Secularism, Constitution और British Raj की J Sai Deepak ने क्या 'गलतियां' गिनाईं? Kitabwala
Вставка
- Опубліковано 17 жов 2023
- खबरों को विस्तार से पढ़ने के लिए क्लिक करे यहां- www.thelallantop.com/
In this episode of Kitabwala, a book based discussion show, Lallantop’s Editor, Saurabh Dwivedi discuss the first book of J Sai Deepak’s written quadrilogy, “India that is Bharat: Coloniality, Civilisation and Constitution.”
In this video, J Sai Deepak discusses the influence of European colonial consciousness on Bharat as the successor state to the Indic civilisation and the origins of the Indian Constitution. He also talks about the importance of decoloniality in order to liberate Bharat's distinctive indigeneity. Along with this, he explains in detail about the character and the traces of concept of Secularism. Along with this Temple entry for females, colonial mindset in textbooks, the practice of history writing in India and Israel-Gaza war are the issues on which J. Sai Deepak has shared his opinion.
During the course of the interview J. Sai Deepak has given references of the a few books and papers, here is the listicle of the same, Happy Reading!
1.)Caste of the Mind by Nicolas Douglas.
2.) Europe, India, and the Limits of Secularism by Jakob De Roover.
3.) The Darkening Age: The Christian Destruction of the Classical World by Catherine Nixey.
LT Premium जॉइन करने के लिए नीचे दिए लिंक पर क्लिक करें: / @thelallantop
Instagram: / thelallantop
Facebook: / thelallantop
Twitter: / thelallantop
Produced By: The Lallantop
Edited By: Radhe
My ancestors were converted to Christianity by missionaries, but I am 32 yrs old and have come back to Hinduism.
Good job ..
Welcome back !!
❤❤❤
Wow man
@@-YOUNG_MASTER- bet that's a non Hindu asking .
i am sc category and I almost converted to Christianity but PPL like modi , Sai deppak, annamalai opened my eyes
Convert ho jata toh hi dhik tha
Sc konsa dharma hay
Bhai u r hindu first and hindu word doesn't mean anything like u r brahmin or sc we shd have to adapt this in our mind
All Hindus are brothers and sisters.
You are Hindu not SC. It's our political leader who devided us in SC, St and General.
पहली बार सौरभ को इतना मजबूर देखा है मैंने
खतम टाटा ,, bye ,bye गया 😂😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂😂
Saurab with uneducated people's 💀
Saurabh with educated people's 🤡
Ur absolutely correct 💯
पहली बार सौरव द्वेदी अपना लेफ्टिस्ट ज्ञान नहीं दिया क्युकी सामने बाप(ज्ञानी) है😂
Bhai Mai aisa comment karne ka soch hi raha tha ki apka comment dekh liya
Jab samne baap hota hai Tab ye drr jata hai
Exactly 💯..
Main bhi yahi soch raha tha comment karne ki. Isko pata hai kiske saamne kitna muh kholna hai. 😂
💯
When J Sai Deepak said :- I am not a South Indian. I am a Indian from south.
It was really a goosebumps moment salute to this guy ❤️🫡
true
Perfect reply.
Goosebumps really? what about this - I am not an Indian I am just a normal human who is divided by borders and nationalities.. Now you got Goosebumps?
See the fact first sir and then act, don't act from your stupid emotions and Goosebumps 😂
Jai Shri Ram
😊@@neelkantsharma5530
A tamilian whose Hindi vocabulary is so much better than even the major Hindi speakers, makes Deepak an amazing person with very high intelligence. Amazing personality.
Bro, his Hindi is not good. That’s why he is using too much English in the conversation. But as a Tamilian still he is able to speak Hindi up to good extent.
He was born and bought up in Hyderabad. Everyone who were born and bought up there, Hindi with lots of Urdu words rubs off in their DNA !
@@siddheshdubey8844 atleast when he is speaking hindi he is using actual hindi words rather than urdu
Isn't he Telugu though ? Telugu's are quite conversant in Hindi in general.
@@siddheshdubey8844can you speak Telugu as fluently as his Hindi? Genuinely curious.
जे साई दीपक जैसे ज्ञान योद्धा जिस प्रकार भारतीय दर्शन,इतिहास ,कला,साहित्य को उसकी गरिमा के साथ अंग्रेजी भाषा में विश्व में फैला रहे हैं वह स्तुत्य है।सच्चे सनातनी को नमन है।
"I will not permit the JNUisation of Indian history any more".....wonderful Sai ji. Respect....admiration.
Who is asking for the permission??
@@ap-hg8wmwell whatever who gave u the right?
@@ap-hg8wmabsolutely 💯
@@lakshyavarshney9942 which right??
@@ap-hg8wm you wrote who is asking for the permission so i wrote my response to that
The reaction on Saurabh face when he couldn't defend the leftist propoganda was priceless
Aah aditya ji yahi comment mai dhoondh raha tha ekdum perfect baat bole ho
Bhai kuch time stamp lga do
Jo aise priceless moments hon
@@Bageshwar_juSarkar yes
Saurabh's face said in Capital : like iss ko kyaa explanation du ki ye sab mann ganat hai aur kuch andhe loog vishwas rakh sakte hai mai nahi...😂. Because Saurabh's is a well educated and doesn't get convinced to such thoughts
Mere dil ki baat tu jaane😂😂
J Sai Deepak को बहुत बहुत शुभकामनाएं इतना महत्वपूर्ण काम करने के लिए मैं चाहता हूं जे साईं दीपक, अंकुर शर्मा, हरिशंकर जैन, विष्णु शंकर जैन, अश्वनी उपाध्याय जैसे अधिवक्ता भारत की माटी से और निकलें। माॅं भारती इनको और शक्ति दे।
Hume hi Shakti deni padegi, kaise?
