Відео

I continue to pay eBay prices cause I'd rather buy a ratty, dog eared copy of Greyhawk Adventures than give ONE penny to Hasbro.

Cool

Great tip and love the session recap! I just rewatched the original Magnificent Seven with my kids last night. D&D definitely takes a lot of inspiration from the Western genre, but I've been thinking on a setting that's more explicitly Western with fantasy elements.

Sounds like a great success

I think the answer is "yes*", but the asterisk is just as important as the answer. As you said, there are many factors that will result in the de-throning of DnD. One of those is the rise in popularity of TTRPGS that *aren't* DnD. Games like D20 are grabbing up new TTRPG fans before they ever fall victim to modern WotC, and shifting tables who have played DnD for decades. Each DC20-quality TTRPG that forms a strong community detracts from the reign of DnD. Like every cut made in a death from a thousand cuts, every loss in brand loyalty is a cut that will end in DnD's death. That is why, IMO, there is a "next" DnD killer. Some of the games killing it already exist and have taken many DnD tables with them.

It was a blast

Hey man, I really appreciate your review and thoughts. Thanks! R.

Is a muscle car from the 1960s obsolete? For sure. Is is still cool to drive them, love them, refurbish them? Hell yeah! Same story I would say :)

The idea that adventuring or being a hero is only for the genetically gifted is nonsense. Most people would take up adventuring only out of desperation. They would be vagabonds, the disposed, the poor, and other outsiders. Second, adventuring is a dangerous profession and sooner or later your character is going to get injured or disfigured. It balances out experience and gives a natural point for a character to retire. He's too badly injured to go on. The idea that wounds do not have lasting effects, not even a scar, isn't realistic. Sure, you get a +1 to your proficiency for experience, but that's balanced by having a bad back that doesn't allow your character to run or lift heavy objects. Gold as XP. The in game economy gets broken because you can't have dragons without a dragon horde. Nobody knows why dragons need treasure or what they do with it. Characters quickly have a golf bag of magic weapons and a dump truck full of gold and all it gets them is a down payment on a retirement home (keep). The GM has to invent ways to separate characters from their treasure, and that creates unnecessary grievances. The desire for treasure warps the motivations for the game. How much is enough? Why is my cleric spending time going down holes and not preaching? Other games, where gold has a truer value, and XP isn't tied to gold, characters are more likely to be driven by factors like doing good for goodness sake, sense of community, religious fervor, etc. The abstract idea inherent in HP. If HP aren't wounds, what is my cleric healing? Is healing just a placebo? A better mechanic would be Luck as an attribute. You make a save because you're lucky. You don't step in that trap because you are lucky. You're not killed by that blow because you're lucky. It also creates an interesting dynamic in the game. The more you roll the dice, the closer you are to death because sooner or later your good luck becomes bad luck. It's why I like games with exploding dice for damage. Now wounds are actual wounds that have to be treated. Now you have to manage risk.

The rules from swords path glory

I'm absolutely amazed at the unjustified hype behind this very ordinary game. And the endless justifications of the hype AS hype, like that makes it a better game somehow. The point isn't that Kelsey is, for whatever reason, successful. The point is that people confuse that success with excellence. The two are not the same.

They wanted to be the next Pathfinder after the ogl was cancelled. They announced quickly, to try and seize momentum, which kind of worked, but then wotc went back on cancelling the ogl, and they were left without a plan. Other 5e clones (e.g. nimble, a5e) have fared better because they had a clear goal and while they built momentum more slowly, but haven't had the foundation of that momentum ripped from under them, and alternative systems that sprung up from the ogl scandal (e.g. daggerheart, DC20) have fared better because they took the time to establish a clear direction to take the game, allowing them to hold on to momentum after wotc changed their minds. But while kobold press' gamble didn't pay off, it appears not to have hurt them much. They had a pretty smooth transition back to the status quo.

Kelsey Dionne didn’t inherit or get anointed - she hustled, networked, and built her name and product for YEARS. Don’t care if others did or didn’t. I respect the hustle.

They can complain all they want (and will likely continue to do so). Hasn't affected the fun of my Shadowdark games any. Nor will it.

Deep Rock Goblactic

# Must stat out the doorknob cult

be nice to me; we worked hard on this. Thank you. We playtested this at seths for 1/2 a year.

Good thoughts I haven’t played shadowdark yet but hope to this fall at conventions Like someone else said learn from her if you don’t want to be left behind

Great video. Thank you. I definitely think that Shadowdark is sucking the air out of the room for OSR. I feel like OSR really is Shadowdark now. Are their any OSRs left that anyone cares about. I don't think so.

Good video Curt! I think you nailed it, the people bitching about Shadowdark overshadowing other creators need to take a hard look at what Kelsey is doing and learn why she has been so successful. She seems like a genuinely nice person that just wants to create good stuff. She also has not alienated half her possible fan base by inserting whatever her personal politics are into Shadowdark. Creators really, really need to learn this lesson. I have yet to play Shadowdark but will be at the end of September at Shirecon with DM Bluddworth. I am looking forward to it.

