Gauntlet Series | Bowers & Wilkins Pi8 Earbuds vs. Devialet Gemini II Earbuds

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 8 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 88

  • @JamesBond-gg4wg
    @JamesBond-gg4wg Місяць тому +8

    The Gemini 2 are phenomenal, I just bought them and they are already my reference headphones (I own 2 very expensive large headphones), I never believed that earbuds are capable of reaching such a high level audio performance and Iam glad I didn’t buy cheaper headphones from Sony or Bose, they are not in the same league and I highly doubt if there are headphones that are capable of reaching such a high end audiophile performance.

    • @ronontech
      @ronontech  Місяць тому +1

      Thanks for sharing.

  • @winstonliu6348
    @winstonliu6348 Місяць тому +2

    Great review and comparison.
    I have both earbuds and totally share the same findings as Ron. I would go further to say the bass on the Gemini ii goes an octave lower than the Pi8. I find the bass on the Pi8 rolls off earlier, although it has more body albeit less detail than the Gemini ii.

  • @saitaro
    @saitaro 2 місяці тому +2

    Thank you, Ron! I haven't had a change to test the B&W's yet, but from my experience with Gemini 2 I agree they have a lot of control. The bass, the highs... everything almost perfect... These were the only TWS that felt truly better than my current Sennheiser Momentum 2's. I didn't like the mic though :) B&W's are too obviously better in that regard.

  • @ColiBen
    @ColiBen Місяць тому +1

    Which is the earbud you would recommend out of all the ones you have ever tested? The priority is sound quality, specifically having the big punchy bass, while also delivering clear and high-quality sound across all frequencies. What is the absolute best available on the market?

    • @simpledude5974
      @simpledude5974 Місяць тому

      I 2nd this question.
      Which one homie???

    • @ronontech
      @ronontech  Місяць тому +1

      @ColiBen Sorry for the late response.
      My number one right now is the Denon PerL Pro earbuds.

    • @mr.casanova7145
      @mr.casanova7145 Місяць тому +1

      ​@@ronontech why

    • @Chuchin619
      @Chuchin619 28 днів тому

      ​@@mr.casanova7145 They have that personal sound technology, it really improves the sound

    • @Patrickmathieu0482
      @Patrickmathieu0482 16 днів тому

      ​@@mr.casanova7145hi guys ! I am one of the first followers of Ron. I really love what he is doing !! You can trust him on the Denon Perl Pro. The momemtum 4 have a brighter sound and instruments separation is a little bit better BUT the immersion you get with the Denon is just phenomenal !!!!! It's like being surrounded by 12 speakers !! The vocals are better, more presence, bass is excellent! Denon sounds louder by a mile! So, if you listen to them, the experience with the Denon is superior! Plus, they are more comfortable than the momemtum 4! At the end of my training with the momemtum 4, my ears bleed! (Joking 😂).

  • @maximusjoseppi5904
    @maximusjoseppi5904 7 днів тому

    I've had a miserable experience with my pi8s... Constant connectivity issues all the time with the left ear bud, right ear bud, both ear buds sometimes, cutting in and out, really slow to connect even when they do.
    They sound great when they work but I hate them.
    Just bought some Gemini 2s, they come in a couple days, hopefully they'll scratch that luxury itch

    • @ronontech
      @ronontech  6 днів тому +1

      That's unfortunate. I've had no issues with mine. Let me know what you think of them Gemini IIs.

    • @maximusjoseppi5904
      @maximusjoseppi5904 5 днів тому

      @ronontech got them today, there is a very noticeable difference between these and the pi8s. These are significantly better with their bass capability. It's better in range, clarity, and power. They're also way more comfortable with zero connectivity issues.
      Not only is the auditory performance much better but the app is way way way better. BW should be ashamed of the app they offer their customers for $400 devices.
      I've had the Sony 1000xm5s, Bose QC 2s and ultras, Sennheiser mtw 4s, Jabra elite 10 Gen 1 and 2, Bowers pi8s, and these Gemini 2s... These are the best by a decent margin.

