![The Coffee House Experience](/img/default-banner.jpg)
- 57
- 113 782
The Coffee House Experience
India
Приєднався 31 жов 2020
Following the rich Bengali tradition of informal discussions (a.k.a Adda) we present this quasi-bilingual (mainly in Bengali, sometimes in English) Podcast on a variety of topics that excite us and other likeminded folks. For more information please visit our Webpage at pratyay.net/others/the-coffee-house-experience/
Our Show is now available in Audio only format on Spotify, Amazon Music, Google Podcast and RSS. See below for the links.
We encourage feedbacks and suggestions at theche2020@gmail.com
We stress that this is a personal venture of each individual involved, and is independent of their professional affiliations. Moreover, the opinions and views expressed by the guests are their personal and are not necessarily endorsed by the hosts.
Credits:
Theme Music: Chhandak Mukherjee.
Editor (Ep#34 onwards): Bijaybrata Jyoti.
Our Show is now available in Audio only format on Spotify, Amazon Music, Google Podcast and RSS. See below for the links.
We encourage feedbacks and suggestions at theche2020@gmail.com
We stress that this is a personal venture of each individual involved, and is independent of their professional affiliations. Moreover, the opinions and views expressed by the guests are their personal and are not necessarily endorsed by the hosts.
Credits:
Theme Music: Chhandak Mukherjee.
Editor (Ep#34 onwards): Bijaybrata Jyoti.
CHE#52 | Bangla Podcast | Bangladesh, 2024 | Sharmee Hossain | Soumik Pal
In this unique episode, we discuss the evolving situation in the unprecedented situation in Bangladesh, with Sharmee Hossain, a Bangladeshi and Soumik Pal, an Indian, both faculties of North South University in Dhaka.
Note: This was recorded on August 10, 2024
UA-cam: ua-cam.com/video/N6LDGIT96p0/v-deo.html
RSS Feed: bit.ly/3yE3SBm
Spotify: spoti.fi/3X15gG6
Amazon: amzn.to/46X1T7A
-------------------------------------------
00:00:00 Start
00:01:41 Intro
00:02:02 Opening
00:03:25 Bangladesh quota reform movement
00:10:40 Involvement of university students
00:13:17 What about other societies?
00:14:32 Violence in Quota Movement
00:17:52 Media Participation
00:21:01 Soumik's journey
00:23:33 Indian government's interference
00:32:11 Media's selling point
00:35:05 us involvement
00:41:26 Khaleda Zia
00:45:01 Bangladesh Jamaat-e-Islami
00:47:43 Students are saving lives
00:51:03 Econocim Class
00:53:20 What about the election?
00:58:15 Bangladeshi Politics vs Indian Politics
01:03:36 Some events
01:11:45 What about the rest of the Bangladesh?
01:13:34 Next step on Reservation
01:21:23 Bongobondhu statue destroyed
01:25:35 Cultural exchange between two Bengal
01:27:27 Bengali Cultural Hub
01:29:52 Catherine Masud's episode on CHE
01:30:07 New possibilities
01:35:28 Sense of being the other
01:38:39 Bangladeshi immigrants
01:40:20 End thoughts
-------------------------------------------
Links:
~ Sharmee Hossain’s academic page: www.northsouth.edu/faculty-members/shss/eml/musharrat.hossain.html
~ Soumim Pal’s academic page: www.northsouth.edu/faculty-members/shss/pss/soumik-pal.html
~ Interview of Meghomollar Basu: nagorik.net/features/awami-league-endangered-hindus-then-turned-saviour-says-bangladeshi-student-leader/
~ Asish Nandy’s article: vlal.bol.ucla.edu/multiversity/Nandy/Nandy_gandhi.htm
-------------------------------------------
Hosted by: Pratyay Mukherjee and Sanjay Bhattacherjee
Special Note: We are excited to announce that, our show has been ranked #8 in the feedspot ranking (podcasts.feedspot.com/bengali_podcasts/) Many thanks to feedpost for this. This is immensely encouraging. We plan to grow further with broader and more diverse host panel with more frequent episodes. Thanks to all our guests, and listeners. Feel free to reach out with any comments/questions at theche2020@gmail.com
#bangladesh #Bangladeshquotareformmovement #quotamovement #sheikhhasina #Bangla #bengalilanguage #banglabhasha #bengali #bengal #PratyayMukherjee #BanglaPodcast #SharmeeHossain #SoumikPal
-------------------------------------------
UA-cam: www.youtube.com/@thecoffeehouseexperience
Facebook: coffeehouseexp
RSS Feed: rss.com/podcasts/thecoffeehouseexperience/
Spotify: spoti.fi/3P75RSN
Amazon Music: amzn.to/3Z9dsVn
Note: This was recorded on August 10, 2024
UA-cam: ua-cam.com/video/N6LDGIT96p0/v-deo.html
RSS Feed: bit.ly/3yE3SBm
Spotify: spoti.fi/3X15gG6
Amazon: amzn.to/46X1T7A
-------------------------------------------
00:00:00 Start
00:01:41 Intro
00:02:02 Opening
00:03:25 Bangladesh quota reform movement
00:10:40 Involvement of university students
00:13:17 What about other societies?
