It seems the show has not provided the required make up to Mahua Moitra and the face looks tired , but Her oratory and argument are brilliant to cover the technical shortcoming.
@@anitajohns4178 We don't need either of them. Both are light upstairs and have never experienced poverty to understand the common people's suffering. Mahua was recently flaunting her Louis Vuitton bag in the parliament to show her class :-)
@@abdullahalfaruquemullick9048 lol.....lol...lol true that brother.....Mahua spells class and flair for the intelligent pretty lady she is....bless her.
@@mrityunjaybanerjee2150 yes it does make a difference because everyone knows that supporters of BJP/RSS blindly follow their leaders & never apply their mind for example at the peak of Covid 19 Bengal BJP president Dillip Ghosh said Covid 19 left India & blind followers like you were clapping.
What's beautiful about this or most interviews, when the interviewer keeps interrupting, over-speaking or putting words into the mouth of the interviewee. Ms Mahua has to constantly request to be allowed to complete what she's saying..and sometimes she says that before she begins her reply..many times and today particularly, she makes an outright point stating that his interruptions i interfere with her train of thought.
Yes she should have been allowed to speak what she had taken time to rehearse.... As usual making no sense . No genuine concern. Just trying to be in news..
Bilkis Bano said;;“on August 15, 2022, the trauma of the past 20 years washed over me again. When I heard that the 11 convicted men who devastated my family and my life, and took from me my three-year-old daughter, had walked free. I was bereft of words. I am still numb. Today, I can only say this - how can justice for any woman end like this? I trusted the highest courts in our land. I trusted the system, and I was slowly learning to live with my trauma. The release of these convicts has taken from me my peace and shaken my faith in justice. My sorrow and my wavering faith is not for myself alone but for every woman who is struggling for justice in the courts. No one enquired about my safety and well-being before taking such a big and unjust decision. I appeal to the Gujarat government, please undo this harm. Give me back my right to live without fear and in peace. Please ensure that my family and I are kept safe.”
You know Karan is unbiased because he always gets into a fistfight with every guest no matter which side of the political/economic spectrum they're from.
Bollywood actresses & cricketers who were outraged & tweeted about an elephant & BLM, will not say a word on this as convicted rapists go free and are being garlanded by VHP on the same day PM said respect women from Laal Kila. The same people (including many celebrities) who celebrated the extra-judicial killing of accused rapists in Hyderabad (which SC inquiry called flawed & staged later) have suddenly gone quite today as convicted rapists & murderers are set free by a BJP State government through remission, which was decided by a panel consisting of 5 BJP members out of 10 I wonder if those people garlanding the rapists, will let them live next to their homes near their mothers, sisters and kids?
@@bw8026 idiot stop bringing religion into this as scapegoat. R u dumb most Hindu woman r rapist by Hindu men. It's not about any religion rapist's & murderer's should b hanged to death or should punished in public like in Arab countries. R u not ashamed to see rapist's & murderer's r celebrated as heros.
@@bw8026 according to you if a Muslim rape a Hindu is crime. But a Hindu raping a Hindu girl is not a crime. How pathetic & cheap ur mindset. Check the stats more rape is committed by the person belonging to the same religion. R u blind or hiding behind Ur sanghis while it was happening
I am with you, but I don't see why someone cannot be outraged about an Elephant. This primacy to human life is stupid, especially if the animal is already on the brink!
If this case wasn't referred initially to Maharastra highcourt, its all 11 criminals might not have been punished for lifetime imprisonment at the end of the trial, which might have even gone for much longer delays to justice in the Gujarat highcourt rather than in Maharashtra highcourt, due to Gujurat state government and the central government interferences, as has been seen in the criminals present release process ?
@@abbasabdeali3239 I don't know how to love Gujarat and how to love Gujaratis. Are they very different different from other Indians. Or it only because of two Gujarati's at centre and two only gujarati business men. Very pathetic
Absolutely.if these 11 criminals were not punished.then they all would have Bern in various positions of this government. ATLEAST.THEY WOULD HAVE BEEN APPOINTED AS GOVERNORS IN OPPOSITION PARTY RULED STATES IN THE COUNTRY TODAY.!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! WHAT A DISASTROUS....IS AVOIDED.!!
As per the 'World Inequality Report 2022'. India is among the most unequal countries in the world, with rising poverty and an affluent elite.' The report highlights that the top 10% and the top 1% in India hold 57% and 22% of the total national income respectively while the bottom 50% share has gone down to 13%. The report was authored by Lucas Chancel and co-ordinated by renowened economist Thomas Piketty, Emmnuel Saez and Gabriel Zucham.
@@smitamishra1460 just the fact that Ambani and Adani together have wealth greater than 50% of all Indians combined in last 8 years gives a good idea about the wealth disparity. Nowhere in the world such phenomenon exists.
Appreciate TheWIRE getting Karan Thappar & miss Moitra together to debate n discuss the TOPIC which every concerned Indian today is questioning. Justice delivered Rightlyfully is reversed in such a horrendous manner.Every right thinking citizen should support people like Moitra & Suhasini Ali for standing up to support Bilkis in her moment of shock & Suffering & all oppressed Women voiceless out there suffering day in & day out. Moitra's point 'NATURAL JUSTICE DEFEATED' in the debate is the Essence!
