Je ne peux tout simplement PAS écouter cette oeuvre sans pleurer à chaudes larmes, sans souffrir pour l’humanité et pour Dimash… 😭 Quel INCROYABLE talent! Merci beaucoup Carl.
Conocí a Dimash por casualidad en UA-cam hace un par de años y quede enamorada de su talento y sobre todo de su hermosa alma, simplemente cambió mi vida de obscuridad a luz. Gracias por su reacción a nuestro príncipe kazajo.
I saw him in Budapest performing this. I was worried he wouldn't, because he El amor en ti first, that came after The stoy of one sky in Almaty. But then he sang it and I was excited like a child at chtistmas. I sat at the edge of my seat and nearly didn't breathe. It was so captivating and I felt with him so much and we all in the audience were one. It's an icredible experience that everyone should share. Love to you and peace to the world❤
I was in Budapest, and I was suffocating in tears, I can't put into words what it looks like live. On November 22, you will have the opportunity to hear him in Prague, Czech Republic. Go to his official channel, where it says Dimash News, there you will find a link to sell tickets. A lot of your fellow reactors were in both Budapest and Istanbul for his concert. It would be wonderful if you could come, I believe the Dears would be delighted, many of us follow your reactions, I know for sure that you enjoy great respect among the Dears, because your reactions are one of the best. A deep bow for exceptional knowledge, eloquence and respect for such an artist as Dimash. Greetings from Serbia.
He simply nailed it in Budapest , just like he did in the Almaty concert 🤩 He gave his heart and soul in this performance and received a well deserved standing ovation afterwards 🥰 Both my husband and I cried during this song but also during others. When ever possible you simply MUST see him live ☺️🎶
I saw him in Budapest and I can’t tell you how brilliant he was I cried , I laughed, I was amazed and quite honestly it seems like it was a dream , so much so that I’ve had to buy a ticket to his concert in Prague in November . Shall I save you a seat ? 😊 Everyone HAS to see him in concert !! He’s so kind , sweet and lovable ❤❤❤❤
Hi Carl, I am a fellow South African. I traveled to Istanbul to see Dimash in concert on his birthday. It was an incredible experience and I loved every second. He performed Story of One Sky slightly differently, with added nuances and inflections, but it left me in tears ... again. It was an absolutely amazing experience, worth every single cent!!
People are born with a great gift once every hundred years, or even less often. I am very glad that I hear and see this miracle. Dimash, you are a miracle for people, thank you and your parents for being you, our wonderful, talented one. We love you
I was in his Istanbul concert for the honour of his 30th birthday. Words are not enough to describe how amazing each and every performance of his was. 😍 I hope you’ll have this experience one day in the near future!🙏🙏🙏
I totally agree with you about his annunciation. I have mentioned it before and I have been crucified for it. I absolutely LOVE Dimash but that does not blind me to the fact that he needs to work on it. When having a conversation his accent is adorable, BUT when it comes to singing it is important that the lyrics be understood. He could definitely benefit from working with a diction coach when it comes to the songs.
Lol, thanks for the encouragement! Yes, it was not any easier a second time around. Thank you for your kind words. Please do enjoy the wave of new Dimash reactions that are incoming.
Creo que esta Obra maestra la compuso tan solo con 25 años es increíble este es un hombre sabio es un alma vieja en un cuerpo joven tanta pasión tanta dedicación tanta entrega jamás se ha visto😢😢😢❤❤❤ más solo mejor que nos ha ocurrido en esta última era
Talking about his English, I’m a huge mark knopfler fan and was just watching a live concert. Couldn’t understand a word he was singing. So stop complaining about his English, he is so improving
Здравствуйте уважаемый Карл .Очень рада видеть и слушать Вас снова. Как ни странно, не буду писать о Димаше: о нём прекрасно сказали миллионы поклонников (и Вы в том числе). А я хочу, в очередной раз, сказать, что восхищена Вашей речью - она меня просто завораживает. В наше "цифровое" время это редкость. Если бы мне довелось учиться музыке (хотя мой преклонный возраст не позволяет), то лучшего наставника-преподавателя я бы не желала. Завидую Вашим ученикам. Привет из России с наилучшими пожеланиями.
This concert was before the music video. So his English wouldn't have changed. If you want to see if there is progression in his English, you are going to have to watch a Fan cam from a later concert.
На концерте в Стамбуле 24 мая, в свой день рождения, Димаш исполнял Историю Одного Неба с такой же страстью, болью, очень эмоционально, на разрыв сердца. По другому Димаш не может. Это же его детище. Его послание миру. Осуществилась моя мечта побывать на его концерте. И у меня опять были учащенное сердцебиение и слёзы на глазах... Всем мира и любви!
I was so lucky to attend his concert in Budapest...this was the masterpiece I was waiting for the whole evening, my most favorite song. From the first note until the last, I sobbed my eyes out, totally mesmerized, glued on my chair, absorbing the intense vibes of energie pouring my skin and running trough my body, his vocals piercing my heart and soul. An outstanding experience! A standing ovation of 12000 people followd his last frozen note fading in the air...The 3 hour concert passed in the blink of an eye, leaving me totally flabbergasted but yet filled whith an incredible warm energie, that energie who went back and forth from Di to his audience during the whole concert.When I left the stadion I said to myself...this will not be the last concert I will ever see! I floated for weeks after on that accumulated energie, addictioning stuff, I can assure you! You have to see him live!, Carl That's for shure! Thank you for your sincere comment! Whith ❤ and 🙏!