00:14:32 Violence in Quota Movement
00:17:52 Media Participation
00:21:01 Soumik's journey
00:23:33 Indian government's interference
00:32:11 Media's selling point
00:35:05 us involvement
00:41:26 Khaleda Zia
00:45:01 Bangladesh Jamaat-e-Islami
00:47:43 Students are saving lives
00:51:03 Econocim Class
00:53:20 What about the election?
00:58:15 Bangladeshi Politics vs Indian Politics
01:03:36 Some events
01:11:45 What about the rest of the Bangladesh?
01:13:34 Next step on Reservation
01:21:23 Bongobondhu statue destroyed
01:25:35 Cultural exchange between two Bengal
01:27:27 Bengali Cultural Hub
01:29:52 Catherine Masud's episode on CHE
01:30:07 New possibilities
01:35:28 Sense of being the other
01:38:39 Bangladeshi immigrants
01:40:20 End thoughts
-------------------------------------------
Links:
~ Sharmee Hossain’s academic page: www.northsouth.edu/faculty-members/shss/eml/musharrat.hossain.html
~ Soumim Pal’s academic page: www.northsouth.edu/faculty-members/shss/pss/soumik-pal.html
~ Interview of Meghomollar Basu: nagorik.net/features/awami-league-endangered-hindus-then-turned-saviour-says-bangladeshi-student-leader/
~ Asish Nandy’s article: vlal.bol.ucla.edu/multiversity/Nandy/Nandy_gandhi.htm
-------------------------------------------
Hosted by: Pratyay Mukherjee and Sanjay Bhattacherjee
Special Note: We are excited to announce that, our show has been ranked #8 in the feedspot ranking (podcasts.feedspot.com/bengali_podcasts/) Many thanks to feedpost for this. This is immensely encouraging. We plan to grow further with broader and more diverse host panel with more frequent episodes. Thanks to all our guests, and listeners. Feel free to reach out with any comments/questions at theche2020@gmail.com
#bangladesh #Bangladeshquotareformmovement #quotamovement #sheikhhasina #Bangla #bengalilanguage #banglabhasha #bengali #bengal #PratyayMukherjee #BanglaPodcast #SharmeeHossain #SoumikPal
-------------------------------------------
UA-cam: www.youtube.com/@thecoffeehouseexperience
Facebook: coffeehouseexp
RSS Feed: rss.com/podcasts/thecoffeehouseexperience/
Spotify: spoti.fi/3P75RSN
Amazon Music: amzn.to/3Z9dsVn
Переглядів: 3 300
Відео
CHE#51 | Bangla Podcast | Post Election Commentary 2024 | Amitava Gupta | Adil Hossain
Переглядів 7672 місяці тому
While the festivities around the national election just came to an end, there were many facts that did surprise/puzzle/mesmerize us. For example: amateurs like ourselves were much closer to predicting the accurate outcome (see here: ua-cam.com/video/fKMHjVM9L50/v-deo.htmlsi=I_tmG_VDaQVDH_AP for our data-based prediction for Bengal) than the poll giants; despite all the social media hype CPIM ha...
CHE#50 | Many Facets of Resistance against Fascism ft. Kasturi Basu and Dwaipayan Banerjee
Переглядів 9832 місяці тому
Like many, Kasturi and Dwaipayan, an independent documentary filmmaker couple, were shell-shocked when the 2019 election results came out, especially by the huge surge in support for right-wing politics in West Bengal. From then on, they dedicated themselves totally to building long-term socio-cultural fronts to resist the neo-fascist right-wing hegemony. Using their forte in documentary film-m...
