@@candicegilkes Is rdr2 not the most detailed game you have ever seen Candice? I can't imagine the hrs that we're spent researching those years to make the game so detailed.
Stop! You violated the law. Pay the Sheriff a fine or serve your sentence. Your stolen carrot is now forfeit. (resist arrest) THEN PAY WITH YOUR BLOOD!
There's other things I've seen he hasn't done yet. Nothing big, little details like the variety of insect life varies in different climates but the insects aren't in the in game Compendium. I've been playing my current playthrough since September of 2021, in the epologue now for over a year. It's like a Holodeck Vacation. I have my own, missions and challenges in the game. I never get bored, I just hang out in my Rdr2 world. 🐎💨👀 🤠
My theory regarding the wooden leg: I like to think that the Strawberry shop owner is a Civil War veteran. Assuming he is around 60 years old in 1899, he could have easily enlisted in the army as a volunteer in 1861. Mind you, limb amputation was the most common surgical procedure executed at that time (three out of four surgeries, or about 60.000 operations; the introduction of the Minié ball was quite bone-shattering). The shop owner's leg reminds me of a specific prosthetic from around that time found in Woodhull, Ilinois. You can search it up yourself!
That actually puts some perspective in the situation of the homeless fake Civil War vet you meet, maybe they planned the shop keeper to interact with him about stolen valor?
The theatre ticket secret is a really cool one. Honestly amazing how something so missable, and such a small item can be held in your inventory, for hundreds of hours until you decide to go to the theatre and watch something there. A specific theatre at that. I'd assume some people would have grabbed the ticket and just forgot about it. Then not noticed when they eventually did go to that theatre. It's small things like that, which put this game Levels above any other game ever made in terms of detail. I truly think red dead 2 will be unmatched in terms of detail until the videogame market eventually dies.
The ticket is actually one of the requirements for gold on the Gilded Cage mission that’s how I knew about it. You know you get a ticket from that stage performer lady? The one you meet in Van Horn in the bar & you have to fight the Sherry Giant. I forgot she gives you a ticket for most of my playthrus & once I realized what I was missing I felt so stupid lol
I'd never seen that cutscene where John bribes his way out of jail! Eating that carrot at the end was a nice touch! The Strawberry general store owner's wooden leg is a great find, my first thought was that he lost his leg in the war, but he seems a bit young to have taken part in the Civil War... Another awesome video!👍
I'm still surprised at how much this game has to offer, even after all this time there is still new things to find every now and then. Love your videos btw it always has a nice ambiance with the music and all it kinda feel cosy
@@stoicaliviu510 Yet people are STILL finding new things is his point. "Every youtuber", yet still didnt get all of them, there's still plenty not found yet.
The Wapiti one hurts so much, such chaos and death for getting the natives of Rain Falls out of that land for the oil, ending up with their tribe being destroyed just for the land to be dry, i never knew this but i did visit the reservation as John expecting a oil field to be there and instead only found some remnants of a driller and the place was deserted, all of that for nothing, thats so sad
It's so frustrating, the fact that not only did they do horrid things to the people there while trying to get them to leave to get to the oil, but also so many of their young men got manipulated by Dutch and lost their lives fighting a completely pointless fight! Rain Falls lost his last child, his home, and so many people for nothing!
@@lacytaylor1501exactly... it hurts because we know Rains Falls was a caring leader that loved his people and loved peace, Eagle Flies was like his father but young and naive with blood ready to boil but ultimatly he wanted his people to be free and respected, and Dutch made him boil, the wapiti indians got totally destroyed by everyone around them without ever doing anything to anger anyone, incredible how a small part of the story has so much depth
I love these because I still play it to this day and there is just endless little details and small AD/Designs/names of buildings/random NPC dialogue etc. that go unappreciated, but also goes to show how seamless it all is that it immerses us in the world first few times you play.
