Host moderator ku oru romba periya 🙏 , beautifully done for letting the conversation evolve amongst the panel from behind the scenes with minimal interruption, well done brother
It's Good to see director ratna mentioning sila nerangalil sila manidhargal as his favourite because this is a gem of this year and it was most underrated.
Wonderful Conversation.......Loved this Roundtable... Krishna didn't interfere btwn their speech🤝 loved Everyone's thought on current cinema👌🏻Pakka Round Table...thanks FC
Easily the best round table this year for me.. I have watched all FC and Galatta plus ones.. good panel members and the discussion was very organic.. anchor was not trying to impress anyone with any over smart questions.. some very good points from almost most of the directors..
Impacted Tamil Films of 2022 is Vikram - music , Direction , Star Cast , Story , Screenplay is astonishing Love Today - Music , Screenplay , StoryTelling , Pradeep was excellent
Thanks anchor... I have always found your anchoring very good. I loved you in your other interviews too. You are a great prospect for the future. You kept throwing interesting topics to discuss, these are brilliant people they will take it to the conclusion. You never look intimidate or awed by their presence, thats important.
Rathna anna nan unga short film madhu va theatre la pathen in case if u see this comment I really liked the short film my mom got tickets through her friend for the screening of four films in sathyam theatre all the four was really unique and great
Such a wonderful roundtable. Delight to watch / hear each one of them. Especially Rajiv Menon. Another good thing about this roundtable is, though at some point they may seem to have some difference of opinions, everyone respects each other's views and when they do explain about their views, it does feels right from their perspective. Good job by anchor by letting it go like a discussion rather than a interview. Good one FC!
4:50 Pushkar made a good point. Every industry survives on the volume of work, everyone needs to get some work. Work needs to happen and we cant just have these star studded and good films being produced. For the industry to run even mediocre or bad films need to break even soo that the entire industry thrives. Since the audience matured i think even oyr quality of filmmaking has to grow, Even our mediocre films need to be decent
Why you don't put english subtitles, there is fans from all over the world who don't understand tamil or hindi or telugu or malalayam but enjoying watching indian's cinema from all the industries, i'm one of them
The Roundtable discussion Show Stealer Director TJ Gnanavel and Director Rajiv Menon 🔥 Speaking different view of cinema and Reality 48:54 The children of God sells DVD by Rajiv Menon where Malayalam cinema content driven compare to Tamil cinema 50:28 Pebbles Oscar Nominations tamil film is not visible to audience 52:23 Director Ram supporting good movie to get visible to audience like Witness movie speaking about issues of Manual scavenger life death and Director Parthiban speaking about Producer with Different way like OTT , Theatre or TV it's depends on content where writer 📝 play Major role to get content with audience the perspective of Directors Gnanavel as cinema speaking about problem of creators and producers and Wonderful conversation by Team 👏👏 Host Vera level listening 🎧 the conversation question or Cinema real problem faced by film makers 1:15:03 The Shawshank redemption movie celebration of people best movies The difference between novel and cinema Thanks for Film companion south for Making Round table of Tamil cinema 2022 Healthy discussion
Please have a round table with Music Directors pleasee.... Yuvan , Santhosh Narayanan , Harris , Sam CS , Ani , Ghibran ... It will be more exclusive than this
20:20 - Vadhandhi web series ah dha indirect ah elarum solitu irukanga. It was hand-crafted for ott. Based on the ott's conditions, the script has been changed based on what people watch the most. For example, there should be a metric set by the ott that more people prefer to watch 18+ scenes in ott. So, they have deliberately included a few episodes for it even though the script doesn't require it. It was molded for ott based on metrics, which is not healthy, and good cinema will die because ott will keep on asking directors to fit the story into the formula they give. So no new ideas will be made into films. It will be all the same shit as before. And one more thing that's happening in the ott world is fake reviews. The main aim of the creators nowadays is to maintain an 8+ imdb score. So why not fill it with fake reviews! A very dangerous approach for cinema, fooling the audience, until they become clever.