Grácias querido !! No hay una vez que lo vea y pueda no llorar !! Me degarra el alma su voz, su entrega !! Dimash es...todo lo bueno de un ser humano !! Te abrazo désde Florida Uruguay 🇺🇾❤️
Bonjour. Je pense que nous sommes des millions de personnes de par le monde qui rêvent de voir Dimash en direct en espérant que ce rêve devienne réalité. Sa force d'interprétation est tellement puissante et en même temps si délicate! De par le monde, il existe énormément de chanteurs et chanteuses de très grand talent, mais je n'ai jamais été autant touchée que par cet homme. C'est pour moi quelque chose que je n'ai jamais ressenti auparavant, et je m'efforce de le partager modestement autour de moi. Bien amicalement de France. P.S.: je suis curieuse de voir la nouvelle version de la chaîne WordSmith
Ever since I watched this Almaty version, I vowed I need to see it live. I went to Budapest, with only one hope to watched this song sung live. This was the song that I cried the longest. I mean I cried “hysterically”, uncontrollably. Now, he sing it better than this performance. His low notes are richer, and in every song there is something different that he does so you will realized that it is different. Some nuances, but so delicately beautiful. I can’t even described it. No words actually. It’s exquisite! That feelings will linger and it did made me so weak afterwards. I was right next to dimash father and boy oh boy, i presume he watch this done many times but he still cried too. He cried with us. This song is a masterpiece. And dimash is just a vocal god.
Excellent reaction Carl. Yes, I watched this live at his concert in Kuala Lumpur last year and together with his "Ave Maria" with everyone present demonstrating emotions that reflected his performances. His concerts last three and half hours! Started at 8pm and finished 11.45!! Attending a Dimash live concert was on my bucket list. And is on my bucket list to attend another one! What is also interesting and special about a live concert is the atmosphere created by the audience reactions aplenty there.
Estuve el 24 de mayo en su concierto de Estambul y cuando interpretó esta obra tan magistralmente todo mi cuerpo se estreneció, escuchar esto en vivo es lo más sublime que he escuchado, ver como se entrega a esta interpretación es un verdadero lujo. Poder verlo de verdad que ño agradezco tanto, gracias universo por permitirme verlo ya 2 veces y las que faltan.
Grazie per averla fatta . ❤️ di questa performance conosco ogni singolo fotogramma. É davvero emozionante. Dimash è una gran bella persona. Molte stelle spariranno, la scia del suo passaggio resterà nei secoli a venire. 🇮🇹❤️🇰🇿
Gracias por reaccionar a ésta obra maestra de nuestro querido Dimash!!!Piel de gallina y llanto cada vez que la escucho.Saludos desde Argentina!!!🤗👋👋🇦🇷Paz🙏🙌
This last part, where he’s exhausted from singing with such passion, got to me HARD ! Such an amazing human being !! Thank you for your great reactions Carl ! We all appreciate you !
Good night!! Thank you very much for your reaction; Furthermore, Dimash's English improves every day. And what's really important: this song is a masterpiece. With a lot of effort I have been able to attend Almaty, Yerevan, Hong Kong (where he was ill) and where he finally received a standing ovation in Budapest... this song can only be fully appreciated when you hear it live and the Almaty performance was sublime; because; Apart from his voice, the percussion of his band really made us "fly" as you could see in this reaction... soon he will have a concert in Prague and another in Dusseldorf... see you there??? Greetings from Chile 🇨🇱
Su concierto en Budapest fue espectacular, mágico y alucinante. The History of one Sky la interpretó con tanta emoción y su voz se escucha en vivo más maravillosa que en los videos de You Tube. El público presente lo ovacionó de pie cuando finalizó esta canción,. Tienes que asistir a un concierto de él es una experiencia única que debes tener. Cariños para ti desde Chile. Un largo viaje a Budapest, pero regresé con mi corazón lleno de emociones.
I hope that people really understand his message, because we have not alot of time to choose between good and evil, peace and war, love and hate, justice and injustice. We must choose Wonderful, Counselor, The mighty God, The everlasting Father, The Prince of Peace.
Never, ever criticise his pronunciation in this. How many other artists can even attempt to sing in so many varied languages. Yes, this Dear is coming after you. Anyway, we don't t even need the words to get the message of his music.
Hola, esa fue la primera vez que la cantó, antes de salir el video. Por eso suena igual que en el vídeo. Luego ya hace algún cambio, como con todos los temas. Gracias por la reacción.
Привет, Карл! Спасибо за очередную отличную реакцию на выступление Димаша! Это знаковое произведение, выражающее отношение Димаша к происходящему... Я думаю, что его потрясающий вокал никого не оставит равнодушным. А что касается английского, то невозможно петь на нескольких языках как будто он является его носителем... Кстати, советую посмотреть живое исполнение этой композиции на недавнем концерте в Стамбуле. Еще раз спасибо и удачи!
Спасибо дорогой друг за эмоциональную реакцию вы очень тонко разбираетесь в музыке вы профессионал вы большой молодец Димаш мастер своего дела тысячный раз мы смотрим это замечательное видео и тысячный раз слезы льются рекой не нужны нам войны мы люди живущие на этой планете хотим мира о чем поет наш великолепный Димаш Спасибо вы большой умница будем ждать с нетерпением ваши реакции они очень правдивы
@@trudyamofah7144 English is not the first language of these Chinese kids either, yet they obviously studied and trained their pronunciation to be correct. Why is Dimash unable to do this? He just needs to check the pronunciation of the song lyrics. He doesn't have to give a 2 h lecture in English.
@@trudyamofah7144 You don't have to learn another language, you just need to hire a diction coach to study that one song with you. Opera singers, for example, do that when they have to sing arias in languages that they don't speak. So why can Dimash not do what is standard in the music industry?
Masterpiece ❤❤❤ The King of emotions and vocals! ❤❤❤❤❤❤You must see him live, he is better than on UA-cam. ❤❤❤❤I was at Budapest and Istambul, unforgettable nights. Ofcourse, he was singing TSOOS. Unbelivable emotions! ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Dimash es un ser humano, lleno de sensibilidad y de su voz y su técnica, no puedo opinar porque no soy experta, lo que se, es que Dimash me hace sentir sensaciones únicas. Dimash es un pintor de la voz. Único ❤
Regarding his English improvement in this song, the recent performance in Instanbul is what you are looking for. This Almaty performance was done about the same time or earlier than the MV.
