Це відео не доступне.
Перепрошуємо.
FFXIV: Level 100 Artifact Job Gear - My Thoughts
Вставка
- Опубліковано 17 сер 2024
- Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @meoni1
Watch Meoni LIVE on TWITCH
/ meoni
Support Meoni Here:
/ meoni
Patreon Benefits include end credit listings & Discord.
Public Discord : / discord
Twitter: @MeoniUA-cam
#FFXIV #Meoni #dawntrail
Background Music:
Square Enix Rights Reserved
By Masayoshi Soken
Music from filmmusic.io:
"Sincerely" by Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
License: CC BY (creativecommons...)
WHM's robe looks like a random lvl 42 dungeon drop.
I’d love to get a WHM artifact in the styling of the on in Stranger of Paradise, not a full robe but something shorter
Something to remember is that this is also the expansion with two dye channels. These have probably been built with that in mind.
He mentions it near the end.
Yeah, I was thinking that the first time seeing the GNB coat. It has that black fade to red, so with two dye channels, it's possible you could mix and match your colors with the fade colors.
The Bard set is giving 80's rocker/rolling stone vibes
it can go straight into aerosmith
Yeah it’s absolutely Steven Tyler coded
Definitely Keith Richards, Ronnie Wood, Richie Sambora, Little Steven Van Zandt, or Stevie Ray Vaugh even, basically any rocker who had a boho look.
the black mage staff with the cat is **chefs kiss**
Definitely agree! I'm a big cat lover. ^_^
Yess, I told my husband that it's going to be my permanent BLM weapon 😂
that guitar bow is so sick
Sick indeed! My friend who mains Bard thought it was so sick he gagged. XD
it's a crossbow!
The bard outfit is Steven Tyler inspired, you cannot convince me otherwise.
i actually looooove that DNC set.
(also, the faux-hair on helmets is called a "plume")
The most disappointing thing about DNC AF gear is that male characters wind up so... overdressed. If male WHM gear is still long robes, why can't male DNC gear be skimpy?
@@KaminoZan ShB DNC gear wasn't all that overdressed on guys. I personally loved the Endwalker DNC set and use it on my guy to this day, even if it isn't skimpy, it still looks really good. :)
"Why would you add a guitar to a bow?" My good being--WHY WOULDN'T YOU? I'm getting some Stevie Ray Vaughn vibes mixed with 80s Hair Metal from the BRD set this time and I am HERE for it! Now if only they'd give us a metal headbanger's hairstyle to go with it. And a Devil Horns emote. And an air-guitar emote. and a headbang emote... and a "let's get the band back together for a reunion tour" sidequest, maybe?
While I don't care for the guitarbow, I love the SRV vibe, particularly with this expansion, and glamming it up a bit's definitely fitting for FF14. I'd love to see *metal* bard, too, at least something more bespoke than Abyssos gear.
I agree so much on machinist aeither packs, either give us option to remove them or change design nghhhh
Knowing how simple the mod to remove it is i have no idea why they wouldnt just give us a toggle. Low priority prob
That is why mods can be awesome - there is a mod to hide it
I will never understand why Machinist is the one job that just has a piece of their weapon that just doesn't change, it's so frustrating, at least let us hide it.
@@mismismism fr, it feels so silly when, for example, SAM has beautiful different scabbards for every sword and aether pack is just... the same lunchbox
@@noamonoch Exactly, RDM get different floating focus things with the sword, PAL can make their shield invisible now same with MNK but MCH has to have this ugly silver box on every weapon.
As a Gunbreaker fan, I adore this set. It's exactly what I am looking for, personally. The pants provide a perfect amount of visual contrast which plays off of the collar. 10/10
I was going to say, if the pants were red or a dark colour in general, it would have lost some of its pop, also matches with the lighter portions of the top and along the gloves and brings it together.
I am not likely to use it, but I’m not going to deny I love the vibes here. Maybe a different angle will show it off more?
Just wanted to let you know Au'ra horns always display on every helm aside from the giant ones like fat chocobo head, so the viper displaying the horns tells us nothing about Viera or Hrothgar
Putting the axe in front out the outfit so you can barely see half of it for WAR was a decision 😅
I still dont know if i like the armor lol...
This set of monk gear is the first one I’m excited to play with. I like pieces from other relic sets, but never as a whole.
