Easy way to see it S superstar A all-star B borderline all-star C consistent average player D do you actually want this player F freakin trash like so everyone can see
Totally agree! I thought he should have been in the top 50 list too. He has only played three years, and only one of those years was bad. (And he still hit for power that year!) And last year was an MVP type year. Definitely should have been an A
Die hard Cubs fan. Totally agree. What a talented division! From Yadi to DeJong, Yelich to LoCain, Javy to Bryant, Marte to Taillon, Votto to Castillo. I challenge ANY OTHER team to win more than 90 games in this division besides these 5. Maybe Dodgers or Sox. Maybe Astros. But TOUGH
*Says he’s ranking them abt how they are now* Him ranking the first player: well since he had some “ok” years in the past I’m gonna bring him down a little bit
Slinky 3 he specifically said 2016 tho as an example that was 4 seasons ago counting 2019. Last year he wasn't nearly as good and using the previous season isn't too aggregious as we're only a quarter through this year
When a person doesn’t know baseball, The best shortstops are: Peter Alonso, Jose Ramirez, Arron Judge, James Paxton, Luis Severino, Brett Barrett, Jacob Degrom, and Edwin Diaz.
He is one of the best fielding shortstops in the game which he toatally missed, has the most raw power of any shortstop, can steal 20-30 bases a year at least, and hits for average. B tier
Trevor Story is literally and All-Star how you gonna drop him in the B category?? I was expecting S but at least put him in A. He’s definitely as good as Turner and others guys in that category
OKAY, HAVE NOT SEEN ENOUGH OF HIM.... YOU SAUD HE WAS ONE OF THE REASONS WE ARE “WINNING” HE IS A ALL STAR, DO YOU NOT KNOW WHAT ALL STAR MEANS?!!?! DO YOU EVEN WATCH THAT FREAK OF NATURE PLAY THE GAME, ABSOLUTELY UNBELIEVABLE
Hes ranked the 21st short stop defensively online. It's absolutely ridiculous. He has some amazing defense and is one of the most consistent and defensively sound short stops out there. Hes a top player.
I’m a die hard Red Sox fan but i think that’s a little disrespectful to didi,I understand that he’s hurt but he’s actually not as far away from returning as many think he is,his defense is top notch and he has shown that he can bring elite offense consistently so in my mind I think he belongs right along there in the “A” tier
Wow, you might be the only red sox fan I actually like! I agree with you 100 percent Didi is a baller regardless even if he hasn't played yet this season
So one of the reasons the AL central leading MINNESOTA TWINS are doing so good is there B rated (ALL STAR) shortstop POLANCODADDY. So let’s just sit here and think for a minute about how on gods green earth the AL STARTING SHORTSTOP IS A B!? This is just getting to be just a joke at this point. POLANCODADDY DESERVES to be an S! SKOL VIKES BABY!
lol as a reds fan i watch this guy get on base at least twice every night and maybe top 3 best fielding shortstops in the league. I see him with several gold gloves in the future.
Kinda think Story should be an A tier. He’s been playing like an mvp and for the start of the season for the Rockies he was our only offense... oh and he’s definitely one of the best fielding shortstops in the game, don’t @ me
Disagree about Jose Iglesias. You aren’t happy with him hitting .250-.260, his average is higher than that. This year he is hovering around .290-.300. And he is crazy smooth. I personally see him as a B shortstop
2nd half of 2017 then coming back from suspension. He was terrific. Starting off great this season. We've seen enough from him that he is and will be a great player. If you do this again in October Jorge Polanco will definitely be in A tier. Hopefully
You called Marcus Semien one of the better fielders at Shortstop... My dude he has 86 errors in the past 5 years. That’s around 17 errors a season at short.. that’s not ideal.
Nick Ahmed is better than that, saves countless runs with his gold glove and he is a decent hitter. 16 home runs and 33 doubles last year playing a defensive position.
I’m a Yankees fan, so obviously I’m a little frustrated with your ranking of Didi Gregorious, but your ranking of Correa and Bogaerts blows my mind. Correa is one of the best players in the league and probably should have been in the S tier along with an s tier bump for Simmons. There is a no way that Bogaerts is in A tier. Maybe top of the B tier, but there is no way that he is as good as Delong, Simmons, Turner and zero chance he is as good as Correa.