It looks like T. J. Gnanavel’s has not seen movies like Thallumala, Beeshma parvam and Rorschach.. I felt the same nerve-racking experience as Vikram when I watched Beeshma parvam. And the irony is that Gnanavel’s Jai bhim is a content driven movie. Its just that Malayalam movie industry make all kind of movies, but we are not celebrated or celebrate ourself like every other industry.
Malayalam doing all kind of movies? 🤨...I don't deny the Malayalam industries prowess in natural and realistic films....But I can't find a variety of genre films like in Tamil viz,.. science fiction/time travel films like( indru netru nalai, 24) that too done by a main stream actor like Surya....or any horror films (demonte colony, Maya) sports genre films ( sarpatta, jeeva, venila kabadi kuzhu) social thriller films (adanga Maru, velaikaran, irunbuthirai) psychological thrillers( anthakaram) psycho thrillers (ratsasan)or any commercial film take in-case with Vikram too will not be done in a effective way in Malayalam,... haven't seen bheesma parvam (would love to) seen thallumala loved it to core...but Malayalam films in my perspective always stick to a one dimensional way of showing their films, it's not bad in anyway.
At the same time one can expect quality films in Malayalam time to time unlike Tamil...but they haven't still undergone the variety of genres that too successfully executed like in Tamil... ☮️
@@sabaris2603 They too have all genres bro like Android Kunjappan, Anjaam Pathira, Rorschach, Churuli, Minnal Murali,Lucifer, ..... but they make it in their way, in their budget limit. They have only around 600-800 theatres and we have around 1500+ here. So they can't invest too huge. Kannada people have Banglore, Telugu - Hyderabad but Malayalam doesn't have a very big single place market where they can promote and derive huge profits. Let's wait n see bro.
@@Michael_017 I loved both minnal murali and churuli , but these films are done post pandemic, after knowing the nerves of fans but I am talking about Tamil cinema that has been doing experimental films since last 10 years successfully...if that's the case even Tamil films are also doing natural and realistic films, but Malayalam films are known to do it well to reach across the masses that is what I am coming to say.... but I have to accept promotions and budgets has always been a hindrance for Malayalam films...when it comes to promotions Telugu films hits it out of the park, with its greater than life contents...
I think promotion is much important. I watched nitham oru vanam, kanam on theatres which was really amazing. But I did not find any buzz or promotion about that movies before that movie was released.
Parthiban, Rajiv Menon, Rathnakumar had some failure recently But they will come back for sure. Form is temporary, class is permanent My expectations : Rajiv Menon - Commercial Feel good emotional drama like Kandukondaen Parthiban - Proper commercial film without much experiment, with Vadivelu super Rathna - Romantic comedy
Also inga niraya peru Krishna inum neraya Question kekka solraanga ..i dono how is this possible they were talking about 30mins for a question in a flow then how should he disturb in between....
Very Interesting... But why did Gnanavel and Rathna kumar Kept interrupting others. It was irritating though they were adding good points, they could have avoided that. Having said that thank you everyone for all your wonderful thoughts, you guys are the ones who are gonna carry our Tamil Pride through this art. Thanks for all the contribution, All the very best to all your future endeavours.
Ganavel was good and great at his vision and understanding. Ratha was normal but others was just in the name of Liberalism hiding in there comfort zone as they are safe and they don’t have issues. We cannot compare Marvel franchises with Indian movies which means Indian movies are best in their own but not in par with Hollywood movies. Even now James Cameron can make a three hour movie and people go to theaters and watch if you have good content then no one can stop. Secondly music went national even before what Rajiv said probably he is in anemia he has watch some of old interviews of SPB where he said when Illairaja was recording in Mumbai people didn’t like as it was not easy so before only music reach Nation and Illaraja took music to nation. All are just behind star directors like Puskar Parthiban etc Ganavel was right in his talks no biased talk to Favoritism for anyone. One of the biggest masala movies were KGF and pusha was telegu versions of KGF, nothing great about the movies including RRR another super duper worst masala. Nothing what is great in this masala movies nothing 😳. Kargi, Jai Bheem, Sila Nerangali silla manidargal, witness, Tannakaran, Natchathiram Nagargiradhu, Thiruchitrambalam, Nenjuku Needhi etc. best movie made in 2022 with no doubt is Kadaisi Vivasayi.