Essa é uma obra-prima de Dimash! Essa apresentação no Concerto de Almaty foi magistral! Dimash é o maior e melhor vocalista masculino do planeta! E quanto ao inglês dele não vejo problema algum, adoro seu sotaque e espero que não perca, porque eu acho um charme! Aliás pra mim essa música bem que poderia ser no idioma Cazaque, pois acho mais bonito que o inglês! Mais em todo caso ele escolheu cantar em inglês e pra está espetacular! ❤❤❤🇧🇷
Thank you for your excellent reaction and analysis,Carl!Personally,I don't mind at all,that Dimash's english pronunciation isn't perfect,after all,my kazakh is pretty rubbish!😂I think,even if you don't catch every single word,the message is pretty clear(and don't forget,many Dears don't even speak english)I always found,that this live performance hit even harder than the video.
Yes, we want his message to come through clearly! More accurate pronunciation of the English lyrics would promote that. Nothing, no one else on Earth, has the flexibility and perfection of technique to carry it off a performance of this song.
Less then 18% of the world speaks English so this makes no sense. That is why there are subs for English and other languages. I understand every word but if I didn’t it would not matter. Music is universal language. I don’t understand a lot of American artists, that’s why it is well known people sing the wrong lyrics I mean did anyone understand bob dylan lol but yet he was very famous. I can maybe understand a regular person having this mindset but a professional in music should know accents don’t matter in music
@@melisvigue7950 Actually, professional singers, especially those with operatic training, work VERY hard to get the pronunciation of foreign languages correct. They take pride in it. You should not take offense when people point out such small errors. The fact that Dimash is actually human like all of us makes his talent and commitment all the more astonishing. Each performance is a marvel, yet he continues to work at getting even better.
I agree that the message here is very strong, and even though we love him, I concur with the need of a clearer pronunciation. Do any DEARS know if Dimash has a coach for English and Mandarin? I realize Dimash sings in several languages, but English does seem to be a language that would have a big impact on his fans. Other than that, this is an ICONIC MASTERPIECE!
Carl, great reaction again, as always. All of us Dears adore his Denglish and would not want him to change much. We have all gotten through the initial “What?” of a few words but I agree a bit of improvement in words such as “fiery” and ‘starve’ would help people hearing him the first time through and would help him get his incredible message across. I, for one, would be happy to work with him on his English pronunciation, any time, any place.😂 I am incredibly humbled and thrilled to have tickets for Prague in November. You just have to see him live. Have you thought about having your subscribers send you and then vlogging about your trip? Count me in to help if you decide to do that. ❤❤❤.
@peggyuser-oq6xz7fg9o If they have already watched all the official versions, I don't see how it will hurt Dimash for them to add value and pleasure to their life, just by watching a fancam. As long as they also watch the official.
Yes, I certainly do agree to what you both have said: after listening to the official one and simply a statement of "wow."I was just taking the opportunity to say that fancams, generally speaking, can and do take views away from him. Good intentions on everyone's part is recognized.
In Istanbul only the first half of the song was live, the second part, staring with the arabic singing, was playback as it usually is. Singing the second part live in a concert would kill his voice!
Great review again, as always! I had hoped you would get into the vocal techniques used to produce the sounds in the "lament" - that whole part of the song that is an eastern-based vocalise. It's so unfamiliar to most listeners that it would be nice to get a "this is how it's done" where we are just listening with jaws dropped. Thanks again! ❤❤
I just want to tell you, I love the sweet nature in your voice, and your love of Dimash, god knows it is such a help for sweetness and love, with all the mayhem and insanity going on.
Carl he did,does it on his diferent ways but never loses the pitch the emotion,he is dimash.I love your reaction and happy that y are a S. africa i lived there since the age of 7yrs old ,then came to europe,States,hve gone back,have a brother that was ans a well known musician in Sa ans now a guitar teacher for he is nearly 74yrs old. THE last was with VOID who are now in europe,he never left SA.he is a true AFRICAN.But my congratulations to the great work ,analysis and articulation of explaining the work of Dimash,i have followed him for over 7yrs and study him,i used to play also in the SA,bassist,very lead style of bassist,Had all types of guitars,went through all the old great ones,at the time we were the band with the strongest music system in the SA.more powerfull than the WHO at that time,we blew money out of my wonderfull mother pockets ,but it was orth it.Thank you1
I really hope you don't take the fancam version. The best quality is in the recording of the Almaty Solo Concert Part 3 on Dimash's channel. It begins with the spoken prologue at 23:23. The acoustic and visual quality is so much better and more impressive than the fancam version. Anyway, I'm looking forward to your video.
Saludos desde Venezuela muchas 😊muchas gracias por compartir y reaccionar a esta obra de arte interpretada por el mejor cantante del 😉 este tema es impresionante 😢 nuestro maestro Dimash se merece todos los reconocimientos del mundo 🌎....sería interesante que por favor reaccionaras a Autumm strom en el concierto en Arnau por favor gracias 😊
It would have been amazing had the audience screamed "we are choosing life" or "peace" instead of yelling Dimash (glad you ended it before that happened).
Siento que tu conentario sobre la pronunciación es irrelevante,nadie más que nuestro Dimash puede cantar e interpretar esta obra de arte.La música se siente en lo mas profundo del corazon y del alma.Cuando Dimash canta en kasajo,chino,ruso ....etc la emoción se siente y se vive de igual manera como si cantara en
I have a question for the knowledgeable Dears. Reactions to this performance all comment on how incredible it is that he maintains such vocal perfection in a live performance, while moving so strenuously and percussively -- especially at the end. I can't help noticing, though, that his singing seems to perfectly match that in the videos behind him. Also, I can't hear any differences from track in the music video. the This suggests to me that he might be lip-syncing to a recorded track. It would be an understandable choice, considering the incredible physical demands of what he does onstage, and it is a stunning virtuoso performance either way. Still, I am curious as to whether it is really live. When I'm bragging up Dimash to my musician son, I want to get it right. ;-)
You are completely right! This performance was entirely lip-synced. What we hear is completely identical to the studio version - from each note to each little accent or even mispronunciation. He can't kill his voice by singing this live close to the end of a 3-4 h concert. However, Dimash does it differently from concert to concert. For example, most of the time, he sings the first parts live while the demanding parts starting with the arabic singing are playback. I think it was only in Yerevan where he sang (a simplified version of) the whole song live. Apart from checking the identity of the voice tracks, you can usually tell when Dimash lip-syncs: he moves much more around during playback performance, up to the crazy jumping things he did in this video (which to me was overacting), and the mic does not stay close to this mouth but is swirled around like a toy. Sadly, lots of Dears sreact allergically to the claim that Dimash lip-syncs certain songs. Only a minority admits that Dimash does it not just on occasion but actually rather frequently.
