EVERY Mechanically Unique Card in MTG

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 8 лют 2025
  • Ігри

КОМЕНТАРІ • 500

  • @theArcosa
    @theArcosa  Місяць тому +162

    ⭐ 1. Regarding 400.7b and 611.3d (Henzie / Zinnia related): The updates to 400.7a/b and addition of 611.3d were very effective in fixing Henzie (and also Serra Paragon, which was not in the video). However, if we notice how 611.3d is worded, it only affects "static abilities [that] allow a player to play a land or cast a permanent spell" or "grant an ability to a permanent spell or card that allows it to be cast". This is great for Henzie because blitz is an ALTERNATE casting mode and changes HOW the spell is cast.
    Offspring, on the other hand, is an additional cost to a REGULAR cast. This means that Zinnia does NOT grant an ability that "allows a player to cast a spell" and is NOT covered by 611.3d yet. A very simple rules update can fix this, and was promised around August 2024: x.com/WotC_Matt/status/1828115172457881777
    ⭐ 2. Season of the Witch was mistakenly cut from the video ☹ It was in the original list, but I somehow lost it in the final script. It works similarly to Firkraag and checks for creatures that "couldn't attack".
    ⭐ 3. The Panglacial Wurm combo with Raggadragga requires you to cast an X-spell tutor like Green Sun's Zenith or Chord of Calling so that its mana value is 7 or greater. If you control a mana dork that generates mana equal to its power, you can go infinite.
    Upon casting the X-spell, Raggadragga will untap the power dork and give it +7/+7, at which point it will generate at least 7 mana, which is enough to cast Panglacial Wurm from your library while searching with the tutor. After the tutor is done resolving, there will be another Raggadragga trigger to resolve--so your dork will start making 14 mana. The tutor searches for Temur Sabretooth, which can return the Wurm to your hand and recast, etc. for infinite mana, infinite power (+ trample) on all your creatures, and infinite ETB/LTB.
    ⭐️ 4. I seem to have forgotten Netherese Puzzle-Ward! It’s the only card to use the phrase “natural result” when referring to dice rolls.

    • @Zakading
      @Zakading Місяць тому +1

      Total War actually also has the same wording as Siren's Call about controlling a creature continuously since the elast turn.

    • @PimpTrizkit-42
      @PimpTrizkit-42 Місяць тому

      There are a bunch of ways to go infinite with Temur Sabretooth. That card is broken.

    • @Kettwiesel25
      @Kettwiesel25 Місяць тому +2

      Honestly, regarding 1. I don't see why rule 611.3d is necessary at all. Rule 400.7b already states that all abilities granted to the spell still apply to the permanent, this is everything we need. The permanent still has blitz, it still has haste, it still draws a card and it is still sacrificed at the end of the turn. Similar for Zinna. Is there somehow a rule that Continuous effects aren't effects? Because in the scenario described here it just seems like 611.3d only repeats a part of the effect of 400.7b...

    • @theArcosa
      @theArcosa  Місяць тому +5

      @@Kettwiesel25 The important part of 611.3d is that it causes the effects to persist indefinitely as an exception to 611.3b. If 611.3d wasn’t around, if you cast a spell with Blitz with Henzie, then removed Henzie before the spell resolved, Henzie would no longer apply since his static effect is no longer active.
      As a result, the Blitz delayed sacrifice trigger would still occur (because it is triggered by the cast) but you would neither have haste nor draw a card later because the permanent would no longer have Blitz.

    • @sgjuxta
      @sgjuxta Місяць тому

      Season of the Witch is a nightmarish card because a creature that "couldn't attack" is not really well defined in the CR, especially in how it interacts with cards that have the active player decide which creatures of theirs will be "able to attack." A card like Crawlspace only lets players declare two attacking creatures each combat, so if there's a Season of the Witch and Crawlspace in play and I have 4 creatures without summoning sickness in play and attack with two of them, what happens to the other two creatures at the end of the turn. On the one hand, they *theoretically* could have been chosen as attacking creatures, but on the other hand, as soon as you choose two creatures to be attacking, any other creatures you have become, at that point, creatures that "couldn't attack."

  • @Randomperson-pk3ce
    @Randomperson-pk3ce Місяць тому +611

    Garth one eye as the commander, this is the perfect list of cards to create the most confusing commander deck ever.

    • @Tinil0
      @Tinil0 Місяць тому +46

      Imagine if correctly judging two of those decks facing each other was a requirement to become a judge

    • @Rancidtunip
      @Rancidtunip Місяць тому +13

      I was just wondering if there was a list of these cards so I could build a deck, lol.

    • @towelguy
      @towelguy Місяць тому +19

      reinventing judge tower it seems

    • @estellairon9448
      @estellairon9448 Місяць тому +12

      Imagine playing it with a gift theme, and send over cards to your opponents' control.

    • @katesullivan6949
      @katesullivan6949 Місяць тому

      Thats what i was thinking

  • @saulgoodguy1840
    @saulgoodguy1840 Місяць тому +405

    Time to throw all of these into a judge tower

    • @finalflameKorisky
      @finalflameKorisky Місяць тому +16

      I own a judges tower and was very excited to see this on my feed

    • @retronymph
      @retronymph Місяць тому +9

      Honestly most of these aren't really difficult to parse in terms of how to play with them, they just need special exceptions because no other cards do what they do in the exact way they do it.

