- 570
- 2 067 760
Basira Education
Canada
Приєднався 29 сер 2019
Go to whyislamistrue.com/help to help us protect Muslims from atheism by gently guiding them to their own realizations that Islam is true and invite Non-muslims to Islam by showing them why Islam is True. Support our work here: whyislamistrue.com/help
Transfinite Numbers, 1-to-1 Correspondence, Infinite Time are Full of Contradictions - Episode 10
We are launching a kalam program in January. You can learn more and save your spot here: whyislamistrue.com/kalam
Learn more about the Why Islam is True Course here: whyislamistrue.com/course
Learn more about Basira's Curriculum in Modern Context here:
www.basiraeducation.org/bccmc
Watch the God's Cosmos Episode "Atheist Science Defeats Christianity" here:
ua-cam.com/video/QtetPPwP2s4/v-deo.html
Watch the God's Cosmos Episode "Kalam Cosmological Argument Quranic Link" here:
ua-cam.com/video/detcZKfEc7U/v-deo.html
In the video, Shaykh Hamza critically examines the modern debate surrounding the Kalam Cosmological Argument (KCA), emphasizing its validity in proving that the universe began to exist. He highlights misconceptions from mathematicians and philosophers, including William Lane Craig, and argues that they make logical errors or false analogies. Shaykh Hamza asserts that classical Islamic scholars like Imam Al-Ghazali presented a more robust understanding of the argument.
The KCA relies on the impossibility of an actual infinity in time, as it leads to contradictions. Modern mathematical concepts of infinity, such as "potential infinity" (a process of continual increase) and "transfinite numbers" (used in set theory), are often misunderstood or misapplied in this context. Shaykh Hamza explains that these mathematical infinities, symbolized by concepts like the "lazy eight" (∞) or "Aleph-naught (ℵ₀)," do not pertain to quantities of time, as time involves finite measurements rather than abstract mathematical operations.
He argues that applying mathematical infinities to time is a category mistake, akin to using unrelated concepts together. For instance, while infinite sets in mathematics can be placed into a never-ending one-to-one correspondence with subsets, this process cannot coherently describe time. Time, by nature, is measurable and finite in any given span, even when considered as an ongoing sequence.
Shaykh Hamza concludes that attempts to use mathematical infinities to argue against the KCA involve the logical fallacy of Begging the Question. As they assume an infinite past rather than proving it. He reaffirms the classical Islamic position that an infinite quantity of past time is impossible, supporting the KCA’s proof that the universe must have a beginning.
Learn more about the Why Islam is True Course here: whyislamistrue.com/course
Learn more about Basira's Curriculum in Modern Context here:
www.basiraeducation.org/bccmc
Watch the God's Cosmos Episode "Atheist Science Defeats Christianity" here:
ua-cam.com/video/QtetPPwP2s4/v-deo.html
Watch the God's Cosmos Episode "Kalam Cosmological Argument Quranic Link" here:
ua-cam.com/video/detcZKfEc7U/v-deo.html
In the video, Shaykh Hamza critically examines the modern debate surrounding the Kalam Cosmological Argument (KCA), emphasizing its validity in proving that the universe began to exist. He highlights misconceptions from mathematicians and philosophers, including William Lane Craig, and argues that they make logical errors or false analogies. Shaykh Hamza asserts that classical Islamic scholars like Imam Al-Ghazali presented a more robust understanding of the argument.
The KCA relies on the impossibility of an actual infinity in time, as it leads to contradictions. Modern mathematical concepts of infinity, such as "potential infinity" (a process of continual increase) and "transfinite numbers" (used in set theory), are often misunderstood or misapplied in this context. Shaykh Hamza explains that these mathematical infinities, symbolized by concepts like the "lazy eight" (∞) or "Aleph-naught (ℵ₀)," do not pertain to quantities of time, as time involves finite measurements rather than abstract mathematical operations.
