Humpback whales' attempt to stop killer whale attack - Planet Earth Live - BBC One
Вставка
- Опубліковано 10 тра 2012
- Subscribe and 🔔 to the BBC 👉 bit.ly/BBCUA-camSub
Watch the BBC first on iPlayer 👉 bbc.in/iPlayer-Home www.bbc.co.uk/planetearthlive Extraordinary footage of a killer whale attack on a Gray whale calf, when humpback whales arrive and try to intervene.
#bbc
All our TV channels and S4C are available to watch live through BBC iPlayer, although some programmes may not be available to stream online due to rights. If you would like to read more on what types of programmes are available to watch live, check the 'Are all programmes that are broadcast available on BBC iPlayer?' FAQ 👉 bbc.in/2m8ks6v. - Домашні улюбленці та дикі тварини
God, this breaks my heart. I just saw Deep Blue where 2 killer whales attack a baby humpback that was clutching to its mother. They kept trying to separate him from its mother for 6 hours and the baby was too exhausted to hold on. I can't get over how terrifying it must be to be stalked and attacked like that for SIX HOURS. and then the mother has to keep on her journey, alone. I was sobbing. I know it's just life and life can be brutal, but damn it's hard to watch.
Kriminal Dragon I don't eat meat. Vegetarian for 15 years, thanks. Don't drink cow's milk either...
Kriminal Dragon uh i dont know how you thought about her not eating meat came to your defense based off her original comment. I think she knew why the orcas were exhausting the baby, to eat it.
Why didn’t the humpback kill them
And do you eat meat?
Hector Aldozar the humpback should have had enough power to shatter the orcas bones so why didn’t it
Humpback whales are truly selfless and full of compassion (more than most humans are capable of), or else they would not have dared this rescue. We give these wondrous, sentient creatures too little credit for their bravery.
Orcas are the same ! sadly you witnesses two social species at the WAR ...but they are BOTH fenomenal creatures compasionate and inteligent . Terms of valid comparations are HARD to make here
Mmm some scientist thinks that rather than compassion it's just that hatred of the Humpbacks against Orcas because they prey on their young and sick.
Can't intervene with nature, humans have already done enough to the ecosystem
Everytime I see one of these pretentious "aNiMAls aRe bEtTER thAN PeOPle" comments my eyes roll hard enough to power a medium-sized city.
@@kukulroukul4698but they both are not as compassionate as a dolphin so let’s just end the convo righ there
That straight line military charge at the very beginning gives me chills. Such magnificent intelligent animals.
They are known as wolves of the sea.
True, but it’s a shame they eat just about anything like sharks.
@@lissalives1 There is no shame, nature doesn't afford them the luxury to pick and choose, besides they have to eat to keep up with their voracious appetite otherwise they will perish.
@@samuellp1146 Killer Whales are such successful hunters (their actually the most successful predator of all aquatic creatures) that they're actually one of the few species in the ocean able to afford eating only certain parts of their prey. They are famously known for eating only the tongue's of whales and liver's of sharks and then discarding the body allowing it to be eaten by scavengers. They have such confidence in their hunting ability that they can literally afford to only eat the things they find "tastiest" and discard the rest, you may be right about their appetite but they absolutely can afford the luxury of choice.
@@alexomer9916 like I said above they are wolves of the seas, they move in pods like wolves do in packs when hunting (also for centuries were known to help fishermen hunt whales) . Fun fact the orca can sense a woman is pregnant guess how?
humpbacks will always try to protect, sadly sometimes they may not complete there mission but they try there best. humpbacks will always be the guardian and it warms my heart to know they try, R.I.P baby humpback...
That calf was a gray whale calf. Not a humpback. They were trying to defend gray whales.
Gray Whale was already died long time ago..
😱
The opening shot of the killer whales in sync is freaking scary.
Humpback whales: defending the creatures of the sea, and protecting earth from interstellar threats since the 80s!
Nice one Trekky. Wahahaha.
