Відео

She's quiet robotic 😂

Too bad she didn't fully develop her chest voice

I listen to Mariah more, but anytime I've heard Whitney or Celine's music, I also got chills from their voice. Despite being a lamb, I think they all 3 have amazing voices.

You forgot Lara the goddess! The best belter in the world!

what song is it in 2:56?

It's Mariah, please

even though its late…… but my ranking is 1-the grace’s lina (A). Good 2-F(x)’s Luna. (high A-). P-G 3-S.E.S’s Bada. (A-). P-G 4-snsd’s teayeon. (B/B+) AA-P 5-red velvet’s wendy (B/B+) AA-P 6-aespa’s ning. (^C+) high A-AA

linaaa

My opinions: They are not equal, though they all excel in different things. Let's give range and versatility to Mariah, congratulations. Whistling. Congrats. Outside of singing and voice, let's give her song writing and producing as well. Congratulations. Let's give stamina and ability to hold power notes the longest, and having longevity for really valuing and taking care of her voice to Celine. Congratulations. Power to Whitney, sure. But that’s the least of it. Additionally, the ability to infuse a lyric with emotion, clarity of phrasing, her tone is pure, rich, velvety, supple, and tender (best a cappella), the best head voice, the best vibrato. Her voice had gravity, and the discipline to know when to hold back, that's ALL WHITNEY. In terms of style, Whitney was the most authentic, straight-forward, soulful, vibrant, robust and regal. Mariah had to flit, flirt, and fidget and whistle to hold your attention because she knew her voice didn't have enough weight to sing it direct. Compare Mariah’s best live performance: “Vision of Love” to Adele’s star making brit performance of “Someone Like You” and you’ll see what I’m talking about (there are things in Adele’s tonal quality and shading, again, gravity and emotive ability that Mariah can’t do, but Whitney can). Celine didn't have Whitney's phrasing either. Her choices are mawkish (look it up), schmaltzy, and inauthentic by comparison (Barbra's kinda like that too). Lot's people don't feel Celine like they feel Whitney. I sometimes wonder if Celine is really feeling what she's singing or is she just pretending to? (eg. It's all coming back to me now). And here's where Whitney show's her gospel roots: she knows to connect to the songs she sings. This is why she delivers the best live performances (MTV: Why does it hurt so bad, Didn’t we almost have it all 1987, etc). In terms of tone, Mariah can sound flirty, warm, feathery, heavenly and airy, like a goddess. Celine can sound crystalline, steely, and majestic like an ice-berg or some awe-inspiring landscape. But Whitney just sounds like the most beautiful woman with a heart and soul and will forever be the most magnificent leading lady with ravishing emotions (I Have Nothing). The flesh and blood queen. Both powerful and tender. The greatest diva who ever lived. And Outside of singing, imagine if Whitney had no voice. She still had enough beauty, talent, appeal, and charisma to be an A-list movie star, which she was. She was the biggest movie star in Hollywood when the Bodyguard came out. For her movie career, she was the highest paid Black actress in Hollywood. She made the biggest cultural impact during her heyday. The bodyguard movie and soundtrack captured the zeitgeist when it came out, hence it being the greatest selling album by a female, in the world, in all of music history. The nearest thing to the bodyguard in terms of impact is Adele's 21. Hence: once in a generation. I will always love you got the most views still....and on and on and on. They are not equal.

Mariah IMO 👑👑😍

7:55 that E6 was not tense at all

Im laughing when you mark it shouty i headvoice...hahah shouty? You mean when you shout you're using your headvoice? Shouty are only in chest voice

One of so hyang's weakness are her light and thin sounds...imagine a 45 years old but still sounds so thin...for me her headvoice is quite unmatched coz her voice sounds free and amazing....all singers has their own weaknesses...but still all of them are the best singers

My only problem with this is the title …. Celine Dion , Whitney Houston, and Mariah Carey ARE THE BALLAD Queens. I’d add Morissette Amon of Phillipines but for the purpose of this post Celine is not remotely underrated she is one of the greatest of all time.

Whitney Houston had it all.

I had no idea about her. Her voice is a gift like that of the great Whitney Mariah anita baker toni Braxton etc

Samaras voice is just out of this world hope she is the voice of our generation 💞

6:53 I honestly thought this high C was a good note because it sounds so pretty 😭

Madison is definitely a vocalist. I can say that wholeheartedly. She said herself that she takes inspiration from Ariana but she does have her own voice. I think naturally Madison can go pretty low which is something Ariana has struggled with but she can also go pretty high which is impressive. I love her voice so much ❤ They are both wonderful.