Edit: WAR needs more hammers, imo.
Same, I've used parts of the relic sets up to this point, but never felt the whole set, prob won't use the head piece for this set, but the rest is amazing
I quite like the whm robe. It looks quite a bit more masculine than most other artifact sets we've gotten, and while those feminine robes tend to look great on female chars, I'm not a fan of them on my male chars most of the time.
Yeah, this will be the first Whm AF that will look good on male characters.
Loving the modern hoodie look they’ve been trying to sneak in here and there and yeah I love this new white mage robe
It might be a little different on girls, it usually is.
As an AST Main, the ASTs gear is so bad… I’m tired of ast artifact armor looking like it was found in the clearance bin of a bathrobe store. Can we bring back the guy who designed the HW artifact armor? PLEASE?
THATS WHAT IM SAYING.
Scholar doesn't get a Robe? THANK YOU!!! Gor once I'm actually happy xD
Don't they usually have jackets though?
@@BaithNa people confuse the long duster jackets with robes when they complain about it.
Monkey Paw curls: You get a jacket but have to wear a dress from time to time XD
Not a fan of the hot pants and high boots, though. I still think ShB was peak SMN. I still rock that coat with the cape in my dedicated SCH glam once I got the dyable version.
SCH has never once had a robe for artifact armour 😂 We got a weird feathered coat in HW for some reason, and every single other chestpiece has been a military coat. It's always a coat.
The dragoon hair piece makes perfect sense when you realize it's actually just a mop whose purpose is cleaning up the tears of dragoon after another floor tank.
some one should make an animation where one of the dragoon abilities tosses out wet floor signs, then he jumps up in the air and comes crashing down head first into a mop bucket...
Bard set is David Bowie vibes
Steven Tyler too.
Wish they'd give the paladin a full helmet instead of another crown
Give us a bucket helmet!
Agreed! But i think theyre doing it to accommodate viera and hrothgar. apparently having headgear on viera and hroth is a big ask.
@@Spaghetty small indie company give them a break
I want a less shiny more battle ready paladin look..like a ret paladin from wow
Or a hood.
is it just me, or does the af gear sets for dawntrail seem very reminiscent of the af gear sets from arr?
white mage, in particular, seems like just an upgraded design of the arr gear set? regardless, i like the set!
Yeah for sure, pretty sure Dawntrail is symbolically meant to be a new ARR, they want to invoke the feeling of the familiar and the beginning of a new chapter. Thats my read of dawntrail tbh
Basically yeah.
it is the new dawn of the game.
AF gear is meant to be takes on the classic class sprites so yea, they all look similar.
It's not just you.
And that's a good thing.
The ARR WHM set was the last one that didn't look "shrine maiden", which is rough on...male characters that don't want to look like shrine maidens, lol. PLD and SMN and WAR I see it, too. Several of these sets look like stylized versions of the ARR sets.
I think they mentioned it on fanfest / LLs I forgot, that they purposefully design it like ARR / first AF gear instead of designs that incorporate Tural's aesthetic.
A duck on the WAR axe? Nah, that's a Tonberry. Fell Cleave will also inflict Everyone's Grudge when using this weapon!
That machinist gun is *chef kiss* It's like the big brother of the little mortar handcannon.
17:28 For a katana the blade is a different color from the guard because they're two separate pieces. They forge the blade, then attach it to the tsuba guard by putting the handle end of the blade through the guard, then assemble the rest hilt.
I also like this samurai set because it's more decorated and armored. They tend to dress SAM as unarmored ronin types, so it's nice to see some "armored, professional samurai" look.
That said, my favorite us ninja
real katanas are modular by default even. remove the _mekugi_ and you could dissassemble the hilt completely. new tsuba, new tsuka etc.
@@rivenoak Yeaup, to the point where proper katana maintenance includes taking it apart completely
@@ZeoffArcaneOfficial dissassembling is prerequiste for shirasaya storage as well. looks cheap but the blade _inside_ could be worth a fortune :D
on another note: Meoni wished for a black blade. is tamahagane even able to procure a dark metal which is fit to serve as sword steel ? my impression with all that polishing and oiling the blade is the blade is shiny metal and nothing else.
I noticed in the Benchmark trailer that the SCH hat on the Viera was really tiny. It makes me wonder if their plan for hats for Viera and Hrothgar is to make them tiny, like they did with the Fall Guys hat...
