STEVEN WILSON & TIM BOWNESS discuss RADIOHEAD, COLDPLAY, U2 & more! THE ALBUM YEARS (2000 Part 1)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 1 тра 2024
  • The Album Years podcast returns (for the first time in video form!) with Steven Wilson and Tim Bowness diving head first into the year 2000 to discuss albums from Radiohead, Coldplay, U2 & more.
    00:00:00 The Album Years Title Sequence
    00:00:18 Introduction
    00:03:49 Radiohead - Kid A
    00:12:40 Coldplay - Parachutes
    00:13:24 Oasis - Standing on the Shoulder of Giants
    00:15:13 Doves - Lost Souls
    00:17:50 Placebo - Black Market Music / Blackbox Recorder - Facts of Life
    00:18:26 More on Radiohead - Kid A
    00:20:01 Chris Morris - Blue Jam
    00:27:49 Gas - Pop
    00:31:47 Broadcast - The Noise Made By People
    00:36:17 U2 - All That You Can't Leave Behind

КОМЕНТАРІ • 137

  • @twilightpole8634
    @twilightpole8634 Місяць тому +48

    steven in his social media popstar icon era

  • @dieper
    @dieper Місяць тому +43

    Steven has the youth elixir

  • @mitfreundlichengruen2337
    @mitfreundlichengruen2337 Місяць тому +46

    Have been an avid listener on Spotify since the beginning, however i'm very much looking forward to watching these two music nerds on video!

  • @sspbrazil
    @sspbrazil Місяць тому +13

    Doves “Lost Souls” is one of my favorite albums from this year, I played that album to death when it came out.

  • @JoseCastillo-oe6zy
    @JoseCastillo-oe6zy Місяць тому +24

    can't believe it's been almost 3 years since this podcast started. it's helped me discover so much music, thanks Tim and Steven!

  • @silveriodide4421
    @silveriodide4421 Місяць тому +7

    Awesome to hear Doves get a mention - they were my favourite band until I discovered Porcupine Tree (still love them) - and I love that Steven and Tim could appreciate Lost Souls. It has a sound all its own, part northern soul, part cinematic soundscape, part indie rock, drenched in atmosphere.

  • @user-bt2od3yw1b
    @user-bt2od3yw1b Місяць тому +13

    Please keep doing the video version of this, its great :)

  • @guennadiyf1752
    @guennadiyf1752 Місяць тому +11

    Spotify and these two blocks are the best way to discover new names.

  • @mstao63
    @mstao63 Місяць тому +5

    I think this podcast is going to lead to a lot of purchases😂

  • @OrigenisAdamantios
    @OrigenisAdamantios Місяць тому +7

    THE SMILE 🎉

  • @JohnMacRae23
    @JohnMacRae23 Місяць тому +14

    The Doves, Radiohead and Broadcast top that bunch for me. The Doves catalog is brilliant Steven, surprised you didn't know them.

    • @analogpeach7174
      @analogpeach7174 Місяць тому +4

      Doves is top tier... The layering is immense, Steven would really appreciate the production for sure.

    • @FranZSound1
      @FranZSound1 Місяць тому

      nocreastodoloqueescuchas.blogspot.com/

    • @andsoistopped
      @andsoistopped Місяць тому +1

      Doves. Absolute class.

    • @x-roytube2218
      @x-roytube2218 5 днів тому

      Anyone who loves Broadcast should keep an eye on my uploads, I have lots of rare live footage that is a bitch for me to upload...I only got a few things on so far, but I've found full concerts shot with real camera equipment which I even showed to the band after the show and they were pretty impressed...just sayin'...and hearing Steven Wilson talking about them makes me happy...they were brilliant and spooky, and very nice people. It's so sad it was over so quickly.
      ua-cam.com/video/bkokhcdIHw0/v-deo.html&ab_channel=X-RoyTube

  • @stevemuzak8526
    @stevemuzak8526 Місяць тому +4

    Radiohead were always way ahead of everybody else.