  • @benjiotigerz1754
    @benjiotigerz1754 Місяць тому +2

    I have an iPhone and use Spotify but would move to Apple Music or another music streaming application if it betters my quality but which one of these is the best? I have no limits on budget thanks

    • @electroduval831
      @electroduval831 27 днів тому

      Its going to depend on what you are streaming from but Tidal and Qobuz stream at the highest quality. Whether or not you can notice that difference on even the best wireless headphones on highly debatable at best. There are videos of audiophile experts who can't tell the difference if using Bluetooth.
      That being said, you can definitely hear the difference with a good set of wired headphones and an amplifier.

    • @Hdih738hj
      @Hdih738hj 26 днів тому

      az80 and pi8 I planned to buy az80, but the salesperson recommended me to buy pi8. Even if I told him that I use an iPhone, the salesperson said there is a difference, and I mainly listen to rock music.

    • @ManDm87609
      @ManDm87609 22 дні тому +1

      Same here but with android. I turned to deezer because of the bad quality of Spotify. When I turned to deezer I thought I bought new earbuds/headphones.

  • @shereifrostom
    @shereifrostom 2 місяці тому +2

    Thanks Ron, been waiting for this one. Curious, do you feel the Geminis sit deeper in the ear? I've got the PI8's and while great and very comfortable, I feel they don't insert as deep as I'd like (tried all sorts of tips but not foam), compared to Momentum 4's for example which feels more wedged in. I wonder if that's affecting the bass and ANC performance potential.

    • @falcodarkzz
      @falcodarkzz 2 місяці тому +1

      Ive had the same issue with PI8, cant get the right insertion. May have to sell them sadly as theyre amazing otherwise

    • @ronontech
      @ronontech  Місяць тому

      To me, they don't sit deeper. They don't have as much of the earbud sticking out.

  • @sebastianheuser1221
    @sebastianheuser1221 2 місяці тому +1

    Good work as always! Thank you so much for all the afford that you put into you reviews.
    Take Care! 😉👍

  • @mangbecak1
    @mangbecak1 2 місяці тому +2

    Oooof this should be tough af!

    • @ronontech
      @ronontech  2 місяці тому +2

      It was...I loved it!!

  • @disastrousemouse
    @disastrousemouse Місяць тому

    I’m on an iPhones be, so lossless retransmission makes the difference if they’re close.

  • @Randomvids01987
    @Randomvids01987 2 місяці тому +1

    Thanks for the review I got the Gemini 2 I was waiting for them to come with the second generation cause always the first it's not the best

  • @Amateur2k
    @Amateur2k 2 місяці тому +13

    Some of you who are in the search for a second opinion with regards to the main players in "premium" earbuds may find the following interesting: I have owned Sennheiser MTW3, Gemini 2, Technics AZ80 and now I just ordered Pi8. Between the first 3 which I tested extensively, I have only returned the Gemini 2 ones :). The reason? I cannot stand the sound coming from "titanium coated drivers", it sounds completely harsh to me (high frequencies), regardless of the manufacturer. If it's titanium coated driver, it's a no go for me, it was similar with B&O H95 premium over-ear which I have sold because of the same reason. So between MTW3 and AZ80 I like them both, they are really different, MTW3 sounds modern and the "Highs" are the best in the industry, also imaging and sub-bass. But AZ80 sounds classically good, like a legacy HiFi system in your ears, with best soundstage on the market. I wait to see them against PI8

    • @ronontech
      @ronontech  2 місяці тому +5

      Thanks for sharing.

    • @StructureMastery
      @StructureMastery 2 місяці тому +2

      I share the same opinion as you about the Gemini II ! Returned mine for this reason

    • @jasonMB999
      @jasonMB999 Місяць тому

      Now what in the world are the "Hls"

    • @Amateur2k
      @Amateur2k 29 днів тому +1

      @@jasonMB999 High frequencies. What else??