He argues that applying mathematical infinities to time is a category mistake, akin to using unrelated concepts together. For instance, while infinite sets in mathematics can be placed into a never-ending one-to-one correspondence with subsets, this process cannot coherently describe time. Time, by nature, is measurable and finite in any given span, even when considered as an ongoing sequence.
Shaykh Hamza concludes that attempts to use mathematical infinities to argue against the KCA involve the logical fallacy of Begging the Question. As they assume an infinite past rather than proving it. He reaffirms the classical Islamic position that an infinite quantity of past time is impossible, supporting the KCA’s proof that the universe must have a beginning.
Переглядів: 5 120
Відео
New Year Lesson From Syria and the Hama Massacre
Переглядів 2,8 тис.Місяць тому
Watch the Quranic Argument that will Silence any atheist here: quraniccaseforgod.com/ Learn more about the Why Islam is True Course here: whyislamistrue.com/course Shaykh Hamza expresses his thoughts and feelings at the start of the new year, reflecting on the liberation of Syria and its significance for Muslims worldwide. Syria holds profound importance in Islamic tradition, being central to e...
Hilbert’s Hotel and William Lane Craig Exposed by Muslim Scholars | God's Cosmos Episode 9
Переглядів 8 тис.Місяць тому
We are launching a kalam program in January. You can learn more and save your spot here: whyislamistrue.com/kalam Learn more about the Why Islam is True Course here: whyislamistrue.com/course Learn more about Basira's Curriculum in Modern Context here: www.basiraeducation.org/bccmc Watch the God's Cosmos Episode "Atheist Science Defeats Christianity" here: ua-cam.com/video/QtetPPwP2s4/v-deo.htm...
All God's Prophets Made the Kalam Cosmological Argument | God's Cosmos Episode 8
Переглядів 4,8 тис.2 місяці тому
We are launching a kalam program in January. You can learn more and save your spot here: whyislamistrue.com/kalam Learn more about the Why Islam is True Course here: whyislamistrue.com/course Learn more about Basira's Curriculum in Modern Context here: www.basiraeducation.org/bccmc Discover the profound simplicity of the Kalam Cosmological Argument-a timeless proof that the universe began to ex...
The Prophet’s First Concern When Threatened With Death | Discover the Prophet Muhammad ﷺ - Ep. 48
Переглядів 1,2 тис.2 місяці тому
Go to discovertheprophet.com/? to find out how you can help others discover the Prophet Muhammad. A donation as little as $1 OR if that's not possible you can even help with a click of the mouse, or even both! Whatever you can do, May Allah Reward You. Find out how you can help at discovertheprophet.com/? Shaykh Hamza recounts a powerful story from the life of the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upo...
Is the Big Bang Really in the Quran or is it a Hoax? -- The Definitive Answer | God's Cosmos Ep. 7
Переглядів 5 тис.2 місяці тому
Watch these previous episodes referenced in this video: Scientific Miracle of the Quran or Cherry Picking? ua-cam.com/video/7IsH5ZwEdGQ/v-deo.html Quranic Scientific Miracle is Not What You Think ua-cam.com/video/wDLrrG7MmDI/v-deo.html For more information about the Why Islam is True Course: whyislamistrue.com/course Learn more about Basira's Classical Curriculum in Modern Context here: www.bas...
The Tragedy of Spiritual Abuse can give you More Hope than you ever Imagined Possible | Ep. 47
Переглядів 1,9 тис.2 місяці тому
Go to discovertheprophet.com/? to find out how you can help others discover the Prophet Muhammad. A donation as little as $1 OR if that's not possible you can even help with a click of the mouse, or even both! Whatever you can do, May Allah Reward You. Find out how you can help at discovertheprophet.com/? In this talk, Shaykh Hamza addresses the impact of spiritual abuse, a form of harm that le...