  • @MarcoGosatti42
    @MarcoGosatti42 Місяць тому +14

    What makes OK Computer so good is the fact it holds more relevance today than it did in 1997.
    KiD A is the greatest left turn in Music history. That album is a 21st century classic.

  • @parttimelarry
    @parttimelarry Місяць тому +2

    Hell yeah, great to have this on UA-cam, hope this keeps going!

  • @abstractaeon
    @abstractaeon Місяць тому +4

    Thanks for this!!!

  • @athuldas4959
    @athuldas4959 Місяць тому +2

    What a treat! Thanks for this

  • @israelthacker8568
    @israelthacker8568 Місяць тому +2

    Best podcast! And great to see a video of it

  • @JeffCooper10538
    @JeffCooper10538 Місяць тому +7

    This is better than the telly! 👍

  • @metalmickey777
    @metalmickey777 Місяць тому +2

    I’m so excited to SEE you guys talk!

  • @saturninebear
    @saturninebear Місяць тому +2

    Well, this is exciting.

  • @paulbartholomew3334
    @paulbartholomew3334 Місяць тому +2

    Another brilliant show and really happy these episodes are coming out regularly now. And delighted The Strawbs got a mention!

  • @marcosaucedo7818
    @marcosaucedo7818 Місяць тому +2

    Im very glad for u to upload the whole episode for free

  • @andychungUK
    @andychungUK Місяць тому +3

    Next level album years! Been listening since pod 1 and LOVE this evolution. Thank you for continuing to feed our musical XP with your experiences!

  • @cruxadowrx
    @cruxadowrx Місяць тому +3

    excelent episode!

  • @gordonstrole290
    @gordonstrole290 Місяць тому +4

    Wow! Look at you, literally! Love it

  • @bryanlinden4522
    @bryanlinden4522 Місяць тому +2

    So glad youre doing with video now. Thank you both for the great music and for always helping me discover or rediscover great music. Cheers 🍻

  • @Nephilim-81
    @Nephilim-81 Місяць тому +4

    Subscribed. ❤

  • @LXDangers
    @LXDangers Місяць тому +1

    Wasn't aware of a podcast on Spotify so I shall be giving those a listen. Very pleased Chris Morris got a mention. I look forward to hearing more

  • @norbertovelazquez7441
    @norbertovelazquez7441 Місяць тому

    Excelente y con subtitulos en español!!👏👏

  • @Universityofvinyl
    @Universityofvinyl 21 день тому

    Cool to have these great convo’s on YT

  • @pv_bassplayer
    @pv_bassplayer Місяць тому +2

    I LOVE this podcast, I really hope you keep doing this on video. Thank you very much for all the music you have recommended!! 😃

  • @SlowRecordShop
    @SlowRecordShop 21 день тому

    Thank you

  • @jamesjukebox2386
    @jamesjukebox2386 Місяць тому +1

    Very good show chaps.

  • @FranciscoBurrola
    @FranciscoBurrola Місяць тому +6

    I hope they'll talk about Ulver's Perdition City in the next episode

  • @ashwinsrinath8955
    @ashwinsrinath8955 Місяць тому +2

    definitely would love to hear more about how your own music fit into the picture

  • @andsoistopped
    @andsoistopped Місяць тому +6

    I think people were cynical about U2 initially because of Rattle and Hum. I think that’s where the ‘careerist’ allegations came into it. If you watch the movie and listen to the record I do believe it’s U2 being amazed by the music and the country and allowing it to shape their output. They were accused of all kinds of nonsense with Rattle and Hum. The fact that they came from Ireland and all of the geographical, sociopolitical machinations of that meant America was a massive deal for them. R and H and the JT is about the discovery of this other land. It’s about reverence for and exploration of but also criticism of - Bullet the Blue Sky, Mother’s of the Disappeared etc. The real problem with U2 is that they haven’t made a decent album in years. No Line on the Horizon was the last interesting thing they did.