His English is improving. He recently corrected himself when he mispronounced the word 'lives' when speaking, which he used to say incorrectly every time. This is of course a difficult word in English as the two meanings of the word (ie the noun and the verb) are spelled the same but pronounced differently. He's getting there now. But he still mispronounces 'fiery' as 'fear-y' and 'starve' as 'steer-ve' in this song, even in his latest version in Istanbul. He still has work to do there. I think he has 'vocal memory' of how he has sung it over and over so many times before. This must be a difficult habit to break and may take effort and concentration over and above what he already requires to present this very challenging, emotional and physically demanding song in concert. It might so far have been a step too far. But he will get it in the end. He is a perfectionist as we know.
Mucha Gracias por tu gran análisis. Obra maestra y ahora hay que difundirla, control y maestría de su voz. Referente al video y al directo prefiero este último, no se puede transmitir más y mejor. 🎻🇪🇸🇪🇸
По поводу произнош🎉ения не соглашусь. У нас был юморист, который говорил, что американоговорящие говорят так, как будто они почтоянно что то жюуют. И это правда. Вы не произноситете нормальные звуки. Вы НЕ лучшие.
I'm so done with the constant swipe on non-English speakers speaking /singing in that language that most english speaking people don't even speak properly themselves! Have you heard a Scottish or Welsh native or different parts of England itself speaking English, their language? It's awful!! Dimash is doing fine IMO.
sorry i have to say this you saying his english hasnt improved as much as you expected give him a break how many people can learn so many languages and change from one to the other in live concerts he is doing incredible with his english , english is one of the hardest launguages to learn so cut him some slack less of the nit picking just enjoy him
Get over the English pronunciation "thing"!!! It's more about the sentiment and emotion 😮! Just because you pronounce a language correctly doesn't assure that the meaning is clear. And why does he have to come across as anything other than his unique amazingly brilliant self that's extremely giving? Yeah, I'm a dear that's coming after you? You've reacted to his live performances before, so why are you claiming to not know whether he can pull this off or not?😮 Umm, a bit of click baiting perhaps 😮...
Why should a reactor not mention Dimash´s pronunciation problems? After all, it is a mystery why Dimash is such a perfectionist when it comes to music and singing, yet at the same time utterly negligent about pronunciation. He spent millions on this video because he wanted it to be a global call for peace and understanding. But he failed to hire a diction coach to help him with the correct pronunciation. Why? Many Asian singers have a better pronunciation. Even the kids in his latest "You aise me up" had a much better pronunciation than Dimash. Why? Why is Dimash the best vocalist on the planet, but at the same time the singer with the worst English pronunciation? Sorry, it really bugs me that Dimash doesn't seem to care about this problem.
Je ne peux tout simplement PAS écouter cette oeuvre sans pleurer à chaudes larmes, sans souffrir pour l’humanité et pour Dimash… 😭 Quel INCROYABLE talent! Merci beaucoup Carl.
Best song best reaction
Всегда плачу, когда слушаю эту песню. Огромное вам спасибо за реакцию на Димаша!
Conocí a Dimash por casualidad en UA-cam hace un par de años y quede enamorada de su talento y sobre todo de su hermosa alma, simplemente cambió mi vida de obscuridad a luz.
Gracias por su reacción a nuestro príncipe kazajo.
Muchísimas gracias por esta reacción con tanta sensibilidad...!👍🇪🇸
I saw him in Budapest performing this. I was worried he wouldn't, because he El amor en ti first, that came after The stoy of one sky in Almaty. But then he sang it and I was excited like a child at chtistmas. I sat at the edge of my seat and nearly didn't breathe. It was so captivating and I felt with him so much and we all in the audience were one. It's an icredible experience that everyone should share. Love to you and peace to the world❤
I was in Budapest, and I was suffocating in tears, I can't put into words what it looks like live. On November 22, you will have the opportunity to hear him in Prague, Czech Republic. Go to his official channel, where it says Dimash News, there you will find a link to sell tickets. A lot of your fellow reactors were in both Budapest and Istanbul for his concert. It would be wonderful if you could come, I believe the Dears would be delighted, many of us follow your reactions, I know for sure that you enjoy great respect among the Dears, because your reactions are one of the best. A deep bow for exceptional knowledge, eloquence and respect for such an artist as Dimash. Greetings from Serbia.
Спасибо за реакцию на космического Димаша 😍😍😍👍👍👍💯👑🎤
He simply nailed it in Budapest , just like he did in the Almaty concert 🤩 He gave his heart and soul in this performance and received a well deserved standing ovation afterwards 🥰 Both my husband and I cried during this song but also during others. When ever possible you simply MUST see him live ☺️🎶
Que hermoso privilegio estar en el concierto del mejor cantante del mundo 🌎.....debe ser una experiencia maravillosa 😉
@@fiorelasuarez7872yes, it was. I was at Budapest and Istambul. Unforgettable nights! ❤❤❤❤❤
Almaty concert - this song was lipsynced....
@dear4dimash…..And you know this how?!?
@@lindahake1666 Because I am not stupid 🙄 but don't take me wrong, I absolutely do not mind he did not sing it live, I understand, why he did it...
Будьте здоровы и счастливы ♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️🫂
great reaction. This version always gets me even more than the MV. 💜
Dimash almaty concert full reaction
I saw him in Budapest and I can’t tell you how brilliant he was
I cried , I laughed, I was amazed and quite honestly it seems like it was a dream , so much so that I’ve had to buy a ticket to his concert in Prague in November . Shall I save you a seat ? 😊
Everyone HAS to see him in concert !!