Inner part of a bell is called the clapper btw
Was not expecting Bard to be the one with my favorite Getup this time around. =O
33:51 I really wish the pictomancer's brush was more like a modern hand held paint brush, instead of this massive wand looking stick.
That DRK armor looks like it's pulling in themes from the Manusya armor, and I'm here for it
20:55 PUNK NOT DEAD!!!! I looove the 80's tartan style pants 🤩😍🤘
Inside the bell is the clapper. As from the saying going like the clappers😊
Really loving the Monk outfit, and the Gunbreaker is very nice (minus the eyepatch).
Interested in seeing how the Astro skirt dyes but I don't really like the rest of the outfit. It just looks like you wandered into the Black Mage shop accidentally.
Really not sure about Dancer. That could either look amazing or it could look terrible. Have to see it in game on my character.
Really like the Red Mage outfit. It's still very typical Red Mage but the extra straps and buckles along with the open shirt give it a very "Adventury" vibe which is perfect for the expansion. And that sword is also very cool.
As a samurai Main I hope that sooner or later they decide to give us something that vaguely resembles a real samurai armor and not the usual kimonos with some accessory
The lvl 70 tomestone gear is pretty much that
SMN got me thinking if they gave them an "Astral/Umbral" stance where they can choose the summons. Like tank stance, but it would change Titan/Garuda/Ifrit for Shiva/Ramuh/Leviathan. They'd have identical moves that end up going to Phoenix/Bahamut but it would give the illusion of diversity. They could then add the rotation where after the first wave of Phoenix/Bahamut, they can toggle modes so it looks like they're going through all six main primals. It'd be entirely optional and just aesthetics unless they want to add some other gimmick.
So, I noticed something on the dancer artifact gear.
the Viera had visible painted toes....
are they actually going to give us proper toes? :O
Yes, and better hands as well
Black Mage, that whole outfit is an instant classic! 10/10, nailed it.
One thing to be aware of for Pictomancer, there's a dagger on the middle back just above the tail spot for races with a tail and the tail CLIPS through the dagger.
Just something to keep in mind.
The Bard gear is just a bohemian rocker. I LOVE IT.
It would sure be so nice if 5 years after hrothgar and viera dropped we could just KNOW that everything was wearable.
5 YEARS!
I wish Glowing affects from artifact weapons could be dyed or changed out for prior artifact weapons particle effects
what is the lore for eathepack not changing appearance? I remember in job quests our teacher was modifying it. so its not one of a kind relic, but a machinery, which, in my head, means that it also should be customizable
I know you didn't seem to like the WAR so much but I just love love love I have the opportunity as a WAR main to finally wear one of the headpieces as a Viera! I know there are head pieces out there (sparse) but I really am so dearly excited.
I love how the dragoon gear looks like an evolution of the ARR dragoon gear
I can see bits of ARR, HW, and SB dragoon sets and I love it
This is Drachen 2.0 and I mean this in the best way possible
I'm in love with my class's artifact gear (gnb/Mch)but also love that they are very similar in style that it can be imagine as a stance change. go from pew pew to edgy in your face slice and dice. LOVE IT! gonna make a transformation macro for these two sets.
Why can't we get a badass full helmet for the Paladin like the DRK one but holy instead of boring crowns everytime
Because Cecil.
Because Paladin AF gear has never featured helmets
There are so many full helmets in this game already lol... way more than any other type of headgear ;[
@@mewimi no way, I am pretty sure there are more crowns/hairpins/barely visible headpieces in the game lol, and they all look the same, I can barely find any decent full helmets
@@Scionofgreyhaven I think you are thinking of all those ones that just have a simple color swap... remove those and you'll find that there are barely any lol.
Red Mage is actually a bit different than normal, it isn't as much frilly or a muskteer looking as normal, particularly with the jacket. Basically the most DMC looking it's ever been.
That focus looks like it may reshape itself a bit being very floaty, so I reserve judgement.
Agree with this. It's definitely less "formal" looking. I wish they would show it on both genders though, they have a tendency to up the frill factor on the female outfit. I'm kinda digging this look though, it feels more casual and fun, like the RDM is entering their Errol Flynn phase.
