Commander Versus - David McDarby (Phenax) vs. Justin Parnell (Tariel)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 16 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 95

  • @phatbastard0alkaline
    @phatbastard0alkaline 10 років тому +16

    McDarby how could you? Cheated in Phenax for 4 colorless and one blue/black at 6:00 . I think McDarby is the real God of Deception!

    • @tylerdurden5127
      @tylerdurden5127 10 років тому +1

      That didn't really mattered as he ended his turn with an untapped land that could produce U.

    • @phatbastard0alkaline
      @phatbastard0alkaline 10 років тому

      MrApotamus He got 1 mana from the Relic in his mainphase when he cast Martial Coup for 5, relic is untapped, he has 6 lands.EOT on Davids endstep he tapped the relic to put a charge counter. He then untapped, got 1 mana from the relic in his mainphase and then tapped the relic for an additional mana, so no cheating.

  • @zarteen
    @zarteen 10 років тому +8

    David McDarby. Singing Persona songs. Milling in commander. A true hero. :')

  • @bouldering122
    @bouldering122 10 років тому +1

    In the first game did I see two elspeth sun champions? Within the pregame mill seven a sun champion came up and then the first phynaxill nine one came up too?

  • @Lost77
    @Lost77 8 років тому +12

    Is this Justin Parnell's first Commander appearance? Classic times... I miss David McDarby

  • @UnofficialAwesome
    @UnofficialAwesome 10 років тому +4

    Monty Python References 35:30

  • @starkd3357
    @starkd3357 10 років тому +3

    "crack fetch take two" "no i dont think i am" "what, but its modern" "shhh" "oh" "thats enough out of you"

  • @TK-Seer
    @TK-Seer 10 років тому +1

    I think in game 1, first zombie tokens only must have two counters +1/+1 instead of three, because titan enters first, and then the tokens.

  • @BaileyCaPWN
    @BaileyCaPWN 10 років тому

    Best Commander Versus to date. Themed fun decks and two players wanting to HAVE FUN.

  • @tylerdurden5127
    @tylerdurden5127 10 років тому

    Very good commander game, as usual. I was actually impressed with your Phenax deck, you milled Justin quite fast! It was also funny when Justin finally beat you using Danny's favorite card: Elesh Norn. Can't wait to watch the next Commander Versus! Cheers!

  • @AgentStansfield
    @AgentStansfield 10 років тому +5

    Phenax + Duskmantle Guildmage can be a fast killer.

    • @B1gLupu
      @B1gLupu 10 років тому

      That is true, even better in multiplayer.

  • @Lucarioguild7
    @Lucarioguild7 10 років тому +13

    Why hasn't Danny West been on lately

  • @HanDaimond
    @HanDaimond 10 років тому +3

    41:13 Did McDarby just sang a Persona 3 song?

    • @ChubbsRN
      @ChubbsRN 7 років тому

      Han Daimond sure sounds like it

  • @cherudim4836
    @cherudim4836 10 років тому +1

    Love the Persona reference at the beginning of G3

  • @loganboehnlein8545
    @loganboehnlein8545 8 років тому +2

    To everyone in the comments who are butthurt about them screwing up the dice in the beginning; they are having fun, they literally could not give two shits who went first.

  • @i8yourfwd
    @i8yourfwd 10 років тому +6

    Noooo, where's Danny West?! :(

  • @John7Uzumaki
    @John7Uzumaki 10 років тому +1

    I personally would run a mill deck in standard or even commander (like here) but I always thought it is counterd way easily.. I mean I have to ask couldnt't the first round annihilation been prevented had Justin Parnell included a Koziliek, or even an Elixir of Immortality in deck plz respond cause I think is too obvious..

  • @ajk252
    @ajk252 10 років тому +2

    Was that a Persona 3 reference at the beginning of game 3?

  • @matthill3590
    @matthill3590 10 років тому

    Game one is jipped, metamorph casts for three colorless and 2 life mcdarby floated a colorless on three from the two stones essentially casting it for 2 and 2 life

  • @ChubbsRN
    @ChubbsRN 7 років тому

    that mill combo at the end was pretty sick

  • @nitzillastudio
    @nitzillastudio 10 років тому +1

    32:20 Phyrexian Ingester gets +2/+1

  • @failsc2player
    @failsc2player 10 років тому

    Is it just me or was David McDarby singing songs from Avenue Q during the games.

  • @WarsWorth
    @WarsWorth 9 років тому

    I loved that intro!

  • @Mecha82
    @Mecha82 10 років тому +1

    That was one hell of milling in first game.