The interview is very much meaningful to the present socio- political scenario. Independent India never seen such a corrupted and hypocritical character as the state leaders before!
It's a pleasant surprise 😊 wasn't expecting the interview with bravest woman parliamentarian ⭐ Mahua looks a challenge in the eye & gives it a wink ! Kind heart, fierce mind & brave spirit.
It’s heartening to note Madam Mahua Moitra’s brilliant analysis of Bilkis Banu’s rape convicts release case. I request Sri Karan Thapar not to interrupt when she was so brilliantly responding to his well thought of questions
I completely agree. Karan Tapar seems to continuously cut her while asking her to let him finish. The last interview he wasted time talking about her cooking skills. Time Mr Tapar recognises he needs to recognise his actions as being sexist. This is because I am yet to see his line of questioning to any other Male in this manner.
As a CM he said hum paanch hamare pachis. Relief camps are Child production factory. That individual is expressing anxiety at the plight of women. I am just enamoured at the wisdom of the individual. Oh sorry also said 50 crore girlfriend. The respect for women is just phenomenal
Hahaha!!! What ever our Prime Minister says from Redfort is not a policy..nothing for implementation.Its just the one who writes his speech.adds to his taste......!!!!
Wonder why Karan was getting impatient on multiple occasions.!! As Mahua said.if the petition were on procedures of the Supreme Court to be contested.the whole issue would have been different and out of focus the misogynist approach of the Gujarath government.
Within just 5 minutes of the debate, it became clear that the timing of conducting this debate was wrong. Let the petition and the hearing first finish...otherwise she cannot talk about many aspects which Karan is persistently raising.
I have great respect and admiration for Mahua Moitra. She handled this interview so well. Despite Karan repeatedly asking her questions that she is not allowed to comment on being a petitioner to the Supreme Court. She did not succumb to the pressure. However, stated her points clearly and bodly. Amazing articulation of thoughts and presentation of views and facts. I pray that your petion is successful and these people who were released be sent back to jail. For clearly they do not repent for their crime. If they did, they would not have accepted the falicitation. Such shameless beasts!!!
Karan seemed to be stressing the questionability of Mahua Moitra 's confidence a bit unusually and unnecessarily. But the lady stood rock solid in her response. She gave a well nuanced cautious explanation of her intention. Here, more than anywhere, she looked more matured by being untempted towards any kind of high sounding rhetorics. Thanks to the total outcome.
Excellent interview. Ms Moitra, exceptionally bright and steadfast, as always. Karan, you must not try to put words in the mouth of interviewee. Only strong personalities like Ms Moitra can fight against that.
As she said bilkis has fought already for justice now it's our time to fight for her as a woman as an Indian. Mahua Moitra true inspiration for younger generation. This is how a women should be represented. Its a shame that ruling government doesn't speak a word about this case. And we don't even expect anymore from them. It's better that their mouth are shut. But i really hope that with this repetition of yours bilkis gets justice. And we can restore faith in our judiciary. More power to you Mahua Moitra
Absolutely Sir. Are these all happening in our country or in some Authoritarian.kingdom.????? Are we any way better than Afghanisthan.or such countries.???
Sir lord Rama is a Hindu but Ravan is hindu that too Brahmin too..... being good or bad doesn't have anything to do wd any religion....this is mere politics to the core....nonhindus are the ikka of some political parties... until they r there..... winning an election is like cake walk.... nobody would ever question them....
Applaud Mahua's calm and measured articulation of this outrageous decision. No words to describe the level of illegality and non application of any thought or empathy on the part of the Gujarat Government and the Centre. Their insensitivity and shamelessness is on display for everyone to see.
It's really inspiring to see this outspoken lady all out to bring justice . Thank you Madam .May God gives you strength to stand up to this difficult times Best Regards
Very interesting interview. Both were great, but Mahua did not fall into the trap of criticizing the judiciary till the outcome of the the judgement, but attacked the executive.
Very precisely.we avoided all such questions.. she says.such questions at this time will be a disservice to Bilkis Banu....She reserves her right to question on the same ground also.but not for the time being.
Good luck Mahua, going by the developments today, wherein the Supreme Court has declared as closed all cases pertaining to the Godhra riots in 2002, one can only speculate as to which direction the entire set of arguments will take the petitioner to. We are witnessing the near collapse of humanity, reason, logic and arguments based on evidence- we are witnessing a brazenness not known in the judiciary so far especially with regard to previous regimes right from Independence till May 2014. This bulldozing of justice by the high court and the Supreme Court is now a given, with judges summarily dismissing cases as being unworthy of a relook especially in cases where a grave miscarriage of justice has occurred at the lower levels.This means that the citizens of the land have no recourse to justice at the hands of the judiciary, which was the last bastion of hope for the common citizens of the country. We have reached a situation where collusive chicanery by the black robed fraternity are a given and where no hope can be entertained by the common folk in India.
