Two Orca Ecotypes are Actually Separate Species
Вставка
- Опубліковано 26 сер 2024
- Orcas are currently classified as a singular, global species, which are further divided into roughly a dozen recognized Ecotypes, which themselves contain certain subgroups within each ecotype.
A new paper looked at the differences between two ecotypes in the North Pacific; the Transient and Resident ecotypes, and determined that both should be reclassified as their own distinct species of killer whale. Lets talk about it
Study Link: royalsocietypu...
Update: as of July, 2024 the Taxonomic Committee rejected the new species proposal. However, they did, for the time being, accept Bigg’s KWs and Resident KWs as separate subspecies.
So, we now have Orcinus orca orca (the standard KW), Orcinus orca rectipinus (Bigg’s KWs), and Orcinus orca ater (Resident KWs)
Great video! Orca enthusiast here.
Greetings from Cologne, Germany and from the „Mission Erde“ Community ☺️🐦⬛🌳🐠
Greetings from Germany. Your deserve much more credit for your work. #missionerde community keep it up.
Who is here from “Robert Marc Lehmann - Mission Erde” Community?
Like 50 people have mentioned this what in the world is going on?
@@Paleopedia218Robert Marc Lehmann is a German marine biologist and UA-camr who often reacts to your videos in his streams/videos 😄
@jaxteller0501 oh my god I’m getting reactions?! WHY HAS NOBODY TOLD ME
@jaxteller0501 alright I’ve only seen one vid of his where he reacts to mine where are the other ones I wanna KNOW lol
@@Paleopedia218 ua-cam.com/video/NbCI26AX4Kc/v-deo.html
greetings
"mission erde" here.
very well made summary of the paper. good to understand (for us non-scientists) and not to long
keep the good work up =)
Greetings from Germany, found you through Robert Marc Lehmann s "Mission Erde" Community.🌎🌍🌏❤️
greetings from mission earth community!! love your channel
greetings from Austria / Salzburg, and from the "Mission Erde comunity" i love your videos! i am so happy that i found you through Robert :3
Greetings from Germany #missionerde 🌳🐟
I found your video on the #MissionErde channel via a reaction video.
Very well explained and very interesting!
You deserve more clicks!
Greetings from Mission Erde!
Some more love from Germany! It was a pleasure to watch your video. Very informative. Let‘s hope the best
#missionerde
Mission Erde 🌎
This is great news for orcas and orca enthusiasts - (greetings from Mission Erde Community)❤❤❤
Great Channel - greetings from Germany (just watched reaction of Robert)
You deserve a lot more subscribers!
(Mission Erde - Robert Marc Lehmann - Community)
You deserve alot more attention, love your video. I am learning so much new stuff thx. Greetings from Germany and much love.
Very good Channel.Good work.Many💚from Mission Erde
Thanks for the informative video and greetings from Germany #missionerde
Orcas are the best! ❤ #missionerde
Greetings from Mission Erde Community in Germany. 🩵🐬🩵
I’ve seen your videos in Robert Marc Lehmanns streams and I just wanted to thank you for your great work 🫶. Absolutely love your videos and immediately subscribed!
Mission Erde is watching you! 😍
Nice work, greetings from Germany "Mission Erde Community"
Mission Erde 🌎 gooo ❤
Greetings from Germany
Helloooo thank you for your super interesting video!! Much love and greetings from Germany ( also from RML Mission Erde 🌍 ❤️)
Hello :)
I'm here to send more greetings from mission erde ;)
Hey , great video!!! greetings from Austria #missionerde
Support comment from #missionerdecommunity
#missionerde Nice Video 💪
I think your channel is so underrated and definitely deserves more attention!! I really like the way you share such important and interesting information with us, you seem like a smart and funny guy! Greetings from the Mission Erde Community 🌎^^
Hope you soon get much more attention, you absolutely deserv it!
(Mission Erde Robert Marc Lehmann- Community)
Thank you so much for your video. Greetings from Germany #missionerde
Thanks, very intresting... good guy.. you have my abo ..#MissionErde
Good and important work! Thanks for that and greetings from germany! 🐋🫶🌱
Great Job. Greetings from Switzerland #missionerde
greetings from germany #MissionErde
What about Type Ds though? They're the most unusual looking of them all with small eye patches, rounded heads and curved dorsal fins. They look like a very likely candidate for a separate species too.
Greetings from Germany. And thanks for the video.
greetings from germany #missionerde
I cried my eyes out when I found out about the new species. Not even sure why. Huge win for the community
#missionerdecommunity
„Robert Marc Lehmann“
New Subscriber here.
Your doing really great.
Super Nice Channel.
im so glad i found this channel
great video - I hope we soon have at least two orca species (greetings from Germany)
Greetings from Germany and #MissionErde Community from Robert Marc Lehmann ♥
Important knowledge. Hope that it helps to protect more the different species. Thanks a lot - great job & love greetings
Great information! Orca
Nerd here,
Sorry, I'm late
THANK YOU for important information about ❤Orcas❤
#missionerde
Greetings from germany. 😀
Ein interessiertes Hallo aus Deutschland !
