'Putin will be gone soon': Exiled Russian dissident Ilya Ponomarev • FRANCE 24 English
Вставка
- Опубліковано 14 чер 2024
- Exiled Russian #dissident #IlyaPonomarev gave an interview to FRANCE 24 from Kyiv. The former Russian lawmaker was the only member of the Douma to vote against the annexation of Crimea back in 2014 and now lives in #Ukraine. He predicted that "#Putin will be gone soon", arguing that the Russian president has "definitely lost the war" in Ukraine and that "no dictator who has lost a war can stay in power". Asked about the suspected war crimes in #Bucha that have shocked the world, Ponomarev claimed that the killings were most likely the results of "panic" by retreating Russian forces, rather than being carefully planned.
f24.my/8WnG.y
🔔 Subscribe to France 24 now: f24.my/YTen
🔴 LIVE - Watch FRANCE 24 English 24/7 here: f24.my/YTliveEN
🌍 Read the latest International News and Top Stories: www.france24.com/en/
Like us on Facebook: f24.my/FBen
Follow us on Twitter: f24.my/TWen
Discover the news in pictures on Instagram: f24.my/IGen
Ilya Ponomarev, a man with a conscience and the bravery to follow it!
Much respect to this humanist! ❤️👍🏻
A lying clown
Agree he spoke the true how think are at the moment and how the end will be for the psychopath
@@brandstyle3639 Psychopath is Baiden
YEEEEHAAAAA!!!
Information on Wikipedia about Ilya Ponomarev)))) a unique hero!😆
Most of the people worldwide is waiting for this. The end of suffering
Silly ... but the World is with you if you meant Murikkka and her Slaves.
@@geIoeschterBenutzer I need to understand what you mean. Could you explain? Thanks
God bless this man Ponomarev who wouldn't vote for the Russian invasion of Crimea in 2014 as a member of the Russian parliament. He is on the Russian hit list as a current resident of Ukraine. God protect him and keep him safe. I appreciate his honesty. 🙏
was a member.
He is a one brave guy
He is a stand up man
YOU MUST'VE BEEN BORN YESTERDAY!!!
Information on Wikipedia about Ilya Ponomarev he is a unique hero!
Thank you for such a sincere Interview sir 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Thumbs up to you Sir Ilya Ponomarev. God bless you.
I hope this man is right in 100% 🙏
I hope you guys one day stop buying into the weaponized disinformation campaigns of the US..
You’re sucking it down harder than you didn’t w/9/11, Iraq, and Afghanistan.
Me too.
Hahaha
Me too 🙏
He lies, because you do it if you hate someone. It can be seen on his face
This guy makes more sense than all those media headlines who guess.
I mean he’s also guessing but whatever. Lol
yes to your comment ..so much click bait..
@@ProgNoizesB no the adds that I have to click for worthless news .but maybe you haven't figured that out yet .the 1st ad..then the pop up ads. .and the little box ads .
He comes across as a fine honourable man. I hope that he stays safe...he's the sort of man Russia will need for the future.
🤣😆
And you should know beacuse you can read character.
@n k this is a biased channel.
Don't talk against America .they destroyed middle East totally
@@baassbooster OP says "comes across" not IS. Words like "appear", "seems" "look like" convey impression no definitive knowledge.
@n k how do you know he was even married?
I admire your grim determination Mr. Ponomarev and I hope you are right.
does he also know the next winning lottery numbers?
@@vhawk1951kl do you?
@@vhawk1951kl imbecile reply.
@@vhawk1951kl I reckon we’ve all got your number.
Balls of steel this man, a Russian politician who left his country to fight to defend Ukraine from Putin.
He ran away meaning hes a chicken.
Picketina na platnom spisku vasingtona. Peta kolona
I think its balls of steel when you stay not when you leave.
Really ! OR its the other way around ?
Amen 🙏 lord
Excellent interview. A fair interview. Very refreshing media seen only rarely these days!!!