Great debate Karan Sir. "Sometimes an angel, sometimes a hellraiser, always a strong woman. Champions keep playing till they get it right". Love you Mahua Moitra🌺 keep up a good fight. ✌️
Initially , there was a suspicious mind at one side and a confident mind the other side, both were very right on their part..it was an outstanding ,it's always a pleasure to watch people who swim against the tides..👍
You think CJIs give interviews..sorry sir..they go straight to a wonderful life or a better post with more comforts..Justice Gogoi in RS, UU Lalit from PP to CJI..
Good Interview. But at some point it was confusing as to who is actually being interviewed. Karan, though one of my favourites, may consider exercising restrain and not showcase his knowledge while interviewing a guest, since that's not the purpose. Let the interviewee speak his or her mind.
Rape convicted accusd shouldn't been realeased though Completed 14 years or so on. accusd must be given capital punishment. Only then they will afraid of laws.
Karan was very logical as always - spot on with his arguments and questioning! Mahua was sorrily defensive for a change. Unfortunately, Karan wins logically. It's sad. Not the outcome one wishes for but all indicators are that this case will not find its due justice. Tragic travesty of justice for the whole of India. Justice Rastogi's comment is highly disturbing. If something like this were to happen to Justice Rastogi's family, would he still say the same? Anyway, this is where Mahua loses the argument. Either she's not comprehending Karan fully (which is doubtful) or is consciously or subconsciously refusing to comprehend the point as she has a stake in the case - for justice of course. Good luck Ms. Mahua... but like Karan, I have not much hope.
It's really very interesting to see 2 of you ...thanks Karen for some direct questions as a citizen we are feeling sad about our judiciary. Even Mohua can't answers but still there is some like u raising the questions , is very very important .
Stand corrected please.. It is not that 'Even Mahua Moira' cannot answer ...she CHOSE NOT TO ANSWER.. as it pertained to stating or commenting about the Supreme Court.
Karan U r Very logical. 1. Please give subtitles in Hindi or translate as a separate Hindi wire article. 2 You are right to say that for Gujarat government there is a conflict of interest in deciding clemency. It is Not only immoral but against the principles of natural justice. Reason being SC itself shifted case to gujrat. Even centre can't decide it because PM of the day is erstwhile CM of Gujarat 2002 . Using power conferred by another article ( which gives immense Power to SC ) of constitution SC MUST CONSTITUTE A CLEMENCY COMMITTEE OF EXECUTIVE WHICH HAVE no conflict of interest Or a unique committee comprising of congress government,aap and tmc etc as per a report several civil servants questioned the sc ruling that let the remission be done within 2 months.
the Supari court completely done this unethical manner by sending the remission decision to Gujjarath, because the same govt which didn't lost the faith in trial is only in power now also.
Mr.Karan Thapar you were excellent as usual,and hats off to you,it's not the legality which is more important as Mrs. Mahao was speaking about but it's all about the horrific, horrendous act committed by those rascals. There could be no question of remission to such acts ,and Supreme court should have not allowed this in the first place considering the disastrous act.
👍🏼🙏🏼 Grateful and a big thank you to Mohua Moitra for filing FIR, wish we have more of your kind to fight fascism... Smriti Irani and all other supporters, protectors and justifiers of criminals should keep themselves and their daughters in place of Bilkis Bano and think 😠
More public representatives we have like M M we the people of India will have better legislation and execution of law. Justice must prevail, if not challenged by an elected representative, duty and moral responsibility. 👏
It is whether DUE PROCESS of LAW has been maintained in this reprehensible crime, not just whether JUSTICE has been meted out to the aggrieved Ms.Bilkis Bano. To my mind, the provision of providing REMISSION for murderers sentenced for CAPITAL CRIMES after serving 14 years is itself questionable, not only because it sets legal precedents, but more significantly, it makes criminals ,innocent of all crimes after 14 years. While there are indeed political overtures, the fact that this remission was done hastily, and without proper consultations with superior officials, manifests, in no uncertain terms, that this a GROSS TRAVERSITY of law and its application while dealing with Capital CRIMES.
I guess Thapar must listen to the guest particularly when it comes to Constitutional provision.. Respect to him over other issues but in a fit to criticise judiciary he's definitely going out of way even with no proper arguments..
Karan is right.there are reasons other than Mahua quoted for challenging remission.attacking Executive only.but..the sharpest weapon is employed first.
Karan a beautiful big fight of an interview. It's particularly more interesting when you have a firebrand of a lady as your opponent. Mahua is too mature and intelligent to take your bait on Supreme Court. I personally feel that it's a little unfair to ask her to comment on Supreme Court. After all, if we can't trust the highest court of the land, where do we go from there? Though that being said, I am not for once suggesting that the apex court is always right. A wonderful interview none the less. Keep up the good work sir.
NO ONE , i repeat, NO ONE, can over-ride Mahua Moitra.or tempt her with a Wrong bait. She is as you mentioned, very intelligent, mature, strong, does her homework thoroughly before she gets into a debate, and No One, not even Karan, can put words in her mouth, like he does with most of his interviewees. She is a fire-brand, and knows when and with whom she needs to be that fire-brand.
We should do our duty in good sense to continue according to our conscience....results are in the hand of Almighty.....nothing to worry about. Thank you genius sir and madam...thank u everybody. Do good and feel good. This is the gist of all humanity. Iswar hamey subuddhy dey...savika sath dey.