    • @0xGRIDRUNR
      @0xGRIDRUNR 25 днів тому

      ​@@finalflameKoriskyah fuck here i was thinking I found some cool cards for the tower but instead I'm just 10 days late 💀

    • @finalflameKorisky
      @finalflameKorisky 25 днів тому

      @0xGRIDRUNR insert slowpoke meme here

  • @kitzreads3064
    @kitzreads3064 Місяць тому +73

    honorable mention: spellweaver volute for blessing us with the incredible rules text “enchant instant card in a graveyard”

  • @Jesin00
    @Jesin00 Місяць тому +69

    Regarding unique symbols and numbers, Spawnsire of Ulamog is the only card with {20}. You may think "that's just a generic mana cost symbol with an unusual number, so it's not unique", but it's at least unique enough that for a while MTGO had it written as {2}{0} and would actually let you activate it for just 2 mana.

  • @MrBurrito
    @MrBurrito Місяць тому +153

    Now, I'm not a judge or a rules scientist or anything, but I did play a LOT during OG Kamigawa block, and I'm pretty sure Sideswipe is printed that way because of Splice onto Arcane. You could cast an arcane spell, but splice a bunch of different arcane spells onto it. You're still technically casting one spell, but it could have a ton of different targets, so Sideswipe could change any of them.

    • @ZakanaHachihaCBC
      @ZakanaHachihaCBC Місяць тому +11

      That would be it.

    • @HS_Gomikubi
      @HS_Gomikubi Місяць тому +5

      I was also there (Kami/Rav the GOAT) so I can follow the logic of why it was printed that way at the time. However, I still get the impression "choose new targets" would function correctly? Like, Redirection and the like still effectively work the same against an arcane with added targets due to splicing? Am I right?

    • @ZakanaHachihaCBC
      @ZakanaHachihaCBC Місяць тому +1

      @@HS_Gomikubi yea, sideswipe just has the condition that it needs to target a spell with the Arcane subtype.

    • @Zantatoes
      @Zantatoes 28 днів тому +2

      @@HS_Gomikubi This one is one of those rules that FUNCTIONALLY doesn't really change anything, but according to the rules it does. Because if a spell has multiple targets, and you cast a spell that lets you choose new targets, (like redirect) you only have 2 choices. Re-choose all of the targets, or let them stay as they are. If a spell has 2 targets, you can NOT choose 1 new one and keep one target the same.
      Functionally, this doesn't really matter, since you can simply choose the same target again. But the ruling exists because Sideswipe very specifically allows you to skip over any targets you don't want to change.

  • @dBradbury
    @dBradbury Місяць тому +143

    Oh I absolutely had a one-off Karn Liberated Shahrazad deck I played at work for a bit after New Phyrexia came out. Got to restart a subgame with Karn, and then I never played the deck again. Thanks for the reminder and the video!

    • @theArcosa
      @theArcosa  Місяць тому +29

      Oh no...

    • @jaredkreft7244
      @jaredkreft7244 Місяць тому +25

      I had a chaos deck back in the day (everyone draws from the same deck), and played Shahrazad. One of the players picked up the card and read it out loud. "Players leave the game in progress.... Sounds good!" and everyone quit. I removed it that evening.

    • @TheUnspeakeable
      @TheUnspeakeable Місяць тому +1

      How? Shahrazad is banned in all formats

    • @dBradbury
      @dBradbury Місяць тому +8

      @TheUnspeakeable The people I was playing with, including myself knew nothing about formats back then. We'd buy cards that did funny things and build decks around them. It was normally a 4-player game with 60 card decks, and let people know if we didn't want to play against a certain deck that day. A person could have a random Strip Mine or Sol Ring, and nobody batted an eye since we didn't know better and just thought they were cheap cards.

    • @fermitupoupon1754
      @fermitupoupon1754 Місяць тому +8

      @@TheUnspeakeable casual is a format...

  • @Master_Yort
    @Master_Yort Місяць тому +28

    My favorite unique effect in Magic is Aeon Engine. You pay 5 and exile it to reverse the game turn order.

  • @imstupid880
    @imstupid880 Місяць тому +37

    A lot of old cards can be described as reading the card and knowing what it does, and then thinking about a second time and realizing you have no idea how it works mechanically.

    • @misirtere9836
      @misirtere9836 Місяць тому +12

      "Reading the card explains the card if you don't think about it too hard"

    • @Numbabu
      @Numbabu Місяць тому +4

      @@misirtere9836i like when oracle text completely changes a card. Or as is most fun to say: reading the card doesn’t explain the card.

  • @issacelkhal7861
    @issacelkhal7861 Місяць тому +85

    Just found this channel, super cool video. Feedback - I think you could have expanded this video to include uses of some of these cards, reading out more of the Oracle text (a lot of UA-cam viewers listen/watch in the background), or point out how some of these cards create interesting scenarios. Definitely earned the subscribe by me, looking forward to seeing your other content.

    • @theArcosa
      @theArcosa  Місяць тому +10

      Thanks for the feedback!

    • @MrDaXLR
      @MrDaXLR Місяць тому +1

      I second that because I listen more than I watch. But even while actively watching I had to rewind and pause to read since I don't have the context for any of those rules and cards.
      Its a super interesting topic and very well made video so I didnt mind, but I would have bounced off otherwise.

  • @callumbreton8930
    @callumbreton8930 12 днів тому +3

    "Hey I know this video is really long and most of you won't make it to the end" bro said this about a 20 minute video

  • @caseywellington4761
    @caseywellington4761 Місяць тому +21

    Henzie would be so happy to know that he's breaking the rules so definitively, that even custom-designed rules can't keep him in line.