Spiritual Abuse, Knowing Who to Trust, and Musaylima the Liar
Переглядів 2,4 тис.2 місяці тому
Muwatta of Imam Malik - Hadith 469 Mālik narrated from Ayyūb b. Abī Tamīmah al-Sakhtiyānī from Muḥammad b. Sīrīn that ʿUmar b. al-Khaṭṭāb was with a group of people who were reciting the Qurān when he went to relieve himself and then he returned while reciting the Qurān. A man objected, “O Amīr al-Mu’minīn: are you reciting the Qurān without having wuḍū?” ʿUmar replied, “Who gave you this fatwa...
Scientific Miracle of the Quran or Cherry Picking? | God's Cosmos Episode 6
Переглядів 5 тис.3 місяці тому
To learn more about Why Islam is True Course go here: whyislamistrue.com/course To learn more about Basira's Classical Curriculum in Modern Context Click Here: www.basiraeducation.org/bccmc The video features Shaykh Hamza discussing how the Quran's description of the universe aligns with modern scientific discoveries, particularly the concept of the expanding universe, which corresponds with th...
Prophet Muhammad ﷺ and the Pedophilia Myth - Shocking Lies Exposed | Defend the Prophet ﷺ - Ep. 4
Переглядів 10 тис.3 місяці тому
To support this initiative go to discovertheprophet.com/? 0:00 - Introduction - The Error of David Wood 2:57 - The Character Profile of a Pedophile 19:50 - The Character Profile of the Prophet Muhammad 33:32 - The Prophet Loved his Grandson 1:03:50 - The Other Hadith David Wood Mentioned narrated by Mu’awiya 1:21:54 - Hasan did not have the Character of the Victim of a Pedophile 1:31:24 - How c...
Quranic Scientific Miracle is Not What You Think | God's Cosmos Episode 5
Переглядів 7 тис.3 місяці тому
To learn more about Why Islam is True Course go here: whyislamistrue.com/course To learn more about Basira's Classical Curriculum in Modern Context Click Here: www.basiraeducation.org/bccmc In this talk, Shaykh Hamza explains how the Quran’s descriptions of the universe align with modern scientific discoveries, suggesting a profound understanding beyond ancient knowledge. The Quran, unlike a sc...
The Unexpected Response to Babies Urinating on the Prophet | Discover the Prophet ﷺ - Ep. 46
Переглядів 2,7 тис.3 місяці тому
Go to discovertheprophet.com/? to find out how you can help others discover the Prophet Muhammad. A donation as little as $1 OR if that's not possible you can even help with a click of the mouse, or even both! Whatever you can do, May Allah Reward You. Find out how you can help at discovertheprophet.com/? This video highlights the humility, mercy, and kindness of Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon...
Bible Contradicts Science - Quran Fits Perfectly | God's Cosmos Episode 4
Переглядів 12 тис.4 місяці тому
To learn more about Why Islam is True Course go here: whyislamistrue.com/course To learn more about Basira's Classical Curriculum in Modern Context Click Here: www.basiraeducation.org/curriculum In this video, Shaykh Hamza addresses the claim that the Quran's statement of Allah creating the Earth in six days is incorrect. He explains the important difference between the Quran and the Bible's cr...
Coming to A College Campus Near You #islam
Переглядів 3304 місяці тому
Why Islam is True On Campus Support this initiative here: whyislamistruefoundation.org/spreading-conviction-on-campus/ The goal of this one-year project is to conduct in-person critical-thinking seminars in collaboration with MSA’s on 40 college campuses, disseminating the Why Islam is True course for free to thousands of Muslims students on-campus, to create an online critical-thinking communi...