Initially I was bit confused why she was stopping Karan from pointing fingers at the court about things it did or didn't do. His points sounded right. Then I realised that she is protecting her interests as a petitioner by making sure that she doesn't become part of a discussion criticising the court. Smart lady..! Spoke like a seasoned lawyer...
Mahua is the Best Speaker & MP among women leaders.
She is an Educated & Admin. Background.
But highly corrupted women
Yep and Supriya Sule too
She is selective on her cases.
And sells fish in Parliament 😆
Thank you dear Manjit Bedi.Begu chesthundi 👍👍
Mahua's mental clarity is awesome 👍 Need more women like her in public domain
Mahua Moitra has once again given us a GEM of an interview. You have given us hope in the present times. Keep it up!
Hats off Mahua Moitra, huge respect!
It seems the show has not provided the required make up to Mahua Moitra and the face looks tired , but
Her oratory and argument are brilliant to cover the technical shortcoming.
What a wonderful woman.!!!!!!! I would touch her feet.if at all I get a chance to meet her in my remaining life.!
I love her words and we need more ladies in the Parlament !!
We need more ladies, like Mahua Moitra in Parliament, not like the type who howl and yell over nonsense, like s. Irani
@@anitajohns4178 We don't need either of them. Both are light upstairs and have never experienced poverty to understand the common people's suffering. Mahua was recently flaunting her Louis Vuitton bag in the parliament to show her class :-)
@@johnalter1116 mahua was flaunting LV what she brought by her own earned money unlike some camerajivi....
@@abdullahalfaruquemullick9048 lol.....lol...lol true that brother.....Mahua spells class and flair for the intelligent pretty lady she is....bless her.
India has a huge TALENT. Due to slogans like Har har MODI the talent is attempted to be Killed
yes she is absolutely right the way the convicts were felicitated suggest that rape & murder have been normalised.
Nobody has normalized rape, extortion, bribery like TMC.
@@1008apocalypse1008 you are BJP supporter
@@1008apocalypse1008 At least they are not awarding rapists with flowers and congratulate them as "Bramhin,....But you fuckers do that without shame
@@Raju2D truth is truth bro, does it make any difference she/he is bjp supporter or not?
@@mrityunjaybanerjee2150 yes it does make a difference because everyone knows that supporters of BJP/RSS blindly follow their leaders & never apply their mind for example at the peak of Covid 19 Bengal BJP president Dillip Ghosh said Covid 19 left India & blind followers like you were clapping.
Unparalleled Mahua, keep it up
It's a real treat to watch both these intelligent forthright individuals 🙏🏼👍🏼🇮🇳... thank you so much Wire for this beautiful interview
What's beautiful about this or most interviews, when the interviewer keeps interrupting, over-speaking or putting words into the mouth of the interviewee.
Ms Mahua has to constantly request to be allowed to complete what she's saying..and sometimes she says that before she begins her reply..many times and today particularly, she makes an outright point stating that his interruptions i interfere with her train of thought.
@@kayadreads13 yes but inspite of the interruptions the conversation was substantial and well executed! That's truly amazing.
Yes she should have been allowed to speak what she had taken time to rehearse.... As usual making no sense . No genuine concern. Just trying to be in news..
@@kayadreads13 Well said
"One assumes that the Prime Minister is not a hypocrite" said Karan. HAHAHA Biggest joke of the year.
Absolutely. THE EMPEROR IS NAKED
HE MUST HAVE GIVEN CONSENT TO THE WHOLE EPISODE OF REMISSION
.OR was it decided at Nagpur Headqusrters itself.!!!!
What a statement from mr.thapar!
Bilkis Bano said;;“on August 15, 2022, the trauma of the past 20 years washed over me again. When I heard that the 11 convicted men who devastated my family and my life, and took from me my three-year-old daughter, had walked free. I was bereft of words. I am still numb.
Today, I can only say this - how can justice for any woman end like this? I trusted the highest courts in our land. I trusted the system, and I was slowly learning to live with my trauma. The release of these convicts has taken from me my peace and shaken my faith in justice. My sorrow and my wavering faith is not for myself alone but for every woman who is struggling for justice in the courts.
No one enquired about my safety and well-being before taking such a big and unjust decision.
I appeal to the Gujarat government, please undo this harm. Give me back my right to live without fear and in peace. Please ensure that my family and I are kept safe.”
You know Karan is unbiased because he always gets into a fistfight with every guest no matter which side of the political/economic spectrum they're from.
Bollywood actresses & cricketers who were outraged & tweeted about an elephant & BLM, will not say a word on this as convicted rapists go free and are being garlanded by VHP on the same day PM said respect women from Laal Kila.
The same people (including many celebrities) who celebrated the extra-judicial killing of accused rapists in Hyderabad (which SC inquiry called flawed & staged later) have suddenly gone quite today as convicted rapists & murderers are set free by a BJP State government through remission, which was decided by a panel consisting of 5 BJP members out of 10
I wonder if those people garlanding the rapists, will let them live next to their homes near their mothers, sisters and kids?