I’ll try to overlook the fact that John stole a regular carrot, before eating a wild carrot after buying his freedom, and trying to look like a tough guy while chewing 😅
Anyone else notice at 7:25 the throwaway comment about a book by "Balzac"? A Rockstar running gag about slyly including the world Ballsack into their games. Like the Bawsaq stock exchange in GTA V. 😉
I can’t believe I never discovered the last one! I love hanging around the market because theres a nice atmosphere and I often approach the stalls to see whats for sale. Edit: Reminds me of that unmarked food stand in Hove beach in GTA 4.
You should make a video about these mysteries! The WHY TREES: ua-cam.com/video/yj2xTo0aoD0/v-deo.html Martha’s Grave: ua-cam.com/video/G2A7MyQb3U4/v-deo.html
It's just my theory: The store owner with prosthetic leg was probably because of some timber work accident. Some cities in RDR2 have characteristic in job area. Just like in Annesburg, where mostly the residents are miner, Saint Denis's are industrial / business worker, Rhodes's are farmer, and Strawberry's are lumberjack.
It's been great fun to watch your creativity and confidence grow through your writing and video editing on this channel. And now you're scripting little scenes for us at the end of your vids? Talk about building a sharp skill set. Keep up the fine work, Strange Man!
So, you may have already covered this, or maybe you haven't, but there's a dead body and a face carved in the cliff in the Grizzlies East right above the Moonstone pond just West of O'Creagb's Run. To expand, there's a dead body that is a man who hung himself. Then, you go up a ladder and there's a face carved into the cliff where John/Arthur sketches it into his journal, (you can inspect it, at the time I was John and was hunting the Legendary Bharati Grizzly Bear) alongside that there is a chest with a Special Health Cure recipe/pamphlet, an apple, jewelry, and rum. There's also a pickaxe and a bucket of water, but obviously you can't interact with those. Hope to see you cover this, I'm curious!
You’d think the ancient tomahawk would have a stone edge not a metal one And I hate going through the market and always accidentally bumping into npcs and feeling like an ass lol
I hate that market, it's almost like you can't not bump into someone, or somehow offend someone no matter how hard you try not to. Real awkward atmosphere there, captures the market mood perfectly.
@@jordanthomasina2854 it's like they did it on purpose to screw up your game... Crazy busy place is Saint Denis anyway, but that market, just drains me does all 10 yards of it. Peace.
You the best man. I just started playing rdr2 last month and it just keep me going and going. There's a lot of mysteries out there and I want to know more about it instead of finish the game fast. Thanks man for this vid. 😘
There is a random encounter with a hunter you can have were he has his leg trapped in a bear trap. If you help save him from it later you meet with him outside the general store in Strawberry where he will offer you to put one item on his tab in the general store as a reward for saving his leg/life. Not sure if there is any correlation there between how the hunter almost lost his leg and merchant losing his. I also like to think that Micha blew it off in his and Arthur's escape from the town when everyone got massacred haha... 😅
I find it weird that the mad preacher near valentine/strawberry he says “he’s always watching” At first I thought of it he’s mad but dwelled on it more and and came to the conclusion it must be the strange man. The preacher says are you the signal and it got me thinking Arthur was the signal for John meeting the strange man and doing the task the strange man told him idk I might be overthinking it but it’s cool to think about.
Maybe the wooden leg man were in the civil war or something maybe not but who knows. And the tomahawk maybe is Rains fall or eagle flies.keep up the good work :)
One detail I didn't notice until just now as I'm finishing chapter 6 is when Arthur points his gun to Micah and such, in the background behind him you can see miss Grimshaw reaching for the gun, and ofc when John appears she has It in her hands
Also recently I've kind of realized that Rockstar games (mainly GTA IV & V/RDR 1 & 2) are sort of half-RPG games. RDR 1& 2 even having a karma system that has the NPCs react to you differently depending on how honorable you are. Same with bounties in a state. You're sort of meant to be fully pretending you're living & surviving as an outlaw/gunslinger in 1899 - 1907.