    • @nianfiedler5291
      @nianfiedler5291 Місяць тому +2

      I agree fully with the first part of your post. U2 have always been fans of other artists, and they have done some incredible collaborations with others through the years. I think they were truly enamored by America, the blues, country and gospel.
      I would say that you should give some proper listening to the last two albums. I like them better than All That and Atomic Bomb. The biggest crime is the Edge not doing what he does best on these albums, but still some great songs.

    • @indigokiller
      @indigokiller 28 днів тому +1

      Atomic Bomb is a perfect album

  • @kasperjrgensen8274
    @kasperjrgensen8274 Місяць тому +1

    Great podcast. I compiled an 'Album Years 2000 playlist' on Spotify to go along with this

  • @paulmenard7936
    @paulmenard7936 Місяць тому +1

    I was fine with the podcast... handy to listen to while driving. But it's great to to hang out with Tim and Steven.

  • @AudioAl5195
    @AudioAl5195 Місяць тому +2

    I love this UA-cam video. Big fan of the podcasts but this is even better and very well produced too.

  • @tmtkview
    @tmtkview Місяць тому +2

    Finally with visuals! After 30 years I learned how to pronounce Autechre which I was doing wrong all this time. I hope they do it correct.

  • @andersoncubillos
    @andersoncubillos Місяць тому +2

    My first time listening to the podcast. I know half of these albums, and I'm grateful to discover the other half. Lovely conversation, and great recommendations!! 🙂🙂🙂

  • @ashwinsrinath8955
    @ashwinsrinath8955 Місяць тому +2

    please, more on UA-cam!

  • @ahumblerequest5222
    @ahumblerequest5222 17 днів тому

    I absolutely love you guys

  • @tomcaufield-officialchanne7251
    @tomcaufield-officialchanne7251 Місяць тому +1

    A British-centric group of albums on this episode, even more than usual! Great to have the visual version option!

  • @UberChuckBAss
    @UberChuckBAss Місяць тому +2

    yay 4 utube premiere

  • @antonsylchenko4809
    @antonsylchenko4809 Місяць тому +2

    Love the new format guys - please keep the show going!
    Any chance for a 90s one after this (perhaps 91 or 94) ? It’s been a while and your thoughts on mbv, slint, talk talk, portishead and nin have been missed :D

  • @shame69
    @shame69 Місяць тому +1

    Thumbs through the roof for Tim's mention of 'retro-futurism'!

  • @billbrn
    @billbrn Місяць тому +9

    keep working

  • @georgiostemirsidis1966
    @georgiostemirsidis1966 Місяць тому +1

    An episode on grunge would be amazing❤

  • @DirranProductions
    @DirranProductions 29 днів тому +1

    The new start with my birth year

  • @alastairadams7861
    @alastairadams7861 Місяць тому +1

    So happy to hear Steven namecheck Orville the Duck, proper bucket list moment that 😄

  • @markgatland977
    @markgatland977 Місяць тому +3

    Excellent video production values, chaps... although I'd expect nothing less from you two 😉

  • @norbertovelazquez7441
    @norbertovelazquez7441 Місяць тому

    Encuentro muchas similitudes con radiohead y con la musica de Steven a nivel de evolución musical, maravillosos ambos!!

  • @budgetguitaristcom
    @budgetguitaristcom Місяць тому +2

    Been a massive fan of the podcast, so I'm stoked for this to be on UA-cam now. Awesome!

  • @threestringsomg
    @threestringsomg 29 днів тому +2

    1 1/2 episodes in did not know this podcast existed and both of you have talked about some of my fave all time artists already so well....loving it....and i look forward to diving into past and future episodes. 👍👍👍
    Also loving the fact Steve enjoys some of my fave artists or knows about them well (Sunno, God Speed You! Black Emperor, Goldfrapp, Faust, Iron Maiden etc.)....metalheads take note the man who produced Blackwater Park has opinions and loves alot of different music!!! 👏👏👏
    Feels weird to say it but year 2000 feels so old now....
    And Broadcast!!!! Love them - they are amazing. Have everything by them.

