Why is Pakistan so Inbred?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 26 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ •

  • @5556bbbc
    @5556bbbc 3 місяці тому +970

    great video! you clearly did a lot of research and kept it unbiased and straight to the point.

    • @AkshatSingh-j6m
      @AkshatSingh-j6m 3 місяці тому

      ua-cam.com/video/95SmaYTcLg8/v-deo.html

    • @paulaharrisbaca4851
      @paulaharrisbaca4851 2 місяці тому +8

      I remembered at 11:39 about the immediate post WWII term of "DP's" or "Displaced Persons" which you heard constantly, my mom said, the same way ypu heard it on Radio Free Europe after the War, people who had been displaced and that had no actual propertyy or home left, had no idea where their families were, and so on.....in "Miracle on 34th St" there is a scene with a little Dutch girl who was displaced and who talked to "Sinter Klaas" and that whole wartime attitude in the media....there was a comic strip called "Dondi" about a little Italian boy who lived with the occupation forces in Italy, as I recall....

    • @mccookboidat
      @mccookboidat 2 місяці тому +2

      Calling them inbred is biased

    • @hawk5096
      @hawk5096 2 місяці тому +41

      No, it's accurate. ​@@mccookboidat

    • @varoonnone7159
      @varoonnone7159 2 місяці тому +24

      Saying that Islam is not to blame is misleading
      I'm from Mauritius and Muslim Mauritians immigrated to Mauritius as indentured labourers from 1834 to the 1920s just as Hindu indentured labourers
      Most of the Hindus and Muslims came from current day Bihar
      Yet, to this day, cousin marriage is prevalent in Mauritius among muslims to the point that the government had to ask muslim authorities to discourage cousin marriages due to the heavy number of children born with congenital defects in these families

  • @vienogola1421
    @vienogola1421 3 місяці тому +4148

    In African culture...wait let me say Kenyan culture it's taboo...in fact you can't even marry within the clan...you find a mate as far from your bloodline as possible.

    • @AthelstansSuccessor
      @AthelstansSuccessor 2 місяці тому

      And still come out inbred

    • @SakuraAsranArt
      @SakuraAsranArt 2 місяці тому +426

      Very sensible.

    • @ChrispyDubstep
      @ChrispyDubstep 2 місяці тому +381

      In South Korea it used to be illegal to marry someone with the same surname as you

    • @stevenmike1878
      @stevenmike1878 2 місяці тому +271

      in native American cultures it was considered incest to mingle with anyone inside the same clan tribe, so two tribes would broker an agreement, sometime men would visit the other tribe but the woman and children made stayed, or the woman would go to other tribe and stay with the new tribe.

    • @ninagill1407
      @ninagill1407 2 місяці тому +41

      Same as in the Sikh culture.

  • @FreshLounger
    @FreshLounger 2 місяці тому +1684

    I once asked a Pakistani why they marry so many close relatives. His answer was, "It keeps the money in the family."

    • @leonhenry4861
      @leonhenry4861 2 місяці тому

      Imagine having that idea for money, like Pakistani is the Mecca of the planet lol the place is a shite hole. No offence 😮

    • @CrystalRaye
      @CrystalRaye 2 місяці тому +267

      Basically the same reason a lot of European nobility and royalty where inbred. Didn't have to split up the inheritance as much.

    • @viciouslady1340
      @viciouslady1340 2 місяці тому +139

      And genetic illnesses

    • @abhilash9918
      @abhilash9918 2 місяці тому +41

      This actually true. We have some communities in india eho do this for exactly this reason. But majority hindus dont cuz of strict religious and traditional code.
      Indian muslims do it too but i dont think they do it for assets because unlike paxtani punjabi muslims who are basically a landed community indian muslims by and large are at the bottom of economic ladder.
      Search about practice of nikah halala and youd be surprised

    • @rupsamukherjee3679
      @rupsamukherjee3679 2 місяці тому +49

      They have money? 😮

  • @ziopera9601
    @ziopera9601 3 місяці тому +2411

    WTF IS THAT SOUND BRO I THOUGHT MY HEADSET WAS COOKED

    • @stevenmike1878
      @stevenmike1878 2 місяці тому +138

      dude i thought the same

    • @Thejbelow
      @Thejbelow 2 місяці тому +103

      LOL same, jiggling cords n shit

    • @midloran
      @midloran 2 місяці тому +40

      It's just a background beat

    • @fajaradi1223
      @fajaradi1223 2 місяці тому +85

      I think his audio interface or mixer is crooked.

    • @Ash_Queen16
      @Ash_Queen16 2 місяці тому +46

      Lmao right? I was like “what kind of music is this??” 😵‍💫

  • @elonnut
    @elonnut 2 місяці тому +882

    I knew a girl in the uk who ran away from her parents because they were trying to send it to Pakistan to marry her first cousin. She luckily made it away with help from the police & government

    • @MolGaeilge
      @MolGaeilge 2 місяці тому

      Im surprised the UK government didnt extradite her in chains to mot appear culturally insensitive.

    • @Truthbetold367
      @Truthbetold367 2 місяці тому

      Yh, and her family are going against Islam. You can’t force someone to marry another in Islam. This is culture not religion (although cousin marriages are allowed I’m forking about the force aspect which is why Pakistan is so inbred). In general if cousin marriages occur occasionally it isn’t bad and chance of child with genetic disorder is only 1 to 2% higher non related couples who have children. If it was Islam most countries Muslim counties would face the same problem, yet it is decreasing in places like Palestine and UAE as mentioned in the video.

    • @toomanymarys7355
      @toomanymarys7355 2 місяці тому +31

      That is very common.

    • @rustledjammies8769
      @rustledjammies8769 2 місяці тому

      @@toomanymarys7355 It's insanely common. It happens to Indians, Bangladeshis, Sri Lankans, Iranians and Afghanis, too, as well as those from a bunch of African countries.

    • @N7_YES
      @N7_YES 2 місяці тому +10

      Parents ae evil... 😊😊😊

  • @murrayeldred3563
    @murrayeldred3563 3 місяці тому +2419

    As I said to a British passport holder of Pakistani descent= Pakistanis may be around 3% of the British population- but around 50% of children with profound physical or mental disabilities causing a great cost to the NHS are from this background. He disputed this vigorously until I show he Statistics on the level of disabilities of such offspring.

    • @mdas5990
      @mdas5990 2 місяці тому +55

      Do you even know what is Pakistan? GO and watch Harris Sultan, Pakistani Exmuslim. He will tell you the truth.

    • @ponygirl6258
      @ponygirl6258 2 місяці тому +195

      @@blueboy3990 NHS, Born in Bradford studies, statistics on neonatal genetic anomalies in the UK. UA-cam generally doesn't allow links, so you'll have to search up the sources yourself.

    • @enkisdaughter4795
      @enkisdaughter4795 2 місяці тому +28

      It’s huge.

    • @NotiBoii-c6l
      @NotiBoii-c6l 2 місяці тому +21

      @@mdas5990 daniel haqiqatjou the slayer of all of your illegitimate fathers

    • @FindingCreatures
      @FindingCreatures 2 місяці тому +18

      @@mdas5990are Harris or whoever that is? This is like the third time you’ve commented the same thing

  • @TheAvgWoman
    @TheAvgWoman 2 місяці тому +1279

    So, everytime I've been to a Pakistani wedding... I see several disabled individuals. More than usual. It's sad and such a disservice to your future kids to not give them a fair chance.

    • @horatiohuffnagel7978
      @horatiohuffnagel7978 2 місяці тому

      Is it a bangin party though? Cousin banging that is!! 😂

    • @UndoEverything
      @UndoEverything 2 місяці тому

      Why are you lying? And what is the ratio of "every time"? Why those "several disabled individuals" are not visible when I visited Pakistan and lived there for 6 months? As you are certified liar, so according to your logic, your whole family is disabled because you spreading lies and you tell everyone that your family is healthy. Thus , you are needed to be admitted in lunatic asylum.

    • @RavenHaili
      @RavenHaili 2 місяці тому

      It's because they don't have proper morals, the children aren't special to them, just chess pieces and bodies they can control.

    • @veraaddoyobo8482
      @veraaddoyobo8482 2 місяці тому +21

      Another way to make money

    • @daenytargaryen8929
      @daenytargaryen8929 2 місяці тому +62

      Well my ex boyfriend i dated before told me..his parents are arranging marriage for his brother to his cousin..i ask the distance and between his brother and his cousing..he said their mom are siblings😮😮😮😮... btw he have brothers who have mental issues...i dont know if due to interbreeding

  • @zgdafzgdaf4264
    @zgdafzgdaf4264 2 місяці тому +903

    Iceland has a family tree card to make sure you don’t mess with a relative. Also even the Pennsylvania Amish goes to the Midwest Amish to make sure new genes are introduced. I think it’s just natural to do this for survival.

    • @godjesus2107
      @godjesus2107 2 місяці тому

      To be a douchebag and pump and dump every woman in existence. Stop hating on cousins!

    • @kjaubrey4816
      @kjaubrey4816 2 місяці тому +38

      And Iceland has a very small population. It seems it would be hard to avoid. Glad you guys have ways to avoid that.

    • @mghegotagun
      @mghegotagun 2 місяці тому +21

      I thought Iceland has an app for that now.

    • @gaius_enceladus
      @gaius_enceladus 2 місяці тому +7

      @@mghegotagun I'm pretty sure they do.

    • @45johngalt
      @45johngalt 2 місяці тому +18

      and in some REALLY rural parts in America (specifically the Appalachias) DNA testing is required to get a marriage license.

  • @Lilliz91
    @Lilliz91 2 місяці тому +217

    Inbreeding is shown to increase aggression as well.

    • @helendancelot
      @helendancelot 2 місяці тому +4

      I had not heard that

    • @trevinschaerr3732
      @trevinschaerr3732 2 місяці тому

      Explains why the Middle East is so violent and why so many kings and queens in history have had unreasonable tempers.

    • @komlat253
      @komlat253 2 місяці тому +17

      That's why the world is so historically so angry haha

    • @Abhishek-zq7ur
      @Abhishek-zq7ur 2 місяці тому

      @@komlat253u mean Pakistanis are so angry? Everywhere they go? For things that’s has nothing to do with them? From Charlie hebdo to Palestinian riots in the west!

    • @Tate525
      @Tate525 2 місяці тому +1

      @@komlat253 Yup we as a specie are pretty inbred.

  • @theodoreconstantini2548
    @theodoreconstantini2548 2 місяці тому +523

    Apparently first - cousin marriage in Pakistan is as high as 70 percent , that is incredible.

    • @Adler133792
      @Adler133792 2 місяці тому +49

      Explains somehow the state of this country IMO.

    • @ConstructionHoney
      @ConstructionHoney 2 місяці тому +9

      Ah it's done over multiple generations

    • @theodoreconstantini2548
      @theodoreconstantini2548 2 місяці тому +21

      @@ConstructionHoney Yes it is, and it will take many generations to undone the damage. As one or two generations is not enough to reverse the situation as this has been going on for hundreds of years.

    • @fangdog291
      @fangdog291 2 місяці тому

      ​@@theodoreconstantini2548at that level of consanguinity, can the damage even be undone in 4 or 5 generations? Cousin marriage rates are increasing in Pakistan. Quite messed up

    • @ronblack7870
      @ronblack7870 2 місяці тому +8

      @@ConstructionHoney which adds up to time bombs genetically in society.

  • @TheOfficialZombieWhisperer
    @TheOfficialZombieWhisperer 3 місяці тому +1964

    Why is it that tribal people like in the Americas are so strict on who could be with who, without formal education they understood how stupid inbreeding is.

    • @FrithonaHrududu02127
      @FrithonaHrududu02127 3 місяці тому +30

      What?

    • @ZaneStachowski
      @ZaneStachowski 3 місяці тому +379

      They're asking how Native Americans knew that inbreeding was a problem, despite a lack of formal education.

