"Evolution is just a theory"
Вставка
- Опубліковано 24 жов 2023
- Many people wrongly think that the term "theory" refers to the degree of evidence for a scientific explanation. They canter-pose this to the notion of a scientific law. They think that theory graduates to become a law as the evidence for the theory develops. But in fact this notion is totally incorrect. A law is a definite relationship amongst a few variables. Whereas a theory is a broad complex explanation explaining, involving, and or predicting many laws.
*English UA-cam: / taimurrahman1975
*Instagram: / taimur_laal
*Twitter: / taimur_laal
![Mod Phil 2: Evolution [Urdu]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ZzPa60YK6_g/mqdefault.jpg)
![Mod Phil 2: Evolution [Urdu]](/img/tr.png)
Please stay safe Dr Sahab. There are very few Pakistanis who stand for science and reason over dogma and tradition, and even fewer Pakistanis who are willing to make their view public
Give me a single example of macro evolution?
dogma and tradition are not the problem it is the people who follow them are the problem
evolution of homo sapiens, evolution of birds from dinosaurs@@muhammadarsalanghouri9713
@@muhammadarsalanghouri9713 Publish your adam and eve creationism bull*** and get it approved by a scientific juristic board.
Anything including science can become dogma , when given more value than it has, what we claim is that the theory of evolution does not have a type of data that makes us know 100% that the theory can't be proven to be false in the future, contrary to something like saying 2+2=4 , this can never be falsified,
This being stablished we have no issue working with the theory of evolution in this frame
Even after incidents like what happened to sir Sher Ali, you still try and educate these masses. I have given up on this awam. and I apricate your patience and efforts.
Tiny water drops can make a hole in stone after long time, I believe there is a good fight between dogma and skepticism taking place in Muslim countries, we must do our part to chip away at dogma
Phir is jnab ko Lai ik debate k lia qaiser Ahmed Raja k sath
Mujy moht fakhr tha taimur laal sahb pr ye jnab qaiser Ahmed Raja sy ik debate q nhi krty evolution pr challenge by qaiser Ahmed Raja
Wait for qaisar ahmad raja video titled “shame on you taimur” 😂
He is the dumbest Pseudointellectual.
Qaiser ahmed raja ki baaten totally logical fallacies hoti hen
@@umroyaaryup and he's followers are brain-dead extremists
@@umroyaar bilkul lekin aesi baatain hamari majority ko bari appease karti hain 😂
@@roeagain999 isi liye to hmari nation science o technology ki field me kuch nai ukhaar rhi ... bs hr cheez blasphemy he, hr cheez buri lgti he inko
Your video on the difference between law and theory is a masterpiece! It is clear, informative, and engaging, with excellent examples and thought-provoking insights.Thank you for sharing your knowledge and expertise with us!
Mujy moht fakhr tha taimur laal sahb pr ye jnab qaiser Ahmed Raja sy ik debate q nhi krty evolution pr challenge by qaiser Ahmed Raja
سرجی بہت شکریہ، تم نے بہت اچھا طریقے سے ایکسپلین کیا۔ اور میں سائنس کا اسٹوڈنٹ نہیں ہوں، لیکن سر جی تمہاری ایکسپلینیشن سے میرا کنکلوژن ختم ہو گیا۔
اور سرجی میں افغانستان سے ہو۔ میں بہت پیار سے تمہاری ویڈیوز دیکھتا ہوں❤ اور تم سے اردو سکھاتا ہوں❤🇦🇫🇦🇫🇦🇫
Salam apko meri taraf se ... ap buht bahadur afghani ho
Your explanation is truly remarkable. My heartfelt desire is to witness a profound scientific awakening in Pakistan, even though I remain uncertain about the generations it might take to realize this dream. However, my hope soars as I witness your unwavering commitment to enlightening our nation through education. May you continue to be a shining beacon for the youth, sir.
Mujy moht fakhr tha taimur laal sahb pr ye jnab qaiser Ahmed Raja sy ik debate q nhi krty evolution pr challenge by qaiser Ahmed Raja
Evolution is Fact.....
theory of evolution have thousands of laws....❤
رقص ابلیس
@@SOCCEREDITS4k-005 God of the gaps?
@@SOCCEREDITS4k-005bhai allah ne duniya banai hai jao khush raho ye padhai likhai se kuch nahi hoga jao namaz padho ap aur jannat me jao😊
@@normal1person-ns3ws Thor is much better....
@@SOCCEREDITS4k-005 theory of evolution is a vast subject, life begin on earth from a cell called fuca. I recommend you to watch Dhruv rathee two videos on evolution you'll understand it better.