Congrats on finishing college and I think that this would make a great mini series. Maybe you and TheAntOrtiz can do a rebuild challenge together of some sort
I personally collect trae turner autographed cards, as I am a big collector on insta, dudes a freaky fast man, only wish he didn’t say that racist stuff on Twitter a few years ago
Dude you're so right about Dansby Swanson, so many of my fellow Braves fans think that he's the greatest thing to ever bless a baseball diamond. He's a great, fun guy but there is no reason that Charlie Culberson should not be starting over him
Putting andelton Simmons at an a and almost and s is like saying that John Gochnaur is the best shortstop of all time If you don’t know who that is there’s a reason
dylan white people only look at offense but they fail to realize just how much defense can win or lose you games and Crawford is top 3 defensively at short and he’s historically not that bad at the plate he’s just having an off year so far
@@westbronco9066 Crawford starting struggling on defense towards the end of 2017. This isn't an off year. This is Brandon Crawford. A mediocre player on all ends of the field.
RiverCatsGaming Crawford was still top tier defensively last year but he’s been pretty abysmal on both sides so far this season but he has looked better defensively and offensively recently so we’ll see
@@westbronco9066 Crawford had a -0.9 UZR in 2018, and I could tell that's how he played. He has lots of trouble making plays he should make, plays that we take for granted that he made in 2014-2015. He's not a top tier defender, and hasn't been on since 2016.
RiverCatsGaming I watch every game and I can tell that he’s not as good as he used to be but last year he was still middle of the road in some stats and elite in others he’s definitely not “mediocre” and defensively he’s still one of the better shortstops in the league
Maybe it’s due to the fact that he’s never really been anchored to one team, but Jean Segura is such an underrated bat. And he has been for a few years.
As a pirates fan, c-tier for cole tucker is fair. He’s shown some glimpses of greatness but hasn’t reached the level that Tatis or Anderson have already
Easy way to see it
S superstar
A all-star
B borderline all-star
C consistent average player
D do you actually want this player
F freakin trash
like so everyone can see
Just because of your greediness you get no likes
Cameron fish who commented they need to see it
F is failure
Cameron Fish he gets more like than you
I can see Paul DeJong as A material
I was expecting a ten minute rant on Amed Rosario from you
Haha yeah me too
Suprised this video was not an hour video
Do more of this plz, every position
Washington Rojoskins people have to make them first
Or he can?
story not getting A is ridiculous
5 tool player come on Marc!
Nicholas Callas routine plays...
Totally agree! I thought he should have been in the top 50 list too. He has only played three years, and only one of those years was bad. (And he still hit for power that year!) And last year was an MVP type year. Definitely should have been an A
I know i watched his 3rd baseman one and was just waiting for nolan and i was waiting for trev to be dropped in S tier
I gave him S on my list
Yeah, Arenado and Story had basically the same year in 2018, and actually did have the same WAR.
Story is the only shortstop in MLB history to have 30 HR, 25 steals, and 40 doubles in a season but, whatever.
Cheech Jose Ramirez Ik he is a third baseman but he did better 35+ HR, 30+ Steals, 40+ Doubles, Highest Average too.
@@brianspahiuStory actually had 35+ HR and 40+ Doubles, and Ramirez had less than 40 Doubles and only hit .270. (Story hit .291) Just sayin
Marc I’m sorry but even as a Padres fan Trevor Story is easily and A tier, he is just so good and is very consistent
Jeremy Epner I agree with Story being A, but Seager I believe is A too.
@@boilerbeast0619 tatis is superstar 😉
You should rank MLB stadiums on tier list
Yes!!!!!!
DeJong is honestly underrated 🤷♂️ A / B tier is where he’s at
Baseball Fan ohh yeah
Marc said A Teir
Baseball Fan lol, coming from a cardinals fan😂😂
Agree
100% agree
I’m a Brewers fan and I 100% agree with the Paul Dejong rating
I'm a brewer fan
Cubs fan here and yeah i agree
Respect. I’m cardinals. But respect
Die hard Cubs fan. Totally agree. What a talented division! From Yadi to DeJong, Yelich to LoCain, Javy to Bryant, Marte to Taillon, Votto to Castillo. I challenge ANY OTHER team to win more than 90 games in this division besides these 5. Maybe Dodgers or Sox. Maybe Astros. But TOUGH
Marky Bleazard yeah our division and AL East are the most talented division for sure it’s not even close honestly
Can you do a reaction to your free agent predictions?
i’m mad
- “i don’t care about previous years”
- (1 min later) tim anderson is playing like an A tier but based on previous years I can’t
I heard that and was so confused.
