simpla fly most positive that Avisail Garcia is nowhere near as good as Howie Kendrick bro, Kendrick is batting like .320 and is helping the Nats get back in the run for the division, wth has Avisail Garcia done?
I guess I’m Bias but u can’t say Gio Urshela is overrated. He’s come in clutch plays a solid third base hits for average. U can’t base everything off of prior stats, this is about right now.
@@huntrc1978 umm yeah he is. have you not seen his stats in the last 2 weeks?? and regardless of the last 2 weeks is pretty underrated player. he's got a good arm, drives in runs and has over 300 hrs.
Thank you for acknowledging Castellanos. People are saying he’s having a bad year because his homeruns and average are down, but he’s one behind Xander Boegarts for the AL lead in doubles. If he didn’t play half his games in Comerica Park he could easily hit 20+ HRs a year.
Dude, we Cubs fans know Kyle Schwarber isn't that good, he was amazing in the 2016 world series but after that he has been ok hitting but HORRIBLE defensively (COUGH COUGH MISSING A CATCH COUGH COUGH PUNCHING A WALL)so we all know he is bad and he's only slightly overrated because there's still idiots who think he is a fricken deity or something. Also I went to a Cubs game and Cubs fans were literally booing Yu Darvish so i guess your rating was fair???? He's pitching ok as I'm writing this but yeah we still expect him to be good and he probably won't be anytime soon or ever.
Gio is JUST AS GOOD defensively as arenado and Chapman if not, a TINY bit worse, and he is WAY better than Machado, and still is hitting like an all-star!!
slm2455 shut the hell up😂😂 Do you even watch baseball??? Arenado, Chapman, And Machado are leaps and bounds better than Urshela, Wait until you get Andujar back and Gio becomes a sub and probably gets traded, he’s only a rental for the yanks and for people to think he is all that great is absurd
I’m a Phillies fan and I usually disagree with your Phillies rankings but I think that Nola ranking was perfect he is having a bad season so far so I respect it
I don’t think jay Bruce will stay this hot either, just riding his wave right now. Nola is having a weird year so I have to agree with you. Good video from a philly fan 👍🏼
Great video but I feel the past doesn't need to reflect on the current season (talking about Urshela)he's a very good hitter when needed and overall he's produced pretty good numbers and is definitely not on the level of arenado and chapman at defense. He is very good though. Just my thoughts,great video Marc!
Andujar is the third baseman of the future but Urshellas defence is definitely up there with those guys that you mentioned. He makes pretty much every play and has an arm that is unbelievable.
I'm a Yankees fan and I agree with Urshela. Yeah he is having a good year and he is fine at third now, but he will eventually go back to what he was with the Indians. It's like people have never seen a hot start before
He's a great pitcher, but when he mess up, he tends to do it big time, plus he's a really hot headed pitcher and he's not very good during postseason, so probably that's the reason why he's been called a washed-up player. He's slightly overrated in my opinion, but I definitely can see why most people won't agree with that, which is cool. I've said a lot of times that he's overrated, but can't argue with facts; yet I still find a lot of hype about him, considering that he's not going through his best season (not bad either, though)
His career era is low 2s lmao. He has a 3.00 era and ppl melt down. He’s the best pitcher of the last 10-15 years and it’s not close at all. Where do you get your numbers from my guy? Go look at a stats site. His career era is a full point lower than mad max or Greinke or Verlander. You can call him a hot head all ya want but so is trev Bauer so is machado so is Donaldson etc...... but ppl don’t have the same hate for them. The reason ppl take a jab at you is because your the best. He was the best of his time. Degrom owns that now, even tho he can’t throw hardly any innings and is soft as crap. He’s good when he does pitch. But degrom ain’t starting 32+ games throwing 220 innings. That’s never gonna happen. Kershaw looked fine last post season! Ppl said the same thing about a rod u til 2009 rolled around and he smashed the crap outta the supposed beat pitching Phillies. Him and Matsui carried that team. I respect you got an opinion, we all do. But please go look the numbers up and then look up the numbers of who you think was the best In The 2010s and I believe you’ll change your mind. Good day
Alexis Toro McNeil is a bit overrated in my opinion, yeah he hits for average and is versatile but has basically no power. Mets fans (including Marc) call him a superstar and he’s not
@Evan Wladkowski I can understand that, but a good contact hitter can come in clutch. Even though he doesn’t hit that many homeruns, he gets a decent amount of doubles and some triples. He mostly hits singles, but getting on base is critical because when a power hitter comes up, and he’s on base, he will have a good chance to score. I don’t think he’s a superstar, but I still think he’s a quality player
ik you probably dont care but i do what do you think of hanser alberto or trey mancani? both are hitting .300 or near it and i need something to root for as an orioles fan. what you think?