    • @Lucas_Antar
      @Lucas_Antar 3 місяці тому +246

      They tried it and saw.

    • @flickrebeat8936
      @flickrebeat8936 3 місяці тому

      Well because they did have an Understanding of Biology, and the way things should be, despite what White people say about Incas they did not Allow siblings to get married, only white people want that even today look at the South 😂 There's literally a video of A Girl whose cousin burnt a place cause he wanted her and she said no 😂

    • @flickrebeat8936
      @flickrebeat8936 3 місяці тому +55

      Because Formal education can be wrong 😂 and also they had an Understanding of Biology

  • @tangaz5819
    @tangaz5819 3 місяці тому +1346

    Shared a house with a lovely pakistani couple in England, was a bit shocked when I found out they were 1st cousins. That was wild to me. Their first baby was sadly born dead. They moved back home and last i heard, they had another child. I often wondered if being related like that was a factor in their first tragic loss.

    • @Tragic.Kingdom
      @Tragic.Kingdom 2 місяці тому +216

      Yes , it's called genetic disease

    • @thespectre717
      @thespectre717 2 місяці тому +114

      Most likely yes

    • @jordanjay1479
      @jordanjay1479 2 місяці тому

      Islam permits cousin marriage. That's why it's so common

    • @nunyabiznes33
      @nunyabiznes33 2 місяці тому +65

      Almost certainly.

    • @dougieranger
      @dougieranger 2 місяці тому +35

      @@tangaz5819 Highly likely.

  • @Azda-emina
    @Azda-emina 2 місяці тому +141

    As a pakistani NOT married to a cousin and not knowing anyone in my circle who is, this was fascinating. Pakistani daramas really romanticise cousin marriages...its so disgusting. Its 'allowed' in islam just like it isnt 'illegal' in many countries but that shouldn't mean that you just chase after cousin marriages in this manner.

    • @ibrahimihsan2090
      @ibrahimihsan2090 2 місяці тому +3

      Are you saying it's not allowed in Islam?
      Mind you, I also find it shocking that the overall majority of marriages in Pakistan involve relatives but that doesn't turn marrying one's cousin into an immoral practice.
      Just doing so in excess is bad.
      Marrying different families instead of only close relatives is very encouraged in Islam.

    • @adrianadam8543
      @adrianadam8543 2 місяці тому

      If it’s 70% that means 60 million non cousin marriages so there is hope.

    • @MistarZtv
      @MistarZtv Місяць тому +2

      It's really weird situation.
      There's a lot of things that are technically allowed like slavery for example, doesn't mean we should keep doing it. 😭

    • @BarlasF
      @BarlasF Місяць тому

      @@ibrahimihsan2090pakistan is not a country it an a**hole

    • @sananguliyev4940
      @sananguliyev4940 Місяць тому

      not only it's allowed, but "the best man", "an example for us all", Muhammad married his first cousin Zainab

  • @letsgoeverywhere
    @letsgoeverywhere 3 місяці тому +1061

    I work in medical research and in a particular disease group caused by consanguinity. It's not just Pakistanis (tho they are well represented), it's any insular community like Amish, Mennonites, Orthodox Jews, etc etc. Horrible results for the kids.

    • @FrithonaHrududu02127
      @FrithonaHrududu02127 3 місяці тому

      I've heard that the single most inbred group in America are the Hutterite.Is that true

    • @here_we_go_again2571
      @here_we_go_again2571 3 місяці тому

      Arabs, Hillbillies,
      Rednecks, People
      from rural isolated
      areas

    • @guycrew3973
      @guycrew3973 3 місяці тому +12

      How bad are the effects on the kids

    • @here_we_go_again2571
      @here_we_go_again2571 3 місяці тому

      @@guycrew3973
      Genetic-based diseases and physical
      weakness as well as increased chance
      of mental deficiencies ("mental retardation"
      etc.), insanity, deafness, blindness
      " *The Consequences of Marrying Your Cousin* "(Genetic Disorder Documentary) |
      ua-cam.com/video/kyNP3s5mxI8/v-deo.html
      *List of genetic disorders*
      en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_genetic_disorders

    • @bornstar481
      @bornstar481 2 місяці тому +107

      @@guycrew3973it just depends on luck but everyone has faulty genes and faulty genes are recessive 90 percent of the time. So when you marry someone close to your genetics your kids end up collecting both genes for a dangerous recessive trait.

  • @891Henry
    @891Henry 2 місяці тому +467

    Keeping property/wealth/power in the family was the downfall of the Habsburgs.

    • @stefanvas6984
      @stefanvas6984 2 місяці тому

      Also the reason for their rise to power... but I am not going to defend 1st cousin marriage in the 21st century

    • @adrianromagnano6384
      @adrianromagnano6384 2 місяці тому +1

      The chin or something?

    • @ChineduOpara
      @ChineduOpara 2 місяці тому +13

      ​@@adrianromagnano6384 Yes, the chin. And other body parts.

    • @fullmetaltheorist
      @fullmetaltheorist 2 місяці тому +4

      I wonder why and how they even made it this far. Like at some point all the cousin marriages would have a clear and visible effect on society.

    • @ChineduOpara
      @ChineduOpara 2 місяці тому +6

      @@fullmetaltheorist Not always. Especially when the people involved are rich, powerful, and can hide things.

  • @CeruleanTalon1
    @CeruleanTalon1 3 місяці тому +1330

    I had a Pakistani student who said she was so sad because she had not first cousins to marry. To her it was made to be the most romantic thing in the world and many of her romance novels were of first cousin marriages. She very much denied and was convinced that genetic inbreeding was detrimental, saying studies proved her right.

    • @mdas5990
      @mdas5990 2 місяці тому

      Do you even know what is Pakistan? GO and watch Harris Sultan, Pakistani Exmuslim. He will tell you the truth. In Pakistan , mullahs encourage 1st cousin marriage as it is recommended in Islam.

    • @carthicss1
      @carthicss1 2 місяці тому +102

      Doesn't she have brothers?

    • @SopranosTV1
      @SopranosTV1 2 місяці тому +256

      It's all the romantication done by the Pakistani dramas

    • @20SG20
      @20SG20 2 місяці тому +29

      ​@@SopranosTV1 Is this real?

    • @SopranosTV1
      @SopranosTV1 2 місяці тому +185

      @20SG20 is quite real. It's like the theme of the majority of the dramas on TV. Two cousins falling in love.

  • @DeeKate
    @DeeKate 2 місяці тому +177

    I live in Toronto, Canada and about 4 years back, my Canadian-born Pakistani coworker married his first cousin. He lied about it being a childhood friend but then got a little tipsy at our staff party and admitted it's his mother's, sisters daughter. His first cousin.

    • @sriya.s09
      @sriya.s09 2 місяці тому +5

      no way... thats so weird what

    • @intellectualcucumber
      @intellectualcucumber 2 місяці тому +17

      Why is he getting tipsy? Isn't drinking against Islam?

    • @okangulal2849
      @okangulal2849 2 місяці тому +27

      @@intellectualcucumber It is against Islam, but either some Muslims don't care as they are not that religious, or have a different interpretation of the Quaran.

    • @tiffany.Elizabeth.
      @tiffany.Elizabeth. 2 місяці тому

      Absolutely vile

    • @adrianadam8543
      @adrianadam8543 2 місяці тому

      Pakistanis or anyone are not Islam following machines. They are human.

  • @DeclanWhite1453
    @DeclanWhite1453 2 місяці тому +542

    Growing up in the midlands you can actually see the population begin to genetically collapse in some places

    • @obesetuna3164
      @obesetuna3164 2 місяці тому +20

      Lol.

    • @DavidValdezBigWaveDave
      @DavidValdezBigWaveDave 2 місяці тому +34

      @@sarahhale-pearson533 One would think that would work but the gates were open long enough they're here to stay

    • @zebraforceone
      @zebraforceone 2 місяці тому +8

      Wait until you find out about Bridgwater

    • @bosmerfromcanada3878
      @bosmerfromcanada3878 2 місяці тому +8

      DEUS VULT, dear Declan. God Willing!!!!

    • @shirleynanono6428
      @shirleynanono6428 2 місяці тому +22

      I don’t even think you know how disgusting that sounds.

  • @Kwippy
    @Kwippy 2 місяці тому +755

    I'm a physician who has worked in various places in the world. I once worked in a devout Muslim country where inbreeding was very common. There were many children with weird congenital diseases, and many of them so weird or rare it wasn't even possible to identify the condition.

  • @Thufferinthuckotash
    @Thufferinthuckotash 3 місяці тому +543

    1:43 You made a mistake. I just read the same journal paper and it refers to Punjab in Pakistan, not India. Cousin marriages are frowned upon in Indian Punjab.

    • @SopranosTV1
      @SopranosTV1 2 місяці тому +42

      Yeah I know I was shocked to know that too😂

    • @prakyathkumar8618
      @prakyathkumar8618 2 місяці тому +33

      Yeah ....if you do end up doing that the social consequences are not pretty

    • @Truthivist101
      @Truthivist101 2 місяці тому +24

      He made other mistakes too, like saying you can marry your uncle or aunt (???) UA-cam is full of pretenders like this, they search on google for their “facts”

    • @Thufferinthuckotash
      @Thufferinthuckotash 2 місяці тому +24

      @@Truthivist101 Sad that he hasn’t addressed my comment tbh. I’m sure he has the right intentions and it’s okay to make mistakes if you can own up to them. I think he didn’t know that Punjab was divided between India and Pakistan during partition. Most people associate Punjab with India, but I expect in depth research if you’re going to try to educate others.

    • @Truthivist101
      @Truthivist101 2 місяці тому +17

      @@Thufferinthuckotash I don’t think he’ll address his mistakes - these are not small mistakes either, huge mistakes which show his basic lack of knowledge on the subject matter, such types think reading a single paper makes them authorities on a subject - who even mistakes Punjab, Pakistan for Punjab in India, it’s common knowledge and his accent is British so this is something he should have learned in GCSE history! In GCSE Religious Studies he should have learned that those religions he mentioned do not allow marriage between an uncle/aunt and their niece/nephew but he clearly didn’t pay attention in school yet has the audacity to make informative videos like this and call himself a shy historian!

  • @dallinweir
    @dallinweir 2 місяці тому +176

    Im surprised that you didn't mention the fact that dating or even just spending time with the opposite sex is religiously, culturally, and legally prohibited in Pakistan.

    • @jasinere35
      @jasinere35 2 місяці тому

      the worst thing about it is they are trying to bring their way of life into every country even the incestrial & paedophillia stuff its not illegal to have bigomist marrage too which in most christian countries is illegal then they wonder why they are distrusted we dont hate them we just dont trust them, their men think that every female is fair game even if they are still at primary school which is something that hasnt been mentioned in this vid

    • @tahaahmed7108
      @tahaahmed7108 2 місяці тому +6

      ​@@jasinere35 It's not you don't know shit about Pakistan even if they laws there never inforced

    • @jasinere35
      @jasinere35 2 місяці тому

      @@tahaahmed7108 comment like that has to come from a paedophile

    • @ultraali453
      @ultraali453 2 місяці тому +21

      Yes, the cousins have probably been introduced to each other at a family event. For many, this is the closest thing to dating that they have experienced in their life.
      Many also harbor distrust of people who are not from the family.

    • @jasinere35
      @jasinere35 2 місяці тому

      @@tahaahmed7108 neither do you its your lot whos got caught child grooming in the uk

  • @isthisthekrustykrab_
    @isthisthekrustykrab_ 2 місяці тому +316

    My friend in the UK works as a geneticist diagnosing congenital birth defects. The vast majority of his patients are of Pakistani heritage, and have closely related parents.

    • @adrianadam8543
      @adrianadam8543 2 місяці тому +9

      The good news is the BBC reported that cousin marriage is going down radically among British Pakistanis under 30. So there is light at the end of the tunnel.