I’ve done the electric chair missions as John at least 4 times. It’s not exclusive to Arthur. I have no idea where you got that idea from. It is completely available in the epilogue.
Don't take GOTY wards seriously, that's just critics deciding, theg don't even know about all this. If a video game is art you can't be really objective about it, it affects everyone differently.
The fact the strange man keeps rdr2 alive for those of us that loved it is awesome.. Best game ever in my book.
completely agree!
You and I have the same book, then 👍
You and I have the same book then
@@candicegilkes Is rdr2 not the most detailed game you have ever seen Candice? I can't imagine the hrs that we're spent researching those years to make the game so detailed.
@@kygreenskeeper8326 we're?
I laughed out loud at the guard's reaction to John stealing a carrot. Was not expecting this one to be so funny. Nice work!
John's Hosea moment
"I stole a carrot, and the sheriff decided I would swing for it!"
Then running around the corner and eating it 😂 really clever and that has become one expensive carrot
Stop! You violated the law. Pay the Sheriff a fine or serve your sentence. Your stolen carrot is now forfeit.
(resist arrest)
THEN PAY WITH YOUR BLOOD!
@@harveywallbanger3123 the fact that i understood the reference makes this more funny
I love that you played through the Carrot Heist for us, thank you for that.
And even better, he even got the unique cutscene where you get out of jail without paying.
The fact that this guy is still going, absolutely blows my mind 😂🙌
There's other things I've seen he hasn't done yet. Nothing big, little details like the variety of insect life varies in different climates but the insects aren't in the in game Compendium. I've been playing my current playthrough since September of 2021, in the epologue now for over a year. It's like a Holodeck Vacation. I have my own, missions and challenges in the game. I never get bored, I just hang out in my Rdr2 world. 🐎💨👀 🤠
@@mrnobody3161 skill issue
.
Yeah can't wait to see videos once GTA 6 comes out, if it ever will...
Strange Man and RedsDeadBaby are the best RDR2 channels forever
My theory regarding the wooden leg: I like to think that the Strawberry shop owner is a Civil War veteran. Assuming he is around 60 years old in 1899, he could have easily enlisted in the army as a volunteer in 1861. Mind you, limb amputation was the most common surgical procedure executed at that time (three out of four surgeries, or about 60.000 operations; the introduction of the Minié ball was quite bone-shattering). The shop owner's leg reminds me of a specific prosthetic from around that time found in Woodhull, Ilinois. You can search it up yourself!
That actually puts some perspective in the situation of the homeless fake Civil War vet you meet, maybe they planned the shop keeper to interact with him about stolen valor?
this was before penicillin. an infected mosquito bite and they'd amputate.
The theatre ticket secret is a really cool one. Honestly amazing how something so missable, and such a small item can be held in your inventory, for hundreds of hours until you decide to go to the theatre and watch something there. A specific theatre at that.
I'd assume some people would have grabbed the ticket and just forgot about it. Then not noticed when they eventually did go to that theatre.
It's small things like that, which put this game Levels above any other game ever made in terms of detail.
I truly think red dead 2 will be unmatched in terms of detail until the videogame market eventually dies.
The ticket is actually one of the requirements for gold on the Gilded Cage mission that’s how I knew about it. You know you get a ticket from that stage performer lady? The one you meet in Van Horn in the bar & you have to fight the Sherry Giant. I forgot she gives you a ticket for most of my playthrus & once I realized what I was missing I felt so stupid lol
I'd never seen that cutscene where John bribes his way out of jail! Eating that carrot at the end was a nice touch!
The Strawberry general store owner's wooden leg is a great find, my first thought was that he lost his leg in the war, but he seems a bit young to have taken part in the Civil War...
Another awesome video!👍
I'm still surprised at how much this game has to offer, even after all this time there is still new things to find every now and then.