Nice to know there are some intelligent and clear-thinking Russians out there, like this guy. Wish there were more. Thumbs up to this man. 👍🏻
👍
I really hope he is correct. This needs to end
Amen 🙏
@G Zeus bla bla bla
@@leonidasspartan6105 He's right you donkey.
@G Zeus what's Russia's invasion of a sovereign country then? Ffs!
@G Zeus Skase Malaka!
They are not "sanctions!" They are Special Financial Operations.
LOL, best comment.
Ruble looks stronger than before. Not sure how those sanctions work.
😂😂😂
@@shamsnoor2808 learn about sanctions then 👍
@@shamsnoor2808, and what can it buy? Not much. Russia has been cut off from buying Western tech so their aviation and space sectors will die, same with their ability to manufacture anything remotely modern for their military. This war will stain the Russian people for at least 2-3 generations, and the people of Ukraine will have a burning hatred for Russia that will not go away.
Respect for this brave and rightful man who presented a very fine analysis of the butcher’s future and for the choices he made on a personal and political level.
Western leaders are butcherers
Very enlightning. Genuin brave man, hopefully protected .
Arnold Schwarzenegger said his new heroes are brave Russians who stand up for the truth. I agree 100%. They are my heroes too.
"Screw your freedom" Arnold Schwarzenegger
Bots are on you @ste
@UA-cam Discriminates Too late if you know what I mean 💉🦠
@UA-cam Discriminates ohh no... We found the INCEL folks!
There are about 50 of them, alas.
This man is the true Russian patriot. It takes courage to oppose the powers that be
It' takes less courage when you leave the country first.
You're kidding!!!
but he left his country
@@sirrcharles1869 they should about him. Hahaha
350000 russians leaves their country every year!!they go to West!
"People never lie so much as after a hunt, during a war or before an election." German Chancellor Otto von Bismarck
It's all in the eyes.
So?
After a fishing trip lol
Hunter here, can confirm.
I never lie as much as I do after Sex. ♀️
Excellent interview.
Hopefully- the sooner the better. May the cruelty being inflicted upon Ukraine end as soon as possible! 🇺🇦 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
Hopefully taken around the back not to be seen again fingers crossed
yes
how to stop cruelty in Donbass since 2014? Ukrainians have been killing their own "separatists".
What about the cruelty being inflicted upon humanity by A-L-L our gov'ts working together and supporting banker and corporate interests? They poison children...
Amen!!
My respects to Mr. Ponomarev the only decent Russian politician who opposed the fascist Putin's government and now he's fighting for Ukraine.
Respect!
A man of conviction, although I can imagine it will not be easy to shoot at your own countrymen
Primero informate bien sobre las cosas que dices
O come come 'fascist' is just another silly word for sinful or it-doesn't-like -it.
why bring religion (all that sin bunk) into it?
so sin is sin, so what?
How much do you know about this person? How much do you actually know about this guy?
Eleven minutes and thirty-four seconds of insight from a guy of evident integrity. Unusual.
Thank you, Ilya. Your perspective is very much appreciated, especially in the arena of political change in Russia. Must agree with you, a revolution is desirable while a coup will just postpone the inevitable.
Bucha was a deliberate genocide.
What's the difference between coup d'etat and revolution?
@@suprememasteroftheuniverse The first just introduces another group of power freaks to screw you over. The second, for better or worse, presents you with the new scheme of things...which may also screw you over. It's just a question of layers.
I remember when Nikita Khrushchev was replaced, the Russians simply said he was "sick" and he was removed.
Your voice in God's ear
Don`t rush to conclude the same now. N. Khrushchev was not democratically elected as it is said now to be the general rule for electing heads of states in a free world, he was elected by an elite core, the ONLY elite core. So, there are some elements that need to be fulfilled first, and anyhow "replacing" is "catching" in this context
best hurry, before the cancer spreads...
Not the Russians dunkoff, the Soviets, if you don’t know the difference, it’s far easier to demonise the Russians, when the Russians were victims of the Soviet System just every one of the 100 distinctive ethnic groups which comprised the Soviet Union.
@@andrabook8758 it already has , from one end of your brain to the other.