    • @gilly5094
      @gilly5094 2 місяці тому +2

      @adrianadam I wonder what impact on the figures the thousands of new arrivals from poor, rural areas of Pakistan will have. I doubt the BBC will be reporting that.

    • @Starsberrysmoothie-kd1cm
      @Starsberrysmoothie-kd1cm Місяць тому

      Oh!

    • @PLEASESTOP145
      @PLEASESTOP145 Місяць тому

      Or what else do you think these people really are? Very filthy and unhygienic and illiterate humans

    • @EthanLomas
      @EthanLomas Місяць тому

      A very sick culture. It might explain why Pakistan has the highest rate of jihadism anywhere in the world 🤮

  • @FrithonaHrududu02127
    @FrithonaHrududu02127 3 місяці тому +453

    I accidentally dated my my cousin in high school. We'd been together for like a year which is like a decade when you're 16. And we were talking about our families. And she said oh I have family from South Boston. I'm from South Boston. She was from West Roxbury, which is about as far apart as You can be and still be in the city of Boston. She said "eah, their ast name was O'Toole i said "that was my father's name. I have a different last name. I haven't talked to that family since I was 7 years old. And sure enough her mother, my father were first cousin's. That was a strange day. I literally had no clue whatsoever..

    • @Mixed_Activist
      @Mixed_Activist 3 місяці тому +59

      I discovered a cousin in class through a family timeline assignment

    • @befrugalwithus
      @befrugalwithus 2 місяці тому +9

      What about Japan on this?

    • @majimespirit8421
      @majimespirit8421 2 місяці тому +48

      Eww. Stuff of nightmares.

    • @TheGrimStoic
      @TheGrimStoic 2 місяці тому +45

      that's not even close to what his video talks about - these are waay closer like parents are not cousins but bro sis, bro bro, sis sis (same father same mother), and arranged with full knowledge and marriages not dates

    • @TheGrimStoic
      @TheGrimStoic 2 місяці тому

      ​@@majimespirit8421 and yet, why would anyone share this with surname, town etc...- I recon he sill faps to it to the day - ask him

  • @TheGreaterBenefic
    @TheGreaterBenefic 2 місяці тому +409

    There is no place for this in a modern world. I am a Turk and I think cousin marriages is a disgusting practice, that's why I prefer our original belief system of Tengri. It completely forbids any marriages with any person unless they are at least 7 times removed. I'd rather trust the science and my own ancestors than other people's ancestors.

    • @Adi-bo5do
      @Adi-bo5do 2 місяці тому +38

      Islam or not the Turks have an amazing history to be proud of

    • @veliborb
      @veliborb 2 місяці тому

      Old religions and beliefs were much more natural than these Semitic religions.

    • @sherwinpatterson9181
      @sherwinpatterson9181 2 місяці тому +12

      I am a Muslim and agree with you 💯

    • @akashpatro9393
      @akashpatro9393 2 місяці тому +17

      Glory to the sky lord Tengri and his follower Genghis

    • @Anastasis-is-here
      @Anastasis-is-here 2 місяці тому +17

      If you are Turk, the Ellenic Gods and the titans are your traditional religion, not something from Mongolia.

  • @KingSeven007
    @KingSeven007 2 місяці тому +111

    The couple next door are cousins, two of three kids have severe physical deformities.

    • @Maderlololohio
      @Maderlololohio 2 місяці тому +10

      Too bad no one has the guts to consider what can be done against it. And also sit down w these people and discuss that this must stop

    • @robinsoto2700
      @robinsoto2700 2 місяці тому

      OOF

    • @gigachad6885
      @gigachad6885 Місяць тому

      ​@@Maderlololohio"people"

    • @EthanLomas
      @EthanLomas Місяць тому +1

      Vile

  • @zhappy
    @zhappy 3 місяці тому +389

    In Hindus, there is gotra system. Two people of same gotra cannot marry because they are considered brother-sister.
    People having the same gotra trace back their origins several generations back to a common ancestor. So this system prevents not only close cousin marriages but also distant cousins sharing a common ancestry hundreds of years back.
    Maybe you should look into it and make a video (although some communities have different exceptions like if you have same gotra but you can't trace back common ancestry going back 5-7 generations, then marriage might be allowed)

    • @lionelproctor82
      @lionelproctor82 3 місяці тому +1

      Not entirely true. In South India, Hindus 🕉 practice cross cousin marriage; marrying father's sister's children or mother's brother's children.

    • @Jaco059
      @Jaco059 2 місяці тому +29

      @@lionelproctor82yes 2nd generation cousin marriage is incredibly common in south India

    • @lionelproctor82
      @lionelproctor82 2 місяці тому +26

      @@Jaco059 Indeed. Even girls marrying their mother's younger brother is frequent in Tamil Nadu. By the way, my own parents are 2nd cousins (common set of great-grandparents), and we are Sri Lankan 🇱🇰 Tamil 🐅 Christians ✝️

    • @Maxr9724
      @Maxr9724 2 місяці тому +43

      ​@@Jaco059 mostly in muslims again

    • @GrindingRepublic
      @GrindingRepublic 2 місяці тому

      @@Jaco059 They're muslims bruh 💀

  • @monojakennedy_3758
    @monojakennedy_3758 2 місяці тому +366

    In South Sudan, you cannot marry from your father's and mother's clan.
    Although in North Sudan, cousins can get married

    • @djcoolbeat6934
      @djcoolbeat6934 2 місяці тому +75

      So the problem is Islam? 😅

    • @monojakennedy_3758
      @monojakennedy_3758 2 місяці тому +103

      @@djcoolbeat6934 yeah. The problem is that people took the whole Arab culture in the name of Islam. They didn't differentiate

    • @birdofthenight
      @birdofthenight 2 місяці тому +38

      True. Inbreeding is very common among Sudanese people, but nonexistent among the South Sudanese, Dinka, Acholi, Nuer, etc.

    • @agengsatya96
      @agengsatya96 2 місяці тому +1

      ​@@djcoolbeat6934 in the quran in qs. 49:13, the most preferred marriage is interracial marriage

    • @orboakin8074
      @orboakin8074 2 місяці тому

      North Sudan is Arabic while South Sudan is African. This sick culture is borne of Arabic and South Asian clan traditions.

  • @lordsneed9418
    @lordsneed9418 2 місяці тому +133

    5:00 You made a big mistake here . "Uncles aunts nieces and nephews are not included in these prohibitions" This is wrong. Your screenshot shows clearly that it says "prohibited to you are your father's sisters, your mother's sisters , your brother's daughters, your sister's daughters" i.e. aunts , nieces , uncles and nephews are prohibited

  • @orboakin8074
    @orboakin8074 2 місяці тому +46

    Here in Nigeria, and much of sub-Saharan Africa, most of our tribes forbid cousin marriage on grounds of consanguinity, even before colonialism officially banned it, incest was heavily frowned upon here. This sick culture is borne of Arabic and South Asian clan traditions.

    • @EB-jf5oi
      @EB-jf5oi 2 місяці тому +1

      Yeah you guys mated with chimpanzees

    • @kalaidoscopez5388
      @kalaidoscopez5388 2 місяці тому +3

      Tbh, African genetics are top notch. Admirer of African athletic abilities from India!

    • @hidum5779
      @hidum5779 Місяць тому

      no it's born of islam.

    • @mjh5437
      @mjh5437 Місяць тому

      @@kalaidoscopez5388 So why do they have such low average IQ?

    • @Nagvanshieus
      @Nagvanshieus 29 днів тому +2

      Cousin marriage is not South Asian, we have a gotra system here through which we trace our and spouses lineage and if there's a common ancestor we don't marry, it's am effort to diversify as much as possible.

  • @pradeepkharta5953
    @pradeepkharta5953 2 місяці тому +958

    Pakistanis never disappoint in disappointing 😅😅😅😅

    • @uusrano
      @uusrano 2 місяці тому +54

      That's probably why the have to arrange a cousin marriage to get married.

    • @Arth-x3h
      @Arth-x3h 2 місяці тому

      Third worlder things ​@@uusrano

    • @bhadwamodi8294
      @bhadwamodi8294 2 місяці тому +23

      99% of those Pakistani are from Punjab province of Pakistan.

    • @Markhor579
      @Markhor579 2 місяці тому +49

      Can't surpass India on the disappointment list tho,
      You guys are on top

    • @____________838
      @____________838 2 місяці тому

      @@Markhor579Pakistan tops them, they’re pretty much India, but with inbreeding.

  • @dreddguy6454
    @dreddguy6454 2 місяці тому +82

    I used to do maintenance work in the schools in the city in which I lived. The number of Pakistani children in the 'special schools' greatly outnumbered the percentage of Pakistanis' in the general population. Keeping the money in the family bears a great cost. To us all.

  • @Mazalinda
    @Mazalinda 2 місяці тому +196

    Here in the UK the pressure on the NHS caused by disabled children born from first cousin, uncle and niece marriages is well known. Also on the welfare state as more benefits are given to families with disabled children.

    • @obesetuna3164
      @obesetuna3164 2 місяці тому +29

      Screw the system. That is their plan.

    • @AF-yq9es
      @AF-yq9es 2 місяці тому +12

      Has the British brought any laws to stop this?

    • @yucol5661
      @yucol5661 2 місяці тому +3

      @@AF-yq9eswhat laws to stop this do you want? People are already working to change attitudes and marriage practices, and marriage trends already where changing on their own just out of cultural change.
      Do some people really want laws like “Being sick is your fault, no rights to you”. “Nhs money to all citizens, except packistanis” Wait, I’m sure that’s what you want cause you feel those people don’t deserve the same rights as you even if they have the same legal rights, they are somehow inferior. And we all know laws will never be used against me, I’m the real British, I’m really in charge and the government works for me only /s

    • @Lilliz91
      @Lilliz91 2 місяці тому +17

      Not to mention aggression from inbreeding.

    • @nicholasstgelais2112
      @nicholasstgelais2112 2 місяці тому +8

      ​@yucol5661 just stop rewarding it with funding.

  • @FFGG22E
    @FFGG22E 2 місяці тому +20

    I've been to Pakistan. I was working on a military base. I spoke with the soldiers there and they told me about the cousin marriage. When I was leaving there was a mob scene at the airport in Islamabad because they were all going to them UK for Ramadan. I saw a number of families with multiple mentally disabled children. Frequently most of the children would have the same face, they would look exactly the same and were mentally deranged.

  • @shakesinthehouse
    @shakesinthehouse 2 місяці тому +72

    My pakistani friends told me her brother has a crush on their cousin. I can't look at her the same way anymore. she said it n a such nonchalant way that I wanted to change subject quickly as possible.

    • @syedrafi2258
      @syedrafi2258 2 місяці тому +3

      Seeing your comment after coming from cousin marriage😁
      However it is now declining and people are now aware and don't marry in cousins ,even old people now also aware of it

    • @AsterRays7979
      @AsterRays7979 2 місяці тому +15

      Reason
      1. Islam
      2. Pakistani dramas, with love stories of 1st cousins

    • @flork130
      @flork130 2 місяці тому +2

      People are slowly moving away. My families is one of those unique Pakistanis with no cousin marriages in the family.

    • @Maderlololohio
      @Maderlololohio 2 місяці тому +1

      ​@@AsterRays7979the dramas r ofc drafted from what lives in their community. I would not say its the fault of the dramas. Also they want to keep their daughters safe w family is another very big reason. Or a girl from their fam will care better for the family of her husband than an outsider

    • @EthanLomas
      @EthanLomas Місяць тому

      Disgusting 🤮

  • @paulaharrisbaca4851
    @paulaharrisbaca4851 2 місяці тому +195

    "Feminisation of migration"? Really? I was of the opinion that women immigrants were vastly outnumbered by young men, unmarried, under the age of 28.