But they need a new name ...humpback doesn’t sound all,that heroic ...
Ah that’s pretty good
@@coolcat5714 What's heroic in a name? Orcas don't sound heroic either. Killer whales sounds better for them wolves of the sea.
Who would travel across the galaxy to talk to a whale?
Whales are so intensely complex. Watching Humpbacks try to help Gray Whale mothers is soul touching. Inter species interactions like this reveal to disputed possibilities that animals have a sense of feeling or morality. Maybe we should expand our definitions and accept there are things we can't understand because we are limited not the other way around.
This is fascinating. Orcas terrorize other whales. I find it interesting to see the intervention of the Humpbacks...perhaps this means they are able to understand the Grey's distress call?
+direfranchement its a guess but Orcas aren't whales but since the humpbacks and grey whales are both speises of the Great whales its possible they understand eachother
I came here from this article on whales saving other species from orcas. Very interesting and fascinating.
www.mnn.com/earth-matters/animals/stories/humpback-whales-around-globe-are-mysteriously-rescuing-animals-orcas
Humpbacks are the gentle giants of the ocean, they've been witnessed to save so many other animals from the killer orcas.
sayjai bao most of the great whales are gentle giants.
Humpbacks are also known to save other species from Killer whales (like seals...)
Whale War I
Black Manta this is the best comment I've ever seen
Mr Gatoso haha
Make this a trilogy
Lol
Except that orcas aren't whales lol
Very proud of my sister who was the first to spot the Humpbacks and filmed this incredible footage.
That’s cool man!
Sam Bromley She's our sister.
What's your sister's name
@@___Anakin.Skywalker his sister's name is Tyrone. She's male to female trans
Wassup 👋
0:07 dat formation tho
I'm glad I'm not the only who thought that was unreal
That would be the equivalent off three humans walking side by side, Second nature.
@@Nozylatten okay captain buzzkill
It was stunning, it was beautiful. I too was mesmerize at that intro.
Idk why i started dieing when i saw that😂 they look like the evil empire of the ocean coming to murder
This is why I love humpback whales. They are my favourite animals 😍
Mammal. Favorite Mammal.
@@t.rok13 mammal still a animal...
Killer ehale
Killer whale
My favorite whale :) :) :) Very close second= Greys :) :) :)
Inter-species cooperation between grey whales and humpback whales is truly remarkable. And in our communities, many people remain silent when their peers are bullied.
That was so nice. And people go and hunt them for their blubber :P
"And in our communities, many people remain silent when their peers are bullied." I know, we could learn from humpbacks I think. Because they will protect seals, sealions, dolphins and other, smaller whales as well. That's why I love 'em... coz they stand up to bullies. I got badly bullied at school. I could've done with a humpback or two in my class at school. Wahahaha.
Untrepid One
The human race deserves it
nah its just Whalesare known to fuck with Sharks and orca whales because its like a war if you were an humpback whale full grown you dont want orca growing up killing ur offspring u wanna try and stopthem from feeding and even attack them at some points
@@milanka882 ok orcas arent bullies
@@ST-wr6bo well they are, orcas are the king at sea
That's sad. To think the humpbacks tried to save the baby, but failed.
@Ben Louis ok there are 2 MAJOR things you are overlooking:
1. It's common knowledge that when filming a documentary, you can't intervene; especially if the scenario is a predators hunting prey. That's what documentary are made for, to document nature unfolding.
2. Even if that wasn't the case, what could they have possibly been able to do to stop the orcas? If they were to move the boat to get between the orcas, what's to stop the orcas from swimming around or under the boat and continuing the attack? Or if they did move the boat it would run the risk of the boat getting damaged during the attack
@Ben Louis your joking right?
@Derreck Jones right you just keep telling yourself that....
