Disclaimer: This comment is not from a Shia or Rafida, rather someone who was born in a Family Following Hanafi Madhab, but with time is getting close to Salafia but at the same time is trying to understand the fitna and the attrocities against Ahlul bait done by Banu Umayah: I utterly dislike the fact that on this day, the martyrdom of Hussain a.s and Ahlulbait is almost fully forgotten. Nomatter how many good things have happened on ashur, the sorrow of the loss of Sayadna Hussain a.s is a very huge burdon. Not even taking a single minute to show the usurpur Yazeed and Ibn Zyad is something i can not grasp my head around.
New year????? The significance of muharram is the fact the prophets family were massacred. Raped. Tortured by the evil yazid. Who after doing that forced people to celebrate..... So many Muslims like u need educating. Just as I did. You need to learn about the events of karabala and what was done to the prophets beloved grandsons a d grand daughters ..... Do u have grand kids?
Dear Shaikh, you may have to cross reference the Ahdith on fasting on 1st and 10th Muharam for the authentication. As you must be knowing associating anything with Rasool that he said صلى الله عليه و آله وسلم is treated as a big sin
Yes we should add one more fast to Aashura fast , it's up to you whether you add before Aashura or after Aashura, العرف الشذي شرح سنن الترمذي (2/ 177) "وحاصل الشريعة: أن الأفضل صوم عاشوراء وصوم يوم قبله وبعده، ثم الأدون منه صوم عاشوراء مع صوم يوم قبله أو بعده، ثم الأدون صوم يوم عاشوراء فقط. والثلاثة عبادات عظمى، وأما ما في الدر المختار من كراهة صوم عاشوراء منفرداً تنزيهاً، فلا بد من التأويل فيه أي أنها عبادة مفضولة من القسمين الباقيين، ولا يحكم بكراهة؛ فإنه عليه الصلاة والسلام صام مدة عمره صوم عاشوراء منفرداً، وتمنى أن لو بقي إلى المستقبل صام يوماً معه".فقط واللہ اعلم.
Fasting of assura is haram. According to ibn massoud in sahih muslim فروى مسلم في صحيحه - كتاب الصوم - صوم يوم عاشوراء - عن ابن مسعود أنه قال: ((قد كان يصام (أي: يوم عاشوراء) قبل أن ينزل رمضان, فلما نزل رمضان ترك)).
That's an incorrect interpretation of the hadith. The hadith means that its OBLIGATION was abandoned, it was still recommended as per the OTHER authentic hadith directly from the Prophet himself. Check literally any of the authoritative commentaries of Sahih Muslim instead of interpreting it yourself. -Imam Tom
@@UTICAMASJID Here s another proof from Aisha herself . في صحيح مسلم عن عائشة انها قالت (كان عاشوراء يصام في الجاهلية و لكن لما جاء الاسلام من شاء صامه و من شاء تركه ) . Also the word ( Ashura) was not known before the murder of Imam hussein. Albani affirms that fasting Ashura is Bedaa invented by the murderers of Imam hussein. The oumaya clan. Here s the source : يؤكد ان الفرح و الاكتحال و الصوم يوم عاشوراء بدعة المصدر : كتاب تمام المنة الالباني (باب: ومن صيام التطوع بيان ضعف حديث النهي /ص٤١١ الى ص٤١٢/ط. دار الراية) .
I mentioned hadith with the same meaning in the khutbah itself. It does not mean what you purport it to mean. Literally any authoritative explanation of both hadith you have cited clarifies that what is meant here is the OBLIGATION of fasting Ashura to have been abandoned, not the recommendation to fast. You have not addressed the other hadith that prove its recommendation. You have committed errors of interpretation and omission. Typical. You are also wrong that the word Ashura wasn't known, since the Prophet himself mentioned it in the same books of hadith you have cited. But even IF the word wasn't known, that would still be irrelevant, since the day was already known to the Jews as Yom Kippur. You're selectivity belies an agenda. -Imam Tom
Your prophet takes his Deen from the jews according to the speaker! If we ask the jews , do you fast ashura, they wouldn't know what you're talking about. This is blind faith!
