It amazes me that people talk about the helmet catch ALL THE TIME yet people HARDLY EVER talk about the fact that he caught it while being covered by RODNEY HARRISON. Rodney Harrison was one of the best safeties of his era and was FREAKING INTERLOCKING ARMS WITH THE DUDE WHILE HE WAS GLUING THE BALL TO HIS HELMET!!!!!
People forget that when he came down with the football the ball hits the ground while attached to his helmet that's an incomplete pass .....so yeah not a catch #patsnation lol
One of the things that makes the Helmet Catch so special is that it immortalised the name of an otherwise unknown receiver named David Tyree. The fact that it was done by someone who ISN'T a famous superstar makes it absolutely perfect!
I think my favorite part of the Tyree story iirc was he struggled in the practices the week prior. Just probably had one of the worst practices at WR they'd had under Coughlin to that point. So you could only imagine going into the game what they probably felt about his chances of making a play. For him to make the biggest play in arguably the biggest upset in NFL history? Yeah. Number 1.
I honestly love how every single player from the steelers they had talking about the immaculate reception all were on the same page with their answers. Fuqua sold me on it too. I say it is a catch, and no one is gonna tell Franco Harris otherwise
@@excaliferfootball5918 yeh, I can't remember the guys name at nfl films that is in charge of the UA-cam channel but they don't upload them all and Isaac takes the time to upload them so he has my respect and gratitude. Or do you mean he rips them from another UA-cam channel? Either way, hope you're good.
Marvin Harrison's one handed, deflection, end line toe tap touchdown while falling down against the Raiders in '01 should have for sure been on the list.
8:41 he does know Revis locked Moss for most of the game he had TWO catches for 38 yards. Yea that TD was 34 yards, but at the end of the day Revis won that game.
@@maryjoforrest1011 not to mention it was on a 3rd and 5 and literally one play before that Asante Samuel dropped a game winning interception. Idk how you don’t say that’s the greatest ever given those circumstances
I get Super Bowl winning catches but as far as historical significance “The Catch” Ended a dynasty and created a new dynasty between two hardcore rivals that’s why it should be #1
There are some amazing catches made by defenders that could have been on this list. Polamalu had at least 3 I can think of. Ed Reed and deion too. Also holmes should be #1 and clarks should be somewhere between 9-7.
People really on TV saying that Tyree's catch was all luck, no skill, when he's holding onto that ball for dear life against arguably the greatest safety in league history of all time Rodney Harrison.
I despise it when they say shit like that and I’m not even a Giants fan (I’m a Ravens fan). The worst part is when I hear the same people act like the Kearse catch was so much better and took only skill and there was no luck involved. Every NFL play has a bit of luck. If Too Tall Jones does not fall for Montana’s fake, then maybe he blocks the Catch before it is even possible, if the Patriots DB that jumped over Kearse knocked the ball away, then he never has a chance to catch it, if Big Ben is sacked then he could never get that throw to Holmes and I could go on. Yet, the Helmet Catch is constantly the target of the “more luck than skill” argument. A little luck should not take away from an all time great play and I still think all the catches I mentioned are all time great catches. Despite that, I would argue that the Helmet catch is actually the most impressive catch ever, one of the hardest hitters in NFL history draped all over him yanking him to the ground, for Tyree to have the strength in his fingers and presence of mind to just press it against his helmet in the Super Bowl, on third down against the undefeated Pats to save the game winning drive, best catch ever in my mind! I’d like to see anyone who calls that catch lucky try to pull it off!
Ok like your point is correct but Rodney Harrison was nowhere near as good as you hype him up to be lmao, also he was 35 at the time and only played 6 more games afterwards he wasn't even the best safety on that team lol
If there was that much skill involved in that catch then someone show me another Tyree catch where he showcases ANY of that skill he supposedly had. That catch was 99% luck.
I can't believe this doesn't have the Drew Pearson "Hail Mary", catch. It was literally created that second, and is still what we call airing it out on a go route, throw a Hail Mary.