Summoner's set looks like christmas the outfit to me, and I can't unsee it
I love the guitar bow, and the catstaff and the reaper gear looks nice as heck
The frill/hair on a helm is called a plume 🐻
i think it’d be nice if machinists’ aetherpacks could change but be used similarly to shields! although that’s just my thoughts on it
I really don't understand why people hate on the AST gear, many of the armor sets in XIV suffer from being really over designed and I appreciate the simplicity and sleekness of it.
I agree with you, but I feel like we could have this simplicity and sleekness with its identity still intact. This just looks like a robe/dress from a mid-level Heavensward dungeon that got scaled down a bit. To me anyway.
This is true. Many ( most? ) of the glams in this game are overdesigned. Especially in the collar area. I wish they'd tone down things and be a bit more elegant over flamboyant.
RDM gear looks sick, I'm looking forward to this expansion.
GODDANGIT I can't unsee that Little Nicky reference
13:40 Plume, is the word you're looking for.
23:40 Personally I would use Bard as an example, they have a ton of unique quivers, and generally a good variety of generic quivers per expansion, and the quiver is more of a static piece like the aether converter. PCT is more in the ballpark of PLD where both pieces are their wielded weapon component. SAM is in the borderline spot with their Sheathe, it's a vital part of Iaijutsu, but on the other hand the blade's themselves for most SAM weapons are pretty conventional, Tsuba, Grip, Pommel, and Sheathe are fancy, the blade is usually just a blade. AST is the closest to MCH, but at least gets a little bit of Color change on the Holster, this would be the bare minimum MCH should be brought up to. Would really prefer AST/MCH to at least be brought up to BRD Quiver level for their static piece though. Keep some pretty generic ones for the more crafted/vendor weapons and maybe some of the more more traditional looking sets, but at least for the Primal/Raid weapons give something more noteworthy. And for AST cards, getting at least changing the color of the card backs an option would be nice as well.
my mouth dropped open when I saw the bard set. I'm glad you liked it too, Meoni!
I never understood why Gunbreaker can’t have a jacket AND trousers like SeeD uniform.
For MCH: we know about why it exists there for lore reasons BUT after meeting allagans, alien races extremely advanced, Loporrits and (maybe) even new ones in Dawntrail, there's no excuse to turn the aetherpack into either something smaller that can be glamoured alongside the weapon or completely remove it with a valid in-lore explanation. Like, just a small set of quests where we go meet the MCH guild, go talk to some of the races and then they come up with a miniaturized aetherpack that fits in WoL's pouch would be enough to completely explain why it won't be there anymore.
On top of that, they could just change the animations to reflect that. Like, even if you don't get a new attack, you get a slightly modified animation where the character simply doesn't interact with the aetherpack.
So excited for pictomancer and I'm gonna happily continue maining as a astrologian
28:47 Wow I didn't know we got Nekomancer this expansion
I think dancer’s set is literally the best
I really hope the fem version just has a bandeau for the bust and is otherwise the same, this looks so good
Bard is basically just a Steven Tyler cosplay and I'm all for it. Ridiculous and over-the-top, and it rules. Super excited for the Dragoon gear, looks like a mashup of the ARR and Heavensward sets; both of which I love.
You are really churning out these useful videos. Good for me being a returning player. I've had my Baldur's Gate 3 fix...for now.
In agreement about the Gunbreaker set. I will probably end up still using the Allegiance set from Endwalker as my glamour again.
The Black Mage outfit is fantastic. Love the cat!
I'm a BRD main. And will 100% be glaming that to anything else. That bow just looks stupid to me.
The rest of the BRD outfit though reminds me a lot of FFXV Ardyn. Not something I'm likely to wear but I do kind of like the look
the color difference on the Samurai is the Hamon line. the demarcation between the blade's edge that was hardened and the back of the sword that was not, to strengthen the blade.
I love the White mage since it actually looks unisex unlike the previous ones it looks very feminine
cant tell the difference between a shuriken (literal star shaped) and a kunai, which is essentially a short dagger with the spinning ring on pommel.
I'd be shocked if the Dragoon set wasn't inspired from Kain in FF4. His helmet also had long blonde fake hair and the entire set was also purple.
The most interesting thing with these artefact sets for me is how they'll dye, because a lot of them feel so similar to old sets it's like they're just remastered versions for the graphics update, which has some merit since the textures are really amazing, but astro, bard, reaper, and dancer are the only ones that feel new and exciting to me.
