THEM.
yeah tell that to US too, not just pakistan.
@@rizkyadiyanto7922 You mean how they made china the 2nd largest economy, with military capabilities on par with the U.S in terms of quantity?
I can agree with that, not sure what the U.S thought to heavily contribute to the creation of the modern USSR.
@@rizkyadiyanto7922 It's for all villains. If you're one as well, make sure to follow me to get more tips. Next week I'll talk about how to stop procrastinating and start your world domination plans.
@@lamentoffalsefacade2.064China doesn’t have modern military combat experience to be taken seriously right now.
@@EmazingGuitarfunny way of saying China doesn't illegaly invade other countries
I feel like Pakistan’s plan was to basically fund and support any rebel group against the Kabuli government. They have been at odds with nearly all Kabul governments from the monarchy, daoud khan, communist gov, Mujahideen to even the recently fallen republic and now the Taliban.
The problem now for Pakistan is that, the only major group now in Afghanistan is Daesh and TTP who also conduct terrorist attacks in Pakistan.
So they basically ran out of possible coup candidates?
When ur anti-something u end up being pro-nothing.
The worst kind of religious manipulation is the one that is used to produce nationalism.
I'll be laughing my ass as the three Islamist faction go ape shit aginst one another. The bad stuff is that they'll spill out to other regions
@@arthurlasido258as if Afghanistan and Iran would ever let IS spread beyond their borders.
@@NoobKillerTMif the coup candidate is ISIS then I don't want to live in this world anymore.
American support for Pakistan was an utterly catastrophic mistake
I hope we cut ties with them and become strong friends with India.
Still pakistan is US's non nato major Ally
Realpolitik. The US was sending aid to the Soviet Union before América was at war in WW2, not out of support for the Soviets, but out of dislike for the Nazis. Post WW2, the US would have much preferred to have had the support of India vs the communists, but they choose a different path.
Thank u for understanding it 30-40 years after Indians did!😂
America's support to all Islamic countries will turn catastrophic mistakes. It is just a matter of time because Islam draw its strength from its barbaric, fascist and totalitarian ideology.
Has anyone EVER benefitted in the long-term from “my enemy’s enemy is my friend”? It eventually backfires almost without fail.
very few times but examples have been the US relations with south Korea + Germany + japan.
its called rambo3
It did put the final nail in the USSR's coffin.
I suppose the British, after nearly 1,000 years of wars with France, suddenly found in the 1900s that the French were vital allies against the rising power of Imperial Germany.
The french and British thats about it
As many others have stated "getting in bed with terrorists turned out to be a bad idea and it now it's biting them in the ass" How shocking
Funniest part was that Pakistanis were celebrating when Taliban took over because they thought Taliban was going to help them 'liberate' Kashmir.
Funniest part it, Kashmir was independent when they attacked in 1947, after their attack Kashmir decided to join India.
@@sparkyblue7016 and Bangladesh was east Pakistan until they started 1971 war but they are not going to admit it😂
fake news
@@sparkyblue7016stop lying 😂
@@ulama7828 It's not 😂. Perhaps pick up an actual history book.
Irony that Pakistan rejects Indias border cus it was drawn by the brits, but when Afghanistan says the same, now its an issue. Also 1.7 million is same as population of Gaza, Im not defending Israel, but Pakistan cant do the same thing at same time,
Hypocrisy is the norm in diplomacy, and Pakistan would not be the first country supporting Palestine to have... Complicated problems with some minorities or ideologies.
Same is true for other countries, including in the West of course.
Rules for thee, not for me.
Pakistan doesn't reject the indian border drawn by the British, it rejects the indian border that extended into East Kashmir after the indians invaded it after the British left. The British drawn border of India does not include Kashmir.
Pakistan is the country created based on religion but couldn’t accept Israel- another country created based on religion
@@prestallar4339 Pakistan invaded Kashmir
As an Indian, I am laughing out loud as it is appropriate.
😂😂😂😂😂... As a South African I'm laughing with you.
Is the map shown is accurate
@@thinadlamini4671go back to looting and crying about colonialism bantus rat girl
@@mhshmore99the map is not made for accuracy. It just shows what both sides claim
Phul sappart saar!
Ah
Pakistan and Taliban 😏
What's that saying...."play stupid games, win stupid prizes."
That is such a hilariously good quote. 😂
Excuse me while l yoink that for myself.