Theory of evolution is backed by:
Fossil records
Physiology
Anatomical similarities
Embryology
And most importantly DNA' structure &
Genetics
Let me first appreciate your continuing efforts to spread rationality in this society full of dogmas and fanaticism. Afterwards, I would like to inquire about the prevalent idea that the goal of Science is not about explaining why something happens the way it happens but how does it happen. We have been inculcated, from our childhood, with this idea that the Science (or Scientific thought) is to come up with the mechanics of how things work. They say Science gives answers to how things work and the religion/philosophy answers the whys of a phenomenon. Can you please guide us in this regard?
Once again, this lecture has been truly remarkable in the understanding of the differences between a law and a theory. Thanks.
In my view, scientific law explains “how” and scientific theory explains “why”.
Science is not restricted to natural phenomenon. Social science explains why wars occur. Why revolutions happen. Why states fail. Etc etc.
@@Taimur_Laal much appreciated, sir.
Any ‘law’ that you think is absolute, is only a mathematical model that best aligns with the observations found thus far and this changes as new observations are found. E.g Newtons law(which now is incorrect as in it doesnt work always) and then einstein’s general theory of relativity. We however don’t know how even this newer theory reconciles with ‘quantum gravity’ . There is no explanation until today. Some think there is something wrong with the latter anyway but no explanation nonetheless. If you want to really know what the scientific method is, try researching more into it and the actual ‘philosophy’ , the assumptions , constraints etc.. behind it.
As difficult as you might find it to grasp, as hume said “science “ is essentially the belief that the future will behave like it did in the past. My advice, don’t scrape though these topics but research more into it. These are very old topics and not at all new as folks might lead you to believe.
There must be a series of videos on different concepts and theories of natural sciences. As you made us fall in love with political philosphy and other major works related to social sciences, hopefully scientific content will spread rationality, end confusion and spark a new interest in science.
Had no idea that you are very good at explaining pure physics-scientific laws. Kindly start the Physics series as it will help us a lot to learn the basics of Physics. Do not why but whatever you explain, it becomes so easy to comprehend.
Mujy moht fakhr tha taimur laal sahb pr ye jnab qaiser Ahmed Raja sy ik debate q nhi krty evolution pr challenge by qaiser Ahmed Raja
Mujy moht fakhr tha taimur laal sahb pr ye jnab qaiser Ahmed Raja sy ik debate q nhi krty evolution pr challenge by qaiser Ahmed Raja
Huge applause sir !
Successfully defied pre-conceived notions.
بہت آعلیٰ ۔۔۔۔۔ مزہ آ گیا
Ye video masterpiece hai
Dear professor, what laws are there in the theory of evolution? I was just curious to ask that are "natural selection" and "random mutation" laws? Additionally, if a theory is made that aligns with let's say creationism, but incorporates the "laws", how would we judge it compared to this theory. Much regards, I love you.
Natural Selection is a theory meanwhile
Evolution itself is a LAW. Everything goes through a process of evolution
natural selection, mutation genetic drift ..etc are mechanisms which explains the diversity of life. There are may laws inside Evolution theory one of them is law of population genetics, another one is law of phylogeny.
Creationism is just a ..... 😂
Law of population genetics
Maududi too called it a theory. Your explanation indicates his ignorance. Ghamdi, another heavyweight follower too toe the line of his mentor. Stay safe sir.
Ghamdi ki majboori he bhai ... wo ulema me phir stand nai kr paye ga bechara
Sir, forget about the difference between Theory and Law for a moment, Yet listen!!! that in the Holy Quran we read about Law of evolution, may be different from Darwin's. Adam was not created in a second or two, his creation occurred in stages. However, we can't accept that life came into being without a Creator as even a single cell is so much complex that one having a minute wisdom can't accept that such a complex entity came into being by itself. Before Darwin, in 8th-10th century, the Muslim Scholars have presented Evolution Theory. For example, read Jalal Ud Din Roomi, in one of his poems he has presented Evolution Theory in Four Stages. And when Darwin presented his Evolution Theory, some western scholars blamed him of stealing the theory from the Muslims. I can count many scientific theories from Quran, For examle the expansion of the Universe, the big bang theory, the mention of Computer like board, the phenomenon of rain from the clouds, Adhesive forces, rotatory motion, the concept of aeroplane as discussion of the flying of the Thrown of Hazrat Suliman (AS) by violent wind, the explanation of the installation of mountains on the earth surface, the movement of mountains as clouds do etc. Thank you Sir!