All different reasons and all different opinions. To me, for the best lows it will prob be Mariah because it's that tone and I think she stylistically pushes. For mid belts, I'll say Whitney and for high belts(mixed voice!) I would choose Mariah. Whitney's rich ease sounds so good and natural and beautiful at the same time!! And it's just Mariah's tone and ease up there like she just floats up there!! Although I think Mariah is the weakest belter out of the whole trinity😭. Whitney, to me has the best upper register/head voice it's so developed and the way she uses it will always surprise and stun me! For Mariah it's her whistles, and for Whitney it's her head voice. Like her clarity is unmatched! And that ease??? She had the best hv in pop music! I think Mariah had the best falsetto tho. We all know Mariah has the best agility, literally 90% of her musicality is runs and riffs! You could make a whole vid of just her agility and that would be like an hour or longer!! But Mariah's agility is so magical it's unreal and that innormal speed can't be matched!! Whitney had the biggest voice of the whole trinity so it would def be harder for her than Celine and Mariah, but Whitney was more of a riffer soul singer. So that wasn't like in her music style. But to be honest they are all amazing and untouched. I feel like Mariah is the best studio singer and Whitney the best live singer!

I'd recommend using some visual cues to indicate your opinion about the quality of vocal runs in the agility segment, something similar to what Ain't No Other Fan (YT channel) did in his "Bad vs Good vocal runs" series. That'd be helpful

Lisa is a Mezzo-Soprano based on her tessitura , just because she can hit high notes doesn’t automatically make her a soprano! Most female singers are not sopranos! A true soprano is very rare!

I'm sorry but I'm curious it is just me or not, but your voice is too small, I have turned up my PC volume to max but it's still small. others are normal

Я так долго здесь че никто не модет забрать

who do you think is a better vocalist, whitney (prime) or beyonce? and who do you think has the better headvoice

😂

Can we talk about how he has this gorgeous voice and his acting is- well- there are no words. He makes me cry. Jeremy Jordan is so so so insanely talented

She's so underrated!

5:59 I think she was sick that performance actually!

5:19 she also have many great G#5 in upon this rock😡

She is neither Whitney nor Mariah. She is So-hyang. We don’t care if she is technically perfect or how high her notes can go. We are simply comforted and moved by her songs. “That’s why we love her.”

Better than you still.

Nice video but Faouzia is a mezzo soprano, pther than that all pf the information is accurate. She's a coloratura mezzo soprano to be specific.

*Easily* the STRONGEST Vocal-crush I've had to date!! 💗💗💗

Let's be REAL here. The Things that Taeyeon really sells is her unique Timbre. Somebody was talented by Years of Training, Hard Work, Technically improved to the Perfection level..... but some just have a "thing".. that was god gifted naturally and it's not something that you can achive by practice even how hard you try... Eunji Talented Taeyeon Gifted

Three singers is no idol but for me honestly the best three singers is Celine Dion the best

Celine❤ Mariah😘 Whitney👍

1:13 to 1:50 what was the background music as you were talking it sounded heavenly.

I love this video🩷

he had good teachers. and a true gift of God.

hurts me ears. sounds more like noise to me

his techinque is good acting to convince us that he is a true Christian

At the end of the day these videos are subjective. While fun, there is no real science going on here. You’re deciding what is “resonant” or “supported” based simply off of what you hear, and unless you hold a doctorates in vocal performance, you’re not qualified to make that distinction. Even if you did have such accolades, basing something solely off what you hear is an educated guess at best. You’re not going into the singers throats and seeing the physical anatomy of what is happening so you cannot say “this note has no tension.” Let’s not forget “supported range” is a pseudo science made up by a 19 year old with an associates degree. You need to get off your high horse and stop claiming to be objective when in reality you’re just giving your opinion.

Not Mariah… she used to have the whistle so that was her only talent now she don’t.. pretending she is all that… Whitney 1st just cuz I knew her before I knew Celine.. then Celine 2nd

Maybe you may analyze katrina velarde (5 octaves vocal range)

Where is the Eb5 at 5:46 from? I know that it’s from Thinkin About you,but what show? It looks like she has bangs so it’s either from Tulsa or Omaha,right?

Samara Joy headvoice or Lisa Fischer headvoice?

Leave it to professional musicians to make a correct judgement about our favourite artist.

I disagree with the belting part, up until F5 she actually belts (with M1), after she uses a usually very heavy mixed voice (M2)

Whitney>Mariah>Celine