Har Bharatiya Apne aap ko sabse Pehle Brahma mane phir atman mane phir Apne aap ko sharir mane.
Yehi humane sari duniya ko Gyan diya hai.
My Sanatani brother from the southern part of Bharat 🧡🧡🧡🧡
आप सिक्ख भाई हो
Yes, we are not South Indians. We are Bharteeya from Southern part of Bhaarat.
Jay Bhaarat 🚩
Jai Bharat , aur jai ho bhai aap jaise deshbhakt ki bhi 🚩🙏🇮🇳@@Srijan_Sanatani
My Brahmin family forcibly got converted into Islam by Mughal Aurangzeb some 500 years back and now I re-converted to my ancestor's religion "Sanatan" again..❤
How do you know your history dating back 500 years.
@@MostLucidthere surname , yes many muslims i know they proudly say they were converted in rajasthan side . WE were rajputs . They said this , more detailed way u ever think . They know more there ancestors .
@@yashasvisharma9356 ok
Hindu family*
BrahminWarrior sounds cringe though. Caste pride is really cringe. Same for Rajputs
My eyes are on Shourabh when Deepak sir said "leftist","colonial mind set","conversation","muslim terror time",mandir concept ","church concept ",and many more against secularism 😂😂😂😂
He used the term "JNUisation of history" in front of a person who is a JNU alumni. 😂
@@MobPsycho1oo .🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@aparnatiwari1708off topic questiob please would you date j sai deepak if you got chance even tho he is black ?
@@jennyjames2673 I will but I am teen so he is now my crush, brother don't worry about me you would not get Emma Watson ok
Sai did it deliberately 😂 He is well aware of the tone and tint of this channel and wanted saurabh to push back. But he didn't 😆. Wise Saurabh.
And Ram Ram, The last 6 mins are🔥😂
I have never seen an intellectual this thorough on Indian history and civilization as J Sai Deepak.
Sai Deepak Sir never hesitate!!!
Loved the fact that Saurabh was not able to respond to "Whatsapp University" jibe 😂
I become a huge fan J Sai Deepak as he explains true meaning of Hinduism . Hats off to U sir
Not Hinduism, say "Sanatana Dharma " !!!
@@boogiewoogie4984 say both no reason to give leftist to do hindu vs sanatani
@sk21719 no.... there is always "Sanatani " .. there is no Hindu!!
@@boogiewoogie4984 There is no Sanatani....there is no hindu....:)
@@boogiewoogie4984 Here you are telling others the correct name of their religion.....SILLY and STUPID......
J sai said that the left chooses to stay silent when they can't argue logically. Saurabh's silence in the end reminded me of that !! Kudos Sai ❤
Your right 👍👍👍
Absolutely saurabh himself being a bampanti gang brought him on the show 🤔😂
😂
Absolutely...
Yaay
never thought a person can have so much knowledge . accuracy in arguments , level of understanding , is mindblowing . sai deepak is a gem . our country needs men like him. he is working for development in true sense. changing our colonial mindset and safeguarding our future gen. hatsoff sir ji
यह किताब मैने खरिद कर रखी है, अब इसे जरूर पढूंगा. लेखक ने आपके सभी सवालो का मन: पूर्वक और प्रदीर्घ दिया.
I still can't believe that lallantap actually invited J Sai on their show to let him share his insights into certain issues damn!!! Appreciate that!!
Paise bhi to kamane h.
@@hp3026 reason is lallantop is left leaning portal...thatswhy im also shocked
I am also trying to find the reason why they called J Sai Deepak ji. Strange
@@prajjwalbaghel149👌🏼
@@shurtipathak6440 phas gya agar j Sai to jyada fayda hai Yogi, dhirendra shastri ko bura bana ke itna impact nhi hoga upper middle class pe(jo convent ki fees afford kar sakte hai) jitna isko phasa kar hoga isliye bula liya risk/reward wali baat hai sari
I am from west bengal and my father was a member of comunist party . Now I became SANATANI and my family pro SANATANI 🙏
জয় শ্রী রাম 🚩🇮🇳
Most Bengalis 90% are Anti-Hindu Leftists and Communists who have always supported Anti-Hindu and Anti-India Jihadi Terrorism, Left Terrorism, and Anti-Nationals in W Bengal and India hence the Bad Economic and Living Conditions in W Bengal. W Bengal is considered one of most backward state in India.
Dada jay sree ram
জয় শ্রীরাম
Did ur father also become Sanatani??
@shubho4534 bhajan gate hai 🙏mere sath aur pura Propaganda sikha ta hu unko mai like temple tax ,wafth bord , genocide, jihad etc
None of the hinduphobic crew speak against J sai deepak, the only reason is Knowledge and Conviction. This need to be adopted.
Sai Deepak is great rastra premi son of maa bharti...huge respect and grand salute for him❤
My family was converted to muslim by few years now i am accepting hindu sanatan dharm as i love and breathe the same qualities and do similar things.
Om namah shivay ,jai sri ram 🙏🏻
Chal jhute Lindu 😂😂😂
Madarchod pura comment section main yahi randi Rona ho rakha hai.
And U Will Be In Hell Good Luck
Congratulations
Zoot mat bolo bhai..
@@vedhh7727 jhoota to tera naam hai yaha katuye
This man is literally what India needs to hear and listen to
India nhi miyan Bharat bolo ....