Big Bang contradicts Christianity | God's Cosmos Episode 3
Переглядів 8 тис.4 місяці тому
Big Bang contradicts Christianity | God's Cosmos Episode 3
Recognizing Corrupt Religious Authorities | Discover the Prophet Episode 45
Переглядів 2,5 тис.4 місяці тому
Recognizing Corrupt Religious Authorities | Discover the Prophet Episode 45
The Big Bang Problem for Atheists - What Hawking and Neil De Grasse Got Wrong | God’s Cosmos Ep 2
Переглядів 25 тис.4 місяці тому
The Big Bang Problem for Atheists - What Hawking and Neil De Grasse Got Wrong | God’s Cosmos Ep 2
A Lesson for Jordan Peterson from the Prophet Muhammad ﷺ , and a Reminder to All. | Episode 44
Переглядів 8 тис.4 місяці тому
A Lesson for Jordan Peterson from the Prophet Muhammad ﷺ , and a Reminder to All. | Episode 44
How Christianity Gave Birth to Atheism and Took God Out of Science | God's Cosmos Episode 1
Переглядів 10 тис.5 місяців тому
How Christianity Gave Birth to Atheism and Took God Out of Science | God's Cosmos Episode 1
A Glimpse into the Prophet's Marriage with Aisha | Discover the Prophet Muhammad ﷺ Episode 43
Переглядів 1,8 тис.5 місяців тому
A Glimpse into the Prophet's Marriage with Aisha | Discover the Prophet Muhammad ﷺ Episode 43
Will the Jewish Messiah be a Liar? Rabbis Betray the Jews to Take Over Israel.
Переглядів 95 тис.5 місяців тому
Will the Jewish Messiah be a Liar? Rabbis Betray the Jews to Take Over Israel.
13 Billion Light-Years Away: Proof of God’s Existence Revealed - God's Cosmos Trailer
Переглядів 3,4 тис.5 місяців тому
13 Billion Light-Years Away: Proof of God’s Existence Revealed - God's Cosmos Trailer
Atheist Shakes the Iman of a New Convert Muslim Until This Happened
Переглядів 5 тис.6 місяців тому
Atheist Shakes the Iman of a New Convert Muslim Until This Happened
Tafseer of Sura Fatiha (Brief Version)
Переглядів 2,3 тис.7 місяців тому
Tafseer of Sura Fatiha (Brief Version)
A Vegetarian Eid - A Call to the Ummah
Переглядів 4,6 тис.7 місяців тому
A Vegetarian Eid - A Call to the Ummah
How to Be Sincere With Other People: Lesson from the ansar of madina (Taksim Mosque Cultural Center)
Переглядів 8227 місяців тому
How to Be Sincere With Other People: Lesson from the ansar of madina (Taksim Mosque Cultural Center)
Red Heifer, Jewish Priest and the Sura Maryam Connection.
Переглядів 65 тис.8 місяців тому
Red Heifer, Jewish Priest and the Sura Maryam Connection.
How Islam solves the contradiction of Jesus being the Messiah even though he was crucified
Переглядів 7 тис.8 місяців тому
How Islam solves the contradiction of Jesus being the Messiah even though he was crucified
Red Heifers and the Sura Baqara Connection - Fact or Fiction?
Переглядів 103 тис.9 місяців тому
Red Heifers and the Sura Baqara Connection - Fact or Fiction?
amazing mashallah
Your problem is that archeology and history show that Mecca was, at best, a minor village when Muhammad allegedly lived. The fact that the Saudi government had to build multiple desalination plants because the Zamzam well is incapable of supplying the meager population of Mecca. The fact that there are now over 25 variations of the Quran with theologically different passages and that they were pasted together centuries after Muhammad had allegedly lived. All point to Islam not being capable of standing up to reason. Yes, the Jewish people have misinterpreted things, Islam has multiple factions too. Yes, Premillennial Dispensationalism is crazy. None of this makes Islam true. Sound Reformed Christianity, thanks to texts written within 20 to 50 years after the death of Jesus, and partial texts, copies of the original text, we now have written no later than 200AD, which confirm the accuracy of today's texts, supposedly attested to in the Quran which claims that Christian Scripture is true, and that Allah, its author claims that He will preserve His word, makes Islam necessarily wrong.
How does secularism not condemn Islam, the most barbaric of the religious who claim Abraham as their father. As for the Bedouins, if they want to murder people, then they will be burdered. The Book says “Then said Jesus unto him, Put up again thy sword into his place: for all they that take the sword shall perish with the sword.” (Matthew 26:52, AV) The Bedouins, as long as they are peacefully trying to take the land from the Palestinians, do have every right to be left alone.