NFL Films should rename their "Top Ten Super bowls of all time" into "Top Ten non-Patriots Super bowls of all time" because win or lose Bellichick-Brady Patriots almost guarantee a classic game like Super Bowl 36, 42, 49 and 51
With regards to Beckhams one handed catch, yes he had the gloves on, but if you look at the replays he used his 2 fingers and a thumb to catch it not looking at the ball with his arm behind his head. Sticky gloves may have helped, but it takes skill, strength and awareness to do it like he did... BTW Jerry Rice admitted to using stickem on his gloves... BTW as a Cardinals fan, #3 was a dagger to the heart. Because fans knew that was the only chance in our life time to see them with a chance to win a SB... The pain... The pain...
Agreed. did you hear the lady, "If I put super glue on my hands I could catch whatever you threw at me" LMAO. You could even pretend to catch a NFL football.
2:57 The Immaculate Reception! 7:17 The Amazing Randy Moss 2010 Patriots catch! 9:33 Marty Booker's 2008 catch vs. the 0-16 Lions. 13:38 Antonio Freeman's HE DID WHAT?! catch! 16:36 Jermaine Kearse's Super Bowl XLIX catch! 20:52 Lynn Swann's Super Bowl X catch! 24:16 Odell Beckham Jr.'s 2014 rookie season catches! 28:29 Santonio Holmes' Super Bowl XLIII game-winning touchdown! 33:55 THE CATCH. 39:09 David Tyree's Super Bowl XLII helmet catch!
I don't understand why no one ever talks about the fact that Santonio Holmes' right toe never actually touches the turf. It's a great catch but his right foot wrapped around his left foot not touching the field is all I can see when I watch that play.
"The Catch" is a really good catch... but it doesn't make me go "Oh my gosh, that was incredible! How did he do that?" Well, he caught the ball. He did a good job catching the ball. It gets a boost for being an important catch, but I don't understand how you put it over the Santonio Holmes catch. It was a better catch in a bigger game. "The Catch" reminds me of the "Greatest Game". The Catch was pretty good. The Greatest Game was pretty good. The terms were coined in the olden days before we got truly jaw dropping plays and incredible football games.
Santonio Holmes should definitely be #1 it was a great catch and won the super bowl for the Steelers. To put anything above it only goes to prove everyone just hate the Steelers.
Discount every catch in which the player is wearing those gloves that would snatch a gnat from air with one finger. They're the same as Belitnikof's catches wearing a ton of stick'um. That makes Franco's catch #10-9-8-7-6. #5 Swann's catch becomes #5-4-3-2. "The Catch" is #1. I'm glad some others agree with me.
The catch is overrated and should not be number 2 change my mind. You’re telling me that you think Dwight Clark had a harder time catching that ball than Santonio Holmes, Odell, Lynn Swann, Jermaine Kearse, Antonio Freeman, and Marty Booker??!!! C’mon it was an incredible play and a great catch, but let’s put this at 8 where it belongs and that’s me being generous.🙄
Let me add a few more: John Mackey's 75-yard touchdown in SB 5 Big Ben Right for Atlanta, defeating NO in 1978 The original Hail Mary, Dallas vs. Minnesota, 1975 Finally, the catch that wasn't: Mike Renfro, Oilers, vs. Pittsburgh, 1979 AFC Championship. Every replay I've seen says it was a great catch, but instead it was a blown call that cost the Oilers their best chance to reach a Super Bowl. It's the flip side of the coin to the Immaculate Reception.
The greatest catches should be a catch so great ....the chances of it ever being duplicated are almost zero...For that...my top 3 are in no certain order are: 1.Tyree catch 2. OBJ 3 finger one handed 3.Holmes toe tap
This list should only have been playoff/SB catches, there's just too many games to pull individual regular season catches and not miss many, many great catches. I saw Gary Clark (who should absolutely be in the HOF) make a one-handed catch pinned to the sideline that could easily be on instead of that Moss catch.
Julio Jones in Super Bowl 51 is gonna be in the Jermaine Kearse category, great catch that became a footnote. So gotta ask, is Edelman's catch in your top 10?
You have to be so strong to catch the ball Odell caught and also keep control the way he did and also it was a pass interference. Great catch. Now you see a bunch of wide receivers catching the ball with one hand.
