The REAL MEANING behind Shiva, Vishnu & Brahma? | Reaction
Вставка
- Опубліковано 27 тра 2024
- Come and join me to see me react to what the real meaning of the Hindu Trinity is about Shiva, Vishnu & Brahma and how it relates to Carl Jung
IG: zuzanareacts
To support this channel, use the link: ko-fi.com/zuzanareacts
Original Video: • The REAL MEANING behin... - Розваги
NO .. its not The REAL MEANING behind Shiva, Vishnu & Brahma
He did not say it is the meaning of Bharma, Vishnu, and Shiv. Carl jung is very famous philosopher in the western world (even in other parts of the world). The video he made was for Western audiences. By comparing the understanding of Carl jung, western audiences can understand the gravity of the Brahma, Vishnu and Shiva. He gave prospective to make others understand in a way that they feel easy. You even can not figure out the real meaning. There are prospectives only. Just like Vaishnav, shaivite, shaktas and other panths have different prospective on the Brahma, Vishnu and Mahesh(Shiva). Thank you.
KARL &FREUD WERE OF THE ABRAHAMC GROUPS
THEY HAD NO CONCEPTION OF DHARMIK SANATANI OF ENDLESS TIME
so I'm not too sure what the argument is here. Are you doubting that an individual from 'abrahamic culture' can study India and utilise it for their concepts/studies?
Surely. The basics of logic and reference depends on surroundings, environmental impact and traditional concepts.
not really - if you spend enough time in the culture you can understand it - I think this argument id deeply flawed. (As I lived that argument and hence I'm claiming it), To me that can only be clamied by a person that never lived substantial amount of time outside of their own culture.
@@zuzanareacts Rapperiya Balaram Other Subtitles Hindi Song
ua-cam.com/video/RxYk0CDHd6Q/v-deo.htmlfeature=shared
@@zuzanareactsEveryone is equal for a true god true god loves anyone
Refference:-Bhagavad Gita 9.32
All those who take refuge in Me, whatever their birth, race, gender, or caste, even those whom society scorns, will attain the supreme destination. [
What is god ?
Refference:-
Bhagavad Gita 8.9 - 8.10
God is Omniscient, the most ancient One, the Controller, subtler than the subtlest, the Support of all, and the possessor of an inconceivable divine form; He is brighter than the sun, and beyond all darkness of ignorance. One who at the time of death, with unmoving mind attained by the practice of Yog, fixes the prāṇ (life-airs) between the eyebrows, and steadily remembers the Divine Lord with great devotion, certainly attains Him.
Bhagavad Gita 7.8
I am the taste in water, O son of Kunti, and the radiance of the sun and the moon. I am the sacred syllable Om in the Vedic mantras; I am the sound in ether, and the ability in humans
Bhagavad Gita 7.9
I am the pure fragrance of the Earth, and the brilliance in fire. I am the life-force in all beings, and the penance of the ascetics.
Bhagavad Gita 7.10
O Arjun, know that I am the eternal seed of all beings. I am the intellect of the intelligent, and the splendor of the glorious
Where is god living? God is living in our heart
Bhagavad Gita 10.20
O Arjun, I am seated in the heart of all living entities. I am the beginning, middle, and end of all beings
Bhagavad Gita 10.11
Out of compassion for them, I, who dwell within their hearts, destroy the darkness born of ignorance, with the luminous lamp of knowledge.
What is the duty of us
Reaching to supreme lord, supreme truth and attaining moksha , nirvana supreme liberation by karma yog,gyanyog,bhaktiyog,sannaysyog,gyanvigyan yog and many more that explained by supreme lord Krishna in shrimad bhagvat gita
The each every qualities of humans came from god
Bhagavad Gita 10.4 - 10.5
From Me alone arise the varieties of qualities in humans, such as intellect, knowledge, clarity of thought, forgiveness, truthfulness, control over the senses and mind, joy and sorrow, birth and death, fear and courage, non-violence, equanimity, contentment, austerity, charity, fame, and infamy.
True god is the only lord of all sacrifice,
Brahman the divine is one without the second-chandogya Upanishad
Bhagavad Gita 9.24
I am the enjoyer and the only Lord of all sacrifices. But those who fail to realize My divine nature must be reborn.
Bhagavad Gita 9.25
Worshippers of the celestial gods take birth amongst the celestial gods, worshippers of the ancestors go to the ancestors, worshippers of ghosts take birth amongst such beings, and My devotees come to Me alone.
Who we are?