  • @turnsole8610
    @turnsole8610 Місяць тому +1

    I'm 51 years old, and 2010, for me, was an important year for The Album, especially in the alternative rock genre. The National (High Violet) Spoon (Transference) are just two examples. These are not debut albums but both propelled these bands into "near" mainstream. Consider exploring 2010. LOVE the Podcast!!!!!!

  • @anthonychilds8193
    @anthonychilds8193 Місяць тому +1

    I never loved Doves, liked tracks, but it was never enough. As Tim mentioned, their earlier electronic beginning (as Sub Sub) was for me a lot better, albeit, much more limited in releases. I'd definitely be interested in re-investigating Doves in whole. Re: Radiohead, they definite borrow more expertly than others, are more talented than most, and Thom is always searching for the next interesting thing (which maybe why he wouldn't think the "album years" ends at the turn of the century because he's still finding stuff a few months before many others (and in many cases helping these albums to blow up). Never checked out Chris Morris, description sounds quite interesting. Fully agree w/ Steve re: GAS/Wolfgang Voigt. Love Broadcast. Still miss them even though they kind of haven't gone away (loving demos will be released, hating it'll be likely the last we hear from them). Trish is ever so missed. In describing the quality of her voice, they miss the content of her lyrics which fit in any era while the voice harkens to the 50s-60s and as Tim said, the electronics are futuristic. I didn't distrust U2's motives (they're a rock band, c'mon), I just thought they got boring and became the "wallpaper music" Bono used to be famously quoted for saying in interviews before they became the biggest rock band in the world.

  • @fredfadda
    @fredfadda Місяць тому +3

    Love to see ! A pity however how it ends… when is part 2 coming??

    • @bobby666666
      @bobby666666 Місяць тому

      Recently the Podcasts have been weekly and posted on a Tuesday late in the day.

  • @eldercaius
    @eldercaius Місяць тому +2

    nice

  • @norbertovelazquez7441
    @norbertovelazquez7441 Місяць тому

    Kid A es un fantastico album!! Radiohead es una de mis bandas favoritas; el disco de coldplay esta bastante bien, que bien la mencion de standing on the shoulder de oasis buen album!!

  • @nianfiedler5291
    @nianfiedler5291 Місяць тому +3

    Great podcast and enjoyed the thoughtful discussion. I do take exception to one part regarding U2. You said that everyone wanted to be Radiohead and U2 was no exception.
    I think you have your timeline off. Achtung Baby was released in 1991 and Zooropa in 93, before Radiohead had even released a proper album.
    What is apparent is that The Bends and Ok Computer were substantially influenced by Achtung and Zooropa.

    • @bowness1
      @bowness1 Місяць тому +1

      I totally agree about Radiohead being influenced by U2 on The Bends and OK Computer (which is mentioned at some point in the podcast), but I think it's possible that - in turn - U2 were subsequently inspired by Radiohead's work that was more traditionally 'Rock Quartet' based. Ok Computer was massive and it was difficult to avoid at the time.

  • @gazmccall
    @gazmccall Місяць тому +3

    Love the video look😂😂😂

  • @quantiquefilms
    @quantiquefilms 14 днів тому

    U2's ATYCLB is huge. Steven's right about Elevation but songs like In a Little While and Wild Honey are just perfect.

  • @richg1776
    @richg1776 Місяць тому +2

    Enjoyed AYs first venture on to UA-cam. Can I point out an editing school boy error. The Gas record was displayed while you were talking about Boards of Canada 😮.

  • @MAKINGUTHINK
    @MAKINGUTHINK Місяць тому +2

    Great first part! Not counting on it, but it would be crazy to hear them cover Hybrid Theory by Linkin Park, which also released in 2000 (I know it’s not really a genre both of them like, lol 😂).

  • @doggity5149
    @doggity5149 18 днів тому

    17:15 I understand what Steven is saying, but to me he is genuinely one of my favorite singers of all time. I just love his tone of voice so much, and it was from the get go, when I first heard a PT song. Such a pleasant and new sounding voice in the "prog" scene I thought. Don't sell yourself short Steven, there are lots of singers that can do all these vocal gymnastics, but YOU have a sound that I think is pretty unique. I've never heard anyone say something nasty about your singing.