💯 true. More shocking & frightening than the rapist's & murderer's r those who celebrated them as heros.
Did anytime The Wire report on Hindu girls being killed by Muslim boys?
@@bw8026 idiot stop bringing religion into this as scapegoat. R u dumb most Hindu woman r rapist by Hindu men.
It's not about any religion rapist's & murderer's should b hanged to death or should punished in public like in Arab countries.
R u not ashamed to see rapist's & murderer's r celebrated as heros.
@@bw8026 according to you if a Muslim rape a Hindu is crime. But a Hindu raping a Hindu girl is not a crime. How pathetic & cheap ur mindset. Check the stats more rape is committed by the person belonging to the same religion. R u blind or hiding behind Ur sanghis while it was happening
I am with you, but I don't see why someone cannot be outraged about an Elephant. This primacy to human life is stupid, especially if the animal is already on the brink!
Most exciting, interesting and educating interview on Karan Thapar Forum. Best wishes Mahua and Karan.
If this case wasn't referred initially to Maharastra highcourt, its all 11 criminals might not have been punished for lifetime imprisonment at the end of the trial, which might have even gone for much longer delays to justice in the Gujarat highcourt rather than in Maharashtra highcourt, due to Gujurat state government and the central government interferences, as has been seen in the criminals present release process ?
Pathetic state of gujrati judiciary in my opinion...especially for my community sadly...we're 2nd class people there.
@@abbasabdeali3239 I don't know how to love Gujarat and how to love Gujaratis. Are they very different different from other Indians. Or it only because of two Gujarati's at centre and two only gujarati business men. Very pathetic
@@abbasabdeali3239 terrorists religion has no class they are like 🐖⚰️🐷🤔
Absolutely.if these 11 criminals were not punished.then they all would have Bern in various positions of this government.
ATLEAST.THEY WOULD HAVE BEEN APPOINTED AS GOVERNORS IN OPPOSITION PARTY RULED STATES IN THE COUNTRY TODAY.!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
WHAT A DISASTROUS....IS AVOIDED.!!
justice should be seen to be done. this type of remission order spoils the judicial system and judiciary
Justce should be seen to be done and not only Talking Narrative and Slogan Narrative of that already old man Modi 71. Disgusting ????!
It's already spoiled to the core.... Don't have Blind faith on Judicial system.
To whom are we talking sir..??? The very judiciary...the pillar to safeguard the individuals legal rights.????????
Receiving by putting garlands and sweets as if they came after winning a war ! Where r we heading ?
@@jayantisenapati9078 Heading towards a disasterous future India.
Great I like mahua Mitra such people should come forward to rule 🇮🇳
💪💪💪🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🗽🗽🗽
As per the 'World Inequality Report 2022'. India is among the most unequal countries in the world, with rising poverty and an affluent elite.'
The report highlights that the top 10% and the top 1% in India hold 57% and 22% of the total national income respectively while the bottom 50% share has gone down to 13%. The report was authored by Lucas Chancel and co-ordinated by renowened economist Thomas Piketty, Emmnuel Saez and Gabriel Zucham.
Can you send me this report please.
@@smitamishra1460 Kindly Google It PDF Available
@@smitamishra1460 just the fact that Ambani and Adani together have wealth greater than 50% of all Indians combined in last 8 years gives a good idea about the wealth disparity. Nowhere in the world such phenomenon exists.
Mahua Moitra is a lady who speaks with conviction and courage. We need leaders like her.
Whenever I see. Mr .Karan Thapar , reminds me of. That famous interview. Of Modi. , dosti bani rahe . 😀😂😂
I ALSO WILL ALWAYS REMEMBER THE INTERVIEW OF KARAN THAPAR WITH MODI.
💯👍
That bagoda still checkouts first if karan thapar is somewhere in close vicinity b4 visiting any place to do poltical propoganda .
Hahaaaa... Even I Miss That Interview
OMG56"5G cried. Very funny to watch. 😂😂😂
Appreciate TheWIRE getting Karan Thappar & miss Moitra together to debate n discuss the TOPIC which every concerned Indian today is questioning. Justice delivered Rightlyfully is reversed in such a horrendous manner.Every right thinking citizen should support people like Moitra & Suhasini Ali for standing up to support Bilkis in her moment of shock & Suffering & all oppressed Women voiceless out there suffering day in & day out. Moitra's point 'NATURAL JUSTICE DEFEATED' in the debate is the Essence!
0⁰⁰p⁰
Agreed...admirable expression by Mahua madam,of the sorry state of normalisation of heinous crimes against women in the state of the ruling tyranny.
Educated intelligent and erudite lawyer madam moitra:)
The interview is very much meaningful to the present socio- political scenario. Independent India never seen such a corrupted and hypocritical character as the state leaders before!
@@whiteboard4963 jaa choos le uska 😂
Imagine letting go such heinous criminals to WIN A STATE ELECTION(Gujarat).
BJP can stoop to lows one cannot fathom.
Ya there existence is with Muhammad [SAW], Islam , talking flith about Auliya Allah & Mugals.
It's a pleasant surprise 😊 wasn't expecting the interview with bravest woman parliamentarian ⭐ Mahua looks a challenge in the eye & gives it a wink !
