We love reading Orhan Pamuk in Armenia. I hope people in Turkey also read Armenian writers. This is a great way to find avenues towards understanding and solving our conflict. P.S. I gave the book My Name is Red to this beautiful Turkish girl from my math class, since then we were best mates.
Fantasti c interview! Thank you! Pamuk, I love your novels. I had to study a.lot to understand your 'world' and I LEARNED A LOT. THANK YOU. YOU BECAME MY FAVORITE WRITER. FL. USA
A finely balanced mind of an intellectual and writer. He speaks with an innocent heart & honest mind. Howmany among contemporary authors do it ? A big ?.
Pamuk gerçekten çok iyi bir yazar. Bu kadar iyi olmasının arkasında doğuştan gelen bir yetenek değil bilinçli ve disiplinli bir çalışma var. Kara kitap yalnızca Türk edebiyatının değil dünya edebiyatının da en iyi eserlerinden biri. Kıskançlığınızı ve saldırganlığınızı bir yere bırakıp biraz ona yaklaşmaya çalışın. Gurur duyun...
I love Turkish language, I don't enjoy reading poems in English but such a great joy when read in Turkish. Such an emotional language. Hüzün is one example as Orhan Pamuk puts it here.
It’s funny. In Peru, many internet trolls have the same opinion about Mario Vargas Llosa as some trolls who have written poisoning comments here. When politics (childish and foolish politics) is more important than literature itself for some people, opinions like these start to multiply. When I read The Time of Hero by Vargas Llosa when I was 18, I was impressed. Some years later, I read it again, and I still love that book. I am sure Carlos Barral didn’t get any money from Vargas Llosa. Jaja.
Some of you people below me are quite naive. Why would you think his English should be perfect? I recommend to all you , who criticize his language skills learn any foreign language...uhm perhaps French? or Turkish? I personally happen to speak 5 language but its quite hard to be fluent in all those languages besides English. So go grab a life
What's wrong with you people! Mr. Pamuk doesn't in any way have to be revered in English cuz it's not his mother tongue and English is not a key to judge once humanity or the writer's quality, and yet he's perfectly using it with a highly sophisticated vocabulary as an original English speaker could do... please get over the superficiality and listen to him, or better, grab one of his books and enjoy the wonderful art of description, details and the words' decorative embellishment.
“Political conformism?” Political conformity is the opposite of what O. Pamuk has inspired within and outside the Turkish community. Critical thinking is what he encourages.
Acaba Turkler kitaplarini okurken anliyorlar mi . Cunku dili cok renkli ve komlekstir. Zaten ingilizce konustugu gibi kitap yaziyor. Uzun ve karisik cumleler kuruyor.
@basicflesh Professor Pamuk speaks rapidly. Better to say nothing than to state such negative comments? Pamuk's voice is like music and what he has to say in this interview is like listening to a sonata. Why can't you hear it? He is obviously genius of a very high order - and you? Your comments: Petty, nonsensical and ridiculous. Grow up; appreciate the gifts of genius that Orhan Pamuk offers his readers. You can in no way approximate him in stature, intelligence or eloquence.
.Orhan Pamuk is an Internet thief. The internet is a bunch who take notes and use those to their movies, novels. Orhan Pamuk wrote his book on The Museum of Innocence
@basicflesh I think it's something to do with the Turkish language, my friend does the same she-he thing. Also, he wouldn't have gotten a Nobel Prize without being a brilliant author. I'm reading My Name Is Red now, or its translation, and I can attest to this. I do agree that his difficulty with English is unfortunate, plus he does seem nervous. Reminds me of when I'm running on coffee.
As a Turkish citizen, I am NOT proud of him. A Turkish writer has to have some words to say about his world. If some writer fulls his wallet seeming lovely to western nations, I would rather think he is a shame ! Lots of things to say about this issue...
To me it is obvious that Pamuk had memorized his answers - at least most of them- prior to the interview. So much for a so-called Turkish intellectual. It speaks volumes that his English is so poor..
Ne yazık ki sizler gibi az okumuş, uluslararası yabancı dillerden bihaber anti-dilbilimciler O. Pamuk'un kullandığı Türkçeyi anlamakta zorluk çekiyor. Zira adam modern batı dilleri seviyesinde ve kriterlerinde düşünüp Türkçeyi o seviyede kullanıyor. Cümleleri baştan sona doğru ve kurallı. Anlayabilmeniz için daha çok okumanız gerek. Zamanla olur, merak etmeyin.