  • @VoidPrincessNoire
    @VoidPrincessNoire 10 років тому

    If you took out the basic lands and any duplicate cards, you could just smash a few commander decks together to make a cube. May even try that sometime.

  • @ielelelele
    @ielelelele 10 років тому +1

    He could have held out on White Sun Zenith and cast it during upkeep to buy one more turn in game 2.

  • @Nr4747
    @Nr4747 10 років тому

    In game 2, how did Justin tap Mikaeus and put a +1/+1 counter on him on the end of David's turn, when Mikaeus still had Summoning Sickness ?

    • @WretchedPhoenix
      @WretchedPhoenix 10 років тому +2

      He didn't? Mikaeus entered with a +1/+1 counter.

    • @Nr4747
      @Nr4747 10 років тому

      Mama_Cooka
      I know, I just remembered it incorrectly.

  • @charliesernovitz3024
    @charliesernovitz3024 8 років тому +1

    👍for Monty Python reference, I miss McDarby.

  • @monomerward
    @monomerward 7 років тому +1

    little does he know that justin will go on to replace him and wipe his legacy

  • @Rhyooski
    @Rhyooski 9 років тому

    That Dunkey reference at 44:52 haha

  • @B1gLupu
    @B1gLupu 10 років тому +2

    Not a single Tariel was cast that game :D

  • @Daeio1
    @Daeio1 10 років тому +1

    Really good game! I looove phenax+eater of the dead :D

  • @grahamwarwick3079
    @grahamwarwick3079 10 років тому

    Game 1, cracking Marsh Flats into Elspeth + Goblin Bombardment would have been lethal. a 14/14 Grave Titan, two 8/8 zombies, three 3/3 soliders and two 3/3 zombies on triggers..swing for 30 and sac 7 creatures to win.

    • @gregrocks1223
      @gregrocks1223 10 років тому

      he could have just blocked.

    • @VoidPrincessNoire
      @VoidPrincessNoire 10 років тому

      He mentioned almost this exact line of play at the end of the video.

    • @grahamwarwick3079
      @grahamwarwick3079 10 років тому

      yargamafrag Yeah, I posted as it happened, realized he recognized it after the fact.

    • @VoidPrincessNoire
      @VoidPrincessNoire 10 років тому

      That's why you should watch the whole video before posting :)

  • @sethpeters7362
    @sethpeters7362 8 років тому

    Parnell is like Walter Cronkite. He gives you the facts and the story as clearly as possible. McDarby is more like a talk show host: lots of energy and charisma, but he doesn't leave you with anything substantial. Because of that, I would hate VS. if McDarby was still around. Watching Parnell and the boys play taught me a lot about Commander. I can't say the same about McDarby. A good host is not somebody you want to punch.

  • @S1L3NTDr460n
    @S1L3NTDr460n 10 років тому +3

    And this is why we run legendary eldrazi.

    • @TheNeverchadnezzar
      @TheNeverchadnezzar 10 років тому +3

      And that is why we run Leyline of the Void

    • @poppaDehorn
      @poppaDehorn 10 років тому

      thats why my mill edh general is lazav, dimir master mind. ok i milled your eldfrazi and you get your grave back but now i have a 10/10 hexproof annihilator general... enter combat step.

    • @poppaDehorn
      @poppaDehorn 10 років тому

      Jehovah here's an old list i had. its changed a little since then but you can use it as a starting point. tappedout.net/mtg-decks/lazav-the-dark-side/

    • @MrThewooter
      @MrThewooter 9 років тому

      if you have phenax as a commander you have to anticipate that and have instant speed graveyard exile efffects.

  • @Bcdeano
    @Bcdeano 10 років тому +1

    Where's Danny!!?!
    ps. waiting for like 10 min for that elesh play. Awesome. great games guys
    pps. Justin Parnell is pretty cool too lol

  • @eduardomlh2001
    @eduardomlh2001 10 років тому

    I can't wait for the next commander vs fingers crossed for a brago king eternal deck!

  • @MetalSnakeBoogy
    @MetalSnakeBoogy 7 років тому

    Consuming Aberration in a paradox/scepter infi deck is boss.

  • @dsweet5273
    @dsweet5273 10 років тому +1

    37 - 14 - 11 = 14......
    Although I suppose it didn't matter.

  • @MrMadCat1
    @MrMadCat1 10 років тому

    One word - Kozilek, Ruiner of the Mill.

  • @jm130691
    @jm130691 10 років тому

    ... Phyrexian Processor + Thousand year elixir :D Damn that could be fun though...

