Emerson, Lake & Palmer - Trilogy (REACTION) with my wife
Вставка
- Опубліковано 5 лют 2025
- Thanks for stopping by and check out our channel! We do appreciate all the nice words from you guys. If you would like to support us, check out the links below. Hope you enjoy our reaction and see you again next time.
📦 Andrei&Dominika Unboxing: / @merchantoflife
📷 Instagram: / merchantofalba
💲 PayPal: www.paypal.com...
☕ Buy Me A Coffee: www.buymeacoff...
🎵Request a Song: www.buymeacoff...
📺 Official Video: • Trilogy
This is my musical reaction, breakdown and commentary analysis of the song and video. This is for educational purposes only. I intend no copyright infringement, and this is not a replacement for listening to the song. As covered under fair use copyright laws listed below, we simply reacted to the video by giving constructive feedback, criticism and comments.
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use. No copyright infringement intended. ALL RIGHTS BELONG TO THEIR RESPECTIVE OWNERS
When I was at school in 1976 our music teacher, Mr Moor asked us to bring in a record and we could listen and then dissect them.
Everyone brought in all the chart stuff in....Bay City Rollers, Slade, stuff like that.
I took ELP Brain Salad Surgery.
He looked at me and smiled.
We ended up playing the entire album and a few of the kids spoke about the pictures it evoked in their minds, but the others who were only used to hearing catchy pop music just sat there looking confused.
From that point on Mr moor (Mick) treated me completely different.
We had many one to one discussions about classical and prog-rock.
He would hand me the keys to the music room at lunch time so I could get the drum kit out and play.
Take a pebble is one you will definitely enjoy.
✌️❤️🇬🇧
Benny the Bouncer... Wicked
That's beautiful you had a teacher like that.
One of the most talented bands ever. All three virtuoso level talent.
You don't hear ELP one single time and understand/love it. It takes time. The more you hear it, the more you understand/like it. That's what makes deep , dense, creative and bold music that stands the test of time
ELP were giants in the field of progressive rock, garnering global recognition because of their emphasis on complex compositions, stunning live performances, and technological innovation ... The band wrote complicated arrangements that borrowed from classical music, jazz, and rock and roll. The results were extraordinary.
For instance, when the album Tarkus (1971) was released, the title track was a 20-minute, multi-movement concept piece, based on a 5/4 time signature, that epitomized compositional dexterity. Decades after its release, Tarkus has been adopted by orchestras around the world as part of their repertoire.
As well, the album Brain Salad Surgery (1973) featured “Karn Evil 9,” a 30-minute track broken up into three different impressions. As proof of its lasting impact, this prog-rock classic will serve as the inspiration for an upcoming sci-fi film.
But the power of ELP’s compositions elevated during live performances ... Songs like Pirates take the listener on a musical adventure on the high seas. Pictures of an Exhibition and Fanfare for the Common Man were perfect examples of how ELP fused classical and rock music to near perfection.
From 1970-1977, ELP changed the musical landscape by breaking all the rules. In the golden era of progressive rock, the group was the ultimate musical expression. There were simply no limits to their creativity. - Excerpts from Ottawa Life Magazine 2020
You said it short and right. All the best and have fun with all kind of good music.
Can't like your post enough!!
I remember seeing colorful grade school flyers with ELP as the featured story. Academia certainly viewed their work as art...
One of my favorite ELP songs. Thanks for listening.
They have one song that you and your wife would love, "In the Beginning ". Its worth the listening, top tier song in the history of classic rock, groundbreaking at the time, very easy listening. You happened to choose the introduction,
They would like fanfare for the common man, and pirates.
From The Beginning
"from the beginning"
Cset la vie.Probably misspelled it,sorry.
Still, you turn me on
Have loved this band since mid 70s First band I saw in concert, never looked back. Haven't heard this one in too long.
Saw Carl in concert recently, he's just amazing, a drumming machine.
If you ever get to see video of some of their early shows you'll see showmanship that has never been equaled. Keith on his flying keyboard, Carl behind enough percussion instruments for 3 people. You have to see to appreciate.