From kraut
acting like USA dint give money to talibans fight soviet
@@Bryxz2 As if Pakistan didn't do the dirty work on the ground.
@@divyanshraiswal6969 Indeed from Kraut's video detailing the relationship between India and Pakistan
It was jarring watching a well spoken man enthusiastically talk about whipping women like its common sense.
(Turns out being good at English Lit does not an intelligent person make)
I don't understand why western media shows Indias Arunachal Pradesh as disputed in their maps. Kashmir is understandable but Arunachal?? China also claims all of South China Sea so why don't they show that as disputed as well?
Very true ..western media is influenced by china
Exactly this guy in his previous video shows Arunachal Pradesh as part of India.
I had doubt, but now I am completely sure this guy is supporting and promoting his agenda and propaganda.
Anyone told u that China dropped its claim?
By the way, India still claims Aksai Chin.😊😊
Probably just ignorance / indiscriminate use of maps from Google images.
@@Steve_Sharpe Actually, there's this thing called the Law of the Sea, that everyone, including these 'Western overlords', are supposed to follow, and the problem is that the strongest local player is ignoring it and has decided that everyone's sea resources should belong to it instead, simply because it's powerful enough to shut everyone else down.
But yeah. Clearly you're not Japanese, Taiwanese, Vietnamese or a Filipino.
Pakistan is the best representation of "Play stupid games, gain stupid prizes"
It may appear stupid game but they are playing brilliantly exactly how Mohamad used to play.
more like lions ate my face
Can't say about Pakistan but their military generals did get a fair prize in American dollars
'Peaceful people' + "peaceful people" = Super peace everywhere
Are ur people any more peaceful ? 60 million people died in the world wars. India keeps fighting with China and Sikhs. And yet u people think ur more peaceful 😂
Yeah the 2 biggest deadliest wars in history were caused by peaceful ppl right?
💣 💥
o k
lmao 🤣Yeah, because when I think of Afghanistan, the first thing that comes to mind is "peace"
jammu and kashmir was is and will be integral part of india🇮🇳🇮🇳
Is it? Why you guys don’t try to take it back from poor little begging Pakistan? You think thats easy? Your military knows how fucked up they will be from tiny pakistan if they even make a little move against them
True
Well who would have thought religion and politics would work well together 😂
There's a Biblical quote that fits here perfectly - "As ye sow, so shall ye reap."
Agree.
As Hindus call KARMA
@@StayFocused-rn9so What does that even mean?
You reap what you sow.
What goes around comes around.
Hillary Clinton warns Pakistan: "You can't keep snakes in your backyard and expect them only to bite your neighbors," - back in 2011
I’m sitting in my room in Vietnam and yet I can hear the very loud laughter of the CIA from the Pentagon.
Pak secret service creates taliban
Peeps: must be cia then
😂
Pentagon isn't laughing, it's highly concerned that a regional major conflict can disturb world trade.
@@puraLusa No, I don’t mean the CIA created the Taliban , I’m referring to the billions dollars worth of modern military equipment conveniently left back in Afghanistan, which may just be bad management and evacuation, but still, this nation is known to be able to spring up dictatorships, engage in drug trades network and support cartels, cover up horrible events from the public’s eye, is it reasonable to think the weapons given to the enemy of their enemy is also the trick up their sleeve. Also, the pentagon might said that they are so “concerned”, but really, they are either going to watch as their two enemies slug it out on each other at best, and engage in selling weapons at worst. Come one, this is the American Empire, they are always playing 4d geo-political chess.
US and India are high fiving as they watch Pakistan shoot itself in the foot.
@@chooseyouhandle yes, and now Joey B is gonna have another place to launder all that sweet, sweet dollars.
@@puraLusa A regional conflict there cannot disrupt world trade.
So glad the US is turning away from Pakistan more and more. It was such a mistake tying ourselves to them.
@@ISLAMMEHMEDOV Pakistan turned its back on the US long ago when they funded the Taliban against the US. They are not our ally.
serves the americans right they thought they could make afghanistan a national democracy
@@ISLAMMEHMEDOVuh, no. US is getting a much stronger ally in india.
@@SelfProclaimedEmperor yup. India can do whatever they want to Pakistan.
@@ISLAMMEHMEDOV I'll take my chances. Good luck with the Taliban. Don't come crying to the US when you need help. Our soldiers want nothing to do with you after what you've done.