  • @spoc351
    @spoc351 10 років тому

    deck list?

    • @silver5465
      @silver5465 10 років тому

      In the description... :)

  • @LordHakkera
    @LordHakkera 10 років тому

    Why not just play Karona and only cast her when going for lethal?

  • @MannyM91
    @MannyM91 8 років тому

    how did erebos die to martial coup though hes indestructible...?

  • @matthewchristie3497
    @matthewchristie3497 10 років тому

    The fact that he played a mill commander s rubbing me wrong.

  • @freeofkings
    @freeofkings 10 років тому +1

    Dunkey references are always acceptable.

    • @Rhyooski
      @Rhyooski 9 років тому

      Yeah I was like, wait...

  • @GENGARFB
    @GENGARFB 5 років тому

    37-25=14?

  • @simondelacruz9834
    @simondelacruz9834 10 років тому +1

    The Avenue Q reference made my day.

  • @x1teDota
    @x1teDota 10 років тому +2

    Get Justin back again. And I want to see a Soldier deck.

  • @martini_blue_
    @martini_blue_ 10 років тому

    Love seeing a mill strat...

  • @Minastir1
    @Minastir1 10 років тому

    You forgot to pay 2 life from vampiric tutor in the first game

    • @austin4568
      @austin4568 10 років тому

      No they didn't. Watch the life total

  • @pistolpete1605
    @pistolpete1605 10 років тому

    great vid but i think mcdarby and danny should stick to these. i love seeing new faces but its so enjoyable seeing danny and david's synergy in their videos

  • @luciadamora7276
    @luciadamora7276 8 років тому

    Why herro their!

  • @jeirda5
    @jeirda5 10 років тому

    I liked Justin's deck, but I don't understand why he used that commander. Was it just for the colors? It doesn't seem to have anything to do with the deck.

    • @nachomamma
      @nachomamma 10 років тому

      Yeah, he mentions it in the recap at the end

  • @Kyn68
    @Kyn68 10 років тому

    dat monty python reference

  • @ElvlishWarrior21
    @ElvlishWarrior21 7 років тому +1

    Justin so naive and nonchalant about mill in this now 3 year old video. Oh how things have changed lol. So sorry Justin...especially after that Halloween treat.

  • @lutherboy95
    @lutherboy95 10 років тому

    I liked it!

  • @paulweiss6252
    @paulweiss6252 9 років тому

    phenax phenax

  • @shooflies
    @shooflies 9 років тому

    that eater of the dead looks so annoying lol

  • @TheLegalCustodian
    @TheLegalCustodian 10 років тому

    Mill FTW

  • @_thefinalunion
    @_thefinalunion 9 років тому

    That's why I play Emrakul.

  • @KoiPondDreams
    @KoiPondDreams 9 років тому +3

    Honestly keep Parnell and dump McDarby! He just seems so pompous and cocky and truly makes for an un-enjoyable atmosphere for a VS video. Danny west and Stephen Green are my favorite!

    • @prestonvana3191
      @prestonvana3191 9 років тому

      Jeff Muccilli 51:47 Mcdarby "I just play here with people who lose"

    • @OnyxVenator
      @OnyxVenator 8 років тому

      +The Völkisch
      I agree, David is my inspiration when the time comes to play blue again. Plus I love his costumes.

  • @haihnguyen5599
    @haihnguyen5599 10 років тому

    phenax op

  • @DirtYpiG83
    @DirtYpiG83 5 років тому

    in first game justin have win in hand

  • @jacobchen4704
    @jacobchen4704 4 роки тому

    Yay mill

  • @Scion_40k
    @Scion_40k 10 років тому

    Annnnnnd this is why you run an eldrazi in your deck, to stop nonsense like this

  • @rolandblake4943
    @rolandblake4943 10 років тому

    A note for david mcdarby:
    Phenax mills equal to power, not toughness, and by the end, you were at 12 not 14.
    Cheater detected.

    • @rolandblake4943
      @rolandblake4943 10 років тому +1

      Sorry I'm wrong, it does mill equal to toughness… but you were at 12 by the end XD.

    • @biglittlesplinter
      @biglittlesplinter 9 років тому

      +Roland B *chuckle*

  • @drop0ut606
    @drop0ut606 10 років тому

    once again, no offense to anyone else, but even with the mill if this video had Danny West...infinity more entertaining.

  • @RealBenda
    @RealBenda 10 років тому

    Awesome content! Just... make someone math-check every combat. You are absolutely terrible... :D

  • @Moose93k
    @Moose93k 10 років тому

    McDarby's a bit of a bad winner. And where's West?