CHE#49 | Bangla Podcast | Election 2024 in Bengal - Prediction via Data Analysis
Переглядів 2 тис.2 місяці тому
Srinjoy and Pratyay analyze the 2024 Lok Sabha elections in West Bengal using voting statistics since 2011. The predictions are also informed by qualitative insights such as anecdotal evidence, candidate selection and varied local issues. This is the first endeavour in amateur psephology by the hosts and should only be taken as a quasi-pedagogical exercise. In other words, don't take the predic...
CHE#48 | English Podcast | Elise Kerdoncuff | Origin of Indians via Genetic Analysis - New Insights
Переглядів 5374 місяці тому
Analyzing ancient DNAs of different populations led to many astonishing discoveries about the past of our species. Unsurprisingly, like other areas, scientific findings through genome analyses collided with conventional wisdoms leading to cultural and political battle. This is especially true for India where a certain political ideology, deeply rooted in conjectured indigenousness, has been gai...
CHE#47 | Bangla Podcast | Pushkar Maitra | Decoding the BJP's rise in West Bengal
Переглядів 1 тис.4 місяці тому
Can we attribute the BJP's rise in West Bengal to the efficacy of their welfare programs? Or is Hindutva and / or PM Modi's personal popularity the key to the party's winning formula in the state? Prof Pushkar Maitra (Monash University) joins us in the latest episode of The Coffee House Experience to discuss all this and much more. Hosted by Srinjoy Ganguly RSS Feed: bit.ly/3VPzYTM Spotify: bit...
CHE#46 | Bangla Podcast | Arghya Sengupta | Is it time to rewrite our Constitution?
Переглядів 6484 місяці тому
The Indian Constitution is widely perceived today as a transformative document that sought to ‘educate’ the first citizens of an India, then recently freed from the yoke of colonial rule, about what living in a democracy substantively means. It would be surprising then to note that large parts of the document are essentially re-purposed from the Government of India Act 1935, which was widely re...
CHE#45 | Bangla Podcast | Garga Chatterjee | Politics and the Bengali language
Переглядів 11 тис.5 місяців тому
Is it inevitable that Bangla as a language will eventually be colonized by the Hindi-Hindu-Hindusthan consensus, which is currently ruling the roost in New Delhi? Garga Chatterjee is at his combative best here as he dissects this possibility and declaims the historical antecedents of the present moment. Hosted by Srinjoy Ganguly and Soumik Ghosh. RSS Feed: shorturl.at/btwMQ Spotify: shorturl.at...
CHE#44 | Bangla Podcast | Ronojoy Sen | The Parliament's role in structuring Indian democracy
Переглядів 4959 місяців тому
India's democratic experiment presents an interesting dichotomy. While elections have witnessed high voter participation rates on a sustained basis, Indian citizens are quite vocal in expressing their distrust of their elected representatives in the Parliament. Ronojoy Sen, senior research fellow at the Institute of South Asia Studies at the National University of Singapore, joins us in this ep...
CHE#43 | Bangla Podcast | Dipankar Bhattacharya | Marxism-Leninism In Today’s India
Переглядів 5 тис.10 місяців тому
The Marxism-Leninism (ML) movement in India started in the 1970s with the famous Naxalbari uprising to overthrow the Government and establish a one-party socialist state la China. Later, the movement was divided into several fragments, a number of which attempted to re-interpret the theory of ML in the Indian context, and subsequently joined electoral politics. Communist Party of India (Marxist...
EP#42 | English Podcast | Aditya Balasubramanian | Revisiting the Dawn of Market Liberalism in India
Переглядів 91111 місяців тому
While most electoral contests today are waged in the battlefield of cultural ideas, the free markets vs centrism debate was firmly set at the centre of the early Indian republic's mainstream political discourse. In fact, free markets served as the raison d'etre of the Swatantra Party, deemed as the first classical liberal party in the nation's political history. Prof Aditya Balasubramanian (Aus...
EP#41 | Bangla Podcast | Barna Saha | A Bengali Woman In Computer Science
Переглядів 2,8 тис.Рік тому
Barna Saha, a professor of computer science at University of California, San Diego, started her journey in at the CSE dept of Jadavpur University. Afterwards with a Master’s at IIT Kanpur, she moved to the US for PhD, and eventually became one of the leading theoretical computer scientists. Among many other things, she was recognized for her unique contribution to approximate algorithms in the ...
EP#40 | Bangla Podcast | Anupam Guha | AI, Labor and Public Policy
Переглядів 1,1 тис.Рік тому
Anupam Guha, a computer scientist by training (with graduate degrees from prestigious Georgia Tech and Univ of Maryland), decided to pursue the public policy related questions from a computer science perspective. With the explosive growth in AI technologies, several tech stalwarts (such as the likes of Elon Musk) expressed their deep concerns about its potential disruption in the job market. Ho...