Kashmir is internal part of India and use proper map otherwise I will report
Pakistan wanted Afghanistan as “strategic depth”. It is Taliban that has strategic depth in Pakistan now 😂
Oh how the tables have turn 😂
Lmao 🤣
That’s because Taliban are Afghans! Just read the history of Durand line and you’ll know everything. Any government in Afghanistan would never accept the Durand line and will never recognize Pakistan as a friend country
@@justyoua522 Right... All the khyber pakhtunkhwa belongs to Afghanisthan which is illigally occupied by Pakistan
Another example of why instead of supporting para-military forces that you don't control, you should just support your own country's military to (*cough* PMC *cough*).
reminds me of that gta san andreas mission:
Toreno: - "Some traitors from another department think they can help the "overseas situation" by financing militaristic dictators in exchange for arms contracts.”
CJ: - “Ay, ain't that exactly what you do?”
Toreno: - “Well, kind of, but we get to pick our dictators. Degenerates that we can control. We try to stay away from these guys with principles, cause that just muddies the waters.”
The advantage of using PMCs or foreign groups is plausible deniability. They can do things that a country can’t do legally, usually terrorism and/or war crimes.
Now that the US has left it's nice to see that part of the world returning to its natural state.
what has changed? there is still constant warfare, bombings and gun battles in streets.
@@jayzsayz so it was in its natural state with the US there too then I guess.
@@dominuslogik484 After the initial defeat of the Taliban, Afghanistan actually became pretty peaceful. For all of a few years before its resurgence backed by Pakistan.
Grrrr how dare those evil American imperialists give Afghan women rights and freedoms!!
It’s natural state minus water. ME (and Africa) already fighting over water, as predicted last year.
I recently heard someone say “never do a deal with someone you dislike, because it’s always bad business”..
I hope that you live in peace, democracy, equality, and secularism wherever you are.
May God save us from secularism and these vile ideas and corruption of mind and society
@@user-ot2yz7it7i Ok, no one cares about Pakistan and their hobby to murder atheists and whoever they accuse of "atheism"
Just stay in your country and don't export murderers and r@pists to us.
No
Yes.. Good I live in 🇮🇳
@@EmirateOfHind As opposed to?
This tension was created by Pakistan.Pakistan unnecessarily interfered in Soviet Afghan war.Which resulted crisis for Pakistan and huge radicalization across the country.
As an a veteran who was sent over there 05 and 07 , Let them fight.....
Pakistan is a Punjabi Muslim majority country, but Pashtuns are demanding their rights, and the Pakistan Army cannot execute or exterminate Pashtuns as it has done to Balochis and Sindhis. So the next best thing is to get them out of Pakistan so that the remaining Pashtuns can be easily neutralized. And power can be in hands of Pakistan Army.
"Execute or exterminate"? What are u talking about ? There are millions of Balochs and Sindhis in Pakistan and they have a fair say in the Pakistani govt with there being Baloch and Sindhi politicians and political parties who have some power in Pakistan. The ex Pakistani PM was literally a Pashtun. Don't speak nonsense and the current PM is from Balochistan.
🤣🤣🤣 bro watches too much poojeet indian media
@@hellothere1656 PM doesn't mean shit in Pakistan . It is Pak Army which calls the shot. Selected PM Imran khan is in Jail and Selected Interim PM Kakar whose job is conduct elections is transferring millions of acre land to Army for farming.
@@cyberverse9141 i don't watch Indian media. i read quran and Allah himself said it.
@@xenon6947 Then by ur logic, the same applies to india. The indian PM can never go against what the indian army demands or else he'd end up dead like Indira ghandi. Also Imran Khan wasn't "selected", he was voted by the people. I know that because of the huge amount of Pakistanis who support him.
The Pakistani Foreign Minister called the Taliban "our boys".
Interesting video, I need to do some more research on this one!
Who could have known that the ISI's crazy policies would backfire?
Great coverage, again.
Though, I’d like to point out that the “contentious” region marked in the northeast of India is a sovereign state of India, Arunachal Pradesh; and it isn’t contested and China doesn’t have any hold or legitimate claim in the region. Do rectify it.
Great video
It’s important to know that the US backed Taliban through Pakistan to oppose the Soviet Union. I do agree that Pakistan tried to use the Taliban to their own benefit to no avail
Taliban was formed AFTER the Soviet conflict. Make it make sense.