  • @bloodyboy8947
    @bloodyboy8947 Місяць тому +141

    Floral Spuzzem is sad that it wasn't included

    • @theArcosa
      @theArcosa  Місяць тому +89

      I am sure Floral Spuzzem will come to choose to get over it 🥲

    • @rmcminiking
      @rmcminiking Місяць тому +9

      My guy if you have floral spuzzem it's time to see a doctor

    • @taofaj4217
      @taofaj4217 Місяць тому +2

      Delif’s cube and Delif’s cone do very similar things I think

    • @NMS127
      @NMS127 Місяць тому +13

      @@taofaj4217 The joke is that the printed wording of Floral Spuzzem allows the card to make a decision, rather than a player.

    • @taofaj4217
      @taofaj4217 Місяць тому +3

      @NMS127 oh whoops. I read the oracle text. That’s hilarious

  • @Hanmacx
    @Hanmacx Місяць тому +25

    5:31 Trinisphere is also funky with effects that changes how costs are paid
    Like choosing to pay life for Phyrexian Mana is done before Trinisphere,
    While choosing to tap creatures for Convoke is after that 😅

    • @elijahbuck6499
      @elijahbuck6499 Місяць тому +1

      That’s because phyrexian mana says you can pay two life instead of mana, and convoke says you may tap creatures to pay for mana

    • @Hanmacx
      @Hanmacx Місяць тому +1

      @elijahbuck6499
      There was a time when Convoke was a Cost Reduction and worked differently
      That's why I'm pointing that out

    • @ZakanaHachihaCBC
      @ZakanaHachihaCBC Місяць тому

      @@elijahbuck6499It’s actually because you make the choice of paying 2 life in the second step of casting a spell, which is why Phyrexian Mana doesn’t work.
      Convoke and Delve both were reduction effects before being changed in M15 to be alternative mana payments.

  • @faesommers
    @faesommers Місяць тому +19

    thank you so much for adding manual captions! i’ve got hearing problems and auditory processing issues, so accurate captions help so much

  • @SaltOfTheEarth1611
    @SaltOfTheEarth1611 Місяць тому +36

    I have a deck that runs raging riving and now that I know Camoflouge exists, I know I can have two decks with weird combat jank.

    • @sirvaniss
      @sirvaniss Місяць тому +4

      "Combat jank" and "spellslinger jank" are two archetypes this video could provide significant fuel for.

    • @philippschmidt9499
      @philippschmidt9499 Місяць тому +2

      Why not both in the same deck for maximum combat confusion?

    • @shonmatthew
      @shonmatthew Місяць тому +1

      If you can manage a jeskai shell, id highly recommend Space Beleren

    • @ManaPirate
      @ManaPirate Місяць тому +2

      ​​@@philippschmidt9499I was both delighted and sad to learn that camoflauge exists. I have a pile that uses Pramikon as the commander and then creates combat chaos with space beleren and raging rivers.
      I then force everyone to play with it using goad.
      Camoflauge would have been immensely funny to include but jeskai :(

    • @ManaPirate
      @ManaPirate Місяць тому +1

      ​@@shonmatthewPramikon the Sky Rampart is the perfect commander for both space beleren and raging rivers. Extremely funny

  • @Halinn
    @Halinn Місяць тому +8

    How to win with Divine Intervention: play in a game with the Limited Range of Influence Option (rule 801), using Hive Mind and Mindslaver, have the player to one side of you Donate the Divine Influence that you previously Donated to them. When the player who does not have you in their range of influence draws the game for everyone in *their* range of influence, you'll be the only player remaining in the game, and thus the winner.

  • @TheShadowflare789
    @TheShadowflare789 Місяць тому +12

    I find it interesting that while Midnight Clock is technically the only card worded that way ("when/whenever the Nth [kind] counter is put on this"), rule 122.7 describing how it functions is worded identically to rule 714.2b which describes the meaning of Saga chapter abilities. Which means, if Sagas had chapter abilities written out of the card as triggered abilities (instead of just roman numerals), they would probably be worded the exact same way ("When the Nth lore counter is put on this Saga, [effect]").

  • @davidhower7095
    @davidhower7095 Місяць тому +20

    I love weird wording on cards. Equinox is a personal favorite. I’m a little surprised to not see Season of the Witch on this list, though, considering it’s the only instance of “couldn’t attack” on cards. Savage Punch saying “before (it fights)” is also unique as far as I can tell.

    • @theArcosa
      @theArcosa  Місяць тому +13

      @@davidhower7095 Nooooo! I had Season of the Witch on my draft list and I somehow lost it when I was writing the scriptttttttt 😭

  • @Hanmacx
    @Hanmacx Місяць тому +11

    Ghostly Flame changes the Color of Damage,
    While not changes the color of a card
    That can matter for Damage Replacement effects and Prevention effects if they say "Red Source" vs "Red Card"

    • @seandun7083
      @seandun7083 Місяць тому

      Edit: I had the wrong card
      It does change the color of the card, just not the color identity.
      Ruling:
      "Ghostfire is colorless in all zones. Its damage comes from a colorless source."

    • @Hanmacx
      @Hanmacx Місяць тому

      @seandun7083
      Wrong card!
      Ghostly Flame:
      Black and/or red permanents and spells are colorless sources of damage.
      "It does not change the color of the source, so that things that trigger on a red spell doing damage will still trigger. The damage itself thinks it came from a colorless source, however."

    • @seandun7083
      @seandun7083 Місяць тому

      @@Hanmacx oh right. Yeah, that is a weird one.

  • @theemathas
    @theemathas Місяць тому +45

    You forgot to mention Season Of The Witch, and its confusing interaction with Silent Arbiter.