    • @jasonMB999
      @jasonMB999 29 днів тому

      @@Amateur2k Hls is no abbreviation for high frequency

  • @unonice
    @unonice 2 місяці тому

    Think I'm gonna grab the Blowers and Wilkens Pi8 .. but I might wait until Black Friday 🛒🛒🛍️ ..
    We shall see ..
    Side Note , I have the Pi7 SE earbuds and the PX8 over ear headphones .. 😁🙌🏾

  • @cobbyessilfie2357
    @cobbyessilfie2357 2 місяці тому +1

    I really want to see B&W pi8 vs Status between 3anc.

    • @ronontech
      @ronontech  2 місяці тому +1

      I have that comparison planned. Stay tuned.

  • @causeydawg
    @causeydawg 2 місяці тому

    Would have to agree…close call. Not 100% sure the B&W have better N/C.

  • @simon5433
    @simon5433 2 місяці тому +1

    Thank you so much for this comparison, but which of these are louder? This is very important for me

    • @ronontech
      @ronontech  Місяць тому +1

      IMO, the Pi8 are louder.

    • @mr.casanova7145
      @mr.casanova7145 Місяць тому

      ​@@ronontech for phone calls i saw the pi8 mic is better so far

    • @mr.casanova7145
      @mr.casanova7145 Місяць тому

      ​@@ronontech for phone calls i saw the pi8 mic is better so far

  • @inick122492
    @inick122492 Місяць тому

    What about volume ceiling? I like loud and wanna know how these top out?

    • @Chuchin619
      @Chuchin619 28 днів тому +1

      Pi8's are really loud

  • @evoxf1
    @evoxf1 2 місяці тому +1

    Next technics az80, and i want just one name what should I buy,
    I am co fused between jabra elite 10 gen 2 and technics

    • @ronontech
      @ronontech  2 місяці тому +2

      I'll try to make that happen.

    • @evoxf1
      @evoxf1 2 місяці тому

      Thanks man, i just need to buy one but there are so many, so confused, as I am in india i will have to ship them from US and also warranty issue might happen for some brands, i want a reliable thing, i am not into airpods

    • @Fredo.heavyy
      @Fredo.heavyy 2 місяці тому +1

      I’m also considering the Jabra elite 10 gen 2 and I currently own the AZ80 and the Pi8.
      The Pi8 are better than the AZ80 in my testing so far but the price is too high.
      The Jabra elite 10 gen 2 might be perfect middle ground.

    • @evoxf1
      @evoxf1 2 місяці тому

      @fredo.heavyy
      Price can be one time ignored, but i will have to consider overall satisfaction,
      Comfort, sound quality and much more, also i saw your revieww today of the Pi8, at first you didnot look super happy 😅😅

    • @evoxf1
      @evoxf1 2 місяці тому

      The jabra gen2 are not cheaper though now.
      I would want your indepth review on the pi8, az80, jabra 10 or any other, i have time till the end of october, to ask my friend to bring from US

  • @MrBigdeexl
    @MrBigdeexl 2 місяці тому

    Good one Ron I'll stick with my Gemini 2 for now but Those az80 be calling my name 😂😂

    • @norrismannjr
      @norrismannjr 2 місяці тому

      Don't fool with the az80 over the devialet Gemini ii

  • @erkanvural3621
    @erkanvural3621 2 місяці тому

    As for volume level and transparency which one is better?

    • @saitaro
      @saitaro Місяць тому

      Both very loud, Pi8 slightly louder. As to transparency - Gemini.

    • @ronontech
      @ronontech  Місяць тому +2

      Both get very loud. I think the Gemini II has better transpaency.

  • @boatymcboatface18
    @boatymcboatface18 2 місяці тому

    I'm guessing the next opponent for the Pi8s is the Beoplay EX.
    You can skip the ANC part of that competition. Even if they are still not the best on the Pi8's everyone knows the ANC on the Beoplay EX is the absolute worst.
    I had been hoping B&O was planning on coming out with new buds sometime soon, but it seems to me that they don't have any plans in the near future now. Alternatively, if they can just improve the current buds ANC with a software upgrade that would work too....

    • @ronontech
      @ronontech  Місяць тому

      I hope they do, too. They just announced there $1,500 headphones. The earbuds should be coming soon...