It's important to know the difference between the Mujahideen and the Taliban. Otherwise you might end up claiming that the US backed the Taliban in a war which was over before the Taliban was founded.
The Us backed the mujahideen Pakistan backed the taliban
The Taliban didn't exist in the 80s lol and mujahedeen were a catch all term for the countless factions fighting the soviets.
So... the problem within Afghanistan is the continued adherence to tribal identities. The same problem that's been there for decades.
Uh....try centuries
At this point, de-trabilization is a must.
Oh look ! It's the consequences of my actions coming back to bite my ass .
Kishmir and Arunachal Pradesh is the integral part of india 🇮🇳 please respect our sovereignty
Arunachal maybe but not Kashmir it's a "DISPUTED" LAND according to UNITED NATIONS
@@henryviii8808who even care about UN. They cant even resolve a single conflict.
I wonder if middle east one day will learn peace
It won't Islam screwed them all
I mean Europe went to war for a hundred years in the “hundred years war”, it’s not an Islamic issue
Islam and peace both can't stay together...
This isn't middle east BTW.
US strategy in central and south Asia has failed totally.
They have fostered a relationship with Pakistan, losing India in the process, all while Pakistan funded and maintained relations with the Taliban, who are as anti-american as it gets.
Pakistan is laughing, India is furious and the USA is left with no real influence in the area.
Instead of allying with Pakistan, they should have allied with India. Then they would have the world's largest democracy on board both to help control Iran and the Middle East, as well as China and the Far East.
The USA underestimated Muslim brotherhood and the fact that "moderate Muslims" will always side with their extremist brothers over the infidel. India knows this, Israel knows this, but Europe and America still believe that Islam is a religion of peace.
True that
To be fair to the Americans, Indians were at best frosty towards them right after our independence, part of it was because Nehru was a socialist and equated capitalism with colonialism, part of it was how we didn't like how Americans treated black people back then which was very similar to colonialism. Pakistan on the other hand was always a willing, if treacherous partner.
Lol the US did not "lose" India and US-India positive relationship is growing year after year. This is a bullshit comment.
Indians didn't leave US with any choice in the matter. They aligned with the USSR from the start. US influence in the region is near impossible to begin with.
India made a far bigger mistake in turning away the US, now it is stuck with Russia which is backwards and aligning with China -of which is fermenting trouble to India 24/7 AND trying to steal land. India is isolated with no friends.
Why would we want to ally with India? They're just as treacherous and dishonest as the Pakistanis. India chose to ally with the Russians, so they chose their side and proved once and for all that they don't have any honor or morality. It is funny to see anyone try to claim India is democratic or has anything in common with true democracies though.
Ahhh the age old classic story!!!! Supporting an extrimist group and then it backfired!!!
Taliban isn't bashtu as you said in the first few minutes of your video the meaning is right but the origin is wrong
It's actually an Arabic word that means
2 students
1 student means Talib
2 students means taliban
3 or more students means Tulab
Edit:
Deeper explanation
It is considered an Arabic word Pashto people just use an Arabic word because they don't have a Pashto equivalent for it. (A N) as people stated in replies exists in Arabic, in the arabic language if you want to make a word for 2 people/things then you either add "IN or AN" For example Talibin or Taliban, both of these words mean 2 students in the Arabic language. Arabic has a huge influence in Afghanistan and Pakistan because these 2 nations use the Quran and both of them have been under the Umayyad dynasty which is an Arab dynasty. Also trades with Arab merchants helped out. With all these factors included, we can see how huge the Arabic language and it's influence on these 2 countries Pakistan and Afghanistan. Just like How Greek, and Roman Empires have huge influence over the languages of modern day Europe.
They also butchered al-Zawahiri's name.
The suffix -an (ان-) in Pashto is used for plural. So in Pashto Talib (طالب) means student and Taliban (طالبان) means students.
Saying Taliban is an Arabic word is wrong because this variation of it is Pashto because of the Pashto Suffix, tho the origin of the world is Arabic.
@@BurningMadthe closed caption is auto generated if you're referring to that.
@@bananaclub69 no I'm referring to them saying "al-Zawahi" instead of "Al-Zawahiri".