@42.11 mins.. mr.pushkar ,please let us know where to find theatres that lets you smoke in the breaks cuz we didnt't find any at vikram vedha songs (hindimade)
Host moderator ku oru romba periya 🙏 , beautifully done for letting the conversation evolve amongst the panel from behind the scenes with minimal interruption, well done brother
Why don't you guys have a roundtable with the music directors. would like to have their view also.
They are always busy/employed back to back 😹 with new projects
Would be nice
Would get more new stories
It really would be an interesting conversation 🙂
+1
Only musicians would understand 🤣
Suriya is one top star/actor who supports the industry truly- as a producer, presenter, even a promoter via social media. Thalaivan for a reason!
Exactly
🤣🤣🤣🤣
Such a genuine round table you ever watch this year... No plastic just pure words of wisdom... Kudos to Krishna for driving this😍
Rajiv Menon - every point is clear 🔥🔥🔥
Gnanavel - clarity 😍😍😍
Rajiv menon's words are insightful . Shows his expertise over the craft. He deserves more❤️🔥
True
Yes, He is a good reader
Well Matured talk by Rajiv ....
Awareness talk by Gnanavel
Exactly, he threw some interesting angles and aspects...Wish we hear more of that, hit or flop, the experience is what matters.
It's Good to see director ratna mentioning sila nerangalil sila manidhargal as his favourite because this is a gem of this year and it was most underrated.
Wonderful Conversation.......Loved this Roundtable... Krishna didn't interfere btwn their speech🤝 loved Everyone's thought on current cinema👌🏻Pakka Round Table...thanks FC
Easily the best round table this year for me.. I have watched all FC and Galatta plus ones.. good panel members and the discussion was very organic.. anchor was not trying to impress anyone with any over smart questions.. some very good points from almost most of the directors..
Outstunned by the answer delivered by pushkar and gayathri for their first question!! They are outstanding 🔥🔥🔥
Impacted Tamil Films of 2022 is
Vikram - music , Direction , Star Cast , Story , Screenplay is astonishing
Love Today - Music , Screenplay , StoryTelling , Pradeep was excellent
i love Rajiv menon's Sarvam Thala Mayam. it was wonderful movie
ரொம்ப தெளிவான இயக்குனர் tj ஞாணவேல்
He was a journalist and screenplay/dialogue writer b4 becoming a director.
யாரு இந்த சாதிவெறி படம் எடுத்தானே case file பெயர் மாத்தினானே அவனா இது...
@@Michael_017 yyyy? Yhny
Wow. One of the most profound round about the current tamil cinema condition.
Rajiv Menon ❤️😍 was brilliant
Thanks anchor... I have always found your anchoring very good. I loved you in your other interviews too. You are a great prospect for the future. You kept throwing interesting topics to discuss, these are brilliant people they will take it to the conclusion. You never look intimidate or awed by their presence, thats important.
Rathna anna nan unga short film madhu va theatre la pathen in case if u see this comment I really liked the short film my mom got tickets through her friend for the screening of four films in sathyam theatre all the four was really unique and great
Krishna hosted this so nicely. Just putting a question and letting the guest take after that.
Parthiban sir's honesty vere level. yet so humble.
There needs to be true care for the society to speak sensibly like Director Gnanavel .
Such a wonderful roundtable. Delight to watch / hear each one of them. Especially Rajiv Menon. Another good thing about this roundtable is, though at some point they may seem to have some difference of opinions, everyone respects each other's views and when they do explain about their views, it does feels right from their perspective. Good job by anchor by letting it go like a discussion rather than a interview. Good one FC!
Except for unsatisfied Parthibs who keeps self bloating
@@vijayaprabu6669 lol true but bearable.