The body is said to be temple,and the soul is shiva,discard the faded flower offering of ignorance,worship with the thought "i am he"- Maitreya Upanishad
What we pray to the supreme lord
From falsehood lead me truth
From darkness lead me to light
From dead lead me to immortality "- Brihadarnyaka Upanishad
God is unborn
Bhagavad Gita 10.12 - 10.13
Arjun said: You are the Supreme Divine Personality, the Supreme Abode, the Supreme Purifier, the Eternal God, the Primal Being, the Unborn, and the Greatest. The great sages, like Narad, Asit, Deval, and Vyas, proclaimed this, and now You are declaring it to me Yourself.
God has thousands names that doesn't means he is thousands many people call him in different names
Truth is one many sages called it's in different names-rig veda
Why human failed to recognise the true god
Bhagavad Gita 9.11
When I descend in My personal form deluded persons are unable to recognize Me. They do not know the divinity of My personality, as the Supreme Lord of all beings.
Who is god
He is bright, formless, all-pervading, existing without and within, unborn, without prana, without mind, pure and beyond the avyakrita, which is beyond all.” Mandukya Upanishada 2.1.2
Nothing is higher ,greatest than a god
Bhagavad Gita 7.7
There is nothing higher than Myself, O Arjun. Everything rests in Me, as beads strung on a threads
There are more knowledge written in shrimad bhagvat gita ,we can found answer of everything ,shrimad bhagvat gita and Upanishad is not only the religion text rather it is a philosophical text because it is for all human beings not for particular religion ,veda means knowledge and the knowledge for everyone
Hindus doesn't have one book, messenger,one judgement , Hinduism is contains with bunch of philosophy
Hare krishna (lord krishna & lord vishnu) ,hare rama (lord rama and lord vishnu) and finally my Om namahshivaya (lord shiva) ❤❤❤😊😊
Har Har Mahadev would complement better here
Om namah shivaya is panchakshari mantra.
rajan krishnan ,what are you trying to say 😂😂😂😂😂
rajan Krishnan, you are mental 😂😂😂
@@user-lg8sg2if8y didn't say anything to you tho?
Har Har mahadev
@@user-lg8sg2if8y also panchakshari mantra should not be uttered carelessly .
There is a difference between mantra and name of God.
Jai SriRam... Om Namah Sivaya
Everyone is coming up with their own theories these days😂😂. However one thing was true that most of us don't know "who we are and therefore we don't know what we are actually capable of". I read a book "The power of unconscious mind" one of the bestsellers and it opens up new dimension to understand our own brain and it is very fascinating.
Yes - I read it 26 years ago actually that was my I think after astrology books first introduction into spiritual topics if you like.
Hey Zuzana. You look great. I still remember reading Memories, Dreams & reflections by Carl Jung where he said "By that time I had read a great deal about Indian philosophy and religious history, and was deeply convinced of the value of Oriental wisdom… India affected me like a dream, for I was and remained in search of myself, of the truth peculiar to myself". He says that at that time he was engaged in an intensive study of alchemical philosophy and took a volume containing the principal writings of Gerardus Dorneus with him. He says that this European text provided a counterpoint to the “foreign mentality and culture. Both had emerged from original psychic experiences of the unconscious, and therefore had produced the same, similar, or at least comparable insights”. In this internet era, most people act or live according to seek attention or popularity of others. A correct word "Diplomatically". They fear of missing out if they will not gonna act in certain way that is considered being good by the societal norms. I feel like this harms one individual by not being themselves throughout our lives and that's where the most problems occurs of not being truly themselves. Love these kind of deep insights videos from you.
Love your comment. This is the types of videos that really bring me joy to be honest. I fully agree with you. I though thing the root cause of all the problems the more and more I observing is lack of love. Once you are loved and have a strong sense of self (which most people I dare to say don't as they don't seek the knowlege or find it hard to work on themselves) then you have much stronger sense of self. The internal locus of control is developed whereas a lot of people have external locus of control and need those external validation experiences. And source of all this (at least speaking for what I'm observing) is serving to the money god and just pure lack of spiritual development.
Carl jung learned all his knowledge from india, later made a U turn and claimed his ideas as his own.
Now the western world has started accepting the fact that Shiva, Vishnu and Brahma and all the other gods including their energy(Shakti)/ultimate feminine as energies of the universe, which are the supreme controller of the universe, yes they are energies but they are also real beings! It is the small scale memory of humans so as to how far in time we remember events, our ancestors in India have always had a real connection with god not just in meditation but also in the real physical world. Even today Hanuman ji and other chiranjeeves are physically present on earth. Non-Believers are free to not accept it, cause we're not an abrahmic religion, take it or leave it. But I pray for you so that you can see the world beyond it's superficial physical dimension, they're is a whole different world.