Im yankees fan and urshela is underrated he hasnt got the playing time in the past the Yankees gave him a shot look what happened yes IF urshela hits like this the rest of the season Andujar wont be there next year
Marc, applause for not overrating your Mets guys. You did this video perfectly, save for two: David Price is, has been, and always will be, overrated. Brandon Crawford? You need to watch more Giants games, his defense is still Gold Glove caliber. Now, his offense sucks( he's being asked to be a #5 or # 6 hitter when he's a #7 hitter, at best). If you were going after him on that, fair. Watch some Giants games, you'll change your mind.
Nathan Macias He’s been sitting mid 90’s this season. His velocity is no where near what it was even last year. His slider is way better than it was in the past though.
I am a die hard Yankees fan and Gio Urshela is doing very good at the time but like Mark said you don't go from being not a good player at all to being this awesome third baseman Didi came back early so now Urshela has time off and I don't think he will be our third baseman.
bcm200 Gio is our third baseman, DJ is utility, dj Can play anything so, that means we can rest somebody and put him in. Which also means everyone will have a lot of playing time.
@@GiovannMan yes but even though Gio is doing very good we have to remember he was brought up from triple a and right now he isn't playing Torres at second Didi at short and D.j at third that just how it is, but don't hate I really think gio is doing very good.
I completely agree with your list except for I think Shwarber isn’t as overrated as you think he is. He’s shown he can be great and he’s young. He is also starting to pick it back up recently. Not a Cubs fan either 😁
Marc, I agree with everything in this video except for Kyle Schwarber being overrated. Some delusional cubs fans may think he is incredible but most rational fans know what he is capable of. Also, he has been hot in June so hopefully those are signs to come. From a FSU fan, please beat Clemson.
Crawford's defense wasn't good earlier this year but it has really picked up. He looks like his old self again defensively. Offensively is another story. I think he was one of the best in the past 8 or 9 years or so overall. But it also kinda seems like you hate the Giants lol
I believe that a lot of people still get excited to see Albert Pujols play because he's definitely an All Star legend, because everybody knows that he is currently not even close to the great player he was once, but the guy's still a legend, and regardless of his current playing, people want to see THE guy. At least, that's what I think
He’s the best pitcher of the 2010s and maybe the best in 20 years. His era is a full point better than Scherzer or Greinke or Verlander. He’s so good when he has a 3 era ppl lose their mind. So he’s just on a level of his own. Funny how they hold him to a different standard but mike trout can’t even make the playoffs and when he does he hits a lowly 1 something against the royals smh.
As a Giants fan, I think Crawford is the best fielding SS, but he’s been terrible this year. As a fielder, he’s a top 3 SS, but overall he’s definitely not a top 5 SS. He’s been hitting below .200 since July of 2018
I would say that Pujols is properly rated. People have accepted that he's a shell of his former self. But fans still go because it's still Pujols. He's a legend even if he is an old and declined. Plus, it's fun to watch him break milestones like he did a few days ago with his 200 HR as an Angel.
Love this list as a Yankees fan I understand urshella isn’t actually as good as we consider him but I dont think fully overrated more of slightly overrated or properly
You should do a video like this but with retired players
Chatmin is over rated
Yea I agree monkeytut
@@benscreativeworld5390 chatmin? Really?!
MoNkEyTuT123 yes that would be wonderful for off season
I 100 percent agree about Clayton Kershaw
You should make a video on the best 3 players from each team
Daniel X I agree
I agree
Notice how he moved Cespedes from Slightly underrated to properly rated lol.
If you’re from Pittsburgh you for sure know who Tyler Glasnow is. He and Meadows are gonna be in our nightmares for quite some time
Howie Kendrick = Underrated
Avisaíl Garcia = Overrated
simpla fly most positive that Avisail Garcia is nowhere near as good as Howie Kendrick bro, Kendrick is batting like .320 and is helping the Nats get back in the run for the division, wth has Avisail Garcia done?
simpla fly he has maybe played in less games but it still doesn’t take away from the fact that he has done more to help his team in a lot less games
You should make it overrated or underrated video with MLB teams
arenado deserves his own tier of underrated for not being on either of these lists
Say it louder
I guess I’m Bias but u can’t say Gio Urshela is overrated. He’s come in clutch plays a solid third base hits for average. U can’t base everything off of prior stats, this is about right now.