Hello to you both, I was a Keyboard player in the 1970s and ELP and Keith Emerson were one of the best bands and Keyboard players. Another band is YES with Rick Wakeman as the Keyboardist, you can see them live with Getty Lee playing Bass on the Music Hall of Fame induction of Yes in 2017
Keith Emerson is the best keyboardist in the history of rock music
C'est La Vie. Greg's voice still shines.
When this album was created, synth's were still coming into their own in the prog rock music scene. This particular Moog55 synthesizer was expensive and had issues with live performance, where in the studio the patches and the sound could be controlled. Production techniques were evolving and processors and reverbs were now in an experimental stage. The beauty of this track is not only in the brilliant performances, but the power its sounds and audio prevailed through the piece. Emerson was an incredibly talented musician, composer and keyboardist and as with all ELP recordings, the adventure continued here. Yes.. the piano beginning of this composition is beautiful in contrast to the bombardment that followed. A lot of flavors...but the melodic content remained in tack with the exception of the very last part of the song.
Regardless of taste...this is music that will never be duplicated again and I appreciate your video putting it out to the people.
One more thing....listen to the "Endless Enigma" track on this album....
ELP has many radio friendly songs that might change your mind. Still You Turn Me On, From the Beginning, and Lucky Man are good examples.
i love this entire album. so many great songs - including this one.
I got to see them live in the early 70's and they put on a great show!
One of the favourite bands of my youth - like Yes it benefits from repeated listening.
Completely amazing brilliance .
Top Shelf Maestros , these Gents .
All three musicians are just masters of what they do. They weren't around long, but the quality of music they produced was second to none. This is a marvelously written and executed piece with all three musicians just being the geniuses that they were.
They have beautiful songs and very forward synthesized music. Very broad spectrum of music. You would love Works Volume One by them. Entire album is with a seventy piece symphony. Keith’s piano is beautiful, Greg’s vocals are beautiful, CeLaVie, Lend Your Love to me tonight, and Closer to Believing are amazing and would change your mind at least in their soft side music. They are immensely talented, however, they were trying to create rock and roll technology into a new era.
Pinnacle of the analog synth. Goose bumps.
Prog Takes a bit of getting used to and not everybody likes it. I was 16 years old when I bought this album along with albums from Yes, Pink Floyd, Genasis and Tangerine Dream. Keith Emerson RIP was one of the great keyboard players of the era influenced by Jaz and Classical music Along with Rick Wakeman of YES (Classically trained) and Tony Banks of Genesis (also Classically trained) I loved Prog it was always a surprise you never knew what you were going to get. they experimented with time signatures, discordance and alternate chord structures all influenced by every music genre that had come before Classical, Jaz, Blues, Rock, Folk and every music culture Middle East, African, Asian and indigenous cultures. All the members of these bands were very highly skilled musicians and composers.
They GREATEST DECADE EVER…WE MUST GIVE Homage to the 50’s and 60’s….they set the table for the AMAZING 70’s! 😎👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
Thank you for this reaction, Andrei and especially Dominika who stoically endured the torment. I am 67 years old and during my life I have met many people, who cannot help but feel uncomfortable with much of EL&P's music even in this era where ideas are more open, which is, of course, very respectable. Can you imagine what parents and grandparents thought when their children heard this in 1972? You're crazy?
Much could be said about this work, but I am sure that those who love this music, as I do, have read more than one analysis by people much, much more capable than I am.
Even as a heavy prog guy (61) and seen ELP in 1977 @ MSG you can't really react to any prog on a first listen, it's too involved.
My father used to play ELP when I was young. 😢 ❤️ Thank you for the share…🙏🏼
Well, Emerson is a keyboard wizard and very virtuous, a but always very musical and non-standard. He was superb
Have a look at
Fanfare for the Common Man - Emerson, Lake & Palmer (Olympic Stadium Montreal). And it is live.They do a fusion of Rock Jazz and classical music.
