Watch BEFORE You Buy! | Fractal Terra Thermal Issues

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 25 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 112

  • @LuckyOctober
    @LuckyOctober 5 місяців тому +8

    Fractal Terra case
    i7-14700kf
    ASUS RTX 4080 proart
    Coolermaster 1100 watt SFF psu
    Noctua nh l9x65
    1 noctua exhaust fan a12x15
    Some RGB Corsair Ram 32gb
    Call of duty warzone: 100•C cpu
    Other games: 60-80•C cpu
    GPU range 40-70

    • @kyle_munoz
      @kyle_munoz  5 місяців тому

      Congrats on the build! My issues weren't with gaming, they were more for video editing and exporting. Glad you could set this up in a way that works for you !

    • @Viquor
      @Viquor 5 місяців тому +1

      I have nearly the same build.
      i7 14700k
      Asus RTX 4070 Ti proart
      Corsair sf1000 psu
      ID cooling is-55 cooler replaced fan with Noctua fan
      And 2 exhaust fans at the bottom.
      Highest I got was 87•C on Warzone.
      Although my pc is abit loud I still enjoy the build.

    • @LuckyOctober
      @LuckyOctober 5 місяців тому +2

      @@Viquor that’s great temps. I switched to the noctua L12Sx77 (the one with the fan on the bottom of the heatsink) and it significantly reduced noise.
      This also dropped my temps by 5-10 degrees.

    • @kyle_munoz
      @kyle_munoz  5 місяців тому +1

      how were you able to fit two fans at the bottom?

    • @Viquor
      @Viquor 5 місяців тому

      @@kyle_munoz I was able to mount 2 corsair 120 slim fans with grills outside on the bottom with just enough clearance for the feet and abit of air to escape. Not ideal but works and doesn’t look to bad

  • @proximal43
    @proximal43 5 місяців тому +14

    Most all sandwich sff cases are negative pressure like this for the best thermal results. Just comes with the territory. I have a terra with a 7800x3d and 4090FE and its runs quite well.

    • @kyle_munoz
      @kyle_munoz  5 місяців тому +3

      yeah understood. I definitely take blame for putting a hot ass CPU in there lol

    • @CarnivoryHODL
      @CarnivoryHODL 5 місяців тому

      What cooler for 7800x3d? Undervolt both CPU & GPU?

    • @kyle_munoz
      @kyle_munoz  5 місяців тому

      ^^^

    • @icephoenix3565
      @icephoenix3565 4 місяці тому

      Can you post your build? I'm trying the same thing

    • @kyle_munoz
      @kyle_munoz  4 місяці тому

      ^^^

  • @aharte17
    @aharte17 Місяць тому +2

    I have a FormD T1, which the Terra was (very) inspired by layout-wise.
    Nice thing about the T1 is you can flip it upside down and install two full-size 120MM fans as top exhaust, completely nullifying the “pulling in hot exhaust” problem.
    Funnily enough that is actually the upside-down position, despite most UA-camrs setting it up this way seemingly by default. Which makes sense as, you know… heat rises.

    • @kyle_munoz
      @kyle_munoz  Місяць тому

      Makes total sense! I don’t understand why the design wouldn’t be like that by default but i’m glad people are realizing that that’s the better way to have it.

  • @KocourMiki
    @KocourMiki 4 місяці тому +9

    I think your issue is using an Intel CPU... they hog power and output too much heat... just get a 7800x3d

    • @kyle_munoz
      @kyle_munoz  4 місяці тому +1

      Agreed! Intel CPUS are wayyyy too hot for a case like this. It’s honestly kinda ridiculous the kind of power they draw

  • @pandalife_gaming
    @pandalife_gaming 3 місяці тому +2

    I'd recommend setting some strict power draw limits for your cpu in bios. Undervolting helps but it'll still try to draw the full 200+ watts and there's just no way any cooler that fits the Terra is gonna keep up with that. I'd think maybe 120w at best but you know, do your own testing.

    • @kyle_munoz
      @kyle_munoz  3 місяці тому

      I actually did both. I don’t remember the exact numbers but i undervolted as well as had power limits at around 130W. It helped, but like you said, there no way to cool something that power hungry without proper airflow. It’s tough because I really liked the look of this thing

  • @UNLKYHNTR
    @UNLKYHNTR Місяць тому

    It actually lowered my CPU and GPU temps by 4°C. Having the fan as an exhaust actually turns the case into a Negative pressure situation, thus forcing cold air inside.