I don't think most people are aware of this in the west. In the west it's more about spirituality - which can mean a lot of things. However, the spiritual community would understand there is one source and unierse what you call brahman - but you would have I think hard time convincing people about the trinity simply because you can from our point of view and I htink form yours as well connect directly to the universe. All in all, spirituality is on the rise but we also have our own origins and spiritual people individuals follow not necessarily always connected to Hinduism. And then there is of course people that are interested and want to know. :)
@@zuzanareacts We don't want to convince people anyways, we always believe in seeking, so we're encouraging people to try and experience things then decide if they got closer to their inner-self. Appreciate your views Zuzana 🙏🔱🌸
absolutely - I think this is really about personal journey. I do believe that Hinduism has greatly contributed to rise of spirituality in the west and I think slowly and surely things will start changing. :)
@@zuzanareacts 😇😇
@Ayush Just don't believe whatever u hear for first time. You probably took the word cheeranjivi as it is and never bothered to research. There is huge disconnect with culture and faith for hundreds of years after invasions. I am afriad most of our people (probably includes u as well) don't understand the real concept and never bother to research the words and events properly. Just like maulanas ,there are bad Babas too. And influencer who make videos on hot topics for clout.Like that guy in video.what is his source? He just randomly connected one researcher's work with gods and create his own meaning? You and that guy in video take 35 thousand years old civilization as superstitious oldies or what?
Thanks Z for reacting on the video I recommended a year ago. The next best psychology related video I find is "OSHO: Moving Towards Healthier States of Consciousness." (play it at 1.5). And current best is "16 indian philosophies explained like strategies in a game"
thanks for checking it out. I've been told Osho is apparently very controversial so I don't think I will react to him but the 16 Indian philosophies has been requested and is on the list.
Trinity Gods are explained in many ways. 😂
HAR HAR MAHADEV 🚩 🙏
JAI HIND JAI BHARAT 🇮🇳
He is trying to potray deities as false. But how can it be so when there are hundreds of books written on them, millions of sages-saint having seen them/interacted with them, from ancient times till modern day.
It is to be understood that deities are energy forms and their iconography is actually how they preferred to show themselves to us in our visions. Deities can take on a wide variety of role for the spiritual seeker according to his needs - from being a local village guardian spirit to a full fleged devata to the transcendental parbrahm. Ex. shiva as a clan deity could be Lord Muneeshwarar, he can be SadaShiva with the popular form or be Parashiva like inarticulate brahman. This parallel can be found in other deity traditions as well. These traditions in India are path-based, backed by experience and are time-tested, they are not a one-man theory with no backing. Shaguna brahman (articulate, with quality and maya) & Nirguna brahman (inarticuate, without quality, no maya). According to saints, without grasping the Shaguna, its difficult to grasp the infinitely subtle Nirguna. Like from kindergarten, we gradually graduate to PhD. Isn't this logical?
How you select videos 😅
Means you search them by yourself or someone share you a link?
You can understand this topic better by unvielled channel also.
All we know about spirituality us by this world and meditation.
Hindu God's name means nature time death life energy power knowledge universe
In ancient times our sages capable of go beyond the cosmos and they literally mate with Lord Bramha and Lord Vishnu. The reality of life is to know the reality of supreme lord and we know by watching on naked eyes. Also lord Vishnu manifest himself many times and still we can find many same places as mentioned in the scriptures. One day again world will start to know the real God. The supreme Narayana...
Not related to this video though...
here are my thoughts on the 3 gods in Sanatan Dharma
For me (how much I have come to understand till now from my understanding)
Shiva = is the god of Time or Time itself (that was always there, which can never die, which has transcended death or is death itself)
Vishnu = is the god of Space or Space itself (everything that exists, it exists because of space, untill it is destroyed by time. After destruction comes a new beginning)
Brahma = is the creator or creation within the time and space and is affected by it (the continuous cycle of creation and destruction as long as time and space exists)
Every scripture(granth as we call them) in Sanatan Dharma can be understood in 3 ways
1. Materialistic way of understanding
2. Spiritualistic way of understanding
3. Divine way of understanding
All three aspects must be considered when reading any Sanatan Dharma granth(scripture).
I hear you - makes sense!
This 🙌
Finally a factually correct comment. The names and nature of God are self explanatory.
We say 'na adi na aant hai uska( He have no begging or end) for Shiva.
What else have no begining or end? The time.
Also, Indians believe that time is cyclic. Thus it's a perfect loop. So there is no beginning or end.
Brahma also dies and he is personification of universe.
Sanskrit word for universe is "brahmand" which is basically his name.