@@vivekanand5154 😄😅🤣
Ye j Sai jockey ki underwear pehenta hai ya khadi gramodyog ki ...ya patre wali
Naa not India only some andhbhakts ye J Sai ek din bohot joote khaayega
@@vivekanand5154 teri maa ke saath Underwear share karta hai... Maa se pooch le apni
सुप्रीम कोर्ट में आप जेसे वकील सनातन को अपनी सही पहचान दिलाने के लिए लड़ रहे है बहुत ही सराहनीय कोटि कोटि प्रणाम,सत्य सनातन धर्म की जय🚩
Two faces of Brahmins. India needs 98 Deepak and 2 Saurabh.
I am flabbergasted with the depth of intellect Mr. J Sai Deepak has.
@@MarCos-bs5rtbhai tum sbko manane lge the kya ,sbko mano koi problem nhi hai .
From my teenage yrs I got admission in catholic diocese runned school, at the end of my school life in 12th, I was so brainwashed & totally convinced to convert into be a Christian.
After few yrs while struggling with my personal issues I was so ready to live in Churches with nuns(in India, we call them mother or sister). But slowly, I have realised now that my country,its culture & its everything including people are best & wonderful. I am fortunate enough to save myself before getting misguided. I am very grateful to my consciousness which saw truth & reality. ❤From my teenage yrs I got admission in catholic diocese runned school, at the end of my school life in 12th, I was so brainwashed & totally convinced to convert into be a Christian.
After few yrs while struggling with my personal issues I was so ready to live in Churches with nuns(in India, we call them mother or sister). But slowly, I have realised now that my country,its culture & its everything including people are best & wonderful. I am fortunate enough to save myself before getting misguided. I am very grateful to my consciousness which saw truth & reality. ❣️🧿
Me too,catholic diocese schools. I feel the same too
how is being catholic brainwashed people?
@@utkarshsingh-rp2dq small scall that you get, and far away than your thoughts
Bro this is just copy pasted
I'm proud Vedic Hindu but I oppose you guys writing such comments for spreading hate between Indians.
If you have really experienced that you wrote than I'm sorry and taking back my words.
But it feels like that you copy pasted the content.
@@Gobar-Bhai bro i attended catholic diocese school from nursery to 8th standard and it was hell for me personally becoz i was discriminated too much over there.
J Sai Deepak said: I am not a south indian I am a indian from south. It's a great sentence. I am agree with you sir. Salute to you sir. You are doing great efforts for increasing hindu culture and hindu dharma in Indian sanatan youth. Thank you very much sir for the giving your valuable information.🙏🙏🙏🙏🚩🚩🚩🚩
साईं दीपक जी, आपको बहुत -बहुत साधुवाद। आपके द्वारा जो सच भारतीयों तक पहुँच रहा है। मुझे पूर्ण विश्वास है। कि भविष्य में इसके अच्छे परिणाम आयेंगे।भारतवासियों को आप पर गर्व है।
जय श्री राम !!!
Never seen anyone who talked about our Indian history with such confidense and cited all the facts. Thank you J Sai Deepak and The Lallantop for this interview.
Have you checked what he says is truth? India is derived from Indigo? What crap.
On his very last point - when he cites a Moroccan example and asks what if women and children from Pakistan (very cleverly not naming it) did the same would you make a moat :) he forgets to mention that India has made the longest border fence which is electrified and what not and is constantly patrolled not just on Pakistan side but on Bangladesh border too and there is in fact virtually no trespassing is possible or happening... small point but just to highlight the level of deceit and deception.
@@NitinSharma-xz4kn abe idiot fence can be easily destroyed by bombs
@@NitinSharma-xz4kninfiltrators can come through tunnels that is very common, we don't have underground concrete barriers as Egypt has and E@nemy has their supporters this side as well ...... learn something from current war.
give your brain some rest Ms.@@deshbhaktstri - underground concrete barriers :) :)
Sai Deepak is such a Gem.
I have not seen Saurabh Dwivedi so serious and open to hear anyone in his show before. 😂
Saurabh was in fear that if he starts debating with jsd than he will destroy him like he destroyed likes of owaisi,Shashi tharoor and many more
@@vinayak7890 Exactly !!
Second book par discuss nahi karega kyunki left British ko target karega India mai lekin uss pahle hua colonisation hua h islamic wala uss par discuss nahi karega
@@NISHUGARVU left Wale discuss bhale he na kare par ab vo jsd ko rok nahi payenge kyoki ab Tak English vali audience he usko jyada jaanti thi ab Hindi belt mai bhi log jaan ne lage hai
Saurabh mann mein: Ye to Dhoti khol raha hai 🌚
Loved the chaste Hindi conversation by Saurabhji (I am from Karnataka but love when Indians talk in their mother tongue so beautifully)… I could sense the time and attention he has put in to understand and then ask insightful questions. Thank you sir 🙏🏻
So much respect for Mr Deepak, for your understanding, synthesis and beautiful way of enlightening us. We wish you both the very best!!!
❤❤
Right?!? So absolutely fantastic. A thing of beauty
Should have seen Saurabh's face when Sai Deepakji spoke about JNU...😂
This is healing process which our civilization is going through. And we have people like J Sai Deepak who are leading us for that.
I am your category but u think what some stae party r doing just bcoz of vote ... plz no politics .. just Rastra
बिलकुल सही कहा आपने 👍
🤣🤣🤣
👍
Poison is already there, just slowed down the proecess.. !
Listened to this episode several times....I vote for Part 2 of J. Sai Deepak with Saurabh Dwivedi. It's a Must!
Dalle saurab ki itni jal chuki hai is interview k baad k part 2 use khade hoke karna hoga.