    • @theArcosa
      @theArcosa  Місяць тому +27

      @@theemathas I knowwww 😭 Somewhere between my draft and scripting, it got lost 😢

  • @Hanmacx
    @Hanmacx Місяць тому +18

    4:20 i still laugh how they needed to update the Symbol from P to H because they needed P for Pawprint 😅

    • @underFlorence
      @underFlorence Місяць тому

      I'm not sure if that's actually true? I recall that symbol being called H way before Bloomburrow came out

    • @Hanmacx
      @Hanmacx Місяць тому +1

      @underFlorence
      > It will be {P}. One older card, Rage Extractor, used {P} already, but that symbol will be updated to {H} instead.

    • @underFlorence
      @underFlorence Місяць тому +1

      @@Hanmacx Guess I misremembered, thank you!

  • @Kjos_jax
    @Kjos_jax Місяць тому +3

    Crazy that we would think a 23-minute video is long when we watch podcasts that last hours regularly. I found this video to be the perfect length. Thanks for the content

    • @theArcosa
      @theArcosa  27 днів тому +1

      I feel kind of weird about it, like somehow the most digestible content is either 30 sec or 2 hr long. Maybe I’m weird though 😂

  • @nvvv_
    @nvvv_ Місяць тому +2

    Panglacial Wurm is one of my favorite cards in magic. What a fun card

  • @celestialTangle
    @celestialTangle Місяць тому +9

    106.11 not having "treat this mana as if it were from a snow permanent" is a crime

  • @insidious
    @insidious Місяць тому +19

    My guess on the Panglacial Wurm combo involves creatures that tap for mana equal to their power, and some way that you can keep putting the wurm into your library and searching to cast it again. Without doing a bunch of searching, Perilous Forays and something like Reito Lantern would work with enough starting mana. A really unique loop, though Panglacial being an expensive enough spell to trigger Ragga and very accessible with things like fetches seems plenty good enough on its own.

    • @theArcosa
      @theArcosa  Місяць тому +13

      Close one! We need to use an X spell tutor like Chord of Calling, Finale of Devastation, or Green Sun’s Zenith for an X value big enough to trigger Raggadragga. If we get Temur Sabretooth, we can just return Panglacial Wurm to our hand and recast it infinite times.

    • @insidious
      @insidious Місяць тому +1

      @@theArcosa A much more obviously useful combo to be sure, tutoring up both parts you need for the combo at once.

    • @DrD72
      @DrD72 Місяць тому

      Not to rain on your combo, but Wurmcalling accomplishes this without the extra hoops, thanks to being an X spell with buyback.

    • @theArcosa
      @theArcosa  Місяць тому +3

      @@DrD72 Yes! And this is why Raggadragga is so funny.
      I like to treat all of these spells as "the same" combo, but with redundancy.
      X tutors are nice because they can double up to find the power dork if you don't have one online as well.

    • @ragnarokgamingyt7476
      @ragnarokgamingyt7476 Місяць тому +2

      I get that Temur Sabretooth puts it in your hand but the Wurm says you may play it from your library so unless you have a way to put it on top of your library, this wouldn't work

  • @Lookalikealagaler
    @Lookalikealagaler Місяць тому +7

    Surprised Butcher Orgg didn't get a mention. Wasn't aware of any other cards with a similar ability.

    • @TheKingNaesala
      @TheKingNaesala Місяць тому +2

      Probably because of various instants and sorceries that let you split damage. Making it combat damage definitely seems like unique text if not rules and deserving of an honorable mention. Defensive formation also allows you to make the same decision in reverse, so maybe that disqualified it. Cool card though

  • @dorping_Wolf
    @dorping_Wolf Місяць тому +3

    my favorite "screw the rules, i do something that should not be possible" card is still "Spellweaver Volute". aka:
    "Enchant instant card in a graveyard"

  • @Feszy_
    @Feszy_ 10 днів тому +1

    Rules Lawyer in the first 30 seconds. I love everything about this.

  • @kazj4908
    @kazj4908 День тому +1

    Another unique thing i find entertaining: Gilded Drake's Oracle text says "This ability resolves even if its target becomes illegal."

  • @vulcanviperx
    @vulcanviperx Місяць тому +14

    3:50 got you bud

    • @roadkillreborn3047
      @roadkillreborn3047 16 днів тому

      I’ll leave a like, if I watch a third video of his, I’ll hit subscribe. I’m here to fall asleep lol

    • @vulcanviperx
      @vulcanviperx 15 днів тому

      @ it’s free, why you acting like it’s a sample at Costco ?

  • @micboyyaboy2578
    @micboyyaboy2578 Місяць тому +13

    13:30 I have like 20 Kaervek's Torches lying around in my bulk boxes, and I always felt bad for not finding a use for them. Glad to see that I was right that they're special!

    • @Artaimus
      @Artaimus Місяць тому +1

      Aye, I got into the game during Mirage and have a bunch as well!

    • @AlexisWrenn
      @AlexisWrenn Місяць тому +1

      Its pretty niche but ive used one as a wincon in combo decks in pauper.

    • @micboyyaboy2578
      @micboyyaboy2578 Місяць тому +1

      @@AlexisWrenn Ooh, yeah, that's a good use! I actually do play a little pauper myself lol

  • @YourPalJamieEllis
    @YourPalJamieEllis Місяць тому +6

    As a comprehensive rules nerd, I love having all of these exceptions, oddities, and cards that probably shouldn't have been printed all in one spot!

    • @Hanmacx
      @Hanmacx Місяць тому

      Use Ghostly Flame to Change the Color of a Damage *Source* 😮

  • @AgelessObsession
    @AgelessObsession Місяць тому +5

    9:55 Ah, yes, destructible. I have that keyword.