@Derreck Jones Cute, you think I've "lost my Moral compass" even though I just know how documentaries work
This person on Quora quoted this better than I ever could so I'm just going to show it here:
Think about it this way
You are in that documentary crew. In the middle of Africa. 3 of you are crammed into a Land Rover jammed to the roof (and above) with camera gear and supplies. You are at the start of a three week odyssey to shoot a nature doc. A Lion cub is injured. What do you do? You are not a vet. You have no room in your vehicle. The nearest vet might be four days away via bumpy road. The cub would likely die on route even if you were not arrested for poaching. What about the Mother? You would have to tranquillize/immobilize her (how?) while you take her cub. Maybe you would also have to frighten off/disable the pride as well for your getaway. So now maybe you have a knocked out lion(s) right beside all your camera gear you left to make room for the cub as you race off to try and find somebody somewhere who knows how to heal a lion cub. Odds are good the mother would be eaten if knocked out when the land rover was out of sight. The cub would die on route. The equipment would be damaged, stolen or lost. You would run out of gas or time. All the animals you tried to save would be dead the documentary would not get done and likely you would never do another nature doc again.
A documentary crew is extremely limited in what they can do on location. A documentary shows what is actually happening, it is not a Disney movie. It is hell out there in the wild.
But a good documentary can help save a species. Global human impact on the environment is killing far more animals every hour than if every animal ever injured on camera could have been somehow saved.
99.9% of the time all a documentary can do is say "look at this thing happening here, send help"
@Ben Louis You cannot be serious.. what exactly would you have done ?
RIP little grey whale ;-;
Humpbacks: I'm sorry ma'am, we tried everything we could, but the situation is beyond us. My condolences.
Humpback Whales are, and ever shall be, my favourite animal
Put a camera under water, all it looks like to us is whales splashing around the surface.
I was thinking the same thing. All the action is below the surface
They would break the camera you idiots
@@spankablenazichimp6084 it's not about breaking the camera so you're the idiot. The visibility isnt good enough to put a camera in the water at that distance.
Good idea! Jump in and do it for them. Lol As it was mentioned before the visibility at that distance won't work so get in nice and close!
There should be filming underground!
fun fact: humpback whales are very friendly animals and are known as 'buddhist warriors' they always try and help other species like in this clip.
Nice info
the crew needed to help humpback whales
Humpback whales are amazing creatures. I've seen them save seals, humans, and now another whale! Amazing, beautiful creatures. They attempted to put themselves between the killer whale's and the baby; but unfortunately it was a bit late. They're just beautiful creatures.
You might be interested in 'humpbacks and killers' podcast by radiolab.
Humpbacks are frequently targeted and killed by Orca...
They knew the threat and also the risks... but went out of their way to try and help a totally different species to them.
Let that sink in.
The dramatic music and the orcas moving in perfect formation at the beginning...
There have been numerous recorded instances of whales attacking orcas who are hunting other species has been, and it's thought that they are not actually trying to save the other species so much, but that they instinctively respond to orcas acting aggressive because they are known to also attack humpback calfs, and it's in the whales best interest to make the orca leave the area.
This was more than 8yrs ago
@@Paclaicidian3000 internet. A wonderful place for knowledge 😂
I loved the part where the fin pokes out of the water but my favorite part was where the fin goes back in the water but then if comes out again. Crazy plot twist!
😂😂🤣🤣🤣💀
I'm rolling on my floor 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Lmfao
Wow... as heartbreaking as it was to witness the attack (and yes, I am aware, that's nature and la da da) it was truly beautiful and remarkable to see what the humpback whales did. And even more impressive that they stayed there for that long. Truly amazing.
1:57 The humpback's blowhole sounds like my car trying to start.
I love the sound they make.
😂 What a funny Comment
1:56
Dude, the fact that these amazing creatures exist makes me wonder about the deeper darker depths of the water. Imagine the crazy living things down there. Fascinating.