@@saitama3843wahi mn b dekh rha tha, jaise hi jnu ka naam aaya...
@@saitama3843kyonki samne constitution, laws, polity ka master baittha hai ye sabd fek nhi payega.
jaise jsd ne bola india naam indus rivers ki wajah se nhi aaya kyonki mera bhi aisa manna kyonki agar hota to native americans ko red indians kyon bola ye sawal mujhe khatakta tha.
Saurabh ko aaj pahli baar itna helpless dekha 😂😂😂
the best videos every astik sanatani must watch - pranam to sai deepak ji for putting this together #JSD 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
I became aware of Sai's presence in 2020 and since then there had been no looking back.
Very grateful to make us feel Sanatani Bhartiya unashamedly, liberate us from secular oppression and bring us to Indic wing.
🙏🙏
1
What about casteism?
@@whykoksyes what about it ?
@@krishna_o15caste means the dominant state of mind and it's not based on birth, ethnicity or race.
@@Das_Akash_X and what if it's about lineage and is directly related to your heirdeitry
Never seen saurabh Dwivedi ..helpless lile this.. The way J sai Deepak presented his views savagely... is mind blowing.
Not a single time he has abled opposed Deepak ji facts .
Journalist Saurab is not reader himself, so relies on the research of guys who stand behind the cameras. So I would suggest that let them narrate their own research.
From starting he is differently humble ... actually he is not
👌👌🤣🤣
@@knnizamani1184 ye baat unhone aap ko khud batayi thi ya allah aaye the batane aapko sapne me. waise raam mandir bhi ban chuka hai, ho sakta hai wo aaye ho.
hum sabne bohot interview aur episode dekhe hai saurabh ke, he is looking helpless before this guy
I don't watch this channel but came here for J sai deepak.
भाई साहब पढ़ना है तो कम से कम इतना बढ़ो वरना मत पढ़ो।
#Respect for j sai deepak📈📈📈📈📈
Bhai detail me padhoge to tum bhi jaan jaoge bhai 🙂🙏 🥰
I am speechless, stunned and literally crying. I am thinking whether I was really educated or colonized😢
If you have looked Indian society, dharma, rituals, dharshan as downgraded then you're really a coloniszed educated that the colonizers wanted us to be...
I'm not saying everything in India was good...
Colonized by mind and free from physical...Choice is yours....Start reading Our indic texts and Bharat philosophy
Colonized.
@@rockatp5253true
You're not alone, brother. Most of us feel the same way listening to #JSaiDeepak
We have successfully reached to a point where self declared secular entities can no longer ignore indic thought writers and are compelled to have discussions unlike in the times of Sita Ram Goel 👏🏼
@@HimanshuMishra00even the sanghs were against them
Its 😂funny to see the same sanghis as declaring themselves as the only protector of Hinduism these days.
@@Pantheon-nu5klsangh is just a body to achieve ultimate goal it is not the ultimate goal
@@Pantheon-nu5kl can u share some reference, incident which makes your point clear? If individuals were against or sangh as whole.
@@andytube07 sitaram goel used to say that rss folks are fools and they harm the hindu cause
@@HimanshuMishra00thats True bcz I am also a firm believer of my dharma and i protect my country and my Dharma too.. when I say this pseudo secular liberals and communists give me the tag that I was a sangi.. every one who supports Sanathana Dharma need not to be a sangi..
Ek baat toh hai Saurabh bhai ne puri chuppi sadh rakhi thi , no rebuttal, no counter argument. I have never seen him like this. I don’t know why!!
This is the best JSD interview in Hindi for the Hindi audience to sit up and churn their grey cells. Thanks to the Interviewer who has brought out the essence of JSD's book and many times remained tongue tied which was not his usual demeanor. Sai Deepak's intellectual aura is such.
This conversation left me thinking how I ended up being so uneducated despite earning two degrees officially. Truly inspiring and enlightening, I hope some day I will manage to learn what is Bharat.
You arw not uneducated. In this era disinformation is catered with made up facts. If you have weaker mind you will be easily brainwashed by some far right agenda. So maintain your sanity. And no one is attacking India or our hindu religion.
Thanks to lalllantop. Finally, JSD has been exposed. Never seen such a bigger buffoon. What is Indic. The man has no understanding of History. The answer to what is Eurocentric by JSD is a laugh. This is truly the age of kaluyuug. Clowns like this can get social media to mouth shiiit
India didn't exist before 1947. Italy didn't exist before 1860. Turkey didn't exist before 1921, Germany didn't exist before 1871, Saudi Arabia didn't exist before 1932 and so on. Concept of Countries was invented in Europe in the 18th century. Before the invention of the concept of countries, there were only empires and kingdoms. Turkey was created after the fall of the Ottomans empire. Dozens of countries were created based on nationalities after the fall of the Ottomans empire. Saudi Arabia was created in 1932 after the fall of Ottomans Empire in 1921. Saudi Arabia didn't exist When Prophet Muhammad was born in Mecca. Italy was created in 1860 by merging various small kingdoms of Italian nationality. Similarly, Germany was created in 1871 by merging various small kingdoms of German nationality. Similarly, all European countries were created based on nationalities.
Now the question is what is nation and nationality? A nation is a society that shares a common language, culture, and history and has shared interests. For example English, German, Italian, Turkish, French, Russian, Dutch, Spanish, Arabs, Persian, Kurds, Japanese, Korean, Punjabi, kashmiri, Marathi, Bengali, Tamil, Malyalam, Thai etc are nations and a country based on single nation or nationality or where a single nationality dominates culturally, politically, in economy and military is called a nation state. Most countries in Europe or 'civilised world' are based on single nationalities and are nation states or simply called nations.