The Freeman catch and Kearse catch are great catches, but let’s be honest.... they TOTALLY have a lot of luck too😂. It just depended where the ball rolled😂. And all those guys were talking about was how the helmet catch was lucky😂
Where is Julio Jones in Falcons vs Patriots SB? End of game, insane catch rt sideline both toes down. Ball over DB's head, down to Pat's 22 yd line, Falcons up by 8. Then Falcons choke!! Go backwards, out of FG range, have to punt. The rest is history. Oh by the way, Im a Pats fan.
I watched Elmo Wright make some catches that were just astonishing and his teammate, Otis Taylor did the equivalent. Those guys were just ball hawks of the first order. Where are they in this catch list?
I absolutely agree with #1! It's not just the whole play that was FANTASTIC, it was the fact that the momentum swung and changed everything & broke N.E.'s heart, which is ALWAYS A GREAT THING! When he caught it, you knew that New York was going to win
How is Manning to Manningham NOT on this is in SB46? BTW David Tyree couldn't catch a cold the week leading up to the SB. He dropped everything in practice.
@Harry Engel Mitchell? Never saw him dirty with the Steelers. Unless you're talking a different Mike Mitchell. Or before he played for the Steelers. I do agree on Burfict and Suh. With Burfict number two and Suh three, Atkinson four. Tatum has to be number one, if only for paralyzing someone for life with Daryl Stingley. Though to give the assassin credit, that was a legal hit back then.
@Harry Engel I'm a native of the Burgh, so I'm a fan as well. Been watching then since 74 at age ten. Yours is also the first list I have seen on dirty players to ever include Mitchell. Don't get me wrong. I could care less if he was dirty much less the dirtiest. To me, he was also an average safety at best. I've seen a couple late hits from him, but never enough to call him dirty. Much less to rank him in the top 4. But to call him as dirty as Burfict??? Wow.
Odell Beckham catch was the greatest show of all time and the second and third greatest catch of all time was in 2022 by George piknins and justin jefferson
The OBJ 1hander in the end zone vs Dallas was the best I've seen... but the helmet catch WAS awesome bc as someone pointed out, the circumstances surrounding it and what was at stake.. but that being said, this should be named Best Catch With The Most On The Line, cuz how that Beckham catch ISN'T number 1 is nuts. And to hear these ppl make excuses as to why he caught it(wearing gloves, it was a meaningless catch, and blah, blah, blah) but this video is called GREATEST CATCHES...And THAT one was amazing... great... call it what you want
THIS LIST IS INCOMPLETE... IT IS "NO WAY" YOU CAN OVERLOOK THE GREAT BALTIMORE COLT, RAYMOND BERRY'S, AS #1 ON ANY SPORTS FAN'S LIST!!! ... HIS STRETCHED OUT "SIDELINE" CATCHES ... OR THE "TOE TAP" REFERENCED HEREIN... "HE INVENTED THEM BOTH!!!"
The fact that all these people act like the Dallas Clark play is the most unbelievable thing they’ve ever seen only to shit on the Tyree catch is so ridiculous. Then to say how that play was entirely luck while saying Jermaine Kearse catch was all skill is so stupid
This has to be one of the most impossible selections to put together when you consider that we have more than 100+ Seasons of NFL Football Games to review. Not that Top 100 Greatest Catches would have been any easier?
Bill Walsh is on video twice with that play saying Dwight Clark would be in the back of the end zone. Once before it happened and they ran that play, and again when calling the play. Also the view from behind Montana shows he was putting it where Clark had an opportunity to catch it and the Cowboys defense didn’t. I don’t care either way, it was awesome and won’t change how I feel about it, about the 49ers or about Montana and Clark. Also there’s evidence it was a pass. I would also say if he was throwing it away, that’s a pretty stupid place to put it and could’ve been risky. Why not throw it away like normal if he was throwing it away? Does Montana have a history of getting intercepted when throwing balls away or a history of throwing balls away in the field of play? Or was Clark taller than everybody and Montana threw it high where Clark could catch it and in the direction Clark was running towards? We all know how it looked and that ppl claim he was throwing it away but that’s partially bc if that’s the case, the 49ers win bc of luck, the Cowboys did enough to win but lost bc of a fluke. The Cowboys are better. It takes away from the play being a legendary catch, and takes away it’s importance. But that’s not what happened, it was a pass, a catch, a touchdown, an NFC championship, a Super Bowl appearance, the beginning of a dynasty, and of hall of fame careers.