Sea is "outer space" if that makes sense
@@dbradandthem2727it doesn’t
Not the first time humpback whales have intervened and helped out. I seen a humpback whale shield a scubadiver from a bunch of sharks. They didn't realize it until they viewed the footage they recorded. But that humpback whale kept moving the diver out of the way with its fin. The diver didn't know why it kept doing that almost like when you put a child protectively behind you in the face of danger or an attack. Then they saw a bunch of sharks. 🤔
the heart goes out to the mother whale 😢😭
you know killer whalers are actually a type of dolphin
+MR Mason Whales not whalers
MR Mason Cetaceans
Dolphins are a type of whale
They're whales.. who are a cousin to dolphins.
They’re whales....... that’s why they are called killer WHALES for a reason
This is incredible how they come to the rescue
Seriously? Not one fuckin underwater footage?
"Look at this amazing incredible thing that has only happened once - that we didn't film!
Wasn't it great?"
"- that has only happened once -"
Actually........
www.mnn.com/earth-matters/animals/stories/humpback-whales-around-globe-are-mysteriously-rescuing-animals-orcas
You cant just throw a camera udner the water.
I dont think you got the point. Look at that camera at 0:59 Do you know how much that cost? You honestly dont think they could also invest in a camera that is water proof? Im just sayin....
Think about what you're actually investing time to complain about here...
Poor baby! Thank you humpback whales for trying! 🙏🏼💔
Crazy how much music plays a roll in movies, programmes etc.. Not many people notice it
The underwatrr footage in this clip is remakable, the footage of the man controlling the underwater camera is just stunning !
From today. My favourite animal will be humpback whale. Close to my heart.
nature is so beautiful and with big balls in the contrast to humans
Old footage but still utterly devastating and beautiful. Wow. 🙏🏾
came here bec of Radiolab. these are just animals and their instincts but i cant help but tear up. the wonders of nature just leaves you in awe, right?
they come like a gang...literally! Dynamite, marvelous, and majestic! I love em!
Yeah, they're like the inner city gangs of the ocean.
Incredible the way they line up in group.
How much of a badass are you if something called "killer whale" runs away from you.
We need to protect all the animals we saw in this video so that future generations can enjoy these amazing sights..but more importantly so that we don't lose any more of these majestic animals.
Love humpbacks! When I fish salmon in fall, I often see humpbacks feeding on bait balls nearby. I can tell a humpback just hearing him blow somewhere nearby. Always stop to observe, take videos, we get excited like kids. They are magnificent!
Okay but why was the way the killer whales breached at 0:02 so badass
EVERYONE GANGSTERS UNTIL BIG WHALE BOI SHOWS UP
HaHaa.. indeed..
That’s my boss and the boat I work on everyday!! So cool!! We still see the CA216s to this day
I feel so bad for the baby and the mom!!😢
that is so sad for the gray whale calf and very sad for the gray whale mother
Wow that is so amazing that the Humpback whales came to the Grey whales aid to try and save the baby grey..thee defenders of the sea. Thanks for sharing!
Amazing that this story was witnessed and filmed.
How amazing to have the opportunity to witness something like this! The sea holds a world of mystery! So cool.
God bless the Humpback Whale and their calves!
Pretty sure Humpbacks have been known to save or attempt to save many other animals including humans before.
Yes. One saved a lady from a great white. He kept his pectoral fin under the lady (in between her and the shark). She thought the humpback was playing with her and she was so scared. When she got back to the boat they asked her how scared she was to see that huge great white coming for her. She said she never even knew there was a shark. Then she realized the humpback was protecting her, not playing with her!
I love the dramatic music lol I thought for a second I was watching a Schwarzenegger film for a second hahaha
Humpback whales are literally the Avengers of the seas
Yet in the end, the grey mother whale continued her journey to the north .. Alone. 💔
The whale used her emergency homie whistle.
It was a very sad ending, I watched it years ago and still remember it. Wish the ending was different. :-(
This breaks my heart, I know the killer whales got to eat but the process of getting the calve is so long and drawn out. It takes a lot of effort to try to save their babies and so much suffering physically and mentally. The bond between the mother and calve is beyond imaginable. And after seeing humpbacks on a whale watching tour I will always have such a great love for them. Such huge intelligent gentle giants. They were breaching like crazy for us, a mother and it’s calve. The baby was trying to mimic its mother, seriously the best experience I’ve ever had.
