Tamron 28-75 g2 (version 2) vs Sigma 24-70 DGDN for Sony E-mount
Вставка
- Опубліковано 16 вер 2024
- In this video I compare the new Tamron 28-75 f/2.8 G2 (version 2) vs the Sigma 24-70 DG DN.
Tamron 28-75 - bhpho.to/3GNWv8g
Sigma 24-70 dg dn - bhpho.to/3gRUXQ8
Sigma 28-70 - bhpho.to/3GTn0Jx
Samyang 24-70 - bhpho.to/3sPdwdr
Sony24-70 GM - bhpho.to/3sPdwdr
Gear I use
Sony a7SIII: amzn.to/3cp4cEi
Sony 50 mm GM- amzn.to/3vcDlnF
Sony 35mm GM: amzn.to/2QZyO9l
DJI RS2 Gimbal amzn.to/3x6pUGJ
Sigma 85mm DG DN: amzn.to/33hS6Ke
Sigma 24-70 DG DN: amzn.to/2SbAWYz
Freewell Mist Filters: amzn.to/3sjqddT
Sony 14mm GM: amzn.to/3xiLrvj
Sony 20mm: amzn.to/37s3Hap
Sony 24mm GM: amzn.to/3g41ENW
Sony 35mm f/1.8: amzn.to/36yiW2v
Sony 55mm f/1.8: amzn.to/2Vrzkve
Samyang 45mm f/1.8: amzn.to/39FH98T
Sony 85mm: amzn.to/3g8MZ3R
Samyang 85mm: amzn.to/36yf7u3
VIltrox 85mm: amzn.to/2JzkgJj
Sirui ST 124 and ST 125 Tripods: amzn.to/3GnRxzY
Small Boling p1 LED Light: amzn.to/3pCtffo
Came-tv boltzen LED Fresnal: amzn.to/3zaeIL0
LED STICK LIGHT: amzn.to/3l59ZCd
AUDIO RECORDER: amzn.to/2EMm93
The review I have been waiting for! From the realest!
💯
Just... thanks for being you. So many Peter McKinnon knock-offs on youtube it is good to have someone like you keeping it real.
🤙🤙
I’ve had the tamron in my wedding kit since the gen 1 first came out, and since I also used the 24-70 at my corporate job. Even though I have access to both of these lenses I almost always gravitate towards the tamron not only because of its lightweight and ergonomics w/ Sony body, but the filter size of 67mm is pretty much compatible with most of my other lenses (24mm, 35mm, 85mm).
Cool
I agree I lost my confidence on the Sigma after getting a ton of “Dusty Nuts!” Compared to my old Tamron 28-75 G1 made with “Vietcong Flip flops” was better at Dust and weather resistance and lighter too for travel. I took that vietcong Tamron all over the world with zero issues. I hear the G2 is even better, sharper even compared to the Sigma? Thanks Vu for the review, I recently sold my Sigma Dusty Nuts and upgraded to the Tamron 35-150 after watching your videos.
Lol
I do have the 28-75 2.8, I tetsed the Sigma 24-70 and this is HEAVY !!
Nice review man. Don't think you can go wrong with either of them. They both great. Side note, I'd buy a 28-70 f/2 for E-mount regardless of price or weight.
Right
Only reason I chose Tamron over Sigma was because of the filter thread size. I already had 77mm ND filters and did not want to purchase new ones lol
Hello, Sigma fixed the dust issue and your lens can be replaced with a new one! Just check your lens serial number. New Sigma 24-70 lenses (with dust protection) have serial number higher than 5504xxxx. I`ve had same dust issue and my 24-70 lens also have been replaced. Good luck!
👍
Thank you, now I can't think about sigma lenses without having DN in mind!