Thank you so much for putting Eaton in the slightly underrated category. There are still Nats fans who say that he's the worst hitter on the team.
What team do you think Bartolommeo colon is best known for playing on I think Mets or rangers
UA-cam made a mistake, GiraffeNeckMarc should have 1 Mil, Why doesn’t he?
Smoak is underrated
Murphy and Cespedes slightly underrated.
Bruce is slighty underrated
Ahmed and Winker are underrated
Schwarber is still the player he is. He hits over 30 HRs and he has improved in the field how can u say he is overrated???
I’ve been on the Matt Chapman train since he was called up. My old boss knew him personally so I kinda grew attached
Slightly underrated = Jay Bruce
Ha. You see the last play tonight 😂
@@huntrc1978 what's your point??
Fr
The Real Doey he isn’t underrated
@@huntrc1978 umm yeah he is. have you not seen his stats in the last 2 weeks?? and regardless of the last 2 weeks is pretty underrated player. he's got a good arm, drives in runs and has over 300 hrs.
Thank you for acknowledging Castellanos. People are saying he’s having a bad year because his homeruns and average are down, but he’s one behind Xander Boegarts for the AL lead in doubles. If he didn’t play half his games in Comerica Park he could easily hit 20+ HRs a year.
Kyle Schwarber= properly rated. He had a slow start but is having better numbers now not including his slightly low average
Can you do a Manager Tier list
Dude, we Cubs fans know Kyle Schwarber isn't that good, he was amazing in the 2016 world series but after that he has been ok hitting but HORRIBLE defensively (COUGH COUGH MISSING A CATCH COUGH COUGH PUNCHING A WALL)so we all know he is bad and he's only slightly overrated because there's still idiots who think he is a fricken deity or something. Also I went to a Cubs game and Cubs fans were literally booing Yu Darvish so i guess your rating was fair???? He's pitching ok as I'm writing this but yeah we still expect him to be good and he probably won't be anytime soon or ever.
Definitely should update both of your lists, great video
Gio is JUST AS GOOD defensively as arenado and Chapman if not, a TINY bit worse, and he is WAY better than Machado, and still is hitting like an all-star!!
slm2455 shut the hell up😂😂 Do you even watch baseball??? Arenado, Chapman, And Machado are leaps and bounds better than Urshela, Wait until you get Andujar back and Gio becomes a sub and probably gets traded, he’s only a rental for the yanks and for people to think he is all that great is absurd
I’m a Phillies fan and I usually disagree with your Phillies rankings but I think that Nola ranking was perfect he is having a bad season so far so I respect it
Collin Rhoades same
I don’t think jay Bruce will stay this hot either, just riding his wave right now. Nola is having a weird year so I have to agree with you. Good video from a philly fan 👍🏼
Im a Yankees fan but I’m not comparing gio to Arenado or Chapman.I even have his jersey and I’m not saying he is Chapman
I just noticed I wasn’t subbed after watching you for a real real long time!🤪😂
Can’t WAIT to see Marc’s Edwin Encarnacion trade reaction video 😆
Where machado Guerrero and Harper or are you doing different players from the first one
He did those in his first video.
Ok I was just making sure thx
Eaton is overrated. The Nats traded Lopez, Dunning, and Giolito for him. Giolito is 10-1 with a low 2 ERA.
Great video but I feel the past doesn't need to reflect on the current season (talking about Urshela)he's a very good hitter when needed and overall he's produced pretty good numbers and is definitely not on the level of arenado and chapman at defense. He is very good though. Just my thoughts,great video Marc!
You should do most clutch players on each team.
Mike trout wouldn’t make that list
Andujar is the third baseman of the future but Urshellas defence is definitely up there with those guys that you mentioned. He makes pretty much every play and has an arm that is unbelievable.
I'm a Yankees fan and I agree with Urshela. Yeah he is having a good year and he is fine at third now, but he will eventually go back to what he was with the Indians. It's like people have never seen a hot start before
Kyle Hendricks has been the cubs most elite pitcher, despite having a rough last game with the dodgers, he has been great
As a angels fan Lucroy should be slightly underaged dark knight should be overrated
Keep it up man, love the content and your attitude
Havent watched it, but alread know its a banger
Kershaw mostly has an under 3 ERA and people call him washed
He's a great pitcher, but when he mess up, he tends to do it big time, plus he's a really hot headed pitcher and he's not very good during postseason, so probably that's the reason why he's been called a washed-up player. He's slightly overrated in my opinion, but I definitely can see why most people won't agree with that, which is cool. I've said a lot of times that he's overrated, but can't argue with facts; yet I still find a lot of hype about him, considering that he's not going through his best season (not bad either, though)
His career era is low 2s lmao. He has a 3.00 era and ppl melt down. He’s the best pitcher of the last 10-15 years and it’s not close at all. Where do you get your numbers from my guy? Go look at a stats site. His career era is a full point lower than mad max or Greinke or Verlander. You can call him a hot head all ya want but so is trev Bauer so is machado so is Donaldson etc...... but ppl don’t have the same hate for them. The reason ppl take a jab at you is because your the best. He was the best of his time. Degrom owns that now, even tho he can’t throw hardly any innings and is soft as crap. He’s good when he does pitch. But degrom ain’t starting 32+ games throwing 220 innings. That’s never gonna happen.