There are dozens of nations within India and Pakistan. And hence India and Pakistan are union of nations or multinational countries. Nations are Punjab, Kashmir, sindh, Baluchistan, Gujarat, Bengal, Maharashtra, Tamilnadu etc. And in modern civilised world countries are created on basis of nationality like the countries in Europe (England, France, Germany, Poland, Norway, Sweden, Croatia etc) or in Asia (Korea, Japan, China,Thailand, Philippines etc) and Bangladesh etc are countries based on nationalities.
Republic of India was created in 1947 out of the British Indian empire on the basis of two nations bogus theory. Two nations were assumed as Islam and hindusim. But in reality, Islam and Hinduism are not nations. India and Pakistan were not created based on nationalities but on two nation (Islam Hinduism) bogus theory. Hence, these countries are based on religions. On the other hand, Bangladesh is a nation state which was created on the basis of Bangla nationality in 1971.
Three predominant civilisations in Republic of India, Indo Aryans, Dravidian and Sino Tibetic ( North East nations in the Republic of India) don't share anything although the first two civilisations share religion hence religion is the biggest binding force of the country followed by Military Power which is used to occupy non Hindu nations (Punjab, Kashmir, Nagaland, Mizoram, Meghalaya) with the country
Punjab should be a free country based on Punjabi nationality like Bangladesh. But Hindu Punjabis and Muslims punjabi don't want to leave india and Pakistan, so we Punjabi Sikhs can't force them to follow us. Hindu Punjabis, who had deserted Punjabi language in 1951 and 1961 census by declaring Hindi as their mother tongue would never support a Punjabi nation state. They support a Indian state based on the Hindu religion. Similarly, Punjabi Muslims of Pakistan dont support Punjabi nation state either. They support Pakistan state that is based on Islam religion.
Similarly, Bengali Hindus don't support Bangla nation state Bangladesh and want to live in India which is based on Hinduism. So Punjabi muslims, Punjabi Hindus, and Bengali Hindus are free to stay in their respective countries based on religions. But similar to Bangla Muslims of East Pakistan, who created Bangla nation state Bangladesh without Indian Bengali Hindus, Sikhs have the right to create Azad Punjab (a Punjabi nation state) without Punjabi Hindus and Punjabi Muslims. As simple as that.
We Punjabi Sikhs have no problem living in a Punjabi Muslims or Punjabi Hindu majority Punjabi nation state but they don't support nation state unlike modern civilised world but a state based on religion.
The Punjabi speaker population of Muslims is around 10 crore. Punjabi speaking population of Hindus is around 3 crore (Punjabi Hindus in Punjab, Himchal, Haryana, Jammu and Delhi). Punjabi speaker Sikh population is around 2 crore. Hence Sikhs would be minority if both Punjabi muslims and Hindus or either one of them come form a Punjabi nation state with us Sikhs. We Sikhs have no problem living as minority in Punjabi nation state among majority Punjabi muslims and Punjabi Hindus, But their radicals minds prefer religion over their nationality and they love to give up their Punjabi nationality and adopt Hindi and Urdu nationality in order to create a state based on their respective religions.
So when Sikhs alone form a Punjabi nation state, it would automatically be a Sikh majority Punjabi nation state called Khalistan. What's in the name? We are open to change the name and keep it Punjab instead of Khalistan and also write the word secular state in constitution because it wouldn't change anything in practice. In practice it would still be Khalistan just like India is a Hindu rashtra in practice regardless of its official name or regardless of its constitution..
@@SatpalVerma000u have not seen the whole interview I think European cannot impose the definition of nation on us there are many countries which have same religion ethnicity and language but cannot form nation but we have formed a nation and country is different thing than nation. India is not multinational country because what u define nations in india I can sub divide them further like punjab can be divided into Manjha and doab region same way same way Maharashtra can be divided into different region these in itself can form nation and these so called nation which u call were formed after 1947 we created them and we keep on creating new regions like we did with Andhra and telangana in same way goa and Maharashtra and uttarakhand and was taken out of up and secondly this Sikh separate identity was created by singh Sabha movement. When gurus talk about themselves then they called themselves hindus.
Bhai if you are asking this question from yourself then your journey has already begun. 👍🏻👍🏻
From Bengal, from my childhood i always thought Hinduism as bad thing. But now in my 22 years of age i think I'm lucky and proud to be born in a Hindu family ❤ and society.
From childhood i always liked & loved the spirituality and Dharma 🙏🕉️.
I want to restore and rebuild the ruined old temples of Bengal. Want to document all the schools of thoughts of Hinduism which is in the world. And want to open a school in India where by doing a course anyone can become a Brahmin & temple priests .
Bcz in our Villages there is the shortage of good priests. Many priests can't even read the mantras properly.
तथास्तु.👍
All the best
I am just curious about what made you think like that about hinduism?
@@_Aham_Brahmasmi_its all subtle subconscious media sourced bias
@@VandeAkhandaBharatam cancerous colonial abrahimic education system .
I am just amazed at the knowledge J Sai Deepak has
God Bless him and keep him Safe and Healthy
Fuck Bro.... This ep was just pure debunking of established and accepted thoughts on so many things, can't even name all of them. Really changed my lens of looking at our people, religion everything. This is possible only by high caliber individuals like Sai sir. Much respect to him❤
I noticed one thing in this interview if anyone has noticed see the face of Saurabh. On his face Sai Deepak is destroying his ideology but he did not question a single thing against him. Wow Deepak sir. Thank you so much
@@prakharagnihotri7894 Saurabh asked few questions but got answered with proper facts, admit it bro he have no counter for Sai's facts and hence he was quite as mouse. 😊
@Deepak.....yes....I noticed too....I am not a subscriber of Saurabh....he is just subtle in his anti Bharath stance.....came here for JSD...