The Palestinians have been the Jews for thousands of years. Bedouins taking the name Palestinian doesn't make them Palestinians anymore than a man calling calling himself a woman makes him a woman!
I’m still confused… are you Holden of Israel or children of Ismael? If Judaism is dumb, let me talk to you about Islam!
Why is it a crisis ? It's called critical thinking and FREEDOM ...
Do you guys even know what your stupid Mohammed did can you prove anything that happened to him NO cult for men
Your problem is that we have Scripture from decades after the death of Christ, and O.T. from 500 BC. Your quite corrupt Quran says that Allah preserves his word, uncorruptible, AND that both the OT and NT are his word. So, we have copies that predate your alleged Mohammed, Mohammed supposedly said that the OT & NT were true. We have myriads of texts from before 631 is it? They confirm our texts of today. You have nothing before what, 800+ AD? You have 30 different Qurans, with so far over 90K differences. Oops!
More people leave this cult the better for humanity and freedom
Saffiya was a Jew and was forced to be a Muslim because the blood thirsty illiterate tribal warlord named Muhammad and his terror followers plundered the community of Saffiya which lead to the death of the husband, then Muhammad took Saffiya as his trophy wife. Religion of peace alright, more like a death cult satanic religion. Anyone defending this death cult religion Islam is of the devils, and the sons and daughters of Lucifer.
Here are facts. Before internet Muslims could not read the Quran since very few Muslims speak Arabic so now when all can read it the young minds understand that it is full of contradictions and made up by a man that had no moral values. It is natural that they leave it...
7:25 Where did the first DNA come from? It came from RNA.
Humans evolved to create god as someone who is always watching and as a punisher of freeloaders.
Its truly commendable because this humility is coming from a king of that time. At a time when kings were known (and still are) for their arrogance and pride.
Alhamdulilah
Islam is cooked. Yall can’t even be honest about your apostasy in mass so how can you correct it. You can’t tell people to learn the Quran and Hadith because they will leave Islam from learning it. The only thing you can do is train them to lie as quickly as possible. The lies will just be debunked over time which leads to more apostasy
Israelites and Jewish people are not the same people, there's 12 tribes of Israel,and various races who follow talmudism, there's European Jews, edomite Jews, Chinese Jews, Indian Jews, African Jews etc, being of the Jewish religion don't make a person from the tribe of judah
Assalamu Alaykum Shaikh, is your basira education support email working? I made some inquiries about your Kalam 3.0 institute a while ago and have not gotten a response.
Salam what is the source of saying that thousand year mean a great amount of time and not a year?
انا عندي اسئلة او سميها شبهات ممكن اتواصل معك
Not happy from this video. 18 min. I was looking forward to explicitly tackling the argument about the designer.
What do Muslims think of the Samaritan Israelits and Karaite Jews
KARAITES ARE JEWS WHO STILL PRAY THE WAY THE PROPHETS PRAYED.
Well said.
You don't have two, as you explained the first...
I appreciate this video. I think, though, philosophically speaking, there isn't opposition between freedom, on the one hand, and necessity, on the other. Causality implies there is, but causality is a concept, not a fact. It is a way of thinking and talking about facts. But it isn't the only way. For me, I think about the relationship between freedom and necessity this way: That which is necessary is free. To give an example (or analogy), if I am holding a bucket with a plug in it that is filled with water and I unplug the bucket, the water will freely flow out. Nothing "caused" the water to come out. But it did do so necessarily, as an expression of the relationship between the water in the bucket, the ground and the hole in the bucket. This freedom is not volitional, but autonomous. It is uncaused, yet conditioned. Conditionality is not causality, and it is a concept we can use to understand events in the universe. With this way of understanding, we do not need to presuppose that if God is not a cause, then God is a volitional agent. Those aren't our only options. For me, God is autonomous, not volitional. The universe is necessitated by God, but this necessity occurs freely, as an expression of God's will.