He’s so kind , sweet and lovable ❤❤❤❤
En serio y me imagino la experiencia de otro planeta 😊...que privilegio tienen de escuchar al mejor cantante del mundo 🌎
Hi Carl, I am a fellow South African. I traveled to Istanbul to see Dimash in concert on his birthday. It was an incredible experience and I loved every second. He performed Story of One Sky slightly differently, with added nuances and inflections, but it left me in tears ... again. It was an absolutely amazing experience, worth every single cent!!
People are born with a great gift once every hundred years, or even less often. I am very glad that I hear and see this miracle. Dimash, you are a miracle for people, thank you and your parents for being you, our wonderful, talented one. We love you
I was in his Istanbul concert for the honour of his 30th birthday. Words are not enough to describe how amazing each and every performance of his was. 😍 I hope you’ll have this experience one day in the near future!🙏🙏🙏
100 % agree. I was too in Istanbul.
I totally agree with you about his annunciation. I have mentioned it before and I have been crucified for it. I absolutely LOVE Dimash but that does not blind me to the fact that he needs to work on it. When having a conversation his accent is adorable, BUT when it comes to singing it is important that the lyrics be understood. He could definitely benefit from working with a diction coach when it comes to the songs.
Bless your soul. Putting yourself through both versions oh well a good cry is needed once in a while. Lovely reaction and analysis.
Lol, thanks for the encouragement! Yes, it was not any easier a second time around. Thank you for your kind words. Please do enjoy the wave of new Dimash reactions that are incoming.
Creo que esta Obra maestra la compuso tan solo con 25 años es increíble este es un hombre sabio es un alma vieja en un cuerpo joven tanta pasión tanta dedicación tanta entrega jamás se ha visto😢😢😢❤❤❤ más solo mejor que nos ha ocurrido en esta última era
👍👍👍🌷🌷🌷
Talking about his English, I’m a huge mark knopfler fan and was just watching a live concert. Couldn’t understand a word he was singing. So stop complaining about his English, he is so improving
Здравствуйте уважаемый Карл .Очень рада видеть и слушать Вас снова. Как ни странно, не буду писать о Димаше: о нём прекрасно сказали миллионы поклонников (и Вы в том числе). А я хочу, в очередной раз, сказать, что восхищена Вашей речью - она меня просто завораживает. В наше "цифровое" время это редкость. Если бы мне довелось учиться музыке (хотя мой преклонный возраст не позволяет), то лучшего наставника-преподавателя я бы не желала. Завидую Вашим ученикам. Привет из России с наилучшими пожеланиями.
This concert was before the music video. So his English wouldn't have changed. If you want to see if there is progression in his English, you are going to have to watch a Fan cam from a later concert.
На концерте в Стамбуле 24 мая, в свой день рождения, Димаш исполнял Историю Одного Неба с такой же страстью, болью, очень эмоционально, на разрыв сердца. По другому Димаш не может. Это же его детище. Его послание миру.
Осуществилась моя мечта побывать на его концерте.
И у меня опять были учащенное сердцебиение и слёзы на глазах...
Всем мира и любви!
I was so lucky to attend his concert in Budapest...this was the masterpiece I was waiting for the whole evening, my most favorite song. From the first note until the last, I sobbed my eyes out, totally mesmerized, glued on my chair, absorbing the intense vibes of energie pouring my skin and running trough my body, his vocals piercing my heart and soul. An outstanding experience! A standing ovation of 12000 people followd his last frozen note fading in the air...The 3 hour concert passed in the blink of an eye, leaving me totally flabbergasted but yet filled whith an incredible warm energie, that energie who went back and forth from Di to his audience during the whole concert.When I left the stadion I said to myself...this will not be the last concert I will ever see! I floated for weeks after on that accumulated energie, addictioning stuff, I can assure you! You have to see him live!, Carl That's for shure! Thank you for your sincere comment! Whith ❤ and 🙏!
Grácias querido !! No hay una vez que lo vea y pueda no llorar !! Me degarra el alma su voz, su entrega !! Dimash es...todo lo bueno de un ser humano !! Te abrazo désde Florida Uruguay 🇺🇾❤️
Я была на его концерте в Стамбуле. Эта песня прозвучала так же страстно и великолепно, хотя и немного по другому. Димаш - непревзойденный!
Bonjour. Je pense que nous sommes des millions de personnes de par le monde qui rêvent de voir Dimash en direct en espérant que ce rêve devienne réalité. Sa force d'interprétation est tellement puissante et en même temps si délicate! De par le monde, il existe énormément de chanteurs et chanteuses de très grand talent, mais je n'ai jamais été autant touchée que par cet homme. C'est pour moi quelque chose que je n'ai jamais ressenti auparavant, et je m'efforce de le partager modestement autour de moi. Bien amicalement de France. P.S.: je suis curieuse de voir la nouvelle version de la chaîne WordSmith
Ever since I watched this Almaty version, I vowed I need to see it live. I went to Budapest, with only one hope to watched this song sung live. This was the song that I cried the longest. I mean I cried “hysterically”, uncontrollably. Now, he sing it better than this performance. His low notes are richer, and in every song there is something different that he does so you will realized that it is different. Some nuances, but so delicately beautiful. I can’t even described it. No words actually. It’s exquisite! That feelings will linger and it did made me so weak afterwards. I was right next to dimash father and boy oh boy, i presume he watch this done many times but he still cried too. He cried with us. This song is a masterpiece. And dimash is just a vocal god.
Excellent reaction Carl. Yes, I watched this live at his concert in Kuala Lumpur last year and together with his "Ave Maria" with everyone present demonstrating emotions that reflected his performances. His concerts last three and half hours! Started at 8pm and finished 11.45!! Attending a Dimash live concert was on my bucket list. And is on my bucket list to attend another one! What is also interesting and special about a live concert is the atmosphere created by the audience reactions aplenty there.