    • @paulaharrisbaca4851
      @paulaharrisbaca4851 2 місяці тому +1

      11:02 I must add that these young women could almost stroll over to Saudi Arabia and remain with vastly more wealthy and available Muslim men than wasting time and money to follow all these illegals who run off through Europe simply in order to go to a place which supposedly once exploited them. Yet they seem to prefer it to a country that will enforce their own "eye for an eye" or "stone and unfaithful woman" or "execute homosexual men for breaking the laws of Allah by sodomizing other young men...." Seriously weird. They want to go to live in the country of the Great Satan.....and try to fool relatives at home by killing the unbelievers.....

    • @TruthKindness
      @TruthKindness 2 місяці тому +57

      He is speaking about well educated women who marry british citizens and then migrate legally. Your statistic includes illegal migration.

    • @filiperosa7496
      @filiperosa7496 2 місяці тому +4

      Depends on time and place

    • @Anivrat1
      @Anivrat1 2 місяці тому +2

      Bro he's talking about Pakistani women

    • @KateeAngel
      @KateeAngel 2 місяці тому +4

      This disparity in gender is declining now. There are more women immigrants than before

  • @prospecops
    @prospecops 2 місяці тому +90

    The main reason is because the vast vast vast majority of Pakistani Dramas involved cousins falling in love. It’s romanticized in the media.

    • @Witchmee
      @Witchmee 2 місяці тому +13

      Doesn't that kinda sound like grooming? Usually an older male cousin and younger female cousin right?

    • @big-anvil
      @big-anvil 2 місяці тому +8

      It’s unlikely that Pakistani TV is a cause here. Rather, the shows exist because cousin marriage is so prevalent in the culture in the first place

    • @ronblack7870
      @ronblack7870 2 місяці тому +6

      @@big-anvil i agree entertainment will mirror society

    • @minni2nandha
      @minni2nandha 2 місяці тому +4

      Most of the drama romanticise cousin marriages, where girls call their cousins brother before marriage, ended up marrying them lol...eww

    • @everettduncan7543
      @everettduncan7543 2 місяці тому +1

      ​@@ronblack7870 not always: see the appearance of gay people in the 90s and early 2000s in American TV shows. That changed the culture, and I'm sure cousin marriages being romanticized in Pakistani shows is reinforcing the practice and even introducing it to people's within the country that in the past didn't approve of inbreeding.

  • @Tarotaro23-k5r
    @Tarotaro23-k5r 2 місяці тому +29

    FALSE, It is about Islam. In india we have arranged marriages (aka rishte) but it’s taboo for cousins to marry, in HINDU culture cousins are seen as siblings.

    • @adityach7
      @adityach7 Місяць тому +4

      Exactly, all my cousins, even second or third cousins who I interact with are basically like my brothers and sisters. Not in my wildest dreams will I ever think of being involved with them romantically.

  • @carthicss1
    @carthicss1 2 місяці тому +1532

    Punjab of Pakistan, not Punjab of India

    • @sule.A
      @sule.A 2 місяці тому +7

      With how massive india is i wonr be suprised if their top 5​@The_Black_Dockk

    • @frankjames7272
      @frankjames7272 2 місяці тому +114

      Its probably islam . one of the most romantic love story in islam is between Ali And Fatima . they are niece and uncle .

    • @throughmyview8411
      @throughmyview8411 2 місяці тому +21

      @mohitji2054 हमारे यहाँ तो अगर गोत्र एक है तो शादी नहीं हो सकती क्योंकि हम मानते हैं कि किसी ना किसी पीढ़ी पहले एक परिवार होगा ।

    • @carthicss1
      @carthicss1 2 місяці тому +111

      @@frankjames7272 how about 53 year old Mohammed with 6 year old Aisha? Doesn't that sound romantic?

    • @dakansa
      @dakansa 2 місяці тому +8

      Punjab of Great Britain as Pakistan and India both belong to Great Britain.

  • @Am-ih5nf
    @Am-ih5nf 2 місяці тому +198

    Literally all of Pakistan married through the Gotra system which is designed to prevent inbreeding, but it was deemed haram under Sharia law for 100 years now.

    • @laylaali5977
      @laylaali5977 2 місяці тому +13

      Islamic law doesn’t dictate who you marry

    • @iscifion7122
      @iscifion7122 2 місяці тому +56

      Gotra is Hindu system to minimise inbreeding and maximise variations and health.

    • @MissionSilo
      @MissionSilo 2 місяці тому +3

      Gotra?

    • @aurelian2668
      @aurelian2668 2 місяці тому +47

      @@laylaali5977 yes it does XD, you cant marry non muslim for example

    • @Ezzkill44
      @Ezzkill44 2 місяці тому +52

      @@aurelian2668 without lies islam dies

  • @patriciatoomingtheplantpar2558
    @patriciatoomingtheplantpar2558 2 місяці тому +241

    I watched a documentary about this and it followed a few families, they have many children.
    One family, one woman had several children most had passed due to inbreeding afflicted genes like, a type of anencephaly where they are born with partial skulls and only a minor brain stem.
    Some were born with malformed limbs and spinabifida.
    She didn't want to marry her cousin but it was the tradition of arrangement because they believe that a new member of the family should also be close family because an outsider wouldn't be "emotionally invested" like close family is.
    Good lord the living children she did have weren't meant to live! She had one that was blind, deaf and had physical anomalies, that child stayed in the house all day in a low high chair of sorts, just existing.
    Another one was mobile but mostly blind and deaf with violent tendencies.
    She was stuck with her 4 existing living disabled children to look after all on her own, the husband/cousin was never seen in the documentary but she said its not his job to look after the kids, only to create them.
    He wanted to keep trying for a "normal" child, it was so hard to watch, she was so miserable, the kids seemed to be as kept as she could muster, it was apparent they were very poor and oppressed. I can't imagine the shame that comes with not being able after years and years of birthing, not to produce a "normal" child so the insanity could finally stop.
    I'm sure she was finally happy when menopause hit and her childbearing years were finally over, but she has the rest of her life to take care of the 4 invalids she brought forth that actually do live for no purpose, joy or productivity.
    They don't believe all these issues are because of inbreeding...
    science is hard? Practical, physical evidence through generations is not proof?
    THEY DESERVE WHAT THEY GET AT THIS POINT, THEY ARE BREEDING THEMSELVES OUT OF EXISTENCE WITH FEWER AND FEWER VIABLE COUSINS TO MARRY AND BREED WITH.
    Perfect example of "you reap what you sow"

    • @Tragic.Kingdom
      @Tragic.Kingdom 2 місяці тому +7

      Name of documentary

    • @bibivanderveen5455
      @bibivanderveen5455 2 місяці тому +28

      The Consequences of marrying your cousin.
      When cousins marry.

    • @enkisdaughter4795
      @enkisdaughter4795 2 місяці тому +11

      @@Tragic.KingdomIt’s here on YT

    • @MGold00
      @MGold00 2 місяці тому +26

      I watched the documentary too. Cos as health care worker. In my town we have a small Pakistani community. Its was bit alarming wen we were doing years stats that in that community. Physical & mental disabilities is higher (x10) than the other surrounding areas & the number is growing even year.
      One of the Dr's said it was inbreeding. He recommended that documentary

    • @zoeybella234
      @zoeybella234 2 місяці тому

      @@Tragic.Kingdom This was one of them. It's mind blowing how this is not stamped out in the UK but they want to ban smoking in pub gardens. Unbelievable. ua-cam.com/video/kyNP3s5mxI8/v-deo.htmlsi=iGv8XupGxtJU1F3b

  • @keyboarddancers7751
    @keyboarddancers7751 2 місяці тому +52

    I worked for many years ('92-'19) in various social welfare roles in the Yorkshire, Lancashire & Manchester areas. It was an unspoken observation (open secret) amongst professional colleagues (social workers, district nurses, occupational therapists, welfare benefit officers etc) that cousin-marriage within the Pakistani diaspora is a catastrophic cost to the tax payer due to the proliferation of resultant congenital disorders and birth defects. Woe betide anyone who deigned to raise concerns about this issue.

    • @adrianadam8543
      @adrianadam8543 2 місяці тому +1

      A BBC news report said cousin marriage is going down in England among Pakistanis.

    • @keyboarddancers7751
      @keyboarddancers7751 2 місяці тому +1

      @@adrianadam8543 Phew; thank goodness for that!

    • @mjh5437
      @mjh5437 Місяць тому

      @@adrianadam8543 The BBC WOULD say that,they never tire of sucking-up to minorities.

    • @gimmemore9709
      @gimmemore9709 Місяць тому

      @@keyboarddancers7751 wouldn’t believe anything the BBC says, if they say it’s going down you bet it’s actually going up.

  • @ascorvinus
    @ascorvinus 3 місяці тому +143

    Your audio sounds a bit inbred

  • @rockoorbe2002
    @rockoorbe2002 3 місяці тому +880

    Pakistan is the Alabama of SE Asia.

    • @ExsoulestzZ
      @ExsoulestzZ 2 місяці тому +27

      india too

    • @user-io7sh7nx7c
      @user-io7sh7nx7c 2 місяці тому +190

      ​@@ExsoulestzZ Inbreeding in Pakistan is 61%, in Bangladesh it is 17% and in India it is 7.5%.
      India has lesser rates than almost all Muslim countries and even Israel.

    • @Lilac_liha
      @Lilac_liha 2 місяці тому +25

      ​@@user-io7sh7nx7c India also has this problem lmao. Shit is not even banned in india country.

    • @Lilac_liha
      @Lilac_liha 2 місяці тому +118

      Pakistan is in South Asia not South east Asia

    • @ezrathegreatconqueror
      @ezrathegreatconqueror 2 місяці тому +57

      @@user-io7sh7nx7c Indonesia, as another Muslim-majority (86%) country has less than 2% cousin-marriage couples

  • @marcoprolo1488
    @marcoprolo1488 2 місяці тому +351

    The only question is: What are Pakistanis doing in Norway?

    • @gotfan7743
      @gotfan7743 2 місяці тому +68

      Norway allowed lot of Pakistanis in the 1970s as guest workers. Around 40,000 Norwegians are of Pakistani origin.

    • @ElamiteMan
      @ElamiteMan 2 місяці тому +53

      Selling Chicken Tikka Masala

    • @komisossoutsidi5801
      @komisossoutsidi5801 2 місяці тому +120

      ​@MayankTrivedi2-bg3dgNorway didn't even colonize Pakistan

    • @LordGeneralOHara
      @LordGeneralOHara 2 місяці тому +10

      Asylum

    • @LordGeneralOHara
      @LordGeneralOHara 2 місяці тому +12

      ​@@ElamiteManChicken Tikka Masala is British it's more like selling chicken karahi

  • @Pintexx
    @Pintexx 2 місяці тому +28

    To think that tens of millions of people in Pakistan and UK have only one pair of grandparents is mindblowing to me. It’s 2024 and This tradition needs to die out!

    • @Eric_Hunt194
      @Eric_Hunt194 2 місяці тому

      When your family tree is a monkey-puzzle something has gone very wrong 😂

    • @Maderlololohio
      @Maderlololohio 2 місяці тому

      Seems like the western leaders need to sit w the imams and ask them to address this issue over and over.

    • @qian4413
      @qian4413 2 місяці тому

      @@Eric_Hunt194 In ancient Egypt a pharaoh's family tree looks more like a ladder than a tree 😂

    • @ibrahimihsan2090
      @ibrahimihsan2090 2 місяці тому

      Are you from America?
      Because I could confidently say America has way worse tradition based problems.

    • @gigachad6885
      @gigachad6885 Місяць тому

      ​@@ibrahimihsan2090 there is nothing worse than making deformed children because you chose a family member as a wife

  • @southbug27
    @southbug27 2 місяці тому +85

    There’s a higher rate of birth defects in America’s Amish community because almost no one converts to the Amish faith & the all of the genetic diversity is limited to the Amish who fled to America a couple or few hundred years ago.