All people should read "Mister Orhan Pamuk" on Reziliazam, but it is Turkish. He has no talent and no capacity for literature, only rich man because of his grandfather, so he can buy all critics.
buzzlikeyear Sikkafalı! Reziliazam'da herifin şeceresini ve yardakçılarını tek tek açıkladım, edebi yetersizliklerini örnekledim. O eser bir başyapıttır. Hayatında Rezilliazam çapında deneme kitabı okuduğunu sanmıyorum, zaten o çapta bir eserin yazıldığına da inanmıyorum.
We love reading Orhan Pamuk in Armenia. I hope people in Turkey also read Armenian writers. This is a great way to find avenues towards understanding and solving our conflict.
P.S.
I gave the book My Name is Red to this beautiful Turkish girl from my math class, since then we were best mates.
@amis paz William Saroyan is a great writer, check him out.
WHAT A SMART MAN! I enjoyed every minute of this conversation!
Fantasti c interview! Thank you! Pamuk, I love your novels. I had to study a.lot to understand your 'world' and I LEARNED A LOT. THANK YOU. YOU BECAME MY FAVORITE WRITER. FL. USA
A finely balanced mind of an intellectual and writer. He speaks with an innocent heart & honest mind. Howmany among contemporary authors do it ? A big ?.
Really enjoyed this conversation . I have also started loving novels.
Fabulous interview.
Pamuk gerçekten çok iyi bir yazar. Bu kadar iyi olmasının arkasında doğuştan gelen bir yetenek değil bilinçli ve disiplinli bir çalışma var.
Kara kitap yalnızca Türk edebiyatının değil dünya edebiyatının da en iyi eserlerinden biri. Kıskançlığınızı ve saldırganlığınızı bir yere bırakıp biraz ona yaklaşmaya çalışın. Gurur
duyun...
Orhan pamuk'un bir kitabını baştan sona okuyabilecek kadar dayanan çok az adam tanıyorum ...
@@assoc.prof.dr.mehmetserdar7417 Çok komik bir yorum.Kıskançlık doğal ama fazla açık edilmemesi gereken bir duygu.
Yes, he's a great author! Recently I read "Snow".
A really wonderful novelist! I have read three novels of his and found them great.
Definitley a great turkish thinker, weather you agree with him or not! I read part of his book "Istanbul" very good insight!
I love Turkish language, I don't enjoy reading poems in English but such a great joy when read in Turkish. Such an emotional language. Hüzün is one example as Orhan Pamuk puts it here.
incredibly familiar approach, great interview.
I red almost all his books but I think Musseum of Innocence is the top of tops
Thank you very much.
May the Allah almighty gives you useful winsdom!
whoa, thought overload... he just spews it out in 40 mins... I could imagine an Orham Pamuk parallel modernism master class.
He is the best writer
excellent piece of communication
It’s funny. In Peru, many internet trolls have the same opinion about Mario Vargas Llosa as some trolls who have written poisoning comments here.
When politics (childish and foolish politics) is more important than literature itself for some people, opinions like these start to multiply.
When I read The Time of Hero by Vargas Llosa when I was 18, I was impressed. Some years later, I read it again, and I still love that book. I am sure Carlos Barral didn’t get any money from Vargas Llosa. Jaja.
SENI SEVIYORUM ORHAN PAMUK ❤️❤️
Great !
Great interview......
Some of you people below me are quite naive. Why would you think his English should be perfect? I recommend to all you , who criticize his language skills learn any foreign language...uhm perhaps French? or Turkish? I personally happen to speak 5 language but its quite hard to be fluent in all those languages besides English. So go grab a life
GURURUMUZSUN ORHAN
What's wrong with you people! Mr. Pamuk doesn't in any way have to be revered in English cuz it's not his mother tongue and English is not a key to judge once humanity or the writer's quality, and yet he's perfectly using it with a highly sophisticated vocabulary as an original English speaker could do... please get over the superficiality and listen to him, or better, grab one of his books and enjoy the wonderful art of description, details and the words' decorative embellishment.
We understand very well. Do not feel angry. All people go to read Pamuk'novels and enjoy.. i love him. FL. USA.