  • @ahumblerequest5222
    @ahumblerequest5222 17 днів тому

    Steven was constantly interrupting during the conversation but the humour is epic.

  • @norbertovelazquez7441
    @norbertovelazquez7441 Місяць тому

    La musica shoegaze tambien es una musica fantastica

  • @anthonydelciello6837
    @anthonydelciello6837 Місяць тому +4

    Really digging the video after all this time! Except that I'm not hearing the audio in Dolby Atmos. C'mon Steven!

  • @nickmoran1
    @nickmoran1 Місяць тому +1

    Gas sounds like i've one in ear in a pond and the other pointed up into the trees.

  • @paullebowski1840
    @paullebowski1840 Місяць тому +1

    You do admire SW, but he can talk and go on !

  • @NonchalantEnigma
    @NonchalantEnigma Місяць тому +3

    Passengers was possibly the other experimental U2 album Steven was thinking of?

    • @JPablo-hh9oq
      @JPablo-hh9oq Місяць тому

      From the perspective of doing a side project yes, but somehow sounds more serious than ironic. I mean, songs like miss Sarajevo and blue room are closer to the mood of ATYCLB

  • @_CoasterNinja
    @_CoasterNinja Місяць тому +1

    I think the Wolfgang Voigt Gas quote is wanting to “bring the forest to the disco, or vice-versa”.

  • @antfirmin
    @antfirmin Місяць тому +1

    I’ve struggled to engage with this episode… I haven’t been a fan of any of these artists but I will listen and rewatch.

  • @FranciscoBurrola
    @FranciscoBurrola Місяць тому +1

    Funny how Steven Wilson has not listened to Standing On the Shoulder of Giants by Oasis and he worked with Mark Feltham and Paul Stacey on To The Bone (specifically the title track sounds a lot like 2000s Oasis)

  • @AbstractEntityJ
    @AbstractEntityJ Місяць тому

    White Pony by Deftones was an amazing album that year. Surprised they didn't discuss it.

  • @MattCermak23
    @MattCermak23 27 днів тому +1

    You guys touch on this a little bit, but I think the comparison of U2 vs Radiohead should really focus on U2 in 1991 and Radiohead in 2000. U2 in 2000 is a band that shifted back to their traditional rock sound after spending the entire 90's experimenting. They were the biggest rock band in the 80's, too. In the 90's wanted to still be that big world dominating band but with a 180 approach. And they pulled it off. Don't forget Original Soundtracks 1 from Passengers in 1995 - they were doing all kinds of experimental things. By Kid A, Radiohead had no interest in being massive rockstars anymore - they wanted to experiment and beyond and just disappear from the rock conversation. They went in the much safer direction, IMO, and really just became an art project.

    • @bowness1
      @bowness1 26 днів тому +1

      An interesting perspective with a fair bit I agree with.

  • @HippieCzar
    @HippieCzar Місяць тому

    Most British podcast wver

  • @gordonstrole290
    @gordonstrole290 Місяць тому +1

    How about y’all’s albums?

  • @crimsonfab
    @crimsonfab Місяць тому

    Hi guys, did Steven notice the similarity between Sea Song by Doves and Drown With Me? 😁

  • @andsoistopped
    @andsoistopped Місяць тому +2

    I think if Doves had a ‘front man’ with a very distinct voice it would distract from the whole. And possibly be annoying.

  • @smalltown2223
    @smalltown2223 Місяць тому +1

    I had an affair with Radiohead, unfortunately we split up. Whilst I love their work, and saw them on the Bends and OK Computer tours, they stopped resonating with me. I’m all in favour of experimenting and I tip my hat to them for that, I really do. It’s just that I feel they lost their identity somehow. Whereas someone like Tangerine Dream did go off piste, they were always that band. Radiohead could release anything these days, and it sells she’d loads. And I feel that’s what they do sometimes, release anything. Great discussion.