@@bananaclub69 It still considered an Arabic word Pashto people just use an Arabic word because they don't have a Pashto equivalent for it. (A N) as you stated exists in Arabic, in the arabic language if you want to make a word for 2 people/things then you either add "IN or AN" For example Talibin or Taliban, both of these words mean 2 students in the Arabic language. Arabic has a huge influence in Afghanistan and Pakistan because these 2 nations use Quran and both of them have been under the Umayyad dynasty which is an Arab dynasty. Also trades with Arab merchants helped out. With all these factors included, we can see how huge the Arabic language and it's influence on these 2 countries Pakistan and Afghanistan. Just like How Greek, and Roman Empires have huge influence over the languages of modern day Europe.
This is why you don’t play stupid games in geopolitics it rarely ever works out
One thing is clear though, never let the british ☕ draw borders
Colonial borders are often terrible, but the other way borders are often drawn is worse: war. It should be voluntary and based on diplomacy and compromise.
Natural borders like mountains and rivers aren't that bad. It is when the British randomly draw straight lines is when issues arise.
@@badluck5647most borders in the world aren't rivers and mountains and were drawn in blood including genocide.
U should read up ottoman and soviet border drawing before thinking it's a british exclusive. And for all rules there are exceptions.
@@puraLusa Mountains are the world's oldest borders as they are an obvious, visible dividing line that help defend against invaders. India, Italy, Russia, and Afghanistan have multiple different empires rule over them, but they all used the same mountain ranges as borders for its obvious benefits.
I am an afghan girl living in pakistan looking for a punjabi pakistani boy who will keep me in his house and marry me so that i will not be deported by govt and pakistan.
Play stupid games win stupid prizes
My girl Hillary Clinton was right on: ""You can't keep snakes in your backyard and expect them only to bite your neighbors". Karma is in the works.
Not a nation I'm not sad for them! 😂
Don't invite mice into your house, or you might one day wake up find your rice being eaten.
play stupid games, win stupid prizes
Pakistan really thought it would be different this time around.
pakistan is not claming all of that land 0:31
Yes we are
@@cyberverse9141 do u dare to clash with ur sugar daddy china for aksai chin & shaksgam valley?
@@GAURAV-dm1gm no Kashmiris or Muslims in general live in those regions so why claim it?
A colleague at work has family in Pakistan but has to be careful he is not kidnapped when visiting. His cousin was taken hostage and his umcle had to pay £40000 for his release. He was saying the police are usless as they get paid by the crimminals.
So surprised as Islamic countires had supposed to be so moral...
what was that map?
This is soooooo shocking.
In this video you baselessly claimed that 14 suicide bombings were carried out by afghan nationals without any proof, along with many other lies against war torn afghanistan. A country in which your country of the United kingdom played a very destructive role.
yawn, those terrorists were already in control before 2001
I’ve heard joke how the withdrawal was a 5D chess move by the CIA cause nor the Taliban has weapons to fight Pakistan and Iran with.
🤣🤣
Why Kashmir is shown in Pakistan.
Don't include India's territories in other country (Pakistan).
What is it with this decade and wars?
Every decade has had wars
2010s had Syria, Yemen, the continuation of Afghanistan, the Donbass, the continuation of Somalia, Iraq, Azawad, the jihadists in the Sahel, Libya twice, and tons of smaller insurgencies like Cameroon and Mozambique
@@socialistrepublicofvietnam1500 I know, but this decade had the most high profile wars... I mean ffs, middle east was a mess for thousands of years, yet it still manages to shock people...
@@socialistrepublicofvietnam1500most of them are peace fools...😂😂
Supporting terrorists is a bad idea? Colour me surprised
Ayo 0:06 got me sweatin bullets can you not show such a long clip of a bearded brown man pointing a rifle at me bro I almost got an anxiety attack from that thx😅
Play stupid games, win stupid prizes.
Pakistan and strategy does not go well together
Pakistan tried to play both sides are now getting squashed in the middle.
If you try to tame wolves, you will find it an act of futility and should also expect to get bit (ifnot mauled) in the process.
I am a bit confused. What is it about the deportation of foreigners out of ones country that is "illegal". Is it just an emotionally subjective or descriptive term or is there something explicitedly written somewhere that makes it illegal?