9:36 even tho Idk who he is and even tho a lot of people don’t I was literally saying to myself when they showed this in the preview that this catch should be on the list idgaf I’ve NEVER seen this before IN my life maybe I haven’t watched enough football but Jesus Christ.
It amazes me that people talk about the helmet catch ALL THE TIME yet people HARDLY EVER talk about the fact that he caught it while being covered by RODNEY HARRISON. Rodney Harrison was one of the best safeties of his era and was FREAKING INTERLOCKING ARMS WITH THE DUDE WHILE HE WAS GLUING THE BALL TO HIS HELMET!!!!!
But he was stupid to not go for trying to strip the ball out. The heck with pulling him down.
What are you talking about AB does it on the run dude
@@aspenrebel of course he was trying to strip him. It happens fast. He was literally all over Tyree, there was nothing more Harrison could have done.
People forget that when he came down with the football the ball hits the ground while attached to his helmet that's an incomplete pass .....so yeah not a catch #patsnation lol
@nathansaillant4703 ???? Uhhhh no. Never did.
One of the things that makes the Helmet Catch so special is that it immortalised the name of an otherwise unknown receiver named David Tyree. The fact that it was done by someone who ISN'T a famous superstar makes it absolutely perfect!
I think my favorite part of the Tyree story iirc was he struggled in the practices the week prior. Just probably had one of the worst practices at WR they'd had under Coughlin to that point. So you could only imagine going into the game what they probably felt about his chances of making a play. For him to make the biggest play in arguably the biggest upset in NFL history? Yeah. Number 1.
I honestly love how every single player from the steelers they had talking about the immaculate reception all were on the same page with their answers. Fuqua sold me on it too. I say it is a catch, and no one is gonna tell Franco Harris otherwise
Hey man! You’re the cure for covid boredom! Stay safe friend
I will, thank you.
Amen. I never knew there was so many top 10s. Isaac is the man fo' sure!
Hope you guys are good.
You do know that he doesn’t make these
@@excaliferfootball5918 yeh, I can't remember the guys name at nfl films that is in charge of the UA-cam channel but they don't upload them all and Isaac takes the time to upload them so he has my respect and gratitude. Or do you mean he rips them from another UA-cam channel?
Either way, hope you're good.
Santonio Holmes got to be greatest catch in history. Just the amount of balance that took.
*The new #1 is Julian Edelman in SB 51. A catch in triple coverage inches off of the turf amidst a 25-point comeback. Still amazing.*
Marvin Harrison's one handed, deflection, end line toe tap touchdown while falling down against the Raiders in '01 should have for sure been on the list.
Do the top 10 receiving corps.
And top 10 power backs
I think Julian Edelman's catch when Robert Alford tipped the ball in Super Bowl 51 should up there on this list.
NO QUESTION
Lolol it's an odd but satisfying feeling when a top 10 countdown revolves around a player catching a football and a bears player made the list
8:41 he does know Revis locked Moss for most of the game he had TWO catches for 38 yards. Yea that TD was 34 yards, but at the end of the day Revis won that game.
I don't understand why that catch was on the list, and the Sea of Hands wasn't.
I will still never get over the dez “drop” it was literally a fricking catch
By rule it wasn't
@@kennethuphoff320 www.nbcsports.com/washington/redskins/three-years-later-nfl-now-says-cowboys-dez-bryant-did-fact-catch-it
For sure it was a xtahc
Lmao no it wasn’t
The Helmet Catch is the best catch of all time because of the circumstances with the Giants beating the undefeated Patriots in the Super Bowl.
You're right and no matter how many times I've watched it and it's 12 years later and it still bothers me.
Plus it was against Rodney Harrison who was top notch.
@@maryjoforrest1011 not to mention it was on a 3rd and 5 and literally one play before that Asante Samuel dropped a game winning interception. Idk how you don’t say that’s the greatest ever given those circumstances
I won so much commissary off that catch!