Estuve el 24 de mayo en su concierto de Estambul y cuando interpretó esta obra tan magistralmente todo mi cuerpo se estreneció, escuchar esto en vivo es lo más sublime que he escuchado, ver como se entrega a esta interpretación es un verdadero lujo. Poder verlo de verdad que ño agradezco tanto, gracias universo por permitirme verlo ya 2 veces y las que faltan.
Hi Carl what an amazing reaction and what an amazing performance! This exceptional artist its such an amazing human being!
Grazie per averla fatta . ❤️ di questa performance conosco ogni singolo fotogramma. É davvero emozionante. Dimash è una gran bella persona. Molte stelle spariranno, la scia del suo passaggio resterà nei secoli a venire. 🇮🇹❤️🇰🇿
Gracias por reaccionar a ésta obra maestra de nuestro querido Dimash!!!Piel de gallina y llanto cada vez que la escucho.Saludos desde Argentina!!!🤗👋👋🇦🇷Paz🙏🙌
"Это не подлежит обсуждению." Наконец-то это прозвучало. Спасибо Вам за эти слова. . С приветом из России
impecable reaccion , sos lo maximo . abrazo desde uruguay
love your impassioned review of this song. you are unique and riveting to watch.
This last part, where he’s exhausted from singing with such passion, got to me HARD ! Such an amazing human being !! Thank you for your great reactions Carl ! We all appreciate you !
Good night!! Thank you very much for your reaction; Furthermore, Dimash's English improves every day.
And what's really important: this song is a masterpiece. With a lot of effort I have been able to attend Almaty, Yerevan, Hong Kong (where he was ill) and where he finally received a standing ovation in Budapest... this song can only be fully appreciated when you hear it live and the Almaty performance was sublime; because; Apart from his voice, the percussion of his band really made us "fly" as you could see in this reaction... soon he will have a concert in Prague and another in Dusseldorf... see you there??? Greetings from Chile 🇨🇱
Es notorio el playback
De Dimash
Невероятная песня! Невероятное исполнение! Браво, Димаш! Прекрасная реакция, Карл!
Incredible song! Incredible performance! Bravo, Dimash! Thank you, Karl for the great response!
menifesting to watch this MASTERPIECE live!!!
Thank you for that lovely reaction! He really is the best! ❤
Su concierto en Budapest fue espectacular, mágico y alucinante. The History of one Sky la interpretó con tanta emoción y su voz se escucha en vivo más maravillosa que en los videos de You Tube. El público presente lo ovacionó de pie cuando finalizó esta canción,. Tienes que asistir a un concierto de él es una experiencia única que debes tener. Cariños para ti desde Chile. Un largo viaje a Budapest, pero regresé con mi corazón lleno de emociones.
I hope that people really understand his message, because we have not alot of time to choose between good and evil, peace and war, love and hate, justice and injustice. We must choose Wonderful, Counselor, The mighty God, The everlasting Father, The Prince of Peace.
Never, ever criticise his pronunciation in this. How many other artists can even attempt to sing in so many varied languages. Yes, this Dear is coming after you. Anyway, we don't t even need the words to get the message of his music.
awesome!!!
very honest and lovely reaction thank you!!
❤❤
Se siente y se vive de igual manera que si cantara en tu idioma natal.
I was in Istanbul last 24th May and.... he is out of this world!
Hola, esa fue la primera vez que la cantó, antes de salir el video. Por eso suena igual que en el vídeo. Luego ya hace algún cambio, como con todos los temas. Gracias por la reacción.
Привет, Карл! Спасибо за очередную отличную реакцию на выступление Димаша! Это знаковое произведение, выражающее отношение Димаша к происходящему... Я думаю, что его потрясающий вокал никого не оставит равнодушным. А что касается английского, то невозможно петь на нескольких языках как будто он является его носителем... Кстати, советую посмотреть живое исполнение этой композиции на недавнем концерте в Стамбуле. Еще раз спасибо и удачи!
He is just the BEST OF THE BEST❤❤❤❤🎤👑🇰🇿💐💐💐✌🇹🇹
I was in Budapest and watched this live. He nailed it.
Спасибо дорогой друг за эмоциональную реакцию вы очень тонко разбираетесь в музыке вы профессионал вы большой молодец Димаш мастер своего дела тысячный раз мы смотрим это замечательное видео и тысячный раз слезы льются рекой не нужны нам войны мы люди живущие на этой планете хотим мира о чем поет наш великолепный Димаш Спасибо вы большой умница будем ждать с нетерпением ваши реакции они очень правдивы
You need to listen to his 'you raise me up' performance in China ❤❤❤
... in which we see pronunciation mistakes again, which distract from the beautiful voice...
@@mmsminimalmusic3110 it's not his first language and he's come a long way. Try not to fixate on that.
@@trudyamofah7144 English is not the first language of these Chinese kids either, yet they obviously studied and trained their pronunciation to be correct. Why is Dimash unable to do this? He just needs to check the pronunciation of the song lyrics. He doesn't have to give a 2 h lecture in English.
@@mmsminimalmusic3110 why don't you try learning another language and we will see if you can pronounce it as well
@@trudyamofah7144 You don't have to learn another language, you just need to hire a diction coach to study that one song with you. Opera singers, for example, do that when they have to sing arias in languages that they don't speak. So why can Dimash not do what is standard in the music industry?
Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank youuuuu from Argentina !!!! EXCELENTE ANÁLISIS 👏👏👏👏👏 EXCELENTE !!!!! DIMASH💪FOREVER❤
💝🙏🏻 Gracias siempre por tus palabras tus emociones y tu respeto hacia Dimash, gracias desde Sevilla,🌹🌸 The BEST The ONE and The ONLY DIMASH EVER🎶✨🎶
Masterpiece ❤❤❤ The King of emotions and vocals! ❤❤❤❤❤❤You must see him live, he is better than on UA-cam. ❤❤❤❤I was at Budapest and Istambul, unforgettable nights. Ofcourse, he was singing TSOOS. Unbelivable emotions! ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
👋🙏🤗❤
INCREDIBLE!!!! DIMASH IS FROM ANOTHER PLANET
Dimash es un ser humano, lleno de sensibilidad y de su voz y su técnica, no puedo opinar porque no soy experta, lo que se, es que Dimash me hace sentir sensaciones únicas.