Seeing the weapons we get for pictomancer and viper will be cool. Since there's going to be an eden ultimate they'll definitely get E12S weapons (since they model them as bases for the ultimate versions) and those should be stunning, and deep dungeon weapons should also be guaranteed because of the way that's structured, so I'll probably be taking a trip to heaven on high.
BRD gear makes me remember the attire that Stevie Ray Vaughan would wear on his shows, like a blues musician with flamboyant attire shredding the guitar with epic solos and melodies.
I'm OBSESSED with Pictomancer's set! I think the skill showcase and the artifact gear have convinced me to try leveling it as my main DPS this expansion ❤
Reaper looks like Meteion cosplay.
The Paladin artifact sets always look so cool
I nearly spit out my coffee with the Little Nicky reference! 😂
Bard's jacket reminds me of my great grandfather's military uniform honestly. He was a Korean War veteran and I still have his uniform safely tucked away. Never wore it either since it'd feel wrong to
As a whole, I love Scholar, Sage, and Reaper.
I love Summoner's top. The half poncho with the scarf is a good vibe for Dawn Trail.
Love the Black Mages cat staff!
Of course, Viper and Picto look great. There will definitely be some Bob Ross's running amok.
Everything else is good, but I feel indifferent on.
The reaper one is gorgeous, the bard weapon is insanely cool. I like the velvet astromancer dress, quite simple but effective. The rest is ok.
the monk reminds you of stormblood , ngl the model looks like Fordolas without the tattoo on her face lol
The reaper weapon looks like something you get after slaying Nargacuga from Monster Hunter. And I am a fan!
And for the machinist, I could see if they wanted to add it similar to what Paladin Have of putting the Aetherpack as a off hand thing. Add it as a package/blueprint similar to what Paladins now get instead of individual stuff.
Also, For the RPR, it really makes me think of Lulu in a way with the belting (from FFX)
So with regards to the aetherotransformers that Machinists have, the customization they have is if the gun is dyable. Whatever you dye the gun, you dye the silver portion of the box. In some cases, this works great, as you'll match the base metals of the weapon and box. In others, say weapons where you customize the glow, any color that works great for the glow is often gaudy on the box at best.
Hopefully two dye channels help with this, but honestly, a few new styles of aetherotransformers, either coming with the gun as part of the package, or a set that can be glamored separately from the gun would be very welcome.
I really like the Black and Red Mage gear! BLM looks like an adventuring mage who'd wander around with their chocobo, as opposed to a sorcerer or wizard more at home in a tower than a tavern. RDM has a bit of that going on as well, though I'd love to see the hat, pants, and coat in black, perhaps with a red vest. As for the weapons, I especially like the focus - anything that *doesn't* just look like the head of a scepter piques my interest - but the cat staff... I'll be tempted to delete it rather than waste a spot in my dresser that would be better spent holding a different weapon that I'll never use. Now, if an upgraded version of that has the cat as a transparent, magical familiar, I'd be *way* more interested.
That BRD is straight up Steven Tyler of Aerosmith, and I'm here for it. I don't even play BRD that often but it's now my goal to get it to 100 🤣
I love the darkknight's helm and chest piece, I'm totally going to glamour the hell out of my char with those!
Lack Mage robes look so awesome! Like a wandering magician. Sucks I can never wear those hats as a rabbit
They're all fantastic, but I'm obsessed with the BLM and SMN gear in particular 😩💕 Perfect way to tempt me into levelling/learning the jobs
They're not too bad once you get the rotation down! I've mained BLM since I started back in HW, and SMN I picked up as my second Caster in SHB, and can say that for certain. You make things go BOOM and it's glorious 💙
For me as I main WAR I personally love the design, but not too much a fan of the helm piece. At the same time I see how it fits better so all races can wear it without any issues as its probably why they chose a Viera to showcase the set.
As a DRG/GNB main I absolutely adore their sets, Dragoon in particular is literal perfection IMO
As a soon-to-be VPR main, I like it but I think I'll be rocking mostly Cryptlurker
I must also add that while I'm not wow'd by it, AST set looks sooo comfy and I want this IRL
The first time I saw the Summoner set, I wasn't crazy about it but it's growing on me. Meoni saying it was a mountain outfit made me reevaluate my opinion. It does look like it fit in that setting. The book looks neat too.
