Pilot VS Sailor: BATTLE!

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 14 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 89

  • @Stitchxavi
    @Stitchxavi Рік тому +67

    Drew’s face talking about the con70 was p r i c e l e s s

    • @Gouletpens
      @Gouletpens  Рік тому +9

      It was tough. - Drew

    • @Vendavalez
      @Vendavalez Рік тому +6

      The new con70s are significantly better, but I still use con40s on all my Pilot pens.
      I do keep at least 20 pens inked or so and I like to change inks often, so they smaller ink capacity is actually a plus in my particular situation.

    • @SmasherBunny
      @SmasherBunny Рік тому +3

      "It's got a button! . . ."

    • @Ava-wu4qp
      @Ava-wu4qp Рік тому

      Sailor shikiori and kiwa guro cartridges. Easy.

  • @alejandromorales9516
    @alejandromorales9516 Рік тому +26

    Brian arguing against that Custom 74 nib ... oh I felt his pain!

    • @Gouletpens
      @Gouletpens  Рік тому +2

      Yeah he had a tough time with that one, for sure! - Drew

  • @erimadriddiaz5442
    @erimadriddiaz5442 Рік тому +37

    I have both, but for some unknown reason, I always choose my Sailor 1911… it might sounds weird, but I love the feeling and the feedback of my Sailor nib.

    • @ichirofakename
      @ichirofakename Рік тому +6

      You are not alone, nor even particularly unusual.

    • @yrknutzreek
      @yrknutzreek Рік тому +2

      I have both myself, though I have an equal love for them both. They're amazing.

    • @ImCFoxx
      @ImCFoxx Рік тому +1

      The only Lamy I use on a regular is my 2K🧡. The Safari is an iconic look but I do not own one. I suspect I think it looks a bit childish with that horrible paper clip attached. I have three All-Stars. I occasionally use one for sentimental reasons. I’m sure the Twisbi is a great pen. Both are great as gift pens to FP beginners. If I were to purchase either of them now, I would definitely like to try the Twsbi Swipe.

    • @chirantanmukherji640
      @chirantanmukherji640 Рік тому

      I love these videos and Brian and Drew you do a spontaneous magical session everytime! Kudos to you. I got a Pilot Custom 823 in Broad and it glides over paper, is butterfly smooth! Have a TWSBI 580 ALR Broad too bit for the price is surely worth the money!

  • @CarzorStelatis
    @CarzorStelatis Рік тому +10

    2:27 'Sometimes works' is better than the CON-40

    • @KCRileyGyer
      @KCRileyGyer Рік тому +3

      I’ve never had a problem with the con 40, I like it.

    • @karma13612
      @karma13612 Рік тому +1

      I took out the little metal cage and shaker ball bearings and now the con-40 works great. I wasn’t getting any ink to the feed before. Now, no ink starvation. And super easy to clean it between inks. 🖋🤷‍♀️❤️

  • @craftasimplelife
    @craftasimplelife Рік тому +7

    Oh my....Drew and the trash talk off the bat! 😂

  • @mirosawdrazek5833
    @mirosawdrazek5833 Рік тому +9

    I use both brands, lines Pilot 742/743 and sailor 1911/ProGear. I prefer Sailors, because (my subjective feeling) Pilot nibs are delicate and Sailor more substantial in my relatively heavy hand. I never checked real mechanical properties, Sailor Imperial with MF is my favorite daily writer.

  • @hbird6347
    @hbird6347 10 місяців тому +3

    I'm dying of laughter and rolling in my bed, PLEASE DO ANOTHER ONE, PLEASE. 😂❤

    • @Gouletpens
      @Gouletpens  10 місяців тому +1

      We're planning another! - Drew

  • @blaiseutube
    @blaiseutube Рік тому +11

    I love the trash talk

  • @JerryBearry
    @JerryBearry Рік тому +9

    I only wish that Pilot would use a converter like the Platinum converters.

    • @Gouletpens
      @Gouletpens  Рік тому +1

      Absolutely! - Drew

    • @karma13612
      @karma13612 Рік тому

      👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏🖋

  • @oscarmedina1597
    @oscarmedina1597 Рік тому +6

    Ugh, Drew defending the Con-70 had me laughing out loud. (I still prefer the Pilot 74.)

  • @Stitchxavi
    @Stitchxavi Рік тому +5

    I love the feedback from sailor nibs. It’s distinct and very pleasant.

  • @sqidvishus
    @sqidvishus Рік тому +5

    Sailor Pro Gear Slim is my favorite pen. That said, I own plenty of Pilot pens and like them as well. Sailor just has a better nib for my style of writing.