Harsh reality of nature
My heart sank along with the poor baby whale
In Banderas Bay (México), we have seen this behaviour too. We have seen orcas attacking a female and calf (humpbacks) and then a group of males comming to defend them. We have also seen them chasing false orcas out of the area.
Orcas make such beautiful sounds but then you realize its them communicating for absolute carnage.
Such beautiful creatures, we still have much to learn.
That's more sad than Titanic
I got so emotional whilst watching this...
See! Animals do sense things and get outraged by things!
Animal altruism and unity at its best by those Humpbacks coming to help that poor mother and calf. Sadly, the Orcas won the battle and killed the calf, but still extra props to those Humpbacks for their valiant effort.
The straight line of whales with the suspenseful music
1:41 Then the Winged Hussars arrived
I feel sorry for the baby and the mother but its life. Killer whales have got to eat. This is real nature.
Matt Matton
That's not true.
It depends on the eco-type. Atlantic orcas feed on minkie whales all the time. Ross Sea orcas feed on seals. Resident orcas, yes, eat fish. Transient orcas feed on sea lions, fish, and other things.
This is perfectly normal, Matt.
+Matt Matton The Blue One well yea it could be but before humans fished the sea empty we whaled it empty which is what they were eating before.
Linda Smith we are also part of nature and we can intervene, but we never think what kind of intervention that actually helps to balance nature, since we just trust our ego and emphaty, not our brain
Matt - that's in correct
Pretty sure it most depends on where the orcas live and what types they are
#moron
I love ORCAS but it breaks my heart when they hunt calfs
Damn the co-ordination of those killer whales with each other is pretty amazing. 😮
They bullied my poor humpy😭😭😭
I agree with a part of ur argumentation, except 4 that suggestion:
"There's absolutely nothing that suggests that we'd have better lives if we, for example, threw out modern agriculture. Nor is there anything that suggests that the way nature works is optimal for any kind of life"
Watch the documentary "Chasing the ice", Btw The system we're living now, aiming for constant expansion, prove itself that our way to live is meant to fuck ourselves up (along with nature). Y? Watch the documentary.
i'm thankful for this video.
1:55 I’ll never forget that noise 2:05
Orca
Apex predators of the sea
Man is the apex predator on land sea and sky
Nope Sperm whales
Indeed they are! But a match against orca and humpback would prove a humpback whale victorious.
Why are orcas still the apex predator?
Well here's the misconceptions appears, apex predator doesn't mean the one that could prey on to something but it means that something couldn't prey on them.
Although a humpback whale can win a match against an orca, still the orca is the apex predator cause the humpback doesn't prey on the orca and just let them go or swim away after the confrontation.
@@ayongjohnvincent320 orca is the apex predator
Orca: I’m gonna eat ya
Gray whale: nooo please i has a mom
Orca: I don’t care noob
Humpback: Hey guys hows it goin
Orca: *great* *i* *was* *just* *leaving*
Великолепное животное,умное и красивое
Such beautiful creatures.
HUMPBACKS- THE COPS OF THE OCEAN
ORCAS- THE THUGS OF THE OCEAN
Thugs??? Morelike Mafia... 😂😂😂😂
nah there predators
Orca pods destroyed half of the whale and shark family
I don't know how the people on the boat could stop the orca, nature is nature.
even if they could of they shouldnt. its nature, gotta let nature do what it does.
they weren't trying to stop the orcas, tehy were trying to film it
But isn't it interesting that intelligent creatures have compassion in a way that isn't necessarily rational? It's possible that intelligence naturally leads to compassion and empathy, which would be a very good thing in case we ever encounter more advanced alien civilizations. But first, we need to figure out how to communicate with mammals on our own planet, because they're biologically similar to us and more likely to be capable of interacting with us than beings from different solar systems.