WOL is left-handed confirmed
a blue blade contrasts better with red armor, thats why its blue and not black.
the thing with etherpack should be very easy to solve, because everyone who uses plugins knows that u can make it invisible with one click.
Why does The Bard armor model remind me of Steven Tyler from Aerosmith for some reason? Lol.
Inb4 someone makes a song reference. Or plays an Aerosmith song on bard instruments 😅
6:15 it's called a clapper. But "thing that makes the bell go ding-dong" is also correct imho
That is a singular black wing on the scythe. Sephiroth fight confirmed!
I wouldnt jump that far ahead, unless he in normal raid might be possible depening what solution 9 is about.
As a SCH main, I'm not really the biggest fan of the outfit. I much preferred the direction they went with the Endwalker AF for SCH, which had a felt looking texture when dyed. Plus it felt more like a commanders outfit.
I'd much rather the adorable black cat be a part of the gear instead of the weapon, but over all I like most of these sets. REALLY love the sage gear. REALLY hate the dark knight robes though lol As disappointed as I am with the new summon being bahamut 2 instead of something like Odin, I love the gear. I love how the textures really make it pop and how it goes back to the original design's color schemes that are classic to the job. These are all going to look amazing in-game in real lighting situations. Hoping we can re-color the pictomancer gear to classic Relm colors from FF6 too. That would just make me love it more
I want a paladin armor set that looks like what an ADVENTURER would wear. Not full-plate. It should look more mobile, like someone would trek through the country with it and not get tired.
Taking the Bard class more in the direction of Chrono Cross's Radical Dreamers and Nikki character i.e. just going for classic rock looks is unexpected but great.
5:57 --- Love WHM. Its more in tune with the Gridanian padjali style, more like a sturdy druid's outfit, and less the pristine Whites of Amdapor...
19:11 --- Might also just be the lighting so wait and see.
21:30 --- Not a fan of the weapon. I like it when the bow has harp- and other musical elements on it, but this one... try the idle pose of Bard with weapon in hand and they will stab themselves through the chest -.- Its bad design is what it is. The idea may be neat and I like the color scheme... but its bad design. The overall armor looks cool though.
24:20 --- Its the same with the RDM focus thingy... Yoshi-P may have said "they are lunchboxes filled with love", but when I'm not happy with my lunchbox, I put stickers on it!
28:59 --- Isnt that Micote sporting a new hairstyle? Also, its clearly not a robe this time. The hanging pieces seem more like part of a cloak or scarf...
31:11 --- Also, Titan-Egi looks different... or upgraded...
The sad part about job armor is, we dont have enough glam plates to use them :( With soon 21 jobs and only 20 plates, we have to once again use role armor sets. And that not even taking into acount the crafters and their glams... It doesnt matter which set I like most: I wont be able to use any of them longterm :(
Dawntrail gives us everything we wanted but still can’t figure out how to make head pieces work on all races… lazy… yes I said it…
They 100% know how. The issue is most likely time. Keep in mind that when they're done with the expansion they work on the next patch. They always work on something. We know they have a priority list. Thats why QoL changes are always sparse in games. They know. They've said that they're aware of it. I wabt them to work on it, but there are more important things.
@@plainsalt how about you finish something you started? If they weren’t ready to release the races fully, they should’ve not released them. Us gamers have become accustomed to gam releases needing to be patched on day one instead of releasing fully like they used to. Running two businesses myself if I knew there was issues and problems with things going on, and I didn’t address them immediately, they would probably be a certain amount of business loss. Besides the subscription fees argue that Fantasia make the second most amount of money out of anything in the game. Time equals money and with that train of thought, you think they take the time to fix the issue.Enix posted a loss on their financials by a considerable amount yet they don’t fix the things that might actually make them a little bit more money. Also that customers are going to be happier, therefore possibly spending more money.
What i get from the gear preview is that they have velvet tech now
Red Mage job gear is interesting. The sword is clearly an homage to Impact, and the Focus has 4 crystalos. 1 representing each type of magic red mage uses, Black and White magic, plus the type of magic the Mage transforms them into, Red magic...So what is the 4th crystal? New magic source for red mages to explore?