    • @essaboselin5252
      @essaboselin5252 2 місяці тому +16

      Back in the day when adoptions were done privately, the Amish used to adopt regularly. It helped them if a couple couldn't conceive, and they considered it better for the child rather than be raised in a single-mother home. Let me tell you - it's a bit of an eyeopener the first time you see a black Amish woman!

    • @toomanymarys7355
      @toomanymarys7355 2 місяці тому +1

      They still forbid first cousin marriage, though.

    • @EB-jf5oi
      @EB-jf5oi 2 місяці тому

      No you guys in the Americas are delusional. It's not about 'biodiversity' to usher in your clown fiesta, but about first cousins deliberately inbreeding

  • @michealbadman6411
    @michealbadman6411 3 місяці тому +257

    Please fix your microphone.

    • @The-Cat
      @The-Cat 2 місяці тому +5

      Please donate money for him to buy a better one

    • @finophile
      @finophile 2 місяці тому +15

      I wonder if it was a deliberate ploy to obscure audio from AI examination

    • @AA-yc9dq
      @AA-yc9dq 2 місяці тому +5

      How can you sit there and spend hours editing a video and not notice that insufferable noise? Or did he just not care?

  • @jonathandudley6589
    @jonathandudley6589 2 місяці тому +51

    If I hear socioeconomic factors one more time…

    • @Ignisan_66
      @Ignisan_66 2 місяці тому +15

      Its always socioeconomic factors. Never any other reasons...

    • @osiand9328
      @osiand9328 2 місяці тому +21

      Socioeconomic factors forcing me to have 7 deformed children with my first cousin

    • @alejandromaldonado6159
      @alejandromaldonado6159 2 місяці тому

      ​@@Ignisan_66Marxist theory blames people's failings on the society instead of the individual's choices/lifestyle. Which is why Pakistani cousin marriages are tolerated in the world stage.

    • @alliwishis_2
      @alliwishis_2 2 місяці тому

      ​@osiand9328
      You are not even thinking about what you even saying
      The answer is right out of your mouth of what you are saying

    • @RobertTaylor-gz2fu
      @RobertTaylor-gz2fu Місяць тому

      They cause the poor socioeconomic factors by inbreeding & overbreeding.

  • @francisadams-u9l
    @francisadams-u9l 2 місяці тому +47

    You should speak to someone in the U.S military intelligence who do this sort of research. I have had many conversations with them that was eye opening. I knew that inbreeding was common in many countries, but what they told me was astounding. In the U.S there is a large Somali population. You could tell there is something not right with those people. My friend told me that the Somali population is largely inbreed. Bottom line, many cultures are still living in what can be called in anthropological terms, The Mammalian-Mesomorphic state. That is, Herd Security. At some point in the ancient past, property and cattle was wealth. Many cultures are still within the pre-bronze/iron age thinking. In ancient times, Herd Security worked because it was farming, cottage industry, hunter and gatherer economy. I have concluded that inbreeding is tied into a very rudimentary economy. Many cultures haven't yet realized the economy of the 20th to 21st century. That is, they are not thinking along the lines of the industrial economy.

    • @PaulTaalman
      @PaulTaalman Місяць тому

      That would explain Ilhan Omar.

  • @michaelcaffery5038
    @michaelcaffery5038 2 місяці тому +44

    I once made a complimentary comment on a video of a Poshto speaking community in NW Pakistan. Among other things I wrote that they looked very Greek, maybe from Alexander's army. This was met with immediate indignation and denial from people of the same region saying not to offend them (they got very aggressive) as they were "pure bloods". As well as an astonishing lack of historical knowledge of the region this shows a xenophobic and racial superiority attitude. I'm not surprised that inbreeding is common.

    • @ibrahimihsan2090
      @ibrahimihsan2090 2 місяці тому +4

      Buddy, simply having more color in their eyes compared to other populations does not equal looking like Greeks.
      Even if your theory is true, the genetic contribution from ancient Greeks is pretty low.
      Not to mention the fact that their gene pool includes other populations as well.
      Calling them Greek is like calling Spanish people Amazigh.

    • @michaelcaffery5038
      @michaelcaffery5038 2 місяці тому +2

      @@ibrahimihsan2090 I didn't even notice the colour of their eyes. What made them look Greek to me was their skin colour and features which would not have looked out of place in Greece. The contribution from Greeks to the gene pool may be small but it is possible that particular community is descended from members of Alexander's army or others. They didn't look typical of other people of the region. I didn't state categorically that they were. Just a suggestion they might be. As you say, the whole region has seen many peoples crossing it so claiming to be "pure bloods" is ridiculous. Why is the idea so bad to you? Because you are racist against Europeans?

    • @ibrahimihsan2090
      @ibrahimihsan2090 2 місяці тому +2

      @@michaelcaffery5038 For one, if you are referring to tribal Pashtuns, that's probably a case of them having pride in whatever lineage or tribe they believe themselves to be.
      Plus, they don't know your perspective and you don't know theirs. For all they know, you could be telling them that their great great grandmothers were graped by Yunani people(that's what we call Greeks).
      This isn't necessarily as much the case in urban areas. I myself am a Pashtun like my father was too but my mother is Tanoli and speaks Hindko as her native language.
      I hardly know anything about Pashtun traditions or my genealogy(just till my great great grandfather on my father's side and that his patrilineal ancestors came to Pakistan from Afghanistan in the late 18th century).
      In a span of a 1000 years, I could possibly have ancestry from several ethnicities(Persian, Arab, Turkic, Mongolic, Punjabi, Balochi, etc) but I don't know. All I know is that I am Pashtun and Babur because my father is Pashtun from a tribe called Babur and that my mother is Tanoli. I hardly know anything beyond that.

    • @michaelcaffery5038
      @michaelcaffery5038 2 місяці тому +1

      @@ibrahimihsan2090 personally, I regard pride in ones lineage or tribe, along with the idea of racial purity, to be the root of racism. It allows the holder of such views to treat others as lesser beings. Think of the British Raj.
      The thing about their ancestors being abused is a very strange attitude. How does that make them look bad? Surely any guilt is to the people who do that sort of thing. If they do have any European ancestry it might not have been through violence. It sounds like people of the region really have a sensitivity to the suggestion and racial hatred. Btw, the people who replied to me almost certainly were not from that particular line/tribe but other Pashtuns.
      Like you, I have a mixture, fairly typical of Britons, of various western European people. Brittonic people, Anglo Saxons, west Europeans, particularly French, Scandinavian and Irish. Particularly from the Scandinavian line I am almost certainly descended from slavers and grapists (I hate UA-cam censorship so much!) and the victims of such. It does not make me a victim or aggressor. Everyone in the world is descended from oppressors and the oppressed if you go back far enough. Even within the same ethnicity.

    • @ibrahimihsan2090
      @ibrahimihsan2090 2 місяці тому

      @@michaelcaffery5038
      Buddy, you have probably zero concept of tribalism.
      I don't like it either but tribalism is a thing amongst a significant portion of rural areas in Asia. Somewhat similar to the South in the US. I don't exactly know what you mean by racial purity in the Pashtun context. If you mean that they refuse to accept that other ethnicities are part of their family tree then I sort of am familiar with that. Turkey has a similar problem where they believe they come purely from Central Asian nomads despite the fact that they are genetically as Central Asian as Messi is Indigenous Argentinian and are of mostly Middle Eastern(mostly east) and Anatolian(especially central and western) stock. Otherwise, I don't know what you mean.
      A certain number of Pashtuns may have similar feelings about their ethnicity and while that can overlap with racism in several aspects, it's not as simple as that.
      People have varying opinions about this kind of stuff where I am from.
      Some are blood purists whilst some are proud of having foreign ancestry(especially if Arab, Turkic, Persian or if believing in some 16th century genealogy theorized by some Mughal scholar, Biblical Israelite) whilst others don't care that much.

  • @tamashbeen6610
    @tamashbeen6610 2 місяці тому +162

    This is considered incest in India, among non-Muslims.

    • @RakeshS198
      @RakeshS198 2 місяці тому +14

      Some non-Muslims communities like Gowdas in Karnataka, South India also have cousin marriages

    • @kiki40665
      @kiki40665 2 місяці тому +20

      ​@@RakeshS198not siblings, they also see gotra

    • @billmago7991
      @billmago7991 2 місяці тому +4

      sure it is😂😂😂 i believe you....millions wouldnt 😂😂😂

    • @QuantumNinja1.9
      @QuantumNinja1.9 2 місяці тому +13

      ​@@billmago7991 you don't need to.
      No need to prove to ignorants.
      But to educate you I'm hindu from Jat Clan.
      And we can't marry people with 4 gotras(surnames) i.e. Father's, Mother's, Mother's Mother's, Father's Mother's.

    • @thingswhatilike
      @thingswhatilike 2 місяці тому +1

      ​@@kiki40665 yas in cousin marriage in Hindus are very common

  • @kaoper
    @kaoper 2 місяці тому +18

    6:20 To be honest, speaking as Pole, I don't think that arranging marriages is still part of polish culture. It was normal practice in times of nobility and aritocracy, just like in other parts of Europe, but now it certainly is a thing of the past. So, if it's not a problem, could you give source to that claim, because I myslef don't know about any arranged marriage or even heard about one?

    • @anythingbut...
      @anythingbut... 2 місяці тому +5

      As another Pole I can support that opinion. We even have a tradition of boyfriend coming for a dinner to meet girlfriend parents, and another dinner like that when he asks if he can marry their daughter (not so much now, more like parents and grandparents generations, and I am around my 40s). That would make zero sense if parents already knew or arranged the marriage already. Don't think Italians and Irish have any arranged marriages as well. Some Roma communities have that but that's sporadic as well as they have tradition called "grabbing" which doesn't involve parents of any party. The whole video is littered with mistakes looking at comments, not only this one.

    • @sundeepparhar1126
      @sundeepparhar1126 Місяць тому

      @@anythingbut... Those are (or were) basically matrimonial interviews. Which are extremely common and prevalent in arranged marriage cultures, with the majority of indian arranged marriages featuring such events as a prelude to engagement. And by the stupidly broad popular Western definition of 'arranged marriage' (a marriage planned and agreed by the families or guardians of the couple concerned, rather than solely by the couple themselves) any marriage where the partners' families participate in planning the event, and give the couple their blessings first, is considered to be 'arranged'.

  • @CheeseLovingGuy
    @CheeseLovingGuy 2 місяці тому +57

    Lots of problems in Bradford UK from Muslims marrying close cousins

    • @realtalunkarku
      @realtalunkarku 2 місяці тому +10

      And grooming gangs

    • @Spidey-2002
      @Spidey-2002 2 місяці тому

      ​@@realtalunkarkuEspecially white ones

    • @ishpeeedy
      @ishpeeedy 2 місяці тому +8

      Shhhh talking about them is considered "racist" ​@@realtalunkarku

    • @Mmemememehu
      @Mmemememehu 2 місяці тому

      It's always the indians who do

    • @Mmemememehu
      @Mmemememehu 2 місяці тому

      It's always the indians who do

  • @NRse99
    @NRse99 3 місяці тому +196

    Christ, that buzzing sound is deafening. Please fix

    • @inaligrimalkin
      @inaligrimalkin 2 місяці тому +4

      Oh thank goodness i thought it was my headphones!

    • @NRse99
      @NRse99 2 місяці тому +3

      @@inaligrimalkin Same here at first, haha!

    • @midloran
      @midloran 2 місяці тому

      Why? It's funny, let the funny stay

    • @NRse99
      @NRse99 2 місяці тому +3

      @@midloranI disagree, but I'm glad you enjoy it at least : )

    • @ronjared2204
      @ronjared2204 2 місяці тому +1

      ​@@inaligrimalkinme too... I was going to switch off my phone!