Grrrrrr!!!!!
I remember doing 2007 fantasy with my friends. I ended up with Tom Brady and Rnady Moss. Probably one of my best fantasy season if not the best
This show is really obsessed with Super Bowl 42. And us Giants fans LOVE IT!!!
Eat rusty nails!!!!!
Ruined perfection and then got em again 4 years later. As a Ravens fan those were sweet years
Honestly Sehorn's pick-6 in the NFC divisional game in 2000 probably should be on this list.
Great as always. Always fun to revisit these top 10’s thank you for that.
I'm a 49ers fan but the best catch of all time has to be Odell's, as Collingsworth said, " that might be the greatest catch I've ever seen"
Thank You for posting all of these Isaac Green. I've had a blast watching them.
Never forget Dwight Clark's "The Catch" that starts the 49ers 80's Dynasty!!!
Manning to Manningham in Super Bowl 46, greatest pass and catch I’ve ever seen!!
So many Marvin Harrison catches that could and should be on here
I get Super Bowl winning catches but as far as historical significance “The Catch” Ended a dynasty and created a new dynasty between two hardcore rivals that’s why it should be #1
I love how the Steelers are so coy about the immaculate reception
There are some amazing catches made by defenders that could have been on this list. Polamalu had at least 3 I can think of. Ed Reed and deion too. Also holmes should be #1 and clarks should be somewhere between 9-7.
Malcolm Butler
They do have an episode for interceptions lol!
The Santonio Holmes catch is number 1 ☝️
Thanks so much for uploading these. You the real mvp
People really on TV saying that Tyree's catch was all luck, no skill, when he's holding onto that ball for dear life against arguably the greatest safety in league history of all time Rodney Harrison.
I despise it when they say shit like that and I’m not even a Giants fan (I’m a Ravens fan). The worst part is when I hear the same people act like the Kearse catch was so much better and took only skill and there was no luck involved. Every NFL play has a bit of luck. If Too Tall Jones does not fall for Montana’s fake, then maybe he blocks the Catch before it is even possible, if the Patriots DB that jumped over Kearse knocked the ball away, then he never has a chance to catch it, if Big Ben is sacked then he could never get that throw to Holmes and I could go on. Yet, the Helmet Catch is constantly the target of the “more luck than skill” argument. A little luck should not take away from an all time great play and I still think all the catches I mentioned are all time great catches. Despite that, I would argue that the Helmet catch is actually the most impressive catch ever, one of the hardest hitters in NFL history draped all over him yanking him to the ground, for Tyree to have the strength in his fingers and presence of mind to just press it against his helmet in the Super Bowl, on third down against the undefeated Pats to save the game winning drive, best catch ever in my mind! I’d like to see anyone who calls that catch lucky try to pull it off!
Come on, a no name receiver that never did anything before or after that play? It was obviously luck.
Ok like your point is correct but Rodney Harrison was nowhere near as good as you hype him up to be lmao, also he was 35 at the time and only played 6 more games afterwards he wasn't even the best safety on that team lol
If there was that much skill involved in that catch then someone show me another Tyree catch where he showcases ANY of that skill he supposedly had. That catch was 99% luck.
I understand what you're saying but the greatest Harrison the greatest safety in football not hardly
I can't believe this doesn't have the Drew Pearson "Hail Mary", catch. It was literally created that second, and is still what we call airing it out on a go route, throw a Hail Mary.
I'd like to see an updated version of this list in a year or so.
Hopkins' catch against the Bills would be included.
NFL Films should rename their "Top Ten Super bowls of all time" into "Top Ten non-Patriots Super bowls of all time" because win or lose Bellichick-Brady Patriots almost guarantee a classic game like Super Bowl 36, 42, 49 and 51
Helmet Catch is undoubtedly the GOAT catch, but Antonio Freeman’s was fucking wild.
Edelman catch is probably the most scrutinized catch ever.
With regards to Beckhams one handed catch, yes he had the gloves on, but if you look at the replays he used his 2 fingers and a thumb to catch it not looking at the ball with his arm behind his head. Sticky gloves may have helped, but it takes skill, strength and awareness to do it like he did... BTW Jerry Rice admitted to using stickem on his gloves...