    • @sqidvishus
      @sqidvishus Рік тому +3

      @screenhut very tiny cursive. I find the smaller 14k Sailor nibs just have better definition and feedback for me.

  • @chriscoffey9793
    @chriscoffey9793 Рік тому +4

    Sailor MF nib - is the perfect factory stock nib in my opinion! Two great pens!

  • @eddie_8868
    @eddie_8868 Рік тому +3

    I haven't used a Sailor, but I doubt it would replace the Custom 74 as my favorite pen. I absolutely love that thing.

  • @RiZenAsH
    @RiZenAsH Рік тому +1

    Ok. I need more of these. The moment Drew starting with the con-70 I about lost it.

  • @paullee6663
    @paullee6663 Рік тому +7

    I'd hate to walk into a B&M store and have Drew 'serve' me... I just know if he was that way inclined it could cost me 10x what I had intended to spend ....🤣 🤣 I've worked with / for a couple of people like that many years ago, it's kind of magical how easy they make it look.... I have a Custom 74, one day I'll get me a Sailor 🙂

  • @paulmchugh1430
    @paulmchugh1430 Рік тому +4

    There is no question that the 1911 is better. Beautiful nib, nice weight and girth. The 1911 is for people who want a upgrade from the 74.
    A better comparison would be the 1911 vs the 743.

  • @GUMONPS
    @GUMONPS Рік тому +1

    I ended up getting a Custom 743 from Japan rather than a Custom 74, because not everyone likes a transparent pen body. That’s the only thing that makes me dislike the Custom 74. That said the nib is so nice.

  • @fcsolis
    @fcsolis Рік тому +2

    I eyedroppered my Pilot Custom 74- it worked! I eyedroppered my Sailor 1911 Grain of Rice pen- big fail. I eyedroppered my TSWBI Swipes- success! I cannot eyedropper my Lamy Safaris b/c of the barrel slots.

    • @philippebarillecavalier9275
      @philippebarillecavalier9275 Рік тому

      I heard you could if you have the barrel of a Safari rollerball. That part can be purchased separately.

  • @angelaphillips4183
    @angelaphillips4183 6 місяців тому

    This was hilarious watching you guys debate

  • @psychophipps
    @psychophipps Рік тому +5

    And we all know the *real* beef with Pilot, their stubborn refusal to release their FM nibs in the U.S.

  • @Taib89
    @Taib89 Рік тому +2

    Please answer this question for me. Why my pilot custom 74 doesn't write under its own weight? How can I make it write under its own weight? I have tried to spread the tines a little, but it still doesn't do what I want.
    Besides that, it is a wonderful, smooth pen.

    • @Gouletpens
      @Gouletpens  Рік тому +2

      Many factors could be at play here. The first things to try would be cleaning your pen thoroughly and swapping your ink. After that, you could consider reaching out to who you bought if from, if it's a newer pen. Alternatively, you could engage the services of a nib technician. - Drew

    • @Taib89
      @Taib89 Рік тому

      @@Gouletpens Thank you Drew. I will try them.

    • @cameronolson4553
      @cameronolson4553 4 місяці тому

      Just got myself a new Custom 74 and I am having the same issue as you right now! I have bought many more Sailors and never had a single issue with those...

    • @Taib89
      @Taib89 4 місяці тому

      @@cameronolson4553 I bought mine from Japan. Maybe you also bought it from Japan. I have realised that the japanese market pens write a little bit drier. I fixed mine by taking out the nib. Then, I widened the slit between the tines slightly and very carefully. Now it writes under its own weight. It is perfect now.

  • @rygregory
    @rygregory 3 місяці тому

    Most of my pens are Pilots. But my favorite nib is my Sailor. It’s so smooth but has feedback in the most pleasant way.

  • @periwinkletree
    @periwinkletree Рік тому +1

    OMG! I was watching this at night, while everyone is in bed, and and trying not to laugh out loud while snorting and covering my face to hold it in. Both Brian and Drew had the best repartee. Priceless! And the points were spot on as well. One important point that sold me on buying the Swipe was that it uses both long and short international cartridges. TWSBI nibs are somewhat more consistent, including the Swipe, and mine works wonderfully in reverse so I get two nib points in one. The biggest downside to the Swipe is it's not very good looking and feels cheap; the Safari wins for looks and durability for sure. I'm definitely a Pilot fangirl. The Sailors do look pretty, but they seem too expensive for what you get.

  • @brhill2
    @brhill2 Рік тому

    Have multiples of both. But my daily drivers is my Pilot Custom Heritage 92. Love the nibs on all my Pilots; smooth and reliable!

