Reel vs Real with the CIA and FX's "The Americans"

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 30 чер 2024
  • Panel discussion about the true nature versus media portrayals of the mission and the work of the CIA featuring showrunners from FX's The Americans
    ABOUT THE EVENT
    Merging the overt world of Hollywood with the covert mission of the CIA, this panel seeks to demystify the CIA's mission by comparing what's seen on TV to what happens in reality. Former CIA officers will join the acclaimed creator and actors from FX's The Americans on-stage for a lively discussion about the facts vs. fiction of espionage, CIA tradecraft, and living under cover.
    Moderated by Joe Weisberg, former CIA officer and creator of FX's “The Americans”
    Originally recorded June 2018.
    Panelists:
    Keri Russell, actress portraying Elizabeth Jennings on FX’s The Americans
    Martha Peterson, former CIA officer and author of the book “The Widow Spy”
    Mark Kelton, former Chief of CIA's Counterintelligence Center
    Matthew Rhys, actor portraying Phillip Jennings on FX's The Americans
    Costa Ronin, actor portraying Oleg Burov on FX's The Americans

КОМЕНТАРІ • 58

  • @Mark-ld5um
    @Mark-ld5um 2 роки тому +31

    I'm glad Costa Ronin is involved in this panel. He's a great actor and a big part of the show.

  • @HoldenNY22
    @HoldenNY22 2 роки тому +43

    I can't believe how think Matthew's Welch accent is in real life. His American accent on the show was flawless.

    • @rorystorm4284
      @rorystorm4284 Рік тому +3

      Welsh.

    • @darthvader3910
      @darthvader3910 Рік тому +3

      He has a strong rp british accent mixed with a bit of welsh. But most welsh people dont talk the way he does.

    • @divyangvaidya9675
      @divyangvaidya9675 5 місяців тому

      ***Thick

    • @douglaswilke8582
      @douglaswilke8582 4 місяці тому +1

      Holy crap...he sounds like he belongs on a Monty python show

  • @marshhen
    @marshhen 2 роки тому +22

    The two male actors in this series were absolutely what mesmerized me about this series. Just fantastic and nuanced performances.

    • @Mitchcraft.
      @Mitchcraft. 2 роки тому

      2?

    • @tenpenthouse
      @tenpenthouse 2 роки тому

      @@Mitchcraft. Matthew and Noah, probably

    • @Bootmahoy88
      @Bootmahoy88 2 роки тому +4

      I’m with you on this. Philip and Stan created a sad and tragic friendship. In the infamous revelation scene it was clear how little Philip was truly invested in the relationship, and that fact only enhanced the horror that nearly consumed and destroyed Stan. Elizabeth was fascinating to me, as it was achingly clear how her real heart was entombed in ‘ice,’ so to speak. She became quite frightening when those masks of affability dropped. That was no small feat for the actress. You could she was a cold hearted KGB assassin. When Philip’s masks dropped he looked empty and sad.

  • @artwithheart3142
    @artwithheart3142 Рік тому +17

    Loved watching the stillness of the CIA members on the panel. Costa is a fascinating person, you could tell he was a deep thinker. Enjoyed this panel.

  • @ahmetrefikeryilmaz4432
    @ahmetrefikeryilmaz4432 2 роки тому +25

    Where the hell is Arkady Ivanovich?

  • @marshhen
    @marshhen 2 роки тому +20

    I am surprised by how hilarious Mathew Rhys is. Amazing.

  • @hilanocarvalho3945
    @hilanocarvalho3945 2 роки тому +44

    The best TV series of all time ! I know nothing lasts forever and I think it ended pretty well, but I miss it a lot ! What about Henry & Page ? A sort of "The Americans II"... Henry as an FBI agent chasing her sister Page, an undercover KGB (FSB) agent, but he does not know about her, once he thinks she moved to the USSR with her parents. And she has to deal with the tough fact that she may fight against her brother. That would be awesome !

    • @bantner21
      @bantner21 2 роки тому +1

      Love it

    • @Mitchcraft.
      @Mitchcraft. 2 роки тому +4

      I would say it's on par with The Sopranos which was amazing

    • @HoldenNY22
      @HoldenNY22 2 роки тому +4

      I like the Idea of A Russian Version of the Show about deep Cover CIA agents pretending to b ea Married Soviet or Russian couple living in Russia. IIt could be set in either the Cold War Era or maybe the Post Soviet Era.

    • @hauntedhose
      @hauntedhose Рік тому

      Of all time ? No…good show tho

    • @raymondsims7042
      @raymondsims7042 4 місяці тому

      @@Mitchcraft.I’d say yeah it’s very close with the sopranos probably slightly above for me. The wire is the best of all time though

  • @PardhaS
    @PardhaS 2 роки тому +20

    Great series- never get tired of watching it. So much nuance and depth in the characters.
    Any show that can make you sympathetic to cold blooded killers who are enemy spies is pretty brilliant.

  • @frankenviews4069
    @frankenviews4069 Рік тому +5

    Funny how the standards of competence to be a CIA agent is so much higher than to be on The Supreme Court, to be a congressperson or Senator, or even President of the USA.

  • @shawncdonnelly
    @shawncdonnelly Рік тому +5

    Regarding the wigs, I always felt that Philip's wig when he was hanging out with Kimmie made him look like Mitch Hedberg. (RIP.)

  • @kathleen4376
    @kathleen4376 3 роки тому +9

    Great idea . Thanks for doing this !