Sai Deepak nay Saurabh ki nunni ka kataa hua bhaag, chaahey kuchh samay k liye hi sahi, vaapis jod diyaa.
Man with Clarity and wisdom..! Voice of Strong Bharat ❤🔥🇮🇳
J. Sai Deepak bahut hi gyani person hai.
Kam se kam aise 1000 gyani ki hamare desh ko zarurat hai.
Phir 10 saal me bahut kuchh changes ho sakta hamare hindu aur bharatiya samaaj me.
Knowledge is respected everywhere . This applies to this guy
I never watch Lallantop, But Just for J Sai Deepak Ji I watched this Episode, Jai Bharat
LallAntop dekhna bhi mt bhai leftist h pura
same
Right@@RohitSingh-fu4kv
@@ReetaYadav-id9sume too and mann karta hai bus j Sai Deepak ko sunate jao
Right
Finally, an author who is truely contributing to put out the real meaning of Our culture and religion.. Great work JSD Sir!
लंलन वाले ,,nationalist::: सामने जो हिंदू बैठे है ये सब बैल जैसे सर हिलाने वाले है..ये नपुंसक कुछ नही करेंगे...
From 1947 , Govts are always favorable to islamic extremists .
.
WHY> Lot of facilities, aids, subsidy for one extremist group.
भारतमे २०५० तक इस्लामीक ३ या ४ देश बनेंगे, तब इन कुत्तोंकी नींद खुलेगी.
Big respect to Shri Sai Deepak ji
I love to listen him...all the knowledge we never got from our stupid school....now thanks to sudhanshu ji,j Sai Deepak ,and many more that we are aware of our real history now...
Wonderful speech of J. Sai🙏🙏
I really follow this guy..he speaks with facts...and our indian culture
lol, he exposes and debunks islamists like you...
@@qwerty-ws5hqmaybe he's more Indian than blind haters who only go by name. LOL.
@@qwerty-ws5hq As a hindu i am telling you that british destroyed us more that anyone else
सर ये जेनुआइजेशन क्या है यह समझ तो आ गया है लेकिन इसकी spelling क्या है यह नहीं मिल रही है। क्या कोई बता सकता हैं?
@@DealWithConceptDWC JNUisation
You are a brilliant author and law scholar Sir. Truely a gem of Bharat.
- Your big admirer from Nepal.
Bro I am also Nepali. Any books on Nepali history you would like to recommend me 🙏
@@erenandlelouch9173 There is a channel named 'History In Nepali'. Listen to that.
@@erenandlelouch9173Also Komon Nepali is good.
U people should study more .....
Sai Deepak will always have my admiration and respect for his immense knowledge and stand on Bharat
शानदार बातचीत , देश मे यह विमर्श बढ़ना चाहिए ।
J Sai Deepak, Anand Ranganathan and Annamalai are legends. There is no match to their knowledge and wisdom and courage. Best treat to watch. Bharat needs gems like them
True. I feel Annamalai has potential to be the future PM of India.
❤
@@himanshupathak1310 Are you against Amit Shah or Yogi Ji? Shameful!
@@documentin9171yogi ban na nahi chahiye.....india ke baki minorities ko khatra hei.....Amit Shah chalega,anamalai padha likha hei
@@cristiano2741 A sadhu has no caste. So please! Yogi Ji is the future PM of India.
No jihadi gave his/her presence in this comment section. Truly beautiful J sai Deepak ji.
I'm Muslim but he is factual. A Muslim who has forgot bharatiya origin will disagree with him
@@Xmagneto11 that's unfortunate bhai
दीपक जी की बहुत सी बातें मुझे समझ मे आयी और कुछ समझ नही सका अंग्रेजी की वजह से पर अंत मे इतना कह सकता हूँ भारत एक देश तब भी था जब अंग्रेज नही थे और हिन्दू या सनातन वो विचार है जो सबको अपना बनाता है ।
He is such a wonderful person that I want to listen him again and again. He is an institution in himself. We want more and more such intellectuals to take birth in our country and make our country what it is. He inspires and influences me to read more. Thank you J Sai Deepak Sir
So far this is the best episode across the entire platforms of THE LALLANTOP. It's an Eye Opener onto our History and our Intellect . The forcefull thought process of the west especially about SECULERISM that were implanted on our minds through our education system has been shattered.
BJP IT cell in full flow in comments section. Bhai, dal nahin galni. 2024 ke baad koi aur job karni padegi. Wohi hoga jo Karnataka mien BJP-RSS IT cell ka haal ho raha hai 😆 😂
When u don't wanna grow this is what happens, it has nothing to do with bjp who is BJP or RSS why do i have to be a bjp or rss member to know the correct history. Just get out of political mindset and have a neutral point of view and always have a question. why??
Never have I ever seen Mr. Dwivedi so helpless and submissive in an interview where the guest not only disagrees but destroys his ideology right in his face. This is power of true culturally awakening backed with cold hard facts which can't be discredited as WhatsApp forward anymore. Mr. Dwivedi couldn't even defend the marxist-communist cabal which Sai absolutely demolished with "I won't let the JNUisation of Indian culture..." Being a subscriber/sympathiser of the same ideology and student of the same institution, all Mr. Dwivedi could do was just meekly ask "what do you mean by JNUisation?" and got further blasted by the truth bombs dropped by Sai. This is why right wingers/Sanatanis/culturally awakened people need to be articulate and armed with impeccable facts rather than being abusive when fighting the termites eating away the culture of the land since ages.