Why this error in map... Correct it fast
6:11 1.7 million Afghans don't live in Pakistan. They live in territory disputed between Afghanistan and Pakistan, meaning according to the Talibam they live on Afghan soil
No it’s not lmao. It’s not Kashmir. KPK is Pakistan lol
@@hammad4178 GIVE AFGHAN ITS LAND BACK
@@VOTVRe Im from Chitral you dirty Bihari lol
@@hammad4178 Lol did you watch the video? Taliban do not recognize the Durand line
@@tamberlame27 Okay and? Some statements hold weight and others are a facade to rally support. I’m from Chitral, there are many Afghans here from a plethora of ethnicities. None of them refute the durrand line. Nor is it ever brought up in conversation. As opposed to Kashmir where the Indian government has 1 million trolls stationed and has had internet black outs since 2016. I don’t need an Indian of all people telling me what happens in my own neighborhood. Stick to your slums in Bihar, keep our names out of your Indian mouth.
While Pakistan has done lots of wrong. I totally agree with them deporting afghanis. It's not sustainable to have so many refugees in your country. Erdogan did same thing with inviting syrian refugees
Syrians aren't refugees, they are ottoman citizens of the neo-ottoman empire Turks decided to create.
Your president repeatedly said this about ex ottoman lands. So shut up, accept them and happy ummah .
@@hamlet557 ?
So if muslims do it to fellow muslims it’s fine, but if Europe does it all of a sudden it’s Islamophobia?
@@hamlet557he's Hindu.
You need to take in refugees if you helped create the refugees. Pakistan helped the Americans ruin Afghanistan. Then they played both sides and helped strengthen the terrorist organizations within Afghanistan. Now they want nothing to do with the people whose lives they deliberately destroyed for their own gain?? Lol. What a joke.
You guys should speak out about this more in terms of it constituting a human rights issue. What Pakistan is planning is illegal under international humanitarian law
No way it's against the law? Someone should tell pakistan, I'm sure if they knew it was illegal they'd stop, I'm sure this is all just 2 big misunderstanding
Peace vs peace competition
Taliban is not students in Pashto, but in Arabic
Afghans are Nationalist, While Pakistanis are fighting civil wars among themselves 😂😂
What civil wars? 😂 what fantasy are you living in kid
"Civil wars"? Is that what ur indian media said ? They also said Pakistan was attacking india with hot weather 😂😂
@@hellothere1656even the Indian media went too far that when locusts arrived in India, they blamed Pakistan for sending locusts by saying "to spread terror". 🤣
Baloch Insurgency, Gilgit-Baltisan protests, Khyber Pakthunwar Insurgency, etc...
@@tarunpandey8339Sindhu desh movement,
Recent protests in baltistan 😂😂
These madarsachap won't accept ...let them live in delusion
Shame both pak & taliban can't both lose..... oh they can!
Pakistanis were the happiest when Taliban tookover, they were literally mocking India for lost investments😂😂
But ofc, no condemnation from any country whatsoever…
When Karma🕉️ is stronger than Kalma ☪️😌🫴
American humvees with Taliban flag. What a time to be alive.
@@prestallar4339 I mean you see F-4 Phantoms and F-14 tomcats being used by Iran so really the middle east is just a mess. you can see shit like a T-55 supported by US MRAPS fighting guys using RPG-7s and Stingers. really its just a boneyard of the cold war in the middle east.
Is that really anything new? US equipment occasionally falls to bad parties -nobody cares when Russian or Chinese equipment falls to their hands though.
@@stephenjenkins7971thats the thing russia and china never claims to be white knight if humanity and human rights , meanwhile usa judge everyone on that scale so when usa does some questionable stuff they gets criticism
@@sk-ig4wt China claims to be peaceful and just doing trade, and Russia claims to be bullied by Western imperialism. Spare me the BS.
More to the point, hypocrisy is nothing compared to actually being horrible in human rights. The fact you care more about hypocrisy than NOT treating people like garbage says a lot.
Correct your map of India J&K and Arunachal Pradesh is part of India.
According to the UN, Jammu & Kashmir is a disputed territory, both claimed by India and Pakistan even China claims some parts of it.
@@talaltariqq_I can understand that but arunachal pradesh dude arunachal pradesh people speak in Hindi
It's actually a majority Muslim population who speaks and write the Pakistani Kashmiri language. They identify themselves as Pakistanis.
@@Nemarh they are only in kashmir valley 15000 km2 area rest jammu is populated by Indians
I wonder who drew those funny squiggly lines? Seems to cause a lot of problems.
Its a story old as world itself Neighbours becoming comrades in arms against united enemy. But once that uniting enemy is gone the neighbours turn their weapons against each other as the uniting factor is no more.