  • @mbb1920
    @mbb1920 Рік тому

    I like both Twsbi and Lamy but I think the Lamy Safari wipes the floor with the Swipe if you're going more for function than novelty. It has a working clip, a better grip and an easily swappable nib. If you're going for novelty, Twisbi swipe might be the winner because of all the attachments that comes with it and it honestly looks better. Like from a functional standpoint, I think the higher ink capacity is its only advantage but that has never been an issue to me because I like changing inks.

  • @SolangeGarnier
    @SolangeGarnier Рік тому

    So Drew, how about a Dots-covered CON-70 converter for your worst nightmare ? But hats off for arguing against your favorite, that was a clear win.

  • @sajjadhusain4146
    @sajjadhusain4146 Рік тому

    I’ll easily pick the Sailor, though I prefer and only own the 1911L, not the 1911S. I think the C74 just alright, with a pretty decent nib. But I like the 1911’s design and all round appearance and certainly the nib a lot more. I would have a harder time deciding between the 1911S and the Platinum 3776 Century, which is another classic that the C74 is often compared to. If all these three were contesting, I’d pick the Platinum 3776. But the 1911L would trump them all.

  • @deanandreoli1975
    @deanandreoli1975 Рік тому +1

    Twsbi is The Young Wolf lmao!!! holy shit im dying@
    😂

  • @River-Moon
    @River-Moon Рік тому

    Safari vs ECO is a better battle IMO. I like the quirkiness and reliability of the safari (my first fountain pen, have 10ish pens now lol) whereas I find the swipe unattractive when I could get an ECO for a lil more

  • @Volkmannx
    @Volkmannx Рік тому

    That was fun!

  • @arupian666
    @arupian666 Рік тому

    OOf, Pilot vs Sailor. I have a Pilot Custom 845, 743, 912, 92, black E95s, maroon E95s, 4 Preras and a Metropolitan. When I need to write something, I reach for one of my Sailors, every time, haha. I have a smaller collection of Sailors, a KoP, 1911 Large, 1911 standard, murdered out black Pro Gear, Pro Gear slim, Pro Gear slim mini and a vintage Sailor (looks identical to the Pilot 95s) I just love the Sailor feedback, the feel of the nib on paper. Feels and sounds like you're writing with a pencil, it makes me smile everytime. Now, Pilot make a fantastic pen, don't get me wrong. The 845 is an utter joy, but it's almost like it's a little too smooth. There's something about Sailor. And they make all kind of fun editions. My ambition is to have them all.

  • @RASPOLOGY
    @RASPOLOGY Рік тому +4

    Sailor 21k MF >

    • @justindesrosiers3145
      @justindesrosiers3145 Рік тому +1

      Ah dunno I’m a big fan of my KOP’s Broad. Oh and love the Music nibs too

  • @KobieK
    @KobieK Рік тому

    I like both Pilot and Sailor, in addition to Platinum pens

  • @EricFell
    @EricFell Рік тому

    Drew, you've really upped your shirt game since waaaay back in episode 76.

  • @JournalingwithSteve
    @JournalingwithSteve 8 місяців тому

    I've always wondered why the 74 and 1911 are always compared. Seems like the 1911 would compare more closely to a 742.

  • @The_Varza
    @The_Varza Рік тому +2

    Wait, Brian is into figure skating? (yes, that's what my brain latched onto out of this whole video)

  • @Tomatohater64
    @Tomatohater64 Рік тому

    Custom 74 in either Forest Green or Smoke is "The Perfect Pen."

  • @eno88
    @eno88 8 місяців тому +1

    Pilot vs Sailor. A rivalry as tight as the Air Force vs the Navy eh? Ehhh?

  • @Shiruvan
    @Shiruvan Рік тому +1

    I love em both, unique on their own terms and being available(though for a price) are appreciations we need in a hobby. objectively better though? all the cheaper steel nibs actually work like you'd expect a fountain pen to be, on both sides. Sailor needs to bring the profit casual to add to the full line of nib size option in steel nibs at the very least to make a punch above, but Pilot and Platinum, also limit their stuff in the steel nibs part like giving options are expensive in all the brands, so...
    I'm willing to let the price issue slide, for what is essentially, objectively, picky purchase option available to be chosen for the worse value😂

  • @MrGyges
    @MrGyges Рік тому

    Keep the match clean, boys, no hitting below the pen line. Round one …

  • @LordWhatever
    @LordWhatever Рік тому

    I do like some feedback on some of my pens it gives a tactile feel that let's you know you're not writing with a digital stylus on a cellphone or computer tablet.