Kind heart, fierce mind & brave spirit.
Great work.. keep doing👍🏻
Oh both of my favorites and far most regarded people.. thank you wire for such treats
Sar tan se juda is my favourite
@@1008apocalypse1008 this shows you upbringing. And atmosphere of your home
@@RakeshGupta-qu9yj Still better than baby Ayesha!
@@1008apocalypse1008 ankita ...no no....bilkis..yes yes...modern secular india !
Way to go, Mahua! Don't let Karan Thapar intimidate you. You made your point correctly and strongly. Proud of you.
Mahua mitra such an outstanding leader.
Thanks for the session. It’s a pleasure to listen both of you.
It’s heartening to note Madam Mahua Moitra’s brilliant analysis of Bilkis Banu’s rape convicts release case. I request Sri Karan Thapar not to interrupt when she was so brilliantly responding to his well thought of questions
I completely agree. Karan Tapar seems to continuously cut her while asking her to let him finish. The last interview he wasted time talking about her cooking skills. Time Mr Tapar recognises he needs to recognise his actions as being sexist. This is because I am yet to see his line of questioning to any other Male in this manner.
As a CM he said hum paanch hamare pachis. Relief camps are Child production factory. That individual is expressing anxiety at the plight of women. I am just enamoured at the wisdom of the individual. Oh sorry also said 50 crore girlfriend. The respect for women is just phenomenal
I remember watching that clip but now the clip has disappeared from the Internet
Hahaha!!! What ever our Prime Minister says from Redfort is not a policy..nothing for implementation.Its just the one who writes his speech.adds to his taste......!!!!
Appreciate the clarity with which every moot point was made without compromising Mahua's petition.
Absolutely amazing conversation
Wonder why Karan was getting impatient on multiple occasions.!! As Mahua said.if the petition were on procedures of the Supreme Court to be contested.the whole issue would have been different and out of focus the misogynist approach of the Gujarath government.
Brilliant! Thank you so much!
Within just 5 minutes of the debate, it became clear that the timing of conducting this debate was wrong. Let the petition and the hearing first finish...otherwise she cannot talk about many aspects which Karan is persistently raising.
I have great respect and admiration for Mahua Moitra. She handled this interview so well. Despite Karan repeatedly asking her questions that she is not allowed to comment on being a petitioner to the Supreme Court. She did not succumb to the pressure. However, stated her points clearly and bodly. Amazing articulation of thoughts and presentation of views and facts. I pray that your petion is successful and these people who were released be sent back to jail. For clearly they do not repent for their crime. If they did, they would not have accepted the falicitation. Such shameless beasts!!!
Remission case before SC will proved whether Judiciary is Independent or not.
Also the confidence of MM on the SC is right or wrong
@@wahidsaifudeen1651 Right
Very true
Karan seemed to be stressing the questionability of Mahua Moitra 's confidence a bit unusually and unnecessarily. But the lady stood rock solid in her response. She gave a well nuanced cautious explanation of her intention. Here, more than anywhere, she looked more matured by being untempted towards any kind of high sounding rhetorics. Thanks to the total outcome.
Truly a great interview. Kudos to Mr Thapar
As always wire is doing great work and serving Indian People with their sheer brilliance and dedication .. thank you Wire Team 🙏🏼
secular ...pro muslim...will keep mum on ankita.....gajab !
Tmc workers literally raped bjp voter woman after they won election
Excellent interview. Ms Moitra, exceptionally bright and steadfast, as always.
Karan, you must not try to put words in the mouth of interviewee. Only strong personalities like Ms Moitra can fight against that.
Thank you Karan and Mahua reminding of a civilized India
You really enjoy the interview when you have great personalities.
For the past two years i am seeing your programs .I appreciate your courage.
Great to hear from both two great people,fantastic interview 👍
Thanks!
As she said bilkis has fought already for justice now it's our time to fight for her as a woman as an Indian. Mahua Moitra true inspiration for younger generation. This is how a women should be represented. Its a shame that ruling government doesn't speak a word about this case. And we don't even expect anymore from them. It's better that their mouth are shut. But i really hope that with this repetition of yours bilkis gets justice. And we can restore faith in our judiciary. More power to you Mahua Moitra
Wow This Is One Of The Excellent Interview On A Criminal Case. Let's Wait For The Outcome On The Hearing.
The interview I was waiting for
The crimes against humanity are nothing if you do crime against certain community and the convicts are supported by certain political party. #NewIndia
But still. Swalpamapyasya Dharmasya Trayate Mahato Bhayat Bhagavadgita, still applicable and Works
Absolutely Sir.
Are these all happening in our country or in some Authoritarian.kingdom.????? Are we any way better than Afghanisthan.or such countries.???
Sir lord Rama is a Hindu but Ravan is hindu that too Brahmin too..... being good or bad doesn't have anything to do wd any religion....this is mere politics to the core....nonhindus are the ikka of some political parties... until they r there..... winning an election is like cake walk.... nobody would ever question them....
Applaud Mahua's calm and measured articulation of this outrageous decision. No words to describe the level of illegality and non application of any thought or empathy on the part of the Gujarat Government and the Centre. Their insensitivity and shamelessness is on display for everyone to see.