Best writer alive.
“Political conformism?” Political conformity is the opposite of what O. Pamuk has inspired within and outside the Turkish community. Critical thinking is what he encourages.
Such a pity that I am obliged to listen to this marvellous speech not in my mother language, Turkish, but in English.
It's such a pleasure to listen to this novelist speaking in English , else I wouldn't ve understood it in Turkish
Acaba Turkler kitaplarini okurken anliyorlar mi . Cunku dili cok renkli ve komlekstir. Zaten ingilizce konustugu gibi kitap yaziyor. Uzun ve karisik cumleler kuruyor.
And that's beautiful 😊
nice interview Joe Pesci.
@basicflesh Professor Pamuk speaks rapidly. Better to say nothing than to state such negative comments? Pamuk's voice is like music and what he has to say in this interview is like listening to a sonata. Why can't you hear it? He is obviously genius of a very high order - and you? Your comments: Petty, nonsensical and ridiculous. Grow up; appreciate the gifts of genius that Orhan Pamuk offers his readers. You can in no way approximate him in stature, intelligence or eloquence.
Right
Pamuk is genial. FL USA
Nasil atabilirim bu adamin resmini benim sayfamdan?
He is a greater writer, rancending his Turkish identity.
4:40
"hüzün"
That interviewer is wearing the single worst-fitting suit I have ever seen on a human being.
they're not looking at you from above you're looking at them from the bottom, from the bottom of ignorance.
.Orhan Pamuk is an Internet thief. The internet is a bunch who take notes and use those to their movies, novels. Orhan Pamuk wrote his book on The Museum of Innocence
HAHAHAHHAHA!
Ne cirkin bir adam!
@basicflesh I think it's something to do with the Turkish language, my friend does the same she-he thing. Also, he wouldn't have gotten a Nobel Prize without being a brilliant author. I'm reading My Name Is Red now, or its translation, and I can attest to this.
I do agree that his difficulty with English is unfortunate, plus he does seem nervous. Reminds me of when I'm running on coffee.
Do you know his books? After you read all you go to be thankfull ! Enjoy!
He is nervous always. He had another books before the Nobel. You are an ignorant. READ AND TALK LATER.
@@gladysrodriguez5498 what are you talking about? Was there another comment that was reported?
As a Turkish citizen, I am NOT proud of him. A Turkish writer has to have some words to say about his world. If some writer fulls his wallet seeming lovely to western nations, I would rather think he is a shame ! Lots of things to say about this issue...
bu hu how sad...
you think his english is bad? Well, his Turkish is no better...
Stupid.
To me it is obvious that Pamuk had memorized his answers - at least most of them- prior to the interview. So much for a so-called Turkish intellectual. It speaks volumes that his English is so poor..
His English is so poor he taught literature at Columbia
His English is amazing
Mahir Özdemir. He teaches at Columbia University, so most of it comes from his lectures i believe. it is not natural.
Sayın Pamuk ne yazık ki Türkçeyi bu kadar kurallı ve güzel konuşamıyor..
Ne yazık ki sizler gibi az okumuş, uluslararası yabancı dillerden bihaber anti-dilbilimciler O. Pamuk'un kullandığı Türkçeyi anlamakta zorluk çekiyor. Zira adam modern batı dilleri seviyesinde ve kriterlerinde düşünüp Türkçeyi o seviyede kullanıyor. Cümleleri baştan sona doğru ve kurallı. Anlayabilmeniz için daha çok okumanız gerek. Zamanla olur, merak etmeyin.
All people should read "Mister Orhan Pamuk" on Reziliazam, but it is Turkish. He has no talent and no capacity for literature, only rich man because of his grandfather, so he can buy all critics.
Şenol Onay Wrong. We don't have to read some book to tell us what reading his books tells us otherwise.
buzzlikeyear Sikkafalı! Reziliazam'da herifin şeceresini ve yardakçılarını tek tek açıkladım, edebi yetersizliklerini örnekledim. O eser bir başyapıttır. Hayatında Rezilliazam çapında deneme kitabı okuduğunu sanmıyorum, zaten o çapta bir eserin yazıldığına da inanmıyorum.
Senol you are jaleous. When he piblished the first excellent book,his grandfather was dieong time. Jaleous!! Envy.