  • @avgjoeshow4208
    @avgjoeshow4208 Рік тому

    I got a legitimate question for one of you 2, and for anybody in the comments who would like to chime in. I have a Sailor 1911 L with a hard medium nib. My wife is getting me the Lamy 2000 that I’ve been wanting for the last three or four months for my birthday that’s coming up and I really like the line width I get with my sailor hard medium, but I’m not sure which Lamy 2000 nib size I should go with. To my understanding they can run a little wider than what most everybody may be used to and I have no idea which way I should go. I’m debating between a fine, a medium, or an oblique medium. Any input on the Lamy 2000 Nib sizes would be greatly appreciated. I’ve looked at the nib nook but I was looking for a general consensus

    • @noregretsguitars
      @noregretsguitars Рік тому

      I have both makes of fountain pens. I like the fine nib size in both Sailor and Pilot fountain pens. My Lamy Fine seems to be comparable. I don’t have any experience with medium nibs.

    • @paullee6663
      @paullee6663 Рік тому

      @Avg Joe Show I'd go with the Fine. I purchased a Med because it was on special offer. I normally go for M but I found it too wet and broad for my handwriting. I sent it back to Lamy and asked them to swop it for a Med. I'm pretty sure if you like a Sailor M you will be happy with a Lamy 2000 F. If you are not, you can always send it to Lamy Germany and they will swop out the nib. I don't think the Oblique Med is for you.

    • @Vendavalez
      @Vendavalez Рік тому

      I am not too familiar with Sailor nibs, but I am with Pilot nibs. So if you have some of those this might be of use to you.
      Anyway, after getting a few Pilot pens, I got a Lamy 2000 and I liked it enough that I wanted to get another one with a finer nib than the one I got.
      So I ordered a fine because, looking at the line width, I was CERTAIN that my first one had to be the medium size. It wasn’t. It was the Fine.
      Thankfully I had a friend’s birthday coming up who is also into fountain pens and I figured I would gift the extra pen to them. And I did get the extra fine eventually which was fine.
      Just my two cents in case it helps someone.

  • @x-ballpointuser3686
    @x-ballpointuser3686 Рік тому

    Drew and the con- 70😂😂😂😂😂

  • @tardigrada6000
    @tardigrada6000 Рік тому

    lol guys this was hilarious

  • @ameliabuns4058
    @ameliabuns4058 Рік тому +1

    lol this is hilarious, I don't like either pen but this is fun to watch, don't see the point of custom 74 over say a metropolitan

  • @agabrielhegartygaby9203
    @agabrielhegartygaby9203 4 місяці тому

    Gentlemen: 3 words: Realo (Progear), 21k nibs, piston fillers.....

  • @gumpware
    @gumpware Рік тому

    Platinum 3776 says, "Hold my nib."

  • @Dosbomber
    @Dosbomber Рік тому

    lol.. Brian wasn't touching that username.

  • @deanandreoli1975
    @deanandreoli1975 Рік тому

    hilarious good times🎉😂

  • @hiteshnh
    @hiteshnh 6 місяців тому

    Platinum 3776 enjoying the video to see who is going to be the first runner up.

  • @brettsmith1655
    @brettsmith1655 Рік тому +5

    Did Brian just imply that dumping a different color dye into the plastic batch or swapping out finials and marking the price up $100 is "innovation". I am not a fan of Pilot but Brian lost the battle for Sailor when that came out of his mouth.

    • @ImCFoxx
      @ImCFoxx Рік тому

      They do the same thing to drugs. They keep the basic drug the same, but change the slightest thing about it, or some other particular, to maintain the patent to prevent it from becoming more available. I get a little weary of the Sailor, constant deluge of pens. I do use them for their fine firm nibs. But I would choose a Pilot first always.

    • @onii-chandaisuki5710
      @onii-chandaisuki5710 Рік тому

      If it were so simple, why can't I do it myself?

  • @ExiledExia
    @ExiledExia Рік тому

    The 21k sailor nib is superb and I prefer Sailor because of the wide variety of choices in sizes, colors and nibs

  • @sociallyhawkword
    @sociallyhawkword Рік тому

    i don't like this salmon slander!

  • @kjhendricks55
    @kjhendricks55 Рік тому

    Bryan, you did a lousy job defending the 1911. Get with the program buddy.

    • @Gouletpens
      @Gouletpens  Рік тому

      To be fair, he REALLY loves the Custom 74! - Drew

  • @mbb1920
    @mbb1920 Рік тому +14

    I like both Twsbi and Lamy but I think the Lamy Safari wipes the floor with the Swipe if you're going more for function than novelty. It has a working clip, a better grip and an easily swappable nib. If you're going for novelty, Twisbi swipe might be the winner because of all the attachments that comes with it and it honestly looks better. Like from a functional standpoint, I think the higher ink capacity is its only advantage but that has never been an issue to me because I like changing inks.