Ghamdi sahb ki glt biyani dakhy aur in shetano sy bchy link pr dekho bai
Search qaiser Ahmed Raja
one of the best lecture of prof. taimur ........God bless you sir huge fan of yours❣
He doesn't believe in God. Bless him thru Marx
What's your problem?
Mujy moht fakhr tha taimur laal sahb pr ye jnab qaiser Ahmed Raja sy ik debate q nhi krty evolution pr challenge by qaiser Ahmed Raja
Thank you for clarifying, please never stop making these educational videos
28 Minutes full of information, Thanks a lot Sir 😇
According to me!!
Law: is actually the mathematical expression or explanations of natural facts!
While THEORY is the verbal explanations of natural facts!!
Am i right??
no, not really. Biological laws exist and they have nothing to do with Math. Physics have many theories with Mathematical explanations such as relativity Theory, Grand Unification Theory. the only valid difference is the one that Sir explained.
It is not necessary for a law to be a mathematical relationship. Newton's first and third law are not mathematically expressed.
@@Taimur_Laalsir plz. Yeh BAAT na karein. You are making fool of yourself
Excellent explanation. You are a great teacher. Just wanted to add that theory like evolution requires thousands of centuries to be established into its true facts.
Very informative and interesting lecture. ❤
will you marry me?
One gem of a lecture! This will help me save a lot of time and energy while debating evolution deniers. I’d just share this video’s link.
Mujy b moht fakhr tha taimur laal sahb pr ye jnab qaiser Ahmed Raja sy ik debate q nhi krty evolution pr challenge by qaiser Ahmed Raja
Thanks so much Sir for this simplified explanation. More power to you 👍
Whenever I here it is just a theory, my mind goes to ZAKIR Nalayak.
Couldn't get your view
😂lol right but you forgot this. “Trust me brother I am a medical doctor”
@@zahidayyub290ua-cam.com/users/shortsFM-e0Q1_SHs?si=hOsq8PxGfQ5ZguuZ
Illogical, orthodox, rhetorically taught parrot. He himself didnt know the difference between law and theory. Hope his video keeps circulating so that everyone knows his mighty knowledge.
Dr.zakir naik ne young Muslims ki intellect ki maa bhen aik krdi he ...🖕 to dr.zakir naik
A video was uploaded recently where molvis were forcing a biology professor to reject Darwin theory and other scientific laws which are against islam..
Great explanation mate. Awesome job!
Taimor on Brian Greene mode😎
Now I'd wish a video just as brilliant as this on evolutionary theory. Ghanta ki bnae 2 ghantay ki bnae ya 20 minutes ki lakin ab bnae!
Very informative, i will watch all your videos from now on. I will start with the playlist.
Mujy b moht fakhr tha taimur laal sahb pr ye jnab qaiser Ahmed Raja sy ik debate q nhi krty evolution pr challenge by qaiser Ahmed Raja
Law is a mathematical form of a scientific theory. Language of theory is common in life sciences.
great ... Sir Taimoor , you never disappoint us .. GREAT explanation
Dr.Zakir Naik left the chat.
😂
Just bcz USSR-riyasat e Madinah for Marxism adopted it doesn't mean it became scientific. Prove it with solid generation by generation fossil record. İf man sprang out of ape (which can be a possibility) then where are the intermediary stages??!
Thank you sir for coming up with comprehensive package of information. I really appreciate your efforts as this really important topic and someone like you would have been one of the best person to speak about this.
👍
thanks Dr sahib i learned a lot.. i thought exactly that way that theory become law.. you explained it excellently.. ❤
Very helpful and I think you had an insight about the confusions which high school teachers deliberately inducing into students’ minds about this. Nice
We want lectures on Philosophy of Science and History of Scientific Development
Great explanation..... informative
What should be my approach towards Evolution?
It is a fact and religion should be your just faith ok
Ignore the hate Dr Saab, Evolution is fact, great video!
Thank you sir for explaining us the difference between theory and law kash ye lacture mere fsc se pehle Bana dete
بانچھ سماج میں شعور کی بات کرنا دنیا کا کٹھن ترین کام ہے ۔۔
sir what if their is subjectivity of explanations. like we can always accept that theory which has more empirical evidence but epistemologically we cant really accept nor completely discard any theory. And i am not sure but i think that if a better theory comes with better evidences we shall discard darwinism.
Thanks for sharing this nice video. Can u plz make a brief vlog on Dogmatic vs. Scientific approach towards oneself and life.