Very well explained! 💗
Thank you so much! Hope you get more and more and more... followers in the future ❤
Nice video #missionerde
Great Video!
My favorite whale/dolphin of all time!
Transients and residents are a different species? I guess that explains the diet and size differences.
Right after this video was released a second study by a different group of scientists was published with more confirmation
That's fantastic news!
Great video :)
Thanks for the great video 💙
#missionerde
Blue Heart isn't good forGerman People. We've got a Fascist Party here who used this as their Label for the Fan-Community of Fascist and Neo-Nazis!
Please use a green Heart or other Emotes for Mission Erde!😉
@@USER_No.1312aber sonst geht es dir gut oder?🩵
Ist dieses hellblau besser?
@@ceoverona1929 such die eins aus 🌍🌎🌏
@@ceoverona1929 z.B. 🌍🌎🌏
@@ceoverona1929 🌍🌎🌏
greaz info mate
lets goooo! i am excited. i say every justified attempt to seperate species on our planet is helping towards a deeper understanding of our wild counterparts. we might even as a whole truly come to the conclusion, that we are in fact just one of many astonishing species on this planet and every species deserves there spot in the current worldorder and we cannot take it away, because they are equally as important and diverse as our own.
this could then lead to a change from anthropocentrism to ecocentrism. i know i know. call me a dreamer if you want.
Let us hope that this realisation will actually be recognised.
Great and very informative video!
Thank you
Awesomee Video 👏
Thank you! 🫶
lil bump for Algo
Great video
nice energy, go on
Can they reproduce to create furtile ofspirng ? If yes, they are the same species.
@@rpd6116 that’s not entirely true. Female ligers (lion/tiger hybrid) are generally fertile and can reproduce. Blue whales and fin whales can produce “flue” whales that, based on genetic analysis, are capable of reproducing with other blue whales at least.
What defines a “species” is not a black and white definition, because just about every definition has at least one example that doesn’t fit within said definition
@@Paleopedia218 if it's a truth about females..., you said yourself the are hybrids, but not a new species
Yes, but YOU said that if two things CAN reproduce together, then they are the same species. I gave you examples that contradicts your statement. Lions and tigers are not the same species, but can produce fertile offspring. Blue whales and fin whales are not the same species, but can produce fertile offspring.
And regarding the SRKWs and the Bigg’s KWs, nothing stops them from breeding together. They just simply don’t breed with each other. Or, according to the study this video is about, there’s no evidence they’ve been breeding over the last 10,000 years or so
Nice work dude! Go on! Abo button is hit ;)
These sounds like cultural and minor anatomical differences though. If that can be considered different species, then wouln't different races of humans be considered different specices?
You missed the genetics
👍👍👍👍👍
Sounds lie their sub species, not separate species...
Tell that to the scientists
@@Paleopedia218 No need. I have No doubt about the actual conclusion of scientists... 😂
Since I am one...
@@davidbarkin8269they are different species taking into account jaw and teeth structure as well as flippers size and shape . In transient flippers are shaped in a way that indicates they chase their prey , whereas the resident orcas on the other hand, have much shorter ones. They are indeed different species
@@evagomes1590 No offense, but we can agree to disagree. The Center for species evaluation has not yet made a decision. I will abide by THEIR decision
whale 🐳🐋 enthusiast ✌
💖
Omgg 😮😮😮
👍
Are dogs, wolves, and foxes the same species?
If they are, please apologize to trees for wasting the oxygen they create.
This may be the dumbest thing I have seen on the Internet.
What are you even trying to say?
Read my post.
@rogerneely5763 wow. It’s almost like I did, and didn’t understand what you were trying to say, because it made no sense to the context of the video’s topic, which is why I asked for clarification
Are dogs the same species of wolves?
Are Asians the same species of Caucasians?
If so, .... To say an Orca is a different "species" because it has a different mark on it's back
Or because it eats differently as a predator
Or because it is taller (sorry) longer than another Orca
Is almost like telling Aboriginesr tribes in Australia are not human because they are shorter than the average American.
Or are you actually implying that?
@rogerneely5763 so did you completely miss the “the two ecotypes have been genetically separated for 300,000 years, and show no evidence of interbreeding in that time” section of the video?
its a wonder we dont do this with humans
A biologist from Mars wouldn't have much trouble with that idea. But you know how it is.
You can! It's easy to apply this same inquiry process to humans with available evidence. When you do, you find one species characterized by high phenotypic diversity and behavioral plasticity (thanks to recent and rapid global dispersal and population expansion), with relatively low genetic diversity and zero reproductive barriers. If you go to the nearest park and see a few gray squirrels hanging out, you're looking at more genetic diversity between those few rodents of the same species than you can find in the entire global population of Homo sapiens. If you're looking to justify cultural constructs of race, genomics are not a good place for you to find support.
@@orcrist3 excellent point, what about using violent or criminal inclination, the lack of two patent households, the propensity to abuse narcotics, the abundance of social welfare usage, or even, the necessity to offer lower standards for admission as the starting point to determine sub-divisions in our species.
Mission Erde 🌎
👍
Mission Erde 🌎