  • @shenandoahologist6713
    @shenandoahologist6713 Місяць тому +11

    Re the claim at 7:45 that Divine Intervention is the only card that can't help us win the game. Off the top of my head:
    - Have it in play to passively boost Perrie the Pulverizer, Bribe Taker, Storm of Forms or Lumbering Megasloth
    - Use Nesting Grounds or similar to move an intervention counter to Gavel of the Righteous or a creature equipped with Luxior
    - Remove an intervention counter for profit with Power Conduit, Xavier Sal, Tayam, Sanctuary Warden or Falco Spara
    - Synergize with constellation or other enchantments matter effects
    - Synergize with permanents matter, mana value matters, colour matters or card count matters effects
    - Ping something for 2 on ETB with All will be One
    Fun vid, by the way. :)

    • @creepykoala7255
      @creepykoala7255 Місяць тому +6

      You are eligable for infinite bragging rights if you manage to win a game thanks to Divine Intervention.

    • @Shenandoahologist
      @Shenandoahologist Місяць тому +4

      Oh yeah definitely. I never claimed it was *good* at helping you win the game.
      (I have seriously considered including it for its unique counter type in a “different types of counters” matter deck though.)

    • @sedmaxime
      @sedmaxime Місяць тому

      Damn I thought I had secret sauce running Divine Intervention in WUBRG Gods tribal Commander and using Nesting Grounds to move counters between gods and also as a way to get Intervention popped faster. I call it "By the Grace of the Gods"

    • @drakesdrum1
      @drakesdrum1 Місяць тому

      You're all overlooking the obvious reason to play Divine Intervention: to force an opponent to overplay their hand in an attempt to pull out a win before it goes off, allowing you counter-punch for the win.
      Alternatively, in a tournament format where you've already won enough games that all you need to do to progress is Not Lose, drop it and guarantee your path to the next round.

    • @Halinn
      @Halinn Місяць тому +1

      Multiplayer game with limited range of influence (rule 801), find a way to give it to someone who does not have you in their range of influence.

  • @michaelsander2878
    @michaelsander2878 Місяць тому +23

    I'll bet celebra-800 is a coding issue. Something about the way the oracle database or website or something is displayed. Those long bars might have have been entered as a character/command/syntax whatever that is removing the first 2 letters from the string. I'm tired and sick so I am not braining good

  • @MomirViggwilv
    @MomirViggwilv Місяць тому +6

    Was expecting Riding the Dilu Horse to show up in the mistakes section

  • @Hanmacx
    @Hanmacx Місяць тому +3

    Altar of the Pantheon and Devotion
    For it to work with the Gods, Devotion is calculated in between Layer 3 and 4
    See Rule 700.5a 😅

  • @PerfectSevenMTG
    @PerfectSevenMTG Місяць тому +10

    RAGING RIVER MENTION!! Amazing video as always Arcosa!

  • @sayntfuu
    @sayntfuu Місяць тому +14

    Pretty sure it's a parsing error. Likely a misaligned query in the DB. They have bad math on the Rulings of Academy Manufactor, you only need 17 manufacturers to hit that number.

    • @stellabiderman4056
      @stellabiderman4056 Місяць тому +2

      The same error is in the ruling for two Manufacturers, which is even more perplexing / obvious. Immediately after the n = 1 case (which correctly states that you'd make "that many") it states that in the n = 2 case you'd make "three times that many."
      I wonder if you can set up a situation that produces a logical paradox according to the rulings as a result of this bad math...

  • @tyronephillips4596
    @tyronephillips4596 Місяць тому +15

    There are 9 steps a player must take when casting a spell (it doesn't feel like it!) and while creating a powerpoint presentation about that I became a bit puzzled about the last one:
    "601.2i Once the steps described in 601.2a-h are completed, effects that modify the characteristics of
    the spell as it’s cast are applied, then the spell becomes cast.[...]"
    I wracked my brain to work out what "effects that modify the characteristics of the spell as it’s cast" are, I eventually found that the ONLY card that invokes this rule is Yidris. Other cards give Cascade, but he is the only one that creates a trigger that gives Cascade, and I believe that's why he gained his own rule.
    Suuuuper niche and very hard to find, doubly so because Yidris doesn't seem like a unique effect.

    • @armedjoy3045
      @armedjoy3045 Місяць тому

      Kicker?

    • @stellabiderman4056
      @stellabiderman4056 Місяць тому +2

      @@armedjoy3045only a specific list of things are characteristics:
      109.3 An object's characteristics are name, mana cost, color, color indicator, card type, subtype, supertype, rules text, abilities, power, toughness, loyalty, defense, hand modifier, and life modifier. Objects can have some or all of these characteristics. Any other information about an object isn't a characteristic.
      While I haven't read every card with kicker, a card with kicker would need to have peculiar wording. Something like "if ~ was kicked, ~ has split second" would do it. I can write others but that's the one that comes the closest to making sense IMO. As I write this, I could imagine a shock that has kicker W that gives the spell lifelink. However it would need to actually say "lifelink" and not just "if ~ was kicked, you gain two life."

  • @dianueva
    @dianueva Місяць тому +3

    Love this video. Quick, direct, and the audio/editing is great

  • @nthetiteGHOST
    @nthetiteGHOST Місяць тому +2

    One mention that doesnt have a rules listing but is unique to my knowledge is river songs first ability.
    It is the only legal card i know of that says draw cards from the bottom instead of the top.
    (Lantern of undersight is a test card that does the same)

  • @retronymph
    @retronymph Місяць тому +5

    I agree with most of the uninteresting cards on the list, but I think Steamflogger Boss deserves a mention for being the only black border card with a deliberately nonfunctional line of text.