4:50 Pushkar made a good point. Every industry survives on the volume of work, everyone needs to get some work. Work needs to happen and we cant just have these star studded and good films being produced. For the industry to run even mediocre or bad films need to break even soo that the entire industry thrives. Since the audience matured i think even oyr quality of filmmaking has to grow, Even our mediocre films need to be decent
14:55 Lens is a very good film but sadly neraya peruku apdi oru padam irunthuthane theriyile. I have recommended to some of my frens to watch it
Could we please get subtitles . Would love to listen in. The reach of such amazing creators needs to be expanded
nice chick
Why you don't put english subtitles, there is fans from all over the world who don't understand tamil or hindi or telugu or malalayam but enjoying watching indian's cinema from all the industries, i'm one of them
This round table was real good...loved every ones view..Pushkar Sir ended with a bang
Thank you for the wonderful round table interview 2022.
The Roundtable discussion Show Stealer Director TJ Gnanavel and Director Rajiv Menon 🔥 Speaking different view of cinema and Reality 48:54 The children of God sells DVD by Rajiv Menon where Malayalam cinema content driven compare to Tamil cinema 50:28 Pebbles Oscar Nominations tamil film is not visible to audience 52:23 Director Ram supporting good movie to get visible to audience like Witness movie speaking about issues of Manual scavenger life death and Director Parthiban speaking about Producer with Different way like OTT , Theatre or TV it's depends on content where writer 📝 play Major role to get content with audience the perspective of Directors Gnanavel as cinema speaking about problem of creators and producers and Wonderful conversation by Team 👏👏 Host Vera level listening 🎧 the conversation question or Cinema real problem faced by film makers 1:15:03 The Shawshank redemption movie celebration of people best movies The difference between novel and cinema Thanks for Film companion south for Making Round table of Tamil cinema 2022 Healthy discussion
Malayalam and tamil roundtable are so good
14:55 Lens is one of My favorite Movie 😍Best😘
Please have a round table with Music Directors pleasee.... Yuvan , Santhosh Narayanan , Harris , Sam CS , Ani , Ghibran ... It will be more exclusive than this
What not AR Rahman, Illaiyaraja..?! Outdated 😸
@@vijayaprabu6669 i don't think he will participate, illayaraja definitely No
@@pritzcutz4373 Absolutely Right.
Why GARGI Director Gautham is not called for any round table discussions ? That was one of the best movies in 2022 , come on guys !
Exactly 💯
Because it's copy movie from korean
@@sarathr4495 What is the name of that movie?
@@MaheshwaranIrulappan mother . Climax is changed .
Telugu director da
Very good panel and thoughtful question and good work by presenter
padatha Epdi vikkanumnu theriyaadha producer dhan nalla padam pannuvaaru - Rathnakumar........................ semma
Director nalla Trailer cut pannattum like Love Today... Why blame producer fully
The facts shared by Rajiv Menon sir were astonishing and clear about the views.
20:20 - Vadhandhi web series ah dha indirect ah elarum solitu irukanga. It was hand-crafted for ott. Based on the ott's conditions, the script has been changed based on what people watch the most. For example, there should be a metric set by the ott that more people prefer to watch 18+ scenes in ott. So, they have deliberately included a few episodes for it even though the script doesn't require it. It was molded for ott based on metrics, which is not healthy, and good cinema will die because ott will keep on asking directors to fit the story into the formula they give. So no new ideas will be made into films. It will be all the same shit as before.
And one more thing that's happening in the ott world is fake reviews. The main aim of the creators nowadays is to maintain an 8+ imdb score. So why not fill it with fake reviews! A very dangerous approach for cinema, fooling the audience, until they become clever.
Oh, Is there an organised review/rating racket?? Thats not good.
Which part in vadhanthi are you mentioning? Just curious know.
It’s a nonsense series. Nothing exciting with idiotic climax
Rajiv Menon is a surprise package
Rathna na deserve more bcz he is good writer also director ❤❤
Best round table session till date 👍
Great job Krishna.
Thalaiva Krishna Vera Level!