EP#39 | Bangla Podcast | Indranath Mukherjee | Of paperclips, goals & data analytics
Переглядів 635Рік тому
He is a leader in the Indian analytics industry with 20 years' experience. He is a co-founder of the wildly popular digital storytelling medium, Paperclip. Tune in to get a sneak peek into Indranath Mukherjee's journey. #banglapodcast #datanalytics #paperclips #AI #machinelearning #IndranathMukherjee
EP#38 | Bangla Podcast | Suparna Banerjee | Maoism in India
Переглядів 1,3 тис.Рік тому
In India Maoism flourished as a struggle of marginalized groups, such as peasants and several indigenous peoples. While characterized by violent armed struggle and guerrilla warfare akin to other similar movements across the globe, Indian Maoism got its special character by taking the deep-rooted caste-division into account and marry it with the universal class-struggle. Suparna Banerjee, a soc...
EP#37 | Bangla Podcast | Swati Moitra | National Education Policy 2020
Переглядів 805Рік тому
EP#37 | Bangla Podcast | Swati Moitra | National Education Policy 2020
EP#36 | English Podcast | Barry O'Brien | Who are the Anglo Indians?
Переглядів 1,4 тис.Рік тому
EP#36 | English Podcast | Barry O'Brien | Who are the Anglo Indians?
EP#35 | Bangla Podcast | Anindya Sen Gupta | Cinema in the age of Algorithms
Переглядів 1,1 тис.Рік тому
EP#35 | Bangla Podcast | Anindya Sen Gupta | Cinema in the age of Algorithms
EP#34 | Bangla Podcast | Rajibul Islam | From popular science to Quantum Computing
Переглядів 1,6 тис.Рік тому
EP#34 | Bangla Podcast | Rajibul Islam | From popular science to Quantum Computing
Clip#33.2 | "No free choice under imperialism" - Garga Chatterjee
Переглядів 601Рік тому
Clip#33.2 | "No free choice under imperialism" - Garga Chatterjee
Clip#33.1 | Sexual Politics of Imperialism | Garga Chatterjee
Переглядів 1 тис.Рік тому
Clip#33.1 | Sexual Politics of Imperialism | Garga Chatterjee
Ep#33 | Bangla Podcast | Garga Chatterjee | Bengali Nationalism
Переглядів 17 тис.Рік тому
Ep#33 | Bangla Podcast | Garga Chatterjee | Bengali Nationalism
Ep#32 | Bangla Podcast | “Adieu Godard” & other Unconventional Approaches ft. Amartya Bhattacharyya
Переглядів 546Рік тому
Ep#32 | Bangla Podcast | “Adieu Godard” & other Unconventional Approaches ft. Amartya Bhattacharyya
Ep#31 | Bangla Podcast | Trina Nileena Banerjee | Women in Group Theater Movement in Bengal
Переглядів 927Рік тому
Ep#31 | Bangla Podcast | Trina Nileena Banerjee | Women in Group Theater Movement in Bengal
Ep#30 | Bangla Podcast | The Legacy of Uttam Kumar ft. Sayandeb Chowdhury
Переглядів 913Рік тому
Ep#30 | Bangla Podcast | The Legacy of Uttam Kumar ft. Sayandeb Chowdhury
EP#29 | Bangla Podcast | Absurdities of our Time - "ভালবাসারা কি সেলিব্রিটি হয়ে গেছে"? ft. Debarshi
Переглядів 800Рік тому
EP#29 | Bangla Podcast | Absurdities of our Time - "ভালবাসারা কি সেলিব্রিটি হয়ে গেছে"? ft. Debarshi
Ep#28 | English Podcast | Creating Cinema in Bangladesh ft. Catherine Masud
Переглядів 1,8 тис.2 роки тому
Ep#28 | English Podcast | Creating Cinema in Bangladesh ft. Catherine Masud