Agreed with everything then you dropped Trevor Story in the B tier
Josh Hight Bro same he’s literally and all start
Trevor Story hit just as good as Nolan Arenado
Trevor Story hit just as good as Nolan Arenado
B seems pretty fair honestly. He obviously has better numbers because of where he plays.
@@ponyexpress5274 yea but like nolan arenado, he is really good on the road as well, he deserves an A
*Says he’s ranking them abt how they are now*
Him ranking the first player: well since he had some “ok” years in the past I’m gonna bring him down a little bit
Slinky 3 he specifically said 2016 tho as an example that was 4 seasons ago counting 2019. Last year he wasn't nearly as good and using the previous season isn't too aggregious as we're only a quarter through this year
When a person doesn’t know baseball,
The best shortstops are: Peter Alonso, Jose Ramirez, Arron Judge, James Paxton, Luis Severino, Brett Barrett, Jacob Degrom, and Edwin Diaz.
i mean you can spell aaron
lol Brett Barrett
Trevor story hit for power hits for average and has a cannon at shortstop and still not a elite shortstop 😤😤
And he steals bases
But, he plays at Colorado. His numbers pretty much double it’s realistic amount.
I agree with everything except I think Carlos Correa should be an S, Ahmed Rosario should be a D, and Jean segura should be an A
Polanco is better than lindor
I agree with Correa
Story a B tier player? Smh 🤦🏻♂️
he rly waited till the last person to ruin the whole list lmao
Should have at least been an A. He is twice the player of all the other B players.
He is one of the best fielding shortstops in the game which he toatally missed, has the most raw power of any shortstop, can steal 20-30 bases a year at least, and hits for average.
B tier
Trevor Story is literally and All-Star how you gonna drop him in the B category?? I was expecting S but at least put him in A. He’s definitely as good as Turner and others guys in that category
Bryce Bienvenu facts 💯
He is definitely not S😂😂
Chris he’s borderline. Another big year and he’ll be considered elite.
Deadass A Headass maybe but considering 17 and 16 idk🤷♂️
Correa and Story both should be S tier
OKAY, HAVE NOT SEEN ENOUGH OF HIM.... YOU SAUD HE WAS ONE OF THE REASONS WE ARE “WINNING” HE IS A ALL STAR, DO YOU NOT KNOW WHAT ALL STAR MEANS?!!?! DO YOU EVEN WATCH THAT FREAK OF NATURE PLAY THE GAME, ABSOLUTELY UNBELIEVABLE
Congratulations for graduating bro!! Godbless with more quality content 💯
Bro Polanco should be higher, his war is 2nd in the AL
Bennett Isdabest yea
He hates the twins in every list he makes for some reason probably because we beat up on Degrom a few weeks ago
Jackson Matthies facts😂
I don’t care about WAR. Show me how WAR is calculated
@@GiraffeNeckMarc you sound like a petty ass weirdo ! Old man
First you dont put Story in your top 50 video and now you put him in B tier. Story is a solid A teir shortstop. Bro what are you smoking
Fact
Understand why Correa isn’t S-Tier but my bias demand that I be sad
I agree, if he was S Tier then we could call the the Triple PR Treat at SS (Which rhymes if u say S, S not Shortstop)
2017 probably
Hes ranked the 21st short stop defensively online. It's absolutely ridiculous. He has some amazing defense and is one of the most consistent and defensively sound short stops out there. Hes a top player.
@@GaelRivera. uhh look at Correa's stats this year. He's a top 3 shortstop EASY
That’s truly Absurd he is easily a top 4 shortstop
I’m a die hard Red Sox fan but i think that’s a little disrespectful to didi,I understand that he’s hurt but he’s actually not as far away from returning as many think he is,his defense is top notch and he has shown that he can bring elite offense consistently so in my mind I think he belongs right along there in the “A” tier
Wow, you might be the only red sox fan I actually like! I agree with you 100 percent Didi is a baller regardless even if he hasn't played yet this season
Seager is finally getting back into the swing of things!
Sam Scherer batting .310 the past 7 games Seags is back and I’m excited
So one of the reasons the AL central leading MINNESOTA TWINS are doing so good is there B rated (ALL STAR) shortstop POLANCODADDY. So let’s just sit here and think for a minute about how on gods green earth the AL STARTING SHORTSTOP IS A B!? This is just getting to be just a joke at this point. POLANCODADDY DESERVES to be an S!
SKOL VIKES BABY!