It looks like T. J. Gnanavel’s has not seen movies like Thallumala, Beeshma parvam and Rorschach.. I felt the same nerve-racking experience as Vikram when I watched Beeshma parvam. And the irony is that Gnanavel’s Jai bhim is a content driven movie. Its just that Malayalam movie industry make all kind of movies, but we are not celebrated or celebrate ourself like every other industry.
Need to do more promotions.
Malayalam doing all kind of movies? 🤨...I don't deny the Malayalam industries prowess in natural and realistic films....But I can't find a variety of genre films like in Tamil viz,.. science fiction/time travel films like( indru netru nalai, 24) that too done by a main stream actor like Surya....or any horror films (demonte colony, Maya) sports genre films ( sarpatta, jeeva, venila kabadi kuzhu) social thriller films (adanga Maru, velaikaran, irunbuthirai) psychological thrillers( anthakaram) psycho thrillers (ratsasan)or any commercial film take in-case with Vikram too will not be done in a effective way in Malayalam,... haven't seen bheesma parvam (would love to) seen thallumala loved it to core...but Malayalam films in my perspective always stick to a one dimensional way of showing their films, it's not bad in anyway.
At the same time one can expect quality films in Malayalam time to time unlike Tamil...but they haven't still undergone the variety of genres that too successfully executed like in Tamil... ☮️
@@sabaris2603 They too have all genres bro like Android Kunjappan, Anjaam Pathira, Rorschach, Churuli, Minnal Murali,Lucifer, ..... but they make it in their way, in their budget limit. They have only around 600-800 theatres and we have around 1500+ here. So they can't invest too huge. Kannada people have Banglore, Telugu - Hyderabad but Malayalam doesn't have a very big single place market where they can promote and derive huge profits. Let's wait n see bro.
@@Michael_017 I loved both minnal murali and churuli , but these films are done post pandemic, after knowing the nerves of fans but I am talking about Tamil cinema that has been doing experimental films since last 10 years successfully...if that's the case even Tamil films are also doing natural and realistic films, but Malayalam films are known to do it well to reach across the masses that is what I am coming to say.... but I have to accept promotions and budgets has always been a hindrance for Malayalam films...when it comes to promotions Telugu films hits it out of the park, with its greater than life contents...
Rajiv ❤
I had a great time watching this Tamil Directors' Adda 2022 :)
I think promotion is much important. I watched nitham oru vanam, kanam on theatres which was really amazing. But I did not find any buzz or promotion about that movies before that movie was released.
'Love Today' had good trailer... #JobDone
Loved Rajiv menon sir's views
Rajiv menon ah pathuttu yarellam vanthinga..
தொடரட்டும் பயணங்கள் அனைவருக்கும் வாழ்த்துக்கள்
Parthipan sir abt pan india vera level😂😂
A wholesomic interview ❤️
Parthiban, Rajiv Menon, Rathnakumar had some failure recently
But they will come back for sure.
Form is temporary, class is permanent
My expectations :
Rajiv Menon - Commercial Feel good emotional drama like Kandukondaen
Parthiban - Proper commercial film without much experiment, with Vadivelu super
Rathna - Romantic comedy
Also expecting A theatrical movie from TJ Gnanavel and Pushkar Gayatri. as their last tamil work released in ott...
Rajiv Menon's Minasara kanavu semma padam. One of my all time favourite.
Surya sir 🥰🥰
Rajiv menon deserves more ✨
Also inga niraya peru Krishna inum neraya Question kekka solraanga ..i dono how is this possible they were talking about 30mins for a question in a flow then how should he disturb in between....
Rajiv menon s a great intellectual ♥️
I just came to see this video - only becoz of Parthiban Counters He is a Sigma . Everyone was attracted to the same.
Very Interesting... But why did Gnanavel and Rathna kumar Kept interrupting others. It was irritating though they were adding good points, they could have avoided that. Having said that thank you everyone for all your wonderful thoughts, you guys are the ones who are gonna carry our Tamil Pride through this art. Thanks for all the contribution, All the very best to all your future endeavours.
rajiv menon 👌👌👌👌👌👌clear speech
Krish ❤️ good to see you man...