Love your videos btw it always has a nice ambiance with the music and all it kinda feel cosy
these are not new things , every youtuber has presented them
@@stoicaliviu510 Yet people are STILL finding new things is his point. "Every youtuber", yet still didnt get all of them, there's still plenty not found yet.
The Wapiti one hurts so much, such chaos and death for getting the natives of Rain Falls out of that land for the oil, ending up with their tribe being destroyed just for the land to be dry, i never knew this but i did visit the reservation as John expecting a oil field to be there and instead only found some remnants of a driller and the place was deserted, all of that for nothing, thats so sad
It's so frustrating, the fact that not only did they do horrid things to the people there while trying to get them to leave to get to the oil, but also so many of their young men got manipulated by Dutch and lost their lives fighting a completely pointless fight! Rain Falls lost his last child, his home, and so many people for nothing!
@@lacytaylor1501exactly... it hurts because we know Rains Falls was a caring leader that loved his people and loved peace, Eagle Flies was like his father but young and naive with blood ready to boil but ultimatly he wanted his people to be free and respected, and Dutch made him boil, the wapiti indians got totally destroyed by everyone around them without ever doing anything to anger anyone, incredible how a small part of the story has so much depth
I love these because I still play it to this day and there is just endless little details and small AD/Designs/names of buildings/random NPC dialogue etc. that go unappreciated, but also goes to show how seamless it all is that it immerses us in the world first few times you play.
I knew a man with a wooden leg named Smith.
(Sorry, I don't know the name of his other leg.)
...terrible lol
@@mickyb.8014 🤠🤏
Very good
🤣🤣👍thank you for mentioning that joke!
@@ChibiPanda8888 🤠🤏
I’ll try to overlook the fact that John stole a regular carrot, before eating a wild carrot after buying his freedom, and trying to look like a tough guy while chewing 😅
The electric chair mission has some Arthur’s funniest conversation while he take the criminal back to Saint Denis.
I just robbed the Strawberry store moonshine still and now I feel awful. The storeman kept saying "I work hard!" and to know he has only one leg...
I hogtied him and knocked him out in his basement after I took everything he had down there. Almost feel bad now, almost.
The market segment is now one of my favorite things lmao. So thrilling up until the end!
The year is 2089. I am on my deathbed. I open UA-cam for one last video. “70+ never seen before details in rdr2” I die happy
I have over a 1000 hours put into this game and this man is still showing me things I never knew about...
Damn
The carrot one is amazing crazy all the insane details in this game and how interactive and reactive the game world is.
Anyone else notice at 7:25 the throwaway comment about a book by "Balzac"? A Rockstar running gag about slyly including the world Ballsack into their games. Like the Bawsaq stock exchange in GTA V. 😉
Always a good day when the strange man uploads.
I can’t believe I never discovered the last one! I love hanging around the market because theres a nice atmosphere and I often approach the stalls to see whats for sale. Edit: Reminds me of that unmarked food stand in Hove beach in GTA 4.
This man is almost single handedly keeping the game alive😂👏
There's also a hidden store next to the butchers near the train station in Saint Denis if you've not covered it
How's doing cowpoke
Dude admired that wooden leg like it was something out of this world
Mind blowing that there’s still new details being found
None of these are new it’s recycled over n over just lots of time between the same facts 😂
This game took 8 years to make and was one of the most expensive games ever made no joke
these videos always make me notice what I haven't noticed when I've played, good job 👍
That transition 3:46 was SMOOTH
Well spotted, super smooth ain't it?!
You should make a video about these mysteries!
The WHY TREES: ua-cam.com/video/yj2xTo0aoD0/v-deo.html
Martha’s Grave: ua-cam.com/video/G2A7MyQb3U4/v-deo.html
It's just my theory: The store owner with prosthetic leg was probably because of some timber work accident. Some cities in RDR2 have characteristic in job area. Just like in Annesburg, where mostly the residents are miner, Saint Denis's are industrial / business worker, Rhodes's are farmer, and Strawberry's are lumberjack.