Masha’Allah what a brilliant response. May Allah SWT reward you abundantly for defending the fair name of our beloved Prophet Sallalaho Alaihi wa’sallam
جزاك الله خيراً كثيراً May Allah SWT reward you abundantly for all your efforts. Masha’Allah an excellent response!
SubhanAllah very beautiful
Love for the kufaar (rhetoric)? Allah swt even cursed them then who are you to be(come) sir? The only logic is left for the REAL ABD who can relate, God does not exist existence Gods. The kufaar are the kufaar, period, Allah has willed it, whoever engages will pay the price of blindness or having (own) knowledge instead of getting it from Allah.
❤
No such thing as an infinite set in the real world. Your brain would have to keep growing in size to actually contain it. As such infinity is an ill defined abstract tool useful for mathematics but not in physical reality
Yes Mohamed is violent, a warmonger is violent, Mohamed and Obama are in the same bracket. Imagine saying if you kill one person, you've kill the whole humanity, and this same person personally kill somebody and ordered the killing of hundreds. Also you've lied on your defense, Saying there was no fighting, is a blank lie. You're sugar coating everything, how about the killing of the jews, or the killing of the husband of the woman that poisoned him . Also the population back then is low . Sir you lie alot . Imagine saying nobody even died .
Masha’Allah a very moving story. I know this story but the way you have related it is is very effective
Sincere jews and Christians should watch these
ٱلسَّلَامُ عَلَيْكُمْ I have some question regarding the contingency argument from Quran. How can i contact?
Every sincere jew and christian should watch these
He married a child, and had sex with a child. Clearly muhammad was a pedo. Truly hilarious the mental gymnastics muhammadans undertake though.
Assalamulaylum, I think you would be interested to see the views of Norman Wildberger (Insights into Mathematics UA-cam channel). I think it pairs well with the kalami/philosophical critique of actual infinity, and critiques actual infinity from a mathematical perspective. He is a big critic of contemporary set-theoretic orthodoxy. Not saying that his arguments are perfect or should be accepted uncritically, but I think they act as a good reference. May Allah bless and accept all the work that you are doing.
wa alaykum as salam wa rahmatullah. Thanks for the comment. Yes, I'm familiar with his work, and it's a good illustration of the kind of work that needs to be done in the foundations of mathematics if we stop using Dedekind cuts (which is why we need mathematical infinities) to define rational numbers.
Muhamad was evil, Jesus is and was always good. The choice is easy
peace starts when you have no obligations to a unvisible man !!!!!
You do not have evidence of a god existing, all of science is done without using gods. I can not believe in god or believe in god and still know what the first law of thermodynamics is, even if you dont. There is nothing on physics that prevents an infinite regress in time. No real scientist believes in god, its intellectual laziness. your god cannot do anything if its outside of time, there has to be time passing to do something you are babbling nonsense. Energy predated the big bang you are wrong you dont know what you are talking about.
Still, you now don't allow anyone to the AlAqsa Dome inside and that stinks to me
Not very helpful, just a lot of repeating the same thing over and over making a huge run time, with pretty poor arguments for the first section at least. Just because one is really good in other areas it doesn’t justify their actions with a little kid being well you know…
he was a kid diddler simple as that.
What is a Kalam argument?
It's an argument that was used by the classical Muslim theologians like Ghazali and Taftazani.
May your work be blessed, and it is a blessed work (filled with barakah) !
Excellent!
But we aren't even allowed to enter SlAqsa , except you. Not right!
They definitely don’t. If you treat time as a linear mathematical variable you can calculate the improper integral going from -inf to a point in time t. If infinite time was possible, the sum would equal t. As the integral is summing every infinitesimally small quantity of the tracing back to infinite back in the past. You get +inf Which goes perfectly in sync with infinite regress criticism. You can’t get to a finite point in time using infinite time. You get +inf, which is what you expect
I didn't quite understand your argument. Time is normally the independent variable against which integration and differentiation take place, but if I understand you correctly, you are treating it as a dependent variable, and if that's the case, then what is the independent variable?