No, that's Stormlight rpg... A bigger shark can eat another

What's going to "kill" the IP momentum of D&d ? WotC (eternal growth) greed, arrogance and distance from the ground level vein of the hobby. They've already done enormous reputation damage to the brand through their antics and controversies. Akin to EA (though not on the same scale), its evermore popular to despise WotC & Hasbro. A player base shave, as they try and turn 5e into another edition, which always results in a certain % of player loss through edition preference. A piranha effect, where very similar games (Shadowdark, DC20, etc) trying to capture that same vibe & audience release with highpoint gimmicks (ex: 4pt economy) that take player chunks away from D&d. A Hasbro that tends to hold onto and vault (for DECADES) IPs that have undergone popularity crash, rather than selling those IPs and allowing them the opportunity for renewal through new party ownership. A coming roleplaying/D&d (probably a "nerd" things in general) popularity crash. Bonus : Continued civilizational destabilization throughout "the west", which will force people to spend less time and money on very optional activities & spending. Hard times tend to require you spend more time paying attention and exerting effort for the basics (ex: the number of Americans forced into "car living" is HUGE), and less time essentially goofing off. I think this will just be (in part) a reality check for a regional civilization that through its former success, decided to spend that societal momentum currency (via misallocated funds, energy and time) on becoming an enormously entertainment top-heavy society.

As Hasbro continues to lose faith with the community and new systems continue to streamline games for a different meta than DnD was created in, DnD will die. I don't think there will ever be another DnD, because ttrpg's will have a healthier ecosystem. More competition with different styles of play will be good for the community and I do think DC20 will be a spearhead in that movement. DC20 is specifically designed to poach 5e's market share and that is incredibly valuable to both the system and the community.

Less offensive, but PERPLEXINGLY BAD is a superhero game I picked up for the laughs "The Blood of Heroes"

Always glad to see a new vid Curt. Personally I'm a free speech advocate - if you are a disgusting human like the maker of Fatal, make it, and the rest of us will know to steer clear of your sick self; if you are THIS BAD at making games [the FATAL maker] just write your weird fiction/manifesto.

Good points all around

from a power-creep POV, i would say if you allow Planescape/Spelljammer/Dragonlance/Eberron backgrounds in 5e, it is basically the same. Also post-Tasha classes fit right in. There is just a very large power range in regular 5e, that WotC are also addresssing with their 2024 edition. It is basically a 2024 5e, before that came out.

loving playing DC20 even though its still in development and its still so much better done with DnD for good

There are a lot of conflicting stories regarding this but it does feel like something wotc would do This is what happens when you fire 90% of the staff who actually did the work

Yet these content creators keep supporting WOTC. They are slow learners, I guess.

there appears to be a lot of missing details and missing context

JorPHdan should live-stream the shredding of the 2024 PHB, He’ll earn far more than the book cost him and send a clear message to WizBro, “No more support for your trash behavior here”.

Well it’s WotC so I can believe that

Just wait until they send the Pinkertons in!

@ en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ely,_Nevada

hey that's me, thank you

Humans have another massive advantage that is often ignored - in that they prompt a neutral reaction adjustment from the majority of other races. If you're using Charisma liberally, and reaction adjustments regularly, you'll see just how punitive this can be for demi-humans. Contextual(!) racial hatred applies, and things can get tricky when you're trying not to get killed by an overwhelming force of Orcs, who are happy to deal with humans, but HATE elves... but you have an elf in the party and their presence is reducing your neutral response to a hostile one.

You sighed all the way through the video and you haven't even read the players handbook 🤦‍♀️

Coming soon. Seths back to school catalog

Thanks for pointing that out. I should have made it clear that this was an enclopida of all skill not necessarily a skill system

Humm ill have to add the never done this before rule

I used a lot of stock art

Hey i made this Thank you

I never got the complaints of the "undermonitized" comment...yes, please, WoTC sell me something! In 10 years there were only 3 player facing books.

So you‘re saying that during the 4th Edition Era, Pathfinder wasn‘t THE DnD Killer?

I recently had the TofV physical books arrive and they are making me tempted to get rid of my core WOTC 5e books based purely on the fact that TofV books are stitch bound, not glue bound. I'd much rather have the more durable book, but if you're already deep into 5e I for sure wouldn't recommend it and do feel as though I got wrapped up in the hype of it all

The main reason I haven't switched to that one is because I have a library of fantasy systems. I have way more than I'll probably ever play but Castles & Crusades and Wasted Lands by Elf Lair Games, was and are my alternatives. I just don't need any more fantasy systems. I'm exploring other genres at this point.

You basically said everything that I thought of when it came to seeing what ToV was going to be like. I have copius amounts of problems with 5E. Hit point bloat, PC's being made stronger with every new expansion, but monsters staying basically the same, and the expectation that I am supposed to write out an entire story with an over-arching narrative, and then read my players several page backstories and then fit all of that into the plot. Any derivative of 5E will, without a doubt, inherit these same exact problems, and thus I've sworn off the epic fantasy genre all together because none of them fix any of the issues I have with the genre. Daggerheart, MCDM RPG, DC20, Tales of The Valiant; I will not be buying any of these games. My efforts are much more appreciated by OSR style games, and I've been buying and playing those non-stop for months.