Ep#27 | English Podcast | History of Central Planning in India ft. Nikhil Menon
Переглядів 8472 роки тому
Ep#27 | English Podcast | History of Central Planning in India ft. Nikhil Menon
Ep#26 | Bangla Podcast | From RSS to Chomsky: An Astonishing Political Journey with Partha Banerjee
Переглядів 5 тис.2 роки тому
Ep#26 | Bangla Podcast | From RSS to Chomsky: An Astonishing Political Journey with Partha Banerjee
Ep#25 | Bangla Podcast | Aparajito and other "Malaise" of Bangla Cinema | Sayantan Dutta
Переглядів 1,3 тис.2 роки тому
Ep#25 | Bangla Podcast | Aparajito and other "Malaise" of Bangla Cinema | Sayantan Dutta
যদি হিন্দু কট্টরপন্থী জঙ্গি সংগঠন আরএসএস-বিজেপি ভারতকে শাসন করতে পারে তবে ভারত কেন জামাতের মতো বাংলাদেশের ইসলামপন্থী দলগুলি নিয়ে এত চিন্তিত যারা আরএসএস-বিজেপির মতো সংখ্যালঘুদের জন্য ক্ষতিকারক নয় দয়া করে বাংলাদেশী শিকার হিন্দুদের বক্তব্য দেখুন।
আন্দোলন সফল হলে স্রোতে গা ভাসিয়ে দেশী-বিদেশী আনেকেই সুযোগ নিতে চায় এর মাধ্যমে আন্দোলনটা সেই সুবিধাভোগীদের হয়ে যায় না। এর দ্বারা বাংলাদেশের ছাত্র জনতার ত্যাগ ও কৃতিত্ব খাটো করে দেখে বিদেশী হস্তক্ষেপের কোন সুযোগ নেই। যখন বিরোধী দলের রাজনৈতিক আন্দোলনের পাশাপাশি কোটার যতো অরাজনৈতিক আন্দোলনের আড়ালে জন আকাঙ্ক্ষা দানা বেঁধে ওঠে। যখন বিশ্ববিদ্যালয়ের ছাত্রদের মেরে হল থেকে বেরকরে দিয়ে আন্দোলন প্রায় দমন করা হয়েগেছে ভাবা হচ্ছিল তখনই ছাত্রদের আহ্বানে বাহিরের প্রাইভেট বিশ্ববিদ্যালয় ও কলেজের ছাত্র সহ সাধারণ মানুষ এতে সম্পৃক্ত হয়ে পরে ও বিশ্ববিদ্যালয় এলাকার বাইরে চারিদিকে ছড়িয়ে পড়ে। তখন তা দমন করা অসম্ভব হয়ে যায় এবং এই আন্দোলনের স্বরূপ পরিবর্তিত হয়ে হাসিনা পতন আন্দোলনে রূপ নেয়।
শেখ হাসিনার স্বৈরশাসনের বিরুদ্ধে এর আগেও অনেকবার বার আন্দোলন হয়েছে যা দমন পীড়ন করে কঠোর ভাবে দমন করা হয়। তখন তো এখনকার মতো বিভিন্ন দেশের হস্তক্ষেপের কথা উঠেনি। এবারে আন্দোলন সফল হয়েছে বলে এখন বিভিন্ন দেশের হস্তক্ষেপ ও ষড়যন্ত্রের কথা উঠছে। আন্দোলন সফল হলে স্রোতে গা ভাসিয়ে দেশী-বিদেশী আনেকেই সুযোগ নিতে চায় এর মাধ্যমে আন্দোলনটা সেই সুবিধাভোগীদের হয়ে যায় না। এর দ্বারা বাংলাদেশের ছাত্র জনতার ত্যাগ ও কৃতিত্ব খাটো করে দেখে বিদেশী হস্তক্ষেপের কোন সুযোগ নেই।
Very Nice discussion
বাংলা ভাষাকে মুখের ভেতর দুমড়ে-মুচড়ে নিয়ে কথা বলা একধরনের স্টাইল হয়ে গেছে। বিশ্ববিদ্যালয় পর্যায়ের মানুষ যদি এভাবে বাংলায় কথা বলে, তাহলে এদেশের ভবিষ্যৎ আসলেই অন্ধকার। এটা ব্যক্তিগতভাবে কোন বিষয় নয় কিন্তু বাংলাদেশে এই সমস্যাগুলো প্রকট হচ্ছে। এতে মানুষের ভাষাগত অশিক্ষা আর দৈন্যতা ছাড়া আর কিছুই প্রকাশ পায় না। আধুনিকতা তো নয়ই।
India out. India is the biggest enemy of Bangladesh.
It's really an amazing discussion. Things are more clarified now..👏👏👏 প্রতিবাদের দেশ...বাংলাদেশ ✊✊✊
bangladesh is not for beginner
"spokesperson for UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres said on Friday that the global body stands against attacks on Hindu minorities in Bangladesh amid the ongoing violence. “What we've made clear is we want to make sure that the violence that has been occurring in Bangladesh in recent weeks is tamped down ...9 Aug 2024"
Sharmee Hossain is delusional. Bangladesh is a Islamic State and its national religion is Islam.