Vishu ji just stay in rest, as multiple universes. He is personification of multiverse. If our universe reaches it's life span, other universe still exist, and every time new universe is born(Brahma) at the same time there are infinite number of brahmas (universes) as mentioned in our scriptures. So there is no question of 'assumption' , it's clear as a day.
We also beleive that god is present in everything. That's cuz this universe is god.
That's also why atheism is part of Sanatan dharma.
As we say there are many ways to reach enlightenment. That is a perfect human being who realises that it's all matrix/maya. And everyone have to die , better do good deeds cuz 'karma'.
There are 2000 recorded cases of reincarnation. Hence all the beliefs comes true.
More I read about scriptures, more i start believing that being an agnostic was right idea.
thanks for sharing. Makes a lot of sense. I'd be curious to know how do you define and I think that's maybe conceptual question - atheist in India - since it's part of sanatan - which is broadly speaking spirituality - how does that work over there? I mean here when you say atheist it just means you don;t believe in God - mainly Christian God. However, I do believe in God (brahman) or the universe etc - do you consider that atheist or ?
@@zuzanareactsPlease watch the Charvaka podcast guy with sham sharma show where they talk about Indian athiesm and also the launch of book Why i am not an athiest
@@noicezzzzzzzzzzzzx4081 noice bhai ko secular pranam 🙏
Not related to this specific video, but in general; Whenever the term consort is used instead of Wife it is misleading and cunning because the term consort is a very loaded word with negative connotation.
In ithikasa and hindu vedas, it is clearly mentions shiva marries parvathy and in every shiva temples on a certain day based on astrology marriage happens between shiva and parvathi devi, the date varies from temple to temple, i don't know about north india, but in each and every shiva temple in southern states of india, marriage rituals is observed and is celebrated with huge function and happiness.
I see
the way this guy speak is thrwing me off , its like he is trying to be mysterious but its sound forceful. And about trinity , that's just one view of looking at it, there are many other interpretations of trimurti(trinity) which are much more amazing than the one he mentioned.
interesting!!
Jai shree ram ❤
Jai Narayan
Great video ☺️
thank you!
I have mentioned this before but doesn’t hurt 1 more time. *Please watch the video series - Power of Mythology* videos by Joseph Campbell. He covers this topic beautifully.
mind , and heart are only instruments to get a gate way to the soul of oneself to understand its depth...yeahh one self would mean me like in ur case u..
This video's you react no use this society
React to 16 India philosophy explain as a game by Indian pixels plz
neutron electron proton 🤫😌
🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩Jai shree ram 🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩
❤️❤️❤️🌹🌹🌹🌹🚩🚩🙏🙏
may i suggest you a vedio podcast about hindu religion and itihas vs Nastik ...with Ami ganatra and kushal mehra... channel name "Prakhar ka pravachan ".. this is a one of the good vedio 😊😊
Please react on Dr Abhisekh Mishra
Please bring back ankit Shah to know about script of collapse please 😢🥺🙏
Gods are real if you do sadhana under the guidance of guru you can see them
have you tried?
Practising
I see - I'd be happy to hear about any results/outcomes!
Hello sister ❤😊
Hello 😊
This man comparing sanatan culture with other religion which is disgusting. Sanatan is a ďharma not a religion. Western scholar and philosophers didn't find anything new but copied our science and other things .
So plz don't impose western philosophy on us .
You completely utterly truly madly deeply missed the point, I'm afraid.
I don't think you really need to be mad about what others believe. Everyone have their own ideas and that guy is one of our own. He did it for clout , nothing else. Also,don't post hateful ideas in comment section@expedition
how is my comment hateful? Where do I post hateful ideas? That's new news to me.
@@zuzanareacts @ExpeditionwithJamu he's just giving his views and opinion... Don't be mad... When some western Christian supremacist like Jordan peterson says that west is the epitome of civilization, then it's good for y'all but when some other person from other culture says it then you all are mad...
No matter how much liberal or friendly y'all try to potray yourselves to be but in there you believe yourselves to be superior.. Please accept your dark side or the shadow side as mentioned in the video
I haven't heard him saying that. I do sometimes watch his videos but they are on different topics/
I think the 'all you are mad' is a vast generalisation so that's not accurate. You really believe that normal people here in Europe care this much?
The superiority is another generalised comments and very very VERY deeply falwed. That just means you really don't understand how the 'western world works' and when I try to explain noone wants to listen. Hence, I'm not even going into this. However, it's an utter nonsense - surely there might be people that could ahve the complex like Americans and Briths but talking about it from Slovak perspective it's nothing but laughable. The thing is you need to realise and I speak for ordinary people - noone cares - noone wakes up in the morning and thinks - let me think about India and how superior I am to them! That's just utter nonsense.
