i don’t know much about this but first thought here is about your quick comment about there not being a g# in the tonality, however there also isn’t an a# in the tonality which is the note being ornamented. not really sure what’s to come from this but curious as to how this note may affect your thoughts:) 14:00 great video, very helpful and informative. lovely to have digitised copies and discussions around things normally only in books :)
The example you gave for op.2 no.3, you are absolutely right about it, but it create confusion when You say" i think it’s wrong to play like most people did" because at the start of the video and towards the end you say two times about: there is no right and wrong about these ornaments, it conflicts, so… But your video is really good though! Very informative
i don’t know much about this but first thought here is about your quick comment about there not being a g# in the tonality, however there also isn’t an a# in the tonality which is the note being ornamented. not really sure what’s to come from this but curious as to how this note may affect your thoughts:) 14:00
great video, very helpful and informative. lovely to have digitised copies and discussions around things normally only in books :)
Merci !
The example you gave for op.2 no.3, you are absolutely right about it, but it create confusion when You say" i think it’s wrong to play like most people did" because at the start of the video and towards the end you say two times about: there is no right and wrong about these ornaments, it conflicts, so…
But your video is really good though! Very informative
Yes I think its like that beethoven wrote it but at the end you do what you want, not soo important