@@UTICAMASJID Do you have proof that the Day of Ashura is Yom Kabur? Besides Rasulallah, according to authentic hadith, had forbidden his companion to read or take Deen from the jews. Otherwise what's his job then? If they follow Moses, they should've followed Mohammed .
That proof is so ubiquitous I'll let you find it. They didn't follow Moses, they followed Allah. But Allah confirmed some of what the Jews were doing as genuine revelation and worth also doing, abrogated other things, and condemned others as heresies and innovations. Moses also taught the Jews to worship one God, should we abandon that too? You're thinking tribalistically. I explained all this in the video, go back and listen.
@@UTICAMASJID So you have no proof that youm kabour is ashura. 2) you have no proof it is ( recommended) to fast ashura. From the hadith Aisha it is understood( it's just like any other day of the year, in which a person can fast or not ) . 3) Imam termizi in hadith sahih Rasulallah says ( do NOT imitate the jews and Christians) . So was your prophet insane when he allegedly said to fast youm kabour like the jews do ??? 4) no reaction from you to what sheikh albani fatwa that ashura fasting is bedaa بدعة. 5) nothing in your sermon about Imam hussein سبط النبي ص . Why ? What Deen do you follow ? Ashura is the day Imam hussein and Ahllulbeit were murdered by the ummaya army and led like slaves to yazid لعنه الله. What Deen do you follow?
Disclaimer: This comment is not from a Shia or Rafida, rather someone who was born in a Family Following Hanafi Madhab, but with time is getting close to Salafia but at the same time is trying to understand the fitna and the attrocities against Ahlul bait done by Banu Umayah:
I utterly dislike the fact that on this day, the martyrdom of Hussain a.s and Ahlulbait is almost fully forgotten. Nomatter how many good things have happened on ashur, the sorrow of the loss of Sayadna Hussain a.s is a very huge burdon. Not even taking a single minute to show the usurpur Yazeed and Ibn Zyad is something i can not grasp my head around.
Agreed, wait for the next khutbah to upload.
MashaAllah Tabarak Allah Imam Tom.
MashaAllah
Allahumma Aameen for a peaceful and blessed New Tear for you and us all success blessings Aameen YARABB
New year????? The significance of muharram is the fact the prophets family were massacred. Raped. Tortured by the evil yazid. Who after doing that forced people to celebrate..... So many Muslims like u need educating. Just as I did. You need to learn about the events of karabala and what was done to the prophets beloved grandsons a d grand daughters ..... Do u have grand kids?
Islam build your foundation, so that nothing can shake u..Certainty brings confidence.Phobias must fade away
JazakAllah Khair
❤
MaSha'a allah sheikh
Assalamu alaykom warahmatullahi wabaraqatuh! Jumma'ah Mubarak!
Subhanallah
❤❤..
Dear Shaikh, you may have to cross reference the Ahdith on fasting on 1st and 10th Muharam for the authentication. As you must be knowing associating anything with Rasool that he said صلى الله عليه و آله وسلم is treated as a big sin
The Ashura fast is a two day fast ??
Yes we should add one more fast to Aashura fast , it's up to you whether you add before Aashura or after Aashura, العرف الشذي شرح سنن الترمذي (2/ 177)
"وحاصل الشريعة: أن الأفضل صوم عاشوراء وصوم يوم قبله وبعده، ثم الأدون منه صوم عاشوراء مع صوم يوم قبله أو بعده، ثم الأدون صوم يوم عاشوراء فقط. والثلاثة عبادات عظمى، وأما ما في الدر المختار من كراهة صوم عاشوراء منفرداً تنزيهاً، فلا بد من التأويل فيه أي أنها عبادة مفضولة من القسمين الباقيين، ولا يحكم بكراهة؛ فإنه عليه الصلاة والسلام صام مدة عمره صوم عاشوراء منفرداً، وتمنى أن لو بقي إلى المستقبل صام يوماً معه".فقط واللہ اعلم.