I'm not accepting antying but things from my Slovak perspective - nation enslaved for 1000 years ( yes not only India) who western Europe looks down upon and who never colonised any country... so please next time you comment at least check what you are saying!
First
Btw Carl Jung stole most of his philosophy from Vedanta. Also Jordan Peterson tries to take Carl jung work as appropriate it as Christian values.
have you read Carl Jung and Jordan Peterson? Just curious to know about what they stole. I think if you find something valuable and bring it to a society it benefits the world. It shouldn't be the narrative them vs us. Of course I'm for showcasing and including the correct sources. However, it all has to be considered and evaluated in context. i.e. what certain ears bring in -e.g. nowadays censorship is real and if you want share some knowlege you may think twice how you want to do it - maybe an option is not to disclose it as it will be rejected but - if yuo don't it gets high changes to be accepted. Nothing in the world is black or white.
@@zuzanareactsHe's correct though these small ideas that the west now potrays as if it's very new and wise is totaly false... These ideas had been discussed already thousands of years ago and when someone tries to take the credit for the idea that doesn't originate from him, it feels like a fraud and cheat... Newton discovered gravity and he gets the credit for it but if today someone comes and says see guys this is gravity and i found it, then what? And yeah Jordan peterson is nothing but a christian supremacist where he potrays as if the world started in west and will end in west.... He just steals ideas and adds some good english vocabulary to it, to make it look fancy for y'all westerners
@@zuzanareacts well, by stealing he means, giving those theories another shape like in today's world you give credit to the sources you've used. So what he meant is the mentioned guy didn't give the reference of his source of knowledge. Like yeah I know it sounds weird but you can see it today, specifically these things have started from the west itself, to claim the things they've given to the world.
@@zuzanareacts yes I have and there was a well made vide on UA-cam too but the uploader took it down. I think Rajiv Malhotra work on similarities in both is still on UA-cam . Not only that Carl Jung didn't even change many of Sanskrit terms names.
@@zuzanareacts ua-cam.com/video/abcKnfV7B08/v-deo.htmlsi=A81u_7Rl27stAaf8
Making video about spirituality can’t help, practising does. Come travel india and explore spirituality. Weren’t you going to come ?🕉️
yes, I'm coming, been exploring spirituality for 26 years.
This is western interpretation, a good narrative, a lot of good things but shallow understanding
fair enough
Start listening to Acharya Prasant...he is best in Vedanta spirituality. His podcast on ranveer show is also good.
ok - thanks for the tip!
I don't agree
what don't you agree with?
@@zuzanareacts He has his opinions it's alright, he's free to interpret as he seems fit.
For me, it's different, I understand them from elemental cause-effect level and what Identity actually is (at elemental level, I'll explain). Before that ask, why Trinity have their feminine consorts for?
Like CRUD(Create, Read, Update, Delete) operations in a database, but it is at the end just a data, or an identity.
Brahma is the cosmic identity or organism of this Universe, and there are other Brahmas, too, I mean other Universes.
For me this Trinity, comes in 3rd stage distribution of the Ultimate Identity (Par-Brahma). I'll give hierarchy below.
Science already gave you the whole electromagnetic spectrum, right? That explains just shakti/matter. Sankhya yoga just gives 2 elements. One "non-element' (shiva) and " element/energy/matter" (shakti). This is Second stage, after Par-Brahma.
Third stage is Trinity, where shiv and shakti has to interact to take on a dualistic family identity, to create, sustain and ultimately dissolve the physically larger identities (society, Nation, Earth, Universe), thereby the Ultimate Yogi, manages it on autopilot by dividing itself into 3 such partner identities of both elements, to serve the purpose efficiently. So, each trinity has their own type of Shakti. (Sanatanis pls orient her on the feminine shakti consorts of Trinity)
To add, every Universe has there own Trinity.
It would be too long if I go more deep.
Just Fun fact: It divides in 0-1, 1-2-3-5-... and so on. It's popularly called Fibonacci series, but it's Bharat's credit. Here,
0- non element
1- element
With interaction of 0 + 1, the next 1 we get is alive 1.
5 is 5 elements.. And so on the material world we see, combination of fundamental elements.
Sanatanis, if you read & understood till here, make her doubts clearer. Thanks.
Later.
@@shiv8841 The thing is, that guy in video didn't even read scriptures himself.He sound like indian himself. Not even vague idea about what is written in books. The metaphors for God are self explanatory and mentioned in books so many times.
thanks so much for sharing!!!
Stop calling it 'mythical'