Unless it is against Pakistani law, the forced repatriation of Afghani people is legal. There would be no "unlawful" activities going on. It would be law enforcement.
Given how the UN supports a whole lot of "shady" activities that cannot be discussed on y-tube, I am not inclined to take any of their claims about legality or morality seriously.
May I ask why Jammu Kashmir and Ladakh as well as Arunachal Pradesh territories shaded????
Disputed
It means disputed kid
because different states claim those regions
@@fenrir834I can understand kashmir but arunachal pradesh is an Indian territory
@@pipipupu5104
which is claimed by China and India, while being in indian control
The TTP part is not explained well. TTP simply means Pakistani Taliban Movement which is the same as Afghan Taliban. They consider Afghan Taliban supreme leader to be their leader too. Also, TTP was created by Pakistan to show to US that Pakistani Army is not having full control over the border areas with Afghanistan and hence Afghan Taliban are actually given sanctury by the Pakistani Taliban and not the Pak army.
Not gonna talk about yemen
O!man
Nobody talks about Yemen
@@ad_astra468 i mean the news that they are aiding hamas
"Play stupid games, you win stupid prizes"
Terrorism is the studiest game any country can play and I find... kinda amusing the next chain of thoughts:
Taliban => Terrorist Fanatics => Give support to them => They eventually attack you => o noes => "who could've seen this coming?"
Reminder that TTP is a separate group despite both having "Taliban" in their name
Still, the Taliban is housing TTP in Afghanistan and doing nothing about it.
They couldn't have done it without Pakistani support.
@@NoobKillerTM Pakistan supported Taliban not TTP which is Indian funded
@@cyberverse9141deflecting the guilt to india 😂, aka head in the sand and swimming in a river in egipt
@@cyberverse9141but saar Indians are idol worshippers saar how did they suport ttp saar
To put it bluntly the world is a dam mess.
I mean I can't be that sympathetic to all the Aghan refugees in Pakistan.
I get entirely that you don't necessarily want a fuckton of foreigners in your country all of a sudden.
But... Pakistan... is not a nation state, not even close, the only thing really holding it together is Islam, and there are already fucktons of Pashtuns in Pakistan, the border of the Pashtun "Nation" crosses well into Pakistan and has for a long time. Given this, these "foreigners" aren't that foreign at all, so I don't get why Pakistan is so mad about it, let alone mad enough to deport them all.
Cause pak foreign policy is agressive and violent. A lot of countries adopt this kind of sick deadly games in their foreign policy, some more visible than others and then go cry at the UN and IMF and enter the "blame the west" club. It's hilarious albeit sad.
why can't these countries form a federal body along ethnic lines? basically divide up regions and form a governing body like the US does with the 50 states. make a senate and a congress plus delegate many responsibilities to the local governments.
@@dominuslogik484 cause the current rulling class prefers sick games.
@@dominuslogik484 You expect Pakistan, a military dictatorship, to really go ahead with that?
@@fsdfsdfsd4561 no I don't expect them to do that, I also don't expect any place in the middle east or africa to do anything close to that because they don't just not get along with their neighboring tribes they actively desire to eradicate their neighbors as the single common factor across both regions.
Peaceful vs peaceful = ultimate piece.😌
Average 🐂🐃 worshipers comment
🇹🇳🌹🇵🇰🇦🇫
Chup bihari
"lol" said the scorpion
Money talks, BS walks.
Can you please explain Balochistan?
There is absolutely no way balochistan will survive without pakistan
"Balochistan" was created by a British administrator on 22 February, 1877. His name was Robert Sandemann, it was done in order to annex territory of Persian Empire. The land is called "Mehergarh" which belongs to Brahvi people. Ethnic "Baloch" have no claim on this land because they are Kurds, who migrated from Syria. The British rewarded those Baloch collaborators for their effort drive out Persian rulers, thus renaming the area of Mehergarh into "Balochistan".
The current Pakistani PM is from Balochistan.
@@boobie34Pakistan is not surviving in the first place.
@@NaSaSh1087 true
"Finally US understood it's mistake to support Pakistan"!
Indians:- "Damn it's been 30 years already since we got that, we're old now"😂
India warned west abt islamic terrorism in 1980s
India warned west abt chinese agression in 2000s
India warning west abt war with Russia in 2020s
West never listened once... just kept fecking around and finding out.
US: “first time?”