  • @darebrained
    @darebrained Місяць тому +1

    On the unique keywords:
    - While Absorb, Fateseal and Poisonous had technically been reprinted, those were all only used on reprints of their cards from FUT and most of those only on list slots, as part of timespiral remaster or "side products" like From the Vault or Archenemy
    - Deathtouch, Lifelink, Reach and Shroud all were previously used effects turned into keywords, so while technically "new" keywords, they were introduced for long existing effects - though since then Lifelink and Deathtouch both became static effects, at the time of their introduction they were triggered
    - _cycling actually saw a singular instance before FUT with Wirewood Guardian having "Forestcycling" back in 2003
    - Frenzy technically saw a reprint in Unstable on "Garbage Elemental"

  • @sporkmaster5000
    @sporkmaster5000 Місяць тому +1

    While not mechanically unique, my favorite one-of wording is Choice of Damnations. Your opponent picks a number and then you choose if they lose that much life, or sacrifice "all but that many" creatures. I'm not aware of any other time you can choose if a variable is the negative or positive in a card effect's evaluation. Just about every time I've played it I get a double take from an opponent, usually after they opt for a very low number.

  • @Reytromancer
    @Reytromancer Місяць тому +6

    Incredible video Arcosa!! Now a deck challenge to make a functional deck with so many of these cards. 😮

  • @fernandobanda5734
    @fernandobanda5734 Місяць тому +1

    Since I was a kid, Arcbound Wanderer seems so weird to me. It could've worked by just saying Sunburst and Modular 0. There was no need to make a composite keyword.

  • @penultimateApogee
    @penultimateApogee Місяць тому +1

    just found your channel through this video, and the fact that you went to the trouble of having accurate & grammatical subtitles on this video make it an EASY subscribe. even for people who aren't deaf or hard of hearing (i personally just eat a lot of corn chips), it really goes a long way!

  • @GunBunnyUTX
    @GunBunnyUTX Місяць тому +2

    Kind of surprised Ice Cauldron isn't on here, as it keeps track of the mana spent to activate it.

    • @hellto2
      @hellto2 Місяць тому

      Jeweled Amulet comes to mind which works similarly.

  • @PimpTrizkit-42
    @PimpTrizkit-42 Місяць тому +2

    9:56 - Celebr-8000 - I would guess that they tried to put the text character for the bullet symbol in there and the rulings engine wasn't designed for extended ASCII set. So apparently the parser chopped off some of the text trying to find useful symbols and it caused the first two (first four?) characters to be deleted.

  • @smashbuddie
    @smashbuddie Місяць тому +4

    I have wondered about this very topic so many times! Thank you for making this video :)

  • @numbers00
    @numbers00 26 днів тому +1

    "I know this videos really long" I'd watch a 3.5 hour version of this video

  • @thomassynths
    @thomassynths Місяць тому +1

    Divine Intervention overcomes Platinum Angel. Them was fighting words when you basically said the card was jank.

  • @arrowrandoman
    @arrowrandoman 12 днів тому +1

    So Kaervak's Torch has Ward 2, basically. That would be an interesting space to explore, I think.

  • @Patrick_Bard
    @Patrick_Bard 8 днів тому +1

    9:52 this seems to be a bug in Scryfall, Gatherer doesn't have the same problem with the rulings.
    You can open an issue with them, this kind of mistake they tend to fix pretty fast.

    • @theArcosa
      @theArcosa  8 днів тому

      @@Patrick_Bard Woah, woah, woah! No way! The errors were on both Scryfall and Gatherer until LAST WEEK!
      Someone at WOTC must have watched my video because they were on Gatherer as well until very recently. You can check it out on the Wayback Machine.
      web.archive.org/web/20250105041427/gatherer.wizards.com/pages/Card/Details.aspx?multiverseid=580712

  • @siubijeni206
    @siubijeni206 24 дні тому +2

    "Hey, I know this video is really long..."
    *be me*
    *check video runtime*
    *be shocked video is only 22 minutes*

  • @Bonesito44
    @Bonesito44 Місяць тому +7

    12:44 you definitely have my attention

    • @kumabear5229
      @kumabear5229 Місяць тому

      haha big creatures go stomp stomp

  • @bastokrepublic
    @bastokrepublic Місяць тому +1

    9:50 it is probably caused by the double dash symbols being an escape character sequence of some type. They define ways to alter the text before/after them in some way.

  • @cope_or_rope
    @cope_or_rope Місяць тому +1

    aeons engine is also a unique ability from commander
    capricopian is also a weird card from commander
    skullbriar is the only creature who keeps +1+1 counters even if it's sent to the graveyard or the command zone

    • @seandun7083
      @seandun7083 Місяць тому +2

      Me, the Immortal from the Dr Who decks is similar to Skullbriar.

    • @Bhit_Whyz
      @Bhit_Whyz 19 днів тому

      There are a handful of combat redirect effects like Capricopian's, Portal Mage and Misleading Signpost are a couple.

  • @xDNightmarex
    @xDNightmarex Місяць тому +5

    Hrm 🤔"Nivmagus Elemental" also mechanically unique? Guess that slipped through your list. (Still love my deck with it, so remembered the card)

    • @theArcosa
      @theArcosa  Місяць тому +3

      @@xDNightmarex With Synthesis Pod, we have a second card that exiles spells you control as costs now!

  • @zym6687
    @zym6687 Місяць тому +2

    19:48 When the monarch dies to the AP that cast a Jared that turn, the rule says to make the AP the monarch then Jared says that can't happen. That's the end of it. Nothing in the rules says to do anything if the AP can't become the monarch.
    The active player is not leaving the game and does exist so the second sentence does not apply to this scenario so it can't make the next player in turn order the monarch as none of its conditions apply.
    As for the last sentence, it doesn't matter that there is still a player in the game that CAN become the monarch at that time for any reason, besides that it doesn't do anything in any scenario but say to continue the game.