CUA Director William Casey (1981)
“We will know our disinformation program is complete, when everything the American people believe is false.”
"panic" does NOT excuse these crimes!
They weren't panicking when they executed people, they panicked when they were losing and didn't hide the evidence of what they did.
He's not excusing anything
@@pickledragonrebel wasn't talking about him....
First time viewer to this channel... I just loved this interview.
Ilya have always fought for a better world. Thanks for been there to restore hope and sustainability to millions of people. The great creator of humans will reward you. Your selfless heroism will be a role model for generations to come.
Poland helps Ukrainians also because they learn in school what it is like to be invaded by the army of a fascist regime (or two).
Remember Wolyn?
We learn that at home.
Nobody taught me anything in history class. The curriculum hasn't changed since Russians wrote it in the 50s. So we safety never reach the year 1900.
It's in my bones.
(As you can tell by my surname, I am Polish)
@@paweszczepanski6738 You didn't learn about soviet attack at school? You gotta be making this up.
@@saffron0044 No. History class is structured so that you NEVER make it to the 20th century. WW2 is skimmed over barely. I always thought it's on purpose. I was taught ancient history like three times over, 20th century is a mistery, cause I never bothered to educate myself in that regard on my own. Nobody does.
@@saffron0044 somewhat yes. We do. But it's barely mentioned and you do spend months on wars between Athens and Sparta, which is quite silly
He’s a very brave man and I admire him.
There is obviously a vial of novichok somewhere with his name on it.
He is a fools- searcher🤘
He spoke absolutely the true
About the end of that psychopath sputin
There are no others end for him other then to be demolished completely
@Miroslav Pavlov 🤣
@Miroslav Pavlov smart actually.
Who they taking to court over these war crimes? Enlighten me someone
Love this man! Glory to Ukraine 💛💙🇺🇦
Excellent interview! You asked concise questions that many people are wondering about. Thank you.
I second that. Great interview!
Yup
You really have to admire his integrity, if he can’t go home I hope he immigrates to America. Florida has a need for such honest politicians.
Florida is one of the holy grails of America. Gtfoh 🤡
@@therealistintheboot8822 of misinformation, deceit, ignorance. Yes. This guy deserves better.
@@therealistintheboot8822 DeSantis has turned Florida completely Fascist, Desantis is a wannabe Dictator. Oh, and the 88 isn't lost on some of us, yet another White Supremacist Fascist in support of DeSantis of course.
@@therealistintheboot8822 Holy Grail? 😂
Aside from the ecosystem, we'd gladly take a SAW and float Florida and Texas out to Sea.🧐
Holy Grail? Explain yourself.
I've got a classroom of 39 History Students that would LOVE to hear your narrative.
We await your brilliant ideology
New York and California are in dire need of honest politicians
Respect and keepsafe Ilya💙💛 Slava Ukraini!!
I have nothing but respect for this man! God bless his soul and all of Ukraine! I hope the good will prevail and evil will blown into oblivion!
"Terrorize" is the right word instead of "scare". All tyrants rule by terrorizing the mass of civilians into obedience.
Sounds like the US.
@@72marshflower15 sounds like Zelensky
🤡Zelenskyy
@@randyborstol2491 not yet but we getting closer. Why not go help your buddy pooping?
@@randyborstol2491 sounds like your mom
Whether Putin's days are numbered or not, there are many others around him that we'd need to be just as careful of. Dictatorships and autocracies don't just disappear.
I think the best that can be expected in this case is a shift from hard-core fascism and dictatorship to something a little softer... But the same ideology and the same political structure.
Oh please.. it’s always been the US.
No they outlive democracies. Democracies always die. The West is dying off.
We need to be careful of the USA instead. They’ve done the worst in other countries around the world
That's why Mr. Ponomarev said he would prefer revolution over a coup.
Exquisite interview with a profoundly astute guest.
Waste of time. Pay attention. And put down the thesaurus for awhile.
@@robperry1745 - I’m not sure what you’re babbling about over there. I must be on the Internet.