BTW as a Cardinals fan, #3 was a dagger to the heart. Because fans knew that was the only chance in our life time to see them with a chance to win a SB... The pain... The pain...
Agreed. did you hear the lady, "If I put super glue on my hands I could catch whatever you threw at me" LMAO. You could even pretend to catch a NFL football.
If you can find top 10 power backs, I will be very impressed like I always am. You are the man Isaac!
Thanks for the words.
Top 10 Fullbacks.
2:57 The Immaculate Reception!
7:17 The Amazing Randy Moss 2010 Patriots catch!
9:33 Marty Booker's 2008 catch vs. the 0-16 Lions.
13:38 Antonio Freeman's HE DID WHAT?! catch!
16:36 Jermaine Kearse's Super Bowl XLIX catch!
20:52 Lynn Swann's Super Bowl X catch!
24:16 Odell Beckham Jr.'s 2014 rookie season catches!
28:29 Santonio Holmes' Super Bowl XLIII game-winning touchdown!
33:55 THE CATCH.
39:09 David Tyree's Super Bowl XLII helmet catch!
Thanks!
Edelman’s catch in SB51 needs to be on here if they regularly updated these.
I hope ghost to the post or sea of hands is on this
I can't believe he wasn't in this list
That’s cool af getting Franco Harris to answer that question 😂
Keep coming with the videos bro real 🏈 football fans appreciate this 👍🏽
Hey man! You’re the cure for covid boredom! Stay safe friend
The Antonio Freeman catch is incredible.
"The catch" was labeled "the catch" because no one had seen the later catches yet.
I didnt think it was that big of a deal. Nor the 2 Swann catches.
The Niners almost blew that game in the end. One of the defenders made a game saving tackle. Then Danny White fumbled to end the Cowboys chances.
It's about the moment more than the physical degree of difficulty. Nobody cares about my glorious one-handed touchdown stab of Thanksgiving Day '77!
I don't understand why no one ever talks about the fact that Santonio Holmes' right toe never actually touches the turf. It's a great catch but his right foot wrapped around his left foot not touching the field is all I can see when I watch that play.
"The Catch" is a really good catch... but it doesn't make me go "Oh my gosh, that was incredible! How did he do that?" Well, he caught the ball. He did a good job catching the ball. It gets a boost for being an important catch, but I don't understand how you put it over the Santonio Holmes catch. It was a better catch in a bigger game. "The Catch" reminds me of the "Greatest Game". The Catch was pretty good. The Greatest Game was pretty good. The terms were coined in the olden days before we got truly jaw dropping plays and incredible football games.
Santonio Holmes should definitely be #1 it was a great catch and won the super bowl for the Steelers. To put anything above it only goes to prove everyone just hate the Steelers.
Discount every catch in which the player is wearing those gloves that would snatch a gnat from air with one finger. They're the same as Belitnikof's catches wearing a ton of stick'um. That makes Franco's catch #10-9-8-7-6. #5 Swann's catch becomes #5-4-3-2. "The Catch" is #1. I'm glad some others agree with me.
The catch is overrated and should not be number 2 change my mind. You’re telling me that you think Dwight Clark had a harder time catching that ball than Santonio Holmes, Odell, Lynn Swann, Jermaine Kearse, Antonio Freeman, and Marty Booker??!!! C’mon it was an incredible play and a great catch, but let’s put this at 8 where it belongs and that’s me being generous.🙄
Max Mcgee in SB 1. 1 handed behind him across his body. That catch should have been in top 10
Yeah! It was cold, he was exhausted, he had a hangover, etc. The ball just stuck in his hand.
Let me add a few more:
John Mackey's 75-yard touchdown in SB 5
Big Ben Right for Atlanta, defeating NO in 1978
The original Hail Mary, Dallas vs. Minnesota, 1975
Finally, the catch that wasn't: Mike Renfro, Oilers, vs. Pittsburgh, 1979 AFC Championship. Every replay I've seen says it was a great catch, but instead it was a blown call that cost the Oilers their best chance to reach a Super Bowl. It's the flip side of the coin to the Immaculate Reception.
How does one make a 43 minute long top 10 video??