You have zero knowledge about Bangladesh. Denmark and Finland have Christianity as their state religion. What do you think they are lesser secular than India? Your country is ruled by BJP and you are lecturing other country! You are delusional my friend.
I am getting shivers. Ms. Hossain is describing the workings of the revolution in so succinct and details. Amazing!
Typical leftists..Academically very sound, eloquent,intelligent but still can't call spade a spade..Calls BJP govt autocratic but never talk about history of Jamat & BNP and how they indulged in arson, looting and specifically targeted minorities in their previous term during 2001-06..I hope these guys are aware of ground realities and how the minorities in Bangladesh feel..If everything is so good why so many minorities move to India since 1971..Never asked that question..
@@souvikkhankari5200 Bangladesh Awami League did more crime to the poor Hindus compare to BNP. If you live in Bangladesh you can understand. Just search in Google two terms Awami League leader and Mandir you will get full picture. And in the 5th August, the student wing of Awami League did the vandalism against the hindu properties some of the places of Bangladesh. There are lot of evidence of it. What you have to do is find the truth, not awami propaganda spreading by Indian media.
I called our August 5, as " Cinco de Agosto " like the Mexican "Cinco de Mayo", both are magnificent and monumental victory. Mexico under General Ignacio won against the French in 1862, while, Bangladesh under general students and people won against India in 2024.
@pratyay - you need to prepare your subject . @sharmee - cannot get you out of mind.
Ana Hazare movement was not sponsored by BJP and RSS. It happened that BJP did well in Gujarat and hence people selected modi. Shoumik don't underplay ana Hazare movement.
The real insights and ground reality of Bangladesh by a veteran Bangladeshi ex- soldier...ua-cam.com/users/liveMhNbXSk1u7c?si=7KkmnS74kBPK4d1o
The opinion of a clearly 'ani Modi' anti Hindu ...so called leftie 'liberal' ( ??) prof represents reality of Bangladesh? Bah...what a joke!!
Shk. Mujib er murti keno bhanga holo...smone urinated on his statue! Your hooligans vandalized the symbol of your "Father of the nation" Democracy?!! Laughable...autocracy of the strongmen youth...tsk tsk...why are the Hindu teachers are forced to resign! Why?
Kno Lenin ar Abraham linkon ke jodi USA ar russia somalochona korte pare.. then who is sheikh mujib..lenin er murti vanga hoyeche russia te...so?? even I asked you a question who killed Mahatma gandhi..Isn’t he is an indian???
Why you are bothered about sk Muzib and Hidu only? Those who all supported The Hasina all are punished including Muslim also and will be punished for their did.
@@aminrahman1500 meaning anarchy is fine eh? It shows that the communal poison of 'paxtan' is ever preset under the surface...shameful
@@akibhanif4316 don't be absurd and funny! Don't compare a millennia disrupting communist revolution with ur situation...urs is delusion...
@@aminrahman1500 Their media is the main culprit I think..and their brought up also..These "Hindi-Muslim" headlines / captions I've only seen in INDIAN media...we didn’t ever grow like this..They judge people on the basis of religion..
Madrassa's student and teacher ra je mondir pahara disse sheta to apnara dakhen na keno?
Hindu der upor attack holo ebong hochhe keno? We know the ground reality...
Na, na America r kono intereest nai! Hasina ke threat korechhilo ekti 'White Man" ...Donald Lu Bangladesh gechhilen farming korte! 🙄🤭☺️
Digital security Act & his father had Special Power Act
A very civilised narrative from india perhaps the only one and both the host and the guest were realistic and matter of fact.
What vested interest of US.? Bangladesh in no way is of strategic or economic interest to any country except India
😂...U S wanted the St. Martin island...let's face facts...Hasina's removal coup was a cakewalk fr US...the partisan faction was bought off...
In fact, to me, Ms Sharmee was unable to paint the complete picture here. This student movement was supported and participated directly and indirectly by the general people. Still, we, the ordinary people, are looking at our students for the directions. They have our full mandate and support. After going through decades of mismanagement, inefficiency and corruption, we are now free. We dream of an inclusive and secular Bangladesh!
Secularism will start with re.oving the national religion.
Can't believe Indian ppl telling the true fact !! Thanks
Really enjoyed listening to this ! Please have more such interfaces. Really refreshing to see young people discuss all issues with clarity and unbiasedness.