Thank you France 24. I have watched a few of your videos and like the clear professionalism. The information is succinct and clear, unlike a lot of Flashy news channels. I especially liked this interview. A very credible source. Thank you for your work.
Exiled Russian Dissident Ilya Pononarev is a good Russian, his word are encouraging and gives hope. God Bless the Urianke and all it people. "Pray for White light potection for them all"
bs
Tu .
I bet BORIS THE DRUNK was as well,you pos
This is the kind of thing that give me(some) faith in the Russian people. Let's hope his predictions come true, and that he'll one day be part of a better, more democratic Russian government.
Путин, вон!
Watch Patrick Lancaster on yt ....he’s a journalist on the ground there who interviews the locals
Like the US?
@@user-jd3rd4fn5m
Једини лопов и ратни злочинац је Путин.
@@sarahalmond4975 oh sh!t ✨✊✨ you beat me to it ✨🤗✨
We need more people like this
Informative conversation. Thanks.🇺🇲
Let's give a shout out to all incredible brave Russians that understand what is going on and risk their life by stating their opinion. Think of Navalny: he survived an assassination attempt and still went back to Russia. He knew he would at least be locked in and I can't think of any other reason for doing that than: if you want to change a country, you have to be in the country. Even if it's in a prison. I do however salute the ones living in exile, too.
I wish somebody would storm the jail and let out all those political people. 15,000
There is a word for those that predict what they*want* to happen, can you guess what it is?
Navalny supported Crimea annexation.
Are you talking about this one?
@@vhawk1951kl
Ummm... optimistic? Prescient?
This man is a clown and a fake. Hahaha
Stalin said: "One death is a tragedy, a million deaths is a statistic". The world cannot become numb to these horrific atrocities. Its too easy for us to turn away thinking its more of the same. It isn't. Each one of those victims had a story, a family a life and they now deserve justice. Don't turn away.
m.
So SHEEPY comment, …. What about the ONE WAY traffic of the “ NEWS “ from
The WESTERN GLOBAL MEDIAS MAFIA CORPORATIONS ??
You are obliged to believe whatever their poisoning NARRATIVE they published 😲
Hmm, where was the worlds outcry at the hundreds of thousands killed by NATO and the US in Iraq, Libya and Afghanistan? Lets me guess, they don't count because they are not white or Christians like the Ukrainians eh?
"SOLIDARNOSC ALWAYS WINS" UNITY DEFEATS ANY "ISM"!
There is no justice on earth …. Only revenge
Great respect to this true Russian patriot. I hope the Father keeps you. I believe Putin is quickly approaching the deprevity of Adolf Hitler.
A very brave and principled man!
From Mr Pononarev lips to Gods ears...I too agree that a coup would be like changing clothes...there needs to be a revolution to let the sun in...
Revolution in the west that will be great.
Yeah, show example... Start with the coup in your country first!!!
Mr. Ponomarev is another real hero who fights for a better Russia and a better World. Immense respect to him! ✌✌✌
No.
@@arabellarosochka4825 < TROLL
@@elainedaprano9130 you are
@@arabellarosochka4825 Crawl back to the troll factory in St. Petersburg
yeah, wanting to bring back communism.
Thank you
Thank you for showing this. It's very important for the Westerners to see to get a fuller picture of all the happenings
Priceless insights and analysis from Ilya Ponomarev. What a brave man to stand up to Putin’s security apparatus!
Amazing Alex, that your words came to my lips, and actually I'm Alexandre too. 😊
Or why you just don't take a look at wikileaks and see who is really the opressor.
@@vitomanza8341 Because wikileaks is not reliable.
@@littledikkins2253 But all western media is? Have you even bothered to look for other views?
It's so unreliable it's founder became one of the ost wanted man by the US secret agencies.
Unlike so many so-called Russian "allies" Thank you for saying no to occupation in Ukraine from day one, which I meant occupation in Crimea 2014.
Meh, Crimea River. The US pushed fo all of this to begin with.
The information is out there if you actually give AF..