  • @WildKat25
    @WildKat25 2 місяці тому +88

    Several Provinces in Canada (Alberta and Ontario in particular) actually had laws against cousin marriage unless they were 3rd or more removed cousins. Blood tests used to be submitted to ensure it. Unfortunately, the federal government of Canada changed the laws in 2008 to allow first cousin marriage all across Canada (most likely at the urging of immigration that culturally allows cousin marriage). Now, legally, first cousins, uncles/nieces, and aunts/nephews are allowed to marry in Canada due to cultural interference from immigrants. I say this as someone who has an immigrant parent (though their country doesn't allow cousin marriage).

    • @dawnelder9046
      @dawnelder9046 2 місяці тому +17

      I did not know that those laws were changed. Time to change them back. Our medical system is failing as it is.

    • @manuelredgrave8348
      @manuelredgrave8348 2 місяці тому

      Who in their right mind at the canadian government thought that changing a country's law to be in favor of incestuous immigrants was a good idea??!?

    • @haileytyers1360
      @haileytyers1360 2 місяці тому +1

      This law was changed so quietly too. I dont think any of us knew about it happening. As an Albertan my parents were in shock when my husband and I didnt need to submit blood test results prior to our wedding in 2014. (Though there was no chance of us being related, thank god.)

    • @megsley
      @megsley 2 місяці тому +2

      oh, Canada, no 🤢🤮

    • @Maderlololohio
      @Maderlololohio 2 місяці тому

      Ugh. Such bad news. The law would have protected the right of unborn children. Hopefully it will be reversed!

  • @bigidea121
    @bigidea121 2 місяці тому +3

    The region where my family is originally from in Ghana, this would be scandalous. Its also even frowned upon for siblings to marry into the same family. For example two sisters marrying men who are brothers or cousins from the same family. (I sometimes see "feel good" stories in US magazines about twins marrying twins and tbh it weirds me out). The traditional thought being is that not only the obvious genetic concerns of putting "all your decendant eggs in one basket" but also other things run in families too. So imagine all your kids are married into a family with other problems like binge drinking, temperment issues, or depression. Funny how our ancestors had a hunch that alcoholism, addiction, and mental health were genetic before science existed to prove it. It also helps avoid issues if that family is always fighting causing drama, are bad with money, or are just dumb/annoying lol. At least only one of your kids is "stuck" with them.

  • @virtualinsanity4446
    @virtualinsanity4446 2 місяці тому +206

    If that wasn't the worst, boys' first sexual experience is usually with their male cousins or their male classmates in Pakistan and it gets conveniently brushed under the carpet and never talked about again because they go on to marry each other's sisters when they grow older. I don't think there is any other country out there where casual homosexuality is so common. It could be due to strictness for gender segregation in the general public, schools, and colleges.

    • @susanwestern6434
      @susanwestern6434 2 місяці тому +23

      Afghanistan?

    • @Burtlocker
      @Burtlocker 2 місяці тому +5

      @@susanwestern6434 casual? lol

    • @nunyabiznes33
      @nunyabiznes33 2 місяці тому +72

      ​@@susanwestern6434Bacha bazi is a different phenomenon, those are boys kept by older men. The Taliban for all the horrible stuff they do, like executing people for listening to Western music, are at least cracking down on those feedoughfiles.

    • @rudhra5957
      @rudhra5957 2 місяці тому +13

      Tf ? Fr ? Well I guess humans are just animals at the end of the day

    • @kennethkuehnle9872
      @kennethkuehnle9872 2 місяці тому

      I've heard that the country of "pakistan 🇵🇰" has the most searches for Gay 🏳️‍🌈 porn in the net than any other country on the face of the 🌎 🌍 earth!!!

  • @nina27sky
    @nina27sky 2 місяці тому +91

    As a pakistani , the reason i have heard on why inbreeding is so common is because of a weird culture we have where once the daughter gets married she has to leave her house and live with her husband's family who are complete strangers to her and these people can often turn out to be horrible , so just for caution the parents think it'll better for their daughter to marry into their own family so that atleast they'll be safe (although this doesn't always turn out to be the case) , so as far as i have seen and heard from the women around me , most aren't interested in their cousins romantically its literally just for safety reasons (just my perspective)🤷‍♀️

    • @LockheedMonster
      @LockheedMonster 2 місяці тому +1

      On the contrary, Pakistan is one of the worst countries for Women!

    • @Cupcake0228
      @Cupcake0228 2 місяці тому +21

      I am Indian and although we dont have inbreeding cousin marriage but we have arranged marriage and people give the same reason that if we know the boy and his family it will keep the daughter safe 😅 I don't think that's the strange reason though actually knowing how women are treated in our culture its a valid concern but inbreeding is not the solution i guess

    • @tofiqueasghar7147
      @tofiqueasghar7147 2 місяці тому +20

      Tackle a problem by creating another.
      But, i believe that if those women are well educated and know how to be independent this culture can end

    • @nina27sky
      @nina27sky 2 місяці тому +7

      @tofiqueasghar7147 Yes while women are now getting educated and finaling rejecting alot of social norms its obviously going to take alot of time for this culture to completely end since its been going on for so long and women haven't gotten their independence completely yet

    • @puneetmishra4726
      @puneetmishra4726 2 місяці тому +6

      Pakistan does not have a great record in tackling domestic violence either so surely this method isn't working. Well, we have this problem too but we have taken the approach of law and woman empowerment, that seems to be working.

  • @MrPapageorgio
    @MrPapageorgio 3 місяці тому +69

    The buzzing is really distracting. Goes for about 7 seconds at 3:05 I'm trying to give the video a shot but it's trying.

  • @megsley
    @megsley 2 місяці тому +13

    and these are the folks the UK wants to import in by the ton 😂😂😂

    • @luciferjohnson8495
      @luciferjohnson8495 2 місяці тому +3

      Says who? Most immigrant population in UK is from India. Also India is diverse. Your logic is flawed. You are acting like that all of em are murderers or something

  • @PratapSingh-qz9jj
    @PratapSingh-qz9jj 2 місяці тому +72

    From India. We are from the Jaat Agrarian community / Martial race. When we marry we make sure that boys clan, his grandmothers clan and his mothers clan isn’t similar to the Girls clan. This is done to avoid inbreeding. Any violation of this rule is seen as marrying your sister. We are a majority in a very small state called Haryana. We win most of the Olympic medals and have a monopoly on wrestling. Good genes help

    • @alburaq3290
      @alburaq3290 2 місяці тому +10

      Martial race 😂

    • @HenriqueSilvanyar
      @HenriqueSilvanyar 2 місяці тому +2

      @@alburaq3290 I suppose he means warrior caste, the Kshatriya.

    • @PratapSingh-qz9jj
      @PratapSingh-qz9jj 2 місяці тому +7

      It’s a silly classification given by the English. Basically we are hardy stubborn Farmers and make great soldiers.

    • @ishpeeedy
      @ishpeeedy 2 місяці тому +2

      ​@@HenriqueSilvanyarnope. The Kshatriya is a playable class where you are a warrior. Jaat is a community in Haryana region. That martial race tag was given by the British colonisers who looked at them and went " tall and muscular so you are a warrior race"

    • @damionkeeling3103
      @damionkeeling3103 2 місяці тому

      Aside from cricket India does seem to have an aversion to sports. The population would suggest they should be getting as many medals as China but that doesn't seem to interest the country.

  • @lloyddale3818
    @lloyddale3818 2 місяці тому +55

    There is an hospital in Sydney Aust that has a birth defect rate of 7 times the National average. It is in an area with a very high population of a certain faith.

    • @birdofthenight
      @birdofthenight 2 місяці тому +13

      Just say Muslims/Islam. What's the fear about?

    • @Spidey-2002
      @Spidey-2002 2 місяці тому

      ​@@birdofthenightYou'd never say it in the real world tho

    • @birdofthenight
      @birdofthenight 2 місяці тому +7

      ​@@Spidey-2002 You probably think I'm from your locale or something? As a survivor of an Islamic terror attack from a country that has borne the brunt of Islam terror so many times, I can say pretty much anything as long as "community standards" allow it. We know them very well and don't live in fear or awe of them like you guys and they know it. On the other hand, they know you guys fear them that's why they take advantage of your countries and systems so easily

    • @tobehonestidkwhattoputhere
      @tobehonestidkwhattoputhere 2 місяці тому +2

      @@birdofthenight I'm genuinely so sorry you had to face something like that. Hope you're doing better. How are you holding up? (if you feel comfortable sharing ofc)

    • @birdofthenight
      @birdofthenight 2 місяці тому

      @@tobehonestidkwhattoputhereThank you. Search for the "Garissa University massacre" on the web (147 killed in cold blood). I was a teaching assistant by then. The experience is a NIGHTMARE. They always single out non-muslims openly and kill them on the spot. Local Muslims harbor and support them openly (jihad), while our leaders (politicians) make things easy for them through policies that allow them to come in easily (disguised as helpless refugees!). It's a very complex situation and any non-muslim from my country would readily ridicule you for fearing them

  • @theodoreconstantini2548
    @theodoreconstantini2548 3 місяці тому +107

    At least Pakistan Norwegians are waking up, that's good. If you are living in a culture that says this is ok and normal then it is hard to break the habit. I think if the average level of IQ falls even slightly this will effect the whole society.
    As there will be less people highly intelligent people as a proportion of the overall population so you are "dumbing down" your population.

    • @NeraBuffy
      @NeraBuffy 2 місяці тому

      No that's not good, look at what happens in UK when there's a high enough number of them who are able bodied. Like grooming gangs and open air machete surgeries.

    • @FranktheHedgehog-u1z
      @FranktheHedgehog-u1z 2 місяці тому

      Why they have been encouraged not to integrate in the UK. The criminal elite we have want to replace native British with these.... easier to dominate and control with an evil cult.

    • @flagshipbowtie
      @flagshipbowtie 2 місяці тому +13

      Dumazz they've been in breeding for over a thousand years. They're already doomed

    • @theodoreconstantini2548
      @theodoreconstantini2548 2 місяці тому +2

      @@flagshipbowtie That could be the case.

    • @ashleyoasis7948
      @ashleyoasis7948 2 місяці тому +3

      in uk its still socially acceptable

  • @ramboram03
    @ramboram03 2 місяці тому +23

    That Punjab statistic is wrong ,its for Pakistan Panjab, first cousin marriage is taboo amongst Sikhs and Panjabi Hindus

    • @randomabcabc
      @randomabcabc 2 місяці тому

      Or any kind of blood relation for that matter.

  • @dmoore8595
    @dmoore8595 2 місяці тому +24

    In the US, many states used to require people to take blood tests before obtaining a marriage license. That was the 90s. I don't know if they still do. Previously, it was not only done to check for STDs but more specifically to check for DNA compatibility. But often people already have children before getting married. But DNA compatibility was always a good reason to wait. You could end up falling in love with a lost relative.

    • @Witchmee
      @Witchmee 2 місяці тому

      Damn.. they should do that when you start dating or something instead. Imagine you're about to marry someone and it turns out he's a long lost half brother or something.

    • @lisanadile4688
      @lisanadile4688 19 днів тому

      This was actually done long before DNA and it was done to check for STDs, particularly syphillis, since that one’s the killer, and the RH blood factor to alert for issues with pregnancy.

  • @Shoutatclouds
    @Shoutatclouds 2 місяці тому +47

    Birmingham in uk has had a real issue.
    Massive birth defects

    • @obesetuna3164
      @obesetuna3164 2 місяці тому

      Yes I can imagine. A city full of Muslim half wits.

    • @col.barnsby8595
      @col.barnsby8595 2 місяці тому +5

      Imagine wanting this group to turn out healthy. You're digging your own grave.