  • @georgeerniej
    @georgeerniej 25 днів тому +1

    At uni I printed a physical rule book, but damn it got outdated quickly

  • @WLDFLD
    @WLDFLD Місяць тому +1

    Great video! I will say it's been 20 years since Shahrazad was the only card to start a subgame. Now there are four such cards.

    • @Idran
      @Idran Місяць тому

      Yeah, but the other three are all silver-border/acorn, and this video is about effects that are unique in black-border. That's also why 726.1 still has the wording "One card (Shahrazad) allows players to play a Magic subgame" even in the most recent version of the Comp Rules.

  • @TheLuckySpades
    @TheLuckySpades Місяць тому +10

    Please elabotate on everything, for me the broken commander cards even after the "fix" is highest

    • @theArcosa
      @theArcosa  Місяць тому +7

      @@TheLuckySpades They’re 99% of the way there, but the issue is that Zinnia is an additional cost that obeys normal casting conditions.
      The exceptions they put into the rules with 611.3d only apply to events that alter a player’s ability to cast. Henzie and Serra Paragon are both cast permission effects (blitz is an alternative casting mode), so these fixes are effective for them.
      However, Zinnia’s offspring ability isn’t covered yet, so it has an unintended side effect that offspring won’t persist if Zinnia is removed from the battlefield before the creature resolves.

  • @hiffwelaflare
    @hiffwelaflare Місяць тому +1

    Divine Intervention can never win you a game, but good lord can it ever win you a match

  • @bradbourque3766
    @bradbourque3766 Місяць тому

    Awesome video! I've been working on a deck with this idea in mind, and this was super helpful. I'm definitely including Cryptic Spires, I had no idea it was legal in commander!
    It's not the most interesting, but Aeon Engine inspired me to start working on the deck, and probably fits under the Metagame Effects actions, because it references the turn order, and I'm not sure any other card does that.

  • @BS-bv5sh
    @BS-bv5sh Місяць тому +2

    This is what I want from MtG content

  • @celestial59
    @celestial59 Місяць тому +3

    Great video, it’s clear a lot of work went into it. Could you elaborate on why Henzie still technically doesn’t work as intended?

    • @theArcosa
      @theArcosa  Місяць тому +1

      Henzie should be fine now, but I was more referring to how the rules still don't account for Zinnia. We're still waiting on a rules update, as promised here: x.com/WotC_Matt/status/1828115172457881777

  • @faceoctopus4571
    @faceoctopus4571 Місяць тому +1

    I guess Grist wasn't unique enough. I think it's pretty unique because it's characteristic defining ability doesn't apply when it's on the battlefield.

  • @Stratic1357
    @Stratic1357 Місяць тому +3

    To my knowledge, Ashiok, Nightmare Muse is the only card that lets you cast your opponents cards that were exiled by a card other than itself.

    • @tomc.5704
      @tomc.5704 Місяць тому +1

      Surely there's at least a few cards that exile your opponents cards and place the same counters on them?

    • @MetaKaios
      @MetaKaios Місяць тому

      @@tomc.5704 Tinybones, Bauble Burglar; Tasha, the Witch Queen; and Draugr Necromancer can cast things that were exiled by someone else's copy of that same card. (They use named counters, but no other cards put those counters on exiled cards)
      The only card I'm aware of that casts things exiled by a card with a _different name_ is Haldan, Avid Arcanist, and that's because it's designed to work with its partner which does the exiling (Pako, Arcane Retriever).

    • @lassehoffmann625
      @lassehoffmann625 Місяць тому

      Also dauthi voidwalker which sees play in cedh and is annoying when 2 people have one and want to cast the same spell (if one person targets a card the other can respond to get to do it before the first dauthi but has to do it before the other ability resolves otherwise both can cast the spell whenever they have priority​@@MetaKaios

  • @Autissima
    @Autissima Місяць тому +1

    Yes please elaborate and tell us more about the glacial worm deck!

    • @theArcosa
      @theArcosa  Місяць тому

      @@Autissima Check the pinned comment!

  • @keepingitcasualmtg
    @keepingitcasualmtg Місяць тому +1

    This was a fantastic video! I learned so much!

  • @bryceduyvewaardt8136
    @bryceduyvewaardt8136 Місяць тому +1

    Since Henzie was a FACE commander for a precon (and I’ve made an all creatures deck with odd creatures like mutate creatures, cost-reducing creatures, Gleancrawler (I THINK it doesn’t return itself from being Blitzed) and The Master Multiplied (I THINK it still sacrifices itself after a Blitz). More clarification for this popular commander would be helpful!

    • @seandun7083
      @seandun7083 Місяць тому +2

      The Gleancrawler interaction should work. Both triggers happen at the beginning of your end step and since you control them both, you can sacrifice it before it's own trigger resolves.
      The Master Multiplied will still sacrifice itself since it's not a token and it only stops tokens from being sacrificed.

    • @bryceduyvewaardt8136
      @bryceduyvewaardt8136 13 днів тому

      @@seandun7083 Good to know, thanks for the clarification!

  • @Londrino
    @Londrino 13 днів тому

    Ah excellent, just gave me another thing to randomly remind my opponent of just to mess with them.
    "Gravestorm count is at 2... pass turn."