The song is called "Trilogy" for a reason: 3 distinct sections with their own rhythmic structure. If you want a song that only contains the softer, melodic guitar-oriented structure of the first part of "Trilogy" you might want to listen to "From the Beginning", "O Lucky Man", or "Sage".
AND: You don't have to like EVERYTHING you listen to!! It's OK!! :) ❤❤❤❤❤
Check out their songs Lucky Man or From the Beginning. Their famous prog ballads. They are both absolutely beautiful from start to finish. Keith Emerson was a true virtuous on keyboards and piano. One of the greatest ever.
The late great Keith Emerson was a master of tension and climaxes. He is already considered an important 20th century composer. With unique cord progressions, musical patterns and some beautiful melodies. He had some early music lessons but was primarily self taught. Not classically trained, he often caught derision from purists. On stage his left hand often was like a 4th band member. An amazing talent who lived music. He took his own life in 2016. His severely injured right hand prevented him from playing up to his standards for years. He was about to go on tour, opening in Japan where he was treasured. His long term partner feels he took his own life for fear of disappointing his very loyal Japanese fans. She came home to find his body. His life long battle with alcohol and depression may also have been a factor. UA-camr Anthony Cornet, a classically trained pianist, did his doctoral dissertation on Emerson. I would highly recommend his piano recital of some of Emerson's solo piano works. ua-cam.com/video/4PGyhpzq6tE/v-deo.htmlsi=tCD7hMe9zuPlNvwX
A few of my favorites. Prelude to Candice, Soulscapes, The Dreamer, Outgoing Tide, Nilu's Dream.
Thank you for explaining 😊
Definitely “From the Beginning “ from this album. Beautifully produced would be excellent to experience. Also, from Works Volume 1, the song “Closer to Believing “ is sooo beautiful vocally and with 70 pieces orchestral accompaniment
The late Keith Emerson was a master of all keyboards....if it had keys he could play it. What you heard in the beginning was Keith playing a Steinway grand piano which he mastered...pure genious.The late Greg Lake had a beautiful voice in my opinion.He was underrated in my opinion.
'From The Beginning' is the BEST......It almost reminds me of the song 'Roundabout' by Yes.
Esses caras, assim como Pink Floyd, Led Zeppelin, Rush, entre outros, sempre estiveram além de seus tempos. Precisaremos ainda de muitos anos para chegar nesse nível. Um abraço aqui do Brasil ❤️
lol Emerson Lake and Palmer is like fine wine!! They get better with age… Not everyone is a wine connoisseur…✌🏼❤️……
OMG - ANOTHER GREAT BAND - ya'll are REALLY hittin' the GOOD ONES, TODAY!!! ELP was SO CREATIVE!! Haven't watched yet: but, I hope you like this one, better, Dominika!! HUGS, YA'LL!!
That synthesizer drive was power;no denying it.That's what was so fascinating about ELP:dynamic contrast,adventurous, cinematic.
That's what I love about you guys... You are quite happy to let us know when you don't like a piece of music. That is a true reaction channel. We lways know when you like it and when you don't I love it.... Keep on Rocking. And don't stop.
I wore this album out…love this Group!!!😎👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
I admire her honesty.
Think of this song as being played by a symphonic orchestra. Strings, woodwinds, brass and percussion make up the different colors of sound, if you will. The composition is meant to give you the illusion of a huge band, although it’s only three musicians.
I hope you can give them one more try, perhaps with one of Greg Lake’s solo songs.
All the Best!
i find it interesting that she can appreciate extreme virtuoso guitar performances, but can't stand incredible artistry on synthesizers.
Greatest song they ever made
ELP often had a very harsh sound. This was one of the bands for which the genera "Heavy Metal" was coined. They created some of the most fiery, masculine music ever performed. It ain't for everybody, but everybody can respect that these were some of the finest musicians to walk the earth.
ELP is most appreciated by musicians.
Che magia dei giganti quanta bellezza ❤
You were not ready and probably never will be ready.
They loved "Epitaph," so I think they would enjoy Greg's stuff more than Keith's.