    • @HistoryWithD-n9y
      @HistoryWithD-n9y 2 місяці тому

      Could only think of immigratoin or the fact that birmingham is just being normal birmingham

    • @Shoutatclouds
      @Shoutatclouds 2 місяці тому +1

      @@HistoryWithD-n9y it's immigration alright

    • @HistoryWithD-n9y
      @HistoryWithD-n9y 2 місяці тому

      @@Shoutatclouds Agreed

  • @tamirheinhardt1606
    @tamirheinhardt1606 3 місяці тому +55

    This has been proven for many years

  • @janchovanec8624
    @janchovanec8624 Місяць тому +2

    Hello Historian,
    Good content.
    Please remake this video with a functional audio. It's a torture fest going through it. The only way I could watch was without audio with subtitles.

  • @aman_chandravanshi
    @aman_chandravanshi 2 місяці тому +25

    In Hindu culture (mostly in North Indian cultures) We have a Concept of 'Gotra'. It says, one is not allowed to marry in same Gotra. And a Gotra consists of Family with 4 generations of men. That means, For my Gotra- Me, My Father, My grand Father and My great Grand Father, All of our family comes under one Gotra, And there shall NEVER be any Matrimonial alliance from the same Gotra.

  • @SaadKhan-ii8ml
    @SaadKhan-ii8ml 2 місяці тому +38

    As Pakistani.. this is because in Pakistan peoples want money and power remain in their family

    • @LordGeneralOHara
      @LordGeneralOHara 2 місяці тому +23

      Abandon Pakistani Culture

    • @watcheronly71
      @watcheronly71 2 місяці тому +3

      That's not only their culture ​@@LordGeneralOHara

    • @Kioki1-x8p
      @Kioki1-x8p 2 місяці тому

      @@LordGeneralOHara That's not their culture, lmao, it was introduced when they converted to Islam. Before that they had Gotra system that prevented cousin marriages, they're less inbred than rest of centuries old Muslim communities in middle-east.

    • @mercedesbenz3751
      @mercedesbenz3751 2 місяці тому +5

      Wow I didn't know Pakistanis had so much money and power.

    • @HistoryWithD-n9y
      @HistoryWithD-n9y 2 місяці тому +1

      They arent going to live long or even enjoy all that money and power

  • @bugleboop
    @bugleboop 3 місяці тому +36

    I think I heard somewhere like top countries of cousin marriages are all over the middle east if I recall it's either sudan or somali that is even higher.

    • @carolinegardner8214
      @carolinegardner8214 2 місяці тому +5

      The Moslem part of Sudan not the Bantu south

    • @birdofthenight
      @birdofthenight 2 місяці тому

      No inbreeding among Somalis. It is a taboo. Inbreeding is an Arabic thing, and Somalis are NOT Arabs

    • @birdofthenight
      @birdofthenight 2 місяці тому +2

      @@carolinegardner8214 South Sudanese ethnic groups are all nilotic, not bantu

    • @keshi5541
      @keshi5541 2 місяці тому

      @@carolinegardner8214 Since when are south sudanese Bantu?

  • @ajmersingh3043
    @ajmersingh3043 2 місяці тому +3

    Danish psychologist Nikola Sennels has done extensive research into the problem of inbreeding in Muslims for fifty generations (roughly 250 years).It may well have done irreversible damage to the Muslim gene pool.
    In Pakistan 70 percent are inbred.
    A Pakistani origin girl went to Bradford in the UK to find out about the inbred children.She left in tears and said "I will never have children of my own after what I saw in Bradford in the Muslim community"
    It is very heart breaking.And what did the grown ups say?They said "Inshalla"==God`s will.That was recorded on a UK TV.

  • @varoonnone7159
    @varoonnone7159 2 місяці тому +41

    Saying that Islam is not to blame is misleading
    I'm from Mauritius and Muslim Mauritians immigrated to Mauritius as indentured labourers from 1834 to the 1920s just as Hindu indentured labourers
    Most of the Hindus and Muslims came from current day Bihar
    Yet, to this day, cousin marriage is prevalent il Mauritius among muslims to the point that the government had to ask muslim authorities to discourage cousin marriages due to the heavy number of children born with congenital defects in these families

    • @Azothoth827
      @Azothoth827 2 місяці тому +1

      same could be said about christianity right? many christians dont actaully pay attention to their religon and do bad things so with your logic ""saying that christianity isnt to blame is misleading",cousin marriage is not encouraged in islam and if pakistanis learned about islam they might have still married their cousins but not excessively most edujacted muslims dont are against it,learn about islam brother/sister before spreading misinformation,i would never udge a uculture before understanding the people and their texts,and also there is alot of economic pressure.

    • @Logan55689
      @Logan55689 2 місяці тому +4

      @@Azothoth827Keep repeating that to yourself, maybe one day you'll convince yourself it's true. Cope harder.

    • @Azothoth827
      @Azothoth827 2 місяці тому

      @logan55689 yea if you are a scholar that knows every inch of islam,i m against it aswell,you cant even tell the basics of what we believe,how about actually learning about us? islam probits excessiveness in anything if it brings harm,

    • @Azothoth827
      @Azothoth827 2 місяці тому

      and how is it cope when i also am against inbreeding situation?who knows more about islam?you or me who has been gaining knowledge since birth for 18 years,i dont follow blindly i question each aspect of my faith

    • @pkhaloobonaccio9883
      @pkhaloobonaccio9883 2 місяці тому

      depi kan linn dire sa? It's true that cousin marriage is more prevalent in Muslims in Mauritius . However, it is very small compared to other countries . This is because many Muslim actually came from merchants background , this is why many have successful businesses in Mauritius.
      Also we have a fair share of high achieving Muslim in academics, if incest was super prevalent , the overall IQ of Muslims would have been lower than other races .
      However, although they form less than 20% of the Mauritian population , they are very represented in scholarship entrance exams awards . Which is not really the case for the 2nd most populated race in Mauritius , the African Creole .
      How do you explain this ?
      Btw Im a Mauritian , and my race is from the majority race of the country .

  • @OutOfElmo
    @OutOfElmo 2 місяці тому +50

    Why should Europeans and western nations have to be saddled with the costs of this? Are we benefiting in some way?

    • @baron420
      @baron420 2 місяці тому +21

      nope we are not

    • @Adam-wg2rf
      @Adam-wg2rf 2 місяці тому +6

      Agree😔

    • @col.barnsby8595
      @col.barnsby8595 2 місяці тому +8

      You're benefitting in a way that now you understand that you don't need to be compassionate towards this debris this time. TNWD!

    • @birdofthenight
      @birdofthenight 2 місяці тому +1

      Sorry to disappoint you! Inbreeding has been common among Europeans for ages and in the U.S., especially in Alabama, Arkansas, West Virginia, etc. Nonexistent in Africa except among North Africans (Arabs)

    • @OutOfElmo
      @OutOfElmo 2 місяці тому +1

      @@birdofthenight Common? You're deluded, or lying. As for Africans, they don't need to be inbred to cost their host nations billions. They're as destructive as a plague of locusts just the way they are.

  • @markgallagher5908
    @markgallagher5908 2 місяці тому +10

    Check out the lad with his two girlfriends at 0:55, they don't just marry their cousins....

  • @thomasdonovan3580
    @thomasdonovan3580 3 місяці тому +241

    The two things you should never do, Square Dancing and Inbreeding.

    • @flickrebeat8936
      @flickrebeat8936 3 місяці тому +23

      😂 what's wrong with square dancing 😂?

    • @drmodestoesq
      @drmodestoesq 3 місяці тому +22

      I believe the joke goes, "You should try everything a least once. Except for incest and Morris Dancing."

    • @Clingerman93
      @Clingerman93 2 місяці тому

      The U.S. isn't even in the top 10 of inbred country's. However the majority of the Middle East is😂​@ShadiwBanned

    • @erikybarra3898
      @erikybarra3898 2 місяці тому +3

      LMAO

    • @vavoropo
      @vavoropo 2 місяці тому

      ​@ShadiwBannedFor what reason ?

  • @bengaldevilbdgr6956
    @bengaldevilbdgr6956 2 місяці тому +31

    Even in India muslims marry among their cousins though the numbers not as much as pakistan .Converted muslims tend to marry among themselves may be becoz of identity crisis.

  • @chrisd924
    @chrisd924 3 місяці тому +83

    Birth defects in Bradford in the UK are double the national average although first cousin marriages have declined since 2010. Its not just the Pakistani communities - look no further than King Charles if you want to see a prime example of inbreeding.

    • @cass7200
      @cass7200 3 місяці тому +1

      He's not that inbred. Even totting up all the historical relative marriage in his parents lines he still comes out a fair amount less inbred than a kid of first generation first cousin marriage.

    • @kaneworsnop1007
      @kaneworsnop1007 3 місяці тому +30

      It's not just the Royal family in the UK, but the nobles/old money. When you meet a posh sounding person they often have the horse like facial features, the large top teeth (just think of the common posh person caracture). That's because all the noble minority wouldn't marry the common masses. So a degree on inbreeding occurred, due to a relatively small community. By looks alone you can often tell the differance between someone who is true old money and former nobility, compared to the industrial revolution old money as they are less inbred and were looked down on by the nobility.
      The royal family is then worse again as they generally married other royals, mostly to secure alliances with other countries, so even more inbreeding occurred. Fortunately its started to become slightly more acceptable for royals to marry people with slightly less noble blood, so their genetics will gradually improve.
      I cant remember if it is sickle cell or another genetic disease which is thought to be prevalent in the royal family due to inbreeding.

    • @ococototo
      @ococototo 3 місяці тому

      @@kaneworsnop1007 its haemophilia

    • @mehrcat1
      @mehrcat1 3 місяці тому

      Royalty is famously inbred. Do a search for the 'Habsburg Chin'.

    • @T-Ball-o
      @T-Ball-o 3 місяці тому +4

      Yes, very apropos comparison. Not.

  • @dbmail545
    @dbmail545 2 місяці тому +2

    One of the driving factors is the presence of "blood" feuds where relatives must avenge actions against relatives. Keeping blood close keeps people from taking on another family's blood feuds as obligations.

  • @kekhusetozao7641
    @kekhusetozao7641 2 місяці тому +57

    Sweet home pakistan.

  • @reinokarvinen8845
    @reinokarvinen8845 2 місяці тому +102

    australian aboriginals had traditional rules how to avoid inbreeding

    • @col.barnsby8595
      @col.barnsby8595 2 місяці тому +12

      Didn't help them to become anything though lmao. They exist solely due to the good will of the Anglo-Celtic culture-bearers and this good will is running out

    • @FodaseNaoLigo
      @FodaseNaoLigo 2 місяці тому

      British imperialism is the reason they are not developed , killed 90% of their population, dont worry muslim immigrants will do the same with western europe​@@col.barnsby8595

    • @DaisyMaeMoses
      @DaisyMaeMoses 2 місяці тому +1

      Very complex rules and the rules applied for centuries back!

    • @abhilash9918
      @abhilash9918 2 місяці тому

      Even paxtanis didnt do it till they were infected by the islamic vir,us.
      Look at the comments. Almost every tribe or ancient people had rules against it but islam is trojan horse that corrupts the operating system.

    • @horsepuncher95
      @horsepuncher95 2 місяці тому +10

      ​@@col.barnsby8595Bold of you to assume most Aussies ever had good will towards them

  • @dadsire-TV
    @dadsire-TV 3 місяці тому +16

    I would share your video but there is so much audio feedback in the recording. Please fix and reupload this is important information.

  • @Destroyer4700
    @Destroyer4700 2 місяці тому +3

    Gee, the partition of India worked so well for the UK. Now all of the incredible people of Pakistan are moving to the UK to turn it into West West Pakistan.

  • @ACMR6297
    @ACMR6297 2 місяці тому +17

    Only 3 minutes in but I’ll take a stab in the dark:
    It’s a consequence of loneliness within the younger generation. Sure older Pakistanis also married first cousins, but younger generations are more inclined as it represents a means to escaping their loneliness.
    The reason why they would marry their first cousins rather than another Pakistani from outside the family could be twofold: one is that they may already be familiar with the individual and aware of who they are getting hitched to; second it preserves the family’s wealth.