  • @double2helix
    @double2helix Місяць тому +1

    You put Henzie in the thumbnail and that was the main reason I clicked on this video, what the hell dude

  • @Val825.
    @Val825. 25 днів тому

    Shout out to My boy "chains of mephistopheles" for being one of the few cards with Oracle text that starts with "here is what happens when You cast chains of mephistopheles"

  • @WallessJ
    @WallessJ Місяць тому

    I think my favorite individual card ruling is from Stone Haven Outfitter. It's 2 paragraphs about a situation that was impossible in the game until the LOTR set. And all it's saying is that "equipped creatures" means all equipped creatures not just one equipped by the card.

    • @seandun7083
      @seandun7083 Місяць тому

      Couldn't you Swift Reconfiguration + Bludgeon Brawl before then?

  • @leaguesmanoframsgate
    @leaguesmanoframsgate Місяць тому

    I think the way to make Jandor's Ring do what it's supposed to is as follows:
    ---
    Ring Of The Shattered Stone: {2}
    Whenever you draw a card, you may pay {2} and {T} before the card enters your hand. If you do, discard the card you just drew and draw a card. Activate this ability as an instant.
    ---
    Obviously it would need some tidying up to make the wording fit with proper Magic language, but I think this is what the card is trying to accomplish, and by forming a space between when the card is drawn and when the card enters your hand it makes it harder to cheat. I'm not sure how powerful it is but adding the tap clause probably helps mitigate the worst of it.

  • @maverickmikeb
    @maverickmikeb Місяць тому

    I grew up invoking the subgame rules. Also, the rules for subgames was changing behind the scenes with how the effects work as I understand it.

  • @griff_grey
    @griff_grey Місяць тому +1

    Prince Zuko jumpscare 21:18

  • @BlueSunHiredGun
    @BlueSunHiredGun Місяць тому

    10:48 I think Charmed Pendant would also fall under Elemental Resonance's rules that add Phyrexian and hybrid mana. That said, Elemental Resonance is still the only one to add generic or snow mana.

  • @JamesR-t2t
    @JamesR-t2t Місяць тому +1

    Curious if you feel like Plains // Battlefield Forge from the MSCHF Secret Lair Drop is mechanically unique - it's fascinating because it is legal in every format and the most literal of transformational cards. I have always wanted to see someone clutch tournament play that card when they need red mana and rip off the sticker

    • @theArcosa
      @theArcosa  Місяць тому

      @@JamesR-t2t You would get DQ’d for that

  • @impishrunt
    @impishrunt Місяць тому

    I hope to see the broken-ness of Henzie and Zinnia explained further. I think I understand the issue on a basic level, but if there is greater detail to go into, I would love to hear it.

  • @mitchellradspinner4491
    @mitchellradspinner4491 Місяць тому

    I know how much time every clip cut and every sound can add up to. You made an awesome video and should feel proud!

  • @mr45buster
    @mr45buster 25 днів тому

    14:50 by no means am I an expert in rulings they same way some of you all are, but my mind immediately jumped to Cyclopean Tomb here as well

  • @137shadowX
    @137shadowX Місяць тому

    oh don't you DARE badmouth divine intervention in front of me. you take that back right now

  • @grantmurdock7385
    @grantmurdock7385 Місяць тому

    Divine Intervention technically could help you win if animated with Opalescence. Though I remember it for being the key "win condition" in an old InQuest magazine's "the world's most annoying deck" build.

  • @lucasmachadoh
    @lucasmachadoh Місяць тому +1

    This is my exact type of video, thank you for making it

  • @Insigneos
    @Insigneos Місяць тому

    Loved the video. Congrats on all the views!

  • @NYNmetal
    @NYNmetal Місяць тому

    Chance for glory is an interesting one that could be counted as a mistake. Creatures you control gain indestructible forever. If you find a way to not lose the game (platinum angel, lich’s mastery) your creatures are indestructible forever.

    • @seandun7083
      @seandun7083 29 днів тому

      It's definitely cool, but Riding the Dilu Horse have a permanent buff long before.

  • @chielover1490
    @chielover1490 Місяць тому +12

    The two times you asked if we wanted to hear I want to hear!!
    I would love to know how panglacial worm combos from you, and even more so would love to learn why in the world those two new commanders are odd! I'm eating this content right up!!

  • @Nocsha217
    @Nocsha217 Місяць тому

    I'm surprised Ice Caildron didn't get a mention, it allows you to oay for a creature soell over 2 turns

  • @austins.3362
    @austins.3362 Місяць тому +1

    Hard earned the like for me when you answered my exact thought of, they reprinted gravestorm???

  • @hedgehogwriting55
    @hedgehogwriting55 Місяць тому

    love that henzie kinda got a "whatever, it works the way we want!" treatment

  • @kilo3989
    @kilo3989 20 днів тому

    I am glad that the rules for specific cards and specific edge case scenarios are, more or less, intuitive. "Yes, of course you can count those two cards drawn as 'two cards drawn.'" "Yes, of course Ashiok doesn't exile your pain land." Etc. 😂

  • @mightyfp
    @mightyfp Місяць тому

    Season of the witch is a black enchantment of sirens call and raging river inspired a while slew of pile cards in invasion block. This is an awesome video btw!!

  • @MarneusAndMilkyBlood
    @MarneusAndMilkyBlood Місяць тому

    I have a copy of circling vultures in my old border themed Asmoranomardicadaistinaculdacar deck, good stuff.

  • @bhalps
    @bhalps Місяць тому

    AMAZING VIDEO, thank you for all the hard work and research you put into this to help enlighten other players

  • @Blargerhonk
    @Blargerhonk Місяць тому

    My favorite deck is the one that my friend describes as "Making you know the rules better". My Chaos Deck. There is no win con, there is no winning at all. It's there to fuck with *EVERY* rule possible. The closest it has to a win con is the hurricane huge ramp combo to try and kill the table at once.