  • @MrMurph73
    @MrMurph73 Місяць тому +8

    Love Radiohead and in-depth Radiohead talk!
    Oasis - most overrated 90's band
    Doves - most underrated 90's band.
    Coldplay - hated the direction they went in after Parachutes. A stunning debut.

  • @gerardmartincoughlan
    @gerardmartincoughlan Місяць тому +1

    Good show, nice to have the visuals ... being Irish, I'll chime in too on the U2 piece - I'm not U2s biggest fan but I agree that the lads are way off the mark on this one, as stated in the other comments - this album is the last great U2 record ... oh, and the country is called Ireland, not "Southern Ireland" 😉

    • @bowness1
      @bowness1 Місяць тому +1

      Surely it's The Republic Of Ireland? 🙂 I'm a quarter Irish (my grandmother was from County Mayo) and I had an Irish girlfriend for many years, so I've spent a fair bit of time in the country. That doesn't make me an expert on U2, of course.

  • @akel135
    @akel135 Місяць тому +2

    Why is SW's mic so much louder than TB's? Revenge for the interruption editing?

  • @theskidmarkoforion4829
    @theskidmarkoforion4829 Місяць тому +1

    I love albums the fan base weren’t so keen on. Kid A…Heritage and others. Not Love Beech tho 😂

  • @JohnMacRae23
    @JohnMacRae23 Місяць тому +2

    Video... how about that!

  • @davehopkinson994
    @davehopkinson994 Місяць тому

    Not the debut album from Broadcast.

  • @So-Be-It_85949
    @So-Be-It_85949 Місяць тому +2

    So linear. This made me laugh.[42:26] Good Chemistry between the the two talkers analyzing the different albums from the bands they chose.

  • @hekmann8287
    @hekmann8287 Місяць тому

    Would You take care of
    The Warning??????????

  • @sidnew2739
    @sidnew2739 Місяць тому +1

    Didn't they make a bunch more of these?
    Where are they?

    • @crustyskellington4056
      @crustyskellington4056 Місяць тому +1

      This is the first video episode of it, but there’s a good amount of audio only ones on the podcast feed

    • @sidnew2739
      @sidnew2739 Місяць тому +1

      @@crustyskellington4056
      Thanks. Where can I find it?

    • @bobby666666
      @bobby666666 Місяць тому

      ​@@sidnew2739I listened to them on Spotify. They can be found on other streaming services too I belive. Probably best to check on the old search engine.

    • @nuisanceguru
      @nuisanceguru 19 днів тому +1

      spotify, apple podcasts

  • @christianreynolds9252
    @christianreynolds9252 Місяць тому +1

    I think it’s unfair to compare U2 to Radiohead. Both bands were at total different stages of their careers. U2 had 10 years on Radiohead. They had moved with the times album on album throughout their career. They had their experimental stage Radiohead had just entered that stage.
    All that you can’t leave behind reinvented u2 to a younger generation. I’m 38 and this was the album that got me into the band. It was a huge album.
    Radiohead were inspired by the path U2 had gone on. Kid a was Radioheads Zooropa.

    • @bowness1
      @bowness1 Місяць тому

      I agree with you, though I think by 2000 it's possible that - as Radiohead had been inspired by U2 (which, like you, I feel they undoubtedly had been) - U2 were taking some influence from Radiohead. That said, U2 always had an anthemic 'Pop' sensibility largely absent from Radiohead. We didn't mean to belittle the massive achievements of All That You Can't Leave Behind (though my U2 favourites are Unforgettable Fire and Zooroopa).

    • @christianreynolds9252
      @christianreynolds9252 Місяць тому +1

      ⁠@@bowness1I think the main reason for the stripped back all that you can’t leave behind was Pop being rejected in America. They also had a few stadium shows that didn’t sell out in the states, some with embarrassing attendances. America didn’t really get Pop or Popmart.
      Maybe abit different for me as all that you can’t leave behind was my first U2 album. I was born in 1986 so I was never old enough to appreciate their music until all that you can’t leave behind. Where as you lived through all those classic albums. When I discovered them I was looking back instead of living in the moment. Achtung Baby being my favourite
      The other u2 album in the 90’s was passengers. It was with Brian Eno and wasn’t released under the U2 banner. Very experimental, wasn’t for me if I’m honest
      I love Radiohead as well. Seen them live a few times. Not a fan of their last few albums though. Last album I really liked was probably in rainbows.