Lol
I'm a videographer. I love the transparency of your videos. And this videos is exactly what I was looking for, but I still feel like missing some information. I'm in between the SIGMA 28-70 and the TAMRON 28-75 G2. My other sigma's have been great (both of them prime lenses). And since I saw your video I became concerned bout the dust problem. I trust sigma auto-focus and video quality. But since the 28-70 is not weather-sealed (except for just one little part), and the Tamron is apparently completely sealed, the I only need to know bout the difference in autofocus. As I said, I'm a videographer, I film tons of concerts, clubs, weddings, videoclips, and one of the main reasons I'm buying a zoom lens is to be able to have the "punch-in" effect, a fast zoom in or out (even in low light situations). So that's why autofocus is so relevant to me. Could you give me some advice? Thanks mate!
you have become my mentor i love you since i met you, i am seeing all your content, thank you for your experience and for your time wasted to give us this amazing free content for us video makers. thank you with all my heart
Thanks for watching
I’ve watched some tutorials on how to clean the inside of that sigma lens, if you’re interested they’re on UA-cam. Im okay so far with out dust in mine, apparently mine was made after they updated it, but for all I know it’s still subject to dusting later on. Good review, I always like your opinions on gear. Seems most people doing the reviews only use camera gear to make videos on other camera gear vs someone like you who actually produces videos for paying clients. I’m sure I could of written that better, but is what it is. Thanks for the review.
Bro thanks for watching 🙌
Regardless your sigma dust or not will perform fine. Mine just looks really bad inside 😬
I love my Tamron 28-75mm Gen1.......That GEN2 looks even better. Don't find the need to upgrade, but maybe one day! The 24mm 1.4 has been living on my camera a lot though lol
Epic B-roll lens cinematic filmic
You cracked me up all through your video DEEZ NUTZ and then your funny end insights. BOKAHHH!! haha. You r awesome. SUBd
🙌🙌🙌
Peace bro, I run with the 50 gm 1.2 in most case, I recently picked up the G2 over the sigma and the image quality is beautiful
I pressed like before starting the video. Thank you Vu!
What does DN stand for?
Deeez Nuts 🤣 bro thanks for review im getting 28-75 tamron today.. 💪💪
🤙
Dude you and me are alike. I said the same thing DN aka DEEZ NUTS lol. I of lucky so far I haven’t had any dust in my sigma 28-70. I have been really happy with it. I am not brand loyal, I try out lenses and if the perform well I keep them. I like how light sharp and quiet it is. But I have the tamron 70-180 and it’s a great lens. So I figured the tamron 28-75 was a good option but I was liking how well the sigma 105 f1.4 did on my a7riv so I gave the sigma 28-70 a try and been loving it. Great video thanks for sharing
🤙🤙🤙
Just bought one of these that came in the post with my a7iv (don't tell my wife) using my fx30 as my b cam now
I still rock my Tamron 28 - 70 Part 1. I find my self digging more and more each day! Great Breakdown!
🤙
Thank you for being honest! I’m debating on Tamron, Sigma, or Canon.
Hi there, I would like to share my experience on the matter. I’m on an a7riv with the most demanding sensor on the market paired with a sigma 24-70 for about a year in many projects and different scenarios and recently I switched to the version 2 of the Tamron mostly because of weight but also I didn’t had the chance to try even the version 1 before but hearing all that great stuff about it.
So….. I agree it’s a great lens and surely you can’t go wrong with it. In terms of weight no comments the numbers speak for themselves. But although I enjoy the differences in other areas I missed that slight iq difference from day one and never got over it (always speaking on the a7riv).
Lastly i had a theoretically newer sigma with the dust issue fixed as the say according to the serial number and for one year of normal use the lens was absolutely fine except one or two very small. Finally I’m thinking on switching back again as the pace of the “dust issue” isn’t comparable with the resolving difference. Thanks for your time on making the video. Cheers
The Dust issue has been fixed in the newer batches of Sigma 24-70 (serial #5504xxxx and up) this should be said in this video!
No it has not been fixed. People with new models still getting dust
@@nVuFilms Well I've researched this thoroughly and you and only you is the only one that I have seen saying this. I've been using mine in quite dusty conditions for many hours and no dust!
I agreed with nvu. I had a sigma with serial after this number and after 6/8 months I had the dust issue me too. So I’ve give back my 24-70 and I have to buy the 24-105
@@gregs4163 I personally know guys with new build sigma with dust.
I'm glad you are enjoying your lens
thanks for the review. I considering the "best" lense for my first FF lense. but i think i will take tamron instead. btw idk why hearing "DN" explanation is addicting ~
Lol
Great Video. I rent the first version of Tamron. Zoom ring was so stiff that I couldn’t use it on a Rsc2 with my A7SIII. I was wondering If G2 has same problem?