  • @michelebartlett3921
    @michelebartlett3921 Рік тому +3

    Matthew & Keri are great. Matthew is a fun guy. Very pleasant

  • @bilbob7624
    @bilbob7624 8 місяців тому +2

    an ex CIA officer making TV entertainment. what a shocker

  • @me0375
    @me0375 3 роки тому +4

    Wow really interesting, thanks

  • @arricammarques1955
    @arricammarques1955 3 роки тому +9

    Costumes and wigs are catnip for actors.

  • @mark_lhr3
    @mark_lhr3 Місяць тому

    Excellent!

  • @davedalton1273
    @davedalton1273 Рік тому +4

    I am surprised that no one asked if Keri and Matthew could really beat up most people. They must have had to undergo training in martial arts, to make it look good during all those fights.

    • @raymondsims7042
      @raymondsims7042 4 місяці тому +2

      You really think little Keri Russell could actually beat up grown men in real life?😂😂🤔

    • @radicalstanza3614
      @radicalstanza3614 2 місяці тому +2

      It'd be a silly thing to ask since the answer is obviously no lol

  • @valeriemiller3262
    @valeriemiller3262 Місяць тому

    Could not hear what FOX reporter said..

  • @Bootmahoy88
    @Bootmahoy88 8 місяців тому +1

    One thing that bugs me a bit about this interview with the CIA case workers, is that they steer far afield of telling how they know perfectly well how to kill a person at close range with their hands, much like Philip did to the KGB officer in the 1st episode. They're highly trained in hand-to-hand combat. I wonder why they did that?

  • @califsherry
    @califsherry Рік тому +6

    While I enjoyed the show emensely - and couldn't stop watching - I'm disappointed in several loose ends. One involves Stan, one involves E & P. (1) While I understand that we leave Stan with the suggestion that the woman he's now living with may be another plant, I don't like leaving the whole Gorbachev issue unresolved, especially since Stan has now been told by two Russians he knows well. At the least, he should have sent the info on to State. (2) How can E & P return to Russia? For all they know, the Central Comm will be triumphant over Gorbachev and surely Claudia will have informed the Central Comm of E's betrayal.

  • @DimitriMoreira
    @DimitriMoreira 2 роки тому +3

    This was amazing, but some of it didn't add up.
    Just for instance, the woman who retired in 2003 had her last 5 years working on 9/11? I mean.. it's.. it doesn't add up.

    • @Mitchcraft.
      @Mitchcraft. 2 роки тому +2

      I would say everything about the 9/11 event doesn't add up so that just adds to it.

    • @BarberBobDetecting
      @BarberBobDetecting 2 роки тому +6

      I think they meant she retired from being a spy in 2003, but remained an employee in a different capacity thereafter.

  • @hauntedhose
    @hauntedhose Рік тому +1

    Rhys’ accent is ridiculous 😂

  • @valeriemiller3262
    @valeriemiller3262 Місяць тому

    Woohoo!

  • @CaptainGrimes1
    @CaptainGrimes1 2 роки тому +2

    He really looks and sounds like Michael Sheen!

    • @bunnygarden215
      @bunnygarden215 11 місяців тому

      They r good friends and shared a flat/ apartment together!!

    • @davidoldham1545
      @davidoldham1545 7 місяців тому +1

      ​@bunnygarden215 he shared a flat with Ioan Gruffudd not Muchael Sheen

  • @DreamerDebora
    @DreamerDebora 3 місяці тому

    Matthew Rhys is so charming and hilarious 😊😂😅!!!! Omg

  • @user-lh1xf5zx6u
    @user-lh1xf5zx6u 22 дні тому

    PPC, you are clowns... You should also organize a scientific forum about this series...

  • @davedalton1273
    @davedalton1273 Рік тому

    Conspiracy2Riot "The next war with Russia will yield more favorable results..." ? Have you checked in with the war in Ukraine lately? Yeah, we're guilty of too much bling and consumerism, but we have led the way (along with NATO) in supplying military aid to Ukraine, as well as moral support. Russia is the aggressor and is now the leading fascist nation in the world. Not an enviable record!

  • @Conspiracy2Riot
    @Conspiracy2Riot 2 роки тому +10

    i loved this show. was sad it ended but on a really fitting note, as the USSR fell to capitalism. what a terrible moment for the soviet citizens. elizabeth and phillip were stellar examples of patriots doing a bang up job while raising a family in the shallow, bling, consumerist/materialist culture of america during a radical time in history.
    i wish it'd gone a dif direction...but the next war w/ Russia will yield more favorable results. the US is an empire in decline.

    • @CaptainGrimes1
      @CaptainGrimes1 2 роки тому +5

      I wanted to see Elizabeth reaction to the fall of the USSR, I wanted to see Phillip interact with Martha in Moscow, see Oleg return and hoped Stan would visit Russia in the late 90s with Page and Henry, maybe just as Putin is sworn in as president foreshadowing the second cold war we find ourselves in

    • @amredrisco8416
      @amredrisco8416 2 роки тому +1

      That sounds like a good follow up. Plus Renee turns out to be a soviet agent and the fall out from that ....

    • @GusBried
      @GusBried 2 роки тому +11

      ....are you actually saying the fall of the Siviet Union was a bad thing?? As someone from a post-Soviet country - no. Just. Effing no.

    • @Ellecram
      @Ellecram 2 роки тому +2

      @@amredrisco8416 I think Renee was Mossad.

    • @radicalstanza3614
      @radicalstanza3614 2 місяці тому

      Patriots lol. They were tools doing untold harm to tons of innocent people for ultimately no real purpose.