Dimash es un pintor de la voz. Único ❤
Regarding his English improvement in this song, the recent performance in Instanbul is what you are looking for. This Almaty performance was done about the same time or earlier than the MV.
💜💜💜
Essa é uma obra-prima de Dimash!
Essa apresentação no Concerto de Almaty foi magistral!
Dimash é o maior e melhor vocalista masculino do planeta!
E quanto ao inglês dele não vejo problema algum, adoro seu sotaque e espero que não perca, porque eu acho um charme!
Aliás pra mim essa música bem que poderia ser no idioma Cazaque, pois acho mais bonito que o inglês!
Mais em todo caso ele escolheu cantar em inglês e pra está espetacular!
❤❤❤🇧🇷
He wrote the music and it took him 3 years to write.
It took him three years to make the video - not just the music
Thank you for your excellent reaction and analysis,Carl!Personally,I don't mind at all,that Dimash's english pronunciation isn't perfect,after all,my kazakh is pretty rubbish!😂I think,even if you don't catch every single word,the message is pretty clear(and don't forget,many Dears don't even speak english)I always found,that this live performance hit even harder than the video.
Dimash ❤ Love from Turkey..
Yes, we want his message to come through clearly! More accurate pronunciation of the English lyrics would promote that. Nothing, no one else on Earth, has the flexibility and perfection of technique to carry it off a performance of this song.
Less then 18% of the world speaks English so this makes no sense. That is why there are subs for English and other languages. I understand every word but if I didn’t it would not matter. Music is universal language. I don’t understand a lot of American artists, that’s why it is well known people sing the wrong lyrics I mean did anyone understand bob dylan lol but yet he was very famous. I can maybe understand a regular person having this mindset but a professional in music should know accents don’t matter in music
No matter what language, if Dimash is transmitting an important message we want everyone to understand it.
@@melisvigue7950 Actually, professional singers, especially those with operatic training, work VERY hard to get the pronunciation of foreign languages correct. They take pride in it. You should not take offense when people point out such small errors. The fact that Dimash is actually human like all of us makes his talent and commitment all the more astonishing. Each performance is a marvel, yet he continues to work at getting even better.
This brought me to tears. Tears for Palestine. Dimash is such a relief from the horror going on in our lives.
💔💔💔🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸❤️❤️❤️
We are many who carry Palestine in our hearts.... Greetings from Dear in Sweden.
I agree that the message here is very strong, and even though we love him, I concur with the need of a clearer pronunciation. Do any DEARS know if Dimash has a coach for English and Mandarin? I realize Dimash sings in several languages, but English does seem to be a language that would have a big impact on his fans. Other than that, this is an ICONIC MASTERPIECE!
Carl, great reaction again, as always. All of us Dears adore his Denglish and would not want him to change much. We have all gotten through the initial “What?” of a few words but I agree a bit of improvement in words such as “fiery” and ‘starve’ would help people hearing him the first time through and would help him get his incredible message across. I, for one, would be happy to work with him on his English pronunciation, any time, any place.😂 I am incredibly humbled and thrilled to have tickets for Prague in November. You just have to see him live. Have you thought about having your subscribers send you and then vlogging about your trip? Count me in to help if you decide to do that. ❤❤❤.
If This Doesn’t Prove DQ To Be
The “Greatest Singer” On The Planet Ever‼️✨🤍✨
Well, Then The Possibility
Just Does Not Exist‼️ 🫠
🤍&🕊️2U&ALLU🤍🦌💫🌎🇺🇸
You should listen to the more recent live version from Istanbul. I am telling you wow.
Are you referring to a Fancam? Those take views away from Dimash. As Dears I would argue it is ill-advised to continue recommending any Fancam.
@peggyuser-oq6xz7fg9o
If they have already watched all the official versions, I don't see how it will hurt Dimash for them to add value and pleasure to their life, just by watching a fancam. As long as they also watch the official.
@@peggyuser-oq6xz7fg9o I am referring to the fact that I just saw it live in Istanbul.
Yes, I certainly do agree to what you both have said: after listening to the official one and simply a statement of "wow."I was just taking the opportunity to say that fancams, generally speaking, can and do take views away from him. Good intentions on everyone's part is recognized.
In Istanbul only the first half of the song was live, the second part, staring with the arabic singing, was playback as it usually is. Singing the second part live in a concert would kill his voice!
I absolutely love this performance!
Great review again, as always! I had hoped you would get into the vocal techniques used to produce the sounds in the "lament" - that whole part of the song that is an eastern-based vocalise. It's so unfamiliar to most listeners that it would be nice to get a "this is how it's done" where we are just listening with jaws dropped. Thanks again! ❤❤
Thank you very much.♥️🎈
I just want to tell you, I love the sweet nature in your voice, and your love of Dimash, god knows it is such a help for sweetness and love, with all the mayhem and insanity going on.
Hi
Carl he did,does it on his diferent ways but never loses the pitch the emotion,he is dimash.I love your reaction and happy that y are a S. africa i lived there since the age of 7yrs old ,then came to europe,States,hve gone back,have a brother that was ans a well known musician in Sa ans now a guitar teacher for he is nearly 74yrs old. THE last was with VOID who are now in europe,he never left SA.he is a true AFRICAN.But my congratulations to the great work ,analysis and articulation of explaining the work of Dimash,i have followed him for over 7yrs and study him,i used to play also in the SA,bassist,very lead style of bassist,Had all types of guitars,went through all the old great ones,at the time we were the band with the strongest music system in the SA.more powerfull than the WHO at that time,we blew money out of my wonderfull mother pockets ,but it was orth it.Thank you1
I really hope you don't take the fancam version. The best quality is in the recording of the Almaty Solo Concert Part 3 on Dimash's channel. It begins with the spoken prologue at 23:23. The acoustic and visual quality is so much better and more impressive than the fancam version. Anyway, I'm looking forward to your video.
