Відео

J'avais regarder l'ancienne animation j'sais pas c'est que mon avis mais la nouvelle animation a quelques chose en moins j'sais pas quoi c'est beau et tout..

Any content made for Netflix is bad. Missing character details, and pastel colors to be background objects. You are better off with the manga. Anime should be made in Japan, by Japan, and for Japan, not for the machine like Netflix.

My understanding is that when the show started the people making it or or informed that the next series would be a soft reboot. Sun and moon, at least initially, removed everything after the Brock and Misty years from Cannon. They fairly quickly realized that was a mistake and re-introduced it, but that’s part of the reason that Ash is drawn younger and stupider. But anyway, since the people making XY knew that the soft boot was coming, they knew the show kinda didn’t matter, and as a result, they had a lot of freedom to do different things that they wouldn’t have had if the soft boot wasn’t coming. So even though Ash is officially 10, he’s drawn more like a 14 or 15 year-old, and he acts a lot more mature. Putting him in a Brock roll for a bunch of new trainers was something they had wanted to do forever, and I mean team rocket actually get to be heroes in the final batch of episodes. And Bonnie is a little kid who acts like a little kid. It’s the high watermark of the entire franchise and I just kind of stop watching after ended because I knew that it wasn’t gonna get any better

I felt this immediately and went back to old one. It feels like a cash grab not a passion project.

Honestly, to me in this show ash has got to be like 15, not ten, it just makes more sense to me

The remake is a more faithful adaptation of the manga with really good fight scenes but the original is a better adaptation for a tv show and flows better. Im torn on both but I think the new adaptation does a better job of showing akane and ranmas relationship. The original feels a lot funnier though.

The only improvement in the reboot is that they could actually afford the time and effort to give Lum her Iridescent rainbow hair. The Blue-Green hair she had in the first Anime was purely because they didn't have the budget and time to animate color changing rainbow hair.

Average MIDte fan iq is 67

I prefer sun and moon

yup I gave up after getting about 3/4 through Uncharted II. It just seemed devoid of really engaging combat and the constant cinematic approach and climbing just wasn't appealing. It didn't help that I'd already enjoyed the heck out of Gears of War at that point and the combat in that was leagues ahead. It's great I guess if you like a heavily cinematic style of presentation

I think Both are great, but i'll stick to the Classic, even tho the remake is faithful to the Manga, the Classic gives more dept in the story of the characters and gives more memorable moments where the characters can flesh out their relationship, but comedy is key, perhaps i'm nolstalgic to the old Anime, but i grew up with a very iconic Anime, and if it wasn't by it's popularity back in the 90's This Anime wouldn't even have a Remake to begin with, Maybe i'm wrong with remaking it from the Manga, but there's no denying the Anime was so successful back in those days.

Thank you for these analyses. This new anime adaptation made me perceive how capable the old studio was when making their own adaptation. In my opinion, their take was also superior to the original manga much more often than not...despite some awful filler arcs, and me personally not enjoying the overuse of comedy during some serious scenes (mostly also coming from the original manga, to be fair). Even the best Rurouni Kenshin adaptation out there (first four OVAs) has quite a different tone compared to the original manga, which makes me think I don't actually like the original author's execution, though his ideas and outlines are great. On top of that, we get this new anime remake that is a stale and washed out, copy-paste take with minimal translation between the medias. The Tsuioku-hen OVAs also shows a much better way to NOT have the comedy interfering while still maintaining the story mature, impactful and artistically sound.

Thank you for these analyses. This new anime adaptation made me perceive how capable the old studio was when making their own adaptation. In my opinion, their take was also superior to the original manga much more often than not...despite some awful filler arcs, and me personally not enjoying the overuse of comedy during some serious scenes (mostly also coming from the original manga, to be fair). Even the best Rurouni Kenshin adaptation out there (first four OVAs) has quite a different tone compared to the original manga, which makes me think I don't actually like the original author's execution, though his ideas and outlines are great. On top of that, we get this new anime remake that is a stale and washed out, copy-paste take with minimal translation between the medias. The Tsuioku-hen OVAs also shows a much better way to NOT have the comedy interfering while still maintaining the story mature, impactful and artistically sound.