Have to wait till the Vulcans get here to communicate with humpbacks. Wahahaha.
on land,people got stabbed ,they were filming with their smartphone and never helped the victim,that's nature,of human.
Also, imagine getting smacked by a Humpback that shit would hurt lmao
Orcas are predators just like us, so I can't blame them. Still, I admire those humpback whales heroism
Bad shamoos
Mysticetes unite, apparently.
THIS WILL BLOW YOUR MIND! In high school I remember watching a movie at my biology class, and they made a point about orcas that I never forgot. They suggested that if you look at orcas bone structure they have hind legs that have basically morphed into the pelvic bone since it's not needed. They hypothesized that orcas could be a species wolf that spent a lot of time hunting near and in the water and over millions of years evolved and adapted to live in the water. Think about it? Orcas hunt in packs and launch coordinated attacks like wolves.
Wow that's actually a great statement 👏
Just further proof how ridiculous macro evolution is. You cannot be serious
@@shoazdon7000 are you retarded? I just said orcas have hind legs and pelvic bone. That's fact do some research pal. Why would a sea animal even have a pelvic bone? Because their ancestors walked bud. Evolution is real it's been proven in a lab. Checkmate.
@@shoazdon7000 theres so much evidence of it, including these vestigial remains like "feet" on snakes and this. did god put pointless vestigial remnants on animals? or are they shrinking away from millions of years of disuse where it's not necessary for s3xual selection? your own refusal to grasp the timescales and how it all works does not speak to the science 'ridiculousness'. only of you.
Killer whales pose little threat to an adult humpback who can seriously injure them
underwater footage would be very much appreciated, next time 😄😄😄😄
I wish nature wasn't so cruel and I know everyone needs to eat but my God a baby
They wouldn't be able to prey on the full grown mother. It's the same everywhere in the animal world. Predators aim at the weakest one to save energy and maybe their own lives
it isnt cruel you just are one of those "people" you eaten a fast food burger? Stuff is made from baby cows so you are eating a baby, that mean your cruel?
Zach DA Yac please dont judge me ... i have been a Vegetarian since i was 19 and i am 63... what I have realized that that way of life isn't for everyone and it's best not to judge others
patricia russell I don’t judge you for you being vegetarian. I was for a year. It’s just that it’s nature and it’s how it operates
aww the end made me cry. mother nature is really brutal but there's nothing we can do to stop giant beasts from eating eachother unless you wanna die to. r.i.p little baby whale poor mom
its so awesome to see all killer whales just coming for air in a line at the exact same time
People will blame sea world for this haha
Mark Foley fuck sea world
People will blame obama or trump for it
@@alexj5376 stop hating nature
The dramatic music on the soundtrack seriously damages the credibility of this video. The makers are clearly looking for drama, not fact.
If you don't find nature dramatic and awesome, then a part of you is a bit dead inside. We're not all Vulcans you know.
Yeah but there is about 15 minutes of this footage without music on UA-cam. It's the original footage too, pretty full-on. Some pretty triggered humpbacks. Wahahaha.
No but Vulcans can communicate with hb's. Wahahaha.
Ruins it for me too
I find whales truly facinateing, there incredibly smart, amazingly strong, and beautiful :)
That was a noble effort. Very noble. And yes, I have to agree, the Humpbacks sound like the TARDIS. I love that.
Moving forward I can't wait to see a video of a shark or a whale killing a baby orca.
It's painful,orcas are wild dog of Ocean who brutally eat his prey alive
HIIIIISSSSSSSSSS
hisssssss (yeah why where these suggested?)
Hisssss
HISSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS
+PlanetaryRogue LEAFY HISSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS
HIIISSSSSSSS XD
Cetaceans are so intelligent and empathetic. You see uninvolved humpbacks, a completely different species of whale, go out of their way to try to help a gray whale mother and her calf.
Omg the first second was cool they came up at the same time they ate so smart