Freddie galvis is so underrated he usually hits around 290 and he a top 3 defender at shortstop
Who else is in your top 3
TG-RocketLeague & GTA Crawford and Simmons and right outside is Ahmed
Gabriel Freedman yeah I put those guys at 2,3,4 and Javier Baez at 1. Cmon man
TG-RocketLeague & GTA ok yeah I forgot about javy I agree with u
Story is an A and semien is a C
He’s a mets fan so he probably doesn’t get to watch those 2 guys play as much
Hey Marc, what’s the website where you can make the tier list?
Tierlist.com
My daddi Goes meow thx
SerGon23 No Problem
Um Jose Iglesias is hitting almost .300 sooooo yeahhh
Andrew Beck he said he barley is hitting .250 lmao dude doesn’t do research but acts like he know ps baseball
tsarg96 exactly
He’s literally having a great season. Why does this guy act like he knows what he’s talking about if he doesn’t
lol as a reds fan i watch this guy get on base at least twice every night and maybe top 3 best fielding shortstops in the league. I see him with several gold gloves in the future.
Kinda think Story should be an A tier. He’s been playing like an mvp and for the start of the season for the Rockies he was our only offense... oh and he’s definitely one of the best fielding shortstops in the game, don’t @ me
I agree, he is just as good as a hitter as Nolan Arenado
Disagree about Jose Iglesias. You aren’t happy with him hitting .250-.260, his average is higher than that. This year he is hovering around .290-.300. And he is crazy smooth. I personally see him as a B shortstop
Sean finally a Reds fan that doesn’t support other shortstops
Jose Iglesias has such a good bat this year he should be a B tier
Yeah, and he's definitely not just an average shortstop. Amazing defense and he's hitting over .300 (for now)
Not really surprised to see Seager starting off Slow especially when he came back from 2 surgeries
And he's finally starting to hit again!
Giraffe you are my favourite UA-camr thank you for being awesome
I havent watched but corey seager is forever my SS
Yes indeed
GO DODGERS
Thank you so much for not ripping on Seager!
2nd half of 2017 then coming back from suspension. He was terrific. Starting off great this season. We've seen enough from him that he is and will be a great player. If you do this again in October Jorge Polanco will definitely be in A tier. Hopefully
He already is A tier
i know you hate the Yankees but didi B tier come on in the playoffs last year he was so clutch
You called Marcus Semien one of the better fielders at Shortstop... My dude he has 86 errors in the past 5 years. That’s around 17 errors a season at short.. that’s not ideal.
Garrett Wilson errors is not a good stat to measure a fielder
VinFTW You can’t tell me a good defender who averages 17 errors a season. Id love for you to try.
Keep ‘em coming!! Great work!!
Fyi: Trea Turner is also injured for a longer period. Regarding your comment on Didi Gregorious
Georg Maidic but he’s actually played a game, unlike Didi.
Marc you are hands down my favorite youtuber ever. I can watch you for hours and hours. Keep up the great work
you should do a tier test of all the MLB stadiums
Y E S
This was probably the best MLB tier list I've seen.
Nick Ahmed is better than that, saves countless runs with his gold glove and he is a decent hitter. 16 home runs and 33 doubles last year playing a defensive position.
CONGRATS ON GRADUATING MAN!!!
Dude Simmons should be an easy S tier
Keegan Lathery nah he isn’t doing that good this year
Agreed
Simmons is A
Really enjoyed this video would like to see more of this!
Do top ace starting pitchers tier list
You do know Brandon Crawford started the All-Star Game last year right?
Golden Apple Reviews he based it off this year only this years stats
GONNA NEED ONE OF THESE VIDS FOR EVERY POSITION!!
I was scared you were gonna put Javy Baez and Paul DeJong in the same catagoty for a second.
Are you doing all other positions?
Love the vids keep it up!!!
You gonna do this for every pos?
Didi is underrated
Didi coming back around June and he should be A or
S but I understand that Tommy John surgery on his right elbow is probably why
bcm200 Didi in S tier😂😂
Seriously? Didi wouldn't even be in S tier even at his best point!
Jose iglesias is a B lower part of B but definitely a B. His glove is amazing and he’s doing good in Cincinnati with the bat
mannyp 664 respect ✊🏻
I think Marc is hating on Jose Iglesias because he hit the game winning homer for the Reds to beat the Mets. Lol
Wes Hill 🤣🤣🤣
How aren’t u a big youtuber yet ur actually a good youtuber
I’m a Yankees fan, so obviously I’m a little frustrated with your ranking of Didi Gregorious, but your ranking of Correa and Bogaerts blows my mind. Correa is one of the best players in the league and probably should have been in the S tier along with an s tier bump for Simmons. There is a no way that Bogaerts is in A tier. Maybe top of the B tier, but there is no way that he is as good as Delong, Simmons, Turner and zero chance he is as good as Correa.