Over founding father's hopes are succeeding in throughMahus sunrise🎉🎉...
why Mr. Modi remains silent on all such issues...waise jitna marzi nonsense cheezo pe non stop baat karwalo
It's really inspiring to see this outspoken lady all out to bring justice .
Thank you Madam .May God gives you strength to stand up to this difficult times
Best Regards
Very interesting interview. Both were great, but Mahua did not fall into the trap of criticizing the judiciary till the outcome of the the judgement, but attacked the executive.
She is an intelligent woman
Very precisely.we avoided all such questions.. she says.such questions at this time will be a disservice to Bilkis Banu....She reserves her right to question on the same ground also.but not for the time being.
How can we say Central Govt. doesn't know about remission ? If it's so than it should be revoked.
Bilkis Banu should get justice.
Two eloquent, educated, brilliant people conversing. What a pleasure to hear them.😊
It was not actually pleasure to hear...the blood was boiling....Where are we heading.!!!!!
Karan Thapar is marvelous. 🙏👌
Good luck Mahua, going by the developments today, wherein the Supreme Court has declared as closed all cases pertaining to the Godhra riots in 2002, one can only speculate as to which direction the entire set of arguments will take the petitioner to. We are witnessing the near collapse of humanity, reason, logic and arguments based on evidence- we are witnessing a brazenness not known in the judiciary so far especially with regard to previous regimes right from Independence till May 2014. This bulldozing of justice by the high court and the Supreme Court is now a given, with judges summarily dismissing cases as being unworthy of a relook especially in cases where a grave miscarriage of justice has occurred at the lower levels.This means that the citizens of the land have no recourse to justice at the hands of the judiciary, which was the last bastion of hope for the common citizens of the country. We have reached a situation where collusive chicanery by the black robed fraternity are a given and where no hope can be entertained by the common folk in India.
Great debate Karan Sir. "Sometimes an angel, sometimes a hellraiser, always a strong woman. Champions keep playing till they get it right". Love you Mahua Moitra🌺 keep up a good fight. ✌️
Initially , there was a suspicious mind at one side and a confident mind the other side, both were very right on their part..it was an outstanding ,it's always a pleasure to watch people who swim against the tides..👍
What is the 'tide'?
Thanks to both of you
Salute for such a bold journalism.
You are referring to Ms M Mahua i hope
Yes i am referring to both, Karan as well as Mahua Madam, i again salute both of them.
Superb discussion superb thoughts by superb fearless lady Mahua moitra ma'am ji namaste and salute 🙏
Why Mr Karan Thapar has not interviewed Chief Justices for the judgments given in the last eight years?
You think CJIs give interviews..sorry sir..they go straight to a wonderful life or a better post with more comforts..Justice Gogoi in RS, UU Lalit from PP to CJI..
@@vaibhavvnaik Exactly even Srinivasan Jain brought down Gogoi in one interview. Thapar will blow them up
@@sarsonsar0 🎯🎯🎯
Mahua Moitra is the real deal.
Good Interview. But at some point it was confusing as to who is actually being interviewed. Karan, though one of my favourites, may consider exercising restrain and not showcase his knowledge while interviewing a guest, since that's not the purpose. Let the interviewee speak his or her mind.
You said it out Loud and Clear. I agree with you 100+% on that.
What a great feeling to find two great minds discussing such a burning topic,wish to see you discussing the Ankita case next.
ankita case is sad but not rarest of rare.chk number of women crimes happng everyday in india.u want discussn on all of them?
Ye nahi karega mullo ka dalla jo hai
@@sagaronline265 achha tere hisab se sirf mullo ka hi case rarest of rare hai
@@pawankumar-ev8xn 2014 se toh yehi dekne mein aaya.tumko kuch aur maalum ho toh link dho yahan.
Rape convicted accusd shouldn't been realeased though Completed 14 years or so on. accusd must be given capital punishment. Only then they will afraid of laws.
They are convicted and conviction upheld in the HC; not simply accused.
Thanks karan thapar for this great interview.
Karan was very logical as always - spot on with his arguments and questioning! Mahua was sorrily defensive for a change. Unfortunately, Karan wins logically. It's sad. Not the outcome one wishes for but all indicators are that this case will not find its due justice. Tragic travesty of justice for the whole of India. Justice Rastogi's comment is highly disturbing. If something like this were to happen to Justice Rastogi's family, would he still say the same? Anyway, this is where Mahua loses the argument. Either she's not comprehending Karan fully (which is doubtful) or is consciously or subconsciously refusing to comprehend the point as she has a stake in the case - for justice of course. Good luck Ms. Mahua... but like Karan, I have not much hope.
Ma'am, you are strong lady I really appreciate! ✨
Well said Moitra. U sre always write. I salute your boldness.
Executives do politics first so Ms Mitra doesnt agree on callous judiciary as Mr Thapar bent upon.
It's really very interesting to see 2 of you ...thanks Karen for some direct questions as a citizen we are feeling sad about our judiciary. Even Mohua can't answers but still there is some like u raising the questions , is very very important .
Stand corrected please..