During Awami league ear, you could not criticize her even in Facebook or other social media. We feel so free after long time. After Seven Years, I started browsing Facebook.
Interesting, to say the least.
এইসব বামপন্থী সেকুলারদের মাথায় কি আছে জানিনা। তবে জামাত বা বিএনপি ক্ষমতায় আসার পরে এই শর্মি আর সৌমিক টাইপের মালগুলোকেই সবার আগে পশ্চিমা দেশে রিফিউজি হিসেবে যেতে হবে
I am not a supporter of Jamat. However, there is a serious misunderstanding about Jamat's role. Jamat e Islami was founded in Hyderabad, India by Maulana Moududi as an Islamic revivalist movement against the West. Jamat was not anti-Hindu. As a matter of fact, Moududi opposed the Pakistan movement. However, Moududi moved to Pakistan after the partition to gain wider support which he did not. Jamat is still active in India and Pakistan. Jamat's weapons are ideological. Apart from its active support of Pakistan during 1971 when it experienced an existential crisis, Jamat does not indulge in lawlessness. Jamat leaders are educated and their participation in the BNP government in Bangladesh was competent. The Bangladesh Islami Bank run by Jamat was a very efficient and popular bank that was occupied by Hasina and given away to an oligarch. Jamat's political influence is very limited and they do not cause any danger to the society. Please do some research on Jamat.
How can one not support such a noble organization!!?
@@subhadippaul4494 Because I do not support identity politics, unlike the murderous BJP/RSS supporters.
@@farukchoudhury934 they dont seem like doing identity politics as per your description ...more like a charitable org. devoted to humanity .....aren't they?
@@subhadippaul4494 জামায়াত আইডেনটিটি পলিটিক্স করে, এরপর যতো ভালো কাজই করুক বাংলাদেশের অধিকাংশ মানুষ সেটি সাপোর্ট করেনা। ওদের ভোট ঐতিহাসিকভাবে ৫-৭%. এরবেশি এরা কোনোদিনই পায়নি। বাংলাদেশ সম্পর্কে জিরো নলেজ নিয়ে তর্ক করতে আসেন। এটা খুবই দু:খজনক।
they got a seat in 16 member team in "secular" Bangladesh with 5-7% support ! damn good politicking I would say..maybe we should take lessons.
এথেনিক ক্লিনসিং চলছে বাংলাদেশে ৭৫ বছর ধরে। সংখ্যালঘরা সম্পূর্ণ নিষ্ক্রমণের দ্বারপ্রান্তে। নিরাপদ দূরত্বে থেকে অনেক কিছু বলা যায়। একবারও নির্যাতিতদের ব্যাপারে মুখে কুলপ। এটাকে কি সেকুলারিজম বলে? বাংলাদেশের ভবিষ্যৎ অমানিশায় ভরপুর। নীতিকথা, হাসিঠাট্টা তামাশা করতেই পারেন কিন্তু ডুবে যাওয়াকো আটকাবেন কি করে?
East Pakistan er freedom fighters ua-cam.com/video/l5ZHGyvrl-E/v-deo.htmlsi=7tqS5OrHQTRufLw6
Ei video theke jabe. J mithyer besati ekhane holo tar proman roye gelo. Soumik er bhranto utopian anlysis abar khule dekha hawbe. Samosto islamist extremists ra unleashed hoyechhe. Gawto 80 bachhor e Hinduder sawbcheye kawm exodus hoyechhe Hasina r amole. Eta fact. Tar ager somoy phire asbei
These conversations are missing lots of depth. Also missing the core priorities, histories and political maturity and misinformation about minorities!
Really a dangerous precedent if such elements who are anti indian people are being interviewed . Jamat far ultra fundamenlist than Rss for sure .
I am from Bangladesh. Really amazed to see an Indian media podcasting actual scenerios. loved it.
Ei mohila ese Bharat sombondhe ka Khushi bole gelen ar apnara sune gelen. Bangladesh ki India ke Hindu country bhabena ? India match harle Eto moja keno hoy?
You unable to understand India as well as indian society.