> didnt understand the rock scene and blames the show for not well conveying it for le monkey brain audience > understood the plot of concrete revolutio perfectly That's like figuring out quantum physics but struggling to grasp the concept of addition like what

One thing I hated about this show is that Claude was objectively *in the right* He was RIGHT and JUSTIFIED to destroy that submarine, he was RIGHT, less justified this time, but still understandable that he chose to get revenge on the nurses and the doctors that part took in the inhumane experiments, over all, he was the only character that didn't look at justice as a binary matter, it's not a one or a zero, he was right to retort to violence for these inhumane things done to him and children Yet the show still treated him as a villain that deserved to be taken down, which was so weird I think they were trying to go for an anti hero archetype, the guy that has good intentions but does bad things for the greater good; they failed miserably if that's what they were going for, they made a sympathetic villain that was right in all ways but still the show had to rug pull us at the last second and make him crazy because they accidentally made him into a better main character than Jiro

thank you for making this video exist

it may be just because the new one has a faster pace, so it wasn't able to flesh out the characters as much as the old one. the new one may not necessarily be better, but it is definitely not bad either, especially compared to other anime remakes.

I do prefer the original anime over the new one, but I do appreciate the new one being made as it's helped introduce more people to the series. The sad fact is that it's easier to get people to watch a modern remake that came out recently, than a 20+ year old classic, regardless of how well it holds up.

Thank you. Won't waste my time watching

Great analysis, I would just point out one thing: the new adaptation is actually much closer to the manga, when it comes to the rhythm and the general sequence of events: this doesn't mean that it's always better and, as you perfectly explained, the direction is very important even when you follow the original material scene by scene. I don't even appreciate all the additions made in the original (like Ranma and Akane eating burgers) since I find some of them to be not so useful after all, but it's clear that the feelings were generally better conveyed and the different scenes masterfully connected. At this point, I don't know if the new one is following almost exactly on the steps of the original in order to be faithful or for lack of time to better adapt the product for the screen. Just to be fair, though, there are some cases where I believe MAPPA did a good job in this adaptation process: for example I found quite nice the scene of Ranma searching for Akane during her confrontation with Shampoo. That's different from the manga and the original but it's probably the one where we have the most dramatic rendition of Ranma's feelings. Anyways, I did notice some of these flaws before but I'm glad and thankful someone could explain it much more in detail, since I didn't have all the means to even realize what was exactly missing!

Original = SOUL Remake = Soulless

I remember when XYZ ended (Xy was when I first saw pokemon) I saw Sun&Moon in TV and I remember crying that day (I was a child) because I would never hear "The future is now thanks to Clemont's science" to this day Gen 6 will have special place in my heart even thou I didn't watch all season at this point and I know some are very good from what people say XYZ is and will be my favorite

For anyone looking to watch pokemon xy and z , Its now on BBC IPlayer

The biggest issue i have with Brotherhood that sticks out in my memory is the Chimeras that join up near the end who are made to draw some kind of parallel to ed and al getting their original bodies back, but like, the two of them can literally transform back into human forms at will.

As someone who watched and the original and read the manga 15-20 years ago as a kid, I really enjoy the new remake. Maybe it’s because I’m already familiar with the characters and their personalities, relationships and motivations- but I appreciate the faster pace. In the end Ranma and Akane are two good hearted people with a very cynical shell, and most other characters are either tools or hurdles that accentuate their true feelings for each other. To that end I feel that the new show handles its pacing much better than the latter parts of the old show. I also felt that Ranma and Akane have a better chemistry early on in the new show than the older one - where they are basically 90% of the time abusive towards each other.

Significantly reduce ecchi stuffs

All my peeps hate Brotherhood. Couldn't get into it because of those first episodes.

I am happy to see people FINALLY admitting to this shortcoming of "Brotherhood." They breeze past the First Act, the part of the story intended to get people invested. I have never watched past these first batch of episode of "Brotherhood" to this day, because I cannot make myself care enough to. I can easily sit through the whole of the original 2003 anime, though.