    • @Tragic.Kingdom
      @Tragic.Kingdom 2 місяці тому +3

      Get to know other ppl

    • @ponygirl6258
      @ponygirl6258 2 місяці тому +9

      Not sure why they would be more lonely than earlier generations, since there are more Pakistani-British now than ever before. Also, Pakistani-British men are not infrequently married to Pakistani cousins they barely know. It really has to do with religion, tradition, and money.

  • @nctjay
    @nctjay 3 місяці тому +74

    Ew why you would marry your cousin?

    • @CarolineIronwill
      @CarolineIronwill 3 місяці тому +32

      to keep money and power in the family.

    • @nctjay
      @nctjay 3 місяці тому +22

      @@CarolineIronwill the history the habsburgs should be taught in pakistan

    • @drmodestoesq
      @drmodestoesq 3 місяці тому +25

      @@nctjay Weren't the Hapsburgs insanely rich and powerful? That's gonna sound like an endorsement of inbreeding.

    • @nctjay
      @nctjay 3 місяці тому +12

      @@drmodestoesq Fine then show them the whittaker family

    • @dennismukoyatv
      @dennismukoyatv 2 місяці тому +12

      ​@@drmodestoesq It will not. There is no amount of wealth in this world that can offset the detrimental impact of inbreeding.

  • @hwaidasweilem8955
    @hwaidasweilem8955 2 місяці тому +11

    5:03 Simultaneously saying uncles and nieces are not exempt from the prohibition, while showing a verse of the Quran saying exactly the opposite! "your father's sisters, your mother's sisters, your brothers daughters, your sisters daughters".🤦‍♀

    • @Waqooyi
      @Waqooyi 2 місяці тому +2

      Yeah he clearly made a large mistake adding that uncles are allowed to marry which isn’t true and clearly says the opposite in the verse.

    • @adrianadam8543
      @adrianadam8543 2 місяці тому +1

      0 Pakistani people have uncle or niece marriages.

  • @cuttysarklnd
    @cuttysarklnd Місяць тому +2

    In Kazakhstan, we have a deeply rooted tradition of keeping our bloodlines pure by avoiding inbreeding for up to the seventh generation-a practice passed down from our nomadic ancestors. This “7 Ata”principle reflects our commitment to strong, healthy communities and the wisdom of our heritage. Salam from 🇰🇿

  • @mikesheth5370
    @mikesheth5370 3 місяці тому +47

    European countries give incentive ! They allow immigration of close relatives!😊

    • @-_YouMayFind_-
      @-_YouMayFind_- 2 місяці тому +1

      Incest is actually not really allowed.

    • @mikesheth5370
      @mikesheth5370 2 місяці тому

      @@-_YouMayFind_- That’s true. However first cousin marriages are allowed according to tradition and sharia! I was talking about many countries of Europe allowing immigration of close relatives !

  • @realdoctortenenbaum
    @realdoctortenenbaum 3 місяці тому +80

    Finally you tackle a topic that incest researchers otherwise avoid for reasons of political correctness!

    • @mybeaniebooz9601
      @mybeaniebooz9601 2 місяці тому +1

      "But theres no studies saying that breeding with your cousin causes deformities!!!" Riiight 😂

    • @yucol5661
      @yucol5661 2 місяці тому +4

      They don’t avoid it. The guy literally showed research papers on it. Scientist don’t avoid much of anything, like MSG or criminology or bibble archeology. Harder when it’s not a profitable field, and healthcare generally is.

    • @ibrahimihsan2090
      @ibrahimihsan2090 2 місяці тому

      Tons of incest researchers discuss it. Even Pakistani newspapers.
      You don't need to be a bigot to point such practices out.

  • @chadwhitman1811
    @chadwhitman1811 3 місяці тому +79

    I think one reason might be the use of the broad term Pakistani which by nationalist standards would imply one cohesive group. Pakistani has to do with citizenship not ethnicity. In fact Pakistan has at least thirteen ethnic groups ." The major Pakistani ethnolinguistic groups include Punjabis, Pashtuns, Sindhis, Saraikis, Muhajirs, Balochs, Hindkowans/Hazarewals, Brahuis, Meos, and Kohistanis" .Plus there are other sizeable minorities. That is not to include various religious groups all with their own subculture and identity. To an outsider they are all Pakistani ,but all those groups are tightly bonded communities and it's members want to marry in that group.

    • @KOOLBadger
      @KOOLBadger 3 місяці тому +9

      Gross aye'?

    • @moh__shuvuu
      @moh__shuvuu 3 місяці тому +19

      This is true. However if they’re first cousins, they are probably in the same ethnicity, right? But not all people of the same ethnicity are first cousins.

    • @chadwhitman1811
      @chadwhitman1811 3 місяці тому +6

      @@moh__shuvuu This is true. However a smaller population group such as any ethnic group in the UK ,the pool of likely brides thar are not related to you becomes less and less .To take another group such as Icelanders ,very little in migration the gene pool is so restricted they publish lists of who is related to who.I noticed Qatar is also mentioned ,the percentage of Qatari subjects that are citizens is small and most of rest are subjects are of non Quatari descrnt.The advantages of be a citizen in Qatar are great which makes it an exclusive club.

    • @diorocks5858
      @diorocks5858 3 місяці тому +22

      I worked in Bahrain and Pakistanis and Bangladeshis have a DNA test before being offered a Work Contract as hey became a strain on the medical health system. Each ethnic group in Pakistan in breed and stay within the ethnic group.

    • @Lilac_liha
      @Lilac_liha 2 місяці тому

      ​@@diorocks5858 Bangladesh? Arent they mostly homogeneous?

  • @marcelacristina129
    @marcelacristina129 2 місяці тому +12

    Argh. Why people want to live like it's the middle ages is beyond me

    • @ibrahimihsan2090
      @ibrahimihsan2090 2 місяці тому +2

      Because not everything isn't your cup of tea is the Middle Ages.
      would you like me to consider homoeroticism something that belonged to the Antiquity period?

    • @ecclesiastes1175
      @ecclesiastes1175 2 місяці тому

      Because their religion is stuck in the middle ages.

  • @MasimbaMusodza
    @MasimbaMusodza 2 місяці тому +5

    In southern Africa, the definition of incest includes members of the same clan, as signified by the totem. I am of the Shumba totem, and anyone of the same totem, even if they were from another ethnic group or country (such as Banda in Malawi, Tau in Lesotho etc) is considered a close relative. Mother's clan is also considered taboo. In our urbanised society, dating from within the same neighbourhood was frowned upon when I was growing up in Zimbabwe.

  • @cpstr828
    @cpstr828 2 місяці тому +23

    I think cousin marriage was fairly common in Europe but really declined with growing mobility brought about by industrialization. On my mother's side I think I have one set of German great-grandparents who were cousins (second cousins I assume). On my father's side somewhat further back, looking at some online genealogy data, I found that there was a marriage where one spouse's grandparents were the other's great-grandparents. This was in a small village in the 19th century Wallonia.

    • @mmhthree
      @mmhthree 2 місяці тому +2

      My Mother's family has a genetic bone defect in the Chafin family line. It is passed via the female. I did the genealogy and found a cousin marriage in the early 1800's, and I believe that is where the defect was born.

    • @Witchmee
      @Witchmee 2 місяці тому +1

      When you live in a small village, it can be like that, especially since there was no internet or anything. They still tend to stick to at least 2nd cousins though.

  • @shivambhalla4525
    @shivambhalla4525 2 місяці тому +12

    Good content, but buddy there was something wrong with the voice editing. The last words of most sentence sounded very very sharp for some reason, so some constructive feedback for the growth of your chanel.

    • @QuantumNinja1.9
      @QuantumNinja1.9 2 місяці тому

      Aur usne pakistani punjab ko Indian bol Diya.
      Aaya bada factual UA-camr👻

  • @kjaubrey4816
    @kjaubrey4816 2 місяці тому +1

    Sounds like Scottsboro, Alabama. It is a small town and nobody moves there. People get married and then find out they are related in multiple ways. I bought a nice house in the countryside not far from there and could not go grocery shopping without people constantly stopping me to tell me how beautiful my kids were. I finally started telling them, "Their mom and dad weren't cousins".
    The people there were visibly inbred with asymmetrical faces and I don't recall one intelligent conversation in eight years of living near there. The local gas station owner was even spreading rumours that I was a government assassin to the people of the town because I wore a suit every day as I worked at an office 40 miles away in the "big city". (Huntsville, AL)

    • @75aces97
      @75aces97 2 місяці тому +1

      Yeah, but were you a gummint assassin? 😋

  • @vmundi
    @vmundi 2 місяці тому +9

    1:52 you said first cousins in punjab, india.. i highly doubt it.. majority of punjabis(sikhs and punjabi hindus) consider consaginous marriages a sin

  • @mehak-GB
    @mehak-GB 2 місяці тому +27

    In Pakistani society, a cousin is neither sister nor brother. In fact, there is a segregation of genders where cousins are not allowed to intermingle with each other. Arranged marriages are more common than loved ones. In Pakistani social structure, marriage is the union of families not the union of couples. There are problems of domestic violence and honor killings also which prompt the parents to marry their children in the family to secure their daughters so that if something happens they can control the situation. Thirdly, the Pakistani social structure tends to make their own family stronger and marriages in the same family strengthen the bond with respect to power and money in society.

    • @TarekRamara
      @TarekRamara 2 місяці тому

      It’s basically due to their conversion. Ghar vapsi is the only solution and now even Arabs have orphaned them. Keep fake Arab names will not make them Arabs but just wannabes

    • @birdofthenight
      @birdofthenight 2 місяці тому +7

      At what cost?

    • @TarekRamara
      @TarekRamara 2 місяці тому +6

      Only if prophet knew about genetic defects

    • @bwa_8
      @bwa_8 2 місяці тому +4

      It doesn't make the family stronger... This is literally regarded.

    • @mehak-GB
      @mehak-GB 2 місяці тому

      @@bwa_8 Socio-political structure gets stronger with respect to land and social structure. Also unlike the west, people tend to more drawn to their families and if some one torture one family member then whole family consisting of even 500 mebers come to save them. In pushtun region, even whole tribe comes for him. Mostly people consider genetic science as conspiracy.

  • @Busyhriehfjeje
    @Busyhriehfjeje 2 місяці тому +6

    My paternal grandfathers parent were Lebanese and we had some cousin marriages as well. Older generations did that.
    There is a theory that the reason why some of us from that side of the family and their descendants (myself included) have some weird conditions with our blood.

  • @4_dennyfauzulhakim479
    @4_dennyfauzulhakim479 2 місяці тому +2

    what's up with the buzzing from (presumably) your mic bruv?
    great informative content, consider checking your mic, mic cable, or mic port tho.
    the constant buzzing hurts the quality of the video.

  • @KOOLBadger
    @KOOLBadger 3 місяці тому +62

    And people make fun our mountain folks in the USA..😂..

    • @Ash_Queen16
      @Ash_Queen16 2 місяці тому +18

      Right? That’s peanuts compared to this!

    • @dwaynekeenum1916
      @dwaynekeenum1916 2 місяці тому

      Yeh it’s Mickey mouse

    • @bigdaddy7729
      @bigdaddy7729 2 місяці тому

      But u mountain folks do with ur real sister and stuff!!!

    • @KOOLBadger
      @KOOLBadger 2 місяці тому

      @@bigdaddy7729 what? Not anymore you stupid. And all royality are closely related! Queen Elizabeth II married her cousin Philip. All those folks are related. Are you a child?

    • @KOOLBadger
      @KOOLBadger 2 місяці тому

      @@dwaynekeenum1916 ?