It's been great fun to watch your creativity and confidence grow through your writing and video editing on this channel. And now you're scripting little scenes for us at the end of your vids? Talk about building a sharp skill set. Keep up the fine work, Strange Man!
An amazing channel about an amazing game!
R* may give up on RDR2... but Strange Man never will.
This game is INSANELY detailed!
i am glad this very strange man still keeps red dead fresh in our minds after 4 years.
What a great video! I’m amazed at the many details Red Dead seems to have. Also, your editing is very nice!
John eating that carrot at the end was worth the money to the police officer rather than the Seller.
It was more sweet that way xd
So, you may have already covered this, or maybe you haven't, but there's a dead body and a face carved in the cliff in the Grizzlies East right above the Moonstone pond just West of O'Creagb's Run. To expand, there's a dead body that is a man who hung himself. Then, you go up a ladder and there's a face carved into the cliff where John/Arthur sketches it into his journal, (you can inspect it, at the time I was John and was hunting the Legendary Bharati Grizzly Bear) alongside that there is a chest with a Special Health Cure recipe/pamphlet, an apple, jewelry, and rum. There's also a pickaxe and a bucket of water, but obviously you can't interact with those. Hope to see you cover this, I'm curious!
Amazing stuff. No idea that veg market was there. The wooden leg too, omg! And the oil rig in Wapiti? You always deliver!
This game took up half my hard drive on my PS4. No wonder… it was full of so much additional content that wasn’t even used!!
You’d think the ancient tomahawk would have a stone edge not a metal one
And I hate going through the market and always accidentally bumping into npcs and feeling like an ass lol
I hate that market, it's almost like you can't not bump into someone, or somehow offend someone no matter how hard you try not to.
Real awkward atmosphere there, captures the market mood perfectly.
@@mickyb.8014 FR you described it well lol 😂
@@jordanthomasina2854 it's like they did it on purpose to screw up your game...
Crazy busy place is Saint Denis anyway, but that market, just drains me does all 10 yards of it.
Peace.
I am replaying the game just observing all the details. I understand why you are still uploading content this game has an insane amount of detail!
Loved the video such interesting finds love the music that you used during your video thank you for sharing this with all of us
You’re gonna make me replay the game soon man. ❤
The fact that Rdr2 has so many secrets and details to discover it’s just truly amazing. And i love it! Because Strange Man is still going strong 💪
You the best man. I just started playing rdr2 last month and it just keep me going and going. There's a lot of mysteries out there and I want to know more about it instead of finish the game fast. Thanks man for this vid. 😘
I heard something about the general store owner being a civil war vet. So he must have lost his leg during that time
Fun fact about the Tomahawk; it is actually a pipe tomahawk. It's a pipe and an axe.
Funnily enough I was smoking a pipe watching this and had no idea. I thought it was a thumb grip!
5 minutes into smoke and scalp and she gives you this loot
What do you do?
There is a random encounter with a hunter you can have were he has his leg trapped in a bear trap.
If you help save him from it later you meet with him outside the general store in Strawberry where he will offer you to put one item on his tab in the general store as a reward for saving his leg/life.
Not sure if there is any correlation there between how the hunter almost lost his leg and merchant losing his.
I also like to think that Micha blew it off in his and Arthur's escape from the town when everyone got massacred haha... 😅
So many hundreds of hours, and you still manage to show me something new almost every time! You are a true legend of the west!
Kifflom ? Oh so youre one of them. I knew it !
The comedic timing of the carrot theft is gold 🤣
$35 bounty for stealing a carrot is wild 💀
You are a gift my friend, keep up the amazing work with these videos.
Im convinced you were a creator for this! I love your content!
All the amazing details of this game, even the ones I already know, make me fall in love with this game more and more
how can you not love this game??