👎🇺🇦👎🇺🇸👎
@@72marshflower15 If clues were shoes you’d be going around with clickers on your socks.
@@sandrabarrie84 the information is all around, you just need to turn on your listening ears and your seeing eyes. If you need your information delivered by a piece of 4x2 then try the "Aussie Cossack" on the UN & NATO.
Sensitive and logical interview
Wonderful to hear from people as informed as this.
Just heard a Conversation with Nina Khrushchev The Daughter of Nikita Khrushchev And She is Correct that "Putin is walking in Stalin's Footsteps"
or hitlers
I like this man and i do hope he is right on all counts. Brave IIya Ponomarev.
No Westerners should be allowed to comment. The level of ignorance in the West is shocking. Dumb, lazy and decadent West.
Great reporting. Thank you.
What a nice guy, he inspires hope
Go on Ukraine 🇺🇦 👏 💪 🙌 💙..
"Putin definetly lost a war, and he will be gone soon" Lets hope!
💣💥☠
By death or arrest
@@shellimendoza6875 both
@@shellimendoza6875 arrest would be awesome!❤️🇺🇦🇺🇸
@@LeoRousseau so would Death
Glory to Ukraine 🇺🇦. May the murdered Ukraine angels help the lord watch over all Ukrainians. Victory for Ukraine 🇺🇦
Very informative interview. Thank you for having Ilya Ponomarev as your guest.
He is not the only, don't generalize. There are many Russians who oppose what Putin is doing. Thank you France for showing the truth.
many but not the majority?
I would say there are "some" not "many" and they are ineffective.
@@budigunawan5624 It's definitely the majority. But the majority of russians would also not risk their lives or their family's to voice opposition.
@@rtqii No, Quack, they're afraid.
The only member of the Duma who voted against the annexation of Crimea. Chuck Norris admires Ilya Ponomarev.
He is admirable for his stand. Takes courage to do what he did.
Annexation 😂 a democratic referendum in Crimea versus a violent coup in Kiev 😂
@@philgibbon5446
1. Your account is 4 days old!
2. You use a fake western sounding username bcz. you think it sounds more reliable than your real one.
3. You think emojis are a valid argument!
Conclusion: Does it make sense to interact with you?
@@philgibbon5446 Russki Troll Bot 😈
@@1_R.R.R._1 you salame.
Excellent interview. Thank you.
Great interview. Interviewee inspires confidence he knows.
Long live Ukraine. Long live democracy. Long live willingness to defend one's homeland.
What democratie there is no democratie democratie doesn't exist and never has why does the whole world population believe that there is such a thing as democratie is together with religion the two biggest lies that was ever created by humans and the one's that still keeps believing these lies are really delusional
"SOLIDARNOSC ALWAYS WINS" UNITY DEFEATS ANY "ISM"!
I AGREE, BUT YOU HAVE TO KNOW WHO THE REAL ENEMY IS AND I WOULD SUSPECT IT IS THE ONE WHO'S TAPPING ME ON THE SHOULDER. THEY WANT YOU TO BE THEIR DOG IN THE FIGHT! THINK ABOUT IT; YOU'RE CANNON FODDER TO THEM.
Don't be naive
@@edgarhenry5292 Just say what you want to say in pLain ENGLISH WITHOUT SCREAMING!!!!
The fact that this man exists is an indictment of Russia. Blessings to him.
the fact that he is still alive is something
There is word for those that suppose things that are not discrete entities with single controlling minds are discrete entities with single controlling minds.
Want to have a bash at guessing what that word is?
What?
normal Russians cannot be blamed for the behavior of the leadership in control
Peter Codner
Can you rewrite in proper english? I for one have no frigging idea what you are prattling about.
Slava Ukrani Heroiam Slava 🤘 Glory to the Heroes ✌️🤘🇦🇺🇺🇦
Praying for both Ukrainians and Russians. Putin has betrayed them both.
Thank you for your information even though it could be dangerous for you
I heard he fired 1,000 employees, fearing they would poison him.
He would know ^^
Dude threw his old life away along with, probably, most friend and family connections, to fight for what's right. You don't see that sort of conviction every day.