Kershaw looked fine last post season! Ppl said the same thing about a rod u til 2009 rolled around and he smashed the crap outta the supposed beat pitching Phillies. Him and Matsui carried that team. I respect you got an opinion, we all do. But please go look the numbers up and then look up the numbers of who you think was the best In The 2010s and I believe you’ll change your mind. Good day
Underrated: McNeil
Overrated: Harper
Alexis Toro McNeil is a bit overrated in my opinion, yeah he hits for average and is versatile but has basically no power. Mets fans (including Marc) call him a superstar and he’s not
@Evan Wladkowski I can understand that, but a good contact hitter can come in clutch. Even though he doesn’t hit that many homeruns, he gets a decent amount of doubles and some triples. He mostly hits singles, but getting on base is critical because when a power hitter comes up, and he’s on base, he will have a good chance to score. I don’t think he’s a superstar, but I still think he’s a quality player
McNeil is like the next Ichiro Suzuki, no power, but knows how to hit
@Purple Cheez I agree
He is not the next ICHIRO🤣🤣🤣 don’t ever compare Jeff McNeil to ichiro
ik you probably dont care but i do what do you think of hanser alberto or trey mancani? both are hitting .300 or near it and i need something to root for as an orioles fan. what you think?
Marc is an underrated UA-camr
CoolKids he’s really byes look at his 2019 season predictions
Love tuning into your videos huge baseball fan
Im yankees fan and urshela is underrated he hasnt got the playing time in the past the Yankees gave him a shot look what happened yes IF urshela hits like this the rest of the season Andujar wont be there next year
Even last year, no one was really talking about how good Nola was so I would put him in the properly rated category.
Nah overrated
Power rankings soon?
Gio Urshela is obviously not overrated that’s so wrong!
Wow! No Braves players? You should at least do Freeman or Acuña
You should do start bench cut where you take three players and start one bench one and cut one
Marc, applause for not overrating your Mets guys. You did this video perfectly, save for two: David Price is, has been, and always will be, overrated. Brandon Crawford? You need to watch more Giants games, his defense is still Gold Glove caliber. Now, his offense sucks( he's being asked to be a #5 or # 6 hitter when he's a #7 hitter, at best). If you were going after him on that, fair. Watch some Giants games, you'll change your mind.
Kershaw has been my favorite player for a long time
Im a phillies fan and i 100% agree with u with Aaron Nola. Hasnt lived up to the hype
Do a tier list of relief pitchers in the MLB
Marwin Gonzalez is literally hitting like .350 since April.
love the content, keep it up
People: Chapman is washed up
Me: still throws 105 hmm
Nathan Macias He’s been sitting mid 90’s this season. His velocity is no where near what it was even last year. His slider is way better than it was in the past though.
Nathan Macias yes thay is me to
@@kylewoodring706 yeah but he starts showing the heat around post season
Buddy chapman isnt that great any more
nick random lool
Nice video though man
Video on top 3 best players on each team.
He did best player on each team and I don’t see a giant difference with that
How is Schwarber overrated? He has been hot last few weeks and is a huge power hitter... Bad rating
Kershaw looks amazing this year
U should do ur opinion on the overrated/underrated skippers
Would you consider Matthew Boyd an underrated player?
I am a die hard Yankees fan and Gio Urshela is doing very good at the time but like Mark said you don't go from being not a good player at all to being this awesome third baseman Didi came back early so now Urshela has time off and I don't think he will be our third baseman.
bcm200 Gio is our third baseman, DJ is utility, dj Can play anything so, that means we can rest somebody and put him in. Which also means everyone will have a lot of playing time.
@@GiovannMan yes but even though Gio is doing very good we have to remember he was brought up from triple a and right now he isn't playing Torres at second Didi at short and D.j at third that just how it is, but don't hate I really think gio is doing very good.