Doesn't seem stiff
Lmao I laughed every time you said what the DN stands for
so its confirmed even the mentioned newer serial models of the sigma with 55641775 and above still has dust issue? Can anyone confirm this?
No, it has been fixed
Mine is 5663xxxx, it's fixed, been using for 3 months . This is my second sigma 24-70, the first I bought 2 years ago got dust on the element . I use mostly for hiking and outdoor shooting
😂 thanks for this I’m gonna get the tamron im on a ministry budget and it’ll work just fine
Sigma DN: Dusty Nuts
Right
I have a 24mm prime lens, would you say that it would be better for me to have an 28-75 or an 24-70
That outro skit 😆😆😆
Lol
The Ligma 24-70 Fart DG DN (DN for Deese Nuts) is my favorite mid range zoom.
You can have Sigma and clean it for free. I'd you are going to buy the sigma make sure the serial number on the lens is higher than 556xxx the newer lens are dust proof.
It's not dust proof.
i appreciate the honesty. i wish more reviewers and YT d-bags would be more upfront about the sigma because none of the reviews I saw from the pro users mention sigma dust issues. I wouldn't have bought it if I did.
I think I need to pay more attention to real world users like yourself versus those reviewers who probably get these lenses for free and/or don't work with them on a daily basis. From my research, I seem to have bought the newer version sigma but I'll keep a close watch on it now and watch for any dust. very disapointing but the bright side is I did buy last december when it was on sale for $899! so far it's been performing perfectly on my a74
Sweet
I contact Sigma distibuter (for 24-70 art) and they said that there are no more issues with dust. Who can you believe? 🙂
Nope
@@nVuFilms 🙆 So I have to go with Tamron g2? 😁
Which lense is best for sony a73. Sigma or tamron ?
hi, have the dust problem been solved with the new versions?
Better but still dusty
@@nVuFilms but the dust can be seen in the picture? or is it only on the lens?
So… I have the Tamron 17-28 f2.8 and I LOVE the lens. So pairing that with the 28-75 i think those are the only lenses i need.
Wowww great....but at the end what was that🤣
Hey man, love your vids 🙏 would you recommend selling the 24-70 DEEZ NUTZ lens to buy the Tamron 35-150? I'm sold in every way on that lens but was curious if I'm sacrificing too much getting rid of 24-35mm since the widest I could go on the Tamron is 35.
Depends what you do
Lots of weddings , portraits, automotive stuff and decent amount of real estate is the bulk of it
My thought process was sell the sigma and get the Tamron and then hopefully also get an ultra wide
@@kanebayer3608 might be doable. The Tamron is hefty tho
That's ok , I like the heft. I have a sigma 105 f1.4 and I'm not sure how much heftier it gets than that😂 but yeah was wondering if that'd be a good move or not. Gaining tons of versatility with the Tamron over the sigma
That outro 😂😂😂😂
Lol
Another great video 100%! Lol
🤙🤙
Sigma 28-70 F2.8 is even better than the Tamron. So small. Perfect for gimbal
Right
It was better than Tamron 1st Gen, but not the Tamron G2, despite the weight differences.
Bro said it has dust in it… just clean it lmao tf this is like his life story
haha "Deez Nuts"
Lol
DEEZE NUTS 😂😂😂
Wait, what does DN stand for?
if you have the 35-150 i dont really see the need for a 28-75
It's huge if you are traveling
Tamron's material quality is worse than Sigma and Sony. It is more plastic and prone to wear in many years of use. Other than that, if I had to choose between Tamron 28-75 G2 and Sigma 24-70 Art, it would definitely be Sigma. Because both lenses are very close to each other in optical quality and a better zoom range at 24 wide ends.
Linear focus ability on the Tamron and cheaper > Sigma
How long did you have your sigma for?
Since it came out. 2019
Anh so sánh 24-70sigma với 24-70 samyang 2.8 đi ạ
Which one is better with oss
They don't have
DGDN - Do Gobble Deez Nutz
Is your G2 still dust free?
Yes
@@nVuFilms 😇
Great comparison, are there any significant IQ differences?
Hic- bạn có phải người Việt Nam ko ạ.😅😅😅
Deez nuts lens hahahah
6:43
vãi ending
These lenses are TRASH. If you want to be professional and have a decent chance to win an award, you use Sony 24-70mm f2.8 GM2.
And Canon has better colorscience.
What does DN stand for?