They are one of the huge popular bands of the 70s that has not gained many of the newer listeners of the current time in comparison to others like LedZep that has gained many more in the last decade .. I think they can have a resurgence eventually
One of their biggest FB groups has 12,000 members, so not true. Many reactors are listening to them for the first time and spreading the ELP gospel.
@@kratino I know that ELP has a certain amount followers for sure and they probably will get more popular as I stated they can have a resurgence eventually because they are so great.
Having watched a lot of your reactions, i believe the ELP songs that would appeal to you ( especially Dominika) are C'est la vie, In the beginning , and lucky man, especially the first one.
Keith Emmerson is the modern expression of Mozart. Your partner is totally missing it. Stay with it. Such a brilliant mixture of musical expression. I'm a musical child of the 60's up to the present, and I had a jazz musician mother as well who made sure that her three boys had traditonal musical band instruction and beyond. Bach, Beethoven, and Mozart would have so appreciated the music of ELP>
This is an amazing track and one of the best ELP Tracks; so beautiful. Sad at the beginning and then it moves into such passionate playing.
Try "Works Vol. 1" and listen to "C'Est La Vie" and "Closer To Believing", they are absolutely beautiful and moving love songs.
As a 14-year-old, I saved up for this first ELP album after we heard the album PATE based on Mussorgsky at school. The synth back then was simply from another world, a futuritic sound that had never been heard back then, later used in films, which other younger people recognized. As a 14 year old, it wasn't chaos, it was just ... . But give up ELP and keep listening to “Ramsch”stein and co; they hurt me, especially the ideology behind them ... . An ELP attempt was worth your try; with PF, Yes, Genesis, LZ, DP, Stevie Wonder, Bob Marley etc. my favorites back then, which are still there today. Good weekend!!!
This piece is a combination of Classical, Jazz, Ballads, and Progressive Rock. ELP were the only band to mix multiple genres of music together, into one piece of music, selling out Soccer Stadiums back in the 70's. They were, as I recall, the first "Super Group" of that era. I don't think we have a group today that can be described as a, "super group."
You need to react to their slow song, FROM THE BEGINNING. You'll like it.
they are TOO GOOD ! lol
You have to hear...Take a Pebble and Knife Edge and Still you Turn me on and From the Beginning and...😂
What do you think about "that piano player" now? Lmao 🤣 🤣 🤣
I guess she doesn't dig Keith's Moog and synth work.
Greg Lake, the bass guitar and vocalist, has one of the best baritones in rock history. Smooth, powerful. He started with King Crimson as their lead singer when they formed in 1969, then joined ELP the Super Prog Group in 1971. These 3 are all stellar musicians at the top of the Progressive Rock food chain. Many of us cut our teeth and discovered "Progressive Rock" via ELP in the early 70s.
If I could play piano it would be this.
Lucky Man is my favorite by them. Good one to check out.
If you want one of their more famous songs listen to Lucky Man. Keith Emerson in particular listen to his organ playing period he is playing 11/7 time with one hand and 3/4 time with the other hand. It's called independence and he was a master at it.
Trilogy es simplemente el mejor álbum del rock progresivo
Such musicianship from all three ELP members. My favorite track of Greg Lake singing is on their Pictures at an Exhibition album (based upon the work by 19th century Russian composer Modeste Moussorgsky), titled The Sage. Beautiful guitar arpeggio's and vocals by Greg Lake.
ELP sont des musiciens de très haut niveau, avec un prépondérance des claviers, et je comprends Dominica, ceux ci, très changeant, sont souvent à la limite de l'expérimental. Comme il n'y a pas de guitare, tout repose sur eux. Et ce n'est pas si facile "d'accrocher", néanmoins meme si l'on aime peu, on peut reconnaitre la virtuosité de Keith Emerson (mort en 2016) est incontestable.
I have 2 songs from ELP, that I am sure you would both love: In The Beginning, mentioned in other Comments below, and Pirates, performed live in Montreal, 1977, with a symphony orchestra backing them up!