  • @님님-w9v
    @님님-w9v 2 місяці тому +1

    제미니2유저로서 딱 원했던 리뷰다 제미니3 나오면 그거나 사야지 ㅋㅋ

  • @HTSontherun
    @HTSontherun 2 місяці тому

    Great review

  • @saitaro
    @saitaro 2 місяці тому

    5:14 is that the Gemini 2 mic in use?

    • @ronontech
      @ronontech  2 місяці тому +1

      No. That was my DJI mic.

  • @executivedetail999
    @executivedetail999 2 місяці тому +2

    I picture you doing all these reviews and then putting your Status Between 3anc's back in your ears....

    • @cobbyessilfie2357
      @cobbyessilfie2357 2 місяці тому +1

      Status between 3anc all the way

    • @ronontech
      @ronontech  Місяць тому +1

      They are pretty sweet sounding!

  • @patriotefrancethefirst4339
    @patriotefrancethefirst4339 Місяць тому +1

    The Gimini II i didn't find them phenomenal at all.
    I tried them for a week and i wasn't impressed so i sold them, I prefer my B&O Ex , Sennheiser MTW4, B&O EQ , nuratrue pro so far than Gimini II.
    Best regards

  • @JamesBond-gg4wg
    @JamesBond-gg4wg 2 місяці тому

    What tablet are using?

    • @cerbudan
      @cerbudan Місяць тому +1

      It’s not a tablet ! Is Samsung fold

    • @ronontech
      @ronontech  Місяць тому +1

      @JamesBond-gg4wg It's a Galaxy Z Fold6.

  • @PonsonKoonsan
    @PonsonKoonsan Місяць тому

    Pi7 s2 ,pi8 ,devialet gemini2 is better, only sound

    • @ronontech
      @ronontech  Місяць тому

      Sorry for the late response.
      Based on your list, the Gemini II have the better sound, IMO.

  • @velisamitic4934
    @velisamitic4934 2 місяці тому

    👌👍🇷🇸🇦🇹

  • @ohsoleohmio
    @ohsoleohmio 2 місяці тому

    how can you compare without using 32bit DSP lossless and aptx hd also things Gemini 2 doesn’t have ? use 32bit DSP and or lossless source then compare maybe

    • @ronontech
      @ronontech  Місяць тому +1

      I compare them with the device I use daily.

    • @ohsoleohmio
      @ohsoleohmio Місяць тому

      @@ronontech Gemini is not HD hi res music its like your listening to crap quality on both then you cant compare .. can you understand the question please .. your comparison is completely irrelevant as you are not taking the music source into consideration.. it must be recorded and in the format of 32bit 192kz very high res as one earbud can play this and the one you use ‘DAILY’ does not

    • @saitaro
      @saitaro Місяць тому +4

      ​@@ohsoleohmio Dude nobody will tell apart between "hi res" and AAC on wireless earbuds (especially on iPhone). 99% don't care about 32bit 192kz, the recodring quality, reamp and the speaker materials are much more important.

    • @ohsoleohmio
      @ohsoleohmio Місяць тому +1

      @@saitaro maybe .. but how would you know till you try , i mean if there is a new lossless earbud on the market by one of the most refined audio manufacturers designers inventors on the planet ie bowers and wilkins that do audio for Porsche or whatever else , why not at least try using lossless recordings recorded properly for the function of listening losslessly with earbuds that are capable of it and at least test 2 earbuds keeping in mind there is a big difference in the capabilities , ofc the devialet is only capable of anc but the pi8s are capable of more ie lossless, sure you cant seem to tell the difference but just maybe a new earbud will come that you can cause i can tell the difference using beyerdynamics 990s so .. dont you think that day will ever come

  • @sebastianheuser1221
    @sebastianheuser1221 2 місяці тому +1

    ... Oh and by the way. You made a mistake by using the name MW09 insted of Gemini II.

    • @ronontech
      @ronontech  Місяць тому

      No...this was deliberate.

    • @sebastianheuser1221
      @sebastianheuser1221 Місяць тому +1

      But MW09 is from Master and Dynamic not Devialet 😉 ​@@ronontech