It was a superb lecture ❤
Bahut bahut shukriya sir
Stay safe and blessed ❤
Dr Taimur, is it possible for a theory, or some aspects of it, to be wrong?
Of course. But not merely because it is termed "a theory".
Sir can you explain String theory please in simpler language ?
Sir, please also explain the definition of theory and law in humanities and social sciences
Sir in that case could we reject the narrative dominance of law over theory I mean there shouldn't be a law in any aspect of life
Thanks, Dr.taimur rehman aj mera concept clear hogya k theory aur law me farq kia hota he ... afsos hmare education system pe 😢
Professor can u make a video on Human species along with the fossils found and carbon dating.
Atomic theory is also theory. But it is perfect
Dr Shabir Ally gives a very good explanation of how the theory of evolution is compatible with Islam. Very nice video
Great explanation. In Urdu we have got one word for theory and ideology ie نظریہ
This also confuses the people
Yes I thought about including this in my lecture but decided against it as it would add yet another layer of complexity :) We actually have no adequate specific word for theory.
Sir if evolution is not right or just theory then why we study it???
Thank you so much dear sir. This is the best video I have watched so far on this topic. Crustal clear.
By the way, what is your stance on the theory of evolution? You ended the video without telling us what your beliefs are regarding the theory of evolution.
Excellent explanation sir I learn alot today!!!
Thanks for such an easy explanation 🎉
وَهُوَ ٱلَّذِىٓ أَنشَأَكُم مِّن نَّفْسٍۢ وَٰحِدَةٍۢ . ٩٨- Al-An'am
اور وہی ہے جس نے تمہیں اٹھایا ایک جان
And He is the One Who originated you all from a single soul
Dr. Israr Ahmed said in his book BAYAN UL QURAN that this might be the reference to a single life cell, like amoeba or the very first organism
Sahil Adeem said that Allah utna hi gaib mien hai jitna os ny btaya hai, har cheez ko ghaib mien na dalien
Kia Amoeba ka zikr Quran me he ...Dr.israr ki opinion quran o sunnat nai ..aur sahil adeem ki saari baaten uska apna khyaal hoti hen
Thankyou.Living in a society of ignorants, it is still enlightening to listen to you.
Great 👍
Wonderful. 👍
Is theory based on evidence then?
Yes
Kindly also educate us on theory of relativity in a lay man’s language.Thanks sir.
Love it❤
Please read Science into the Soul by Richard Dawkins for understanding this.
Nice sir 👍
Gravity which is part of the four dimensional curved matter is the presence of Gravitons relative to the continuum of spacetime.
Sir well done you really nailed it.....
We need to correct our science books being taught in school that contradict science and basic concepts.
Even theories doesn't explain why a phenomenon exists. For example, Einstein deduced on the basis of observation and previous work that there should be a force (gravity) to hold the space together. But he didn't explain why there is gravity at the first place.
Observing physical phenomenon is easier as we can observe them and ultimately we can create an understanding to explain how things are connected together.
The problem with the theory of evolution is that it involves a pretty large scale of time that no one has observed or recorded.
And on the other hand we have plenty of evidences in the form of divine manuscripts that humans and other creations are made that way by a creator.
I have a question, not a critique. If one accepts the theory of evolution as true then is there a point to be a part of religion?
And if one believes it is true and still believes a religion is he a mentally ill?
I don't see why the religion and the evolution can not co-exist.
I mean before all the apes and common ancestor and single life organism, there has to be something that was created, the potential of evolution in the organism that lead to us, has to came from somewhere.
1.your acceptance or rejection of evolution does not change that it is natural fact
2. The dielemma with religion is that , it definitely hurt the organised structure of religion but wait for some time before the same maulvi will say God is the force behind evolution, they dont want their authority to be demolished
As far as individual is concerned , element of believe is the core of its existence which has shaped the human social structure, had the first tribes were atheist we would not have constructed such dynamic civilizations, it provides meaning to an individual
I am perfectly fine with accepting evolution and since keep on contemplating the what is god with all the knowledge about universe we have
Rather then follow sn organised commandment who tell me this is the god , no questions
Believing in evolution is kufr. Because these people believe that what the Quran says is false, and what their theory says is true.
Religion should be separated from science, not only science but also from state affairs .. Religion should be your private matter, ok ... Hindu thinks his own religion is right . Similarly, Christians and Jews do ...
Religions are old ways of observing the universe ok
Excellent dr. Saab, ❤❤❤
Mujy b moht fakhr tha taimur laal sahb pr ye jnab qaiser Ahmed Raja sy ik debate q nhi krty evolution pr challenge by qaiser Ahmed Raja
@@buttautocenter Raja is lowest of low he is jot a biologist and he play religion card, even he has put Engineering Mirza like on risk.