  • @0mnikron702
    @0mnikron702 Місяць тому

    You can undervolt the cpu to cool the cpu and you can do it with the gpu and drop even more heat outta of the case the choice of cool also makes a difference the case isn’t that big of a problem as you make it sound to be

    • @kyle_munoz
      @kyle_munoz  Місяць тому

      If you paid attention, I already mentioned that I tried undervolting and temps still were very high. The cooler is the biggest one I could find that fits in this case except for the one that came out after I had already gotten rid of it. I made this problem out to be as big as it was in reality for me. The case was too hot and didn’t have enough proper ventilation for my use so i made a video letting people know that if they also had this issue too, they’re not alone

  • @vaporhazy
    @vaporhazy 4 місяці тому +1

    Fractal Terra case
    Ryzen 7 5800x3D (undervolted and legit see zero performance issue in benchmarks and renders)
    rtx 4060 gigabyte low profile
    Corsair SFX 750
    Thermalright AXP90 X47 (Full Copper)
    zero exhaust fan
    Corsair Ram 32gb
    CPU has never went above 85c in (COD Cold War, Overwatch, Cyberpunk 2077) HOT SPOT in stress test 3dmark steel nomad was 85C on GPU.
    After Effects 3D rendering CPU was pushing 80C consistently- luckily I use premiere mostly for my job lol. Premiere was 100% fine doing 4K video editing.
    GPU range 40-72
    I've not had issues, but I might install a top mounted exhaust fan to help with the temps a bit.

    • @kyle_munoz
      @kyle_munoz  4 місяці тому

      That’s awesome! Yeah from what I’ve seen, Ryzen CPUs work well in this case. Less power hungry so less heat to get rid of.

  • @y_kajikawa
    @y_kajikawa 3 місяці тому

    I agree.
    The airflow is poor and there are problems with cooling the motherboard. The operating temperature of the M2 SSD is quite high and sometimes a fatal error occurs.
    I changed to the NCASE M2.

    • @kyle_munoz
      @kyle_munoz  3 місяці тому

      M2 seems to be a great case! Keep me updated on how it goes!

    • @y_kajikawa
      @y_kajikawa 3 місяці тому +2

      @@kyle_munoz The installation of the NCASE M2 has improved to a level where there are no problems.
      The CPU temperature is -20°C after changing from an air-cooled cooler to a 280mm liquid-cooled cooler. The GPU and motherboard temperatures have also dropped, but the drop in the ITX motherboard temperature is less than 10°C, including the operating temperature of the M2 SSD.
      As you point out, airflow is important for cooling.
      Cooling performance is a weak point for ITX motherboards, as each manufacturer adds small fans to the VRM and M2 SSD.

    • @kyle_munoz
      @kyle_munoz  3 місяці тому

      yeah, i’ve seen very similar improvements after swapping cases and moving to liquid cooling.

  • @itstusk9495
    @itstusk9495 3 місяці тому +1

    this case I believe is built for productivity in mind meaning its not designed for gaming so the power draw doesn't need to be that high else you will run into problems. look for cheap 4k builds that will save you money use less psu power to run meaning it'll run cooler. This isn't built for high end gaming in mind cos the more power you spit out the hotter this thing will run.

    • @itstusk9495
      @itstusk9495 3 місяці тому

      I have found a fix potentially for this case that lowered my temps by 10-20 degrees Celsius. Download a software called Throttlestop and set power plan to either 'Save Power' or 'Balanced' this is set to 'performance' or 'high performance' by default.

    • @kyle_munoz
      @kyle_munoz  3 місяці тому

      Exactly my point with this video. This case is not meant to have a high end workstation put in it. Even with undervolting and power limiting, the airflow is just not sufficient to cool the components.

    • @itstusk9495
      @itstusk9495 3 місяці тому

      @@kyle_munoz I found changing my power plan has helped bring down my temps even while gaming. I would look into doing that the case is a little beast and having everything set to performance isn't going to be great for this case.

    • @kyle_munoz
      @kyle_munoz  3 місяці тому

      same, but everything i tried wasn’t enough to bring the cpu temps to under thermal throttle threshold so i just swapped cases

    • @itstusk9495
      @itstusk9495 3 місяці тому

      @@kyle_munoz oh fairs I managed to achieve good reads 48 degrees on desktop and 60-70 in game. I did have 90-100 and I was soo worried this thing was gunna blow up lol. I will be trying to add 2 fans to the top of the case eventually but that'll happen down the line.