Love your channel dude
Congrats on finishing college and I think that this would make a great mini series. Maybe you and TheAntOrtiz can do a rebuild challenge together of some sort
I love your vids keep it up
wheres manny machado??
On 3rd base where he belongs
Gg”s for graduating! And keep up the good work
Bogaerts should be in the S range. Hes been a top 3 offensive shortstop in each of the last 2 years and has how many silver sluggers?
Why did u choose Cole tucker for the pirates?
THANK YOU FOR SAYING PAUL DEJONG IS UNDERRATED, Has had an terrific start to the season
You said u were gonna do a best player out of every state video
Rex Mixes he did say that
Did you watch the video, I address that
GiraffeNeckMarc I watched but I already had commented it and realized afterwards
Trevor story is a A tier no dought
Glad to see Arcia have some respect despite a bad hitting year last year
Marc u know baseball !!!
U see I ain’t the only who thinks trea Turner is a god
I personally collect trae turner autographed cards, as I am a big collector on insta, dudes a freaky fast man, only wish he didn’t say that racist stuff on Twitter a few years ago
What u gonna do 😔
Dude you're so right about Dansby Swanson, so many of my fellow Braves fans think that he's the greatest thing to ever bless a baseball diamond. He's a great, fun guy but there is no reason that Charlie Culberson should not be starting over him
What website did you use
Putting andelton Simmons at an a and almost and s is like saying that John Gochnaur is the best shortstop of all time
If you don’t know who that is there’s a reason
Brandon Crawford is amazing at short. Wth
dylan white people only look at offense but they fail to realize just how much defense can win or lose you games and Crawford is top 3 defensively at short and he’s historically not that bad at the plate he’s just having an off year so far
@@westbronco9066 Crawford starting struggling on defense towards the end of 2017. This isn't an off year. This is Brandon Crawford. A mediocre player on all ends of the field.
RiverCatsGaming Crawford was still top tier defensively last year but he’s been pretty abysmal on both sides so far this season but he has looked better defensively and offensively recently so we’ll see
@@westbronco9066 Crawford had a -0.9 UZR in 2018, and I could tell that's how he played. He has lots of trouble making plays he should make, plays that we take for granted that he made in 2014-2015. He's not a top tier defender, and hasn't been on since 2016.
RiverCatsGaming I watch every game and I can tell that he’s not as good as he used to be but last year he was still middle of the road in some stats and elite in others he’s definitely not “mediocre” and defensively he’s still one of the better shortstops in the league
How is miggy ro in d?? He's hitting almost .300 this season and is an awesome fielder, barely gets any errors either
What did you graduate with?
Carlos Correa is S tier no doubt ❗️💯
Maybe it’s due to the fact that he’s never really been anchored to one team, but Jean Segura is such an underrated bat. And he has been for a few years.
love the vids
Jose Iglesias has the 35 best avg right
When you gonna do best player from each state in the US?
Jose Iglesias is hitting .295 this year. Way above .250 and 60. Gotta be B tier with combo of insane D
How do u have Dejong over Didi and Didi is coming back soon
Congrats on graduating Marc
where did you get the list from
There are no F Tier Starters because if they were F Tiers they wouldn’t be starting
Gael Rivera have u seen Richie Martin?
Orioles r a different breed of a team they’re a triple a team at best
I know, but an F means Failure and if he was a failure then they would sign a cheap shortstop or promote one of their current minor leaguers
Gael Rivera one would think but it’s the orioles
IK but if he’s good enough to make it to the Majors you have to give him some credit
Please do a firstbaseman tier list josh bell is carrying the pirates
You are right
how do you put correa and dejong in the same tier:|
It’s so hypocritical to put Delong A but not Story
That’s what I’m saying lol
Story has to be in A. His defense is very underrated and just look at his offensive stats.
KOT4Q did a tier list for best Point Guards and Shooting Guards
Apple Fanboy that’s great!
Bets player from each state?
I’m so glad you put Paul dejong where you did I think he’s having a very good season starting off
Mark: I’m going to rank how I feel about them RIGHT NOW
Also mark: I’m going to take into account Tim Anderson has had some bad previous years
Love this and thanks for putting some respect on dejong
As a pirates fan, c-tier for cole tucker is fair. He’s shown some glimpses of greatness but hasn’t reached the level that Tatis or Anderson have already
You should do these for each position. This was worth watching