Yeah he’s a tosser 😂😂😂😂😂🤡🤡🤡🤡
This man has eloquence for English not being his first language. "Access to his physical body" paints a much truer picture of what would be done to depose Russia's current leader
Who do you want to overthrow?
Love this Ilya! He brings so much sense and perspective to what’s happening, cuts through the Média headlines and explains things clearly.
@@user-jd3rd4fn5m oh, well, you beat me to it ✨✊✨
@@user-jd3rd4fn5m Google what?
@@72marshflower15 you're agreeing with either a bot or farm troll. 😂
Yeah, that embezzlement accusation sounds real legit... 🙄😂
@@user-jd3rd4fn5m go sniff Pootlers nutz somemore commie.
He has no sense. Clearly fake things.
I appreciate those Russians who are against of the LAWLESSNESS of their President. They are Heroes.
I find people who blindly parrot after the US weaponized disinformation campaigns to be disgusting.
Pleased to make your acquaintances..
✨🥴✨
Absolutely!
What about NATO's lawlessness?
@@chokedbybacklog5433 , what about whataboutism?
vs the ones that rape women then shoot them in the head?
his approval rate is derived out of fear, the man is a beast I hope this brave man is right...
Fantastic report.
Not gone soon enough.
This guy is great. Love listening to his perspective.
I'm so sorry 😞
He is an exceptional person. It’s people such as him that make the difference for us all between tyranny and freedom. Outstanding bravery.
Excellent interiew. Unfortunately, to give equal weight to both sides of the "journalistic story" is a catastrophic failure. Treating the Russian narrative as equal to fact is morally Wrong. Good on llya to set the narrative straight.
The most sensible discussion I've head yet from ANY Countrys News
How can world leaders just keep setting back watching what Russia army doing and have done to these people.
How could world leaders just watch aside America bomb Middle East?
Mr. Perelman is a skilled interviewer. American here, his English is excellent and he knows his subject. Thank you sir.
Very informative with many details. It's good to hear perspectives like this.
So grateful to Ilya for telling us about the
True situation in this war !Thank you 🙏🌈
Szia Ildi! 🤗🌈
Pray for Peace.
MayGod hear your voice!
No matter how much security you have they can always turn against you and take you out 🤷
Iliay Ponomarev, love his interviews, extremely gifted man, I see him as a great leader and I agreed with Illiya that Russia needs a revolution to change putin#s regime and government. Putin and this government are disgraces for this country. My heart is with Ukraine,
😄😅🤣
It’s now a month later... can you define ‘soon?'
I like the word he coined: “foreplan”. These war crimes were not foreplanned. If we can “foresee”, why can’t we “foreplan”?
Ukrainians are setting an example of courage and actual love of democracy that many of us spoiled Americans seem incapable of anymore. My heart aches for the atrocities against these beautiful and strong human beings.
Well said.
Lily s
I find it so strange that you can find hope in a place you probably know nothing about while comparing and disavowing your own country.
@@digitalbath8577 Who the hell disavowed their country? Learn to read!
@@digitalbath8577 I’m not disavowing my country, your statement is eye opening none the less. Reading comprehension is yet another area of devastation. 🙄
@@lilys7431 oh ok guess I read you wrong. You literally are calling Americans spoiled and incapable of democracy..thanks for your Strawman arguments. Maybe you need to learn how to convey your sentiments before speaking for everyone in America.
Thank you for your English transmissions!
Opinions like that, is the reason why he is exiled
It's absolutely essential for future peace in Europe that Putin and Russia cannot claim any level of victory. Withdrawal from Ukraine must be total and all frozen Russian assets should go to Ukraine for rebuilding, and I wouldn't blame Ukraine for insisting on a 200 mile demilitarised zone on the Russian side of the border with Ukraine.
💥Right no punches below the belt is going to help,cut off the head, cut off their resources.👍💪🇺🇦
Probably 300 km, rather
Michael give repetitions to black people and stop killing then and discriminating and then we can talk.Amerikkka