Decade of seventies Playboy readers poll.
Keith Emerson #1 keyboards
Carl Palmer #1 drummer
Greg Lake #2 bassist
Lake also did classic guitar, vocals, and lead guitar
Lake was beaten by Paul McCartney.
When it comes to ELP, generally speaking, people either really like them or they really dislike them, and one tends to figure out very quickly which side one is on. And I've never seen someone move from one side to the other. They're one of those few bands that work that way. The Mars Volta is another band like that. I'm a huge fan of ELP and have been from the moment i first heard them. But I've got friends who i respect very much as musicians who can't stand them.
Unfortunately, today the world works according to the black and white scheme, especially politics, even in democratic countries. The Internet with its social bubbles reinforces the whole thing.
It's completely normal to not like certain music. It just used to be that you listened a few times before making a final judgment after listening to it once. Have fun with all kinds of good good music!!!
Even though ELP have a number of beautiful ballads, most of their songs are a show of keyboards masterfully played by Keith Emerson. That's progressive rock. Change of moods, tempos, volumes and styles within one song. Excellent.
Hell ya! I was in high school when this came out. ELP were pure genius. Mozart, Bach, and Beethovin would have dug the groove.
You should listen to this first thing in the morning......ELP.......better than coffee!!!.....caffeine don't compete@!!!......Marmite of the music world......love em or hate em.
ELP are a really two-faced band. They have songs for die-hard progrock fans, which are not easy for the first-time listener, and then they have really catchy tunes, which I'm sure you both would love, but they weren't suggested for you 🙂 and then there's the in-between, where they take you to progrock world, but do it in a way which everybody can enjoy. I suggest trying The Endless Enigma (all 3 parts), or Take a Pebble, they are perfect in-between songs, I'm sure you would love them 🙂
They have many more than two faces.
I fully agree with you when I remember the first time I heard it but this song ( all of it) really grew on me. I love it now. But yes, it is true ELP can descend into chaos at times and it becomes unpleasant. A bit to showey. Try "In the Beginning". I know you will love it. Don't give up on ELP.
ELP is one of the very best prog bands of all time. They are sometimes pinned with being the first prog band. Prog just isn't for you, that's okay. There's enough music for everyone.
You have to keep your mind open to jazz and classical music influences in ELP music, or you will never get it.
Keith Emerson, "that keyboardist" stated when he formed ELP that "he wanted to do for the keyboards what Jimi Hendrix did for the electric guitar."
Someone is steering you to difficult ELP tracks to start off listening to. You should have been given ELP suggestions like this to start slowly:
1. From the Beginning
2. Lucky Man
3. Still You Turn Me On
4. PIRATES
Then progress from there. Listen to suggestions from people who know where to start with a difficult band. There are too many knuckleheads out there throwing out silly suggestions to try to impress people or something.
like try Toccata. 😂
From The Beginning is a suggestion from Emerson Lake and Palmer that is less chaotic
I love that part 😂
I love this song, and this is my favorite ELP album, but I understand that it's not to everyone's taste. Others have mentioned, and I'll echo, that you may like their radio-friendly songs, "Still, You Turn Me On," "From the Beginning," or "Lucky Man." You may even like "Jerusalem"!
ELP is an acquired taste, but you must give them one more chance. Watch the live video of Karn Evil 9 1st Impression Part 2 / 1974 California Jam. Carl Palmer is one of the best drummers who ever lived. He does a drum solo in that song that will blow your mind. He's the only surviving member by the way.
They will not appreciate that. We've got too many people throwing out their most demanding stuff. That's just silly. They have to be eased in.
@kbrewski1, agreed. They obviously don’t like synthesizers. They should probably try Greg Lake songs, more their speed
@andrewk5710
In my comment, I suggested From the Beginning, Lucky Man, and then Pirates from the Works album. Its a longer epic tune, but more orchestral so I think they could handle it. Plus its a great tune.
Sort of cross between Genesis and Rush before Rush exploded onto the scene. ...but...was ELP . superband all on their own.