  • @NikolayBoyanov
    @NikolayBoyanov Місяць тому

    after undervolting my CPU i don't have any cooling problems. In my opinion, the fan pushing from below is not such a problem for the rest of the components, because it is located in the front of the case, and the CPU and theGPU are in the back - I could be wrong, but that's what I think. Im whit Ryzen 9 5900X, and 4060Ti

    • @kyle_munoz
      @kyle_munoz  Місяць тому +1

      Yeah typically the thermal issues occur with Intel CPUs

  • @KocourMiki
    @KocourMiki 4 місяці тому +1

    4070ti super slim MSI, 7800x3x with AN600... I have no thermal issues even during extensive gaming... no additional fans.

    • @kyle_munoz
      @kyle_munoz  4 місяці тому

      that’s really solid!

  • @harryf7351
    @harryf7351 4 місяці тому +1

    I'm a little concerned as I'll be using the L9i noctua cooler. But hopefully it'll work, the cooler is compatible and the 9700X is pretty power efficient so here's hoping!

    • @kyle_munoz
      @kyle_munoz  4 місяці тому

      I think you’ll be good. Maybe a little under volt just to ensure but I think it should stay within a safe temp range.

    • @PopcornLover200
      @PopcornLover200 3 місяці тому

      I’d recommend the l12s or x77 variant

    • @kyle_munoz
      @kyle_munoz  3 місяці тому

      ^^^

  • @frodo1488
    @frodo1488 9 днів тому

    really awesome video, had me a little worried for the build i had planned in mind but when you mentioned you're using a 13700k i was at ease 😭😭 that thing drawing 200+ watts is nuuuts. im going for a 78x3d or 98x3d (if its available) while using an axp 100 full copper but im debating using that or an axp90 full copper

    • @kyle_munoz
      @kyle_munoz  9 днів тому

      yeah 200W is ridiculous in a case this small 😂. But for your setup I don’t think you can really go wrong with either. I’ve seen that there are only marginal gains when using the axp100 over the axp90 so I’d say save some money and space and get the 90.

  • @themistokliskalatzis934
    @themistokliskalatzis934 2 місяці тому

    Why you don't swap the fan to intake air from down and exhaust from top..🎉

    • @kyle_munoz
      @kyle_munoz  2 місяці тому

      as i mentioned in the video, i did try that and temps got worse 😂

  • @stanislavkk2808
    @stanislavkk2808 4 місяці тому +1

    So what case do u use now?

    • @kyle_munoz
      @kyle_munoz  4 місяці тому

      hahaa video coming soon about this but I ended up going with the SSUPD Meshroom S V2

  • @Kronique
    @Kronique 22 дні тому

    Funny, I came for the lut editing video a few months ago, and now this haha

  • @rolandux123
    @rolandux123 5 місяців тому

    I7-13700F, cooler axp120-x67 . Was quite ok browsing, playing CS. But temps reached 90c and sometimes 100 while playing Cyberpunk. I have Asus mb, ended up settings default intel power limits.

    • @kyle_munoz
      @kyle_munoz  5 місяців тому

      Yeah same here. I played around with power limits and i think i ended up being stable around 155W, and it helped but not as much as I'd hoped. @viquor has had some success with two slim fans on the bottom of the case, maybe try that out and see if the extra airflow helps?

  • @FoghornWashington
    @FoghornWashington 2 місяці тому

    What case did you buy?

    • @kyle_munoz
      @kyle_munoz  2 місяці тому +1

      ended up with the SSUPD Meshroom S V2. Couldn’t be happier!

  • @chrisrussellca
    @chrisrussellca 4 місяці тому +3

    Just returned mine. Had some defects and it was a skillet

    • @kyle_munoz
      @kyle_munoz  4 місяці тому +2

      LMFAO A SKILLET! I like that. What’s your replacement gonna be?

    • @chrisrussellca
      @chrisrussellca 4 місяці тому

      @@kyle_munoz I have several cases, 3 T1’s and just got a Meshroom S v2 for testing.

    • @kyle_munoz
      @kyle_munoz  4 місяці тому +1

      holy crap! Dude your channel is sick! What do you use all these PCs for??

  • @Nierez
    @Nierez 4 місяці тому

    There is nothing but the FormD T1? Guess I'll just get in line 😅

    • @kyle_munoz
      @kyle_munoz  4 місяці тому

      Lian Li, Corsair, and SSUPD actually make some cases that fit the bill for me. I’m making a video about the case i replaced the fractal with very soon.

  • @themistokliskalatzis934
    @themistokliskalatzis934 2 місяці тому

    Maybe you did something wrong in the air flow department...heat goes up so you have to orient everything to Go Up..❤

    • @kyle_munoz
      @kyle_munoz  2 місяці тому

      see that’s what i thought too but when i change the direction of the fans to push the air upward, the temps increased. 😕

  • @zajebanosaurus
    @zajebanosaurus 2 місяці тому +1

    the guy did the math

    • @kyle_munoz
      @kyle_munoz  2 місяці тому

      and people still doubting me 😂

  • @juliuslagmay
    @juliuslagmay 5 місяців тому

    Woah, that’s a really good point. Love this video! Ill definitely consider this on my PC build.