শর্মি আচ্ছা জায়গায় ধরেছে, আমাদের ছোটলোকের মতো ব্যবহার কে! উত্তর দেওয়া যাচ্ছে না।
শর্মি একটু বাঙাল ভাষাতেই কথা বলুন।
বাঙাল ভাষা বলতে আলাদা করে বাংলাদেশে কোনো ভাষা নেই। অনেক অনেক ডায়ালেক্ট। বাংলাদেশের এক প্রান্ত থেকে আরেকপ্রান্তের ভাষার কোনো মিলই নাই। আপনাদের দেশে যেটি বাঙাল ভাষা হিসেবে চিহ্নিত সেটি ময়মনসিংহ এবং ফরিদপুরের মিশ্র একটি ভাষা। শর্মি আপু যে ভাষায় কথা বলছে সেটিও একধরণের ডায়ালেক্ট যেটি বাংলাদেশের বহু মানুষ ব্যবহার করেন।
@@mmd13135 বাঙাল ভাষা বলতে, উনি, মার সাথে যে ভাষায় কথা বলেন, সেটাই বলতে চেয়েছি। বাংলাদেশের ভাষা বিন্যাস আমি চট্টগ্রামের হওয়াতে খানিকটা বুঝি।
@@nibirdasgupta9723 উনি মার সাথে এভাবেই কথা বলেন। আমিও এরকমভাবে কথা বলি। আমার মাও একরকমভাবে কথা বলে তবে ইংরেজিটা ব্যবহার করেনা।
@@nibirdasgupta9723 এই আলোচনায় সৌমিক পাল বলেছেন পশ্চিম বাংলার লোকজন অনেককিছু জানেইনা বাংলাদেশ সম্পর্কে। সবচেয়ে বড় যে অজ্ঞতা তা হলো ভাষা কেন্দ্রিক। এরপরের ব্যাপারগুলি উনারা আলোচনা করেছেন যেমন ধর্ম বা কালচারাল ইস্যু।
@@mmd13135খুব ভালো। আমার বয়স সত্তর আমার মা অবশ্য স্কুল ইত্যাদি বলতেন।
স্বপ্ন দেখতে না জানলে বিশ্বাস আসে না।
এখানে তো অনেকে ডঃ মুহাম্মদ ইউনুসকে সিআইএর এজেন্ট বলছে!
Jara Nobel peace prize pai tara mostly western powers der agenda ke fullfill kore..Basically Western stooge..
এজেন্টই তো। আমেরিকার কয়েকটা চাওয়া ছিলো বাংলাদেশের কাছে। যেমন সোফা চুক্তি, অস্ত্র যুক্তি, সমুদ্রে গ্যাস তেল উত্তোলন চুক্তি যা আওয়ামী সরকার দেয়নি। এখন ইউনুসের কাজ হলো কিছুদিন থেকে এই চুক্তিগুলো করে তারপর বিএনপি জামাত কাউকে ক্ষমতা দিয়ে চলে যাওয়া
@@lonewolf5144 let's wait for a year or so till the so called election takes place. If the reverse happens would you change your idea then? I will.
@@nibirdasgupta9723 Jara Nobel peace prize recipient tara protyekei western powers der agent..Obossyoi uni USA er agent..Hilary Clinton onake 2001 saal e Nobel Peace prize er jonnyo nominate koreche..Hidden agenda na thakle keu nominate kore na..Onar gramin bank theke loan niye anek gorib manush sorbossyo hariyechen..
Jara Nobel peace prize recipient tara protyekei western powers der agent..Obossyoi uni USA er agent..Hilary Clinton onake 2001 saal e Nobel Peace prize er jonnyo nominate koreche..Hidden agenda na thakle keu nominate kore na..Onar gramin bank theke loan niye anek gorib manush sorbossyo hariyechen..
আমার দেশে এখন একজন শিক্ষক ও বোধহয় পাওয়া যাবে না যিনি শরমির (বানানটা ঠিক হলো?)মত বলতে পারবেন। বাঙালি শিক্ষক এরকমও হয়!
শর্মী হবে।
Y no videos on rg kar?
1:01:00 another pinaki bhattacharya in the making :D
100% agreed.
একদম। যাদবপুরের মাল থেকে আর কিইবা আশা করা যায়
@@subhadippaul4494 লোকটা সত্য কথা বলছেন। আমার খুব বাজে ধারণা ছিলো পশ্চিম বাংলার সবাই বুঝি ব্রেইনওয়াশড। উনার কথা শুনে সেই সন্দেহ রইলোনা। এখানে পিনাকি হওয়ার কিছু নেই, সত্য গ্রহণের ক্ষমতা তৈরি করুন।
Ho shotti bolle todr chulkay
indibong... please elaborate
loved it
Ei podcast ta khub dorkar chilo, thank you.
সাবাস তোমাকে অশেষ ধন্যবাদ তুমি বাঙালিকে আশা ও আলোর পথ দেখাতে পারবে