@@suhailahmad1796 Thank you kindly
Its of 9th and 10th.
Knew wHAT?
" The biggest and badest man on earth..." 🙂
Fasting of assura is haram. According to ibn massoud in sahih muslim فروى مسلم في صحيحه - كتاب الصوم - صوم يوم عاشوراء - عن ابن مسعود أنه قال: ((قد كان يصام (أي: يوم عاشوراء) قبل أن ينزل رمضان, فلما نزل رمضان ترك)).
That's an incorrect interpretation of the hadith. The hadith means that its OBLIGATION was abandoned, it was still recommended as per the OTHER authentic hadith directly from the Prophet himself. Check literally any of the authoritative commentaries of Sahih Muslim instead of interpreting it yourself.
-Imam Tom
@@UTICAMASJID
Here s another proof from Aisha herself .
في صحيح مسلم عن عائشة انها قالت (كان عاشوراء يصام في الجاهلية و لكن لما جاء الاسلام من شاء صامه و من شاء تركه ) .
Also the word ( Ashura) was not known before the murder of Imam hussein. Albani affirms that fasting Ashura is Bedaa invented by the murderers of Imam hussein. The oumaya clan. Here s the source
: يؤكد ان الفرح و الاكتحال و الصوم يوم عاشوراء بدعة
المصدر : كتاب تمام المنة الالباني (باب: ومن صيام التطوع بيان ضعف حديث النهي /ص٤١١ الى ص٤١٢/ط. دار الراية) .
I mentioned hadith with the same meaning in the khutbah itself. It does not mean what you purport it to mean. Literally any authoritative explanation of both hadith you have cited clarifies that what is meant here is the OBLIGATION of fasting Ashura to have been abandoned, not the recommendation to fast. You have not addressed the other hadith that prove its recommendation. You have committed errors of interpretation and omission. Typical.
You are also wrong that the word Ashura wasn't known, since the Prophet himself mentioned it in the same books of hadith you have cited. But even IF the word wasn't known, that would still be irrelevant, since the day was already known to the Jews as Yom Kippur.
You're selectivity belies an agenda.
-Imam Tom
Your prophet takes his Deen from the jews according to the speaker! If we ask the jews , do you fast ashura, they wouldn't know what you're talking about. This is blind faith!
We take our Deen from Allah. The believing Jews followed Moses, a genuine Prophet of Allah. They call it Yom Kippur....nice logics.
@@UTICAMASJID
Do you have proof that the
Day of Ashura is Yom Kabur?
Besides Rasulallah, according to authentic hadith, had forbidden his companion to read or take Deen from the jews. Otherwise what's his job then? If they follow Moses, they should've followed Mohammed .
That proof is so ubiquitous I'll let you find it.
They didn't follow Moses, they followed Allah. But Allah confirmed some of what the Jews were doing as genuine revelation and worth also doing, abrogated other things, and condemned others as heresies and innovations. Moses also taught the Jews to worship one God, should we abandon that too? You're thinking tribalistically.
I explained all this in the video, go back and listen.
@@UTICAMASJID
So you have no proof that youm kabour is ashura. 2) you have no proof it is ( recommended) to fast ashura. From the hadith Aisha it is understood( it's just like any other day of the year, in which a person can fast or not ) . 3) Imam termizi in hadith sahih Rasulallah says ( do NOT imitate the jews and Christians) . So was your prophet insane when he allegedly said to fast youm kabour like the jews do ??? 4) no reaction from you to what sheikh albani fatwa that ashura fasting is bedaa بدعة.
5) nothing in your sermon about Imam hussein سبط النبي ص . Why ? What Deen do you follow ? Ashura is the day Imam hussein and Ahllulbeit were murdered by the ummaya army and led like slaves to yazid لعنه الله. What Deen do you follow?
@@UTICAMASJID
Ae you going to commertate the death of Imam Hussein عليه السلام on the 10th of Muharam or not ?
MashaAllah