  • @vidurbutalia2130
    @vidurbutalia2130 5 місяців тому +3

    Man has a mech. eng. degree (from LMU, but still) and has a UA-cam channel. what influencer stole your girl, man

    • @kyle_munoz
      @kyle_munoz  5 місяців тому +1

      woah woah, no LMU slander here!

  • @mr.simmonds5681
    @mr.simmonds5681 3 місяці тому

    Optimum Tech did a similar video with the ghost S1 and saw lower temps using a single fan as exhaust. He did actual testing and posted results. Your video isn’t very scientific and seems more opinionated. When it comes to optimising thermals in a small itx case there are so many variables. It’s not impossible to run mid to high end components in this case while managing thermals.

    • @kyle_munoz
      @kyle_munoz  3 місяці тому

      This video was to show the theory of thermodynamics that I think proves why people are having issues using this case with high end, energy-hungry components. So yes, these are just my opinions but they are based in theory and weeks of research & testing within reason for a normal person like me. I don’t have extra CPUs, GPUs, or coolers to do side-by-side testing so reading about other people’s experiences showed that I wasn’t the only one experiencing this, leading to me making the video. I could’ve been more quantitative with my declarations, but that would’ve been too specific to my build, so I went with the qualitative conclusions that could be applied to a variety of different builds within this case.

  • @garphyst2826
    @garphyst2826 4 місяці тому

    new subscriber! saludos desde México 🌮

  • @oscarlopezmov
    @oscarlopezmov 5 місяців тому

    Love it!🔥🔥

  • @LS-is5ob
    @LS-is5ob 5 місяців тому

    formd case reveal :D?

    • @kyle_munoz
      @kyle_munoz  5 місяців тому

      hehee gotta wait and see!

  • @darkoz1692
    @darkoz1692 4 місяці тому +1

    I have this case and disagree with pretty much everything this guy said and I don't need a mechanical engineering degree to come to that conclusion.

    • @kyle_munoz
      @kyle_munoz  4 місяці тому +1

      Very interesting! I’d love to hear more about your experience and why you disagree.

    • @Travis_B_Chillin
      @Travis_B_Chillin 4 місяці тому

      @@kyle_munozcrickets 😂

    • @kyle_munoz
      @kyle_munoz  4 місяці тому

      LOL typical UA-cam commenter 😂

  • @chengong388
    @chengong388 5 місяців тому +3

    no, you're dumb for using a 13th gen intel CPU when there's much more efficient AMD available.
    But also, for thinking undervolting which is what a -5% power? is a solution to bad airflow. If your airflow is bad you need to fix the airflow not to reduce power consumption, but ok, say you wanted to reduce the power consumption for whatever reason, you would just do that with straight up setting a power limit, which is extremely simple and you can easily set a 50% or lower power limit without any stability issues. Yet you went for undervolting why? because it's a popular concept today?

    • @kyle_munoz
      @kyle_munoz  5 місяців тому +1

      Yup 13th gen wasn’t the best but I already took responsibility for that choice. Pretty obvious that fixing airflow is the solution to bad airflow…😂 The whole point of of the video is that the airflow in this case is not good, and since airflow is meant to cool components, reducing the heat produced by those components is another solution. When I said I undervolted, I meant that I both undervolted and power limited the CPU as low as i could while keeping it stable (around 140W as opposed to the stock 250W) and it was STILL thermal throttling. Any more helpful suggestions that maybe i haven’t tried yet?

  • @megadeth8592
    @megadeth8592 5 місяців тому +1

    you should just delete this.

    • @kyle_munoz
      @kyle_munoz  5 місяців тому

      Why?

    • @RagnarCrumpets
      @RagnarCrumpets 26 днів тому

      @@kyle_munoz Clearly he is jealous. He must get very upset every time he sees it in his feed. It can be the only reason.

    • @kyle_munoz
      @kyle_munoz  25 днів тому

      @@RagnarCrumpets LOLOL

    • @RagnarCrumpets
      @RagnarCrumpets 25 днів тому

      @@kyle_munoz hey while I have you. I just bought this case and overall I’m very happy with it but one thing I didn’t notice it is is that since the motherboard has to be installed upside down in the case that means that all the ports on the back are also upside down so when you look at it from the back all of the words for each of the ports is all upside down…..

    • @kyle_munoz
      @kyle_munoz  25 днів тому

      yeahhh, that happens in these SFF builds sometimes