Max McGee Green Bay Packers side arm catch
1974 Terry Metcalf of the St. Louis Cardinals catches the ball from Jim Hart between three Dallas defenders
The greatest catches should be a catch so great ....the chances of it ever being duplicated are almost zero...For that...my top 3 are in no certain order are:
1.Tyree catch
2. OBJ 3 finger one handed
3.Holmes toe tap
No argument from me! Totally agree
This list should only have been playoff/SB catches, there's just too many games to pull individual regular season catches and not miss many, many great catches. I saw Gary Clark (who should absolutely be in the HOF) make a one-handed catch pinned to the sideline that could easily be on instead of that Moss catch.
Best OS the Rest: All Moss....that man was FOOTBALL!!!
Geez even when I saw these catches during the live games I didnt believe and now I still dont-wow!!
The CATCH is the #1 of all time
The Catch should have been number 1! David Tyree was just lucky as that dude @41:19 said!
Julio Jones in Super Bowl 51 is gonna be in the Jermaine Kearse category, great catch that became a footnote.
So gotta ask, is Edelman's catch in your top 10?
How was Julien Edelmans catch not on here it was part of the greatest comeback in superbowl history
I'm just starting the video. If number 1 isn't santonio holmes in the corner to win super bowl 43 then there is no justice. Edit: there is no justice.
Odells catch against the cowboys...hands down...the best catch ever
You have to be so strong to catch the ball Odell caught and also keep control the way he did and also it was a pass interference. Great catch. Now you see a bunch of wide receivers catching the ball with one hand.
The Freeman catch and Kearse catch are great catches, but let’s be honest.... they TOTALLY have a lot of luck too😂. It just depended where the ball rolled😂. And all those guys were talking about was how the helmet catch was lucky😂
Oh gosh Flula Borg.
Dear God Flula Borg
I almost clicked off the video when I saw him show up
Flula Borg provides shitty jokes and shitty commentary. Shouldn't be in any NFL Films Top 10.
Odell Beckham has the greatest catch known to man
The greatest catch of all time was the santonio Holmes made in Superbowl fourty three
Update on the immaculate reception: a new video shows the ball didn't touch the ground. It was a catch. It was the right call.
Obj committed the P.I. on that catch
Can we also talk about Antonio Freeman, and the TORRENTIAL rain?
Whats the music in Santonio Holmes catch?
Here after the Hail Murray against the Bills
Where is Julio Jones in Falcons vs Patriots SB? End of game, insane catch rt sideline both toes down. Ball over DB's head, down to Pat's 22 yd line, Falcons up by 8. Then Falcons choke!! Go backwards, out of FG range, have to punt. The rest is history. Oh by the way, Im a Pats fan.
to me nate pooles catch against the vikings was a combination between santonios and tyrees. he toe tapped with the ball against his helmet
The Holmes catch should have been #1
I watched Elmo Wright make some catches that were just astonishing and his teammate, Otis Taylor did the equivalent. Those guys were just ball hawks of the first order. Where are they in this catch list?
THEY GOT BUBS ON HERE! BUBS!
Do the top 10 receiving corps.
And top 10 power backs
Santonio Holmes should be number 1 period....
The greatest catch in the seattle new england game was the catch two plays later.
I absolutely agree with #1! It's not just the whole play that was FANTASTIC, it was the fact that the momentum swung and changed everything & broke N.E.'s heart, which is ALWAYS A GREAT THING! When he caught it, you knew that New York was going to win
How is Manning to Manningham NOT on this is in SB46? BTW David Tyree couldn't catch a cold the week leading up to the SB. He dropped everything in practice.
Add d-hop “sea of hands II” catch
freeman catch, IT WAS ALSO RAINING
Odell THE GREATEST TOUCHDOWN CATCH EVER ‼️‼️‼️
Dude that's a joke Santonio homes in the corner to win the super bowl
DeAndre Hopkins has entered the chat.
How come they never show different angles of the Immaculate Reception?
Because technology didn't bloom yet.
Because they did not use the number of cameras then that they do now. The film you see of it is what is available to look at.
@Harry Engel Tatum was playing his typical assassin style of football and it came back to take a chunk out of his ass.