I find it weird that the mad preacher near valentine/strawberry he says “he’s always watching” At first I thought of it he’s mad but dwelled on it more and and came to the conclusion it must be the strange man. The preacher says are you the signal and it got me thinking Arthur was the signal for John meeting the strange man and doing the task the strange man told him idk I might be overthinking it but it’s cool to think about.
The greatest Red Dead Redemption 2 content creator of all time!
Absolutely love this channel
Prosthetic legs were sadly common at the time among civil war veterans
35 dollar bounty for stealing a carrot
Is carrot kidnapping some kind of joke to you?
The editing is REALLY good on these videos
The whole carrot thing was absolutely amazing 😂
another day another SM banger video
Here is a German and he say: "I love your videos, man!" You are the best Strange Man I now.
Never knew he had a wooden leg!
Arthur: *Steals a carrot*
Officer: So you have chosen death. *SWING WITHIN A WEEK!*
The Greatest Work of Art of all time. 5000 hours in this game and I'm damn proud of it.
Seeing videos like these get me even more excited for GTA 6
I cant believe I never noticed that about the markets
The Carrot: 😎
Nice one Strange Man. 👍🤣
Lore for the Tomahawk I'm gonna make up now and say it used to be Eagle Flies.
That carrot skit was amazing 😂
Thanks for the content mr strange man
9:54 "you'll be swinging within the week." dude it was a carrot 😂 reminds me of The Black Knight with "it was only a turnip."
This game is an absolute blast, too bad that I was stuck in a depression and couldn't muster the subtlety that the game deserves.
You know it's early when the video only has 2 likes
We are still finding new things about this game and it is incredible. If this is happening with RDR2, imagine how massive GTA6 is going to be.
another day to live by when strange upload a new video!
This guy’s gonna make the best gta6 videos
Gta 6 wont be so detailed I think
Loved the end of the video 😂😂😂 John eating the stolen carrot 🥕
Amazing video
Maybe the storeowner in Strawberry fought in the civil war and lost his leg there🤔
LOL love the dramatic arrest for the heinous crime of stealing a carrot. :D
Today I helped a Veteran get his prosthetic leg back from his horse. Amazing level of detail in this wonderful game.
That ending lmao good stuff SM
Maybe the wooden leg man were in the civil war or something maybe not but who knows. And the tomahawk maybe is Rains fall or eagle flies.keep up the good work :)
One detail I didn't notice until just now as I'm finishing chapter 6 is when Arthur points his gun to Micah and such, in the background behind him you can see miss Grimshaw reaching for the gun, and ofc when John appears she has It in her hands
Also recently I've kind of realized that Rockstar games (mainly GTA IV & V/RDR 1 & 2) are sort of half-RPG games. RDR 1& 2 even having a karma system that has the NPCs react to you differently depending on how honorable you are. Same with bounties in a state. You're sort of meant to be fully pretending you're living & surviving as an outlaw/gunslinger in 1899 - 1907.
It's always about the details, with this game.
Subscribed❤ you know your stuff and I'm really enjoying the content
I’ve done the electric chair missions as John at least 4 times. It’s not exclusive to Arthur. I have no idea where you got that idea from. It is completely available in the epilogue.
It's never been available in the epilogue for me, only while playing with Arthur could I do it.
This was one of the best of the latest ones.
I wonder if you shoot the wooden leg then, come back later if its bandaged or even with hopping around on a crutch
Amazing video mate, as always great job !!!
You do an amazing job!!!
And this somehow didn't win game of the year still boggles me
Don't take GOTY wards seriously, that's just critics deciding, theg don't even know about all this.
If a video game is art you can't be really objective about it, it affects everyone differently.
I bet that, a hundred years from now, this guy is still going to come across new things in the game. Just watch!
And still waiting on news from rockstar for gta6 😂
@@Ricky-qq2bz You're not wrong!
Most people still alive rn would be dead 💀
Man, i didn't know about the peg leg! Wow, i play this game for the second time and never thought about that
in case anyone was wondering $0.22 per hour would be about $7.03 today