Dude! You clearly enjoyed it. Look at your face during the video. You are totally sucked in by the genius of this modern composition.
I got the same feeling.
Don't give up yet. You like that piano try take a pebble or the acoustic orchestra and choir in closer to believing will leave you speechless.
Progressive rock of the 70’s started technologically based music.
ELP is not for everyone but maybe give Take a Pebble or Lucky Man a listen, I think it might be more to your liking.
I like your honesty Dominica. I have been a fan of ELP since they started. I think some parts of their compositions are intentionally disturbing, whilst others are simply beautiful, such as the track " Take a Pebble " - on the same album.
P. S. If the keyboards in these are "too much" - you might try their song: From The Beginning....what keyboards they have in that tune: are very different....I think you might enjoy that one!!
Hello, O Recomendéd... The song Oh My Father From Emerson Lake and Palmer....... Its Very sensitivo and im sure you like it..... Saludos From MÉXICO
I think you both would much prefer some of Emerson, Lake and Palmer's more mainstream hits like "Lucky Man" and "From The Beginning", as well as Greg Lake's "I Believe in Father Christmas", which is frequently heard on the radio this time of year.
While I agree that the beginning section is the best part of the song, I love the entire song. But if it's not for you, no one should be offended. They should be grateful for your honesty. Keith Emerson was one of the pioneers of using synths, and if you don't like synths (I hate a lot of modern synths myself), you're not going to like a lot of their music. ELP isn't for everyone. 🤷♂
It's ok to not get it...ELP experimented with fusions of many styles and uncommon sounds and seemingly discordant time signatures and like this piece, not a little jazz stylings. Thanks to them and their fusions over the decades since 1970, I've gained a much greater love for jazz, as well as classical... their adaptations and interpretations of Bartok, Ginastera, Holst, Grieg, Mussorgsky, Copland and many others were simply masterful...
But, to each their own. 😊🤷
Nice to see honesty when you don't like a song or artist. Most of ELP will not be for you, HOWEVER based on what I have seen on your channel you would like "Lucky Man" and "From the Beginning" by them. Much gentler easy listening songs without the wild keyboards.
Try “Cest la vie”
I recommend ‘Robots’ by Kraftwerk (German band)
Could be a generational thing, plus as prog bands go ELP are even more a "guy's" band than most others (except perhaps King Crimson.) Why I like this song is -- yeah, there's a nicely romantic front end, something ELP didn't do often but which they usually did well. IMO the piano transition to the proggy section is clever, and then I think the synth-y 5/4 riff is pretty cool. 1972 was very early days for synths in rock music and Keith was better at coming up with interesting synth textures than many back then. I agree the transition to the next section (still 5/4 but it feels like 6/8+3/4) is a bit clunky, and it's an example of how prog songs could sometimes feel taped together. The best have that 'suite'-like feel, but are more than the sum of their parts. "Trilogy" might not reach that height for some, but it works for me.
You guys clearly enjoyed yourselves. Don't be contrary just to be contrary. Save that for Ted Nugent!
Please try Ces't la Vie.
EL&P could create some lovely music. They were great at incorporating classical and jazz elements into their brand of Prog Rock. Expert musicians. They could bring the energy! And the melodies. But they did like to use that '70s Moog Synthesizer that may be 'offensive'. (I also find that moog sound tiresome)
Check out their 'Fanfare for the Common Man' cover of Aaron Copeland's classical piece. Dramatic. Energetic.
Music for Intelligent People !
Sometimes music is to be interesting or have an impact, rather than just being pretty.
I'd like to suggest that you might consider expanding your horizons. And emerson lake and palmer's catalog includes many, many different sounding styles. But I'm thinking maybe they're not for you.
Everyone’s taste is different, ELP are an acquired taste for sure. I love them but my wife can only handle them in small doses. It’s all good.
I wish Mozart could hear this he would lose his mind
comment on my last comment below, that is for me not more me auto corrected I believe
Suggest take a listen to “Take a Pebble”
Don't feel bad, right where you did not like it is exactly where my wife quit liking it.