You should rank pitchers signature pitches. For example Clayton Kershaw’s 12-6 curve and Chris sale’s slider
GiraffeNeckMarc= Underrated
Kyle Schwarber I think is slightly overrated just because the way he is playing right now at leadoff man
You should do overpaid/underpaid
Good idea
Matt Carpenter hit around 45 homes last year
Swing and a miss on Urshela 😊
It’s been a couple of years since the last one, but you should do an updated version of your jersey collection. That would be a sick video.
was Josh Bell in the last video?
*puts Andrew Miller at slightly overrated*
Then says,
“But I don’t think he’s as bad as people say he is.”
that's why it says slightly
This video kinda makes sense
I completely agree with your list except for I think Shwarber isn’t as overrated as you think he is. He’s shown he can be great and he’s young. He is also starting to pick it back up recently. Not a Cubs fan either 😁
Marc, I agree with everything in this video except for Kyle Schwarber being overrated. Some delusional cubs fans may think he is incredible but most rational fans know what he is capable of. Also, he has been hot in June so hopefully those are signs to come. From a FSU fan, please beat Clemson.
Finally someone else who understands what type of player schwarber is. I thought I was the only one
Rougned Odor is never overrated. That punch was 10/10 and you can't call that overrated.
I’m a Very big cubs fan but Kyle Schwarber is very overrated
Nola is underrated
Crawford's defense wasn't good earlier this year but it has really picked up. He looks like his old self again defensively. Offensively is another story. I think he was one of the best in the past 8 or 9 years or so overall. But it also kinda seems like you hate the Giants lol
No braves, thanks
I believe that a lot of people still get excited to see Albert Pujols play because he's definitely an All Star legend, because everybody knows that he is currently not even close to the great player he was once, but the guy's still a legend, and regardless of his current playing, people want to see THE guy. At least, that's what I think
If you look at what the Nationals gave up for Adam Eaton, you might want to rethink your thoughts.
Lucas Gioloto is the only top prospect the white Sox got from that trade
The other prospects are playing atrociously
Except for Lucas Gioloto
KLAYTON KERSHAW IS, say it with me, O-V-E-R-R-A-T-E-D
i agree
Thank you for putting KERSHAW there, finally somebody realizes he is still an above average pitcher
He’s the best pitcher of the 2010s and maybe the best in 20 years. His era is a full point better than Scherzer or Greinke or Verlander. He’s so good when he has a 3 era ppl lose their mind. So he’s just on a level of his own. Funny how they hold him to a different standard but mike trout can’t even make the playoffs and when he does he hits a lowly 1 something against the royals smh.
Who else is a white sox fan and is triggered because there were no sox players
Giolito very underrated
Giolito is the best pitcher in baseball. Yeah I said it
THANK U FOR SHOWING RESPECT TO PRICE!!!!! 🙏🏻🙏🏻
👎Yankees fan
He almost just threw a no hitter
Thankyou for putting marte on underrated and when he did use those steroids he was horrible
You are such a yankee fan hatter!! i love itttt
Hey never ever say Dustin Pedroia is not the best second baseman because he is
😂
He's really not
@@fahad_nyc MVP! MVP! MVP!
As a Giants fan, I think Crawford is the best fielding SS, but he’s been terrible this year. As a fielder, he’s a top 3 SS, but overall he’s definitely not a top 5 SS. He’s been hitting below .200 since July of 2018
Do a tier list on mangers please😃
Urshela=overrated ❌ incorrect
I would say that Pujols is properly rated. People have accepted that he's a shell of his former self. But fans still go because it's still Pujols. He's a legend even if he is an old and declined. Plus, it's fun to watch him break milestones like he did a few days ago with his 200 HR as an Angel.
I love these videos
The Dark Knight never had powers anyway lmao
GEO IS A BEAST ?????
As a Cubs fan I agree that Kyle Schwarber is overrated lol
Same here
A are a bad cubs fan if you watch this a month later
I only know Glasgow because we traded him for Chris Archer, and I am also a big stat nerd, so
Oof the Pirates in that trade though
Probably goes down as one of the worst trades of all time.
Are the Mets a World Series team still?
yu darvish is getting better since the beginning of the season. His good outings are getting more and more, although he has a few meltdowns
Also im sorry chris paddack is overrated af. The dude got sent down to double A. Like come on now..
He got sent down because he had an innings limitation
Love this list as a Yankees fan I understand urshella isn’t actually as good as we consider him but I dont think fully overrated more of slightly overrated or properly
Teddy Kurtz no, he’s insanely overrated