    • @bowness1
      @bowness1 Місяць тому

      @@christianreynolds9252 I think that's a decent point about All That You Can't Leave Behind being a reaction to the negative response to (and relative commercial failure of) Pop.

  • @PrisonTorture34
    @PrisonTorture34 Місяць тому +2

    I hope they cover some hip hop. Great pod

  • @Biffinnbridge
    @Biffinnbridge Місяць тому

    Opinions are like arseholes and they two are a right pair of opinions!

  • @kevcatnip7589
    @kevcatnip7589 Місяць тому +2

    Maybe cover your own material ,,Or similar??

  • @amdby
    @amdby Місяць тому +1

    Jeez, I think I saw Tim smile. Also, Steven, unpolitically correct or politically incorrect, what do you think?

  • @pauly2929
    @pauly2929 Місяць тому

    Can you not put the album cover on the two shot please… I’m trying to check out Steven’s studio…

  • @judegraham463
    @judegraham463 Місяць тому +3

    Steven has such insightful observations about music but when he finished up by critiquing Bono's lyrics by pulling out one line from one song and made a general criticism about his lyric writing from that, well I do find that a bit annoying. I guess what it says to me is that Steven Wilson does not pay attention to lyrics because it is 'lyric' writing that is Bono's greatest strength. I would argue that Bono is one of the greatest lyric writers in the Rock genre over the past 50 years.

    • @morbidromanceband
      @morbidromanceband Місяць тому +2

      That's my sentiment as well. The lyrics "you make me feel like I could fly" etc. are fitting for a song called "Elevation". Bono has penned countless brilliant song lyrics. It's a silly overgeneralization to label him as bad with lyrics just because of one song.

    • @judegraham463
      @judegraham463 Місяць тому

      Thats a good point you made about how it's just as important for a lyric to fit the feel of a song, as it is for a lyric to read like poetry been read from a book. Can think of a hundred and one of Bon Scotts lyrics that fit this criteria down to a 'T'. Thanks@@morbidromanceband

  • @adammartin7007
    @adammartin7007 Місяць тому +3

    38:46 You are being unfair to U2. The careerist move was made with All That You Can't Leave Behind. That's their real "pop" record. Their journey into electronic music during the 90's was real. Zooropa is not a particularly dancey record. It doesn't really fit into the dance world, and certainly didn't fit into the alt rock world. Their love of electronic music was real. They even owned their own nightclub.
    39:52 This is inaccurate. U2 always stated that they never had those Americana roots in their music, and that the Joshua Tree was their first step into exploring it. And so what if an Irish band does it? How is it any less genuine than many British bands of the 1960's owing a huge debt to Delta and Chicago blues?

    • @bowness1
      @bowness1 Місяць тому +3

      I totally agree that it's as legitimate for U2 to experiment with Americana (and other genres) as it is for John Mayall (for example) to delve into Delta Blues. Artists from anywhere should feel free to plunder / personalise whatever feels right to them (Bowie and Prince were masters of this approach). I also accept that the band's eclectic enthusiasms were genuine. Personally, I liked the fact that the band played with possibilities and confounded expectations. I was basing my light hearted observations purely on a few half-remembered interviews with Bono I'd seen. Usually, they were clips on documentaries and typically (from what may be a flawed recollection on my part) he'd say how the subject of the documentary - Punk, Thin Lizzy, Clannad, Johnny Cash, Krautrock, Billy Mackenzie/Associates etc - was the biggest influence on U2.

  • @willemvandeursen3105
    @willemvandeursen3105 22 дні тому

    There was a time I wandered away from popmusic. Until I discovered Radiohead. Their recordings have an incredible atmosphere. I hate U2. I prefer Madness.🙂