Love you Carl💜and all your heartfelt, knowledgeable comments and reactions to Beloved Dimash.💜😊💜
Que hermosa reacción 😍 muchas gracias por compartir en tu canal a esta obra de arte maravillosa interpretada por el mejor cantante del mundo 🌎
I saw him in Budapest. Story of one Sky had me covered in ‘hoendervleis’😜 the whole time, until the tears just flowed!
Que hermoso comentario cuando dijiste es Dimash 😊
Спасибо за искреннюю реакцию!❤
Saludos desde Venezuela muchas 😊muchas gracias por compartir y reaccionar a esta obra de arte interpretada por el mejor cantante del 😉 este tema es impresionante 😢 nuestro maestro Dimash se merece todos los reconocimientos del mundo 🌎....sería interesante que por favor reaccionaras a Autumm strom en el concierto en Arnau por favor gracias 😊
Hola amigo, yo estuve en Budapest y Armenia y cada vez que la canta,lo hace de distinta forma, un saludo desde Barcelona España
It would have been amazing had the audience screamed "we are choosing life" or "peace" instead of yelling Dimash (glad you ended it before that happened).
Siento que tu conentario sobre la pronunciación es irrelevante,nadie más que nuestro Dimash puede cantar e interpretar esta obra de arte.La música se siente en lo mas profundo del corazon y del alma.Cuando Dimash canta en kasajo,chino,ruso ....etc la emoción se siente y se vive de igual manera como si cantara en
I have a question for the knowledgeable Dears. Reactions to this performance all comment on how incredible it is that he maintains such vocal perfection in a live performance, while moving so strenuously and percussively -- especially at the end. I can't help noticing, though, that his singing seems to perfectly match that in the videos behind him. Also, I can't hear any differences from track in the music video. the This suggests to me that he might be lip-syncing to a recorded track. It would be an understandable choice, considering the incredible physical demands of what he does onstage, and it is a stunning virtuoso performance either way. Still, I am curious as to whether it is really live. When I'm bragging up Dimash to my musician son, I want to get it right. ;-)
You are completely right! This performance was entirely lip-synced. What we hear is completely identical to the studio version - from each note to each little accent or even mispronunciation. He can't kill his voice by singing this live close to the end of a 3-4 h concert. However, Dimash does it differently from concert to concert. For example, most of the time, he sings the first parts live while the demanding parts starting with the arabic singing are playback. I think it was only in Yerevan where he sang (a simplified version of) the whole song live.
Apart from checking the identity of the voice tracks, you can usually tell when Dimash lip-syncs: he moves much more around during playback performance, up to the crazy jumping things he did in this video (which to me was overacting), and the mic does not stay close to this mouth but is swirled around like a toy.
Sadly, lots of Dears sreact allergically to the claim that Dimash lip-syncs certain songs. Only a minority admits that Dimash does it not just on occasion but actually rather frequently.
Now, now, let's not steer our sweet Carl toward a minefield! 😉
@@mrychards6682 😆
His English is improving. He recently corrected himself when he mispronounced the word 'lives' when speaking, which he used to say incorrectly every time. This is of course a difficult word in English as the two meanings of the word (ie the noun and the verb) are spelled the same but pronounced differently. He's getting there now. But he still mispronounces 'fiery' as 'fear-y' and 'starve' as 'steer-ve' in this song, even in his latest version in Istanbul. He still has work to do there. I think he has 'vocal memory' of how he has sung it over and over so many times before. This must be a difficult habit to break and may take effort and concentration over and above what he already requires to present this very challenging, emotional and physically demanding song in concert. It might so far have been a step too far. But he will get it in the end. He is a perfectionist as we know.
Mucha Gracias por tu gran análisis. Obra maestra y ahora hay que difundirla, control y maestría de su voz. Referente al video y al directo prefiero este último, no se puede transmitir más y mejor. 🎻🇪🇸🇪🇸
❤❤❤❤❤
По поводу произнош🎉ения не соглашусь. У нас был юморист, который говорил, что американоговорящие говорят так, как будто они почтоянно что то жюуют. И это правда. Вы не произноситете нормальные звуки. Вы НЕ лучшие.
👋🇱🇻❤️🙏🙏🙏🌍🕊🙏🙏🙏🇰🇿
This is stil a few years old take, now is much better, as Budapest, but not from his official page.
I'm so done with the constant swipe on non-English speakers speaking /singing in that language that most english speaking people don't even speak properly themselves! Have you heard a Scottish or Welsh native or different parts of England itself speaking English, their language? It's awful!! Dimash is doing fine IMO.
sorry i have to say this you saying his english hasnt improved as much as you expected give him a break how many people can learn so many languages and change from one to the other in live concerts he is doing incredible with his english , english is one of the hardest launguages to learn so cut him some slack less of the nit picking just enjoy him
Get over the English pronunciation "thing"!!! It's more about the sentiment and emotion 😮! Just because you pronounce a language correctly doesn't assure that the meaning is clear. And why does he have to come across as anything other than his unique amazingly brilliant self that's extremely giving? Yeah, I'm a dear that's coming after you? You've reacted to his live performances before, so why are you claiming to not know whether he can pull this off or not?😮 Umm, a bit of click baiting perhaps 😮...
Why should a reactor not mention Dimash´s pronunciation problems? After all, it is a mystery why Dimash is such a perfectionist when it comes to music and singing, yet at the same time utterly negligent about pronunciation. He spent millions on this video because he wanted it to be a global call for peace and understanding. But he failed to hire a diction coach to help him with the correct pronunciation. Why? Many Asian singers have a better pronunciation. Even the kids in his latest "You aise me up" had a much better pronunciation than Dimash. Why? Why is Dimash the best vocalist on the planet, but at the same time the singer with the worst English pronunciation? Sorry, it really bugs me that Dimash doesn't seem to care about this problem.