Probably the most enjoyable and informative interview I've ever seen. Credits to Mr. Dwivedi for inviting Mr. Sai even though subconsciously knowing what he could do to his institutional subscriptions. Absolutely spectacular dismantling of the inferiority complex ingrained in our society by the brown sahebs.
Thank You Mr. Sai. I'm finally starting this book almost 6 months after buying it.
Deepak haven't faced a real historian
Good one i know some people will come up with some excuses. More and more people awaken its definitely a problem for liberals and leftist in india. Now they need work hard and there excuses and propaganda not going to work. I just observe people like sai or any other, understand people, their perspectives, debate, research in loop which is the culture of sanatan dharma. In some cases we may not agree on certain aspects but still we need to gain knowledge and experience which is must for the “evolution”. That is “Dharma”, yes “Bhishma was also a follower of dharma but lost somewhere. So my point is “we need more and more debates, research and discussions, hope to see more people like J sai, ranganathan in bharath.
Agree totally 👏👏👏
@@lenovoa-hy4fireal historian like west endorsed christians or leftist 😂😂😂
@@randomtrickspro8828 watch his video on why we burst cracker on Diwali?he rightly defend his illogical logic ,in the name of so called tradition. The so called soul who came from heaven they can't find way by their own they need human help.
I appreciate his eloquence. His engineering background makes his argumentative skills stronger than the rest.
Very nice interview. Deepak has so much intellect’s view with facts. Very thorough in his work
15:55 - Indian literature
22:48 - Indians
24:24 - Tribes and aryan invasion
27:26 - Shahshi tharoor school of thought
30:28 - how the name "India" came
32:31 - Secularism and christianity
36:20 - ban on using mother tongu
43:03 - hindu and Christian approach to nature
43:45 - Janjaati and nature
49:50 - secularism
1:13:23 - Marxist theory
Thanks Bro!
Hindu rashtra ab banega jai jai shree Ram
You should read a book HINDU IN 35:40 HINDURASTRA by Anand Rangnathan.
thanks
What Jai Sai said about Uttarakhand and Himachal is absolutely 100% right. I'm a uttrakhandi and I understand our state is dependent upon tourism and so we have to improve infrastructure but not at the cost of destroying the things that made this place a tourist spot.
For example- from Roorkee To Dehradun when you are on the outskirts of Doon you would immediately realize even if you are sleeping in a bus or car that you are in doon because of the air quality and calmness of that mountain, the beautiful scenery that it used to have was just amazing totally amazing.
But to boost the infrastucture development they ruined everything every single thing that made the whole journey wonderful.
I hope somebody reads it.
i read it.
lots of love and respect for J Sai from Bihar
@@harshvardhananimations461 thanks mate for giving your time to read my thoughts
पूरा उत्तराखंड गंजा कर दिया । देहरादून दिल्ली के जैसे फैलता जा रहा है।
कॉर्बेट जैसे जंगल के आसपास के जंगल काटकर रिजॉर्ट बन गए ।
उत्तराखंड को तथाकथित विकास निगल गया । जिस राज्य को 80% घने जंगल में ढका हुआ होना था ।
Yes, if we see with heart, it won't be tough to understand what all the rooted, original earth customs developed all over the world - before Abrahamic religions.
Somehow the first thought they got - we can do anything to this earth, even over consume for our pleasure.
That's the first thought towards downfall.
Till then people with those thoughts are few in a large society.
UK k politicians himachal k comparison mai bohot jayada corrupt hai
They don't give any fk for environment
First time I got the clear idea of "Right"" of India. Meant to ssay "right" Ka राइट perspective mila.. Love this dialogue hats off to jai sai deepak ji.
What a man,,, we want more proud intelligent Brahmins in Bharat
सौरभ जी गजब का बौद्धिक स्तर है साई जी का। मैंने पूरा साक्षात्कार सुना । अदभुत परिश्रम किया है उन्होंने। दूसरी पुस्तक की समीक्षा की प्रतीक्षा रहेगी।
आप पर भारी पड़ा बंदा.....
i am just thrilled how time after time Sai clearly expresses his thoughts with such clarity and accuracy that no one could question his logic and intellect. it's a great manifestation of study and academic excellence...
Please don't accept any crap because he says with arrogance. Please go and read history and understand. And please understand that it not only his book that covers history. His book is his perspective of history. Do you think it is the truth?
@@tusharshah8938for you this is arrogance of the knowledge but for him knowledge is the arrogance
@@tusharshah8938You think so because, his logic runs in to counter towards your brainwashing, if you could ever break the brainwashing of yours and see things objectively then you can see what the rest is seeing.
@@tusharshah8938 you want to unite hindus or want them fight each other on caste first answer this?
@@tusharshah8938mtlb arrogance bolke facts ko ignore kar dega😂. Aur kaisa history? Tum kaun si history padhe ho bhai.. Romila thapar ki? Irfan habib ki? 😂😂aise historians to primary sources se interpret hi nhi kiya. Historians kayi tarah ke hain.. Tumne kiske huwe padhe. Baat karta hai arrogance ki😂😂WTH.
Simple si bat hay , mere ghar may kon aayega uska decision may lunga, na ki court.
I m stunned . J sai 🎉salute 🫡
This video should be a must watch for anyone studying Indian history and current sociology! Pearls of wisdom from deep research.
Propaganda
It’s a must watch video.