It is not that 'Even Mahua Moira' cannot answer ...she CHOSE NOT TO ANSWER.. as it pertained to stating or commenting about the Supreme Court.
Karan
U r Very logical.
1. Please give subtitles in Hindi or translate as a separate Hindi wire article.
2 You are right to say that for Gujarat government there is a conflict of interest in deciding clemency. It is Not only immoral but against the principles of natural justice. Reason being SC itself shifted case to gujrat.
Even centre can't decide it because PM of the day is erstwhile CM of Gujarat 2002 .
Using power conferred by another article ( which gives immense Power to SC ) of constitution SC
MUST CONSTITUTE A CLEMENCY COMMITTEE OF EXECUTIVE WHICH HAVE no conflict of interest
Or a unique committee comprising of congress government,aap and tmc etc
as per a report several civil servants questioned the sc ruling that let the remission be done within 2 months.
If one BJP MP or MLA speaks with this clarity, knowledge & conviction.. I will vote them. Just one ❗️
the Supari court completely done this unethical manner by sending the remission decision to Gujjarath, because the same govt which didn't lost the faith in trial is only in power now also.
Mr.Karan Thapar you were excellent as usual,and hats off to you,it's not the legality which is more important as Mrs. Mahao was speaking about but it's all about the horrific, horrendous act committed by those rascals.
There could be no question of remission to such acts ,and Supreme court should have not allowed this in the first place considering the disastrous act.
Thank you for discussing the core issues.
Karan: In this interview you are not listening. You seem to speak too much yourself without allowing her to speak.
Excellent episode.. Thankful to wire team ..
👍🏼🙏🏼 Grateful and a big thank you to Mohua Moitra for filing FIR, wish we have more of your kind to fight fascism...
Smriti Irani and all other supporters, protectors and justifiers of criminals should keep themselves and their daughters in place of Bilkis Bano and think 😠
Karan thapar ..mahua ...great outspoken fearless persons.. Hope they don't change. Ive stopped trusting all..
Great Karan Thapar!
He is a neutral journalist not control by any political party.
More public representatives we have like M M we the people of India will have better legislation and execution of law.
Justice must prevail, if not challenged by an elected representative, duty and moral responsibility. 👏
I think ur community like owaise more
Sar tan se juda wale log justice ki baat karte hai to hassi ate hai 😂😂🤣🤣
Nice to see you here Mahua!
Great to watch strong individual in their respective realm engaging in very serious matter.
It is whether DUE PROCESS of LAW has been maintained in this reprehensible crime, not just whether JUSTICE has been meted out to the aggrieved Ms.Bilkis Bano.
To my mind, the provision of providing REMISSION for murderers sentenced for CAPITAL CRIMES after serving 14 years is itself questionable, not only because it sets legal precedents, but more significantly, it makes criminals ,innocent of all crimes after 14 years.
While there are indeed political overtures, the fact that this remission was done hastily, and without proper consultations with superior officials, manifests, in no uncertain terms, that this a GROSS TRAVERSITY of law and its application while dealing with Capital CRIMES.
I guess Thapar must listen to the guest particularly when it comes to Constitutional provision.. Respect to him over other issues but in a fit to criticise judiciary he's definitely going out of way even with no proper arguments..
Karan is right.there are reasons other than Mahua quoted for challenging remission.attacking Executive only.but..the sharpest weapon is employed first.
Very informative. Very bold and valiant fight.
I so wished for her to be back!!!
Thanks!!!
Excellent interview. Highly thought provoking
Karan a beautiful big fight of an interview. It's particularly more interesting when you have a firebrand of a lady as your opponent. Mahua is too mature and intelligent to take your bait on Supreme Court. I personally feel that it's a little unfair to ask her to comment on Supreme Court. After all, if we can't trust the highest court of the land, where do we go from there? Though that being said, I am not for once suggesting that the apex court is always right. A wonderful interview none the less. Keep up the good work sir.
NO ONE , i repeat, NO ONE, can over-ride Mahua Moitra.or tempt her with a Wrong bait. She is as you mentioned, very intelligent, mature, strong, does her homework thoroughly before she gets into a debate, and No One, not even Karan, can put words in her mouth, like he does with most of his interviewees. She is a fire-brand, and knows when and with whom she needs to be that fire-brand.
We should do our duty in good sense to continue according to our conscience....results are in the hand of Almighty.....nothing to worry about. Thank you genius sir and madam...thank u everybody. Do good and feel good. This is the gist of all humanity. Iswar hamey subuddhy dey...savika sath dey.
Welldone MissMahuwa I appreciate you to rise your voice against to injustice
Pleasant to hear talk two rational and intelligent people, help bring all aspect.
Excellent interview. Both are well known intellectually.
Initially I was bit confused why she was stopping Karan from pointing fingers at the court about things it did or didn't do. His points sounded right. Then I realised that she is protecting her interests as a petitioner by making sure that she doesn't become part of a discussion criticising the court. Smart lady..! Spoke like a seasoned lawyer...
I LOVE both the Host & Guest
Best of #karanthapar
Brilliant, invincible
Highlight of the interview is when Karan says : I assume he isnt a hypocrite....
Amazing Mahua 👏🏽👏🏽