Mysskin sir ram sir vetri sir kumarraja sir ivagala vachu oru round table panu ga flim campaign 🙏🙏
When you are going to do #Kannada film directors adda,.... We are waiting eagerly
Gnanavel is making good sense with his comments
Please add English subtitles
13:23 - Parthiban
1:25 🔥🔥🔥
Pls Do In English. Found Very Difficult To Understand 😕
@51:00 kuzhangal
Intha roundtable vachu solren. Audience a easy purinchika mudiyum . Ithuku munnadi vantha rajamouli , kamal, lokesh roundtable alavukku itha view panna neenga ninaikira success cinema industry ku varum
Ganavel was good and great at his vision and understanding. Ratha was normal but others was just in the name of Liberalism hiding in there comfort zone as they are safe and they don’t have issues. We cannot compare Marvel franchises with Indian movies which means Indian movies are best in their own but not in par with Hollywood movies. Even now James Cameron can make a three hour movie and people go to theaters and watch if you have good content then no one can stop. Secondly music went national even before what Rajiv said probably he is in anemia he has watch some of old interviews of SPB where he said when Illairaja was recording in Mumbai people didn’t like as it was not easy so before only music reach Nation and Illaraja took music to nation. All are just behind star directors like Puskar Parthiban etc Ganavel was right in his talks no biased talk to Favoritism for anyone. One of the biggest masala movies were KGF and pusha was telegu versions of KGF, nothing great about the movies including RRR another super duper worst masala. Nothing what is great in this masala movies nothing 😳. Kargi, Jai Bheem, Sila Nerangali silla manidargal, witness, Tannakaran, Natchathiram Nagargiradhu, Thiruchitrambalam, Nenjuku Needhi etc. best movie made in 2022 with no doubt is Kadaisi Vivasayi.
Add English Subtitles
Kasu illa ba cost of cinema is becoming tooo high 🙃 I want everyday movies too watch
But disasters while watching we will not come to theater
sad that no one mentioned about Kadaisi Vivasayi that surprised me
very true!!! what a gem it was!
❤️🔥
@42.11 mins.. mr.pushkar ,please let us know where to find theatres that lets you smoke in the breaks cuz we didnt't find any at vikram vedha songs (hindimade)
Rajiv Menon🔥
Same conversation happened in Galata plus... Almost the same only think change here is love today....
This year belong to Vikram, PS and Kantara 💪🏻
It could have been great if this was in English. We got to know that our tamil directors thoughts.
If all the Tamil films/series there on OTTs are available with proper subtitles then not these interviews are?
English subtitles please!! Telugu viewers here!!!
Thank u krishna❤️
SHAWSHANK REDEMPTION BEST EVER WRITTENED FILM .IF U DIDNT SEE IT. U MISS A MARVELOUS MOVIE OF ALL TIME
Maybe the Tamil cinema council should create an OTT platform.
Agree with gnanavel -yes Tamil cinema has all genre.
rajiv menon i am not expected here, but he is more informative , partiban alwell
What is job for Anchor ..... ,Not an easy job Anchoring Roundtable like BR
Director rathna Kumar Anna 💙✨
tj gnanavel sensible😍😍
Where are the real directors? Pa Ranjith? Vetri maaran? Selvaraghavan?
More regional is more universal 🔥
-"Rishab shetty"
20:27 spelling mistake 😂😂
Very good interaction..... Congratulations
Anyone here knows what happened to inbox show cinema viketan ?
Those who r wondering whats the term "adda" means (like me)
- a place where people gather for conversation. 😁😉
When you are going to do Kannada film directors adda,.... We are waiting eagerly
Neel, Rishabh okay then?!
Guys let's celebrate gargi that's best of film in 2022
1.14.45 plot twist background laugh 😂
I expected more writing points from Ratna Anna bcz he has the ability to tell a big matter with simple example 💜 little disappointed ☹️
Missing mottai... #BR
Avar Galatta Kku poitaaru
Where is kadaisi vivasayi Manikandan 🥲