@@harnektl😂cry
@@harnektl Uwaaa uwaaa cry baby cry
Agreed
He is the type of scholar Bharat and Bhartiyas need. Huge respect for compiling such facts and information into a written document. Decolonisation of the mind is utmost necessary for the further development of Bharat otherwise we will end up as a 3r grade copy of some western country. Mansik gulami , sharirik gulami se jyada khatarnak hai.
True
True.
😅😅😅😅😅What a statement at 01:40:45 by J SAI DEEPAK after that this so called intellect idiot became quite 😂😂😂
Amazing interview of J Sai Deepak. He is definitely a voice to be heard and learnt from. Thanks to Saurabh for reading and analysing the book completely before interviewing and then asking some very critical and important questions. Thanks to both!
JUST BRILLIANT !!! Sai Deepak undresses all the leftists, liberals, colonist, lutyens, critiques of sanatani traditions piece by piece - WITH EVIDENCE AND SOLID LOGIC !!!
I'm thrilled that Sai is compiling thorough research for all future generations. And he's certainly shaping the present as well ❤
I always eagerly wait for Sai Deepak's new Seminars and interviews everytime... He is an actual 'correct voice' that has emerged in the last few years...
He is been sent by God
He and Sudhanshu Trivedi Has Lots of actual History and Culture Knowledge ..
Yes... But the people are not sharing the proper platform to D. Sai deepak
Very interesting dialogue and great researchby Sai Deepak.
जब साई दीपकजी बात करते है तो उनका गैर संनतानी धर्मो का प्रखर ज्ञान समीप आता है , ये बहुत जरूरी है।
I am am Ex-muslim but proud Sanatani now 🙏
🥰🙂❤️🤗💪💕🇮🇳🕉️
We are proud of the warriors like you who can be remove the obstacles to the road leading to your home of Sanatan dharma..
This man has such a great depth of knowledge, and his perspective is what many of people like us want to express.
I will have to watch this conversation over and over to remember all words. Also get J Sai Deepak Books.
One of theeee best interview ever....love u J sai deepak ❤...what a thinker .....❤u r the real thinker,intellectual, ideal,deta driven inspiration of the country ❤
This Person is True Intellectual Property of Bharat! ❤
bhai, His entire knowledge is based on Secondary Sources . He epitomises Indian Civilisation and its traditions but doesnt acknowledge the fact that Civilisation has to be seen in context of contemporary developments. He is not an IP of Bharat but a conservative ideologue who is furthering only one line - “ Sanatani Hindu khatre mei hai”
@@shashankmittal3931then what is primary source?? NCERT?? Or whatever garbage Romila Thappar wrote??
@@adityasaurabh-exam3175 Primary Source would be person's own research , going through accounts of people who lived through those times . Romila Thapar's garbage has been the source of India's brightest minds today . Might not be perfect but there is always space for debate.
@@shashankmittal3931 Go through his books where he has cited all of his sources. You have not read even one book in your life and are only shouting like a slave of the goras.
All primary resources are mentioned in his book
This guy truly inspires me, can't say that about 99.99% popular people.
आखिरी कुछ मिनट सौरभ की गांड jharr सै बोली मजा आईऔ😂😂
Sanjay Dixit, Pushpendra Kulshreshttha, Ami Ganatra, Anand Rangnathan, Vikram Sampath, Vishnu Shankar Jain, Ravi Singh Choudhari and many more..
@@ns7379I think he known all them but ye video dekhne k baad josh me aagya hogya isliye aisa likh diya hoga 😂
@@nzxhell527 Yes but let him say or realise this, Hume josh aur hosh dono chahiye. Hosh hai aur josh nahi to Gandhi aur Josh hai Hosh nahi to teenager 😂.
*Sai deepaks ancestors where not allowed inside temple untouchability.* Thank god Dr.Ambedkar wrote constitution to eradicate untouchability, so today sai deepak can go to school and defend Hinduism.
This is the bunch of sources which shows that the potential and reality of our great india. Jay hind
Every Indian MUST watch this video
I am from Jharkhand and I can say churches are operating in the tribal belt to convert them to Christianity. And to some degree they have got success as well. Truly astonishing.
To how much degree are they successful?
@@mangopudding5979 I would say half the tribal population believes and/or follows in Christianity. Thats why they have been raising demands to implement Sarna code. Their actual religion. A distinct religious identity separate from any other religion.
@@inalpha15 but are they leaving xtianity?
@@mangopudding5979 Some will leave, some will not if Sarna code gets implemented.Their children have also been born into Christianity. So its unlikely
@@inalpha15 what is Sarna code? If Sarna code is applied then they will leave xtianity right? People are not fighting against Xtianity?
😢It is sad to see that all the history we read for competitive exams is taken from the "JNUisation of History" or "Western lens". And if we cite another perspective to answer the historical question. So that perspective is considered wrong or invalid.
Time stamp
आप सही देश भक्त के साथ मुलाकात कर है ऐ हम सुनने वालोका और सिखने का भाग्य मिला
AmZing...to be a south Indian and speak in favour of Hinduism takes a lot of guts
Sad commentary about what south Indians have become, if it takes lot of guts for them to speak in favor of Hinduism
Sanatan is rooted in southern Bharat everywhere
J. Sai Deepak himself says, "I am not a South Indian, I am an Indian from South". There is the basic difference of mentality.
@@vipin_inthis was awesome my friend
Please leave karnataka alone, you can easily speak about Hinduism as a kannadiga.. yes, rest of the south india, especially in Tamil Nadu, it needs lots of courage to do this. Kudos to Annamalai ji too