Jo mazbi card khel rha hai uski bri fikr hai ap ko mirza injeenear playing mazbi card I know very well
Ager qaiser Ahmed raja low hai to ik debate krny main kya hrj hai jb k wo boht tamez aur piyar sy bat krty hain
Sir stay safe we need you❤
Allah hum sub ko hidayat day. Or in respectable shariah, implementing lovers ko b who has no authority to force their opinion on others. But what to do when they are backed by Zia's poisonous strategy even after 40 years of his death.
Great video
Thank you 👍❤️
Great effort...
If you travel to the sun at the speed of light then your time of departure to the sun and your time of arrival from the sun will be the SAME.
Time moves differently for objects in motion but is always the SAME at the speed of light relative to objects at rest.
Sir ne baal kala nhi kiya taake unhe zyada sanjeedgi se suna jaye 😂
Doctor sheib wiki pedia oar sciicest ki batoon pa imam la aya howay hein
So that’s mean I belive that’s bulshit
Doctor sahib read tomuch fairytale
They did read to much scince ism if they read little bet Quran they will understand
you are my best teacher ❤❤
Sir you are enlightened!!
Agreed ... Lekin yeh Tau batain Keh kitnay laws ki explanation theory of evolution encompass ker Rahi hay?
The laws underlying Darwin's theory of evolution through natural selection are: (1) more individuals are produced than can survive; (2) there is therefore a struggle for existence; (3) individuals within a species show variation; and (4) offspring tend to inherit their parents' characters.
Dear Dr sahib statements jo ap nay likhi woh khud Chand observations Hain Jo Darwin nay observe ki on his journeys isliay unko koi elihada say nam nahi dia gaya jaisay physics etc mein mukhtalif laws ko diya gaya hay .... Pehlay Tau in observation or parent to offspring gene transfer per law define karain ..theory ki baat Tau phir baad mein aye ge... Doosra mamala yeh hay Keh theories have a lot of imagination in them without concrete facts as the history of science is littered with multiple rejected theories ..the problem with theory of evolution is that as u said empirical evidence is hard to test in proving theories and in evolutions case specially fossil records has many gaps and to build a whole concept of science and then to call every one who does not follow that concept as illiterate is actually a kind of an extremism in itself
@@Taimur_Laal infact the Google search you used to reply to my question.. employed the word "propositions"🙂
❤🇦🇫from Afghanistan 🎊
Qaisar Ahmed Raja has entered the chat.
More like cancer ahmad raja lande ka biologist. Awam bhi aise mullo ko sunti hai bajae science dano ke jinho ne apne baal poori zindagi tehqeeq kar kar ke safed kye hote han
How does this Darwin's theory of Evolution corresponds to the Birth of Mankind as stated in Holy Quran?
Does it correspond to Holy Quran or it is not even a consideration for you guys?
It’s a good but separate question. At the moment I am only talking about the difference between law and theory.
Nice theory.
یہ ہماری ٹیکسٹ بک سے کب نکلے گی۔ کیونکہ ہمیں بھی یہی پڑھایا گیا ہے
Good
Stay safe sir❤
impressive
pakistan has still some intellectual.
aap nay tou naam liye bina kaam kr dala😁👍
Nice
but there is no absolute truth in iscience .according to science .
This statement only means that science is continuously developing. It does not imply that the rejected theories are suddenly found to be correct.
Biology law has now mathematical expression 8:36
Some of them. But not all of them.
Gravity is just theory too.
Qaiar Raja sb, claims that the theory of Evolution is not a proper theory as it can not be tested. Raja Sahib is inspired by Christian apologists and probably watched their videos on UA-cam before recording his own videos. Sadly both Raja sahib and Ghamdi sahib have a feeble understanding of how a scientific theory works.
Qaiser ahmed raja USA 🇺🇸 k televengalists ko sunta he Jo aj tk nai maante k insane chand pe gya he ... kuch un me se aj bhi earth 🌎 ko flat maante hen ...yhi log Bermuda triangle 🔺️, illuminati , 9/11 was inside job jesi absurd thinking ko phelate hen ...jese k pakistan 🇵🇰 me zaid hamid krta he
So next time if anyone dares to refute evolution as a theory, he must bring forth an equal bulk of Scientific evidence to support his alternate theory- since Creationism or Intelligent design has no scientific basis! Am I right Dr. Sb?
It Means i have Been Taught Wrong 😐 ....This statement is Law Not A theory 😕