The new adaptation certainly tried to match the old one as much as possible, but there will be some discrepancies, they're not shooting for an exact 1:1 replica. I just hate that they opted to give girl ranma a pinkish eyeshadow instead of purple from the original. The purple really made her eyes stand out, and given that the new hair color is also a pinkish hue, there's not enough contrast between the 2 and it takes attention away from the eyes.

So far the original is better, but it's still very early. Hopefully the new show animates the great stories from the manga that never made it to the original series, and cuts the filler.

Ranma 1/2 Boys And Girls 1989 2024

There’s one big difference the two shows has

i did watch both 1989 and 2024 to see which version i like . And i do prefer the 1989 anime . So now i'm going to read the manga

After I saw the headline that Ranma 1/2 is getting a remake on Netflix, I clicked and watched all of it. Show is hilarious 😂

I like both of them. It's cool getting new ranma content even if it doesn't feel like the old anime. Honestly I'd rather have the new one feel like a different adaptation instead of just retreading the old show.

The remake for the whole Cho episode sucked ass. Directing in the OG is still king.

I can't even tell if OG UY has filler. They're really good episodes maybe a few I didn't love but they're not bad I just didn't enjoy them

I hope it's just a matter of cramming material that has already been covered, and they'll get better soon when story goes beyond what we've already seen. The HxH reboot got much better art and music by the time the Chimera arc is progressing. Meanwhile, the new art style and music in Kenshin are not (yet) that interesting. As a biased fan of the original, what puts me off the most is Kenshin's voice and Megumi's more generic design.

Lum isn't entirely innocent in the original anime but I think the animation team had a soft spot for her so some aspects of her character were softened just a little. She's still pretty posessive of Ataru, she's got a bit of a history of not being the best friend or self absorbed sometimes. But the OG anime is far kinder to her character. Which is fair because for Takahashi - Lum was originally this one shot character and the series was gonna have other wacky things happen to Ataru as part of the series with Shinobu as the long suffering girlfirend. After one chapter without her - the Okatu fans sent so many requests for her to come back that Ateru's friends were originally written in as those Otaku that just really wanted Lum back - which happened for the following chapters after. The original takes a bit more from the original manga and they stay more "straight" with the Manga so you get more of Lum being not only posessive, but also being almost deliberately malicious against Shinobu or Ataru. Where the OG anime generally tries to have Ateru or someone else do something on purpose or via misunderstanding to earn her ire.

The new series has a lack of comedic timing which the original excelled at. They cram way too much into these new episodes and the show suffers because of it. The teacher your referencing in the new series, is the teacher later in the original series though. He is featured in some classic episodes as well as Beautiful Dreamer.

I am really confused on how anyone who loves the 90s version could say anything positive about the reboot. The colours are awful, the animation a complete disaster, the drawing, the new OST is so dull whilst the old one was so iconic. For me it’s a complete fail and all the fun aspect of the old one is totally failed and missed !! 🥹

Speaking as a creator. Poor Takahashi, it's a shame how western society is butchering her hard work :(

XYZ is available on Netflix in Hong Kong!!

they should have just remade the original in 4k. that would have been all

I can't stress enough that greninja could've thrown the shuriken at the ground and have won.

Thanks. I've been wondering what people think of the new version, and it's been so long since I've seen the old one this really helped. One thing you didn't mention is the music. I prefer the music from the old version. I though maybe I was just being nostalgic, but now I'm sure. It was better before.

The whole feel of OG FMA was better from the concept of the Homunculi to the war dramaesque sound track. The ending was really the only thing that drug it down for me.

There was no need to remake Ranma 1/2 -- what Netflix should have done was buy the right to the original anime and then continued the story -- like Ranma and Akane in college or something like that... or actually married.

The original Ranma 1/2 has a better opening. I like the first one the best and for the dub version the same voice actor who voices light Yagami also voices Moose. It’s quite funny. 😂