@Harry Engel Mitchell? Never saw him dirty with the Steelers. Unless you're talking a different Mike Mitchell. Or before he played for the Steelers. I do agree on Burfict and Suh. With Burfict number two and Suh three, Atkinson four. Tatum has to be number one, if only for paralyzing someone for life with Daryl Stingley. Though to give the assassin credit, that was a legal hit back then.
@Harry Engel I'm a native of the Burgh, so I'm a fan as well. Been watching then since 74 at age ten. Yours is also the first list I have seen on dirty players to ever include Mitchell. Don't get me wrong. I could care less if he was dirty much less the dirtiest. To me, he was also an average safety at best. I've seen a couple late hits from him, but never enough to call him dirty. Much less to rank him in the top 4. But to call him as dirty as Burfict??? Wow.
Odell Beckham catch was the greatest show of all time and the second and third greatest catch of all time was in 2022 by George piknins and justin jefferson
Top 10 worst officiating calls.
The OBJ 1hander in the end zone vs Dallas was the best I've seen... but the helmet catch WAS awesome bc as someone pointed out, the circumstances surrounding it and what was at stake.. but that being said, this should be named Best Catch With The Most On The Line, cuz how that Beckham catch ISN'T number 1 is nuts. And to hear these ppl make excuses as to why he caught it(wearing gloves, it was a meaningless catch, and blah, blah, blah) but this video is called GREATEST CATCHES...And THAT one was amazing... great... call it what you want
Number 10 should've been in atleast the top 5
THIS LIST IS INCOMPLETE... IT IS "NO WAY" YOU CAN OVERLOOK THE GREAT BALTIMORE COLT, RAYMOND BERRY'S, AS #1 ON ANY SPORTS FAN'S LIST!!! ... HIS STRETCHED OUT "SIDELINE" CATCHES ... OR THE "TOE TAP" REFERENCED HEREIN... "HE INVENTED THEM BOTH!!!"
The fact that all these people act like the Dallas Clark play is the most unbelievable thing they’ve ever seen only to shit on the Tyree catch is so ridiculous. Then to say how that play was entirely luck while saying Jermaine Kearse catch was all skill is so stupid
This has to be one of the most impossible selections to put together when you consider that we have more than 100+ Seasons of NFL Football Games to review. Not that Top 100 Greatest Catches would have been any easier?
Number 1 should be 28-3 Julian Edelman
Lance Moore and Julian Edelman disrespected so bad on this 🫣
Bill Walsh is on video twice with that play saying Dwight Clark would be in the back of the end zone. Once before it happened and they ran that play, and again when calling the play. Also the view from behind Montana shows he was putting it where Clark had an opportunity to catch it and the Cowboys defense didn’t. I don’t care either way, it was awesome and won’t change how I feel about it, about the 49ers or about Montana and Clark. Also there’s evidence it was a pass. I would also say if he was throwing it away, that’s a pretty stupid place to put it and could’ve been risky. Why not throw it away like normal if he was throwing it away? Does Montana have a history of getting intercepted when throwing balls away or a history of throwing balls away in the field of play? Or was Clark taller than everybody and Montana threw it high where Clark could catch it and in the direction Clark was running towards? We all know how it looked and that ppl claim he was throwing it away but that’s partially bc if that’s the case, the 49ers win bc of luck, the Cowboys did enough to win but lost bc of a fluke. The Cowboys are better. It takes away from the play being a legendary catch, and takes away it’s importance. But that’s not what happened, it was a pass, a catch, a touchdown, an NFC championship, a Super Bowl appearance, the beginning of a dynasty, and of hall of fame careers.
I'm a Washington fan born and bred, but even I have to say where the hell is Drew Pearson and the original Hail Mary?
I hate all the old heads hating on the obj catch. Get out the old days
9:36 even tho Idk who he is and even tho a lot of people don’t I was literally saying to myself when they showed this in the preview that this catch should be on the list idgaf I’ve NEVER seen this before IN my life maybe I haven’t watched enough football but Jesus Christ.
It sucks to watch at least 6 ppl who've never even caught a football in a backyard game talk about pro sports for a half hour....ugh!!!
“the catch” should be “the throw”